If Indo-Aryan migrations from Central Asia to South Asia is 2000 BC is an undisputed factual event that is accepted by all mainstream academics and historians. Where are all these historians on YouTube? All I see when I search for the subject are Indians talking about how it's a lie (out of India/indigenous Aryanism) One of the few "serious" defenders I was able to find is a guy named Survive The Jive who is apparently a "racist" so he's not considered a valid defender of the topic. Isn't it the responsibility of historians to fight bad history? Why are they so oddly quiet on this topic despite claiming they're right?
read papers, not tiktoks
>>18465042>Why are they so oddly quiet on this topic despite claiming they're right?Because there's no way to defend it without "looking like a racist". "Oh look it's a white guy claiming Aryans gave India their language, culture, and religion".
>>18465042Survive the LARP is a neopagan without relevance beyond its followers; it shouldn't be used as an example of anything. We have good evidence that at least there was a migration, and a new article, still under review, revealed something quite interesting:There are nuances, as with everything in life, but at this point it's undeniable that there was a strong cline between North and South, and David Reich himself, in a recent podcast, linked this to the caste system. We just lack more samples, but there is a clear dispersal of ancient Europeans in places as remote as Tajikistan, and some funerary evidence and Indo-European material culture in South as Balochistan
>>18465042ā́rya- (Skt.) has no definite reconstruction going beyond Proto-Indo-Iranian Áryas-, *heryos- is untenable, and even if one were able to prove it and the reconstructed cognates, the onus is on them to prove that they were used as ethno-cultural self-designations historically.
>>18465384>ā́rya- (Skt.) has no definite reconstruction going beyond Proto-Indo-Iranian Áryas-, *heryos-You are wrong but the least you could do is get the Proto-Indo-Iranian reconstruction right.The word was loaned into Elamite. We know for a fact it was *Háryas and not *Áryas.Elamite ḫar-ri-ya-na-um /Ḫariyanaum/https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/Reconstruction:Proto-Iranian/%C3%81ry%C4%81naHm
>>18465042>if thing is true, why no video essayJesus christ...
>>18465389It's a Twitter account, anon, no joke. I knew you'd show upYou could reply there and take the opportunity to create a profile with these linguistic schizophrenias. There's some kind of fever of people repeating the same thing, especially Indians. Go there and refute them all. We're counting on you.
>>18465042The quick kill on this is indians have an R1a clade who's ancestor was found running around Belarus 4500 years ago and indians speak a language that didnt originate in India, the oldest version of this language is from Europe.There is no kind way to say "youre the product of a man from Europe who didnt look like you having lots of sex with women who did look like you".indians being unbelievably arrogant will do literally anything but accept reality.
>>18465455Lol that's true >muh Christianity
>>18465455Arguing on Twitter is such a waste of time. I'd rather write a research paper.
>>18465493If you have the credentials, why not? Actually, there's no need to debate; just creating a few threads there would be helpful, and if it's not wrong, I'll copy and paste your posts there, okay?
>>18465466Indians will do mental gymanstics to say that R1a Belarus guy "originally" came from India somehow. Or the haplogroup before him did.
>>18465572I can charge, not much, about 100 dollars via PayPal will be enough And you won't be able to refute everyone on Twitter; there are many renowned Dravian academics like Mr. Razib, we agree more than we disagree, especially about Christians
>>18465572If you had an ideal linguistics paper covering a narrowly defined topic at your disposal, what would it be about?Just curious.
>>18465574This is a troll. I don't ask for money. Also this guy doesn't have access to my email address which you can use if you need to tell me something privately.
>>18465576I think it depends on the subject. Comparative mythology relies quite heavily on linguistics, if not primarily on linguistics. In the case of the "Aryan" question, we would have to be extremely cautious. I think an entire session could be devoted to discussing whether this statement can be addressed academically and formally without including "Nazism." Not that I'm particularly a "libtard," but academia wouldn't approve a paper that simply talks about "Aryan." I looked at your posts and those of other guys on desuarchive.org and a lot was discussed here and there's a lot of useful information besides >h2ér-yo as I said, there's a lot of misinformation on Twitter. so if you see your posts pasted there, it's me
>>18465582Ok going to create my account
>>18465851No, I am not going to create my account.If I am wanted on Twitter why doesn't someone link to an interesting Twitter post. Do you think I will read Twitter otherwise?
>>18465875Yes, you will create the account.
>>18465042>poopjeetshttp://www.google.com/search?q=toilet+witches+indiahttp://www.google.com/search?q=codex+pajeethttp://www.amazon.in/s?k=cow+dung+cakeshttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c2Pi4-zWJTg
