[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: a9x4wo.jpg (93 KB, 535x499)
93 KB
93 KB JPG
>"Islamic Golden Age"
>Looks inside
>Mostly just Arabic translations of earlier Greek, Latin, and Middle Persian works.
>The majority of intellectuals and thinkers were in their time accused of being heretics and apostates. Their reputation in the Islamic world was only redeemed by ironically European colonizers who took an interest in them.
>None of their discoveries and inventions were advanced upon (unlike Christian Europe where medieval scholasticism developed into the modern university system).
Also, the majority of intellectuals weren't even Arab. It was mostly Andalasians (Spanish Muslims) and Persians.

We don't give the Greco-Roman paganism credit for the accomplishments of the Greeks and Romans, so why would we give credit to Islam for the accomplishments of these scholars?
>>
>>18282817
>the majority of intellectuals weren't even Arab.
Why is that important?
>>
>>18282817
>"hurr durr it wasnt arabs"
YOU RETARDED FAGGOT
ITS THE ISLAMIC GOLDEN AGE
NOT THE ARABIC GOLDEN AGE YOU SUBHUMAN BRAINLET KEK
>also muh persians
Lmao
They where scientifically irrelevant before islam
I can agree on greco-roman texts but persians ?
Literally intellectually irrelevant before converting to islam and they based their civilisations on semites/afro asiatics anyway
>>
>>18282817
https://files.catbox.moe/fh7zoc.mp4


https://files.catbox.moe/3mmmgn.mp4


https://files.catbox.moe/hm04ow.mp4


https://files.catbox.moe/45oc9u.mp4


https://files.catbox.moe/y6h7cx.mp4


https://files.catbox.moe/j5sjt5.mp4


https://files.catbox.moe/0vhh7m.mp4
>>
>>18282819
>Why is that important?
Because of retarded Arab nationalists who unironically claim they were all Arab (Ba'athists)
>>18282829
>ITS THE ISLAMIC GOLDEN AGE
>NOT THE ARABIC GOLDEN AGE YOU SUBHUMAN BRAINLET KEK
Perhaps you didn't read the rest of what I said. The majority of intellectuals and thinkers were in their time accused of being heretics and apostates. Their reputation in the Islamic world was only redeemed by ironically European colonizers who took an interest in them. None of their discoveries and inventions were advanced upon (unlike Christian Europe where medieval scholasticism developed into the modern university system).
>They where scientifically irrelevant before islam
University of Gondishapur says hello, it mogged anything west of it. Of course I wouldn't expect you to know of it's existence since the majority of you muzzies are inbred (picrel).
>>
>>18282839
>Because of retarded Arab nationalists who unironically claim they were all Arab (Ba'athists)
And how does that relate to Islam at all?
>>
File: 1738489370233.jpg (339 KB, 1080x721)
339 KB
339 KB JPG
>>18282839
How Inbred must VOlga Tartars be, they have been Muslims for twice as long as Anatolian Turks.
>>
File: 1506705493601.jpg (18 KB, 324x324)
18 KB
18 KB JPG
>>18282872
I mean they look inbred so there is no reason not to assume so.
>>
Medieval Christians were themselves influenced by Islamic thinkers though, there's a reason we call him Averroes and not Ibn Rushd
>>
>>18282839
I know about gondishapur but it was small and basically the only thing intelectual in pre islamic persia
Greco-romans where intellectually superior by light years
>inbred
Funny you say this considering persians literally fucked their sisters
Go look up xwedoah
>>
You will never be accepted by Euroaches, Reza
>>
>>18282819
>>18282817
This is some kind of a wignat sperg thread, the brains of the Islamic golden age were Persian, the muscle was Turkic and the founders were Arap
>>
>>18282817
what a retarded post
>>
>>18282839
>Gondishapur
The entire city was settled by Arameans with its dominant being Syriac. The scholars living in Gondishapur were likewise Christian Arameans and unrelated to Persian incest babies.

White subhumans were barbaric trashes civilized by Semites.
>>
>>18282875
Islamic thinkers who were driven out, if not killed, by their fellow Muslims under the accusasions of heresy and atheism
>>
For me its the Protestant Golden Age aka the Industrial Revolution.
>>
>>18282817
>and middle persian
Name one
>>
OP is mostly right but also being unfair.

Arabs advanced alcohol distillation for example.
>>
Persians are arab
>>
>>18283157
Way less than the scientists killed by devil's of the spanish inquisition
>>
>>18283516
No but they are MENA and will never be europeans/white like they fantasize
In some case, they are as brown as fucking south asians
>>
File: Timur_reconstruction03.jpg (247 KB, 590x892)
247 KB
247 KB JPG
The funny thing is apart from Persia, there were probably more smarter people from Uzbekistan who contributed to the Golden Age than Arabs.

The same place that produced this guy btw. Yeah nomadic steppeniggers were somehow more intellectual
>>
>>18282817
Look inside this. Lead production fell to like 5k tons during that time.
>>
>>18282817
>"Islamic Golden Age"
>99% just being Mesopotamia
>>
>>18283526
Another retarded brainlet who think that islamic Golden age mean arabic Golden age
>>
>>18283522
Persia was intellectuality irrelevant before islam
>>
File: 1763344294498393.png (225 KB, 659x725)
225 KB
225 KB PNG
>>18283518
Never happened.
Spanuish Inquisition was about hunting down Jews who were pretending to be Christians in order to get government positions and subvert their country

Something that we desperately need right now

Scientific method was made by Franciscans
And science itself is the result of Christian efforts at banning all forms of magic
>>
>>18283649
Don't preach about tolerance if you have none.
The ottoman empire treated the balkans like kings compared to anything classic whites did
>>
>>18283649
>It never happened but they deserved it
Meanwhile the Islamic golden age has millions of dubious religious beliefs not being executed for subversion or whatever thought crimes a Soviet union lover wants.
>>
>>18283544
Zoroaster, Jamasp, Bubares, Borzuya, Tansar, Mazdak, etc say hello. Also, Greek philosophers like Pythagoras, Heraclitus, and Plato were heavily influenced by Zoroastrian ideas.

“Persia was intellectually bankrupt before Islam” is nothing more than an Islamist fanfic.
>>
File: Frieren kkk.jpg (432 KB, 2048x1677)
432 KB
432 KB JPG
>>18283708
Neither did Christians
Inquisition was a response to Jewish antics that are happening right now
Had the USA had an Inquisition, they won't have Epstein

>>18283702
Tolerance?
Buddy, the Ottomans welcomed the Jews that were driven away by Spain and Portugal
And the Turks soon realized why they were expelled
>>
Thread made by a Shah worshipping diasporat iranian btw
>>
>>18283732
You're right

Jews repayed Muslim tolerance to them with Zionism
>>
>>18283734
The shah did nothing wrong + the protestors in Iran trying to overthrow the government rn are literally chanting “javid shah.” So fuck off jeet
>>
>>18283732
The Ottoman empire was philojudaic af and arguably the early modern version of the US they literally sanctioned all of Italy because of muh joos
>>
>>18283732
>Neither did Christians
So why did you try to stamp out Gnosticism then?
>>
>>18283739
The shah was a pathetic western and zionist puppet illegaly installed by CIA glowies and shills who overthrew the righteous iranian PM (Mossadegh)
>>
>>18283743
He openly expressed his distain for Israel several times, he was anything but Zionist.

Also, Mossadegh was a former Qajar aristocrat who was salty about the Qajars being overthrown by Reza Shah. If anything the coup against Mossadegh was completely justified
>>
>>18282817
I never got this hadith,
you might as well say you saw the prophet take a piss at that point
>>
>>18282817
Most Turks have Greek DNA.
That's why Turks wanted to have AncestryDNA banned because they correctly identified them as Greeks.
"Ottoman" dishes were stolen from varied southern European cuisines as well.
>>
File: 1760407884793922.png (106 KB, 787x655)
106 KB
106 KB PNG
>>18282829
>>also muh persians
>Lmao
>They where scientifically irrelevant before islam
Greek philosophers were trained by Persian magi.
>>
>>18283758
Why is DNA testing banned in israhell??
>>
>>18283758
TURKS ARE ASIAN.
Turks share all dna with chinese people.
>>
>>18283766
They are not banned, just regulated. But cases such as this:
https://www.upi.com/Archives/1992/09/19/Forgery-ring-sold-fake-Jewish-documents-to-would-be-emigrants/9998716875200/
https://www.nzherald.co.nz/world/russian-firm-caught-selling-fake-jewish-identities/BN2RCEXRYERWP222XGDNXPR34E/
>>
>>18283742
Because it is a heresy and therefore a direct attack against the faith
Pagans were treated much better. In fact, the Church is directly responsible for the survival of their writtings to this day

Islam did the same with the Khawarij, Ahmadiyya, and of course, the Islamic thinkers who were accused of atheism
>>
>>18283522
You idiot, Tajiks are not the same thing as Timur.
>>
>>18283742
Gnosticism died out by itself mostly, as they saw sex as an evil thing most of gnostic sects died out due to dwindling populations.
>>
>>18283775
Gnosticism is the natural conclusion of Platonism though >>18283728
>>
File: 1753447420161975.gif (1.29 MB, 500x500)
1.29 MB
1.29 MB GIF
https://islamicwisdom.neocities.org/
>>
File: 1766767947779843.jpg (9 KB, 225x225)
9 KB
9 KB JPG
>>18284016
All heresies that the Church purged were properly tried, and presented proper arguments as to why they are wrong.

This is not a blind dogma, and the violence was withheld, and contained as much as possible

Tolerating heresies is exactly how you get scam cults like the Prosperity gospel, Jehovah's Witnesses, and Mormons
>>
>>18283734
>>18283737
>>18283740
>>18283743
>>18283766
Paki Bro W
>>
>>18283758
False on both accounts.
>dna testing banned
Nope, rumor spread by some butthurt losers.
>dishes stolen
Is that why all of them have Turkish names and even the Balkan copies of these dishes are just the Turkish name with a gay suffix on the end, Costas?

Amazing how no Turk ever actually diminished ancient Greek accomplishments but Greeks are unable to ever give credit for anything and keep stealing. Kind of like how you stole most of your philosophy from the Egyptians and the Persians, I suppose.
>>
>>18284580
I didn't say it was banned, I said Turks wanted to have it banned.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.