>>151521681
Because it's a prelude to a training arc. She should have mastered the perfect strike in one episode so we could move on with the plot and get some good fights.

>>151521681
I kinda checked out after the first episode. Flashy anime battles where everyone bounces around works for battle Shonen but when it comes to wrestling series I want fights to be a bit more mathotical. If you wanted to keep the quicker pace maybe the creator should have picked mma instead of wrestling.

>>151521681
Andy feet.

>>151521859
This. It's like the first volume of a shounen manga on its own, it's barely even anything to go by.

>>151521681
It starts with "B" and rhymes with "track."

>>151521681
Andy's training felt weirdly simultaneously rushed and way too slow. Ten episode first season so I get the need to rush things a bit but it really didn't make the best of its time. I think it may have benefited from having Bertie be the season finale fight maybe. Could have dedicated more time to show Andy training and excuse her explosive growth while also exploring the world and lean more into the idea of Bertie being a bad end Andy. Also fuck the Perfect Strike move is so damn lame. Having the whole first season be about her trying to learn that one damn move sucked. Also felt like the show was in a weird space ending up on Adult Swim. Feels like it got sent out to die rather than be given a chance. I want to hope we get more because fuck what we got feels like it ended way too soon but I wouldn't hold my breath with how no one from th crew has talked about it.

>>151522449
We also needed more of that. Should have given her a barefoot and open belly costume like >>151521681 has

>>151521681
1) If the guy wanted to make a fighting anime or battle shonen type of thing, he should have followed their rules. The cliches are there for a reason: they distilled the genre for decades and only what works is left. Originality should be in the details, not the execution.

2) You can't have a girl be a protagonist of this sort of show unless you're going all in on fanservice or catering to an older audience with more mature themes.

>>151521681

what ensign mariner doin?

>>151521681
So is her show dead after one season or what? Has anyone from the crew or Adult Swim said anything?

>>151521681
As other anons have pointed out it has massive pacing issues
It does have another big problem, though, and one that's much worse in my opinion for this kind of show:
The power and stamina systems make no sense. Andy is a string bean with no training then suddenly she can lift and fuck up a 400 pound monster, meanwhile plenty of other characters her size act like them doing so would be physically impossible and bigger characters are shown weight/strike training.
Despite being a tween girl accountant Andy can take more punishment than fucking Ippo, getting up after being literally mangled, meanwhile way bigger and stronger characters get KO'd by one ok punch

It just results in a setting without stakes

I've heard it has a severe lack of ryona

If you like wrestling at all you can tell the people who made this didn't. It feels like a wrestling anime written by a guy who watched most of DBZ and had an episode of mid 2000s Raw in the background and thought that's all he needed to know about either

>>151523023
This.
But making it about girls is the only way it would have been made in this litterally damned country.

File: 1729818645169977.png (114 KB, 427x487)

114 KB PNG

>So, like...ya know how Naruto learned shadow clones in one episode? How about we stretch that out into ten?

>>151521681
Retarded premise that was ripping off better shows that did the same thing, while not understanding why people like shounen battle series in the first place. Also, black female protag.

>>151523941
There was a decent amount of it but it had very little impact. Andy was practically invincible right from th start and would bounce back form what looked like massive blows instantly every time.

>>151524485
Doesn't really make any sense. They set it up as an untalented girl learning to fight and needing to rely on technique and wits and clever tactics to win, but then it becomes a story about how this normal girl with zero training, zero special traits, zero powers, just being able to endure things that should otherwise kill a normal human in her own setting, while beating people who are blessed with superhuman toughness, power, and abilities.

>>151521681
I thought it was kinda dumb, it reminded me of ultimate muscle but like bad fanfiction version of it.

>>151524536
It really was weird. They sped past the learning the basics part of the training arc and just jumped into her being able to fight heavy hitters from the get. Then dragged their feet with her trying to learn the instant kill move of all fucking things. It's the complete reverse of how it should have gone. And a big kill move is just a bad idea anyway. To compare it to the series the creator even referenced, it would be like if by the end of the second episode Ippo had somehow managed to beat Miyata or Sendo (main rivals) and then spent the rest of the series trying to learn the perfect Dempsey Roll. Sure he loses maybe once against Date Eiji (Japanese Champion) but it was stupid close and he just barley looses. Where the fuck is the buildup in that? The best parts of Ippo were him learning the basics before he even had the Dempsey Roll move. Having Andy completely skip that part really compromised her growth and made the whole world feel weird since we have to assume just everyone could have done it then but no one fucking does. Being a wrestler doesn't feel special when a random girl can tustle with the best less than a week after starting.

>>151524720
Despite the creator insisting he was a fan of pro wrestling and anime, the guy clearly has no fucking idea how either of those things do their storytelling. I have serious doubts that he's ever really sat down to watch a single night of Japanese pro wrestling, let alone a sports anime like Ippo, and it's no fucking wonder this show came out as such a stale turd. It's a poorly told story for no one.

>>151524623
I wish it was like Ultimate Muscle. The kind of ridiculous over the top characters and villains would have been fun. Invincible Fight Girl's style was cute and cool enough to work but they just didn't commit to the bit

>>151521681
Not enough bertie or andy ryona

>>151521681
Ok better question how would you fix it anons? like if /co/ was to re-write or design the show and andy? What would you all do

File: Andy foot pale sole edit.png (1.25 MB, 1920x1080)

1.25 MB PNG

>>151522449
and Andy soles

>>151524447
He overheard that anime protagonists are always learning moves, but didn't hear the part where it's new moves each episode.

>>151525367
>The entire first season is training for her debut as a professional wrestler.
>She has one match per episode to train, and Andy learns something new with each defeat.
>The climax of the season is when Andy wins her first match using everything she's learned and makes her professional debut.

>>151525367
Remove the perfect strike thing. Just have Andy wanting to train under Poblana because she looked up to her and she was a champion. Having the big goal be one big dumb ass instant win move is lame. Have Andy struggle more. Give her some almost wins but having her win her first big fight and almost every fight after that really roughed things up. If she has to win that first fight to set up Immaculate losing it then play closer to rules of wrestling and have her win on a technicality against Immaculate while he's fine and she's a beaten mess. Could even be a decent setup if that one win gives her a big head that gets popped and grounded down into the ground when she has her next fight. Let her first real win feel big by it being the first breakthrough she made. Let her scrappiness shine through by the fact she keeps at it even after losing and losing. Have better control over the tone. The violent shift between the Perm Gang beating up and attacking everyone and then all the other accountants comically throwing garbage at the Perm Gang really deflated the moment and it can't really risk having that kind of mood killers with such a short run time of a ten episode first season. I'm not saying you can't have jokes but balance them out better without ruining the tension and dramatic energy the fights and emotional moments are trying to build up. Honestly the tone and the insane growth of Andy was the two things I didn't really like about the show. Andy herself is cute and I want to root for her but when she wins pretty much everything it feels less impactful. The wrestling world is dumb but fine. It can work on Mucha Lucha or Yu-Gi-Oh levels where everything revolves around one thing. That's fine. Just explore the world more and let being a wrestler, the big thing about the world, feel hard and earned when Andy gets it.

>>151521997
>maybe the creator should have picked mma instead of wrestling.
With how punch and kick focused the fights ended up being they probably should have. Feels like a MMA based world would have been also easier to justify any kind of fighting styles.

>>151527384
also would have meant Andy feet in all episodes

>>151521681
Did she fight women?

I would not be surprised if there was any executive meddling.

>>151521681
Is it over? I was hoping there was going to be more. But I understand why it would be put down.

>>151527777
There's no telling. But it's been a year since the first season premiered and we've gotten no word one way or the other. There's still those TV guide episode descriptions that looked like stuff from a later seasons with characters that we hadn't seen yet, but without any confirmation if there even is a second season it feels like grasping at straws expecting anything from those. Unless Adult Swim is playing a really really long game with this one.

>>151527412
bertie

>>151521681
We have anime at home.

File: golpea-duro-hara.png (1.06 MB, 1600x900)

1.06 MB PNG

>>151521681
It should have done a complete arc in the episodes they got instead of feeling like the prelude of a long anime that will never get done.

It's bizarre I say this but Golpea Duro Hara did the thing with the fighting girl much better, by the end of the short series she is facing her demons and defeating the big bad. If you have little time to tell a story you need to move it along.

>>151528201
>Golpea Duro Hara
Never heard of this. Girl doesn't look so bad and a fight girl show that gets shit done sounds promising. My Spanish would probably get me by but I have to ask, is there subs?

>>151526379
Yeah honestly much better and makes her feel more well rounded, hated how the first ep sets this up. She has the whole leg bar training and vid stuff then suddenly in ep 3 she's a literal fighting demon. She can tank punches from a guy who is stronger and in better shape than immaculate who literally damn near crippled her. How did andy go from cowering in fear of hits and pain to smiling and walking into someone who's specialty is literally strong punches that break and tenderize meat also all in same day.

But if she did learn a few moves, it'd make sense why she'd be so well rounded and suddenly more athletic plus each fight would help her grow but we lowkey only had 2 big fights for training
>>151527080
Yeah, the perfect strike feels like a s2 thing at best. Make it so she needs a special move for the real/industry wrestlers who all have them or aren't easy to beat but having it and having it be so overpowered it insta wins is dumb asf

Yeah I feel ya sad that the most hype the show got was when it was only a pilot as we all had more ideas and hopes then as the show went on I saw as the fans and threads got smaller and died faster. Why I wanted to ask I did remember a idea from like the finale thread of maybe could become a /co/ project since well damn this series is lowkey dead in the water most likely so honestly could be refurbished or even edited new girl or making andy better etc.

I also said the same but with the comedy just called it trying to hard to be anime/that weird comedy in anime which lowkey is old even in the east as that stuff was very classic 90s-00s anime esque. But I also feel can make some things work but they constantly boost her ass up to high or deflate the moments with comedy or sudden anime bs. I'd also prefer if it's just "fighting" world as it feels nothing is wrestling exclusive or mma world etc. Like their isn't even a 3 count thing like pins which would be a easy way to give her wins

Because the show had boring designs even compared against the standards of fucking real life wrestling extravagance.

Against previous extravagant wrestling-themed shows and anime this one just looked incredibly lame and tame.
Just compare it to Punch Punch Forever and at a glance you can tell which cast looks more interesting.

The main character looks BORING.

>>151528523
It's weird how she starts tanking everything after the first fight without any prior buildup or other than copying stuff from a videotape

>>151528680
yep and also the vid didn't even talk about damage negation or how to take a punch. In fact all she learned from beef boy was how to punch for five secs then suddenly she's a punching expert and knows how to read punches. Literally she became a genius in less than a week time
>>151528585
True and why punch punch forever has tons of views not even my type of humor but the designs and concept are much more appealing to the eye and greater masses.

Why I said could be fun to try and redesign her and try to re write her verse since god knows this is destined for a write off

>>151523023
>2) You can't have a girl be a protagonist of this sort of show unless you're going all in on fanservice
This.
People like to invoke Soul Eater for the "shounen with a female lead," conversation but always conveniently forget that Soul Eater is absolutely packed with fanservice.

>>151528741
>Literally she became a genius in less than a week time
I kept hoping this would turn out to at least be an accountant thing. Like accountants are good at information analysis and that gave her a unique edge. Any kind of excuse for it. But then it would completely invalidate Mikey and that wouldn't be cool. And we didn't get any explanation anyway. Fuck she got good enough by her fight with Bertie that she didn't even really need him anyway. Just such a weird exponential growth for her without doing anything to earn it.

>>151521681
>action show
>female lead
>didn't even make her hot or cute

it's like they wanted to fail

>>151528987
yep honestly this she really had nothing that explained her skills or growth. I mean even mikey help wouldn't suddenly make her so op. Also hated how her wins weren't even by the skin of her teeth her wins were very much over the top. Even bertie, she should have been a big threat someone who knows both punching and kicks literal kick boxer nope she only knows the imperfect strike just like andy and her perfect strike bs. But instead of making bertie her opposite a girl that hates wrestling who is really good at it genetically and through years of abuse/training nope she just rages out and still loses to andy.

Same with immaculate she not only beats him but beats his whole squad

>>151521681
Because it wasn't made for children but for upper-class white liberals and that market is already saturated

File: crossover.png (331 KB, 1163x1101)

331 KB PNG

>>151528201
You beat me i was going to talk about this show.

Also something funny Invincible Fight Girl and Golpea Duro Hara final battles end the same way with the main characters defeating their largers antagonists using their special move they learned from their old teacher, that they take them an entire season to perfect.

>>151528987
>>151529207
The problem is, most likely, that the creator isn't a very good writer, but got hired for being black. And the show isn't well written, but got greenlit for starring a black girl. And there's no one with balls or talent left in the company to tell the black guy writing a show about a black girl that he's doing it wrong and he should rewrite this shit for it to be good.

I think I agree that the wrestling angle was a bad decision. It doesn't really lean enough into what wresting fans like about wrestling to appeal to that niche, and instead goes for more of a flashy shonen fight anime. But those kinds of anime usually have more to distinguish them aesthetically, instead of just unremarkable wrestling leotards.

>>151521681
Why is OP a faggot?

File: e209f8ecf08eecb24f2b45b3b(...).gif (1.27 MB, 350x260)

1.27 MB GIF

>>151529649
Real fuck up of the the wrestling is being unremarkable.
Kinikkuman that shit.

File: image_2025-12-01_235206304.png (861 KB, 1200x518)

861 KB PNG

>>151529622
Why I joked /co/ should re-write it since pretty much free game and not a bad inital concept. I don't even think andy is all that ugly just needs a few tweeks and she'd be great mc
>>151529649
The thing is even outside of just anime their are a lot of western wrestling shows they could have played off of like just the most basic is mucha lucha. Literally has simplistic designs but they work because they all have unique natures skills and use great color schemes and vibes like real luchadors. No one has special features irl but with outfits and stage presences they make it all work

An mucha lucha makes using same outfits still feel fun and cool. Many of the kind outfits are basic but idk they are much more memorable i still love "Buena Girl" and her outfit is super basic

>>151529649
There's barely anything that constitute wrestling except for a grapple or 2 but yeah it should've been open styles of all kinds

>>151529649
This really. No flashiness or crazy characters and stories for NA wrestling fans and no charismatic wrestlers and elegant acrobatics for Latin wrestling fans.

Compare a fight in this show to a fight in Kinikkuman. Big difference.
https://vimeo.com/844761985

>>151521681
Chocolate…

Andy herself is cute but her base outfit isn't so interesting. How would you redesign her outfit?

>>151528680
You know, I'm kind of surprised that the video tapes ended up not mattering after that first episode. Felt like Andy would, probably should have, been constantly calling back to his videos for guidance and moves she'd be using throughout her fights. And just general moral boosting.

>>151528286
I know is on HBO Max, maybe it has a english track? not sure.

>>151532148
>HBO Max
Wouldn't have guessed that. That does sound like a good sign for the chance of subs or a dub. I'll check into it then. If I find anything I'll share it here. Thanks anon

>>151523023
>You can't have a girl be a protagonist of this sort of show unless you're going all in on fanservice or catering to an older audience with more mature themes.
Holy secondary!
>>151528931
The best parts of Soul Eater barely have any fan service from Babayaga castle to the end of the manga the only fanservice heavy segment in the story is the chapter of lust in the book of Ebion

>>151532588
None of that shit ever even got animated.
Sorry m8, if you want people to care about your female protag action show, it needs to have fanservice.
Simple as.

>>151532588
we get it you want to be a woman

At least it's better than Cannon Busters
That show was outright incoherent

File: Holographic meatloaf.jpg (28 KB, 600x315)

28 KB JPG

>>151521681
It seemed cool, but I knew it was going to inevitably get cancelled or written off so I didn’t wanna bother getting invested in it.

>>151532725
>Not even a single post before moving the goalpost
Amazing.
Anyways read more manga and watch more anime, there's hundreds of action shows with female MCs in Japan, some indulge in fanservice, others ignore it completely, both types of shows are equally popular over there.
It's so common, specially nowadays, that it isn't even something worth acknowledging.
Western shows are the only ones who have a problem with female MCs on action shows

>>151532774
Most female-led action anime are pretty much irrelevant.
The most recent shounen anime with a female lead was probably Shy, which, again, is irrelevant.
Look man, if you're a yurifag just say so, we both know where this conversation is going, you guys got really weird and gay once you started watching more cartoons.

>>151529755
I loved watching this anime because it was like watching them figure out the battle shounen conventions that work (and ended up sticking) in real time.

>>151532795
It's funny how Battle Angle/Gunnm is one of the better examples of a female lead battle shounen- except it actually had to run in a seinen magazine.

>>151528680
>>151528741
I thought they were going to tie Andy's freak tier endurance to her parents' accountant background with accountants constantly being in high pressure situations. But that obviously didn't happen. She can tank hits because plot armor.

>>151532837
To be fair, Gunnm has lots of casual, graphic violence. Lots of people getting decapitated, limbs getting ripped off, skulls smashed in, arms and legs broken, people getting ripped or sliced in half, etc. etc.
And also some occasional titties, as is customary for most action seinen properties.

File: Mikayil-Yusifov-art-king-(...).jpg (186 KB, 713x950)

186 KB JPG

>>151530076
>no charismatic wrestlers and elegant acrobatics for Latin wrestling fans.
Amen.

If you're going to play the genre, you have to embrace it.

File: 5cc06d98f01eaf9db876b0d3f(...).jpg (341 KB, 1920x1080)

341 KB JPG

>>151524720
>To compare it to the series the creator even referenced, it would be like if by the end of the second episode Ippo had somehow managed to beat Miyata or Sendo (main rivals) and then spent the rest of the series trying to learn the perfect Dempsey Roll.
Why take inspiration from Ippo? There are better examples of wrestling in anime.

>>151532774
NTA but 'over there' is doing a lot of heavy lifting.
This was a show that was trying to market itself towards fans of schlocky shonen trash on a block that is mostly schlocky shonen trash, but that basically never works when westerners do it because they think teenage boys are a problematic lost cause and that drawing a boob will cede too much ground in the culture war.

>ctrl+f precure
>0 results
buncha slackjawed boomer casualfags acting like they know shit about anime, KWAB

>>151532865
she's a prodigy or some bs is more of an answer to explain it but really those hits she's been taking should've crippled her tiny frame

File: the invincible #@&% girl.png (918 KB, 1920x1080)

918 KB PNG

>>151521681
Poor pacing and execution.

>>151533242
Precure ain't relevant.
Like yes, it's got some surprisingy badass fights, but its frilly magical girl aesthetic was clearly not what this show was inspired by or referenced so heavily. Most likely because Precure never really gained a foothold in the west to begin with.

>>151533367
Powerpuff girls was basically a parody, in the same vein of Ninja Turtles

>>151533242
I don't think Precure had much influence on this show.
Like...at all.
I doubt the showrunner even knows what Precure is.

>>151532588
What is your counter argument? "Nuh-uh!"? If the show is an action comedy about fighting, you have to have either a boy protagonist or sexy girls for boys or quality writing for adults. For example, PPG was an action comedy with girl leads, but that went all-in on ultraviolence and had really good comedic writing. It succeeded despite having three female gnomes for leads, not because of it. Fuck, you even need pretty girls in a cartoon for girls, they're not going to want to watch some plain stick throwing punches. (formerly >>151533367, deleted for shoddy editing.)

>>151533433
It surpassed that status by becoming a better version of what it was parodying. Same as TMNT.

>>151521681
why is andy only wearing one stirrup

>>151533479
Frankly I think trying to make it an action comedy is part of the problem. Slapstick requires a lack of consequence and a lack of consequence means people will check out because there are no stakes. You can have funny moments sure, but selling the audience on the adventure and threats matters way more in action stories.

File: Rapeable Fight Girl.jpg (146 KB, 1920x1080)

146 KB JPG

>>151532865
Yeah and I still say that's weird as we see immaculate isn't a top tier wrestler so not even like she learned from taking his hits to take others. No the beef punchers are considered top tier at strikes but andy was beaten bloody and scared against out of shape and low tier nobody like immaculate.

>Andy after just some playful hits the day before tanking high level punches
>>151533244
Oh 100% she would have realistically had so much internal damage or broken bones it's not even funny. Like their are techinques to taking punches too if you really want what it seems most people do watch/read "How to Fight" literally is about a weak boy learning moves one at a time to become stronger and he actually feels like he earns his wins as every single one is hard fought and take weeks if not months of training. to become a more well rounded fighter later on and the irony is it's very humorous as well but serious exactly what this show wants to be

>>151533525
>Frankly I think trying to make it an action comedy is part of the problem.
I don't know about that, an action comedy can work so long as you know when to be lighthearted and fun and when to be serious.
Even absolute grimdark edgelord stuff like WH40k has some occasional lighthearted comedic content, or even grimdark comedic content, like almost everything that involves the Orks.

>>151521681
Basically it just doesn't deliver on any of what it sets up.

>>151533525
Both can exist in a show. Most action anime has violent slapstick that leaves no lasting damage and actual fights where damage counts.

>>151531822
>How would you redesign her outfit?
Remove the red parts, compromise with the yellow and white.

>>151521681
It was trying way too hard to be anime instead of its own thing. At this point I’d rather watch an actual anime, this show had nothing to offer

>>151521681
Not enough ryona

In a battle series not having a consistent power system is a cardinal sin.
Yes, fine, you can have Andy tank epic amounts of punishment only to win in one ultra-decisive move, but there has to actually be a reason she can take hits and others can't. People should notice and point out that it's strange of you choose to explain it later.

From watching the whole show I see no reason the con man couldn't do literally anything Andy does because physical build and training don't seem to actually matter

>>151533801
Well depends if it's realistic then it works off real rules or if more simplistic, but with this series it's all over the place they don't even really follow wrestling rules. As someone said they should have leaned more into the "Fight" part of the name also some characters use FUCKIN poison and fire so really what are the rules. Like do I have to accept mofos coming at me with blades and whips if I fight?


This is a interesting concept as well, also weird they didn't introduce "chi, ki, etc" because I mean that punch is obviously not a normal one. An she was lifting and throwing characters ten times her size. It's like the opposite of OK KO they kind of explain everyone have powers and that people can do absurd thing and the level system and tk stuff. Even though it's much more episodic and it actually is ok being mix of wrestling boxing mma and super heroes as it never says otherwise

>>151533860
>Well depends if it's realistic then it works off real rules or if more simplistic
Which is in itself establishing the rules of the power system.
But like you said it was all over the place. Andy is a string bean throwing around mountains but then the perfect strike is about proper body rotation? Fuck off.

File: bertie__invincible_fight_(...).jpg (83 KB, 827x1232)

83 KB JPG

>>151521681
It wasn't good, but it flopped because simply WB didn't have any faith in it and never really marketed it to begin with. Disney, as bad as they are, at least marketed their shows (the bare minimum but still). Even the bad press Owl House got helped it get a base, but it still needed to be initially supported by Disney. I don't think anyone even heard of IFG, not even when it was airing. I only heard of it because I'm particularly interested in it. And it was in dev limbo for a while now. It really should've been a CN show but we all know how that story ended. So, many reasons why the show ended up flopping. Sucks but it is what it is. Bertie is still my favorite recent cartoon girl

File: Screenshot_23.png (1.1 MB, 1440x900)

1.1 MB PNG

>>151521681
because the artists don't like the show

File: Screenshot_198.png (868 KB, 947x817)

868 KB PNG

anons talking about fanservice but i think that she have a hot body

>>151533081
Because the creator referenced Ippo as one of his inspirations and Ippo is a pretty sizable series. Trying to draw inspiration from it would be a good idea since it did Ippo's beginning very well. Tiger Mask would have probably also been a good idea to borrow from to get the big personalities right. Really the whole point is moot since they didn't really take inspiration from anything and sure didn't learn anything from those series and instead just name dropped them.

>>151533884
Yeah basically the series is very haphazard with all of it's rules honestly should just go the baki route where damn near just mix of skill experience and form then just imagination and believe in power. Like the light speed strike, or how dude learns all chinese martial arts just by attaching a chinese masters hands. But the ridiculousness is part of the charm In this show their is no charm since series just started and we genuinely don't know the rules or way things work they act like it's all just fighting and techinque but then she'd need to use a style fitting her like her original grappling/submission focused technique
>>151534064
Ironic bertie is obviously the most popular side character, both here and on twitter. Also bertie actually deserves a win but fails just because she's up against mc.

It's sad how small it is dude even Haunted hotel popped off more which is insane. Haunted hotel felt so basic now I see fanart in my twitter feed every so often. It also has more heart honestly though as it feels like it's trying to be a good show not just a family guy clone etc. While IFG feels like it has no idea what it wants to be

>>151533525
I think it depends on how well they can balance the tone. If they have good writing then having humor and drama can enhance both of them. The momenta of humor can draw you closer to the characters which makes the drama even more impactful since you can care about these characters. And the moments of humor feel stronger once they're our breaks in the character drama where they can breathe. It's a balancing act and when done well it's strong tool. When done poorly however, it sucks and deflates any drama and makes the jokes feel in weird taste. If they don't have the writing skill to use both they should just stick to one.

>>151522492
wtf is a brack?

>>151521997
>mathotical

>>151534255
It being good really means little. This is why the most tasteless of people eat AI slop, hook line and sinker. It's what the powers above want. Such is the life of a cartoon in the 2020s

>>151533598
>immaculate isn't a top tier wrestler
That was a weird thing. Like it made sense early on that she'd only get lucky against losers who aren't actually high ranked but then when The Perm Gang showed up again they appeared like a big threat and everyone was unsure about fighting them. Like Andy's whole journey took place over the course of a few days so it's not like they could have developed that big of a new reputation over the course of less than a week.

File: andy_outfit_v1.png (224 KB, 700x1142)

224 KB PNG

>>151531822
>>151533767
I did it myself

File: andy_outfit_v2.png (223 KB, 700x1142)

223 KB PNG

>>151534761

File: andy_outfit_v3.png (213 KB, 700x1142)

213 KB PNG

>>151534772

>>151534787
Of the three edits I made, this was my favorite.

>>151534787
The leotard is a classic. And I do really like how >>151534761 is open backed. The show liked doing back detail and that shows off a lot of her back

>>151534480
I suppose so plus fandoms love a series they can latch on too and just mix in lore
>>151534702
I mean weren't they just street toughs not real wrestlers. I mean the beef puncher dad seems to have been a real wrestler at some point and same with berties parents. But they call the perma gang salon goons implying they are just bodyguards or goons which would be dangerous but not really a threat to the others which is why they were all ready to defend andy against them

I mean seems like it was less of a rep and more of a they already got some lore to them. As they said they grew up around there it seems and think they just grew into it all over their time. Also why I felt bad as the concept made it feel like hardwork and hardship is meaningless against talent after seeing the gang's back story
>>151534787
long sleeve leotard is interesting

File: PowerGirl.png (216 KB, 284x548)

216 KB PNG

>>151535444
>long sleeve leotard is interesting
It's a reference to Power Girl.

>>151535444
>bad as the concept made it feel like hardwork and hardship is meaningless against talent after seeing the gang's back story
That did suck. In retrospect kind of funny though since it's also a very anime thing to do having the guys who worked hard just fail anyway while the protagonist wins because he's the special. A bad lesson to take from anime but a lesson they did take.

>>151533508
Stirrups are feet lingerie and only one gives that asymmetrical unique look.

File: andy_outfit_new.png (1.06 MB, 1200x1200)

1.06 MB PNG

>>151534787
other edit

>>151536535
>Imagine spanking Andy before and after each fight.
>The first spanking makes her embarrassed.
>The second spanking is more pleasurable for you because she lost and is hurt.

>>151521681
It's a shittier version of Kill La Kill minus the lewds & with niggers, made by woke Tumblr dykes. I'd rather watch Kill La Kill.

>>151535779
Ah I see it now
>>151536509
I mean they do look nice, also they fit a fighter since supposedly they are meant to help with well balance and grip also ironically for flat footed people iirc
>>151535828
Honestly now want a inverse protag who would usually be the rival/antag up against the bs special mc. It is bs though dude will train 100 years for a plan and mc just comes in and washes them
>>151536535
Told you all we can fix her though idk what else I'd want to edit about andy. I do love a good /co/ project though. I might draw something later myself but these edits are peak anon
>>151536722
Implying that some mean fighter wouldn't do it publicly during the match.

>>151536535
Show should've just been m17 once it was on [as] and given us naked andy vs bertie ryona

>>151536776
>made by woke Tumblr dykes
Show me the woke tumblr dykes who worked on the show? Or are we just gonna pull shit out of our ass?

>>151536535
Ok yeah I'm starting to really like this sleeved leotard look for Andy. Was initially unsure about removing the red from her outfit but simplifying the colors down to just the three ended up working well the more I look at it.

>>151536839
>but these edits are peak anon
Thanks!

>>151536907
Of course you single handedly keeping the hype alive. I myself do think on how one could fix andy's design and vibe in show
>>151536854
Naked is boring the spice is clothed ryona and loss as fight goes on
>>151536885
could always put the red/orange in the shoes

>>151536885
The problem with Andy's original design is that it has five colors:
>Yellow
>Red
>White
>Brown
>Blue.
It's very cluttered, and the red clashes with the other colors.
Although I admit it would have the same result if you removed the yellow and replaced it with more red.

>>151537153
Also, the double leotard was a design problem from the start.

>>151536854
Naked isn't as fun though. You don't get to have clothes being ripped and torn the worse fights are going for Andy. The change in attitude as she's confident fully dressed and embarrassed as it's ripped up is a big part of it.

>>151537139
True. But then I think something would have to be changed with her headband. The blue there matching her shoes is kind of nice and if you change the shoes you'd lose some of that.

>>151533314
Needed more Andy butt

>>151537139
>andy's vibe in show
How?
The only thing I can think of is that he'll lose more and cry from the pain of his injuries after every fight.

File: blue ursus.png (606 KB, 1080x1531)

606 KB PNG

>>151521681
they should have made her a beefcake instead of a 95 pound womanlet

Maybe introducing Bertie earlier could have helped as well. Giving Andy a solid rival from the get to try and aspire to being like initially and then hoping to beat or save once she realized how far gone Bertie was

>>151539488
cartoons can't make a decent gorilla woman

>>151540133
Someone who knows nothing about the series might misinterpret this frame.

File: Screenshot_413.png (1.24 MB, 1440x900)

1.24 MB PNG

>>151540147
she just loves being handled by a big person

>>151539488
Maybe if the show had premiered on Toonami / Adult Swim at the start. I think it initially seemingly being planned for Cartoon Network meant they had to have a kid protagonist.

File: G18qQBDWsAA3UQj.jpg (53 KB, 1170x655)

53 KB JPG

Best character

File: Screenshot_195.png (2.04 MB, 1439x809)

2.04 MB PNG

>>151540717

>>151521681
It tried to be shonen without knowing how to be one. It was very clumsy at it.

>>151521681
MOGGED

>>151521681
what is andys expression trying to convey?

>>151540099
These were cool. Do we have all the crew's art anywhere? Or is it lost on their various social media accounts?

>>151538899
I think that'd be more vibe loss, but also be cool if maybe she did have some reaction to losing or battle damage. like after the beef puncher fight have her reacting to all her adrenaline being gone and now all the damage hitting her at once.
>>151538284
As anon above says seems like they wanted her to have every color in her outfit for some reason. Think she just needs one or two core colors rather than like 5 plus as many said with og design the orange/red blend in with her skin tone because red and brown are on the warmer color side. So boom you almost got a flesh color vibe.

Also you mean hair band I was like does she have a fucking headband lol
>>151539488
Think her being a womanlet is fine as most male heroes are as well at start but play with it more. Like her first fight she uses her speed and size to slip and get people in grapples or submission holds. Also makes her fights feel like uphill battles

>>151539501
Yeah, maybe she should have been the one involved with her in the beginning.

File: GeZfbkPW4AAMBbk.jpg (96 KB, 1160x653)

96 KB JPG

>>151539501
>>151541609
Actually this is a great idea for a re-write def feel bertie is one of the best parts of the show. Only other note is not making her parents such a joke it kills the tension and trauma of her back story when we see her parents goofy ass posing and talking after beating their daughter and running her out of town such a shitty tonal shift

Idea I think could go
>Bertie is first one to find andy, gives her advice to stay at the bar or helps her to a rookie gym
>Bertie seems more aloof and uncaring when it comes to wrestling but tries to not completely shit on andy's dream
>She and andy fight to help her learn the true rules and ropes of modern wrestling. Andy loses one sidededly
>Also make bertie a full on kick boxer not just a one move junkie
>She should be a super rookie well known and a rising star but she hates it. She's only training to become number 1 or to defeat/humilate her parents so they'll acknowledge her
>Bertie and Andy are good friends but a bit at odds
>She always shits on poblana and wrestling or tells andy that it has a darker side but can't bare to kill andy's vibes
>Then the town arc is still about 2-3 eps but bertie doesn't want to go or doesn't go with andy and her squad
>But she saves them last second they think now she's fully a member then the reveal it's her town and parents
>Why she hates poblana and wrestling
>Then it's the second fight of andy and bertie, now she has a bit more experience and knows bertie style a bit
>Bertie almost accepts andy's way of thinking that wrestling is just fun and not so serious. Then her parents arive and call that loser mentality and call her a failure
>This leads to unbound bertie rage mode though prefer not so hulking myself maybe just fit/muscle girl bertie like her being just covered it torn bandages and her muscles are slightly bigger and see how many scars she's gained to become big like her parents
>Then same end andy wins and bertie is kicked out and humiliated by the town

>>151524485
It needed to lean harder into Andy not having any special physical ability and just getting by on pure determination.

>>151521681
Girls cant lead shows like this. It appealed to nobody. Artstyle was also really bad for the kind of show it wanted to be.

File: king-tekken3-comic-artwork.jpg (2.93 MB, 939x1920)

2.93 MB JPG

>>151533041
King is the king.

>>151541943
Yeah that sounds interesrting. Gives Bertie and Andy more reason to fight and creates a parallel between them. Andy the dreamer new to the wrestling world and Bertie more aware of it. Life long skill from someone raised by wrestlers and someone who's a messy beginner raised by accountants. Someone still believing in wrestling as their dream and someone who's life has been fucked by it. Bertie was already one of the better, if not the best, character bits from the show so tying it deeper to the show could have been good. And it gives a sort of overarching plot line beyond just "become a wrestler" that Andy had in the show.

>>151540717
scott pillgay?

>>151542870
Yeah bertie is peak and feel it should have been played with more that well she is exactly what andy wants to be. She's the daughter of the super "interesting" wrestler parents who are ex legends in their own rights. An yeah she is the best my hope is that she'd become a recurring antagonist like the promoter guy finds savaged/abused bertie and turns her into a true fighter something like. "Why are you crying little one, you should be ANGRY! In this world might makes right you lost that's why you were wrong, Poblana won that's why your parents lost themself and now some ACCOUNTANT is taking your birth right are you going to just sit here and cry or become the top so you can change this world?" Feel be a fun way to show how great he is at his job he finds people and knows what to say each time. He takes andy and uses her hype and love to raise her up but someone like bertie he uses her guilt and rage to make her desire more.

I think could see it as said above more that reason wrestling is bad is that "Might makes right" and this leads to toxicity. Think best route and why I say have bertie around problem with her main crew is they aren't super interesting. While "Big sis" bertie could help to let us subtly see darker or more warped side of the world then we get the true Ka blam of the evils when we see her backstory and it hurts more because she's been on off with andy and the squad.

>Also another re-write question but should they keep the 2 guys?

I feel what mikey does is what andy should do herself as she should be like deku and be so into wrestling she recognizes moves and things but also think a expert isn't bad just not a fan of either of them

>>151521681
I'd like to see some fighting of this, any drawfags?

>>151543317
Yeah, it should have leaned into the social commentary a lot more.

>>151539488
>5'10
>huge
All those tough girls are only up to my dick.
...
nice

File: who could they be.gif (2.42 MB, 640x360)

2.42 MB GIF

>>151543345

>>151543604
huge for japan that's their 6ft

>>151524536
My Hero Academia has 100 manga chapters and 40 anime episodes in the training arc, BEFORE of any fight with a real enemy. Fight Girl not have enough time.

>>151540743
Scenes like this is why it flopped. She should have pissed herself when getting hit like this.

>>151523666
Silently canceled maybe.

>>151543958
Think most things that didn't get confirmed by now are gg. With talks of warner being sold soon or in the works

>>151521681
Not enough ryona

>>151543958
Probably. No one knows but with how long they've been silent it's likely. The creator and team just isn't saying anything. Usually we'd have some kind of leak by now but Adult Swim / Toonami shows are weirdly tight lipped with regards to leaks.

>>151544001
True

>>151544001
Genuinely. Would have helped her case if she got beaten and lost more.

File: wwe-sexy.gif (742 KB, 220x228)

742 KB GIF

Andy should become an attention-seeker bitch as the story progresses.

Then her friends tell her she's becoming obsessed with the spectacle and neglecting the fight.
Andy loses an important fight and realizes her friends were right.
This arc ends with Andy becoming more humble.

>>151545687
I don't know who was doing these but these edits were freaking incredible. Very high quality and remained in the show's style

>>151545892
I could see that for a corruption arc maybe. Like she finally starts getting wins and it starts really getting to her head. Before getting that attitude beat out of her as she has to learn her lesson. Maybe could have lightly touched on her having a bit of an ego after she lucks out and wins her first fight with Immaculate and then thinks she's ready for anything only to be humbled immediately by the first fighter that's not a washed up street urchin.

>>151521681
>Fake wrestling anime made by people with no interest in wrestling or anime
Maybe they should've cared less about checking off diversity quotas.

File: IFG.jpg (363 KB, 1037x671)

363 KB JPG

When all the characters have better designs than the main character, it's because you ruined it.

File: Screenshot_24.png (1.63 MB, 1440x900)

1.63 MB PNG

>>151543854
she just pee everything before the fight

Requesting
>>151546659

We should establish a power scale.

Novice < Street fighter < Fighter < Professional < Master < Demigod.

>>151521681
Why would I as a non-american white man watch a show about a black woman? And why would I watch anime-but-worse when I can watch anime?

File: Screenshot_360.png (1.61 MB, 1440x900)

1.61 MB PNG

>>151547656
why not?

>>151546359
I like the boys' designs, the problem is the girls' designs, they're not ugly, but they're meh.

File: MV5BMT.jpg (300 KB, 1024x1448)

300 KB JPG

>>151547772
For one thing because there are better options. Second, because I lack the white guilt or cultural background that would make me put up with black girlbosses and wimpy white male sidekicks.

File: Screenshot_841 (6).png (1.1 MB, 1440x900)

1.1 MB PNG

>>151548013
but imagine the sex with her

>>151547977
Most of the outfit designs in the show are just fine. Nothing too standout but fine.

File: fabien-mense-ifg-busters-(...).jpg (1.09 MB, 1920x2441)

1.09 MB JPG

>>151548013
But don't you want to bleached Andy?

>>151543827
40 episodes of training would not have saved this unfunny, derivative dreck.

>>151521681
The ratings would skyrocket if she showed off her beautiful brown feet instead of wearing those ugly blue shoes

>>151543574
That it should have since it's obviously there
>>151548013
Definitely think her side kicks are a bit lacking, idk what I'd want but the two boys we got were a bit meh. I feel a squad should be able to fight or add to the team in their own way but even the analytic boy didn't really feel like he was doing much to me outside of the first fight.
>>151548792
Think people have been asking for this since like ep 1

>>151548792
I would let that bear girl empty my balls.

>>151545892
Honestly could be fun especially at the start of her big debut/after winning in the true league which seems to differ. Seems to be basic fights and real wrestling federation but really think a gloaty andy could be fun. either she loses or maybe she meets or hangs with even more shallow naracisstic fighters and realizes the path she's going down

File: Andy_outfits.png (923 KB, 2802x1142)

923 KB PNG

Combine all versions into a single image for better comparison.

>>151549689
Her gay little capes just confuses me. What is its purpose? Not physically, but thematically and aesthetically. What does adding a half-foot of cloth attached to her shoulders do for her costume?

Also; Would pound Andy to an inch of her life if she wore the rightmost outfit. Physically AND sexually.

>>151549809
>What does adding a half-foot of cloth attached to her shoulders do for her costume?
On a practical level, I think it's because a longer cape would be impractical in combat, since her opponents could use it against her.

>Edna Mode: "NO CAPES!"

On the other hand, aesthetically, she might want to look like a hero, but at the same time, the short cape represents her inexperience, like a bird whose wings are too small to fly.

>>151548149
You are supposed to look at porn when you're horny. Also onmodel cartoon women haven't been attractive since Ms Bellum.

>>151548792
Race fetishes are creepy.

>>151536885
>Was initially unsure about removing the red from her outfit but simplifying the colors down to just the three ended up working well the more I look at it.
The red might have worked if it had been a more intense and brighter red.

File: Capwithhm.png (1.47 MB, 1920x1080)

1.47 MB PNG

>>151550152
Ok, anon is gay.

>>151549809
Poblana in her prime had a big cape so I think Andy had one because she was inspired by her? Even if they never directly say it. It also gives you something to grab her by as a plus.

>>151550495
I'm not gay. She may be black, white, yellow, red, green, whatever. When I see an attractive woman, I get off to her being attractive. I don't get sexual pleasure from thinking of other groups being humiliated or from making her children not being purebreeds of a group I don't like.

>>151524447
it did take Naruto a solid 10-15 episodes to learn the rasengan

>>151551302
That it did. And it took Ippo sixty episodes, most of the first season, to learn the Dempsey Roll. But that's cheating a little since Ippo had great base foundation of boxing and the fights were cool even if he didn't know any special moves back then.

>>151549689
Put together like this and it really does highlight how much impact a little change could have had. I like the sleeves leotard and the short shorts and sleeveless ones a lot.

File: 02_08851832_050.png (1.45 MB, 1920x1162)

1.45 MB PNG

>>151551302
Yeah, but Shadow Clones was his "thing" before he started learning the Rasengan and was integral to learning it.
Coming at it from a shonen angle, spending ten episodes to learn effectively a base kit move is some hubris.

>>151521681
No marketing, and bad slots

>>151551788
The bigger issue is that the move she was trying to learn is just lame. A one shot instant win move just isn't a good idea for a show like it was trying to be.

File: invincible-fight-girl-and(...).jpg (53 KB, 1400x700)

53 KB JPG

>>151551500
I'm considering whether the red aura should stay or go.

I think a yellow aura would be better.

File: like-i-swear-to-frog-bert(...).jpg (185 KB, 2048x1054)

185 KB JPG

Okay, I get that she's getting more muscular, but why is she a head taller?

She's basically Hulk.

>>151553103
Honestly I want to redesign bertie unbound

File: 1709873589726032.jpg (69 KB, 827x584)

69 KB JPG

>>151552686
Agreed. The Perfect Strike is a shit in a lot of different angles. If you introdunce the stupid move earlier, you could at least have her hit it in differnt ways. In hindsight, should of been a Diamond Cutter, mr. wrestling fan man.

>>151553451
What would you have in mind for that, good anon? Do tell.

>>151553451
I'm listening.

>>151552686
If they follow anime rules, once an ultimate move becomes spam able , it loses 90% of its power and only works on grunts

>>151549689
think her first oufit could work if it was black under the leotard part

>>151553694
I'll try something a bit later used to draw a lot in the old threads but like all the others lost a bit of interest. Might do some rough sketches, but I am enjoying redesigns and re write talks I still say it's a fun concept and can be re worked as I remember how hype the first few threads were.
>>151553948
An you shall keep listening lol, gonna be a sec

>>151554323
It depends, the problem is that there are two leotards, but if it were just one leotard, any color combination would work.

File: Unbound_Bertie_Render.png (379 KB, 580x1056)

379 KB PNG

>>151553103
She-Hulk

>>151554291
Pretty much. That's what I mean about it being so lame. Even if the best thing happens and she does learn it a one shot knock out move, soon enough everyone will just end up immune to it or something and it'll stop mattering and end up even lamer. If it had to be something it should have been some state or just fighting style she was trying to learn. Not just one specific move.

>>151554729
would

>>151552704
It could be? The aura tying into her uniform is good for color matching so if her uniform becomes primarily yellow then making he aura yellow too would fit. I have to imagine they considered doing it in the show but thought it may be too Super Saiyan like. But with how much else they borrowed they may as well have if it meant a better cohesive look.

>>151554438
true really is interesting how little things can make a design better. Idk what I'd want with her actual outfit as I feel you can also just do a full redo of it as well

>>151551788
>>151551302
>>151524447
Not to mention the only reason he can pull off shadow clone so well is because he has practically infinite chakra, he doesn't need to be efficient, he just needs to know how to do it.

File: Sx-supersonic.png (603 KB, 640x1050)

603 KB PNG

>>151555478
>I have to imagine they considered doing it in the show but thought it may be too Super Saiyan like.
if you're going to make references, go all the way.

Nobody complained when Sonic did it.

File: Screenshot_411.png (1.12 MB, 1440x900)

1.12 MB PNG

>>151554729
you would not survive the sex

>>151554729
I must break you Andy!

File: andy_outfit_new_2.png (853 KB, 1440x900)

853 KB PNG

>>151554108
other edit.

File: 81Yp-ZY1BvL._SL1500_.jpg (253 KB, 1055x1500)

253 KB JPG

>>151521681
First impression: reminds me of those SaturdayAM not-manga comics
Why consume imitation?

File: Screenshot_841 (10).png (1.12 MB, 1366x780)

1.12 MB PNG

>>151556101
amazing, can you do in this one?

File: Screenshot_197.png (881 KB, 807x827)

881 KB PNG

>>151556288
i think that the quality is too low in this frame

>>151556288
I'll see what I can do with this one; the quality is very low, but I think I can do something.

But it will have to be tomorrow.

>>151556323
I can definitely do this one.

File: andy_outfit_new_3.png (804 KB, 1440x900)

804 KB PNG

>>151554084
other edit.

>>151556323
It's funny how sometimes Andy has curves, but other times she looks like a thinner girl.

>>151556454
Nice. Full leg leotard and the bright yellow pops well.

>>151556696
>Full leg leotard
Long Sleeve Leotard.

File: Screenshot_841 (9).png (364 KB, 814x500)

364 KB PNG

>>151556420
>the quality is very low
yeah, i just noticed after sharing it.
i love to screenshot the cartoons that it watch
>>151556454
the edit make the scene more lewd

>>151556853
I meant like she's got her full legs on display.

>>151556891
Oh... I understand.

File: 1761615890856484.jpg (76 KB, 559x440)

76 KB JPG

>>151521681
Anime sucks.
With Japanese anime, people are willing to overlook that because OMG JAPANESE THING POGGERS. Japanese products are always held to lower standards.
If you make an anime with exactly the same process, but you aren't Japanese, you will not be afforded that leniency, and people will correctly assess your shit as being abysmal.

The fact I will never know what stand hydra's deal is or what she looks like under the mask annoys me more than it has any right to

>>151557228
I'm still annoyed we have descriptions for what sound like a rival or fighter friend for Andy in the Direct TV episode descriptions, but we have no fucking idea who that is.

>>151554343
Go for it, We enjoy all takes on the Bertie and the cast. Good luck.

>>151521681
The thumbnail in the catalog made me think the girl on the left was wearing a diaper under her shorts

>>151557430
Fuck my life stupid ass win 11 updated and killed my bertie drawing and now it's all gone

>>151558114
Ouch. I'm deeply sorry about that. Windows can be a dick at the worst possible times. We'll still wait if you're still up for it, no rush.

File: image_2025-12-04_012324707.png (106 KB, 642x808)

106 KB PNG

>>151558259
I did a fast redo but now can't get same flow back and now stupid ass win 11 is freezing so much, my pc has 32 gb of ram and a 16gb graphic card like how does win 11 make everything suck

I'll try and fix tommorow but gets a good base down

>>151558114
Fuck that sucks.

>>151558476
Still, looks like you managed to get something going again. Looks like your rig is really crapping out. Good luck man and here's hoping it doesn't keep giving you trouble.

>>151558767
It's a brand new laptop too fuck me think the type just is known to lag and Idk how to fix it. Honestly ridiculous plus might be to long to return it

but tis life and saw can draw easier on a smaller canvas but still sucks. But will just have to save up and buy another one if can't return it swear crazy they can just sell lemons.

>>151558908
Man that's some screwy luck. Did the drawing application not have any backups saved? Or did the Windows 11 update just screw with all of it? It's also weird to hear a new laptop have such an issue. If anything else did get messed up or if it's still lagging I'd think you may want to look into seeing if something is running in the background slowing things down. Regardless I'm glad to see it's not keeping you down.

>>151559198
Nope I'll try more later maybe some just doodles or more color blocking just to get used to this new set up. Hopefully can fix the lag and stuff with some new stuff I'm trying.

Think I Might even try and sketch a andy design later on. But bertie is my fave

>>151558114
>Win 11
Fuck.

>>151558476
It looks good.
I feel like I've seen this before, did you use any references?

File: andy_outfit_new_4.png (712 KB, 1400x700)

712 KB PNG

>>151552704
other edit

>>151521681
I tapped out halfway into the second episode. The whole time all I thought was "why would I watch this over an actual anime?"

It has the problem a lot of western takes on anime have which is that it's afraid to commit. It has this air of ironic self distance like it's constantly telling the audience "don't worry, we think this is stupid too don't take it too seriously". Killed any desire I had to get into it.