What is the strongest case of a "Contradiction" in the bible?What is the strongest "Contradiction" that's between 2 Old Testament sources?What is the strongest "Contradiction" between 2 New Testament Sources?
>>18347691we're not gonna do your homework anon, google it
>>18347691I can give some examples, but what makes a contradiction stronger than another contradiction when a contradiction is a contradiction, does it cease to be such if someone can come up with some nonsensical resolution on the level of transubstantiation or something?Between Old and NewEye for an Eye becoming Turn the Other Cheek.Smiting Your Enemies becoming Loving Your Enemies.Old versus OldThe basic lineages and population census numbers often contradict, but people cope by saying some records are referring to actual numbers while others are legal numbers or something.New Versus NewMatthew says Judas hanged himself while Luke says he disemboweled himself, but some people cope by saying Luke left out the hanging part because it wasn't as important as him falling from his hanged position and busting his guts open somehow.
>>18347807>New Versus New>Matthew says Judas hanged himself while Luke says he disemboweled himself, but some people cope by saying Luke left out the hanging part because it wasn't as important as him falling from his hanged position and busting his guts open somehow.I've read that in old India, suicide by hanging was a common way of checking out and it wasn't unknown for them to botch it horribly and have these results (even without the rotting eventually causing this.) (Read British Raj accounts of India, we have primary eyewitness sources of a civilized culture encountering what was effectively an ancient pagan culture, and what they did. They're useful. Amazingly some of the habits creeping back into modern woke (heathen) culture are documented in them, like trannies living in polycules and weird abortion stuff.)
>>18347691How about the narrative contradiction where in Matthew Jesus has a "great secret" that the disciples must not expose, yet when John tells the exact same story and theres no secret, and Jesus is in the streets saying "I am" to everyone.Honestly don't see how christians read John and don't say "some of this has to be bullshit". John is pure evangelism with no attempt to tell events accurately.
>>18347817>it wasn't unknown for them to botch it horribly and have these resultsSo why wouldn't the text mention that it was a botched hanging, why would he fell headlong instead of he hanged himself? And how exactly do you disembowel yourself in a botched hanging, he hung himself by the waist instead of the neck?This is the exact type of nonsense I am talking about though, how is it possible to even point out a contradiction when people can invoke magic to settle any possible contradiction?
>>18347830>So why wouldn't the text mention that it was a botched hanging, why would he fell headlong instead of he hanged himself? And how exactly do you disembowel yourself in a botched hanging, he hung himself by the waist instead of the neck?I don't remember the exact source, but I believe it involved either falling before the noose was properly set or maybe the length of the rope. There have been botched hanging executions in modern times which I regret googling.Either way, bodies rot. It would eventually happen if not immediately.
>>18347841>I don't remember the exact source, but I believe it involved either falling before the noose was properly set or maybe the length of the rope.Not in these accounts, it doesn't say anything about a hanging in luke, it just says he fell headlong in his field and his intestines burst open and in matthew it doesn't say anything about his intestines bursting open, only that he was filled with guilt and hanged himself.>There have been botched hanging executions in modern times which I regret googling.Those result in broken necks and dismembered heads, not disembowelment.>It would eventually happen if not immediately.It wasn't posed as an eventuality in luke it just says he fell and burst open, not the he fell and nobody noticed until weeks later when they found him burst open as you seem to suggest.You ever think that maybe you should actually read the sources and familiarize yourself with them before you start commenting on them in ignorance or nah you like being embarrassed because of the humiliation fetish?
>>18347849Also, matthew has judas returning the silver he got for betraying jesus before killing himself on purpose, while luke has him buying a field and spontaneously dying in it, the accounts are incredibly contradictory.
