[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: The_Book _of_Jonah.jpg (285 KB, 1152x2048)
285 KB JPG
Isn't the universalist message of the Book of Jonah kind of odd given its age (estimated 6c.BC - Hellenic period)?
God in the Old Testament seems to be rather this 'proto-nationlistic' tribal God of Israel which only Jews are allowed to worship and suddenly we've got this story where Ninevaians are spared because they had shown humility.
>>
>>18445518
I love this comic. It's so cool how instead of getting jobs or having sex you play with your little dolls to convey stories. You're like the icon writers of the 21st century.
>>
>>18445518
Noah wasnt a jew as you are defining it
>>
>>18445518
Jonah is a cope. Considering how evil the Assyrians are they wanted to understand why God didn't destroy them.
>>
Biologically speaking I don't believe a human could survive inside the belly of a whale for 3 whole days and nights...
>>
>>18445529
Also, this book is obvious fiction because there’s literally evidence to suggest that Ninevah ever converted to Judaism at any point and in reality, they still continued to worship their native gods up until the Christianization of the Assyrians in the 2nd to 3rd century AD. There’s also the fact that Assyria remained “wicked” even after they supposedly “repented” as Ashurbanipal, the most brutal Assyrian king, lived long after Jonah.
>>
>>18445518
No, because you’re mistakenly assuming God does not exist instead of recognizing the scriptures as the self-revelation of the unchanging eternal God.
>>
>>18445539
I’m honestly shocked and even a little horrified that the Jews would lie about what happened to them and about what their enemies did. That’s sick. Good thing they kicked that habit a long time ago.
>>
>>18445539
The book does not claim they converted to Judaism, Anon…
>>
>>18445546
Then what did they repent of? Now the story feels like a bunch of priests telling the Jews how much they suck because even the Assyrians (read:Nazis) repented when they heard Yahweh’s warnings.
>>
>>18445539
There's also 0 evidence that Moses ever existed or great that numbers of Jews were enslaved in Egypt or that there was an exodus, despite thousands of years of Jews, Christians and Muslims desperately searching for proofs.
>>
>>18445549
They repented of a particular sin of that time, and only it. We read nothing of the Assyrians turning away from their gods or embracing the laws of Judaism, only a single repentance of a particular sin. It is very strangely written if the author’s intent is to tell us the Assyrians converted to Judaism.
>>
>>18445533
I heard that some 18-century monk theorised that Jonah spent these 3 days in some taproom drinking there.
>>
File: the_holy_bible.jpg (3.2 MB, 2298x2297)
3.2 MB JPG
>>18445550
>0 evidence
>>
>>18445569
Why would the Assyrians listen to a rambling Canaanite anyway? Repent of what? It implies not only was there a Law of Moses at the time of Jonah but that the Assyrians knew what it demanded.
>>
>>18445571
I mean the book of Jonah compares the inside of the fish's belly to Sheol, so maybe it was just a metaphor for being away from God or something
>>
>>18445574
Jonah wasn’t a Canaanite, there was a law of Moses at the time, and the distinct evils of the Assyrians are well known to this day.
>>
>>18445573
Fifth hand accounts of mythological tales which use circular reasoning isn't evidence or else we could equally claim every religion is true based on its myths
>>
>>18445573
>not KJV
to the trash it goes
>>
>>18445571
>>18445576
That’s unbelief, Jonah ends up in the fish’s belly by being thrown overboard from a ship and the fish carries him to the coast where it spits him onto land. This metaphorical interpretation is impossible. The only reason to doubt the story is if you believe there is no God and therefore miracles could not happen.
>>
>>18445579
Moses isn’t real, and the real Jonah was a Canaanite court prophet serving the Omrides.
>>
>>18445539
>>18445543
>>18445546
>>18445550
>Also, this book is obvious fiction because there’s literally evidence to suggest that Ninevah ever converted to Judaism at any point
Meant to say “literally no evidence” not “literally evidence,” mb.
>>
>>18445580
I agree, that’s why I reject the atheist religion and its evolution myth.
>>
>>18445585
Incorrect
>>
>>18445584
Complete Biblical literalism is a very niche and not widely respected position. You won't find anyone who agrees with you outside of Appalachia, the Deep South, or Sub-Saharan Africa.
>>
>>18445587
Do you also believe the world is flat and 6000 years old and orbited by the Sun?
>>
>>18445589
Absolutely correct. But as long as the religion makes you a better person I’d rather you believe otherwise.
>>
>>18445595
By “complete biblical literalism” you mean orthodoxy, belief in God. If you think your appeal to the wisdom of the world will persuade me you are a fool. I have brethren across the world who have not bent the knee to Baal.
>>
>>18445599
Better person? What’s that mean? If there’s no God then there’s nothing wrong with killing women and children in the street so I think you just borrowed my worldview.
>>18445598
The world is about 6,000 years old.
>>
>>18445602
You proved my point. Keep believing in the Bible, you psychopath.
>>
>>18445601
Your fundementalist, literalist, double Calvinist interpretation of Christianity wasn't even invented until the 18th century.
Before then everyone understood what a metaphor was. Then retards like you started surviving past infancy due to technological progress.
As the leading Early Christian scholar Origen of Alexandria wrote:
>“Who is so silly as to believe that God planted a paradise eastward in Eden, and set in it a visible and palpable tree of life and anyone who tasted its fruit with his bodily teeth would gain life?”
It appears the intelligence of Christians has only declined since the religion was first practiced.
>>
>>18445573
A jewish history book that has had multiple edits over millennia, plagiarized the Enuma Elish scribed on clay tablets, 4000 years before the bible and that has had 0 edits.
>>
>>18445602
>The world is about 6,000 years old.
We have evidence of human activity from 360,000 years ago. 60x longer ago than you believe the universe has existed for.
How do you explain dinosaurs? Or geology? Or astronomy?
>>
>>18445605
God bless you.
>>18445607
This is historically false, and it’s telling that you can only cite Origen, the condemned, highly unorthodox heretic as an antecedent for your syncretism. It is highly dishonest for you to cast your re-interpretation as “knowing what a metaphor is”, when you have no exegetical argument nor was your novel interpretation known for thousands of years of history. What you meant to say is that the meaning of the text is literal, but you don’t believe it because you are a syncretist with the atheist religion, a cultist of Baal, so you rewrite the text and willfully corrupt the scripture like your father the devil.
>>18445610
Incorrect
>>18445612
You have evidence of human activity but it’s not that old. All those other things are testimonies to the power of God.
>>
>>18445622
Imagine writing all this bullshit at 9 am on a weekday

Whewlad
>>
i hate sharing a board with mentally ill boomers
>>
>>18445666
Nice digits, infidel. Do you think your jokes will be as funny when the devil is cutting the flesh off your bones with a hot knife in hell, reciting each one of your "clever" little quips to you, again and again and again?
>>
>>18445522
It must suck being able to only do one thing or another for you. Try getting more hobbies and interests
>>
>>18445723
the devil is an invention of herodian jews
>>
>>18445539
wait until you read about the rest of bibble



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.