[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: hispanic american studies.jpg (417 KB, 1080x1919)
417 KB
417 KB JPG
Why do Hispanicists from Latin America piggyback on the success of Spain's legacy rather than bring up what they have contributed as Latin Americans?

They talk about how they are more qualified as Greco-Romans than the Anglo-Germanics, but what else have they done to continue that Roman legacy besides being ruled by a bunch of Romance-speaking Catholics? Are they just taking out their grievances against the Anglos?

I've even heard of some Brazilians involved in the Hispanicism movement; they don't speak Spanish ffs.


For the record, I find Hispanicism based only when European Spaniards do it.
>>
Because Latin American countries' post-independence history is just one coup after another, with massacres, human rights' violations, and rampant embezzlements of public funds happening all at once.
Brazilians do not want to feel proud of gang wars in Rio that took place 60 years ago, and Mexicans do not want to feel proud of massacres of farmers and factory workers on strike.
>>
File: lol.png (445 KB, 499x510)
445 KB
445 KB PNG
>>18124677
this is so fucking funny
>>
>>18124677
You haven't seen anything yet. There's an almost supremacist ideology circulating among these people, where basically it's said that being a mongrel somehow makes you superior, and the future is really for the world to be mixed-race. See the related photos of these people. Most of them, and the Hispanists, come from Mexico. And there's this attempt to relativize the European concept and treat Anglo-Saxons as a kind of common enemy. The clowns then claim that the peoples of the Iberian regions of the Americas possess the territorial, racial, and spiritual factors necessary to initiate the "universal era of humanity" again, in contrast to the evil and racist Anglo-Saxons.
>>
>>18124716
>>
>>18124726
Cringe as f
>>
>>18124716
they go as far as to say that spain isn't a white european country and it's an insult to associate them with the evil western civilization
>>
>>18124677
>I've even heard of some Brazilians involved in the Hispanicism movement; they don't speak Spanish ffs.
They spend more time complaining about Spain than about the Portuguese. I speak fluent Portuguese. There's a Brazilian YouTube channel where the author says it's necessary to talk about the Iberian Peninsula or something like that, and throughout the video and in the comments, he says that the Iberians were somehow the pillars of American miscegenation and how this would somehow be an identity that would unite all peoples along with Catholicism. Then he insults the English and Americans for turning their countries into a conference of northern Europeans or something like that. I'm not sending the video or link because I assume almost nobody speaks Portuguese, and I think something that unites them is a hatred for "Anglo-Saxons," right? I've seen other Brazilian channels with the same theme
>>18124716
>cosmic race
LMAO
>>
Don't north americans do the same with rome?
>>
>>18124736
Correct
>>
>>18124776
>>18124736
Btw, latin= italian
>>
>>18124782
What does it mean to be "culturally" white? Iberia is within the European cultural sphere, yet according to the logic of these imbeciles, Spain is white.
>>
>>18124807
probably from the moorish sphere
but spaniards have more celtic and probably even more germanic dna
they're genetically closer to the irish than anything else

the idea that southern europeans are brown medchads who see more in common with mena and northerners are whitecucks seem to be a jeet/latinx projection

afaik, southern europeans irl consider themselves fully white europeans
>>
File: 1680817315475.png (154 KB, 1000x526)
154 KB
154 KB PNG
>>18124831
>they're genetically closer to the irish than anything else
No they aren't lmao
>>
File: true hispanicist.png (484 KB, 938x728)
484 KB
484 KB PNG
>>18124782
actual spaniard hispanicist chad spreads the truth that spaniards are indeed white
>>
>>18124831
>whitecucks
You already lost
>>
>>18124714
>evolution of cowboys
Pretty based
>>
if they are roman why do they not succeed like romans
>>
>>18124677
>>18124714
>Greco-Roman
Lmao. These civilizations were explicitly pagan, even their philosophies can only truly be understand within the context of the pagan Greco-Roman religion.
When the Greeks and Romans converted to Christianity in the 3rd century, it was very late in their history and they were basically dying civilizations.
>>
>>18124677
Just so you know, I'm Catholic, but I'm sure their Catholicism is quite different and has innovations not seen in Europe. For example, I don't recall the kings of Spain worshipping African thunder gods or making offerings.
>>18124716
They speak for themselves; even among the most extreme Phalagist groups I've seen here, there was no mention whatsoever of this uninterrupted unity between Spaniards and "Latinos." Where exactly did this come from?
>>
>>18124917
Larpagans are no better than Hispanists; both are two sides of the same cancer cell that attacks the body. Furthermore, Greek philosophy was often at odds with "polytheism," and it was precisely this that was later developed by monasteries, but that's off-topic, so who cares?
>>
File: 1671068633845.png (412 KB, 602x452)
412 KB
412 KB PNG
>>18124677
>>18124716
>>18124726
>>18124731
>>
>>18124928
Wrong.
>>18124714
Greatest example of devolution
>>
>>18124782
This is what christkikery does to your brain.
>>
>>18124714
Is that a motherfucking Jojo reference?
>>
>>18124716
I believe this.
It is the universal obligation of white men to pick up the torch of the Portuguese and whiten minority wombs
>>
File: GlINzGkXsAAcPVJ.jpg (144 KB, 724x900)
144 KB
144 KB JPG
>>18124677
>Spics are roughly 40-50 percent European, 40-50 percent indigenous American
>They speak a European language
>Practice the Iberian and traditionally European religion
>They're not allowed to appreciate their culture because Germanics wuz Rome or some shit
????
>>
>>18124714
why do latinx claim italian heritage
>>
>>18124776
Where does England fit into this weird narrative? Especially given its much longer history than the US, and its historical dearth of anti-miscegenation laws
>>
>>18124714
Lmao wtf
>>
>>18124677
Well, I've seen the opposite. Certain types of South Americans (like Argentinians and Chileans) somehow feel a kind of shame about their Mediterranean heritage. This is reflected in the huge number of German and Anglo immigrants who moved to those countries, I suppose to try to "improve" their countries with genes from northerners or some nonsense like that.
>>
>>18124677
Nah. WASPs (especially from New England) are generationally racist and while they do not explicitly condemn race mixing, they do implicitly by their actions.
>>
>>18125072
The only evolution I see here is from Joseph Joestar to Kujo Jotato.
Then again, it's weird that Jotaro is supposed to be half-Japanese, even though his facial features look like those of an Ethiopian negus rather than anything like the members of the Yamato race.
>>18124967
basao
>VIVA LA RAZA CÓSMICA INTERGALÁCTICA
This made me laugh out loud for real. We finna be space conkererz n shyzzz.
>>
>>18125575
Outside of São Paulo and Buenos Aires, the closest the vast majority of Latin Americans will ever get to approaching Italians and Italian culture is by ordering Domino's Pizza, playing Mario games, and watching The Godfather dubbed in Mexican Spanish.
Most Mexicans, Colombians, and Peruvians have literally never seen an Italian in person and cannot imagine that there are Italians in real life outside of memes about people shaking their hands and AI-generated brainrot music videos.
In fact, most of them only "know" of Italy as the place where Ferrari cars and Dolce & Gabbana purses come from, so the only way for their minds to wrap around the idea of Ancient Romans like Cicero, Seneca, and Julius Caesar being actual human beings with actual thoughts is by thinking of them as extremely old versions of their own countrymen, since otherwise they cannot think of them as anything other than flailing hands moustachemen with cartoonish personalities who can only say "Mamma mia", "Cazzo!" and "porcoddio!".
>>
>>18124831
Only Iberians, French, and British care about "white". Only Italians, Macedonians and Greeks can claim Greeks and Romans. Everyone else is a piggyback LARPer
>>
>>18124831
We aren't MENA and aren't like Nordics. Both of you should stop trying to claim Greco Roman heritage. You will never be Italian or Greek.
>>
>>18124714
that pic is hilarous. dumb spicks lol
they are better than niggers tho lol
>>
>>18126207
>WASPs (especially from New England) are generationally racist and while they do not explicitly condemn race mixing, they do implicitly by their actions
imagine believing this in 2025 lol
>>
>>18126561
only italians and greeks get to claim greco-roman heritage
spaniards have no relevance
>>
>>18124714
Hahahaha latinx are so funny
>>
>>18126321
What the fuck are you even talking about, why are you projecting your own pathetic autism, I live in a spic country and Italians aren't some alien race you fucking moron
>>
>>18125072
>>18126279
Wish part 3 have Italian hamon masters Suzie Q
>>
Is this better or worse than the Bolivarian Patria Grande Larp?
>>
>>18124677
Without help from the indigenous people, Spain wouldn't have gone past the Caribbean islands. That is their accomplishment too.
>>
File: IMG_1366.jpg (30 KB, 640x294)
30 KB
30 KB JPG
>>18124677
They’re insecure mongrels who hate Anglos because of the rivalry between Spain and England. They have an identity crisis so they co-opt the hatred of Anglos from 1700s Spaniards and LARP as le BASED Roman Meds. The Hispanist’s mind revolves entirely around the nefarious perfidious blue eyed anglosajon pirata yanqui imperialista. It’s an obsession. None of these people are the 6 foot tall WestEuro-looking criollos they depict themselves as. They’re 5 foot tall indio-tilted mestizos that are indistinguishable from your average Guatemalan
>>
File: DSCN9781.jpg (47 KB, 860x645)
47 KB
47 KB JPG
>>18124919
>They speak for themselves; even among the most extreme Phalagist groups I've seen here, there was no mention whatsoever of this uninterrupted unity between Spaniards and "Latinos." Where exactly did this come from?
Old books, the author of this one got executed by the republicans during the war. Later La Falange Exterior tried to export their brand of ultranationalism and "panhispanidad" to Latin America but they got cucked by the glowies. Alfonso XIII declared October 12th as the Día de la Raza.
>>
>>18125428
Spics are roughly 40-50 percent European, 40-50 percent indigenous American
This is a meaningless statement
>They speak a European language
So do 100% black Nigerians
>Practice the Iberian and traditionally European religion
They do not. Most Spics are not religious in their day-to-day lives, identifying as Catholic is more important than genuine belief and practice to them. Furthermore, Latin American Catholicism is famously rife with pagan influences
>They're not allowed to appreciate their culture because Germanics wuz Rome or some shit
LOL
Calls Roman and Iberian culture “their culture” but accuses Germanics of we wuzzing despite them reviving Europe and carrying the legacy of Rome after the empire collapsed
>>
>>18129864
Hispanidad is literally old fascist propaganda
>>
>>18128647
>Is this better or worse than the Bolivarian Patria Grande Larp?

It’s the same thing. Bolivarian concept of Patria Grande is a Hispanicist concept. The account posting this subscribes to the ideology of Hispanismo
>>
File: IMG_1401.jpg (270 KB, 1080x1590)
270 KB
270 KB JPG
>>18129883
What’s your point? That doesn’t have much of anything to do with what I said in response to OP. Also, this image is Argentine in origin and depicts a white person. See picrel
>>
>>18128540
>I live in a spic country and Italians aren't some alien race
Unless you grew up with gabagools next door, you do NOT know what gabagoolmensch are like.
>>
File: 20251102_232055.jpg (80 KB, 640x480)
80 KB
80 KB JPG
>>18129889
I got it wrong and replied to the wrong person. But yeah, I guess the artist got lazy and recolored the image as a black dude without much thought also >>18124677 Hispanidad by definition wasn't intended to be a white guy only thing. Here's an image of an inca princess by the same author. If you think it's cringe when someone does it, it's cringe when anyone else does it and says the same exact things. I don't like Hispanidad because it hinges a lot on fascist historical revisionism.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.