[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


>invents the most retarded writing system in your path
>>
Slightly number in Vietnam, still use Classical Chinese characteristics.
>>
>>17959978

I agree. Christian made writing systems are much better.
>>
Why didn't the Chinese ever develop an alphabet? Even Egyptian Hieroglyphics became more abstract over time and evolved into Phoenician and Greek, why didn't the same thing happen with Chinese characters?
>>
File: 1756533191350.png (1 KB, 275x183)
1 KB
1 KB PNG
>Makes it even worse
>>
>>17961206
They wanted to keep it hard on purpose, so only the most autistic eunuchs could work in the palace. Literal gatekeeping.
>>
>>17959978
>carve words on turtle bones as instructions for priests
>it becomes a writing system for the whole county
oops?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oracle_bone_script
>>
>>17961142
The Latin Alphabet is greco roman pagan
>>
>>17959978
korean writing sytem is actually the best
>>
>>17961527

No. The Latin alphabet is Christian. It was first drafted by Alexander of Constantinopole. Greeks and Romans used cuneiform, while other pagans didn't have writing at all.
>>
OP is a fags
>>
>>17959978
it's good for empire making
>>
File: Transcribed.jpg (241 KB, 1280x848)
241 KB
241 KB JPG
>>17959978
Mongolia has fuck all to do with the Chinese writing system. Heck, they even established their writing during the empire period... getting the basis from the Central Asians.
Vietnam, on the other hand, is a full Sinitic state. Look up Ho Chi Minh's letters where he still mixes the characters and latin together.

>>17961206
Egyptian hieroglyphics were an abjad. They were writing out the sounds, just with very fancy forms.
>>
>>17959978
it looks cool so it's fine
>>
File: ching1.jpg (381 KB, 800x800)
381 KB
381 KB JPG
>>17959978
what are they saying??
>>
>>17962426
>Egyptian hieroglyphics were an abjad.
That's only partially true. They were a mixed system that included symbols that represented consonants alongside logograms. They're more similar to Japanese writing systems than Chinese ones.
>>
>*blocks you're path*
We've had west mexican writings for ages but the writing is so utterly dense and built around pictures and obscure metaphor that people spent years thinking they were like comic books or something.

The maya invented a much more normal writing system based around shitloads of small symbols representing normal sounds, and the west mexican cultures seemed to have lots of knowledge of this system and even partially used it as essentially captions for their pictographic writings, but they just didn't feel like converting to anything readable I guess. Teotihuacan firmly rejected mayan writing in favor of pictographic systems and they were basically the rome of mesoamerica, so I guess maybe because of them they associated readable script with lack of class.
>>
>>17962942
This is a Maya book for comparison
>>
File: wojaksoyjak3467823.png (758 KB, 752x706)
758 KB
758 KB PNG
>>17961527
>EVERYTHING GOOD WAS MADE BY NON-CHRISTIANS AND EVERYTHING BAD WAS MADE BY CHRISTIANS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

>TAKE ME SERIOUSLY PLEASE FOR FUCKS SAKE PLEASE TAKE ME SERIOUSLY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
>>
File: Inca-Alphabet-2.jpg (201 KB, 1080x1080)
201 KB
201 KB JPG
>>17962942
>>17962943
Actually I'm wrong, now that im thinking about the americas the most retarded "writing" system is absolutely Quipu without a doubt
>>
>>17962942
>>17962943
This is so retarded.
>>
>>17962946
To be honest Simon, that Picrel more accurately represents you when seeing bustyboys than anything else.
>>
>>17962963

WHAT?
>>
>>17961885
>we have over 9,000 characters
lmao, nah, china is fags
>>
>>17961533
>other pagans didn't have writing at all.
Except the Egyptians, the Phoenicians, the Assyrians, the Armenians, the Georgians, the Etruscans, the Raetians, the Nori, the Iberians, the Germans, the Anglo-Saxons, the Scandinavians, etc.
>>
>>17962949
Quipu probably recorded mostly numbers
That they could have recorded language is speculation
>>
>>17959978
Americans invented - and widely employed - something even more retarded. It's called the three-cueing system which is a method of teaching the kids reading by NOT using the phonetic characteristic of a Latin alphabet. They would show the kids a picture of a cat, for example, with the word "cat" written below, and the kids were supposed to remember the whole shape of a written word WITHOUT recognizing and learning separate phonemes. And so on with thousands of other words. It's like the Chinese system but deliberately worse.
I shit you not, if you wonder why illiteracy as high as among modern Americans is even possible them it's because if pure charlatan imbeciles managing the American education.
>>
>>17963620
Wow...you're....wrong and extremely retarded!
>>
File: 983.png (109 KB, 340x444)
109 KB
109 KB PNG
>>17963620
You're going to tell me about my country and then pretend to be American when you're called out.
>>
>>17963624
>pretend to be American when you're called out.
You couldn't pay me enough for that.
>>
>>17963620
Americans children are taught English using Phonics like literally everywhere else in the world. What the fuck even possesses you to just spread misinformation without even trying?
>>
>>17963620
>>17963624
>>17963631
The 3 cuing system was invented by
Marie Clay, an australian, you retard
>>17963628
>bragging about being a third worlder
weird post
>>
>>17963631
depends where you are. most left wing democrat run shitholes teach the australian marie clay 3 cues bullshit because George W Bush told them to teach phonics so they teach democrat kids to read wrong to piss off Bush
>>
>>17963636
>The 3 cuing system was invented by Marie Clay, an australian
same difference, mutt. YOU have widely embraced it kek
>>
>>17963695
australians are bongoliods, you gay retard and your country hasn't invented AC and all your men wear dresses, tranny
>>
>>17963736
>you gay retard and your country hasn't invented AC and all your men wear dresses, tranny
That's a great insight about the origins of your writing system and the extent of your working vocabulary.
>>
>>17959978
>makes up 3000 different letters and will fire you if you get one wrong at the wrong time
Heh, nuttin personnel kid
>>
>>17963742
I'm just describing what you are in a way you will understand, troon
>>
>>17963620
Oh now I get why they have all those weird spelling competitions, most kids just can't spell any word they don't know previously
>>
>>17963950
spelling bees predate Australian Marie Clay's bullshit by like 50 years and predates widespread American use of Australian Marie Clay's bullshit by like 80 years
>>
>>17963622
>>17963624
>>17963631
American here, i really hate to say it but this is a real thing. It never took over the whole country because it was fucking retarded, and thankfully its now in decline, but tens of millions of children from the 80s to the 2010s were in fact taught reading like that.
Its more often called "Whole Language"
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whole_language
>>
>>17962426
Mongorian script is aesthetic af. Great flag, too.
>>
>>17963620
Nah, Nigga. We hooked on phonics n' sheeiiit!
>>
>>17959978
Japanese and Koreans invented alphabets/syllabaries of their own THOUGH
>>
File: 1756514563480554.webm (2.83 MB, 720x1280)
2.83 MB
2.83 MB WEBM
>>17965501
I told that teacher lady the only letters I needed to know were

>U
>S
>A
>>
>>17964914
it wasn't invented by Americans though, it was invented by an australian and only pushed by dems because Bush wanted phonics
>>
>>17961533
The earliest inscriptions in the Greek and Latin alphabets both date back to the 8th century BC you faggot. Cuneiform was already long extinct and forgotten by the time of Greece and Rome
>>
>>17962946
Literally the most accurate representation of an atheist I have ever seen.
>>
>>17959978
It has soul.
That you can’t deny.
>>
>>17961206
Lots of reasons, but some context:
Modern Chinese is descended roughly from the Qin. Even during the Warring States Era, every state had its own writing system, similar but in some cases simply unintelligible. After unification to the Qin Empire, the writing system was standardized which was a huge achievement. Every noble, scholar, bureaucrat, had to learn this new system. The benefit was that every dialect now had a common writing system, even if they couldn't understand each other. The southern Chu couldn't understand wtf people from the former Dai state were saying, but they could write out. It wasn't uncommon for this psuedo-text message format for bureacrats from remote regions like Nanzhong to communicate to the imperial court through just writing out their messages and having a eunuch read it out lout.

So you got a writing system that is used by the elite/scholar class, almost exclusively and it was a massive pain to implement the first time around that it's a miracle it got implemented in the first place. These elites have a vested interest in maintaining the writing system (conservatives in power hate change). It's like the StarCraft 2 Balance Council where SC2 pros were extremely conservative in their balancing, or made it balanced to favor pro play instead of casual play. There was no reason or impetus for change. And even if there was, such reform would have been huge, costly, and resisted at the institutional level by millions. Centuries of tradition would need to be undone. That's why one of Communist China's crowning achievements was the implementation of simplified Chinese and standardization of Beijing Mandarin dialect.

Even in Korea, when King Sejong created Hangul for the peasants to learn the language easier, the elites resisted and he just exiled them. Korea is of course a vastly smaller country, so it wasn't as difficult as implementing as China. In Japan, they reformed their language roughly with the Meiji Era.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.