>supposedly writes some of the best creator owned books>totally rapes my three favorites at Marvel (Punisher, Fury, Moon Knight)why is he like this?
It's all graded on a curve.
>>150407562>The Turtles' lives suddenly take a turn for the worse, and they start to hate each other...again.>They forget what they learned before and mostly just get into passive and meaningless quarrel.>The three turtles are forced to become idiots in the story to make Donnie look smart.>The whole story has no progress at all, and new villain is just a "filler" villain.And they said IDW TMNT got better. lamo
>>150407562>supposedly writes some of the best creator owned booksNo way.
>>150407816Way.
>>150407562I'll never forgive and would kill on sight if I ever met him for what he did to the Serpent Society.
>>150407562I've never read anything good written by him.
>>150407881I've never read it, but since it's from Vertigo, it's probably overrated, like almost everything from Vertigo.
>>150408180It's the only genuinely good thing he's ever made. You sound like an insecure marveldrone.
>>150407562Nobody has ever read Scalped or Southern Bastards. They are likely terrible like everything else he's ever written.
How did he get this far? Nothing he's done is good.
>>150408233If the dude only made one good thing by your own admission, it doesn't sound like that guy's insecure, he's just touched the stove enough times to know it's hot.
>>150408308he is a militant atheist
>>150407562>That time he ruined She-Hulk and put her in weird borderline non-consensual relationship with Thor.
The only JA work worth a damn are Scalped and his run on Punisher MAX. Everything else is godawful garbage. I especially hate his DC work.>>150408255I disagree but not without a fervor because I despise JA but they're pretty good although, like everything he does, they always fail to make the most of the ideas introduced and always falter and wane and then end in a whimper.
>>150407796Aaron's TMNT run is shit. It's like someone pretend to look edgy in a way that feels like someone who got their ideas from reading fan's half remembered feeling about the vibes of the Mirage era.
>>150407562>>150408308I think at some point he became "the asshole we call when we wanna run a character into the ground" at Marvel. Maybe they keep one of those on standby at all times.Like, it feels like he has a checklist he does every time.>retcons, check >replace with a woman, check
>>150407562He looks like the platonic ideal of a White Male Liberal.
>>150408255This. It's likely the same case as something like Y: The Last Man, in which it was well liked by its relatively few readers, but it's actually not good.
>>150408602>his run on Punisher MAX.This shit was absolute ass juice even before he returned to the character to run his name through the mud.
>>150410769The one part I hear was good was the Bullseye arc but the rest was another dragging of Frank's character. Why did Frank go on talk radio?. Why is Jason Aaron obsessed with divorce?
>>150408971Very much like a Scott Galloway IMO. The type of dweeb that effeminate leftists think is gruff and manly and so can speak to young men on the level. Only they don’t realize young men see them as the spineless, feckless pussies they are.
>>150409849Stfu
>>150410838Now now let anon cook
>>150407562Reddit loves him, apparently.
>>150412605/r/cucksincomics?
>>150409849BKV is an exceptionally shitty writer in general.
>>150408840You left out Aaron's trump card.>What if character... was other character!?Stuff like making She-Hulk into Hulk, Echo into Phoenix, etc.
>>150407562He’s just the American Warren Ellis
>>150407562bro's surname is a First name lmao
>>150413635He wishes.
>"Yeah I'm gonna retcon in that everytime She-Hulk fought a male villain she got grope & molested!" What the fuck is wrong with these male feminists?
>>150407562hes a clown
>>150407796Reminder that Aaron was originally hired on to write TMNT indefinitely, and he didn't even get through a whole year before they started shopping for a replacement. After the initial "new #1" hype died off and people started realizing how fucking shitty the comic was, sales dropped off fast as fuck and now they don't even chart anymore after being firmly in the top 10 for the first few issues.
>>150408840>retcons, check >replace with a woman, checkI guarantee this fucker had planes to keep April O'Neil as the new Casey Jones after he had Casey shot and hospitalized in the first few issues. And now in his last couple issues of TMNT, Casey is fine, the Foot Clan are ditching their evil cop routine, and Karai is in charge again, and Hale will probably be dead or permanently locked away in continuity limbo until someone in 5 years wants to do a deep cut reference to that one-time villain that got turned into a chimera to remove him from the story.
>>150407562He's trash, he's always been trashHe got early love because he wrote power wank for Thor fans. It was absolute dogshit, but they ate it up because they really want Dragon Ball Z, but for only white people.
>>150407562>why is he like this?Because comic companies still think this shit moves comics and it doesn't.
>>150407562I enjoyed Scalped. It's been a few years, but I don't remember any low moments that tend to happen with longer series. I heard his other work is bad/gay.
>>150412605that explains why his Doctor Strange run is the way it isman
>>150407562that's one big-ass beard
>>150412605Reddit basically only praises comics even if the comic is shit. You simply can't have a proper discussion that talks about the good and bad because it always end with someone brushing you off by saying "well I thought it was fun"
>>150416238IDW might let Karai get away with it again. We've see some of her minions like Natsu, Koya, and Bludgeon didn't believe that Karai would do something dishonorable as allow a DA to lead foot soldiers. Even Casey trust Karai like a fucking simp. Let face it, IDW Casey's characters has been butchered many times. They should let him died in City Fall arc.
modern comic writers do not like comics, they all think they can do better but do not have the balls to walk away from the steady checks
>>150407562>supposedlyYour problem is allowing third parties and industry figureheads to shape your understanding instead of actually formulating your own opinions. If you had, you’d understand this is the man behind Whor and have lowered your expectations accordingly.Jesus christ, what’s next? An OP being shocked and confused that SCOTT SNYDER isn’t a good writer?
