[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


Janitor application acceptance emails are being sent out. Please remember to check your spam box!


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 1753290728471750.jpg (11 KB, 327x243)
11 KB
11 KB JPG
Just read the Qur'an... I think I'm Muslim...
>>
Said no one ever
>t. abdul muhammad al karachi
>>
>>18167209
Many such cases. When I quit Christianity I opened the Quran on a lark and was shocked to find just a book of laws and a LOT of copy-pasted Old Testament. 99% of what people say is in the Quran simply isn't there, they're just making up fantasies in their heads. It was really enlightening. I consider myself a quranist now (no Hadiths for me, I don't need to follow that weirdo brownskin Muhammad's personal diary).
>>
>>18167236
>99% of what people say is in the Quran simply isn't there, they're just making up fantasies in their heads
such as?
>>
>>18167209
It was the Zutting that convinced, wasn't it?
>>
File: islam4.jpg (2.28 MB, 1000x10000)
2.28 MB
2.28 MB JPG
>>18167209
koran is a pile of poop only good for burning
>>
>>18167243
Taqiyya for instance. Most people think all Muslims will lie about being Muslim just to get elected to the city council or whatever. That's not how it works and it's not in the Quran.
>>
File: 1756293978272801.gif (188 KB, 320x236)
188 KB
188 KB GIF
Drop the ack, Abdul
No one's converting to Zuttlam
>>
>>18167209
Really? You can read Arabic?

The Bible is still the Bible when translated. However, the Qu'ran is only the Qu'ran in the original language, anything else is considered just a translation not the actual book.
>>
File: zutt.png (19 KB, 423x866)
19 KB
19 KB PNG
>>18167209
>>
>>18167236
Yeah most hadiths should be taken with a grain of salt at best, some really retartdded nonsensical stuff like needing to eat with your right hand only and music being Haram "because... Because it just is ok!?"
>>
>>18167586
The question is, why would you take some but reject the others
They are all apocryphas

Not one is canon. And yet, some are treated as equal to the Quran
>>
>>18167209
Welcome to the club
>>
>>18167586
>>18167650
I reject and denounce all hadiths and so should every Muslim in the World
>>
>>18167209
It's simple. I quite like it. I don't believe in converting but Muslims have my respect. Definitely the last remaining truly traditional and monotheistic religion
>>
>>18167282
>>18167243
This is a perfect example of taqiyya, because taqiyya is in the Quran.
16:106
Whoever has disbelieved in Allah even after his belief excepting him who has been compelled and his heart is (still) composed with belief-but whoever has his breast expanded in disbelief, then upon them is anger from Allah and they will have a tremendous torment

3:28
The believers should not take unbelievers as protectors in preference to believers. Anyone who does that will completely isolate himself from God unless you are seeking to protect your selves from them. God warns you to beware of Him. God is our ultimate destination.

Muslims are literally only able to lie and never state the truth on ANY topic. It's like some force physically prevents them from ever being truthful to any extent. Truly a satanic religion.

On the contrary the more you study the Quran, the more you realize it is ALWAYS ambiguous enough to leave the door open to the most abominable interpretations you can imagine. It's designed that way.

>>18167209
So you have brain damage and will fold if any ideology presents a simple enough front for you. Got it. Notice how you didn't provide even the shadow of an argument in favor of the Quran being "true".
>>
zutt'd itt
>>
same queen muhammed was the first true LGBT ally truly a pioneer good gurls get zutted
>>
The chapter where Muhammad (ZUTT BE UPON HIM) has his moon split is particularly beautiful
>>
>>18168167
This isn’t taqqiya, this is literally God telling muslims that you haven’t sinned if you pretend you aren’t Muslim to save yourself from death.
>>
>>18168493
tell that to shia muslims
>>
>>18167209
Kek. I can't imagine how low your IQ must be for this to actually happen.
>>
>>18168493
Literally nowhere is the condition of "it needs to be a direct threat of death" ever specified in those verses and you KNOW you're lying. As I said, you are physically incapable of being truthful on any topic related to islam.

Isn't it funny how Allah puts a seal of dishonesty on muslims' hearts, and then tells them the non-muslims have a seal on their hearts? It's peak projection.
>>
>>18168562
Being unironically attracted to islam is caused either by low IQ, or being a sperg who believes too easily in people's sincere motives and is incapable of detecting untrustworthy persons.
>>
>>18168682
I dunno, I know some very smart people who have fallen into "submission." Paul from BloggingTheology is a very well spoken white Brit who is devoted to Islam, and he seems pretty intelligent. Could just be the accent fooling me. You don't have to be dumb to make "wrong" decisions, particularly in politics and religion.
>>
>>18167236
Rejections of the Hadiths and the rise of Quranism can only grown now that thanks to the internet ridicolous and silly hadiths like the infamous al-Zutt one are being translated and shared around
>>
>>18168056
Based Pakibro
>>
>>18168674
Did an arab fuck your girlfriend or something?
>>
>>18167236
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hadith_sciences

moron
>>
>>18168056
Then you also reject and denounce 60% of Islamic tradition

Salat
Hajj
Zakat
Aqiqah
Sabr

All gone
>>
>>18168674
>calling me dishonest
You’re being a shitstain and intellectually dishonest the verse clearly says “who has been compelled”, which can easily mean death and threat of death or abuse. Kys
>>
>>18168910
Hajj is in the Qur'an, but I agree, rejecting the sunnah and hadiths is silly.
>>
>>18168945
compelled includes, but is not moral duress.
And the quran is inherently vague and up for interpretation, what with the translation issues.
>>
>>18169120
*mortal not moral
>>
>>18167209
Grand age of ZUTT!! (Feel free to say brown supremacy. Let's hear it).
>>
>>18168167
>breast expanded
L-lewd
>>
>>18167332
??? but theres lots of non-arabic words in the quran and some that are a total mystery
>>
>>18168769
that guys a retard
>Could just be the accent fooling me
yeah he comes off as if he should know better
>>
>>18168910
Jesus taught us how to pray and to Quran confirms the Bible so thats how you pray
>>
>>18169434
Bible says that the Quran is false
>>
>>18168506
>tell that to shia muslims
these guys live amongst headchoppers. They get suicide bombed all the time
>>
>>18167209
Enjoy burning.
>>
>>18169662
the quran says you'll be the ones burning
checkmate
>>
>>18167209
Muslims don't read, they worship a cube five times s day, fuck goats, and marry their first cousins.
>>
Alright my Muslim friends, tell me about Sufi Islam. I want to dive into direct experience of God.
>>
>>18169675
none of this is permitted in Quran
>>
>>18169685
Muslims don't read so they wouldn't know.
>>
>>18169687
Most Christians haven't read the Bible, the same is not true for Muslims and the Qur'an.
>>
File: 1752867550987884.png (207 KB, 400x610)
207 KB
207 KB PNG
>>18169683
Picrel should be a good intro. Best wishes.
>>
>>18169690
Muhammad himself technically never read the quran because he was illiterate, checkmate
>>
>>18169690
Most Christians are retarded devil worshipers that exalt christ killers.
>>
>>18169690
>the same is not true for Muslims and the Qur'an.
Yes it is. Most Muslims can't even read Arabic and translations of the Quran are forbidden. Most Muslims don't even know what the fuck is in the Quran because they can't read it. At least Christians can pull up a translation at any time and start reading.
>>
>>18169696
Ahhh, okay, so I'm already a Sufi.

Sweet, love being spiritually enlightened. That's how you know em.
>>
>>18169713
Where do you get the idea that translations are forbidden? My translated Qur'an was approved by Al-Azhar University.
Also, Muslims memorize phrases in Arabic along with what they mean, but that doesn't stop them from also reading translations.
>>
>>18168167
Example #3,593 of using Shia psychos as a stand in for the vast Muslim majority who do not believe in lying ever
You probably think all Muslims worship the Ayatollah too
You probably don't know what a Shia even is, mutt
>>
>>18169723
>Where do you get the idea that translations are forbidden?
Muslims. This is what I've been told whenever I've argued with them about the reliability of the Quran.
>Muslims memorize phrases in Arabic along with what they mean
Some may, most don't.
>>
>>18169747
Well they're wrong and probably already speak Arabic anyways. The Arabic version is the most authentic but reading translations is valid.
>Some may, most don't
Of course they memorize what they mean, the fuck? It's not like it's hard, they're just a few sentences.
>>
>>18169747
Translations of the Quran aren't considered Qurans technically, but rather tafsirs (explanations). The reason being is that once you translate or try to explain it, it isn't God's word.
>>
>>18168910
>Salat
In the Quran. 3 times a day. Quranists aren't the only ones who do this. Nizaris do too. Early Muslims also didn't all do 5 times a day. Even hadith agrees with this.
https://sunnah.com/bukhari/64/163
>Hajj
In the Quran. 3:97
>Aqiqah
Not obligatory. The Quran, and thus God's command, is still complete without it. Hanifa also thought it best to call it illegitimate as to avoid doing similar things as the pagans, so even some hadith followers don't practice it.
>Sabr
In the Quran.
>>
https://www.reddit.com/r/AcademicQuran/wiki/talmudparallels/
>>
https://www.youtube.com/@ExploringtheQuranandtheBible/videos
>>
I could never see the appeal of islam, also the fact they hate figurative art and music is a deal breaker for me. would fuck a hijabi ho though.


To me jesus is just an infinitely more interesting being than Muhammed the pedo


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iYlgihQFPrg
>>
>>18169929
>hate art
Only really strict ones really hate art in the casual settings. Most Muslims just understand it's not appropriate in the mosque or in religious contexts, except for Shiites, who have plenty of religious artworks of figures.
>hate music
This again is only really the case for the really strict ones, and again only applies to religious contexts for most Muslims, except for those who accept or tolerate religious music as in the case of many Sufi practices.
>>
File: 1762970951818055.jpg (76 KB, 1080x484)
76 KB
76 KB JPG
>>18169929
Only some fiqhs are against art and music doe. And Aisha was 19 when she married Muhammad according to some sources (and Shia)
>>
>>18169938
>>18169942
Muslims who keep even one image of a living creature in their homes clearly demonstrate disbelief in (and disobedience to) many of the hadiths in Sahih al-Bukhari, and therefore disbelief in the entire Sunni tradition, which is built on the hadiths of al-Bukhari. Anyone who rejects the hadiths is a kafir, according to the generally accepted opinion of Sunni scholars.

https://sunnah.com/muslim:2105
https://sunnah.com/bukhari:3322
https://sunnah.com/bukhari:3225
https://sunnah.com/bukhari:3351
https://sunnah.com/bukhari:5181
https://sunnah.com/bukhari:5949
https://sunnah.com/bukhari:5957
https://sunnah.com/bukhari:5958

The rich history of Islamic art only demonstrates the extent of disregard for the commandments of Muhammad among Muslims.
>>
>>18169963
These are mostly against status, drawings for example are generally disliked but not inherently prohibited. The less life-like the better. The Malilhi madhab has no issues at all with digital drawings.
>>
>>18170713
*Maliki
>>
>>18170713
>but not inherently prohibited
contradicts the hadiths
>>
>>18171031
No, it doesn't, those refer to graven images.
>>
>>18171035
True. Some hadiths explicitly give exception for images on woven things like cloth.
>>
Reject hadiths. Embrace Quranism.
>>
>>18169690
I seriusly doubt most muslims have the avanced knowledge in classical arabic to ready the Quran, when a lot of their countries have litteracy issues . Most of them read ditranslations, IE not the true Quran according to Islam
>>
>>18169938
>Shitte art
Dosent count. You know full well militan sunnis, especially Wahhabis (the form of Islam shilled every by the petrodollars) destroys any image or statue they can find, religious or not
>>
>>18171035
No. Reread the hadiths.
>>
>>18171257
Most Muslims aren't even Arabs. Only about 20% are. Even the ones who are Arabs natively speak a dialect which is significantly different than Classical Arabic.

So it's safe to say most Muslims are relying on tafsirs and translations to fully understand even if they're well-versed in MSA.
>>
>>18171087
>Some hadiths
Which ones exactly?
>>
>>18167236
So you pray three times a day?
>>
>>18171295
A real muslim would at least be in the process of learning classical arabic to be able to fully understand the quran, most muslims today are just posers
>>
>>18171299
Shia are allowed to pray 3 times a day too (combining prayers). It's not that uncommon.
>>
>>18167229
OP just said it liar
>>
>>18171249
I know more quran than hadith i think but im not sure. The quran is special in an amazing way.
>>
>>18171293
They do. Cope.
>>
>>18167209
>I think I'm Muslim...

neck yourself
>>
>>18172128
Why?
>>
>>18172136
He allowed jews to convince him that Muslims are the ones poisoning his food, turning his son trans and his daughter butch, pushing pornography in every media outlet, putting furries in the military and classrooms, and buying off politicians. And he believed them.
>>
bump
>>
bump
>>
>>18167209
What convinced you? Was it the 99th repetition or the 100th repetition of the story of Aaron and Moses before the Pharaoh?
>>
>>18168769
>Paul from BloggingTheology is a very well spoken white Brit
He lies all the fucking time (like all muslims), is a literal self-hating faggot, and has a disgusting face and voice that makes me unable to listen to him for a split second. Find a better example.
>>
File: 6248561.jpg (38 KB, 750x500)
38 KB
38 KB JPG
>>18173251
It was that time when Allah allowed Muh to marry any woman he likes, and his first cousins as well.
>>
>>18168945
There you have it. The muslim liar, knowing he's been found out, pathetically attempts to insist he's right, and lashes out in anger.

All muslims are liars, or ignorant. There is no third possibility.
>>
>>18171466
This cursed book consistently produces the worst societies on planet Earth (with the sole of exception of India).

inb4 no true scotsman
>>
>>18169685
You did not even pretend to have read the post, cousin fucker.
>>
>>18167209
If Judaism is an animal you eat, Christianity is the digestion and energy you get from it, and Islam is the shit that comes out.
>>
>>18167209
do you pray 4 times a day turned to Mecca? if not, then you're no Muslim. but I have good news for you: the Quran is the Word of God, like the Vedas, so it is a universal Sacred Scripture, that belongs to all Mankind, not only to Muslims. the same can be said about the Bhagavad Gita

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLvctceCTQG8LMSWNsKx1otfLUw0N_Jysx

actually, the Gita is the only Sacred Scripture you really need to learn (read, comprehend, put in practice and experience)
>>
>>18167209
I grew up in a Muslim household. I like Islam but the historical Muhammad seemed to be a revolutionary who advocated for the merging of the priest and warrior class and death to the concept of passivity and textual understanding as the path to connection with God. Both Sunni and Shia in the modern day basically depend on rabbis and despite agreeing with Islam metaphysically the nonsense that stems from hadiths and lack of a guide makes it the same as Judaism and Christianity now.
>>
>>18173611
>it is a universal Sacred Scripture, that belongs to all Mankind
Mankind rejects the Quran, which is the vilest, most anti-human scripture ever inspired by devils. The few traitors to humanity that enjoy that glorified toilet paper do not matter.
>>
>>18173616
>advocated for the merging of the priest and warrior class
That's an anthropologically terrible idea, which explains the violence and inefficiency of muslim nations.
>death to the concept of passivity
Muslims are some of the most passive people ever, because nothing matters in this life and ignorance is glorified by islam.
>>
>>18173643
>Islam is violent while also saying Islam is passive
You are actually retarded. Guided violence and desire to preserve itself is the thing that makes Islam actually functional compared to Judaism or Christianity. If they had something like the Taliban I'd respect them more.
>>
>>18173640
>few
It is the second largest religion in the world and fast approaching the first.
>>
>>18171812
So, you're declaring those Islamic scholars who believed these hadiths forbid any images of living beings to be liars and distorters of Islam?

Either you're right, or they are. Otherwise, Shariah is simply something ephemeral and vague, something that cannot provide clear and understandable rules for various aspects of human life.
>>
>>18174213
They have always forbidden graven images, and there have been cartoons aired in Muslim countries for decades as well as Islamic historical art. It really depends a lot on context which you can't grasp.
>>
>>18174220
Cope.
>>
>>18174242
Lmao you're the one coping, I gave actual examples of Muslims being fine with art.
>>
>>18174253
>I gave actual examples of Muslims being fine with art
They violated Shariah. You ran away from the questions asked.
>>
>>18167209
What I wouldn't give for jeets to stop spamming pisslam shill threads in my white supremacist anime board
>>
>>18174296
How did they violate Sharia when it is obviously near universally agreed that it refers to graven images, except to retards like the Taliban? Are you saying every major Muslim country deliberately violated Sharia? Lol, lmao.
>>
>>18174324
>Are you saying every major Muslim country deliberately violated Sharia?
Whether or not countries comply with Shariah law is irrelevant to the question. The Ottomans and their ulema permitted alcohol and hashish, but this doesn't mean it follows from the Quran and hadith.

Let's get to the point. Either Shariah law absolutely prohibits any images of living beings, or the sheikhs who offer such a maximalist interpretation are liars and distorters of Islam. Choose between the two. There's a third option, according to which Sharia law is fundamentally unrealistic and simply a construct in the minds of Muslims—hence the contradictions between madhhabs and between scholarly opinions.
>>
>>18174336
>Let's get to the point. Either Shariah law absolutely prohibits any images of living beings, or the sheikhs who offer such a maximalist interpretation are liars and distorters of Islam. Choose between the two.
There is a middle way which I've already explained. It prohibits graven images, and the maximalist interpretations are wrong (most madhhabs agree with this one).
>>
Read hadiths = leave Islam
Read Quran = embrace Islam

Makes grug think
>>
>>18174352
>Read Quran = leave Islam
Fixed.
I was a quranist for years, it was only when I started really studying it, that I was compelled to notice all the glaring errors and blatant lack of actual guidance on any topic whatsoever.
>>
>>18173679
Most of them are ignorant and don't even know the actual contents of the religion, and have never been seriously exposed to other points of view. They are victims and not traitors. Unlike you.
>>
>>18173678
No, those are the things the make islam dysfunctional and insure that every islamic country will become either a complete shithole, a dictatorship, or both(the more usual)
>>
>>18173678
Yeah, they're passive except in destruction, you are slowly starting to understand the issue.
>islam
>functional
Have you missed the part where every muslim country and muslim family is blatantly dysfunctional as hell?
>>
>>18174253
If Muslims are fine with art, why do they never make great art? Where are the muslim waltzes, the muslim novels, the muslim movies? Muslim art always sucks, except when others make it for them (like for a few old mosques). Muslim art always sucks because muslim conscience is stuck at "I must not think wrong thoughts and can't into complexity". You are destroyers, not makers. That is your purpose embedded in you by the religion you've chosen.
>>
File: 1761913863162739.png (981 KB, 544x680)
981 KB
981 KB PNG
>>18174373
>>
>>18174488
Eh, looks like a blur.

It reminds me of the stating coming from the tv when you tune to a dead channel.
>>
File: 1756125507822384.jpg (646 KB, 964x1200)
646 KB
646 KB JPG
>>18174516
>>
>>18174533
That looks even worse. Looks like something straight out of a Lovecraft novel.
>>
File: 1739916059974285.jpg (958 KB, 1170x1447)
958 KB
958 KB JPG
>>18174533
>>
>>18174541
You have shit taste, man. It's objectively beautiful.
>>
>>18174542
This looks better, although it still looks like shit plastered all over the walls.
>>18174545
>beauty
>objective
Lol

I favor minimalism myself. To each their own.
>>
>>18174551
Just say you're an Evangelical without a sense of beauty in architecture.
>>
>>18174553
I'm an atheist.
>>
File: 1736920134417639.jpg (473 KB, 1080x1439)
473 KB
473 KB JPG
>>18174557
That makes sense too.
>>
File: 1734887574924652.jpg (417 KB, 1080x1440)
417 KB
417 KB JPG
>>18174562
>>
>>18174562
Why is Islamic architecture so gaudy? Have they never come across the idea that less is more?
>>
>>18174567
Name one minimalist cathedral that doesn't look like shit.
>>
>>18174573
Why a cathedral specifically? I don't know many Cathedrals with a minimalist architecture. Although I do like Baroque architecture, they do know how to go all out with endless details. Not Islamic architects, they always end up looking half-assed.
>>
>>18174577
No examples provided.
>they do know how to go all out with endless details
Oh, you have none.
>>
>>18174595
>No examples provided.
Yeah, because I don't know any.
>Oh, you have none.
That's what I just said.

Show me some minimalistic mosques. C'mon.
>>
>>18174601
I never claimed to prefer minimalism. I do find it funny though that you like baroque because they have so much detail yet complain when it's on a mosque. Whatever.
>>
>>18174603
>I never claimed to prefer minimalism.
I never said that you did? I do. So, show'em.
>I do find it funny though that you like baroque because they have so much detail yet complain when it's on a mosque.
I like baroque because I consider it at the exact opposite of minimalism. They don't half-ass it, they go all out, which I can appreciate. Islamic arquitecture just seems to be in the middle, not embracing gaudiness.
>>
>>18174605
This is just cope for the fact that you can't name a single minimalist one. Now you're moving the goalpost.
And I don't know any minimalist mosques, never claimed to like minimalism, and never implied religious institutions should embrace minimalism.
>>
>>18174614
>This is just cope for the fact that you can't name a single minimalist one.
A minimalist cathedral? No, I can't. And I don't care much about cathedrals anyway. I'm an atheist remember. So now show me some cool minimalist mosques.
>And I don't know any minimalist mosques
You wasted my time.
>>
>>18174623
Too bad.
>>
>>18167209
its a boring book
>>
>>18174683
It isn't really. It feels like God is talking directly to you when you read it.
>>
>>18174687
You can read Arabic? If you can't, you haven't read the Qu'ran. It's only in Arabic everything else is a translation and not the real thing.
>>
>>18174928
>You can read Arabic?
Yes.
>everything else is a translation and not the real thing.
It's still worth reading a good translation with tafsir of you can't read Arabic. But you should strive to learn it still.
>>
>>18174966
Read it, really liked the parts about beating your wife and the extremely boring parts about inheritance.
>>
>>18174970
According to my Qur'an's tafsir:
>Disciplining one’s wife gently is the final resort. The earliest commentators understood that this was to be light enough not to leave a mark, should be done with nothing bigger than a tooth stick, and should not be on the face. Prophet Muḥammad (ﷺ) said to his companions “Do not beat the female servants of Allah.” He said that honourable husbands do not beat their wives, and he himself never hit a woman or a servant. If a woman feels her husband is ill-behaved, then she can get help from her guardian or seek divorce.
>>
>>18174987
>explain away the problematic parts through taqiyya
Ok I will beat my wife with a toothpick. I'm sure that's what they had in mind when they wrote it.
It's okay to beat your wife if you don't leave marks.


Btw have you stopped beating your wife?
>>
>>18175002
>only hearing what he wants to hear
no point in continuing
>>
>>18175002
Taqqiya is only for when under threat of death. kys
>>
>>18175009
Ummm ACKSHUALLY my commentary totally contradicts the text and explains it away so it isn't an issue.
>>
>>18175015
NTA but it doesn't contradict anything
>>
>>18175015
>contradicts the text
clarifies the translation*
no idea how monolingual retards like you still lurk on /his/ with 0 understanding of the shortfalls of translations and expect them to be a literal understanding of the text.
>>
>>18175041
>politician: Kill the rich!
>commentator: he actually means he wants to increase taxes on the wealthy
>anon: I see no contradiction
>>
>>18175044
That's literally often true though when it comes to political slogans or rhetoric. Are you telling me that pic related literally wants people to eat babies?
>>
>>18174346
>There is a middle way which I've already explained
The middle way is the recognition of the imperfections and ambiguities of Islam.

>most madhhabs agree with this one
Cite the opinions of the leading scholars of three of the four madhhabs (if you're talking about the majority of madhhabs) that permit the depiction of living beings in paintings.
>>
>>18174488
>>18174533
>>18174542
There are no images of living creatures. Because Muhammad claimed that angels do not enter a room where there are such images >>18169963

Don't Muslims expect angels in their homes? How many illustrated books do you have?
>>
File: 1763648362385.jpg (203 KB, 1024x559)
203 KB
203 KB JPG
>>18175110
>is that a picture of a cat???? I am not allowed to be here!
>>
>>18175110
>>18175905
Maliki Madhhab
>Generally considered the most lenient on drawings:
>Classical Malikis differentiated strongly between 3-D statues (usually forbidden) and 2-D images (generally allowed).
>Drawings are allowed if they are not used for shirk, not displayed in a reverential way, and are not obscene.
>Many Maliki scholars openly allow art, illustrations, and even realistic images.
Hanafi Madhhab
>Allows non-sacred, non-idolized drawings, especially when:
>The image is 2-dimensional (e.g., drawings, photos).
>It does not contain complete, living beings (e.g., missing head or essential organs).
>It does not involve worship, glorification, or hang in places of honor.
Shafi‘i Madhhab
>Traditionally more restrictive, but still:
>Strongly forbids 3-D images of living beings.
>Permits 2-D images in many cases if they are not objects of veneration.
>Many contemporary Shafi‘i jurists permit photography and non-idolizing drawings.
Hanbali Madhhab
>Classically the most cautious:
>Most classical Hanbalis prohibit realistic depictions of humans/animals, even 2-D.
>Permitted:
>Non-realistic drawings
>Images missing essential features
>Non-living forms (plants, landscapes, patterns)
>Contemporary Hanbali (including many Saudi) scholars allow photography and sometimes non-idolatrous drawings, but many still discourage realistic images.
And lastly, the Ja‘fari (Shia) Madhhab
>Generally permits drawings and photography, including realistic images, provided:
>No idolatry is involved.
>No obscene or immoral content.
>No disrespect to religious figures.
>Shia jurisprudence is generally more permissive on artistic representation than Sunni madhhabs.
The only one with serious restrictions is the Hanafi school, which requires removing parts of the body. That's it. Checkmate.
>>
>>18174567
That's Persian architecture. Not all Islamic architecture is like that.
>>
File: The_Court_of_Gayumars.jpg (2.56 MB, 2000x3037)
2.56 MB
2.56 MB JPG
>>18174373
>Where are the muslim waltzes, the muslim novels, the muslim movies?
Waltzes are a western art form. It's like asking why Germany never made manga. There's Islamic music. The novel was never popular in Muslim countries and poetry was always considered superior to prose. There's 1400 years of poetry in Arabic and 1000 years in Persian.

Movies? lol. Iranian cinema is fantastic and highly praised by cinephiles.
>>
>>18176029
>Movies? lol. Iranian cinema is fantastic and highly praised by cinephiles.
Any recommendations?
>>
File: The-Message.jpg (31 KB, 260x382)
31 KB
31 KB JPG
>>18174373
>muslim movies
I don't know much myself, but I do know of one that's like a Muhammad version of a Jesus movie (pic related).
>>
>>18176083
A Hero, A Separation, About Elly for minimalist, realistic portrayals of modern Iranian society / family which is what Iran is best known for.

Holy Spider was produced outside Iran but is kino so deserves a mention.
>>
>>18176098
Have you seen it? I have and it's pretty cringe, and it "conveniently" skips over a ton of embarrassing facts of the sunnah.
>>18176029
Arabic poetry, like the rest of islamic culture, is glorified gay smut.
>>
>>18176344
I NEED to write a paean to th sultan's handsome cupbearer, kuffar
>>
>>18174687
Ever noticed how muslims appeal to their emotion as their only "proof" of islam?
>It feels like God is talking directly to you
It literally doesn't. It feels like a narcissist is trying to brainwash you into hating your fellow human beings, and that's what happens with retards like you who hate humanity. You've found a "God" to your taste, suited to your level of moral degradation.
>>
>>18176363
I never claimed it was a proof for Islam, retard, I said it wasn't boring. There are many proofs for Islam.
>>
>>18176447
Please share them. If there are indeed proofs, any rational man would embrace Islam no?
>>
>>18176528
Just look it up yourself lol.
>>
>>18176533
I did and they were not convincing. Sorry bro, your religion is not "proven"
>>
>>18176543
Enjoy burning.
>>
>>18176623
What if you're wrong though?
>>
>>18167209
read hadith, mo is a pedophile
>>
>>18168842
>AL-JOOBULL BIN MAKMOOT SAID THAT MOST HADITH IN BOOKINI AND SPOOLINI ARE SANGRIA-ISHATTIE.

PLEASE READ UP ON DAOOF HADOOF

DOOF DOOF

>science
>>
>>18167209
stick to re-reading and don't get into the communal footsnifing. save yourself years of disappointment
>>
>>18176630
I'm not.
>>18177125
Aisha was lying to seem more pure/important. Simple as. She was probably 19 when she married, according to historical sources.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.