Should the Northern States pay reparations for the War of Northern Aggression?
>>18072604Winners are not judged
>>18072604What do you think Reconstruction was? The North rebuilt everything thay was destroyed in the South. Done and paid for already.
>>18072615>What do you think Reconstruction was?A program to further destroy the South by appropriating their wealth and political power and giving it to carpetbaggers and freed slaves.
>>18072618What’s wrong with giving it to freed slaves? They earned it.
>>18072651What about carpetbaggers?
>>18072665What about them? The republicans rightly believed that blacks should be allowed to vote after all the crap the south put them through. So of course they came down to support that. Unless you mean just the business element of it. What’s wrong with buying in a buyer’s market?
>>18072604>South fires first>"""""northern aggression"""""Why are dixiecucks like this?
>>18072604It was already northern money which rebuilt the south.>>18072762victim mentality
>>18072618Aadly that wasn't enough clearly
>>18072762They fired at a foreign military base located deep in their territory that North refused to evacuate.Weird how union fags never mention this part
they did and still do
>>18075147>a foreign military baseLiterally how is it foreign>deep in their territory>deep>their territoryIt was a Federal fort you inbred retard. Maybe if they could stop miscegnating with their slaves for two fucking minutes they would have realized they needed to re-acquire those federal forts before chimping out and firing at them Weird how dixietards can only ever repeat the same meme argument every time
>>18075304Confederacy and Union were different countries anon
>>18075407>Union>countryJust how fucking braindead are you, nigger?
>>18075413So what was it
>>18075416The US is a country. The Confederacy was an rebellion. It was never a country. Literally no other country recognized it as such.
>>18072604They do with taxes for white trash and brown welfare for the South
>>18072618>Appropriating their wealthYou mean building an economy not based on slave labor?
>>18075418So? US wasn't recognized initually either after they declared indpendence
>>18075428The Dutch-controlled island of Sint Eustatius recognized US sovereignty in November of '76 you retarded halfwit>uh, uh, that doesn't count!!!The British recognized it for what it was and were rightfully pissed at the Dutch as a whole
>>18075445Wow a Sint Eustatius?? This changes everything /sWho even cares if it's recognized or not. Somaliland isn't recognized and it is effectively a separate state.
>>18075457>hurrr that doesn't count durrrrThe British recognized it you faggot >whataboutismpottery*If* the Fagfederacy is taken as its own country, that only makes Sumter even more of a "the South shot first" scenario btw. Sumter was a Federal, US fort. Firing on it was an open aggression and act of war then. If the Fagfederacy was its own country then firing on Sumter and marching into the border states was no different than what Britain did in 1812 and the US was 100% in the right in retaliating. >inb4 more dixietard cope
>>18072604They did and do lol.
>>18075477It would be open aggression if they fired into Northern states' territory which they did not. Fort Sumter was on their land. They can do whatever they want on their land.It's like if US set up a base in Siberia then Russians found out about it and decided to nuke it. This clearly wouldn't be a reason to invoke article 5 as no NATO member was attacked. This is no different
>>18075499It would be like Cuba firing on Gitmo.
>>18075499>their territorySumter was a man-made island. It was not South Carolina's territory. The US Federal government owned it. >hurrrr Russia is just like this part of the US that's on the same continent and was a part of the same country until a handful of miscegnating nigger lovers decided to chimpout over losing their nigger mistresses durrrrYou're actually retarded, as are all dixiefags
>>18072604It's simple>sign up for voluntary union on the basis of states having rights>withdraw from voluntary union when yanktards overstep their authority>the whole Jewish enterprise is unveiled and they go mask off revealing that once they trick you into it, you'll be slaughtered by their bluebelly golems for trying to get outYanktards are desperate to obfuscate these facts
>>18075515It may have been man made but it was still part of South Carolina. Surely it wasn't the exclave of D.C. federal district Sorry but Confederacy decided to peacefully secede and become independent. The right thing to do as civilized men is to respect their wish. Otherwise we are no better than the Serbs.
>>18075543>but it was still part of South Carolina.It literally wasn't. They sold it to the US federal government when the chunk of rocks that it was was turned into Fort Sumter. >peacefully seceding is when you fire on a federal fort because the men inside are doing absolutely nothing except eating moldy hardtack and waiting until the day they can go home Anderson was himself a Kentucky slaveowner. Your own kind didn't want anything to do with secession retard
>>18075552So which state was it part of?
>>18075515Oh, like the US Government owns Bagram Airbase?
>>18075552Also they gave them ample time to evacuate it (very gentlemanly thing to do imo) but North still refused. Well... FAFO then.
>>18075557It was a Federal fort you retarded faggot>>18075563>whataboutism>>18075564Why should they have evacuated a Federal fort? They did nothing to antagonize the South Carolinians. The South also fired on the Star of the West when it tried to reach Sumter. No matter what way you try to cope, the South fired first in a non-threatening situation.
>>18075499>It's like if US set up a base in SiberiaNo it's more like Poland or Germany attacking Königsberg, which is a russian exclave.>>18075557Do you think that Virginia owns the Pentagon?
>>18075538Anti-Semitic confederate sympathizers are funny because the Confederacy was bankrolled by wealthy Charleston Jews with stake in the slave trade
>>18075906Also most prominent abolitionists were notably anti-Semitic and condemned slavery as an extension of Jewish vice
>>18072604Who pays the most and receives the most in federal taxes?
>>18075147The forts were on federal territory, and therefore they were objectively still legally part of the US.
