[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: TIKHistory.jpg (127 KB, 1280x720)
127 KB
127 KB JPG
>gets laughed off the internet forever
lol
>>
>>18066199
i liked his video of Hegel, did something happen?
>>
>>18066199
I dont know why he's so stubborn.
>>
>>18066199
I'm out of the loop, what happened?
>>
>e celeb drama
>>
>>18066205
>video of Hegel
The only people who can make unbiased videos about Hegel are philosophy professors who look completely uninterested in what they're talking about and don't try to associate Hegel with any current political or ideological movements, but instead just treat the Hegelian System as if it were something purely factual, like discussing peptide synthesis.
Anybody else will either make Hegel sound like a mystic or a pseudoscientific charlatan, neither of which are adequate descriptors for any German Idealist philosopher.
>>
>>18066199
Stopped watching when he started using his channel to promote libertarianism. What happened?
>>
>>18066220
>>18066366
He got endlessly made fun of and refuted. Instead of accepting the challenges to prove he was right, he just "took a break," and now I guess just reads Ayn Rand all day or something.
>>
He's still raking in $5~6k/month via patreon even though he's producing nothing.
>>
>>18067418
Excuse me sir, but this is called 'going Galt'. Will you PLEASE respect my religious beliefs, jeez
>>
>>18067529
>going Galt
Danny Phantom was an objectivist?
>>
>>18067479
holy based
>>
>>18066199
He should've just continued his battlestorm series. It all went downhill when he started making his lolbertarianist economics/politics video and trying to apply them to WW2.
>>
>>18067852
Based and truth pilled, NEVER over extend your grift
>>
>>18067852
This.
Imagine the kinoness of Battlestorm Operation Tpyoon.
>>
>>18066199
Where did he get this bullshit from of calling everything he doesn't gnostic? From schizo christians?
>>
>>18067418
Who did.
>>
>>18068934
There's no one person who single handedly slew the dragon, it was a bunch of independent researchers who all disproved TIK. That being said a lot of them are just as biased and manipulative as TIK himself so it's not to say either are paragons but rather both are jokes who should be laughed at.
This is coming from someone who probably agrees with most things TIK has said too. He is delusional when it comes to the economy of Nazi Germany and the Soviet Union.
>>
>>18069810
I think it's very impressive that he united nazoids and leftoids in busting his bullshit.
>>
He's correct about National Socialism as practiced in Germany being Gnostic in doctrine, by means of using eugenics as the avenue to have man eventually usurp the creator. Additionally, the Gnostic, Luciferian doctrine permeates almost all world systems in history, with biblical Christianity actually being one of the world's only exceptions; and only broad, widespread exception, for it is unique in placing worship of God over worship of the intellect. Tik is also correct about the NSDAP deliberately targeting, attempting to compromise, and cracking down on Christianity, in large part due to this difference and the resistance it created.

It would be interesting if someone asked Tik regarding this same Gnostic strand materializing in contemporary Libertarianism, with its social darwinist replication of the lie of the serpent, and clear mystery school influences.
>>
>>18069943
>He's correct about National Socialism as practiced in Germany being Gnostic in doctrine
Completely retarded. NS is anti-gnostic and explicitly life-affirming, with little to no care for the specifics of the afterlife. Post a single NSDAP source that belittles the world as some fallen realm of the demiurge (you won't).
>NSDAP deliberately targeting, attempting to compromise, and cracking down on Christianity,
In part because christianity is gnostic-adjacent, but mostly because it is jewish.
>>
>>18069943
>He's correct about National Socialism as practiced in Germany being Gnostic in doctrine
Only if you believe in his retarded fan fiction version of gnostic beliefs. He fundamentally doesn't understand gnostic ideas so any connections he makes to them are flawed at best and completely made up at worst.
>>
>>18069810
Any examples.
>>
>>18066199
I actually liked some of his videos, but he was really a contrarian
>>
>>18069943
He stopped calling the Nazis gnostic and went back to claiming they were Wotanist. His gnostic idea was interesting but more or less baseless
>>
>>18069943
>Gnostic, Luciferian
Boogeyman for the average christcuck. The gnostics also believed in your Jesus, they also believed in Yahweh but thought he was evil the satan. Ancient egyptians also thought that Yawheh was an evil deity, that he was satan. Gnosticism evolved out of buddhist influences very likely from the persian empire and realizing the contradictions between the narratives of the old and new testaments and some hellenistic influences from orphism and platonism.
>>
File: $_57.jpg (289 KB, 1200x1600)
289 KB
289 KB JPG
>>18070006
>mostly because it is jewish.
That's th main reason. It's not proven that this book was also made by Hitler but he never denied it and it fits the opinions he holded in other writings like Mein Kampf. This book claims that Josef and Moses were something like proto-bolshevist who used something like proto-bolsevism to destroy egypt and steal the egyptian's wealth. It also claims that there was a carthage-jewish connection.
Hitler also thought it is ridiculous how children are taught in school about Adam and Eve in religious class but then are taught the scientific explaination, the theory of evolution in biology class.
>>
File: ewige jude 45 58.webm (3.29 MB, 720x546)
3.29 MB
3.29 MB WEBM
>>18070225
Gnosticism predates christianity and most likely judaism too. Or that is to say, the core tenets at least can be found in several Hellenistic mystery cults.
>>18070237
>It's not proven that this book was also made by Hitler
I don't think anybody claims that Hitler was somehow Dietrich Eckart. DE was a real dude as pictured in your picrel. Whether the Hitler character he presents is representative or not is debatable, but might be accurate for the period.
>This book claims that Josef and Moses were something like proto-bolshevist who used something like proto-bolsevism to destroy egypt and steal the egyptian's wealth.
The story is likely fabricated (the pharaoh isn't even named!?), but if real, this is almost certainly true.
>It also claims that there was a carthage-jewish connection.
There is. Jews essentially emerge from or are tightly tied to the Carthaginian/Phoenician/Punic civilization.

Hitler certainly saw the bible as a jewish creation and lamented christianity's rise in Mein Kampf.
>>
>>18070249
>I don't think anybody claims that Hitler was somehow Dietrich Eckart. DE was a real dude as pictured in your picrel. Whether the Hitler character he presents is representative or not is debatable, but might be accurate for the period.
Maybe you misunderstood me. I said I think it's true that Eckart wrote this book together with Hitler or with the help of him. Eckart was a member of the NSDAP and helped the party. He was also editor in chief of the Völkischen Beobachter. I'm just arguing against if someone claimed that Hitler nothing to do with the book.
>>
>>18070249
>The story is likely fabricated (the pharaoh isn't even named!?), but if real, this is almost certainly true
I think there is some truth to the idea of the Exodus being connected to the Hyksos.
There seems to have been a Hyksos ruler with a similar name to Jacob called Yaqub-Har or Yak-Baal. Jacob could be based of him but his story heavily changed over the years. Moses could be based on one of the last hyksos rulers who had to flee from them.
Or the Exodus story is a combination of several stories in Canaan. The egyptians conquered Canaan in the 15th century BC and ruled over it for some time. Maybe there were more than one cases of canaanites being brought to egypt as slaves and some of them then escaped back to their homeland?
Moses was then based on one of the slave revolt/escape leaders and the story then became combined with the hyksos story?
From what I've heard Jacob and Moses were mentioned a lot earlier than Abraham or Isaac in levantine myths.
>>
>>18070341
Mea culpa, I completely missed the "also" in your sentence.
>>18070360
I admit that it is possible, but I still think that pretty much the whole Exodus story is made up. There could certainly be a cultural memory thing in that the canaanites (incl. jews) and the Egyptians were beefing for a while.
Seems Holocaust-tier though.
>>
>>18066199
He got tired of always winning. When all your opponents can muster is a rehashing of the same cope papers written by propagandists and later debunked. It's no wonder he got burnt out, everyone that was sane saw, agreed and then promptly moved on, only hate watchers remained
>>
File: Eric_Voegelin.jpg (8 KB, 187x262)
8 KB
8 KB JPG
>>18068136
Eric Voegelin

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eric_Voegelin?wprov=sfla1
>>
>>18070006
>>18070013
>>18070129

Gnosticism doesn't necessitate belief in the afterlife; it is a loose array of multiple different sects, some of which adhere to the afterlife existing, but some of which denying such outright. National Socialism is fundamentally Gnostic in structure for it advocates for the purification of man through a worldly struggle whereby the more intellectually and spiritually gifted, or "Aryan", race, containing the highest concentration of the "divine spark" in man, is refined from the rest of humanity, and thereafter rendered in perpetual struggle to perfect himself and domineer the Earth and reality. Thus, the "Aryan" race usurps God. It's the lie of the serpent repeated, whereby if man pursues the intellect, he will be like God.

>>18070225

The Gnostic sects which appropriate Jesus as a Luciferian figure do not believe in "my" Jesus; in accordance to biblical Christianity, this is a heretical position. You are referencing Gnosticism's historical inspiration from pagan origin yet also trying to equate Gnosticism to contemporary Christianity by saying they involve worshipping the same figure simultaneously. This is wrong; in biblical Christianity, Jesus is God, and the Son within the holy trinity, not an adversary to God but God in the flesh.
>>
>>18066199
His face pisses me off. Not attacking his appearance, but just the way he fucking stares and makes that face
>>
>>18072126
>Thus, the "Aryan" race usurps God.
This is your fanfic, not theirs. Defining anything that seeks to improve the world or man within it as gnostic is utterly retarded.
>>
>>18066199
Like all libertarians he went from anti nazi to accepting them the moment his guy gor into power
>>
>>18072178
It isn't about improving the world, but about reaching a point of total dominion and providence over the world through pursuit and application of the intellect in ways outside of God's moral authority.
>>
>>18072208
Tik spent his entire Youtube career criticizing Nazism and referring to it as a doctrine of total political-economic delusion and mass murder. He never accepted Nazism.
>>
>>18072226
>more fanfic
>>
File: 1717207105544.jpg (167 KB, 640x599)
167 KB
167 KB JPG
>>18066199
I watched a video by this guy where he claims Marxists were Gnostics, because: "Both believed the world is corrupt and wanted to change it".

He is probably in rehab for ketamine addiction.
>>
>>18072261
Wittingly or not, Nazi ideology is structured exactly as such.
>>
Oh look, another discord tranny raid thread full of mtfs malding over a right winger under the guise of being based and redpilled "nazism." Fuck off.
>>
>>18072208
YWNBAW no matter how hard you dilate, hopefully you join the 41% of your kind because of evil drump orange man.
>>
>>18072268
Liberals (incl. lolberts) aren't even remotely right wing.
>>
>>18068136
It comes from James Lindsay. Basically, chuds got tired of the Cultural Marxism talking point so they had to find a more ancient conspiracy that encompasses everything they don't like. Enter Lindsay who gave lectures about how woke, post-modernism, marxism etc. all actually come from Gnosticism, which is portrayed as an ancient, scary irrational cult. Jordan Peterson also got into it before he got hospitalized again for a mold infestation.

It's just a new right-wing grift to make grifters' followers feel good about themselves.
>>
>>18072265
>>18072304
You just have to read a few pages of Marx and know some basic things about Communist practice to find this plausable.
>>
>>18072304
>OMG le heckin chud meme
>OMG evil jordan peterstein milquetoast man
>he told me to clean my room
When the fuck did this place become filled to the brim with leftist fucks like this post? This site's dead.
>>
>>18072304
Isn't Perterson just a Communist fan boy who hates Christianity and decided to make a big distraction movement to psyop the masses?
>>
Real niggas know that much of the anti-Gnostic discovery is really owed to Bill Cooper.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2iCLykzJ0d8&list=PL11E33A6AEEB2674F
>>
>>18072311
Neither Marxism nor National Socialism has any historic connection to Gnosticis. They are both mainly products of late modern philosophy.

Gnosticism was basically dead by the time of Constantine. It was claimed that some medieval heretical sects like the Cathars were inspired by Gnostic teachings. But it's more likely that the inquisition was using Ireneus's book on 2nd century heretics while interrogating Cathars. Ireneus wrote this big book making fun of Gnostic beliefs, and the inquisition probably just pointed to this, and asked the Cathars 'is this what you believe?' until they said yes.

Some of it's teachings may have lived on in Hermeticism. But the problem is that Gnosticism was heavily inspired by Platonism, and every educated man read Plato since he was alive. So you didn't need to be a member of a Gnostic sect to get the idea to mix Christianity and Plato and come up with ideas that sound a bit like what Gnostics believe.

Gnosticism was a part of Western Esotericism as a whole which is basically variations of Plato's metaphysical idea mixed with Christian and sometimes pagan (eg. Egyptian) traditions. But almost all Gnostic texts were lost until 1945, and people only knew about Gnosticism from Nicean criticisms. You could draw connections between Western Esoteric tradition and Marxism but by the same logic you would also have to do that to literally every other Western philosophical school because everyone was inspired by Plato and later thinkers commenting on Plato in some way.
>>
>>18072356
Was Rasputin Gnostic?
>>
>>18072356
>Neither Marxism nor National Socialism has any historic connection to Gnosticis.
>Gnosticism was a part of Western Esotericism

???
Self-contradictory
>>
>>18072304
I don't know who Lindsay is, and I haven't listened to Peterstein cry about anything since long before his benzos took him out the first time, but "cultural marxism" certainly has gnostic elements, knowingly or not. Everything jewish has at least some gnostic elements, for they are predisposed towards it. And as this anon >>18072356 points out, Plato is involved, and jewishness is heavily Platonic.
>>
>>18066199
When the fuck did he start talking about Gnosticism?
>>
>>18072226
By that logic every ruler in world history could be considered gnostic.
>>
>>18072375
Christianity is heavily platonic.
>>
>>18072126
So Gnostic in this context just means anything other than the most retarded and backwards from of Christianity.
Then how is the term in any way useful when discussing different ideologies, if they're all Gnostic?
>>
>>18072461
A surprising amount, perhaps, though not every. Leaders tend to seek power in spite of God's will sometimes, but not always; and most often not an absolute sort of power over all reality as the Nazis aimed for.
>>
>>18072486
You think the world is a binary between biblical Christianity and man attempting to ascend himself into godhood as the Nazis attempted?
>>
>>18072491
TIK sure thinks so.
>>
>>18072491
>man attempting to ascend himself into godhood as the Nazis attempted
Assuming you have any sort of consistent metric to arrive at this conclusion, you would most certainly reach the same conclusion if you applied it to practically any other ideology.
>>
>>18072486
They realized that they can't just call everything they like satanic. People would find it ridiculous. Instead they use the word gnostic for everything but he then calls gnosticism luciferian showing his true reason for using the gnostic boogeyman. It is a back door for him to call it satanic.
>>
>>18072503
I don't. It certainly applies to some, but not all.
>>
>>18066199
WHO THE FUCK IS THIS GUY
>>
>>18072521

A guy who makes Microsoft PowerPoint slideshow videos that people keep manufacturing controversies about, primarily about Nazism, to trick outsiders.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tMNsR16_sGI
>>
>>18072268
>people criticized my favorite grifter and I am mad, I know I'll call them all discord trannies
Take your meds or kill yourself
>>
>>18072464
Yeah, it's jewish, which as I said, is heavily Platonic.
>>
>>18072511
>It is a back door for him to call it satanic.
Exactly this.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.