[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 1759430428544.jpg (27 KB, 287x346)
27 KB JPG
What if in the mid-1990's, in the fallout of the Soviet collapse, an elite force of highly trained American soldiers is deployed by the US military into Tartarstan to eliminate Islamic extremism in the region.

These brave soldiers would parachute in and engage in CQC in the mosques where the cowardly Tartar women and children hide, eliminating the mosque with tactical detonaters, their work not complete until the entire city of Kazan is purged of anti-western forces...

The soldiers would continue the battle in the countryside, White, Hispanic, and Black soldiers learn comradery as they pop Tartar communist gooks in the head and set aside their differences to take down the radical tartar forces, showcasing the superiority of Western democracy against Asiatic despotism.
https://youtu.be/9HJcjmCYMCM?si=oI_LX7VFscigsUYC
>>
bump
>>
bump
>>
What if Austria-Hungary have right timing invaded Serbia in 1905 (Russia preoccupy with Japan) or 1909 (Russia back down after bosnia crisis)?
>>
>>18457676
What if the Soviet Union didn't give away Xinjiang
>>
>>18457676
What if Soviet-Japanese sign a nongression pact in 1932-33?
>>
What if East Germany didn't unify with the West but form new state called Brandenburg-Pomerania with Berlin merging as new capital?
>>
>>18457676
What if Scandinavia somehow avoided Christianization and remained as the last bastion of paganism in Europe?
>>
>>18457676
>gooks
Soviet state did have Korean immigrant.
>>
>>18459055
Isolated and position in bad economically
>>
>>18459055
I cast… CRUSADE!
>>
>>18459053
The official flag is kino Reichskriegsflagge.
>>
>>18457676
What if Earth had an advanced intelligent futanari elf race that evolved from pseudo synapsids-like monkeys/bandicoots during the late Jurassic to mid-Cretaceous period and established early civilizations in the Paleogene period?
>>
What if OP and anon kiss?
>>
>>18459181
>Late Jurassic (160–145 mya)
Proto‑Aelonar: gliding pseudo‑synapsid mammals

Nocturnal, social, arboreal

>Early Cretaceous (145–100 mya)
Increased intelligence

Early tool use

Complex vocal communication

>Late Cretaceous (100–66 mya)
Proto‑elves emerge

Survive K–Pg extinction

>Paleocene (66–56 mya)
Rapid radiation

First stone tools

Clan structures form

>Eocene (56–34 mya)
Canopy megacities

Copper Age

Writing systems

Maritime exploration

Antarctic civilizations flourish

>Oligocene (34–23 mya)
Bronze Age

Continental trade networks

Early philosophy and astronomy

First large‑scale states

>Miocene (23–5 mya)
Global cultural divergence

Domestication of megafauna

Maritime empires

Desert and tundra cultures emerge

>Pliocene (5–2.5 mya)
Climate cooling

Migration waves

Rise of highland and desert civilizations

>Pleistocene (2.5 mya–10,000 BCE)
Ice Age adaptations

Glacial migrations

Bronze metallurgy becomes universal

Other intelligent species (corvids, cetaceans, rodents) reach proto‑sapience

>Holocene (10,000–2000 BCE)
Agricultural revolutions

Monumental architecture

Global diplomacy

Maritime circumnavigation

By 2000 BCE:

Dozens of major elven civilizations

No humans anywhere

Earth fully shaped by Aelonar (high-elves culture)
>>
>>18459517
>No humans anywhere: only elves and other intelligent species

>Asia and Pacific islands — The Cradle
First cities in Eocene canopy forests

Bronze‑age river kingdoms

Philosophy schools: Memory, Harmony, and Pattern

Early astronomy and mathematics

Maritime expansion into Pacific and Indian Oceans

>Africa — The Rift Kingdoms
Savanna‑adapted clans

Domestication of giant Paleogene herbivores

Stone‑fungal hybrid architecture

Rift Valley city‑states become centers of metallurgy

Deserti subspecies evolve in Sahara and Arabia

>North America — The Redwood Realms
Forest‑canopy civilizations

Plains mound‑builders

Pacific whistled‑language cultures

Domestication of glider‑cats and thunder‑hoof ungulates

Bronze‑age trade routes across the Rockies

>South America — The Green Empires
Jungle ziggurat cities

Terror‑bird domestication

Botanical science centers

River empires along proto‑Amazon

Highland cultures in Andes (montanis subspecies)

>Europe — The Stone‑Fungus Kingdoms
Cold‑forest clans

Megalithic fungal‑stone monuments

Bronze‑age trade hubs

Early metallurgy schools

Maritime cultures in Mediterranean forests

>Australia — The Fire‑Oasis Cultures
Desert‑oasis kingdoms

Marsupial megafauna symbiosis

Click‑whistle hybrid languages

Fire‑ecology mastery

Bronze‑age coastal navigators

>Antarctica — The Lost Southern Homeland
Warm Eocene forests

Abandoned as continent froze

Mythic origin of many religions

Ruins preserved under ice.
>>
File: GFj2_VdaQAAdNob.jpg (102 KB, 828x1026)
102 KB JPG
>>18457676
What if Leonid Brezhnev lookmaxxed? How would this affect the dynamics of the Cold War?
>>
What if Hideki Tojo accepted the Hull note?
>>
Had he been willing to compromise on the adoption of the tricolor flag, the Legitimists would likely have secured a victory in the 1873 grand assembly.

What if the French designed the swastika on white royalty background and use it as national anthem as well political responsibility.
>>
>>18457676
What if Hideyoshi conquest of Korea successfully.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cAoinrFMgQ0
>>
>>18457676
What if the Hanseatic League had managed to stabilise their hold on the Baltic states, and grown their fishing and shipping industries to the point where they become a permanent fixture in Eastern Europe?
>>
>>18457676
>cool story bro
>>
>>18457676
The real academic term is counterfactual history but I'll bite.

My scenario: Ataturk gets killed in the Balkan Wars. What happens?
>>
>>18460032
Is this viable?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alldutch_Movement
>>
>>18459181
This post is 106 IQ
>>
File: entente power lost.jpg (162 KB, 1600x1440)
162 KB JPG
Buttrape by the Treaty of Sèvres
>>
>>18457889
>>18458276
bumping won't make you win Vietnam, us bro
>>
>>18459053
>BERLIN UNDER “ONE CAPITAL, TWO SYSTEMS”
Berlin becomes the jewel of the republic.

>East Berlin – Government Core
Houses the presidency, parliament, ministries

Traditional civil‑service structure

State‑run media and national archives

Strict zoning to preserve historic GDR and Prussian buildings

>West Berlin – Autonomous Economic Zone
Separate tax system

Independent municipal courts

Special visa rules for foreign investors

Tech, media, and creative industries cluster here

More liberal social policies

>Unified Institutions
Police and emergency services

Transportation network

Education accreditation

Cultural heritage board

Outcome
Berlin becomes a hybrid of:

Vienna’s imperial culture

Hong Kong’s dual‑system economics

Prague’s creative energy
>>
File: Best. Boner. Ever..gif (930 KB, 448x252)
930 KB GIF
>>18460368
Viable or not it's got me rock hard
>>
>>18457676
What if Aegon I Targaryen, his sister-wife Rhaenys and one third of royal army (included few lords, sellsword and settler) transported to America, 1066 AD?
>>
File: yomi-boudica [fate-go].jpg (977 KB, 1450x2400)
977 KB JPG
What if Boudica of the Iceni was militarily capable in shieldwall and pre-modern guerrilla warfare, learning from captured auxiliary commanders, proclaiming herself Queen in London, and using it as a logistical hub instead of sacking the city.
>>
I wish my boy, Totila, had won and brought back Gothic Rome from those eastern tyrants.
>>
>>18460387
Thats what comfort women are for, Chang
>>
>>18461133
>Building a Fleet Later On
Takeaway: A native British fleet is plausible and strategically devastating.

Why a fleet matters:
Rome relied on sea supply lines to reinforce Britain.

A British fleet could:

- Intercept transports
- Raid Roman coastal forts
- Block reinforcements from Gaul
- Control the Thames and eastern coast

This forces Rome to commit far more resources to Britain than historically.

>5. How the War Changes
Scenario: Boudica holds London and fights a defensive war
Rome cannot easily retake a fortified, populated London without a full legionary siege.

The governor, Suetonius Paulinus, is cut off from the richest part of the province.

Tribes on the fence (Brigantes, Dobunni, Atrebates) may join her once she looks gaining a stable power.

Rome’s response becomes slower and more expensive. Reinforcements must come from Gaul or even the Rhine frontier. Nero, already politically unstable, may hesitate to pour more legions into a costly quagmire. A negotiated settlement becomes possible, Rome sometimes accepted client‑kings when direct rule became too expensive.

A stabilized, fortified, diplomatically savvy Boudican kingdom could become:

A semi‑independent British client state, or buffer kingdom like Armenia or Mauretania.
>>
File: Julius Civilis.png (1.6 MB, 1024x745)
1.6 MB PNG
>>18461133
Tributes and customs duties from merchants utilizing the Thames, along with access to continental iron, timber, and horses, were all vital for prolonged warfare. This also provided diplomatic leverage with tribes who harbored resentment towards Roman taxation in Gaul.

The significance of this lies in Rome's primary advantage: its consistent ability to compensate its troops. If Boudica could achieve the same, she would transition from being a rebel to a sovereign.
>>
>>18461243
The Batavians: Rome's Most Formidable (Worst) Allies

The Batavians were recognized for their exceptional military prowess:

* Elite auxiliary troops
* Outstanding swimmers and river combatants
* Accomplished horsemen
* Possessing a strong sense of independence

Notably, they led a significant rebellion in 69–70 CE under Julius Civilis.

Consider the hypothetical scenario if Boudica's uprising in 60–61 CE had established a lasting kingdom:

* The Batavians would have observed a thriving anti-Roman state across the Channel.
* This would have provided them with a secure haven for diplomatic relations, commerce, and strategic collaboration.
* Their rebellion would no longer have been an isolated event, but rather a coordinated effort between German and British allies.

Such a situation would have presented Rome with a critical two-front crisis:

* Britain in the west
* The Lower Rhine in the east

Historically, Rome faced considerable challenges with a single Batavian revolt. The simultaneous occurrence of two such rebellions would undoubtedly have had devastating consequences.
>>
>>18461248
>How Boudica Could Attract Batavian Mercenaries
This does not necessitate contemporary logistics, but rather political acumen. Her potential offerings include: gold and merchandise from London's trade, hostages and marital alliances with Germanic elites, and a pledge of reciprocal recognition: "Should you assist me now, I shall uphold your autonomy in the future."

The Batavians contribute: professional infantry, cavalry proficient in countering Roman horsemen, riverine experts for the Thames and North Sea, and officers trained by the Romans. This represents the closest approximation Boudica could achieve to a proto-legion and able cut Roman network of road.

>Opening a Second Front Against Rome
This scenario presents a significant threat to the Empire. Should the Batavians align with Boudica, several critical consequences could ensue:
Roman fortifications along the Rhine would face direct assault. The movement of troops from Germania to Britain would be severely impeded. Rome would be compelled to reallocate legions from Britain. This alliance could also incite other tribes, such as the Frisians, Chauci, and Cananefates, to participate in the conflict.

Rome's frontier system relies on swift reinforcement. Should both the Rhine and Britain face simultaneous crises, that system would unfortunately falter.
>>
>>18461133
I asked Gemini a similar question about Nero and her
>>
>>18461301
Must be Xbox games
>>
>>18457676
What if women wanted to have sex with me and I weren't a virgin?
>>
>>18461301
Boudica wouldn't just be a martyr; she’d be the founder of a Celto-Romanic (some Greek) state.

By adopting Roman logistics and military discipline, and continental Germani allies while retaining the fierce independence of the tribes, her kingdom would likely resemble the later "Gallic Empire." London would remain the capital, but instead of a Roman outpost, it would be the heart of a maritime power that controlled the Channel long before the Anglo-Saxon and Vikings (Norse) ever set sail.

Do you think the other tribes, like the Brigantes in the North, would have stayed loyal to her "New London" government, or would they have feared her power as much as they feared Rome's?



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.