The general thread for Manga / manga-styled comic-making, manga-style illustration and related comic work. That said, everyone is welcome here.Support each other and talk about your work or the work of others that excites you. Inking, character design, paneling / layout, writing, planning, and other discussions are all welcome.Post resources, questions, in-progress pages, breakdowns of other works, etc. If a work is not yours, credit the maker (unless it's fucking obvious like a full page of One Piece or something).Thanks to everyone for making /mmg/ a level-headed and helpful place. Remember, drawing and making comics and manga are difficult endeavors, and we're all in this struggle together.Previous thread: >>8072652Some resources:/asg/, our stylistic sister-thread series for those focused more on illustration >>>/ic/asgBooks:Understanding Comicshttps://e-hentai.org/g/2042453/83e7da6ed0/Making Comicshttps://annas-archive.org/md5/d55168f7579c1e23275d1fc9f0a2255dManga in Theory and Practice: The Craft of Creating Mangahttps://annas-archive.org/md5/2877da11e2f852d220853e9944e6ea49Story: Substance, Structure, Style and the Principles of Screenwritinghttps://archive.org/details/RobertMcKeeStorypdf/Even a Monkey Can Draw Mangahttps://kupdf.net/download/even-a-monkey-can-draw-manga_58b9ca16e12e89233badd376_pdfThe Shonen Jump Guide to Making Mangahttps://mega.nz/file/i81imLpI#GcheJ9Jjk3lw1RE9nQWgL4RG4wEBNOcRmgA-iaU6WpgVideos:"Manga Senpai/Tokyo Name Tank", "SMAC! THE SILENT MANGA AUDITION COMMUNITY"Habanero Scans: https://www.dailymotion.com/HabaneroScans/videosManben link can be found on archive.org on different pages separated by season: https://www.reddit.com/r/manga/comments/1bu9f0y/found_all_of_naoki_urasawas_manben_and_manben_neo/Urasawa Channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCkIFOAoFm47XOAlJwTa6Ieg/videosOP image is from The Valiant Must Fall.
>>8080457Other open comic publishers:Dark Horse ( https://www.darkhorse.com )>Dark Horse still welcomes your submissions, and all submissions will still be reviewed, just as they always have been.>All unsolicited story/series proposals must have a full creative team on board. Writer-only proposals will not be reviewed.Image comics ( https://imagecomics.com/ )>Image Comics only publishes creator-owned material. They do not contract creators; they’re only interested in publishing original content for which you would retain all rights.>Image Comics publishes creator-owned/creator-generated properties and THEY DON’T PAY PAGE RATES. Image takes a small flat fee off the books published, and it will be the responsibility of the creators to determine the division of the remaining pay between their creative team members.Drawn and quarterly ( https://drawnandquarterly.com/ )>Please email a low resolution PDF with at least 20 pages of comics and cover letter to submissions. Do not send dropbox links, scripts, or proposals. Please read our submissions FAQ.Fantagraphics ( https://www.fantagraphics.com/ )>submission page: https://www.fantagraphics.com/pages/faqTop Shelf Productions ( https://www.topshelfcomix.com/ )>Regarding submissions, we're easy. Just email us a download link of what you'd like us to review. NOTE: We cannot accept cover letters, plot synopses, or scripts unless they are accompanied by a minimum of 10-20 completed pages (i.e., fully inked and lettered comic book pages).Additional publisher lists:> https://jasonthibault.com/definitive-list-comic-publisher-submission-guidelines/> https://writingtipsoasis.com/best-independent-comic-book-publishers/
>>8080459Some western / indie publishers of Manga:Saturday AM ( https://www.saturday-am.com/ )> Digital indie magazine, seems to be on the up-and-up> Open submissions for long-form series; also distributes series currently being published elsewhere.> Regularly publishes one-shots, making it a good potential outlet for already-finished work.Oni Press ( https://onipress.com/ )> Technically indie, but at this point large enough by comic standards to be mentioned in the same breath as other publishers.Antarctic Press ( https://antarctic-press.myshopify.com/ )> Longtime large-indie publisher of OEL / manga-esque books.> Seemingly taking submissions at present if https://antarctic-press.myshopify.com/pages/submissions is anything to go on.Yen Press ( https://yenpress.com/ )> Started out as a small indie publisher of original / Korean material, and has grown reasonably popular since.> As of 2016, it is also one of the western arms of the Kadokawa Corporation, with Kadokawa owning a 51% stake.> Editorial inquiries can apparently be sent to yenpress@yenpress.com, however, they apparently are not open to new submissions at this time.Viz Media / Viz Originals ( https://www.viz.com/originals )> *The* western manga publisher.> Currently in the exploratory stages of setting up an English label.> Submissions are open and several books have been announced. However, progress on the label seems to be moving very slowly.> Still might be worth a shot anyway.Shrine Comics ( https://shrinecomics.com/ )> Small indie manga publisher> Seemingly attempting to make the transition to physical volumes> Allows crossposting to other sitesIconic Comics (https://www.iconiccomics.com/)>A bit like Oni Press and Antarctic Press>A small publisher with a focus on indie works with manga inspiration
>>8080460/mmg/'s very own anon-led anthology: /ic/onographyhttps://discord.gg/QYnFBves7Vhttps://forms.gle/d3a2Cwwd44sJYyqv9(Anthology project is defunct but the discord is alive)Additional community added Resources:Mangafonts: https://mangafonts.carrd.co/Hiro Mashima YT: https://www.youtube.com/@mashimaCh/videosGanmo, a job listing board for manga assistant work: https://ganmo.j-comi.co.jp/postsHow (You) can help /mmg/:> Know about a contest or a publishing opportunity? TAG THE OP and post a link.> Have a new resource? TAG THE OP and link / mention it for inclusion.> Don't be a crab> Have a link / DL for a mentioned resource? TAG THE OP and mention what you're supplying a link for.> SCREENSHOT / PASTEBIN effort posts that help you for posterity.
Today's AttemptMostly a meme-like page for a friend.
Gonna start the last page of chapter 1. Then I'll start the prologue. Man, I can't wait to finally draw something other than spaceships and cockpits.>>8080474Idk what this is about but I really love the art.
You will never be Japanese. Your webcomics will never be manga.
>>8080531Good. We already have a crab. ATTENTION MANGA MAKERS! If you can't get past this crab, you don't stand a CHANCE. So GO DRAW and prove this man wrong!
Thief chase guy here with a new project.I said in my previous post that the thief chase story was to allow me to practice my art skills, and that next I need to practice my writing skills, and this is exactly that.I was already pretty good at drawing going into the previous project so it went pretty smoothly, but that is absolutely not the case here for writing. I want to work and rework this draft until I get it as good as I can manage.It unfortunately suffers from the same problem as the previous project in that it's a story in the middle of a story. The characters are not introduced and it's kind of assumed you already know them well. I'm just doing it for a bit of learning so it's not a big deal imo. Please let me know what you think and tear it to pieces
>>8080622In an effort to give as much context as possible to make up for the sketchy sketch, here are the characters and two of the key locations.I haven't drawn the bigger temple yet.My own self-criticisms I've come up with so far are:>timing issuesbetween pages 5-6 there should be a few hours time skip, long enough for the main characters to have returned home and noticed that the problem hasn't gone away.During the temple attendant segment (pages 9-15), I think in a few areas it moves too quickly, but I'm not sure how it reads to others.The fixing of the pipes, (pages 23-24) happens too quickly I think, maybe there should be an additional last minute conflict, like trying to find the pipes or dropping the wrench or something.>characterisation issuesI feel like everyone is too angry overall.I think the establishing of the conflict (pages 6-8) feels odd, they accept the task too easily.>exposition issuesI assume the reader knows the characters and their personalities, but I don't assume they know some of the super specific details in this one story, such as there being multiple aquaducts allowing them to turn the water back on while the aquaduct is still broken because they got the water from an adjacent pipe that happened to be nearby, or maybe that whole idea is bad, I dunno.I don't think I've made it clear enough that Julius blew up the aquaduct, and it may also be unclear that an aquaduct brings in water to begin with. I don't think the whole bit about a spring being sacred is communicated. It means it's just magic, there aren't any pipes to make it work, water just comes out of a rock and they built the fountain around it.>dialogueI think alot of the wording is clunky
>>8080474Are you the guy who drew that comic about rabbits? Your art looks better.>>8080478Is that your art, looks pretty professional?>>8080622It's a little bit hard to read. Like one point would be, first page is action, but the panels are very straight. Page 4 is more Not a fan of page 2 as well, it looks like a stair case. Looks like the top and the two panels on the right, do a zoom or something, it gets smaller in smaller by a similar factor. So the 3 panles on the right (1,3 and 5) have their own flow downwards, but the manga is red in a Z figure of course.
>>8080668>Page 4 is more static, but panels are diagonal and very dynamic.Where did the rest of the sentence go, lol?
Wasn't happy with my deletter g nib. Bought Zebra for the first time. Not sure if it's because my old deletter, was, well old, but the Zebra is so much better. It's not really softer, but it writes dryer and i can draw much better fine lines. The deletter nib writes very wett and thick, do if try to cross-hatch and the lines are not far enough apart from each other it becomes one big blob of ink. Not a problem at all with the Zebra.Yeah, i think i will by 1 or 2 new deletter in the future, to see if they behave brand new the same. Would like to try Tachikawa as well. Now that i see, how strong the difference between brands can be.
>>8080668>Is that your art, looks pretty professional?Heh. I wish. Is just a reaction image.
Drawing on paper with a nice nib feels so much better, than scratching plastic on plastic.But it's the looks as well. I've to see to this day, such crisp and dynamic lines like pic related done digitally.In my head, that's what real manga will ever look like.
>>8080675Got it, i wasn't sure, it's right on the upper edge of what i think a good amateur can achieve.
>>8080668>It's a little bit-Thanks for the responseThe first 2 pages are tricky because I want to establish that there's a fight going on, but at the same time the fight is not important to the story. I think I may also have been a bit rusty when drawing them and got a bit more warmed up with the rest of the chapter. I'll make a note to redraw it to be more dynamic.
>>8080685No, i mean not the layout, per se, but the (or a) name is hard to read, as i‘m not an editor I don’t have experience with interpreting other people’s roughs.
>>8080690Ah, I see, it is pretty poorly drawn. I redraw some of the panels to make it easier for others to read, but I didn't bother with the introduction since I didn't think the actual specific of the fight were important.
Why do people nowadays hate boxy paneling?
>>8080699What do you mean by boxy panelling? Do you mean panels that are boxes with 90 degree corners, or do you mean pages with more than 6 panels?
>>8080695Many pro mangaka draw even less detailed.I think they write the character names over the stick figures (seems like it, at least, they write something over the chars, maybe emotions as well, i can't read Japanese). If you want to show your roughts to someone else, it might be a good praxis.
>>8080701I think he mean pages that look like office cubicle with all the content being contained inside it instead of ordinary manga that takes more of 'illustration book' approach with overlapping art/panels, panel extending to the edge, no borders, etc.
>>8080706Nta, but choosing between those two i‘ll take Akira. If too much is going on out of frame it brakes the immersion for me and it starts looking like yaoi slop for fat white womenx
>>8080706It depends on the genre you read as well as the time period, but in my experience, what you describe as ordinary manga is far from ordinary. Most manga panelling is very conservative, very bread and butter. I see bleed panels alot but that's hardly anything dramatic. I don't think I've ever seen a panel overlapping, and the only times a character pops out of the panel is when it's a fullbody introduction. The only things I see regularly pop out of the panels are the sound effects.
>>8080707Some of you fuckers have the weirdest takes.
>>8080622what format/template did you use for this thumbnail sheet?
>>8080734There is no template, It's just boxes I drew myself.
>>8080622Good work so far! this is a great foundation for a solid filler episode in your story. i have a few critiques. The gags on pages 11, 12 13 do not read well. they need some breathing room between them. I know this isn't like a dark gritty story but without any time between them it makes it confusing to understand what is going on and even tho individually the pages seem funny when they are clumped together like this it losses its impact. page 15 feels out of place and random unless i missed soter falling on the ground in page 12. i think a lot of revision from pages 11-15 would go far because it kinda feels bloated. i really enjoyed the ending from 21-24 i think it was done well but you add another page or two of reaction from they by-stander or the group being like we did it or something. I'm a retard so if you take my opinon with a grain of salt lol
>>8080744I agree with pretty much everything you say.I think the gags of pages 11, 12, and 13 really need more breathing space. Page 15 is a bit of a filler page, perhaps I could cut it out entirely and use the free space to spread those earlier pages out a bit more. Though I'm not sure how splitting gags across multiple pages will work in terms of readability, pic related.Hmm perhaps you're right with the ending also, I used the last page as a way to make it clear that Soter's temple is now fine, but maybe a better last page would be the character's cheering that the day is saved instead.There's not really anything stopping me from adding or subtracting the page count, but I think it's good to be consistant. I see alot of webcomics fall into the habit of ever reducing page counts, starting from 30 something, then 20 something, then 15, and it's a bit depressing. I'd like to learn how to write while sticking to a set page count.
Still a nodraw pre/beg/. I'm just writing all my ideas down on paper. Scenes, characters, etc. I have no idea what I'm doing, but it took me 5 years just to get the courage to do this alone.
Anon, i would like to see, how far im from the top.How many man hours does a manga page take? Decent art, decent magazine. Maybe not Murata, but above average.
>>8080926Don't compare yourself to professionals.
>>8080478Thanks! It's just a gift I made for a friend featuring their Mega Man X OCs. It's not meant to be part of an actual series or manga project, just a standalone page>>8080668I'm not the person you're referring to, but thanks anyway! I don't post in this thread very often, so it's understandable that you got us mixed up haha.Also, another attempt at using screentones to give my OCs a more manga-like look.
>>8080930Yeah thats why i mentioned man hours, i will do everything alone obviously.I‘m sure Murata is able do draw the backgrounds, it’s a time thing.But in case of OPM Murata gets a lot of prise for his backgroungs, which he doesn’t draw. On the other hand gis assistants fuck up his art with a thon of unnecessary filters and digital effects.If i ever have assistants, i‘ll make them draw everything by hand, for their own good
>>8080926>>8080950Varies by work and by page but it still takes hours for the pros. Think something like 4-8 hours a page.
>>8081037Pic related can be done in about 2 hours, from sketching to lettering. If you are familiar with the character, maybe even less.But more elaborate pages are 1 to 2 full days of work. I think i will aim for two days.That's 1-2 short weekly chapters per month, solo. Not great not terrible.That's an interesting video on that topic, btw.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lopX8rXABlk
>>8081085>Pic related
>in ero manga #80 is usedWhy the difference in screentone density between publishers?
>>8081142Eromanga has more fine details under the tones that matter, I suppose. But I would not take this random sidenote to be true across all eromanga. I mostly used 60, for example.
storyboarding all the pages in advance really is motivating me to finish one page per day. Much better than what I was doing before
>>8081220
>Twitter now lets you post up to 20 images in the same postVery nice, a good change for once
>>8080768I think u can even give en a lil more breathing room. Also don't be afraid to dont worry too much sbout oage count as long as it fall from the 20-30 range ppl wont care. It more about the story
extremly racist comic based on my true life experience
pain
>>8081333Except it's none of those things, because the comic isn't racist at all, and you are not Korean nor a White girl, so this has nothing to do with your life.
>>8081360Moggs my legacy though?
>>8080457>1793968060538616.pngThe pedo-op is back?
>>8081416Yeah. I've made all the last 3 threads plus this one. You guys take too long to make a new one.
>>8081360Mouth looks good but eyes bother me
Very nice Video for basics.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p8jqB_bQltc
How high should your iq be, to write mind games manga like Hunter or death Note?
All the culture war bullshit going on makes me feel discouraged. I want to make a manga where the main character is a chubby woman with tan/brownish color skin, but I know if I do that it'll just get mocked as "woke" or "everything wrong with western artists" or whatever. It sucks that people automatically assume a work is "political" or "pushing an agenda," but I don't care about wokeness/anti-wokeness/DEI/representation or any of that culture war bullshit. I just want to do it because I have a fat woman fetish and I think brown women are hot. I feel like I'm getting it from both sides because my bbw fetish art is probably seen as "objectifying" by the woketards, and "woke" by the asmongoldtards. Both of those groups are just as pro-censorship and authoritarian as they accuse the other side of being and I want nothing to do with either. I don't know why it's so hard for people to just be pro-free artistic expression, even if it "offends" them.
>>8081521Just make whatever you want. Some small-fry making a random fetish comic is barely going to be a blip on either side's radar.
>>8081518you dont need to be smart, you can learn how to structure stories like that.
>>8080707>it starts looking like yaoi slop for fat white womenxi think ur retarded man, no two ways about it
>>8081544Fuck you, i can identify the sexuality, race and political agenda by looking at someone's art. I would say my success rate would be over 90%. Gay and womenx are sometimes hard to distinguish, but overall my art radar is very good.Dorohedoro is harder, as the mangaka is obviously a lesbian. Yeah such cases can be harder to get, but overall it works pretty good.I can explain it, as i trained the skill, but many viewer just feel it unconsciously, even if they couldn't explain the reasoning.It's like with op. He has not posted anything explicit, but everyone registered that he is a pedo.>>8081521You are a larper and a nodraw. Post your art.Breeding brown women is genetically encoded into white mans dna. Who will give you shit for that?If you write a character that's a mary sue, girl boss, has i giant chin and is ugly, than sure you will get shit, deservedly.
I bought a tachikawa grip and zebra nib bundle, but the zebra g sits very loosely in the holder. The deletter nib on the other hand sits too tight. It has this plastic hold for normal nibs and crow quills, but even the deletter maru pen sits pretty loosly.When i draw the rubber ring has some give, witch is awquard as the nib itself is soft.I have western holder, the nib sits pretty tight in it, but its thin and long, i like the ergonomics of the tachikawa (shorter and girdier) much more.What do?Do i have to by a deletter holder? Zebra nib holder are rear for some reason.
>>8081527But you need some kind of self confidence that the reader will follow you. If the master plan is stupid, no one will like it.
>>8081560>Dorohedoro is harder, as the mangaka is obviously a lesbian.she's not lol, the men are very sexualized and most of every woman in the series is in some hetero relationship, you can say she's bi or pan because she does not hold back on fanservice and sexual content but your radar already failed you horribly
>>8081583>she's notWe can never know for sure, something is not. Right? But she is definitely progressive.Look at this picture, every character is depicted with a silly onions face. Could you ever imagine Akira Toriyama drawing something like that? No, you couldn't.
It goes like that: Political views, gender, sexuality. The later is the hardest. It would be easy to think Araki is gay, for example, because his femals have very strong facial features, sometimes.
Well, just to make sure. You guys are a little bit stupid.What i meant by it looks like yaoi, is, i'm not a big shojo reader but if i look into female oriented manga like shojo or yaoi, it has always broken panels, shit is floating, words float in white space without bubbles, panels are broken, character are regularly drawn outside of the borders... that what i actually meant, with my first message.Pic related is a random pic from google search for shojo manga.
Have you seen Omoto draw like that?
>>8081599Have you ever actually read any manga, or is all of your knowledge based on out of context pages you find on google or random grabs from /a/.
>>8081616I flip through a lot of stuff without reading it, never read any shojo or yaoi, lol.Right now i research more than i actually read.
>>8081599this anon has a point, shojou looks different at a glance and you can identify it pretty easily, but its not really a hard rule. The problem is if you say anything on 4chan you'll get people arguing on semantics and bring up counter examples. Lets just focus on manga and manga making instead of trying to own each other with logic.
If somebody questions what you said, without asserting their own opinion plain and simple, assume it is bait.
So, if I'm in a rush to make money, what genre is basically the shortcut for guaranteed success in comics/manga today?
>>8081677power fantasy isekai with a dash of porn
>>8081521All that's just hyper-online bullshit peddled but a small but vocal minority. Normies (which the vast majority of people are) don't care either way how "diverse" a cast is, they just care if the writing is good and the story's entertaining. And who am I kidding, a lot of people don't even care about that, a lot of people only care about "hype" and "aura."The people who have melties because a cast is "too diverse" or "not diverse enough" are just loud, but they're far from the majority.
>>8080699I miss Araki's bizzare paneling.He's paneling has been much more simple since part 7.
>>8081521>pro-free artistic expressionEnjoy it while it lasts, anon, because even right now Japan is having a huge war between otaku and feminist regarding picrel.>tldrThis is a manga about middle age guy having relationship with a high school girl who works as a cashier.Feminist want to ban it as it's seen as promoting harmful toxic masculinity.Otaku retaliate by also wanting to ban Yaoi/BL.It's a lose-lose war where whoever wins will take down Japanese's 'freedom of expression'.
>>8081753>japan is tiring of pedophiles >japan is tiring of degenerate porn addicts Good I hope it spreads.
>>8081744i love that panel in battle tendency where joseph looks thru binoculars and we get a round panel, it's very goofy but also exactly the type of thing someone who's fully enjoying the potential of comics would do
>>8081521I love rape.I'll make a manga where all the girls will get raped.
>>8081808>I'll make a manga
>>8081333
>>8080457Alice-anon, if you need an assistant, please post here or in Ganmo.I'd like to apply.
Is there any proper drapery curse available?https://www.nma.art/courses/drawing-the-clothed-figure-live-class/https://www.proko.com/course/drapery-fundamentals
>>8081820>curseI know drapery is hard, but come on anon, you don't have to sacrifice your soul to the devil for it
>>8081822Lol, we need to faustmaxxing, there is no way arround
Chat redpill me on not using screen tones like Togashi or Toriyama do.Does the modern audience expect to see a lot of screen tones rendering?
>>8081834just draw
>>8081834The audience doesn't pay attention to things like that. They pay attention to how a comic makes them feel. Most people likely aren't even aware that screentones are a thing, they just see the characters and the world, the artist's hand is beyond them.But generally speaking, not using screentones produces a high contrast look, and if you use hatching to fill in the midtones, that produces a whole another look as well. Screentones make for a very soft modern look.If your motivation for not using screentones is that you think it's tedious or difficult to print or display, I recommend you just suck it up and get good at it. Comics are hard enough to draw as is, if you're going to make a comic, don't start cutting corners before you've even begun
>>8080457
>>8081839But i don't know how.
>>8081841>don't start cutting corners before you've even begunI have to, if i want to do a job of 5 men alone.
I realized I dont like sharing progress or wips or even posting on social media. I just want to draw and release thing when they're done. I was born 30 years too early.
Can mc have sex in first chapter if it’s a shonen?
>>8081757Too many shrimpdicks like you who get nothing and instead of upping your game you cry that nobody else should get any either.
>>8081677Lol if you're in a rush to make money, you can>sell your ass>join the military (sell your ass to the govt)>do crime (until you have to sell your ass in prison)Drawing doesn't even register as a blip on the money making radar.
What do you guys manga making studios look like? Here's mine.
>>8081753calling dips over half of those japanese feminists are from korea
>>8081876So far like this.
>>8081878S. Korea is currently a muppet with the USM's hand up its ass to push the bankers' agendas in East Asia. This is why Kpop started getting pushed so hard out of nowhere worldwide. SK has always been a shabbos goyim, much moreso than even the Japs.
>>8081876Mine is not quite as cluttered yet but I also sit on the ground.
>>8081876I bought another house since then but it's basically the same setup
>>8081878Lool, such gigacope
>>8081876I dislike traditional over digital because digital is just so much more convenient, but sometimes I lament not really having anything that feels like an artists studio because you kinda don't need anything other than a tablet if you're going digital.
>>8081871>>8081878Hoping the feminist win just to deprive you from your porn.
>>8081895No one will ever touch you, you are unloved and unwanted, and no amount of seething at the world will change that.
>>8081896
If I want to write shonen, where can my target audience find it? Kids these days only read isekai shit and definitely not on webtoon where romance and BL rule everything.
>>8081937Kids don't readYou have to make a series of diktok short reelz with AI voiceover
Going to a local comic showWish me luck
>>8081937I haven't exactly got a successful shonen myself so I'm just talking out of my ass, but speaking as an enjoyer of shonen myself and thinking about the kind of person who reads shonen stories, it's not the kind of audience that seeks out a comic/mangaPeople who read things like Chainsawman, Demon Slayer, Jujutsu Kaisen, they don't go looking for them, they don't consider themselves to be genre followers, each title they read feels individual, like something new and cool they've heard about.Places like webtoon are basically only women, and part of that is because it's the kind of thing women do, they go looking for stories, they follow the genre.Going with that idea, if I wanted to target a shonen audience, I'd go all in on the viral marketing strategy. Make twitter posts, make memes about it, videos about it, hype it up as the coolest thing ever. It doesn't really matter what you're thing is, whether it's a comic or a manga or a webcomic, nobody thinks about that stuff, they see cool thing, they wanna read cool thing, it's that simple. The audience is everywhere, scattered about, there is no shonen manga reading club.
>>8081892>a mic and light overheadwhere's the camera you're hiding?
>>8081948So basically, shonen fans only care if something’s mainstream, not some niche thing nobody’s heard of. That’s going to be tough. Sure, viral marketing can work for any genre if you put in the effort but it takes connections, and you practically have to be an eceleb for it to actually pay off.
>>8081890>artists can buy houses now
>>8081947luck for what
>>8081959I'm going to find my big break and secure a million dollar contract for the manga I have in my head
>>8081885it doesn't make sense, Kpop is highly sexualized, unless that's the bankers' agenda?
>>8081947As?>>8081948>People who read things like Chainsawman, Demon Slayer, Jujutsu Kaisen, they don't go looking for them, they don't consider themselves to be genre followers, each title they read feels individual, like something new and cool they've heard about.TRVTH NVKE right there. Normies aren't real humans with a contentiousness.
>>8081962How much money does it make? Does it lead directly to discord in normal relationships forming between men and women? Does it target mostly preteens despite the sexualization? Have you been paying attention?Yes, it is absolutely the bankers agenda.
>>8081876
Shilling my 4komahttps://elfhospital.thecomicseries.com/comics/1/#content-start
>>8081956>>8081963That's not exactly what I mean.While people do pick up what's already popular, that also applies to literally everything so it's meaningless to say.But with males aged 10-25 in particular, the shonen demographic, they don't consciously think about things as being worth their attention because they're popular.It does have an effect, but the effect is only subconscious and once they've actually consumed the thing, whether it was popular or not is irrelevant.If you can manipulate their initial perception of something to be cool in a social sense, that's your hook. This is pretty much the basis of all marketing for any product targetted towards this demographic
I dont think you guys need to worry about people reading your manga, just assume nobody is going to read it. We are not in the 2000s anymore. Peolpe don't look for things to read, they doomscroll on one of three shitty websites. Pretty soon there won't even be a place to upload your art, we got like 3 years left max before the internet becomes like TV. Just a bunch of channels you can watch and cannot input anything into.You shld be drawing manga beacuse you find it fun, and you should be telling the story you want to tell.
>>8081993>People don't look for things to read, they doomscroll on one of three shitty websites. Pretty soon there won't even be a place to upload your art, we got like 3 years left max before the internet becomes like TV. Just a bunch of channels you can watch and cannot input anything into.I hate the antichrist
>>8081993>You shld be drawing manga beacuse you find it funHas it ever crossed your mind that people who make manga for fun also want to get paid? There’s no money in it without readers and your manga is worthless if nobody reads it.
>>8081993The real question is, why don't you kill yourself?
>>8081997I'm not talking about people who make manga, I'm talking about the people in this thread asking questions and not doing anything. If you think its not worth it to draw manga, then don't. There is no trick to make it worth it or profitable.
>>8082002pyw
>>8081995Lol, what is that, your little autism mantra? Do the magic words change your reality?
>>8082007maybe I already did, in this thread or a previous thread, or even in the next thread...
>>8082014Or maybe you are just shitting up the thread, asshole. Wouldn't be surprised if you're the pajeetnasian retard, pretty sure even that it's you.
I had takoyaki and spicy miso ramen for lunch, and now I am working on my manga. You wouldn't even believe how Japanese I feel.
>>8082019Besado!
>>8082019I just drank some bottled tea imported from Japan. I can FEEL the Japanese-ness flowing through me. It is very important I draw as much as I can before the effect wears off.
Is MediBang always full of these useless brushes and screen tones? I doubt I’ll ever need to use 70% of them.
>>8081876this isn't really my manga studio. just joking. here's my real one.
>>8082236>eight tables...... but why?
>>8082359nice
>>8082244It's part of my ergonomic setup. So I can stand , or sit at the small monitor. Really good to have a setup like that if youre on the PC a lot
>>8082384Once I make it I'm going to get a setup like this
>>8082374Jojo‘s costume design is so ass
>>8081972It's goodCute and simple art, nothing laugh out loud but they're all amusing enough to keep reading (like most 4koma series in general)
Took me 3 days to do a big manga analysis with a free claud model, as the token regenerate every 5h.Finally ready, it's useless. The only information it has given, that the Japanese market is shrinking a little. But that was in the news.French market is shrinking hard, didn't know that. I guess ingenues and doctors have no time for reading comics.
>>8082403>manga market
>>8082403AI shitters are so retarded it's unreal
Is it too loaded? Should I simplify it?
>>8082406I‘m an ai-hater, you idiot
>>8082411well, if you hate Claude so much, why don't you marry it?
>>8082408Everything in this page is the same size, bad, autopilot direction creates garbags composition.
>>8082417All right, thanks, I'll redraw everything.
>>8081142Important note that some people might not know. 50 series tone sheets are 55LPI, and 80 series sheets are 70LPI. It's a little misleading as other series the numbers are the LPI. The pic shows 51 And 52, so 55 LPI 10% and 55 LPI 20% sheets
Why are you people and japs still hell bent on doing old n busted manga format that is outdated, hard to read and still in black n white instead of doing superior webtoon that is easier to consume and fully colored?No wonder japan is falling behind korea in all departments of entertainment field.
>>8082433And why don't you kill yourself?
Finally finished a full scene.Trying to get a feel for how I want to do things for a longer story, would appreciate any feedback.https://files.catbox.moe/vndroc.pdf
still working/developing a style.
>>8082460Better hair and better belt then you are done
Think about it logically. Drawing manga solo is a cheat code. You do everything alone and get all the money.If you can produce appealing , but simple art with little rendering, you could draw 2 mangas. A weekly series and a monthly one, or one without strict deadlines.So you would make x5 amount of money, or you could sell x5 less manga without worrying about money.Think about it logically. If you can produce simple, appealing art and write stories that suit the art style, you are set for success.
I let the slop machine analyze the market and find popular manga with low fidelity art. Then i can read them and figure out, what the hook is.Like, if you aren't a retarded pajeet, you can really use the slopa machine as a tool.Like it gave me Cat Soup, i've watched the anime many years ago, but i newer knew there was a manga behind. It has pretty cool art style.
>>8082403https://voca.ro/1ecqBXoRVY93
>>8082474https://vocaroo.com/1bnoVqfLEfMl
>>8082474I hope you're also giving Claude-kun access to your remote dildo so you can really use the slopa machine to fuck yourself in the ass as well
You guys are just a bunch of anti-intellectuals, who does not appreciate the importance of theory enough.
>>8082477Lool
>>8082479theory and skill only matters in a healthy industry. there is no manga industry in the west, so it doesn't matter how good or bad your first manga is. Just fucking draw and have fun.
>>8082547>so it doesn't matter how good or bad your first manga is. Just fucking draw and have fun.You are a cuck. I am in pursuit of glory, not fun.>there is no manga industry in the westTime to get big in Japan, then.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HcsYb3OoM8c
>>8081220I find the storyboarding part the most fun. it's the least demanding, and is the most "free play">>8080622These are fantastic, all the lines are very clear and there's a wide variety of interesting compositions.Hefferchu volume 1 is done, please check it out and let me know what you think (it's on tapas/webtoons/pixiv/inkstra on https://efsius.net). I'll be streaming my submission for the Artfol contest due tomorrowhttps://www.twitch.tv/efsius1/https://www.youtube.com/@efsius1/streams
>>8082547this mindset is why you will never make a manga, only comics.
Is there a way to get this book? Checked internet archive, cgpeers and some torrents, nothing.
>>8081972That's funny
>>8080457>>8080459>>8080460>>8080462somehow along the way we lost the Japanese publishers and competitions from this general.It has been missing for a few threads already. Wanted to look up upcoming competitions, so I notice them missing again
>>8082572>bwis bwimdswebt bis bwhy bwyou bwiww bwevew bwake a bwawbwashut up retard, lol
>>8082460Yeah the hair is kinda stiff. Too much spray in it.I'd look at a Björn Andresen interpretation.
>>8082466>>8082685Yeah I definitely need to find a method for hair and hands, style-wise they tend to be inconsistent
>>8081588Your brain is poisoned.
>>8082669You want to compile a list of all japanese publishers and competitions? That would be a long list my man, but go ahead.
>>8081973I dunno man, I just like drawing aliens and whatever happens happens.
What is the most right-wing manga ever created?
>>8082784Successful manga? Probably Zipang.
>>8082784Drama Queen is a recent one which is pretty anti immigration but it kinda flips flops
>>8082433Webtoon format is not superior. It legitimately pisses me off that I have to scroll this fucking much with majority of the page being either empty space or some "whoosh" or a piece of hand. It all looks so retarded and reading that crap makes me seethe. So I stopped even trying. Manga is actually dynamic and hold your grip. I dont really care about color, but the requirement of color ends up just driving the image quality down overtime and promotes the use of 3d slop
>>8082794From the description it sound ultra cucked. Maybe you're trolling.>>8082795>Drama QueenStill haven't started reading it, and it's already axed.But i heard different interpretations of the political stance so far.
>>8082797All the demoralizing massages (ai, webtoon, mo market in the west...) are all written by some retarded attention whore from pajeetnesia. You're better of ignoring him.
>>8082797>>8082801Cope.Everyone around me from my families, friends, to colleagues read Tower of God and Solo Levelling webtoon and not a single one of them gives a damn about Kimetsu no Yaiba nor Jujutsu Kaisen manga.Webtoon is thriving by being more easier to read a.k.a. consumer friendly while manga is still being seen as nerd's comic.
>>8082772No, the list was just 5 points or so of Japanese Manga competitions. It was part of the OP forever until it got list along the way. I guess some retard made new threads and forgot the section and then his OP got copied from then on It needs to be restored
>>8082807This.My coworker also finished Solo Levelling in just few days saying it's the best thing they ever read while dropping Kimetsu no Yaiba saying it's a 'labor' to read.
>>8082801At first I thought it was different anons but maybe you are right that it's just one guy from indonesia samefagging and replying his own posts.
>>8082797webtoons are designed for women on phones to get a quick spurt of dopamine reading a basic shell of a story. watch the youtube videos of webtoons (the website) staff talking about stuff. You can tell they're not right in the head.
>>8082813webtoons is cringe, its literally just different animes revolved around video game quirks such eg: "Level 1000 undercover newbie" or flippin "I'm a level 1 newbie dating A max level" its soo "commercialized" its gross, the whole catalog feels souless
>>8082798>Still haven't started reading it, and it's already axed.i don't know if it was officially axed but it's gotten this far and just wrapped up its main plot pointsit kinda meandered a bit so it just felt like the author didn't know what else to do with it
>>8082798>From the description it sound ultra cucked. Maybe you're trolling.It's a nationalist history revisionist story. It's the very definition of a "rightwing manga". Sorry, I didn't realize we were talking in Retard.
>>8082810>>8082807Do the thirdwordies really think they are making a point here? Not having the pajeet audience is a feature not a bug
>>8082825They got transported to ww2 and they do not immediately support Japan as they are too conditioned to being burgers lapdogs. If you don’t put blood first you aren‘t right, some cuckservative at best.
>>8082943Then by your retarded ass-backwards standards, no, there are no rightwing manga.
Does it make sense to use Japanese sound effects, can't Japanese read Latin?
>>8080457Hello, I thought of trying to start a manga magazine, as the first step, I'm running a contest.I won't sugar coat things, there is no user base yet, the hope is that artists will each pull in some of their own audience, and thus combined each artist will benefit from each others' audiences.The prize for the contest is $100, I'm not sure if PayPal can pay out to every country, and also there are higher cash payouts listed as well but the final result will likely be just one or two bronze ($100)s handed out, which is what Shueisha usually does as well.https://mangacoin.org/contest/mangacoin-contest-1If you feel like submitting something you've already made, or want to even draw something new for this, please go ahead.Thank you for your attention
>>8082961Mangacoin sounds like a cryptocurrency, which makes the whole thing feel like a scam.Furthermore it puts too much focus on the money side of things, rather than the manga. I can't see how this would attract readers
>>8082964I got the cryptocurrency feedback a couple times, which means of course it's correct, and you are correct for bringing it up, and the focus on the money thing does seem like an issue at first,However a different argument can also be made.1) Focusing on how creators can monetize attracts creators2) Readers knowing that they can directly support creators and read on the same platform without all the hoops and annoying distractions on other sites is attractive3) The core concept is making supporting your favorite creator as simple as a "like" button.Right now it remains to be seen where it goes and how it is taken.However, keeping that core functionality (the main idea of this project - I wouldn't bother making one if it had nothing to set it apart from the competition) while not putting the coining aspect in the name (MangaCoin) would not make sense.
>>8082961>>8082967My question would be, "why do this when it doesn't even lead to anything?" I suppose since you also allow entries that are already done that's fine, but why would someone spend weeks or months on a project for a site that doesn't even have an audience? The existing Japanese contests gets your work in front of the eyes of legit manga publishing companies, professional mangaka and editors, and established fanbases of those publications. At worst you're getting feedback and a decent audience looking at your entry, what exactly are you getting here?On top of that, you seem to be making it fairly clear that Gold and Silver prizes may not even actually exist for the winners, so that seems rather deceptive. I get that sometimes even in big contests, they don't always necessarily give out the top prize, but people still know there is a legitimate chance at a legitimate prize. Not a contest on a site with almost no established traffic or readers, for a prize that you're not even sure will exist.
>>8082819I don't understand why people have gravitated towards ridiculously stupid sounding titles for comics/mangas; inclusive of this is their obsession with certain words or extremely long titles. If I have to read yet another title including the word "villainess" or encounter a long title like "In the real world I was just a lowly cook for a large restaurant but then I was reincarnated into the isekai world and managed to roll a high level character in an adventurer's party with maxed out cooking skills?!?!?!?!?!" I am going to scream. Bring back concise titles please, I don't care what the genre is:>Cardcaptor Sakura>Bleach>Berserk>Bastard!>Vagabond>Ghost in the ShellAnd so on.
>Jiichiro Kashima, a manga artist who previously worked as an assistant on works including "Cannon Master", has announced that he is giving up on his goal of becoming a regular manga artist at Shonen Jump after trying for 8 years since the end of his high school days.>He admitted that leaving a place he had been tied to for so long was painful, but he still wanted to start anew, and clarified that he has no issues with the editorial department or the publisher.>"I feel that I simply don't have what it takes to draw that kind of manga">He will now shift his goal to creating seinen manga, starting with a short story with a proper conclusion to submit to the publisher for consideration again.>At the same time, Kashima's works are characterized by beautiful linework, solid composition, detailed backgrounds, and clear emotional expression, which has led many readers to comment: "His art style looks much more suited to seinen manga than Shonen Jump.">Although his 8 year journey in Shonen Jump has come to an end, for Kashima, this may just be the starting point of a new path as a manga artist, a source of encouragement.If someone who's several levels above you can't stay afloat in the shonen industry, what makes you think you can?
>>8083003I don't think anybody here is trying to work in Jump
>>8083003The better question is, why don't you kill yourself, Pajeet, instead of shitting up the thread you not belong?
>>8083005Where would everyone's endgame be then? I thought getting serialized by Jump is where you consider making it.
>>8083008They dont have an endgame, do you think their skill is reflective of somebody with an endgame? They sit comfortably on the bottom of the bucket.
>>8083009>>8083008>pajeet starts samefaging again
>>8083009Maybe you're right. I guess it's pointless to discuss anything substantial in here when no one seems to take their manga career seriously
>>8083008Since day 1 my goal was to simply make a comic/manga that got at least a dedicated IRL readership and some fanart. I have achieved both. The very idea of becoming a comic creator as an occupation is disgusting to me. It would kill my desire to draw immediately.
>>8083008I just want to make as many great comics as I can. What's Jump got to do with that?
>>8083003Nobody would make an announcement like this if they didn't actually have a problem with shonen jump. Artists jump from magazine to magazine all the time, it's not uncommon for someone to make a manga that doesn't fit in one magazine but does in another.If he just wanted to make seinen works, then he would have just done exactly that, there would be no need to make this announcement. He 100% has an issue with shonen jump and this is his big quitting post about it.Doing the whole "it's not you, it's me" thing is very typical of Japanese etiquette. He says he doesn't have what it takes. What he's really saying is that Shonen Jump is too gruelling of a magazine to work for.
>>8083040There is no bad pr, or what do the mutts say?Pulling some attention to his new thing, is not a bad movie. The angle of, i wasn't a good fit for shonen, but now i do seinen is okey. It will not pull a lot of readers, but some will check out his work, and if it's good people will stay.No one knows what this guys exactly problem was, but being a grown man and having to write for teens is not ideally.I myself tried to come up with a shonen, but even a "dark shonen" is too limiting. I want to have like 10-20% escalation potential in my backhand.If you know the movie Drive, it is pretty normal 99% of time, somewhat slow, regular violence level. And than towords the end it has a very sharp spike of violence in one scene and this scene is what the movie is known for (and the ost).The synopsis of the movie is an autistic criminal guy and the girl thinks, oh well i can change him and then she sees his psychopathic side in an explosion of violence and she is like, okey, fuck it.The violence could be just implied (to get a lower raiting), but than it would do exactly the same, romanticize criminals. So a low age restriction rating can be a problem, from an artistic stand point.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-DSVDcw6iW8
>>8083008endgame is making manga viable in the west
>>8083003having beautiful art doesnt matter. there are millions of artists with beautiful art.And when they say "expressive characters" they're talking by japanese standards, so they're likely not very expressive at all. Maybe his manga is too generic but that's got nothing to do with me. My manga is unique because only I can make it.
>>8083078I think manga published in Jump primarily succeed by focusing on characters with immediately memorable, distinct traits, paired with a certain level of chuunibyou appeal that hooks younger readers. On top of that the narrative structure needs to be concise, punchy, and easy to follow right from the first chapter. Looking at this author's work, the art style feels overly dense and detailed for a Jump serialization, I’m not sure if that’s just a lingering habit carried over from their time working as an assistant, where heavy background rendering is the norm. Regardless, plenty of talented creators simply aren't a good fit for Jump's specific editorial formula. Even AoT was famously rejected there before finding massive success elsewhere.That said, I also think part of the issue lies with modern Jump's ridiculously high, almost arbitrary standards when deciding which new series to actually get behind and promote. It’s surprising that shit like nuOne Piece hasn't faced harsher editorial pushback after all these years. The manga clearly doesn't meet the tight pacing and quality standards it set in the past, yet they continue to drag it out purely to milk the franchise down to the very last drop.
>>8083087I think Weekly Shonen Jump is currently in a bad state. They've got this reputation of being the best of the best, almost all of the biggest titles have come from Weekly Shonen Jump, it's the Gold's Gym Venice of manga.But the expectations for authors in it has now become soo high that it's actually a hinderance. It's just too much. Authors now think they're not good enough, or whenever they try to write a story they try to come up with the next Naruto, something that will sell hundreds of millions of copies, and it fails because of that. Everyone's got stage fright.
>>8083091No shit. The moment they announced Naruto is coming back, it practically screamed how desperate their situation has become. It’s not just Jump though, it feels like the entire shonen publishing industry operates the exact same way across the board. Editorial departments are only interested in hunting down once-in-a-generation prodigies who already have all the talent, speed, and resources lined up to launch a hit career out of the gate. As a result, any creator who is simply average, developing at a normal pace, or lacking an established support network gets completely overlooked or dropped at the first sign of trouble. Jump just happens to be the most ruthless example of that mindset. The only real exception to this bottleneck is when someone gets extraordinarily lucky stumbling onto a premise that feels just fresh enough and hits broad enough mainstream appeal to explode into a viral internet phenomenon, much like Spy x Family did.
>>8083091>Naruto shadow rising>Live actions, vidyaLooking at it from afar as an outsider, all of this "cheating" the manga industry to make more money is disgusting, like next they will make official dog ponchos and naruto cereals
Shonen has diversified a lot. They have semi-seinen hits, historical hits, female hits, indie stuff like MAD, they have an amateur platform (that is full of ai slop, but that's a different topic) where you can just come on top and land a run in Manga Plus...The funny thing is, what they don't have right now is a strong classical shonen.Bringing Naruto back, makes sense, Kishimoto failed his other manga runs and a lot of people hate Boruto, for a good reasons.For aspiring mangaka it's a bad sign, the manga industry is starts to reassemble Marvel or Disney. Were they put all the effort in legacy ips instead of supporting newcomers.So the manga industry may turn to shit, but as for right now, it's not that bad. So hurry up and hop on the train before it disappears.
>>8083105>Shonen Jump
>>8083105we had my hero academia and people hated how positive and hopeful it was. That was the last shonen and the west will never accept another shonen again so they need to ignore us.
>>8083143Yeas, demand for classical shonen diminished, it seems. The demographic alone would explain that.But making a shonen darker and more realistic is a problem if you want to drag it out to infinity.>usYeah, us, fellow white brother.
Is there an english website that actually has a minimum quality requirement when uploading and could reject you if they think your mangas not good?
Manga making bros... Help me get motivated.
>>8083040>Nobody would make an announcement like this if they didn't actually have a problem with shonen jump.That's not true at all. It's perfectly reasonable to make such an announcement with no animosity toward the publisher you are leaving.
>>8083259world war three happening in the next decade its now or never
>>8083259Tell your story anon. If not you then who?
>>8083259>help me get motivatedNo, I won't. Either you have an inner drive to tell your story or you don't. Any pushing from outside will just peter out and then you'll need a push again. Reach inside yourself and ask why you allegedly have a comic to make. If you don't have a reason, then there is no point to make one and you're just wasting your own time.
>>8083273>become hit mangaka>country won't send you out as war fodder since you're too much of an economical assetdelightfully devilish seymour
what's some good recourses for learning how to write character dialogue?I don't struggle with the world building process for my setting, and I'm piecing a story together by coming up with scenes that are good excuses to explain it. However whenever I get down to trying to write character interaction I just draw a blank.at best I'm worried it will come across as boring or stiff, at worst I'm worried it will be cringe. I'm not good at doing emotional sappy stuff.Then again maybe I don't need to do any of that in the first place. have the world building be the main driver of the story with minimal character drama going on.
>>8083290This guy thinks his webcomic is gonna save him from the trenches.
I gotta start on my one shot
>>8083305cringe, do it because you want to produce something boozoo.
>>8083317Nice.
>>8083273That's one thing I don't have to stress about. My country has conscription but I got exempted for being too undersized so they wouldn't draft me even if ww3 broke out tomorrow. I'm more worried about dying alone without achieving my dream than anything else right now.
>>8082961That's cool. I don't know about the theme but I may consider it
>>8082961I'll consider it if I ever finish my first oneshot. Come back and remind me next year.
>>8083297best to just read books/watch movies and absorb from thereor maybe join some rp server or even some ai chatbot and watch how they do it if you don't want to jump in yourself
>work for two weeks on 8 pages. posted it to socials.>a total of 2 likes, a jeet bot and grandma.thank you granny.
>>8080457Did an exercise from "making comics" had to recreate a movie. Took longer than expected but got it done! Lmk what you think i could do better or should focus on!
>>8083405Whats your social I wanna be viewer number 3
>>8083417Isn't it to recreate A scene from a movie? Not really sure what you're supposed to be getting out of doing what you did, where you've just redrawn a frame of a bunch of scenes from the whole movie. The point of the exercise is to figure out try to convey what the scene in the movie is conveying in a different medium. It's supposed to be a difficult exercise that pushes you to make creative choices.
>>8083008I want to make people who read my manga FEEL. I want you to come away from my story with a feeling. Any feeling. That is what turely great media does imo. Even if its a negative feeling. As long as it aint boredom. Id most likely self publish though to build and audience and cuz i just want to see my manga on a store self one day
>>8083419No point of the exercise was to recreate a movie in 16 panels the. See what wat panels you could possibly remove and still get the story across
>>8083421Oh I see, guess I was thinking of a different exercise. Carry on then.
>>8083405seconded, getting 8 pages of anything done and posting them is already pretty cool, even if it turns out you're still /beg/ and people here make fun of you a bit.
https://kadokawaworldmanga.com/contest/#application
>>8083439>no webtoonslop allowed>no Gayrman as official languageFucking based! I start drawing right now!
Is it okey to use historical paintings and drawings as refs? Not tracing of course, but taking the background, poses etc?As a homage, i don't try to hide it.
Loolhttps://mangaplus-creators.jp/episodes/us2611172017550027515604