[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


Janitor application acceptance emails are being sent out. Please remember to check your spam box!


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: Civilizacao.jpg (230 KB, 1080x1042)
230 KB
230 KB JPG
Trvke: racism is about skin color.
>noooo it's about fancy buildings and inventions
If that were the case Mesoamericans would be considered superior to Scandinavians.
>>
>>18112945
>implying that the atlantian whites weren't responsible for the megalythic American constructions
Ngmi
>>
File: My Sides IRL.jpg (818 KB, 1368x1568)
818 KB
818 KB JPG
>>18112945
>índios
>Mesopotamia
Go back.
>>
Vikings weren't White so their technical level does not concern me. Only Christians are White.
>>
>>18112945
But pyramids were made by aliens from space
>>
Why are brazilians obsessed with nordicists
>>
>>18112959
>glorified earthen mounds made with normal-sized bricks are "megalithic" because...there's this one wall in Peru and they're technically the same type of building as the pyramids in egypt o algo
>>
>>18112945
No it's about pattern recognition and behavior. Non-whites tend to be dysfunctional, where there are more non-whites there is stealing, there is rape, there is scamming, there is shitting in the street, there is murder. That's all that's going on here.
>>
File: 1549462409608.png (3.36 MB, 1504x2312)
3.36 MB
3.36 MB PNG
>>18112983
Inferiority complex. Non-whites seethe in envy of us, now they dig into our past in a desperate attempt to disprove our obvious superiority.
>>
>>18112961
For some reason, a non-insignificant number of people insist on referring to mesoamerican temple-pyramids as "ziggurats". I would imagine whichever brazilian made the OP pic is one such person and just grabbed the first image he found when googling the word ziggurat.
>>
>>18112945
>Mesoamericans
That's literally Ur in Sumer you dumbass. Learn about your own injun mestizo culture paco
>>
File: 1761328676572.jpg (61 KB, 221x246)
61 KB
61 KB JPG
>>18112994
I'm not the retarded OP's, jackass. American pyramids are compared to Ziggurats because their civilization is called MESOamerica and the Egyptian Pyramids were just giant tombs/cemetery, unlike the Zigarats and Teocalli which were temples.
>>
File: 6 - SoyBooru.png (144 KB, 1252x799)
144 KB
144 KB PNG
>>18112986
>there has never been stealing, rape, scamming, shitting in the street or murder in white societes
>>
>>18112945
racism is about skull-shapes, stature, genetics, and heritable personality traits. intra-racial qualities also vary somewhat and correlate with social status
>>
>>18112945
The vikings lived in walkable cities
>>
>>18113021
>>there has never been stealing, rape, scamming, shitting in the street or murder in white societes
Did I saw that? comparing the prevalence of these activities between whites and non-whites is like comparing day to night. If you take all non-whites out of Sweden for instance you'll reduce the overall crime in the country probably by 95 percent.
>>
>>18113044
This. In Ur you'd probably get mugged, pickpocketed and scammed around every street corner, it was a mud favela.
>>
File: 5tgsdy7zqype1.jpg (371 KB, 1500x998)
371 KB
371 KB JPG
>>18113089
They already had suburbs back then
>>
>>18112945
ESL thread?
>>
>>18112945
>>
>>18112945
This is kind of stuff goes totally unnoticed with people just assuming the modern Notre Dame we have was "built" in the 1100s and the same with the Hagia Sophia for example, when they're literally a result of centuries of reconstruction + new addition
>>
>>18113113
No wonder the elites stopped using them as slaves and pivoted to Indians.
>>
File: 1760881236585082.jpg (63 KB, 628x628)
63 KB
63 KB JPG
>>18113113
That's called the WARRIOR gene and it's something that gets selected based on the environment. Yes, Black people are warriors, cracker. They endured centuries of abuse at your hand and selected for this as a survival strategy.
>>
Brazilian thread
>>
>>18113177
>we wuz wariazz and sheit!
No, you just have zero impulse control
>>
>>18112988
why you post the fucking statue about barbarian wear roman armor and that statue is made by roman you dumb barbarian?
>>
>>18112961
>it's not real because my Spanish great grandrapist said so
Yeah ok Pancho.
>>
>>18113244
>why you post the fucking statue about barbarian wear
seeennnnhhhhooooorrrrrrr
>>
>>18112945
No one speaks this jigaboo mumbo jumbo boot-lipped fagspeak in your image, ESL.
>>
File: 144024.png (62 KB, 541x646)
62 KB
62 KB PNG
>>18112988
>What they were like genetically
Oh no no no
Also, Nords still lose on the soap thing:
>Europe, soap in the 9th century was produced from animal fats and had an unpleasant smell. This changed when olive oil began to be used in soap formulas instead, after which much of Europe's soap production moved to the Mediterranean olive-growing regions.[47] Hard toilet soap was introduced to Europe by Arabs and gradually spread as a luxury item. It was often perfumed.
>>
>>18113177
Yeah that's why we don't want you in our society.
>>
>>18113106
Yes it was the Norse who reintroduced the town system to Britain after the Saxons let romans towns disintegrate. The Norse town system was also more modern compared to the roman towns.
>>
File: DIjbvHWXgAA1eze.jpg (147 KB, 880x440)
147 KB
147 KB JPG
>>18113422
Jorvik Norse York in England.
>>
>>18113089
>>18113431
>small village of mudshithouses proves we wuz kangz
>>
>>18113377
>uses fucking Austrian Gauls probably from a sample close to actual Italy.
Jesus christ you are a dishonest piss stain.

The Germanics and Gauls were using much more modern soap compared to the filthy romans that all that matters mestizo.
>>
>>18113450
>>small village of mudshithouses proves we wuz kangz
No it shows the Norse introduced the town system to Britain numbskull.
>mudshit
Use your 2 brain cells and look at the illustration again. Do you see any mud walls there? holy fuck you are stupid.
>>
File: Hallstatt_LaTene.png (250 KB, 600x438)
250 KB
250 KB PNG
>>18113452
>idiot doesn't know where Hallstatt-La Tene culture started
Cope haha. The Bretons who were actually Nordic-like were very primitive in comparison.
>>
Another Brazilian thread ?
>>
>>18113492
Theres no coping dipshit you used a sample from closed to Italy that's not going to tell us much about Gauls from western or northern France you smooth brain.
Makes sense as well like I've said before Italians are related to the celts.
>>
File: 20240617_225423.png (76 KB, 520x851)
76 KB
76 KB PNG
How the Gaulish people looked like
>>
>>18113527
and for those who are illiterate, this means that they were similar to Western Europeans like the French, Belgians and even Welsh. I made a point of using a sample from further south to see that even the southernmost Celts were still closer to the French and not the Spanish. Some here use samples selected there, but these samples are close to Belgians and French from the center and north, use averages.
>>
File: 39229.jpg (637 KB, 861x1918)
637 KB
637 KB JPG
>>18113523
>>18113527
Hallstatt-La Tene culture started in Austria/South Germany. Anyone else just adopted the culture. There's samples from Germany and they are Iberian/North Italian-like as well.
>>
>>18113527
Ah yes the swarthy brown Belgian people lmao fucking retard.
This is proof that Gauls were far more Nordic than modern day French people because half of Belgium is literally Germanic.
>>
File: a question for op.png (546 KB, 755x561)
546 KB
546 KB PNG
>>18112961
This. Plus
>Norse
>battle helmet with horns
>>
la tene aryos samples plot with french, germans and belgians.

Distance to: Czech_IA_LaTene
0.01578866 BelgianB
0.01653702 French_Nord
0.01777136 French_Pas-de-Calais
0.01808242 German
0.01819178 French_Brittany

Distance to: ChannelIslands_LIA_LaTene
0.05004101 German_Hamburg
0.05017179 German
0.05049237 Welsh
0.05056211 German_Erlangen
0.05092293 Norwegian

Distance to: Slovakia_LIA_LaTene
0.01676597 French_Occitanie
0.01850509 French_Nord
0.01855879 BelgianC
0.01905332 French_Auvergne
0.01990868 French_Alsace

Distance to: Hungary_IA_LaTene
0.01831462 French_Auvergne
0.02131342 French_Occitanie
0.02152328 Swiss_French
0.02470235 Italian_Northeast
0.02503906 French_Provence

Even the most southern samples plot with southern France...
>>
>>18113560
This, the only reasonable post here
Samehueflag btfo again
>>18113523
I made some models in qpAdm and got different results, mainly using FST metrics, apparently the English ones are also relatively close to them too
>>
>>18113541
>Hallstatt-La Tene culture started in a warmer part of europe
Gee big surprise there. The La Tene culture was also not monolithic you drooling retard, it was extremely diverse with each local tribe having their own distinct architecture and customs. I mean compare the Oppidum's Entremont, Heuneburg, Bibracte, Manching and Corent all completely different from each other owing to their distinct cultures.
>>
File: 1731977559553.png (55 KB, 474x961)
55 KB
55 KB PNG
germany_lech_MBA is not even a celt

>While Hallstatt samples from present-day Czech Republic plot on top of the genetic diversity of present-day French, Belgians and Germans, close to Iron Age individuals from present-day France

I.e. closer to belgians than to iberians or italians
>>
>>18113560
Is this supposed to be some kind of win by the mestizo? I'm confused. Your chart is showing allot of Northern European there lmao
>>
that they were destroyed by 160 white people negates all their accomplishments
>>
File: 1761663413711.png (560 KB, 654x436)
560 KB
560 KB PNG
>>18113560
>>
>>18113577
>>18113560
the Brazilian was massacred again. we are sure he was paid for this
Celts= belgians and French.
>>
File: 55714.png (86 KB, 678x873)
86 KB
86 KB PNG
>>18113560
>>18113577
>>18113590
German sisters...
>>
>>18113590
I refuted him more than 5 times this week alone, my ego can soar and see how he says le Nordic, le Nordic in every post, when at no point in my posts was this even mentioned, it's really a personal problem he has with Nordics, I'm just educating the academics with G25 certificate that the Celts were not Spanish or something like that
>>
>>18113599
They were Spaniards
>>
File: 1731234601004.png (263 KB, 1140x819)
263 KB
263 KB PNG
>>18113605
No, they weren't>>18113577
>Compared with contemporaneous data, the Hallstatt individuals cluster homogeneously intermediate between Iron Age samples from present-day France and the Czech Republic41,42, together with Bronze Age samples from the Bavarian Lech valley38 within the present-day French variation (Supplementary Figs. 4.2 and 4.3).

>This strong genetic affinity between Hallstatt individuals from southwestern Germany and present-day French can also be observed in formal F4 and FST statistics, as described in Supplementary Note 5.

>While Hallstatt samples from present-day Czech Republic plot on top of the genetic diversity of present-day French, Belgians and Germans, close to Iron Age individuals from present-day France (Supp. Fig. 5.8b
>In general, the European PCA implies high genetic similarity between the Hallstatt genomes from southwestern Germany and i) present-day genomes from France (Supp. Fig. 4.1b)
>>
>>18113599
His problem is different, he is so angry with Nordics out of envy and secondly due to a feeling of frustration or abandonment for not receiving the expected help in times of need, he desperately asks the magical blacks for a white wife, but this did not happen, all goats and birds are no longer being useful, that's why his internal anger against Northern Europeans. It's all so tiring...
>>
>>18113629
You would think the magical blacks would do something about brazil being a shithole oou algo assim.
>>
>>18113629
Really, I can't find any alternative other than internal envy, and I'm not even Nordic, I'm Italian. Looking at some posts on this thing, I came across posts not only of sexual content from a guy clearly addicted to pornography, but often featuring fantasies of white women and dark men. I suspect there's some kind of internal feud against Northern Europeans or something.

Anyway, I've already educated him for the sixth time this week, so that's the end of the matter.
>>
>>18112988
>"Celts were kangs n shieet"

I think the celt hate its pretty stupid, they did pretty well for an small, relatively isolated group, but this is pure copium, black levels of copium, actually-
>>
File: 162710.png (34 KB, 653x340)
34 KB
34 KB PNG
Nordics had nothing to do with any of these civilizations whatsoever except the Bretons (who were the most primitive of the Celtic groups).
>>
File: 1706839665186.jpg (90 KB, 532x700)
90 KB
90 KB JPG
>Celts don't exist, it means nothing genetically, it's just a language group! LOL you think "Celt" means anything? What a retard!

Let's be honest: this is just the latest Nordicist cope.

200-100 years ago Nordicists claimed Celtic blood was subhuman Alpine trash that was for the masses of slaves. Now that it turns out from genetic studies that the British are mostly genetically Celtic and similar to the Irish, that the Gauls were far more advanced than Roman historians claimed, and that all the Gaulish areas of Central Europe were the most advanced and not the Nordic ones Celts suddenly don't exist and they were just an extension of Nords and the ancient Gauls were just like Swedes n sheeit
>>
File: agGjY16_700b.jpg (119 KB, 639x862)
119 KB
119 KB JPG
>>18113651
He might be a mulatto/mestizo mixed Brazilian an actual favela monkey lmao
>>
>>18113736
Oh you are back kill yourself that's all I'm saying.
>>
>>18113655
>but this is pure copium, black levels of copium, actually
You obviously no fuck all about iron age Europe.
>Celts were kangs n shieet"
Yeah they had king's dumbass. Also attempt to disprove everything in that infographic and I'll wipe the floor with you.
>>
>>18113736
>extension of Nords
Because they were dumbass at least to a certain extent their cultures overlapped and so did their geography.
Tacitus himself was unsure how to place Belgae culturally so were other thinkers of the time, some calling Belgae tribes Germanic and others Celtic.
>>
File: 1746887166868.jpg (385 KB, 1284x840)
385 KB
385 KB JPG
>>18113736
>genetic studies that the British are mostly genetically Celtic
Nope.

>David Reich's laboratory found that 90% of Britain's Neolithic gene pool was overturned by a population from North Continental Europe characterised by the Bell Beaker culture around 1200 BC who carried a large amount of Yamnaya ancestry from the Pontic-Caspian Steppe, including the R1b Haplogroup. This population lacked genetic affinity to other Bell Beaker populations, such as the Iberian Bell Beakers, but appeared to be an offshoot of the Corded Ware single grave people. It is currently unknown whether these Beaker peoples went on to develop Celtic languages in the British Isles, or whether later Celtic migrations introduced Celtic languages to Britain

>The close genetic affinity of these Beaker people to Continental North Europeans means that British and Irish populations cluster genetically very closely with other Northwest European populations, regardless of how much Anglo-Saxon and Viking ancestry was introduced during the 1st century
>>
File: image.png (2.69 MB, 1022x1552)
2.69 MB
2.69 MB PNG
>>18112988
How does it make you feel that Native Americans built the same sort of towns and cities but at a larger scale

and I don't even mean the Aztec and shit, I mean in fucking Illinois
>>
>>18114288
Nothing because they didn't have the wheel and their architecture was primitive.
>>
File: 640px-ANE_dispertion.jpg (49 KB, 640x274)
49 KB
49 KB JPG
>>18114288
Natives share the same ancestry with Nordics, literally you're just proving the point that our people are successful wherever they born.
>>
>>18114288
Mesolarp is also "anti-nord" or something like that? Understand
>>
Crazy that this board has existed for 10 years now and we're still doing the whole mudhut architecture war gimmick with the exact same talking points every fucking time
>>
>>18114335
It isn't.
We, the people who study and make threads about mesoamerica don't care about the ethnic/race fights of the board.
If this guy wants to mess up with nordics that's his deal, don't try to include all of /his/ mesoamerican community as if those were our opinions.
>>
File: 1761692422.jpg (1.09 MB, 3387x1393)
1.09 MB
1.09 MB JPG
>>18114300
Fake and Gay. Mesoamericans and Andean peoples independently invented:

>wheels
>agriculture
>pottery and ceramics
>domestication of animals such as turkeys, ducks, dogs, and bees (cattle, pigs, and horses were brought by the Spanish, which explains why they didn't use their wheel as much and why thousands died in Cocoliztli, since these pandemics are transmitted from viruses/parasites to rats, which the Spanish also brought, which then pass to cattle, which pass to insects, which pass to humans, and Mesoamericans had no immunity because they didn't have these animals)
>road and commercial networks
>monumental architecture (They used slaked lime. They built impressive pyramids of cut stone. A considerable feat for a people essentially from the Stone Age)
>urban life/cities equivalent to those of classical antiquity in the Old World, both in population size and physical extent
>work with copper, bronze, gold, and alloy production
>organized armies
>highly literate priesthood
>writing and poetry
>philosophy
>semi-complex mathematics and highly complex astronomy
>censuses and topographic surveys
>aqueducts, dikes, and other hydraulic systems
>hydraulic cement
>sewer systems and toilets
>legal systems (written laws, courts of appeal) and advanced forms of government, including senatorial republics, bureaucratic institutions, etc.
>zoos, aquariums, nature reserves (Probably the most inventive when it came to obtaining plants, animals, and food. They were literally the Chinese of the Americas)
>alcoholic beverages
>fresco technique
>empirically based medical treatments
>complex odontology
>a lot of other random mundane things, like soap, for example
>>
>>18114327
This they are quasi-Caucasoid
>>
File: 1512359856112.jpg (72 KB, 650x570)
72 KB
72 KB JPG
>>18114370
They invented first:
>domestication of corn (one of the most impressive feats of selective breeding in history), the nixtamalization method, and many other plants
>chocolate
>the best sanitation and hygiene practices in the world at the time
>true and academic Bontatincal gardens
>universal public education (probably, some sources say school wasn't mandatory for the Aztecs, but most do)
>chinampas (artificial islands, Tenochtitlán, the Aztec capital, went from a swamp to an American city with more density/population than some large contemporary European cities)
>the world's first true suspension bridge (potentially)
>the world's largest human monument, which is also the world's largest pyramid
>some specific metallurgical techniques/alloys
>taxonomy
>state-run economies
>>
>>18114370
>Fake and Gay.
"argument" from incredulity. The artist who drew that is an archaeologist his reconstructions are displayed in museums halfwit.
>>wheels
No they didn't that painting is post Spanish contact. Toys barely count.
As for everything else you mentioned Europeans and Caucasians also invented all of that
>>
>>18114361
it's been going on for even longer if you count /int/
>>
>>18114375
>posts an illustration ironically after claiming mine was fake because "reasons"
That illustration is fake and gay because nah ah. You are a toddler
>>
File: 1739371019982143.jpg (193 KB, 1324x790)
193 KB
193 KB JPG
>>18114327
The difference is that common ancestor of the Nordics and Amerindians looked more like the Amerindians, the Amerindians have more of their genes and they were the ones who gave rise to blond hair.

>According to Lazaridis between 14% and 38% of Native American ancestry may originate from gene flow from the Malta-Buret people (ANE). This difference is caused by the penetration of posterior Siberian migrations Into the Americas, with the lowest percentages of ANE ancestry found in Eskimos and Alaskan Natives, as these groups are the result of migrations into the Americas roughly 5,000 years ago. Other estimates for ANE ancestry among first wave Native Americans show higher percentages, such as those belonging to the Andean region in South America

>It is also reported in modern-day Europeans (7%-25% ANE admixture directly from Yammaya), but not of Europeans predating the Bronze Age

>Blond hair is associated with a single nucleotide polymorphism, the mutated allele rs12821256 of the KITLG gene. The earliest known individual with this allele is a female south-central Siberian ANE individual from the Afontova Gora 3 site, which is dated to c.17,000 before present (the earlier ANE Mal'ta boy lacks the sequence coverage to make this determination). The allele then appears later in ANE-derived Eastern Hunter-Gatherer (EHG) populations at Samara, Motala and Ukraine, circa 10,000 BP, and then in populations with Steppe ancestry. Mathieson, et al. (2018) thus argued that this allele originated in the Ancient North Eurasian population, before spreading to western Eurasia

>Geneticist David Reich said that the KITLG gene for blond hair probably entered continental Europe in a population migration wave from the Eurasian steppe, by a population carrying substantial Ancient North Eurasian ancestry
>>
File: tgsoOCI.png (3.19 MB, 3200x1600)
3.19 MB
3.19 MB PNG
>>18114404
>Hanel and Carlberg (2020) likewise report that populations derived Ancient North Eurasian ancestry, specifically the Eastern Hunter-Gatherers and the Yamnayas, were responsible for transmitting this gene to Europeans. The gene was also found among the Tarim mummies
>>
>>18114387
>>18114398
>A wicker man was purportedly a large wicker statue in which the druids (priests of Celtic paganism) sacrificed humans and animals by burning. The primary evidence for this practice is a sentence by Roman general Julius Caesar in his Commentary on the Gallic War (1st century BC), which modern scholarship has linked to an earlier Greek writer, Posidonius

>While other Roman writers of the time described human and animal sacrifice among the Celts, only the Roman general Julius Caesar and the Greek geographer Strabo mention the wicker man as one of many ways the druids of Gaul performed sacrifices. In the mid-1st century BC, Caesar wrote in his Commentary on the Gallic War that a large wickerwork figure with limbs was filled with living men and set on fire. He says criminals were the preferred victims, but innocent people might also be burned if there were no criminals. Writing slightly later, Strabo says in his Geographica that men and animals were burned in a large figure of wood and straw, although he does not make clear whether the victims were burned alive. He adds that the ashes were believed to help the crops grow

>Also in the 1st century BC, Greek historian Diodorus Siculus wrote in Bibliotheca historica that the Celts sacrificed human and animal captives by burning them on huge pyres along with the first fruits. It has been suggested that both Diodorus and Strabo got their information from the earlier Greek historian Posidonius, whose work has not survived

>In the 1st century AD, Roman writer Lucan mentioned human sacrifices to the Gaulish gods Esus, Teutates and Taranis. In a commentary on Lucan—the Commenta Bernensia dating from the 4th century and later—an unnamed author added that sacrifices to Taranis were burned in a wooden container

Truly a superior culture to those violent savage injuns.
>>
>>18114436
>He says criminals were the preferred victims
This is the important part mestizo, injuns like the aztecs would literally pull the hearts out of innocent children while they were fully conscious. When Europeans practiced human sacrifice they killed criminals not the innocent.
Don't even get me started on the evil shit the Comanches used to do.
>>
>>18114436
Most civizations have done human sacrifice.
The romans did human sacrifice for their own satisfaction or example.
>>
>>18114436
The wicker man was badass though spic
>>
>>18114458
The thing is you're ignoring why they did it.
The aztec human sacrifice was a way to help Huitzilopchtli in his war with his sister.
Also, the aztec gods also sacrifice their blood themselves in order to create the humans.
>>
>>18114471
Human Sacrifice in Aztec and Mesoamerican religion was a broad group of practices with no singular goal of that sort, it was part of many different rituals dedicated to many different deities with many different intents. The specific example of child sacrifices that guy brought up were dedicated to Tlaloc, not to Huitzilopochtli, with the intention of making sure rain falls.
>>
>>18114471
It's just typical non-white low empathy behavior. Like I've stated before when Europeans did cruel things it was out of a sense of extreme justice. There are no accounts of prehistoric Europeans sacrificing children but this was a very common practice among non-white cultures.
Even when we burnt witches most of the time we strangled them first to ease their suffering
>>
>>18114488
>with the intention of making sure rain falls.
Savage cruel animals, the Spanish did the right thing.
>>
>>18114503
Allowing the ruling classes of nobles and priests who directly practiced such customs to simply convert to christianity and retain their noble status in the new colonial order while shipping off their innocent peasants to be worked and raped to death in mines and estates? Yeah, real divine retribution right there, i'm sure they cared about the innocent children, as much as you.
>>
>>18114488
Obviously there were more gods than just Huitzilopchtli, like the one you mentioned, tlaloc, i just mention Huitzilopchtli as an example, since he is one of the main gods of the Aztec pantheon.
>>
>>18114415
Jōmon and Nahuatl have some west Eurasian dna
>>
File: Huitzilopochtli_V.png (182 KB, 341x500)
182 KB
182 KB PNG
>>18114458
>literally pull the hearts out of innocent children while they were fully conscious
Why don't you stop lying? The deity to whom the Aztecs sacrificed the most was Huitzilopochtli, the patron god of the Mexica who guided them to Tenochtitlan. He was a god of war and his sacrifices had to be obtained through wars. When the Aztecs weren't waging enough war, they would literally LARPing that they were doing so (flower war) to nourish Huitzilopochtli move of sun in his battle against his sister and brothers to prevent the end of the world. Children were sacrificed to Tlaloc, but blood was not the main focus, but rather their tears since Tlaloc was a god of water/rain, they were tortured to cry as much as possible and then thrown to die slowly inside a cenote (underground lake). Anyway, why do you care about the sacrifice of people you consider inferior and on the same level as animals for slaughter, hypocrite?
>>18114496
Your guys also killed children.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Witchcraft_accusations_against_children

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infanticide#Middle_Ages
>>
File: 1760529968292.jpg (443 KB, 1243x791)
443 KB
443 KB JPG
>>18114548
Fun Fact: The Spanish killed more children in one day than the Aztecs did in centuries. According to the amount of sacrificed children in the Main Temple of Tenochtitlan, the Aztecs sacrificed about 70 children in 200 years. Spaniards killed 8000 nobles and their children on the same spot in a couple of hours.

>While Hernán Cortés was in Tenochtitlan, he heard about other Spaniards arriving on the coast – Pánfilo de Narváez had come from Cuba with orders to arrest him – and Cortés was forced to leave the city to fight them. During his absence, Moctezuma asked deputy governor Pedro de Alvarado for permission to celebrate Toxcatl (an Aztec festivity in honor of Tezcatlipoca, one of their main gods). But after the festivities had started, Alvarado interrupted the celebration, killing almost everyone present at the festival, men, women, and children alike

>The Spanish version of the incident claims the conquistadors intervened to prevent a ritual of human sacrifice in the Templo Mayor; the Aztec version says the Spaniards were enticed into action by the gold the Aztecs were wearing, prompting an Aztec rebellion against the orders of Moctezuma. While differing so on Alvarado's specific motive, both accounts are in basic agreement that the celebrants were unarmed and that the massacre was without warning and unprovoked
>>
>>18114548
>During the festivals of Atlacahualco, Tozoztontli, and Hueytozoztli, children were sacrificed by cutting their hearts out. They were selected by a favorable day sign and brought to seven different mountaintops around the city. Their crying was thought to portend rain
I'm not lying you are paco.
>https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Witchcraft_accusations_against_children
Again about justice not torturing children to bring the rains like an animalistic demon.
>>
>>18114560
That was literally the Tlaxcalan injun savages you liar. Cortez ordered them not to kill women and children but they did anyway because injuns are violent and have low empathy nice try juan.
>>
File: Iberijeet.jpg (11 KB, 311x162)
11 KB
11 KB JPG
>>18114575
The one who started the massacre at the templo mayor was literally a SPANIARD CONQUISTADOR, PEDRO DE ALVARADO, you didnt even read what he published Paco, but anyways, iberijeets are always like this.
>>
>>18114575
As the quote that guy posted clearly states, not even the Spanish sources ever dispute the fact that the conquistadors were the ones who ordered and put into practice the Toxcatl massacre. Also, Cortez wasn't even in the city when it happened, he couldn't exactly order anyone to do anything at all.
You're probably getting it confused with the Cholula massacre, the one in which the Tlaxcaltecs were an important factor in its proceedings, and even in that case the Spaniards were a more than willing agent. Also, some of Cortez' soldiers who would later defect to other factions did accuse him of consciously letting his native allies continue to practice human sacrifice and cannibalism.
>>
File: 1760530184127.png (422 KB, 1268x1644)
422 KB
422 KB PNG
>>18114568
>During the festivals of Atlacahualco, Tozoztontli, and Hueytozoztli, children were sacrificed by cutting their hearts out. They were selected by a favorable day sign and brought to seven different mountaintops around the city. Their crying was thought to portend rain

Who were sacrificed to Tlaloc, a non-Mexica deity unlike Huitzilopochtli, the greatest god of the Aztecs. You should argue that they both shared the Templo Mayor instead this. Those who did this shit the most in Mexico were not even the Mexica/Aztecs, but the peoples who fought/were subordinates to them and allied themselves with the Spanish. It was these people who introduced the Cult of Tlaloc to them.

The 20,000-70,000 estimate isn't even just for them, or even the Aztec Empire, it's for all of Mesoamerica sans the Maya area ("Central Mexico" as defined by Simpson/Borah/Cook, though i'd argue that term should exclude Veracruz, Oaxaca, Gurrero, and West Mexico), AND it's also not even really an estimate because it's just from harner proportionally scaling up Borah/Cook's 15,000 sacrifices a year estimate with revised population figures even though there's no reason to think sacrifice #'s scale proportionally with total population figures.

TL;DR The people with whom the Spanish allied themselves (who are called/confused with Aztecs because they lived in the Aztec Empire and was the most powerful in the entire region) sacrificed more people than the Aztecs, who probably sacrificed between like 500 to 7000 people a year. Remembering that Tenochtitlan was founded in 1325.
>>
>>18114568
>torturing and burning children because of non-beliefs in the moral code of a bronze age midianite god is justice
You mad.
>>
>>18114366
>we
You mean you, mesolarp? Yes, u r also provocative, that’s why your shitty threads sucks
>>
>>18114488
Happened almost every day, yes.
>>
Someone tell me.. is the mesolarp the zucoid in disguise?
>>
>>18114594
>>18114601
You have to remember that alot of conquistadors were non-white brown moors and savage guanches.
Cortez was a man of honour not the monster the left try to paint him as.
>>
>>18114300
How is it any more primitive then the shit in >>18112988, both have large scale earthenworks but and similar wooden structures

>>18114335
I'm not anti-nord, I think Germanic, Celtic, and Norse metalwork art is gorgeous and really impressive stuff, and I think their earthenworks are really neat and they, like the Mississippians, show how you can do stuff just with earth and wood that's pretty cool.

But if somebody is going to shit on other areas of history just to make their own pet topic seem more impressive, I think it's fair to call out the hypocrisy or poke fun at their expense sometimes, if it's clear that they're posting in bad faith

>>18114398
>>18114375
That reconstruction of Yaxchilan bridge is somewhat speculative, but I haven't been able to suss out to what degree. I'd certainly take it with more grains of salt then say Gentling's art of Aztec palaces, which are very grounded and in line with actual fairly intact ruins from other sites, but I don't THINK the bridge reconstruction is complete speculation either, as I understand it if nothing else we have evidence of the spires in the middle across the river, and depending on how much is intact of the landings/abuttments on both sides of the bridge, that would implicitly kind of require a flat deck span and the suspenders, maybe?

1/?
>>
>>18114725
cont:


>>18114548
Flower wars likely had as much use as pragmatic military/geopolitical tools as they did as a way to get captives, as argued by hassig, smith, etc, see: https://desuarchive.org/k/thread/58096307/#58178924 In general I favor a more pragmatic interpretation of Aztec militarism then a ritually driven one since most researchers lean that way, and the evidence that the Mexica ever actually specifically

>>18114560
Maybe there were 70 child skulls in the analyzed remains of the Huey Tzompantli, but that research found ~5% of skulls were from children and the rack seems to have held around ~16,000 skulls, not including the two skull towers (which are where the analyzed skulls are from). So the actual amount of sacrificed children would likely be like 800-1200+, emphasis on the "+" since we don't know how tall the towers were and they may not have contained earlier periods of deposits, though I do know from Lopez Lujan saying so that at least some of the skulls in the rack or towers were deposited prior to Ahuizotl's reign, which is when most of the deposits were

>>18114615
The Keeley graph here is nonense btw, the methodology for the Aztec figure is terrible, if people are curious I can post about it later if I have time. Keep in mind that while Zumárraga's 20k estimate is across a wider area then just tenochtitlan or even the aztec empire, and so is Harner's inflated total via borah/cook, there is a 20,000-80,000 estimate range for the 1487 reconsecreation of the great temple (for ahuizotl's coronation, the event where the huey tzompantli in the form we excavated it was probably made), but the rack's scale disproves those figures.

>>18114646
>>18114633
None of the posts above you are from me, though one of the anons is basically remixing prior posts of mine

2/2 for now
>>
>>18114646
Probably yes.
>>
>>18114646
No, the Mesofag is an objectively respectable poster who actually knows his shit and has been around on this board for as long as i can remember, since at least the first two years after its creation to be more specific. I do understand, judging by some of the other posts on that other thread that's up right now, that you're upset over people rightfully calling you out for your strange fixation on Teotihuacan's reconstructed status, but i don't think he's even responsible for most of it (a significant portion of it is me, in fact).
The Brazilian avatarfag on the other hand is a much more recent phenomenon with a noticeably unique and distinct posting style that involves a whole lot of anime pictures and who seems to believe in a bunch of wacky magic shit, like Atlantis-type stuff, that the mesofag does not, though he does evidently seem to get a lot of his information information on more mundane aspects of Mesoamerica from the mesofag's posts.
>>
>>18112945
>If that were the case Mesoamericans would be considered superior to Scandinavians.
uhhhh yeah if history stopped in the 15th century so you could ignore the fact that scandinavian countries are 10,000x more prosperous than any latam shithole
>>
>>18114633
Honestly, I don't think it's the same person at this point. The worshipper of magical Cubans is one of those spammers who use "Mesoamerica" as a weapon against Europeans, yes, but there are others. There's the guy who pretends to be cultured and intellectual, although he uses semantics to seem intelligent, and there's the brainless one above. In the end, they all use blogs, artistic drawings that are often not necessarily accurate, and of course, Wikipedia.

I already debated with one of them about the population of Tenochtitlan; basically, I presented five different authors, and my response was mockery. They are not cultured. I wouldn't waste time, but you can troll them by saying the word "reconstruction." Just today, a guy in another thread said that one of the photos of Mesoamerica was a reconstruction, but you can troll them by saying the word "reconstruction."
Just today, a guy in another thread said that one of the photos from Mesoamerica was a reconstruction, and he or she automatically invoked an anonymous person who hurt him for a thread months ago.

Lol. The irony is that some of my posts were reported, perhaps because of a complaint.
>>
File: 1735434486617.jpg (878 KB, 3184x3184)
878 KB
878 KB JPG
>>18112945
>>
>>18114714
The guy who led the Toxcatl massacre was Pedro de Alvarado, Cortez' second in command most famous for his red/blond hair.
>>
>>18114037
>Tacitus himself was unsure how to place Belgae culturally
not that it changed much
>>
>>18112945
>racism is about skin color
except it isn't, since race isn't color
color is part of race when looking at massively zoomed parent groups like 1+1=2 conclusion that Africans and Europeans are different, but you have to have negative iq to think this is where racial borders are drawn
this is American-tier where they think race is "white, black, and Asian" without a hint of irony
>>
>>18115302
>except it isn't, since race isn't color
Race isn't color, but racism is
>>
>>18112945
>hut
>comfy
>built with the materials of your area
>respects nature
>birth strong eugenic people (meat and milk)
>strong sense of community, strong mental health
>save from plagues if isolated

>city
>inhuman (humans didn't evolve to live surrounded just by buildings and thousands of other humans), atomization every single time that has been tried
>use materials from other regions
>cost human and animal suffering
>birth mental illnesses (because is anti-human), plagues and dysgenics (eat ze grain)

Meme is unironically based.
>>
>>18114853
Ok?
>>
>>18115752
You're the same kind of wignat who whines about africans living in huts and how that's bad. Now you frame it this way.
>>
>>18112945
>Trvke: racism is about skin color.
Not all racism is the same.
But yeah there are definitely a lot of utter retards who can't look past color to the point where they'll define color based on theur racial wishes.
Pretty schizo, but what can you do?

Also protip: pic of preserved historical thing >>>>> artist's rendition regardless of subject.
>>
>>18114745
I've been here since this board existed, because I was infodumping about Mesoamerican shit on other boards since before /his/ was made, and I was on 4chan for many years before even that prior to when I started posting about Mesoamerica

Anyways, yes, Teotihuacan's structures have been moderately to heavily restored in some cases but the only structure I know of that really has it done in a misleading way is the Pyramid of the Sun, and most of the time you can tell what has been restored or not because there are pebbled inserted into the mortar on the restored bits

That's more an indication then you'll get for heavily restored sections of roman or mesopotamian ruins in Italy or Iran

>>18114763
What did you say regarding Tenochtitlan's population? Link the thread on desuarchive and I'll give my thoughts
>>
>>18118398
>Link the thread on desuarchive and I'll give my thoughts
I don't have time for cheap academic jargon; your verbosity is fine on a Saturday afternoon, for example, when we don't have much to do. But just search on desuarchive.org and you'll remember the day. I only got mockery in response
>>
>>18114763
>>18114745
Mesolarp is so annoying and biased
>>
>>18113558
the cimbri are descended from the same cimmerian traders that settled anatolia.
at an early date they did wear horns, which is why schizo med historians put horns on vikings, because medshits lack temporal discernment
>>
>>18114375
Tenochtitlán was truly impressive looking for something a bunch of savages stuck in the stone age could build. It looked impressive even for 1500 European standards and they still couldn't work metal properly.
Anyone that denies the beauty of Tenochtitlan is some save EVROPA soi.
>>
>>18119500
The thing Was ugly



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.