Hannibal Barca was berber and not pheonician
>>18288681>Hannibal belonged to this ethnicity that was made up in the 20th century
>>18288684>lybics didnt existProto berbers exist since 3500 years ago Why are a lot nafris so self hating and with inferiority complexIts not because kabyles or whatever are annoying and retarded that you must hate what you areIm not saying you must speak amazigh but what you saying is retarded>>18288681In blood ?Probably but culturaly, he was carthaginian/punic or just lybico-punic
>>18288681he was (North) Korean
>>18288681Why would a noble from the city of Carthage which was a Phoenician colony be the same ethnicity as semi nomadic people from the country?
>>18288681Probably a patrilinear Jew like all Punics, with admixture from random North African women his ancestors intermarried with.
>>18288815Most of the time it was punic princess and numidian princes >>18288807Assimilation over centuries
>>18288882>Assimilation over centuriesBut that never happened. Even in the Late Roman period there was still a clear delineation between Berbers and the settled peoples of North Africa. Carthage continuously looked to Phoenicia for more settlers and people to settle new cities in the region or join Carthage.
>>18288681>>18288684>>18288761If Juba II is to be trusted on stating that he descended from Hannibal via his mother, Hannibal was probably part of the faction of the Massylii tribe that married into Carthage due to the Massylii being their vassals.Calling Hannibal "Punic" then is a bit like saying the native Etruscans were Greek just because the founders of Rome were greeks that married into and took over the place.the founding myth of Carthage is that of Dido, Aeneas and Hiarbas. People often only focus on Dido and Aeneas, but Hiarbas was the native berber, and probably an ancestor of the Massylii/Masaesuli as these are the ONLY royalist berbers aside from mythic kings like Atlas which did not leave a royalist continuous tradition aside from a mythic memory of a time when there existed kings in he Atlas mountains.
Harry Paul Barker was English.
>>18289372Absolutely not retardThe difference between those two where only cultureThey where the ones who kept the old ways and the ones who assimilated to new culturesNafris are still mostly berber
>>18288761>This made up 20th century ethnicity is related to his Iron Age ethnicity because... it just OKAY. >>18288761>Why are a lot nafris so self hating and with inferiority complexWhy are you so rootless that you adopted a cumskin-made ethnicity AND so insecure you seek validation from us through adoption of said cumskin-made ethnicity
