[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


Janitor application acceptance emails are being sent out. Please remember to check your spam box!


[Advertise on 4chan]


Who was better?
>>
>>18131084
At what?
>>
>>18131084
Hitler killed the most white people, so him.
>>
>>18131084
Napoleon
>>
>>18131084
Caesar
>>
>>18131084
Hitler miles better for his people being a national socialist
>>
>>18131084
Tempted to say Napoleon because of Caesars relatively short reign as dictator, but a rule that results in Augustus being emperor should be considered.

Hitler was an expert politician and speaker but I don't think he was good for Germany in the long run.
>>
>>18131084
Alexander takes the cake but Jesus did it better.

How would you cut that knot?
>>
>>18131186
>hey alexander how do we untie this knot
>hurrrr duuuhh *cuts it like a barbarian*
>WAOW how innovative!!!
What a shite story
>>
>>18131084
FDR mogs all of them
>>
>>18131205
The whooshing sound you just heard was the meaning of it passing clean over your head.
>>
>>18131084
>Left
Good general but mostly carried by his Legions.
Decent administrator and diplomat but tone-deaf politician.
>Middle
Not a military commander.
Decent administrator and diplomat, and even a much greater politician with a silver tongue.
>Right
The greatest military commander in history.
The greatest administrator in history.
Decent diplomat and politician but outmaneuvered by more empathetic and psychopathic snakes like Tsar Alexander and Talleyrand.
>>18131186
>Fagsander
Carried entirely by his daddy's army.
The moment his men smelled pajeets they told him to fuck off and he couldn't do anything besides marching them through desert like a seething bitch out of spite.
Crap administrator, diplomat, and politician. His subordinates were a bunch of opportunistic psychos who pissed all over his legacy and family, said "no way fag" to his will, and went off to do their own thing.
Never got the hype.
>>18131210
Sharties should die.
>>
>>18131230
>greatly oversimplifying Alexander
kys
>>
>>18131290
>Stating the simple truth about the gayreek retard is oversimplification
Fuck off, gayreek lover.
>>
>>18131295
Sorry jew boy but he was the true lion of God, not like you fake and gay serpent larpers
>>
One got killed because he was too good. Another killed himself like a pussy in a bunker, and the last one had to live in exile on a cuck island in the middle of nowhere. Make your own assumptions.
>>
>>18131300
>God
Abrahamkike construct of some Babylonian moon war idol.
Stop outing yourself.
>>
>>18131084
Replace crazy mustache man with Hannibal
>>
>>18131589
Jews shit and piss themselves about Alexander because he claimed to be the Lion, of Herculese by pure blood tribe descent. Jews fancy their people the lion and they never got over it.
>>
>>18131610
Fagsander lost.
Go make me kebab, Ahlmext.
>>
>>18131084
>caesar
>hitler
>napoleon
From best to worst
>>
>>18131084
Adolf’s Germany fought against the great evil (USSR). Those other guys either fought weak opponents or countries that weren’t ruled by evil despots.
>>
>>18131084
I would say Napoleon because he didnt chimp out like those other two retards.
Between Hitler and Caesar I have to give it to Hitler, because if he didnt chimp out he would be remembered fondly as an efficient if ruthless chancellor who rebuilt Germany after the (((20s))). Caesar is mad overrated, he was just a discount Sulla whose entire legacy was carried hard by Augustus.
Augustus mogs all three of these tards.
>>
>>18131227
Explain the meaning then, idiom-using ass mothafuka. As far as i see it the challenge was to untie the knot and tardexander sliced it clean in two like a beast
>>
>>18131604
not the same.
hannibal was the first anti-imperialist.
invaded rome not to conquer, but to deter.

the others? classic europeans trying to subdue the rest.

so, my ranking:

hannibal
hannibal
hannibal
caesi
napi
hitli
>>
>>18131084
adolf because he is a tragic hero
napoleon was just a skilled opportunist and cesar was too naive and selfish
>>
>>18131084
Napoleon because he liberated the Jews and created the modern world
>>
>>18131230
>>Left
>Good general but mostly carried by his Legions.
Same legions which would get slaughtered en masse when commanded by incompetent generals? You're just so dumb.
>Decent administrator and diplomat but tone-deaf politician.
Calling a guy whose career was 40 years of politics and little over 10 years of warfare a 'tone-deaf' politician is truly something else. Braindead tier.
>>Middle
>Decent administrator and diplomat
Excellent diplomat. His diplomacy consisted of: threats, demands, war. How rich
>and even a much greater politician with a silver tongue.
Best politician of all time. Lead his country to utter ruin, amazing stuff.
>>Right
>The greatest administrator in history.
His understanding of economy was limited a best. France simply had good bureaucracy and Napoleon had some good ideas when it came to statecraft and civil matters. But let's not get carried away.
>Decent diplomat and politician but outmaneuvered by more empathetic and psychopathic snakes like Tsar Alexander and Talleyrand.
He was even worse of a diplomat than you are a historian. He ruined all his military achievments with retarded diplomacy which honestly says it all. Just look at how he botched the russian campaign before it even started. Instead of ensuring he has Sweden and Turkey on his side (both hated Russia and had legitimiate interest in taking it down) he commited to bringing Austria and Prussia with him on the campaign even though it was obvious they will betray him at first opportunity. While insulting Sweden and having it turn on him next year. Just lol
Also, are you really comparing a religious nutjob and the "Europe's biggest child" tsar Alexander to the most macchiavellian character of all time Talleyrand? You are just spewing random words.
>>
>>18131084
Caesar
>>
>>18131110
oy gevalt!
>>
>>18131674
He thought outside the box
If you knew more about big Alex you would not be asking such a low IQ question
>>
>>18131589
saaaaaaaarrrrrr bloody basterd behenchod lasagna bitch
>>
>>18132534
>Calling a guy whose career was 40 years of politics and little over 10 years of warfare a 'tone-deaf' politician is truly something else. Braindead tier.
The same faggot who couldn't read the writing on the wall that he was going to get killed and generosity toward his enemies wouldn't make them forgive him? That guy?
Romefags are truly something else.
Didn't even bother to read the rest of your copium wall.
>>
>>18132600
>le hindsight is le 20/20
go to bed kid. tomorrow is a schoolday
>>
>>18131084
Best Tactics: Caesar>Napoleon
Best Cause: Hitler
>>
>>18131084
Hitler because long after dying his message echoes in the hears of people all over the world. Until the nonwhites are removed, the spirit of Hitler will burn with vengeance. If they aren't, his spirit will weep with sorrow, and kindle with spite. And after they are removed, Hitler's spirit will nourish and fortify the brilliant world that emerges.
>>
>>18132557
>Oh megas alexandros please my baby is tied up in this rope by accident please save it!
>No problem m'am *slices babby*
>WTF megas alexandros you sliced my baby in half!
>its free from the rope mam excuse me but i was thinking outside of the box
>>
just different reincarnations of one great man.
>>
>>18132900
>false equivalence
ramshit please redeem a history book SAAAARRR
>>
>>18131084
Napoleon was the most noble and had the least amount of closeted skeletons.
>>
>>18131084
Napoleon got more of he wanted in the end then the other two. The Roman Republic died and so did Germany, but France, Liberalism and Nationalism has survived for better or worse
>>
File: 1755606810337342.png (1.61 MB, 1600x1173)
1.61 MB
1.61 MB PNG
>>18131084
I think Hitler's legacy still has time to fully manifest, and I think when that happens he will have a strong case as the greatest European of all times, but until then I think Caesar takes #1. He was just too complete of a man with a life so ridiculously amazing it sounds like a novel.
Napoleon was great and in the same stratosphere, but he made too many unforced errors, and having emancipated the Jews also brings him a bit down in my estimation, despite him in later life coming to hate them intensely. So for now
1. Caesar
2. Hitler
3. Napoleon
And I would put Alexander below them as well.
>>
>>18132611
I accept your concession, retarded romefag.
>>
>>18133743
Rome does not concede, brownoid shit stinking sewer rat
>>
> I think when that happens he will have a strong case as the greatest European of all times
/his/ distortion from reality never ceases to amaze me.
>>
>>18133893
/pol/troons unironically belive that in two more weeks everyone will be loving gaytler and hailing swastika flag, they keep repeating the same thing for over a 10 years
>>
>>18133256
dumb mutt award
>>
>>18132991
>random unrelated fallacy
>racism
>muh history book
admit it, its a stupid fucking story
>>
All 3 are nothing compared to Christ
>>
>>18133993
>'slices baby'
>cries muh raysis
so fragile yet so retarded
>>
File: 1748736113533166.jpg (702 KB, 2048x1189)
702 KB
702 KB JPG
>>18133826
>>18133826
>Rome does not concede, brownoid shit stinking sewer rat
>>
>>18134241
Yeah when did i say i wasn't also racist or think its a bad thing? I just believe you to be a faggot for using it as a crutch for your shitty argument in support of a stupid fable.
>>
>>18134261
>t. stinky melty
sad desu
>>
>>18131084
Caesar>Napoleon>>>>>>Hitler
>>
>>18134280
KEK.
Seething spic.
>>
>>18131147
>I don't think he was good for Germany in the long run.
why, did something happen?
>>
>>18135726
>cringe and way off the mark
take a shower stinky
and brush your teeth with cow dung or whatever you dysgenic fucks do
>>
>>18131084
Hitler was influenced by Napoleon and Napoleon was inspired by Caesar. And the entire battle of Alesia was fucking amazing.
>>
>>18131637
Ceaser isn’t even a discount Sulla. He got forced into waging a war because Pompey wouldn’t back him running for a legal office to prevent prosecution for the war crimes he committed against the Gauls.
Basically if the senate didn’t have a bunch of shit stirrers Caesar would have been a nothing.
>>
>>18132600
>The same faggot who couldn't read the writing on the wall
that is rich coming from adolfboo
>>
>>18135739
>spic still malding
Yup, it's booty blaßt I'm smelling.
>>
>>18131084
Timur
>"muh steppes nig"
Exactly. Imagine getting outclassed in empire building by a crippled uzbek.
>>
>>18131139
This.
Neither Caesar nor Napoleon were socialists, they were only after their own image
>>
>>18132914
>reincarnation
good morning saar



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.