[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/co/ - Comics & Cartoons

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


Janitor applications are now being accepted. Click here to apply.


[Advertise on 4chan]


>>
>>150474935
I always respect his design, it was the first 90s edge I was exposed to
>>
>>150475034
Same,i got invested in reading his comics after seeing some youtube shorts about him and they were the pretty good for what they were. Edge kino with just the right amount that it doesn't feel too much.
>>
>>150474935
I have an IQ above 60 so no.
>>
>>150474935
The nostalgia goggles are thick, and it's cool it's still ongoing, good for Todd, but it is a boring book.
>>
>>150474935
I'd fuck him.
>>
>>150477023
As the undead zombie or after he gains access to his human form again?
>>
>>150477088
Undead zombie.
>>
>>150474935
Spawn's biggest issue is being all style and no substance. The HBO cartoon effectively covers all the notable quality stories the character's had in his 30+ year history. At this point though they're really just spinning Al's wheels, and I dont see any means to remedy that. Alot of 90's capes suffer from this same problem.
>>
File: Spawns-repaired-face.png (3.23 MB, 1400x1250)
3.23 MB
3.23 MB PNG
>>150477193
Understandable,it is his best look
>>
Main problem with Spawn is that it went through a formative phase where all the elements of the lore were established and the main premise of his conflict was set up and all that ... but then instead of converting that into a proper status quo so they can spin yarns all day about the villain gallery and so on ... they decided to making it an ongoing story.
Now you'd think that's the correct way to do stuff, but in this case it's not since the ongoing story started to be progressively more lame as it went on. It suffers from the X-Files effect where the main issue of the comic/character is resolved multiple times then it just kind of keeps going and it apparently wasn't resolved, then it's resolved again, then not, etc....

Since the setting is interesting enough it should've just become a "perpetual present" kind of comic book.
>>
File: h88n5hwio6281.png (775 KB, 640x949)
775 KB
775 KB PNG
>>150474935
What did Hellboy do better?
>>
>>150474935
I liked the design and the occult setting. Had some cool toys too.
>>150477667
But basically this.
>>
>>150477695
Get a better film adaption. I honestly think the 90's Spawn movie was such a confused, under budgeted, poorly written mess it tanked Spawn's street cred and he's never really recovered since. Meanwhile HB can coast off the two Deltoro pictures and the animated films forever more before new fans actually dive into the Mignola books.
>>
>>150477667
>>150477716
Did any alternative 90's heroes seriously manage to escape that problem? It seems like all the ones who did either wound up in strange new directions (savage dragon), died off (Pitt, Shadowhawk, Witchblade, etc), or get repeatedly hard rebooted to an ever dwindling audience.
>>
Personally i liked the animated series,and comparing it to the comics,it did a good work of streamlining the best aspects of Spawn to create a coherent adaptation that is miles better than the source material.
My only criticism of it would be that you never see Spawn fighting for real.
>>
>>150474935
bump
>>
>>150474935
Yes
>>
>>150477728
It’s more subtle
>>
>>150474935
He's cool
>>
In theory
>>
File: cloth myth.jpg (95 KB, 720x960)
95 KB
95 KB JPG
>>150474935
>all style
>0 substance
>the best thing about it are the toys

It's basically the Saint Seiya of capeshit. Yes, i'm a spic
>>
>>150480933
Never overstuff your display shelves
>>
>>150474935
>couldn't shapeshift to his old former self so he turns into a white man instead

Poor Simmons.
>>
>Todd attempts to pull another Spawn-like series in the 2000's
>MC's origin story also involves cuckoldry

Something tells me that Todd's daughter is not actually his and he knows it
>>
>>150474935
I read the entirety of it and was surprised with how it took nearly 2 decades of irl publication to address a plothole the size of a moon crater (why the throne of hell was empty after Cogliostro backstabbed Simmons and took the throne for himself)
>>
>>150480998
the filename
>why_Ghost_Rider_is_OP_in_Marvel_Rivals.jpg
>>
>>150480933
>McFarlane, like Kurumada, can't write for shit
>TV shows did a lot of favors into making it something decent
>Side materials are usually better
Damn, you are right
>>
>>150474935
No
>>
Have the modern issues from the main comics have gotten any better? I stopped reading around resurrection
>>
>>150477695
Quality over quantity. It helped that Hellboy wasn't monthly, so the stories are more focused without needless throw away issues that are filler. It was obvious from the start that Mignola put more thought and research into his stories. Spawn issues 8 & 9 really stand out as what could have been if Todd wasn't so egotistical. Quite the self-own when he admitted to not reading books in that old interview with the Comics Journal. It's even more bizarre because he went to college. There is such an abundant amount of literature and research concerning myth, legend, folk tales, religions, the occult, and paranormal encounters, that would have given Spawn more of a grander scope and atmosphere from its inception. It was the adversaries that made Hellboy memorable, as I felt HB was starting to get stale as a character for me. Lost interest when Mignola stepped away from doing interior art. I don't care at all about the films from either property. I think the films were wastes of time and energy for both McFarlane and Mignola. As the elder statesmen of comics have said, comics don't need films to legitimize the medium. Still wish Todd had kept drawing instead of becoming a businessman.
>>
>>150477695
>>150485386

Hellboy and Spawn are completely different animals. Any similarities are extremely superficial.

Hellboy is inspired by Lovecraft and old timey occult, pulp serials, folklore and steampunk stuff with a bit of cartoon humor thrown in. It has a very specific vibe that's well defined and unique.

Spawn on the other hand is very much capeshit at its core. There's Spider-Man in there, Batman but most importantly Swamp Thing. People tend to overlook that connection. A man is dead, comes back in a monstrous form and given dominion over an area and has to "police" it. He still feels human for a while but that starts slipping. Also struggling with competing primordial forces. Other inspirations include Fincher's Se7en and the serial killer movie genre. Also juggalos.
Best thing that could've happened to Spawn is they could've fast tracked the character to be a neutral protector of Earth (or at least part of the Earth) and he has to fend off forces of Heaven & Hell (and others) etc... they kind of did it in the comics but it was just convoluted and a lot of back and forth.
>>
File: 455.jpg (212 KB, 1600x1108)
212 KB
212 KB JPG
>>150474935
>>
>>150487256
>There's Spider-Man in there, Batman but most importantly Swamp Thing

and Venom, which I don't know if counts because he is also a McFarlane co-creation
>>
>>150485386
>the films were a waste of time
The first two Hellboy films garnered a shit ton of fans and are kino, wtf are you talking about
>>
>>150474935
Spawn would require a reboot to get good,honestly. Or getting an equivalent of Ultimate/Absolute comic run
>>
>>150489285
yeah the lore is so inconsistent that no one would give damn if that happened

>Jesus was a vampire
>ackshually Jesus is a non-binary primordial deity that predates god and satan
>>
>>150489320
>K7-Leetha wasn't suppose to be anything special compared to the other hellspawn symbiotes
>Oops actually i lied,the suit is FAR ancient and it's also made out of original sin
>Also it has an agenda of it's own by wanting to destroy everything and all that has happened was because of it's plan
Like i knew i was reading something that abides by the rules of cool,but sometimes it was hard not to roll my eyes
>>
>>150489777
or how originally heaven's army was only chicks but now it has both men and women
>>
>>150490860
My favorite part was around the Jim Downings saga where they retcon Malebolgia dying like a bitch to it being part of his master plan to get K7-Leetha back.Like countless pages were teasing this supposed encounter of Jim having to fight full power,super serious Malebolgia upon his return and that Violator was going to help him out.

And i'm a bit ashamed to say that i was hyped since it seemed like a big deal,especially how Malebolgia did this cool stunt of fighting Spawn on his hometurf just to prove he's too strong but he winds up dying like a bitch to Jim's "NOT Divine Spawn" form in less than a few pages.All that setup for nothing.
>>
Actually no, I don't. He so surface level and trivial. Yeah he has an okay design, but that's it. His books suck, and Todd is an asshole
>>
>>150474935
I like Spawn and his whole vibe...

BUT

I don't think his comic is technically good. Like, if you pick up one of those big Spawn Compendium books and try and read 50 issues in a sitting your brain will leak out your ears.
>>
>>150477023
>>
>>150489285
>Or getting an equivalent of Ultimate/Absolute comic run
He had that and it was good despite being written by Bendis



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.