/his/ - What if I don't consent to the Social Contract? - History & Humanities

Anonymous

10/01/25(Wed)08:27:59 No.18037652

File: 3837.jpg (203 KB, 1143x1600)

203 KB JPG

Anonymous 10/01/25(Wed)08:27:59 No.18037652 Archived

What if I don't consent to the Social Contract?

Anonymous
10/01/25(Wed)08:33:43 No.18037657

Anonymous 10/01/25(Wed)08:33:43 No.18037657

If you want to victimize others, welcome to Stirner.
If you want to live peacefully, welcome to objectivism.

Anonymous
10/01/25(Wed)08:46:27 No.18037669

Anonymous 10/01/25(Wed)08:46:27 No.18037669

>>18037652
You will be forced to consent. It's a question with only one answer. You will consent whether you like it or not

Anonymous
10/01/25(Wed)08:53:54 No.18037677

Anonymous 10/01/25(Wed)08:53:54 No.18037677

>>18037669
Then its not consent?

Anonymous
10/01/25(Wed)09:02:11 No.18037685

Anonymous 10/01/25(Wed)09:02:11 No.18037685

>>18037677
No it is, because you would be crazy not to consent. It would be equivalent to not consenting to getting thrown off the ship in the middle of the Pacific

Anonymous
10/01/25(Wed)09:08:44 No.18037691

Anonymous 10/01/25(Wed)09:08:44 No.18037691

>>18037685
But in this scenario I could open the door of the pressurized cabin and jump out if I really didn't care about the consequences?

Anonymous
10/01/25(Wed)12:59:00 No.18038081

Anonymous 10/01/25(Wed)12:59:00 No.18038081

>>18037685
>you would be crazy not to be insane
Bad logic

Anonymous
10/01/25(Wed)13:10:43 No.18038108

Anonymous 10/01/25(Wed)13:10:43 No.18038108

>>18037652
Since there's no anarchist territory in the world where you can go if you reject the social contract, you'll just end up getting thrown in prison by the state.

Anonymous
10/01/25(Wed)14:33:40 No.18038298

Anonymous 10/01/25(Wed)14:33:40 No.18038298

>>18038108
>all homeless people are in prison

Anonymous
10/01/25(Wed)14:40:54 No.18038304

Anonymous 10/01/25(Wed)14:40:54 No.18038304

>>18038298
Homeless people live in squalor tho, do you really want to live like that?

Anonymous
10/01/25(Wed)16:02:19 No.18038443

Anonymous 10/01/25(Wed)16:02:19 No.18038443

>>18037652
What if I consent to the social contract but the other side repeatedly and demonstrably breaches the contract?

Anonymous
10/01/25(Wed)16:04:24 No.18038450

Anonymous 10/01/25(Wed)16:04:24 No.18038450

>>18037657
I just want to be able to have sex as a low status man free from legal restraints so I'm not always on edge all the time. Masturbation isn't cutting it and I need a real woman to stick my dick in.

Anonymous
10/01/25(Wed)16:14:24 No.18038480

Anonymous 10/01/25(Wed)16:14:24 No.18038480

>>18038450
Welcome to stirner it is, then. Shame.

Anonymous
10/01/25(Wed)17:05:43 No.18038592

Anonymous 10/01/25(Wed)17:05:43 No.18038592

>>18037652
So break it. Reject the standards society imposes on you, break whatever laws you feel like. Just accept that your actions have consequences; and the state has a much bigger stick then you do.

Anonymous
10/01/25(Wed)19:28:03 No.18038874

Anonymous 10/01/25(Wed)19:28:03 No.18038874

>>18038443
then you kill them in their sleep

Anonymous
10/01/25(Wed)19:43:44 No.18038925

Anonymous 10/01/25(Wed)19:43:44 No.18038925

>>18037652
Than you can live out in the woods off grid like many people do

Anonymous
10/01/25(Wed)19:52:08 No.18038953

Anonymous 10/01/25(Wed)19:52:08 No.18038953

>>18038298
in some countries, yes

Anonymous
10/01/25(Wed)19:53:08 No.18038957

Anonymous 10/01/25(Wed)19:53:08 No.18038957

>>18038480
everything is downstream from sexual biology

Anonymous
10/01/25(Wed)20:05:41 No.18039002

Anonymous 10/01/25(Wed)20:05:41 No.18039002

>>18037652
then you are not protected by said contract, and there is no reason why any other more powerful actor, the state, wouldn't force its will on you.
To whom you gonna appeal? The mother nature?

Anonymous
10/01/25(Wed)23:47:01 No.18039424

Anonymous 10/01/25(Wed)23:47:01 No.18039424

You’re asserting that legitimacy requires actual consent. Many libertarian philosophies operate on this premise.