[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/co/ - Comics & Cartoons


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: decon.jpg (408 KB, 1200x1847)
408 KB JPG
Did this interaction really require an entire page?
>>
>>153556718
>Eight copy-pasted panels of Bendis sitting and thinking, and only on the 9th does he say "Yes".
>>
>>153556718
AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA HOW IS HE THAT SMALL????
>>
>>153556989
He's Canadian
>>
File: rjih6blc0coz.jpg (349 KB, 1536x2048)
349 KB JPG
>>153556954
Bendis is a genius.
>>
>>153556718
You'd rather they cram an entire lengthy monologue from Kitty about how he made love to her in the missionary position for the sole purpose of procreation, complete with additional boxes of her inner thoughts to provide vital, super important emotional and/or narrative commentary, all within a single 5 x 5 inch panel, OP?
>>
File: xmen.jpg (185 KB, 887x1071)
185 KB JPG
>>153556989
He's sitting down.
Everything in that room does have strange dimensions, though. How far away is Logan from the doorway behind him? How much space is there between the table and the fridge? How many kitchen cabinets are attached to the wall with the fridge?
>>
File: 1777856900993822.png (3.86 MB, 1497x1579)
3.86 MB PNG
>>153556718
Here I fixed it. gave it some action on the bottom so kids will want to keep on reading
>>
>>153557276
Yes.
>>
>>153557276
yea
>>
>>153556718
>decon
>>
File: 1764850445899366.jpg (473 KB, 1536x1348)
473 KB JPG
>>153557076
>>
>>153557981
>nails the social interaction in a concise way
>gives the readers an extra panel of Storm being HENTAIED
Dangerously based
>>
>>153557981
This is actually pretty good.
>>
>>153557981
nice
>>
>>153556718
I dunno OP does this page from thirty years ago require a second thread?
>>
File: steely dan.png (851 KB, 794x626)
851 KB PNG
>>153559352
>blues
>>
>>153559918
The more comic threads, the better.
>>
>>153557076
>RDJ slips in one liners and quips
>Bendis interprets this as Deadpool level “LOLSORANDUMB XD XD XD”
Can you imagine Tony Stark, in any sort of interpretation, even the RDJ version, doing anything like this? Like what in the fuck this page went thru so many hands at no point did anyone say “this is the worst thing ever put to a page in the history of comics. This makes Rob Liefeld look like fucking David Mamet”
>>
>>153556718
Did that page require another thread?
>>
>>153559965
>>153559944
>>
File: ai art.png (1.77 MB, 1004x1567)
1.77 MB PNG
>>153559918
>>
>>153559995
This is "barely" a comic thread. It's a low effort whine thread from some fag chasing (you)s after he saw the last one have actual discussion and posts. Just a monkey copying without thought
>>
>>153557981
Excellent. You've got a future kid
>>
>>153557981
holy based
>>
>>153557276
sure
>>
>>153559949
>in any sort of interpretation, even the RDJ version
It's shocking that marvel-tards still wonder why an indefensible company that went all in on the lowest common lowest effort highest payout 'creativity' wouldn't do shit it viewed, in it's hackiest and truest self, as synergistic
>>
>>153560039
It's better than a non-comic thread. If you don't like it, make better comic threads.
>>
File: 1503071771361.gif (879 KB, 245x230)
879 KB GIF
>>153561738
>that line up
I'd give it a shot, ngl
>>
>>153557981
This reads more like Superior Foes. I like Superior Foes. But I dunno if every comic should be like this. However it is more readable than modern day shit.
>>
File: IMG_5517.jpg (453 KB, 650x1791)
453 KB JPG
>>153560009
>>
>>153563450
Superior Foes is unfunny dogshit.
>>
>>153557276
thats what claremont would do, with additional narration boxes in each panel
>>
>>153557276
yup
>>
>>153563816
>>153566038
OP, you should just kill your self instead of constantly making this thread.
>>
>>153556718
Yes, this is funny, and legit needs those panels.

>>153557076
This is cancer and I hate it.
>>
>>153566047
Nah
>>
>>153557981
I was about to say if you were claremont but there need 1000 words to be a claremont page
>>
>>153557317
>*two* separate entrances into the kitchen from opposite angles
Do you want to cause a mess and/or stab some? Because thats how you cause a mess and/or stab someone
>>
>>153566047
It's fine
>>
>>153566777
>*two* separate entrances into the kitchen
What? Are you blind?
>>
>>153557057
Oh so that's why it is. Area is from Quebec and Between Friends was crammed with this level of recycling.
>>
File: astonishing x-men edit.jpg (365 KB, 1200x1146)
365 KB JPG
>>153556718
Would you prefer it more like this?
>>
>>153571421
Better.
>>
>>153571421
Now it has no innuendo
>>
>>153571504
It's still there. You don't need a stretched out panel for that
>>
>>153559949
>Like what in the fuck this page went thru so many hands at no point did anyone say “this is the worst thing ever put to a page in the history of comics. This makes Rob Liefeld look like fucking David Mamet”

According to credits, Tom Brevoort was one of the editors

This is one of those things that make me wonder if it's Brevoort's passive-aggressive way of letting Bendis take the fall with bad idea or bad page after another, or he was checked out by this point
>>
>>153556718
>>153557317
This is some storyboarding shit.
>>
You posted this thread recently with the question being about decompression. So why are you spamming the same shit?
>>
>>153573706
This is my first time posting on this board
>>
File: more ai art.png (3.68 MB, 971x1619)
3.68 MB PNG
>>153556718
There I used Ai to fix the panel and make the page even better
>>
>>153566743
I can fix that
>Kitty inner monologue: it’s such a beautiful morning in the Xavier school, it almost makes me forget about all the problems with Illyana and how odd it is to have Peter back from the dead. With his armored skin it’s like he’s a genuine shell of a person
>Piotr inner monologue: Da, it is my comrade Logan, otherwise known as Wolverine, sitting at the kitchen table for breakfast. In Russia we didn’t have breakfast, the bourgeois kept our bellies hungry. Luckily my mutant power not only hardens my skin but my belly as well
NEXT PANEL
>Logan inner monologue: more bubs in the kitchen that’s just great I’m a loner I don’t like other bubs up in my personal space. Thanks to my mutant healing factor I can stand to be alone. Wait I think I smell something on Kitty with my heightened mutant senses. Smells like maybe Kitty and the Ruskie spent the night together
FOURTH PANEL
>Kitty inner monologue: oh my goodness I didn’t think to take into account Wolverine’s heightened mutant senses! He can probably smell Peter’s musk on me, I can feel the blood rushing to my face to make me blush, I should use my mutant power or phasing through walls to escape this situation!
>Piotr inner monologue: Lenin’s ghost! Comrade Logan has discovered I’ve been intimate with Kitty! In Mother Russia we never speak of such things…perhaps I’ll use my mutant gift to steel my skin to steel my emotions as well!
>>
>>153557076
I remember years ago /co/ thought this was genuinely hilarious.
>>
>>153574707
Bull. Fucking. Shit. Show me proof. How dare you make a claim like that without backing it up.
>>
>>153556718
Yes, it did. Whedon and Cassaday understood how to let the art speak for itself. It wasn't decompression or laziness, it was individual story beats for comedic effect. Logan looks at Kitty, then at Pete, then drops his one-liner.

Compare that to slop like >>153559423
>>
>>153574707
The reality is it was more like this:
https://desuarchive.org/co/thread/77221478
>>
>>153574760
https://desuarchive.org/co/thread/78636690/#78644400
Looking back, it may have been the tumblr tourists that were openly invited into the board thanks to the drawthreads.
>>
>>153574811
That post reads like it could be either someone from tumblr or someone shilling for Marvel and/or Bendis
>>
>>153574634
10/10 perfection
>>
>>153574634
Fuck you, Claremont.
>>
>>153557981
You should do this professionally, good stuff man



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.