why did one turn out so much worse than the other, when the source material for both is garbage?
>>153409640They didn't turn Tragg into literally drumpKirkman proved that he smart
>>153409640Which one is the series that turned out worse than the other?
>>153409640The original boys comic spoofed George Bush and the War on Terror. So of course the 'modern audiences' Boys was going to have to spoof Donald Trump and the Republicans . . . Even as everyone is getting really fucking sick of the 'Trump is literally Hitler' hyperbole. At this point why not just lean into the absurdity and give homelander a shitty wig and an orange spraytan?
>>153409782>Kirkman proved that he smarthis main female character aborted the main male character's child when he was off planet for like 30 seconds
>>153409640Because Kirkman is just shit at writing>sets show in zombie universe>makes zombies almost irrelevant in favour of character drama>sets show in superhero universe>makes superheroes almost irrelevant in favour of character drama>does not understand why this pisses people off>also can't write character dramaHe's such a stupid fucking hack
>>153409812>hyperboleOnly red state retards. Maybe Israelis and Russians.The rest of the world? Lol, you wish
>>153409865Cope
>>153409887Seethe, dilate, appreciate
>>153409865Even if you don't like trump. The joke isn't funny anymore. The 'Trump Is Hitler' joke should be to political satire as the fart joke is to normal comedy, less is more. Otherwise people just get grossed out and leave.
>>153410162...joke?
>>153409640>OP doesn't specify whether The Boys TV series turned out better than the Invincible TV series or if it's the other way around so that anons can start fighting I see right through your games...
>>153409640The Boys is so ridiculous it end being funny, manly for Homelander and Butcher. They carry the show.Also the criticism over politics and right-wingers is so pathetic it ends making far right things in the show to look awesome. Probably is almost intentional.I give non shit about Starlight's drama, however. Fuck that.
>>153412018>manly for Homelander and Butcher.It still sounds like a compliment.
>>153409887nah he's right, I live in Australia and everyone thinks Trump is a drooling retard. Literally only Iranian diaspora and Jews like him, for obvious reasons.
>>153409640Give it time. The real retarded shit for Invincible is coming
>>153412052It is. Both actors are funny on screen. In fact they should have four times more screen time.
>>153412118the only retarded shit i know is the rape and the abortion
>>153412146>>153412052I'm just glad Jensen Ackles is still in the show.I think the black noir storyline from the comics would've been cool too
>>153409640they are both terrible though comics and shows though?
>>153409812>>153410162Trump's reputation is the worst it's ever been, people dont think its hyperbole. And parodying Trump was common even before he was president. The knock against the Boys is that it just stopped doing a parody of now and just started doing it explicitly which is less interesting.
>>153409786The boys fell much farther from grace, get real, invincible humiliates it just by having an actual timeless plot that remembers it's about superheroes instead of seething over current year slop>>153409815>main female character abortedAlso happened in the boys, what's your point
>>153409833If he's shit at writing why did the Invincible cartoon turn out better than The Boys, despite sticking more to the source material than The Boys show did?
>>153412516>Also happened in the boys, what's your pointstarlight is old news. nobody's liked her in like 3 seasonswe're all about WMAF now
>>153412630I was watching the Invincible cartoon and it's fucking trash. I think the cunt just identifies popular trends and tries to attach his mid dramas to them in search of bank. It's worked, don't get me wrong, but what works is boring. innovative ideas rarely succeed, he's just managed to create yet another generic money making machine.And I want a refund for the time I put into his shitty fucking cartoon
>>153413467the invincible cartoon is funny because they do a lot of virtue signalling (like making amber black) which ends up coming off the opposite way they intended (like making the unlikable bitch a black woman)
>>153412675every time I see a screenshot from s5 I feel like I I'm somehow getting more retardedvery much glad knowing the writing is on the wall that it'll end like dogshit and all the people who thought it wasn't going to be shit get proven wrong
>>153409640Capeshit deconstruction stories is faggot shit.Change my mind.
>>153409812Hey! Hitler at least liked animals and nature.
both shows are fun, I'm glad I don't take any of this seriously and only enjoy the ride
>>153409640It helps Invincible isn't TDS the show and has an actual story, The Boys was legit never good
>>153412018>Homelander and Butcher. They carry the show.At this point, Soldier Boy is the only good part of this shitshow.
>>153409786>>153411946Come on, no matter how trash you think Invincible is and will get, it's obvious that The Boys is still much worse.
The Boys S1 was legit not bad. It was released at a time when "fuck capeshit" was a relevant vibe and not just Garth Ennis' autistic seething. It only went to complete unwatchable shit because it's made by retarded thin-skinned American Jews who care more about Twitter than about making a good show.
>>153409640Invincible mostly sticks to its source while the Boys writing seems to be made up on the spot using a dartboard.
>>153409640both are shite.
>>153415908and thats why The Boys is much more entertaining
I genuinely can't tell which you're referring to. They are both equally unfun and poorly budgeted.
>>153409640Because one of them was taken over by political partisans and virtue signalers who use the show as their soapbox. Poorly thought out changes were made to core elements of the original story, as well as the identities of major characters to fit modern agendas.Also, the budget is clearly going to the celebrities rather the show's production.That show is another example in a long line of shows ruined by modern day political activism, producer greed, corporate hubris, and disrespect for the source material and the comics medium in general.That show is just awful, made by awful people.
>>153409640>The Boys' source material was a edgy deconstruction of the super hero genere that didn't took itself seriously until like the very end. Was very political and wasn't shy when it came down to insulting any major groups>The show and spin off is a safe edgy leftwing/Jewish soapbox that twisted the source material into an unrecognizable tool to constantly insult one specific group while taking itself seriously from the beginning.Invincible is still practically following it roots with being mature capeshit despite it minor abnormalities.Also let not forget that the creator for invincible is still the main director for the show. Last time I check, Ennis has nothing to do with The TV series beside having that animated segment in the diabolical anthology short. That short and season 1 was more in tune with source material than the rest of the series. It's ridiculous.
Because Invincible wasn't interesting in the first place.
>>153409640The Boys became an incredibly confused and brazenly retarded mouthpiece for its retarded writers and director. It's too busy trying to say something about modern culture to actually tell a story, which is so far off the rails that they've just been making up gross and horrendous things to keep the audience hooked with shock value.Invincible just mostly just trying to adapt the comics with some questionable changes, but still making an overall acceptable edgy superhero cartoon.
>>153412630The Boys show is just wearing the skin of the comics and the people writing it are somehow far worse than Kirkman. Neither are truly great, but between the two, The Boys is worse.
>>153409812>everyone is getting really fucking sick of the 'Trump is literally Hitler' hyperbole.We aren't and it isn'tSit down and shut the fuck up kid
I liked the Tick Amazon show better than either of these. I want to go back and fix the timeline.
>>153409865I live in a red state and conservatives here are sick of him too. Ironically, them banning DEI, transgenders, abortion, and immigrants made it easier to see the figures actually responsible for increasing fuel prices and worsening their quality of life.He's so objectively terrible that my priest was ranting about him in sermons yesterday, he condemns abortion and lgbt!You have to be balls deep in pro-Trump podcasts and twitter to think that a blasphemous incompetent pedo like him is good.
>>153418643>NOOOOOOO YOU HAVE TO LISTEN TO US WHINE ETERNALLY ABOUT MUH MUTT POLITICSyawwwnyou were saying the same things with South Park's last season. all it did was ruin discussion of that show forever.
>>153409640Invincible is the best western action cartoon we have in spite of its flaws. A lot of western action cartoons prior had worse action scenes and animation along with having no continuity because of TV censorship. They were hot garbage to watch.It doesn't hold back on the sex and gore, so it is equivalent to anime
>>153412354I don't know? My statements must be posed as questions because I'm a retard zoomer?
>>153418682mutt politics is affecting everyone badly across the globe because of retarded tariffs and wars, it is not irrelevant in the slightest and everyone normal hates him
>>153409640The Goys tv show is meta kino, its pretty much a Vought adaptation made after the (narratively real world) events (of the comics )
>>153418713>our free ride is over ;;sounds like he's doing a good job then
>>153418724A lot of you Trump supporters have yet to realize that no one likes you outside of your echochamber.
>>153416708Yes, but one is still better than the other.
>>153409640The Boys is clearly written by people with TDS. Invincible, despite having Leftist propaganda, is actually free from TDS surprisingly. Turns out when you focus on writing instead of crying about Orange Judas, your show can actually achieve quality.
>>153418651>How do you do, fellow conservatives? Dont we all just hate le Drumpf?You people will never stop.
>>153418600invincible is run by seth rogenargument invalidated
>>153420011Invincible isn't TDS but it is (((subversive))) in the way many hollyweird adaptations are
>>153420464Aren't both shows run by Seth to an extent? At least invincible has the original creator in charge. The TV show is essentially a revision from the comics.
Can The Boys please end with everyone getting brutally murdered like in the comics?Kill Butcher, Mother's Milk, Frenchie, and the Female.If Hughie doesn't murder Butcher it's all worthless.
>>153418647Man, I miss that show. Thanks for reminding me
>>153421084From the supposed leaks, take them as you will, the only major person to die beside homelander and butcher would be frenchie. That's it. Ofc they will continue milking this series with it prequel show.
>>153418643You're gay
>>153418096I doubt Amazon will ever care to invest in better animation for Invincible. Hell, the shitty animation sparks MORE engagement online, which is exactly what they'd love
>>153409640season 5 is better than 4 and 3 so far
>>153409640The boys adaptation completely FUCKED Homelander's character.In comics he's just some random aashole with powers and his descent into madness wasnt of his making.In the show they just play it for tropes(Hes fuuucked up and sad because of his childhood brah) and also make him drink titmilk because lmfaoedge.The entire culmination if his character, and an ironic showcase of WHY people love superheroes, is this scene where author all but turns to face the camera and goes "If Homelander didn't have any powers he would be no one special. He is as dull as a bus station crackhead.". The inverse of that is of course, the classic idea that a hero is made by the strenght of his character and not the powerset. So this pastisch of superheroes, ends up playing into the (well-beloved) tropes in a way that makes even the superhero media haters concede.It's genuinely written well as fuck but somehow the consensus is that the show is good?The show just makes him drumpf and a mommy fetishist.I would actually appreciate it more if they went all in on the Trump comparison and had Homelander fuck kids on Stormfront Island but even their parody is without balls.
>>153418714>The Goys tv show is meta kino, its pretty much a Vought adaptation made after the (narratively real world) events (of the comicsThis is the greatest interpretation i''ve ever fucking heard.It explains so much.They make starlight a retarded whoreThey make M.M into a walking stereotype of a BLACK MAYNThey make Frenchie into a faggotThey make The Female into a tiktok stacyThey make Hughie into a rape victim twink cuckold.It's all the things a seething corporation would do to rewrite history...Holy shit. Thank you for raising that concept. Saved the show and elevated the comic for me lmfao.
>>153409640Invincible isn’t a series of like 30 blackmail attempts across 40 episodes.
>>153418643>We aren't and it isn'tIf you're serious, that is really sad.
>>153418651such a shame american conservatism turned out this way, italy has a conservative PM and he seems alright, even my country just recently elected a conservative, hes a bit dick sucky towards trump (which comes with the territory of being a latin american conservative) but besides that, hes just, normal
>>153422847>secret final episode of the show is the actors doing a series wrap up as their real selves talking about how the real events of the comic affected them
>>153409640>similarity ends at "gory superheroes and evil superman">somehow constantly compared
>>153423137I would KNEEL if that happened.I think the series finale is already out though?
>>153420051Cope
homelander being trump feels very liberal the boys was about how personalities like homelander don't actually have real individual power but are systemically propped up by capitali just read they had homelander SUCCESSFULLY take over the world? wtf lol
>>153409640They both suck. And not just as shows but comics to.
>>153409640Both are garbage>>153416708/thread/
>>153423277Could Uber be adapted?
>>153420895I think he's involved in both but more involved in Invincible.Erik Kripke (Supernatural) is better than whatever Garth Ennis would have come up with
>>153423470Uber is pretty cool but id like to know the consensus before i next display an opinion in public
>>153409640the boys, no matter how dogshit the plot is. is still 100x better than the 0 budget animation for invincible with shitty celebirity voice acting.
>>153423277u are not cool
>>153425671invincible has good animation (sometimes)
>>153409640That's happen when liberal activists can't follow the source the material from a success comicbook, and Robert should know better.
>>153425012No, not because it’s too gruesome, because it puts some Nazis in a…forgiving light
>>153421433I am not in fact your dad
>>153426886Are these "times" in the room with us right now?
>>153409782>proved that he smartIronically stupid.
>>153424804>Erik Kripke (Supernatural) is better than whatever Garth Ennis would have come up withClearly not.
>>153426886It fucking does not. I gave it a fair shot, got to the midpoint of season 3 or something, was impressed literally 0 times by the animation. I frankly got offended by the fact that this series obviously got views, got the green light for further seasons, yet literally nothing got better
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1J6_NCoh8tY
>>153422791>I would actually appreciate it more if they went all in on the Trump comparison and had Homelander fuck kids on Stormfront Island but even their parody is without balls.Ironically enough even the fucking comics unintentionally predicted irl shit like Epstein's Island with Herogasm.
>>153429953KINOOOOOOO
>>153423277sybau pepe, what do (You) know
>>153418651>Ironically, them banning DEI, transgenders, abortion, and immigrants>implyingHim not actually doing any of that and instead being a complete ZOGbot with a fanbase of groids publically celebrating about how they'll happily have jewish blackmail pedorape and wars and trans kids if they get deportations that aren't happening is kinda the problem here
>>153409812>Trump is literally Hitler' >hyperbole.Huehuehuehueh
