[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: Karl_Marx.jpg (85 KB, 640x750)
85 KB
85 KB JPG
>Create a philosophy for the masses to free them from suffering.
>Masses hate you.
ngmi
>>
>>18051057
You missed a part
>Create a philosophy for the masses to free them from suffering.
>it results in even worse suffering that kills 100,000,000 and nearly ends the world in a nuclear holocaust
>Masses hate you.
>>
To be fair he underestimated human competency to carry out large goals.
>>
>>18051063
It would seem that was sort of the purpose, judging by the result. The ones who died suffered no longer.
>the sickle was the reapers, the hammer was the Smith, the people were the wheat, chaff and iron.
>>
>>18051057
That's not Jesus
>>
>>18051057
>>18051063
call it, bait or retarded?
>>
>>18051078
Look at the make up of the bolsheviks you might be on to something
>>
>>18051079
that's material Jesus
>>
>>18051057
>Followers were so cringe that even on your lifetime you deny you follow your ideology out of spite
Lol
>>
What philosophy? Guy was just a doomer with his revolution bullshit and had no plan how to run the country if the revolutionaries won.
>>
>>18051157
Sad but true.
>>
>>18051063
Never forget the 100 gorillon.
>>
>>18051063
Can we see the bomes of these 100,000,000?
>>
File: 1735105212588331.png (626 KB, 602x799)
626 KB
626 KB PNG
>>
>>18051063
the hoholcaust card is played out
>>
File: 1755504523449755.png (270 KB, 750x658)
270 KB
270 KB PNG
>>
>>18051063
>100,000,000
is that with out without the nazis that died in ww2 and their potential offspring?
>>
>>18051239
>>18051243
muh 80 trillion killed by capitalism because we didnt send enough billions of dollars to africa
>>
>>18051251
could say the same about the hoholcaust
>>
>>18051243
What level of retardation do you have to be on to attribute the deaths from the Paris commune to capitalism?
>>
>>18051263
they were massacred by capitalist forces, get your head out of the gutter, bougiecuck
>>
>>18051268
I'm sure the French troops taking the city back were thinking "how can I profit off this?"
>>
>>18051300
damn you are even dumber than i initially assumed
>>
>>18051057
Should've made his philosophy simpler desu. The notion of class conflict, of humanity's telos in communism, of dialectical materialism are just extras which makes the average marx reader completely lost to the point which is :

>man has natural proclivities like working, expressing himself, being social etc
>man can't do that because "x" alienates him from his essence
>therefore we need to, within the limits of possible, work towards a society where "x" doesn't alienate him

The problem is that all extras aforementionned antagonize marx from the bourgeoisie and creates a utopic and historic vision of his thought when in reality it's much simpler.
>>
>>18051308
You already lost shit for brains when you posted those retarded images making claims like 12 million dead in the holocaust because of capitalism, in nazi (national socialist) Germany
>>
File: marxmutt.jpg (88 KB, 888x849)
88 KB
88 KB JPG
>everything in human history can be reduced to material conditions and class struggle or however the gefülte fisch is poached
>>
>Gibs me dat fo free
>>
>>18051317
>national socialism = socialism
like i said, you are actually retarded

sorry mate but i dont see the point in arguing which mentally disabled people like you
>>
>>18051318
I look like this and say this
>>
>>18051324
Likewise retarded communist child
>>
>>18051338
Don't worry kiddo, in a few years you'll outgrow this communsit phase
>>
>>18051345
im not even a communists, just not a delusional old man
>>
>>18051345
Let me guess ? You're an edgy fascist because we must return to tradition ? Or maybe you're a lolbert who couldn't understand taxes ?

which is it anon ?
>>
>>18051353
he's either a child with conservative parents or a boomer

because he's spouting utterly antiquated propaganda
>>
>>18051353
lolberts are the biggest losers on the planet (after centrist liberals), so that's my guess
>>
>seething so hard hes samefagging now
sad
>>
>>18051365
i bet you're a single guy in your 60s with no children

a sad, wasted existence
>>
>>18051365
come on anon what's your belief system, I'm sure it's a really good one that won't be pulled apart and shit on immediately
>>
>>18051243
>atomic bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki
Kys
>>
>>18051239
Capitalism doesn’t exist. It was a strawman Marx created to lump everything he complained about into a single category and is outdated. By his own definition, the modern US isn’t capitalist.
>>
>>18051750
What was his definition?
>>
>>18051057
Except he was intellectually dishonest about any criticisms of how his systems could ever be put into place, just making vague notions about how they would "wither away".
>>
>I will save the world from english industrialism and financial domination
>how
>I will make AN EVEN BIGGER BANK
jew
>>
>>18051239
The reduction in carbon emissions alone is worth it.
>>
>>18051747
He's a mentally retarded 14 year old communist, don't even bother
>>
>>18051747
>>18052036
There is no justification for it.
>the japs would have fought to the last screaming infant
If the US nuked Hamburg or Milan you'd have made the same argument about Germany or Italy.
>>
>>18052642
The nukes were originally intended for Germany and were only used on Japan because by the time the nukes were complete, Germany had already surrendered
>>
>>18051063
>100,000,000 gorillion
Retard chud ass clowns (rightfully) deny the 6 million but when faced with a much much higher one they mindlessly believe it because muh commies bad.
>>
>>18053066
moron
>>
>>18051750
I agree it isn't a very useful term for describing reality, but Marx didn't create the term. Ironically, the earlier instances of it being used were french royalists who were claiming financiers had too much power over the business of the state, due to a circumstance where the state was increasingly indebted to these financial "capitalists" during peace time. The term capitalist pre-dates "capitalism" as referring to these financiers, and capitalism just became the -ism form that criticized this arrangement as politically destabalizing for royal power. Prior to this, it was claimed that the state usually only ran up debts in war time. It was easier for the state to unload war debts because at the end of the war the business was basically done, whereas peace time debts usually were sustaining a peace time political order. So the sovereign didn't feel as at liberty to default on these debts, since it would mean political instability if parts of peace time state capacity suddenly weren't getting paid.

Of course, this sense of the word is very far from our modern manner of using it. But what is similar is that the royalists saw a relationship between the state and its creditors as compelling the state to act in certain ways. The modern term broadly shares this connotation, that "capitalism" is the thing forcing people to behave a certain way. The french left increasingly adapted this meaning to the word. I think there are fairly complex influences for why the term has come to have the sense it does today. Too much for a single post. But it is just a theological story about what is happening. It isn't a useful way of understanding the world. Most people tend to have been exposed to the word first, take for granted it must refer to something that exists and then try to figure out what that thing is. They rarely stop to think maybe the word isn't referring to anything real.
>>
>>18053063
I'm aware.
The justification used for nuking Japan is that they wouldn't have surrendered without them because the population was too fanatic. That they'd have fought to the last man and the nukes were a kindness.
But a basic counterfactual makes it clear that the same justification would have almost certainly been used in Europe for the Germans or Italians if the bombs were deployed there. When we actually know that both nations surrendered far before they fought to the last man.
>>
>>18051057
>>Assume the economic factor as foundational framework for the world
>>Proceed to call yourself anti-religious
Marx was retarded. He didn't even grasp basic philosophical and scientific ideas. After publishing his works, the masses(the mob) actually got the pretext to fuel and canalise their ressentiment, anger, hatred towards higher, aristocratic classes which is the reason why revolutions put the empire's condition into everlasting turmoil, caused massive atrocities, genocide, suffering, killing, hatred...
>>
>>18051233
No but its the most well documented horror in history and you should be jailed for even insinuating anything else sis
>>
>>18051057
Reddit man
>>
>>18051243
....but 8 billion alive because of it, along with all the technical and scientific progress in the world, but that goes without saying.

Commies cause famines. Capitalist create "fat pigs"........one sounds like there's less starvation involved in one than the other ;)



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.