[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: sddefault.jpg (38 KB, 640x480)
38 KB
38 KB JPG
Where did he disappear to?
>>
>>18420029
Is this the guy who convinced libertarians that Nazism was a leftist ideology because the state did things?
>>
>>18420031
and he was correct
>>
>>18420029
He said no no words behind UK government.

Nazis have last laugh.
>>
>>18420101
state is always wrong if it has to enforce taxation over a random individual
>>
>>18420029
Either dead or in prison. He was a bong who dared to criticize the government over there so he might've been jailed and put into prison for that.

Quite the shame because I liked his battlestorm series of videos. Very informative.
>>
>>18420031
>>18420031
I think the just used Nazi quotes from actual nazi leaders, such as hitler himself who said that they were leftist and that national socialism was inherently leftist.

"B--B--But 80 years of marxist academics told us that he was an evil conservative"

If Hitler was a true right wing conservative or restoration, he would have restored the Kaiser and reduced the size of the state. But he didn't because he was a revolutionary Utopianist, which are inherently left wing views.

BTW before retards reply.
Right wing = conservative/ traditionalist/ retorationist

Left wing = progressive, revolutionary, disestablishment of traditions.

Remember the the Nazis changed the way Germans said hello to each other. lol.
>>
>>18420029
Rapture
>>
>>18420029
btfo'd all the leftists five times over, left no survivors, and retired.
>>
>>18421108
leftists in question btw:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZmInkxbvlCs
>>
>>18421095
LOL
>>
>>18420114
They were in coalition with DNVP and not the SD, they were de facto right wing.
>>
>>18420031
His rationale was a lot more in depth than that, but you knew that already, prick.
>>
>>18420103
how does that make it leftist?

>>18420101
No he wasnt.
>>
>>18421122
Does practicality cancel out ideology?
>>
>>18420031
all the stans are gibsbros this year
>>
>>18420031
Left, right, who gives a fuck? The important thing is the Nazis were correct.
>>
>>18421234
correct in getting raped
>>
>>18421236
You need shemale correction
>>
>>18420114
>>18421122
>>18421203


I'm convinced the political spectrum doesn't make sense anymore because people have their own custom understanding of it.

Some think right-wing means monarchy, others know right-wing means republican liberalism.
>>
>>18420029
>Sloptuber
Go back to r*ddit
>>
>>18421314
DING DING DING DING DING
>>
>>18421314
>doesn't make sense anymore
>anymore
>>
>>18420029
Is he also some kind of christian larper? He uses gnosticism as his boogeyman. He also claimed that racism is a form of socialism somehow.
>>
The whole “Nazis weren’t left wing” thjng relies entirely on a very specific niche academic analysis that’s dominated by leftists

Same as Mussolini’s actual initial fascist thinkings, the root of fascism was to resolve the class divide in a war different to communism but still bringing in much needed reforms.

All the caveats given to explain how the Nazis weren’t REALLY “left wing” economically always have obvious outs. Like

>they privatised X company!

Yeah, and then made a condition of it being that they solely do government contracts set at non negotiable prices, use slave Labour provided by the government, and have their board staffed with a bunch of state party loyalists. TRVE CAPITALISM

Also just look at the evolution of the pre Nazi party fascists, the early Nazi party rhetoric under dresser into hitlers campaigning. Economically it was about addressing the issues communists raised, while assuaging the elites that they weren’t going to just execute them like commies

If anything I’d say that’s a major difference between fascism and communism, communism requires a full revolution and overhaul of the system while Mussolini and Hitler largely used the system as intended to destroy it and subvert it into an instrument that worked for them, even if this meant existing elites stayed (king and aristocrats in Italy, old Prussian nobility in Germany, wealthy capitalists in both)
>>
Marx didn't invent socialism.
>>
>>18421354
It was a regulated form of capitalism but still capitalism.
>>
>>18421375
Nonsense. Capital was under full control of the Workers Party (aka proletariat) kek. It's not capitalists' fault that your dream system doesn't deliver; anywhere in the world.
>>
>>18421370

Step by step, 1+1...


Q: What did the French Revolution achieve?
A: Turning France from absolutism to consistorialism form of socio-political organization, disempowering [feudal] land nobility & empowering enterprisers & guilds, traders & merchants, artisans, and labor.

Q: What does socialism & communism achieve?
A: Monopolizing everything within & under the political party & state apparatus, enforced by police & military designed to serve the political party members than everyone else.


Again, step by step, 1+1... Why do socialists & communists advocate for refeudalization of the very same entities that sought liberty from feudal [old] world order, that – unmistakingly – appear to empower again the nobility holders, now conveniently designated as “the party”, respectively secret police & military officers?
>>
>>18420031
I like how this simple yet correct statement indefinitely buck broke leftists, that they are still seething about it to this day.
Still zero arguments proving him wrong to this day btw.
>>
>>18421470
More like it made rightoids seethe because they believe leftism=gayniggerjews and therefore associating Hitler with leftism was a grave insult.
>>
File: hes-not-amused.jpg (1.55 MB, 3472x4624)
1.55 MB
1.55 MB JPG
>>18420029
>be TIK:
>"theres this small group/religion that secretly controls the world, they created communism/nazism/Israel and want to make all non-members into slaves... ...and that group is called: the gnostics"
>"WHAT DO YOU MEAN I'M DESCRBING THE JEWS!!!!
>"UR AN ANTI-SEMITIC BIGOT REEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!
This guy refuses to call out the Jew and tries to pin Jewish traits on other groups, so I don't trust anything he says.
>>
>>18421867
>when I point out that the elites are mostly Jewish, it's just pattern recognition
>NO YOU CANT POINT OUT THAT THEY'RE ALSO ALL BILLIONAIRES REEEES THAT DOESN'T COUNT
>>
>>18421329
Eric Voeglin invented that concept about 70 years ago. I suggest you try not to be illiterate. I like Voeglin because he makes tankies seethe.
>>
>>18420114
>he would have restored the Kaiser and reduced the size of the state
What?
>>
>>18421329
>racism is a form of socialism
Firstly, modern racism is collectivism and secondly the first trade unions (at times when racism wasn't yet outright illegal) were purely racist as they protected white workers against blackfaces willing to work for lower wages.
Listen faggots, the guy is an ancap and ancaps don't have a horse in this race as we are neither left nor right so we just say it as we see it. We call BS whenever we encounter it. Personally I am also agnostic and I just watch theists-atheists quarrels with amusement. The faction which holds the political power usually bullshits the most; historically it was the religious right, currently it is the atheist left.
Truth will set you free guys.
>>
>>18420114
Didn't the Kaiser have a fairly powerful state?
>>
>>18422720
It was authoritarian, but by far not as centralised as the Third Reich. Individuall German states had more significant liberties to the point where some parts of the German Military were basically semi-autonomous and only placed under Prussian command in war time (Bavaria, Saxony, Württemberg). It was basically a modernised Feudal state
>>
>>18422199
>Eric Voegelin an anti-racist faggot who decided to call everyone he dislikes gnostic
>On /pol/ he is mostly mentioned by a brazilian macaco
>https://archive.4plebs.org/_/search/text/%22Eric%20Voegelin%22/
>On /int/ he is also mostly mentioned by a brazilian macaco
>https://desuarchive.org/_/search/text/%22Eric%20Voegelin%22/
I see a pattern.
>>
>>18422747
Hilter was followed many mistakes repeating the Great War.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.