Post stroke editionWhat language(s) are you learning?>Share language learning experiences!>Ask questions about your target language!>Help people who want to learn a new language!>Participate in translation challenges or make your own!>Make frens!**Comprehensible Input Wiki**comprehensibleinputwiki.org/wiki/Main_PageRead the wiki:4chanint.miraheze.org/wiki/The_Official_/int/_How_to_Learn_A_Foreign_Language_Guide_WikiUseful links:>Free language‐learning book archive:mega.nz/folder/INlRkAQC#CthKI9-_kmDNyrOx12Ojbw>Books on linguistics and language courses:mega.nz/#F!Ad8DkLoI!jj_mdUDX_ay-8D9l3-DbnQ>Assorted language resources and some nice visual guides:pastebin.com/ACEmVqua>Torrents with more resources than you’ll ever need for 30 plus languages:https://archive(dot)ph/x0dFH>Russianon’s list of comprehensible input resources:docs.google.com/document/d/1wXd0V32TjCFsr1-F_en_lA4MI-i7JtyYf26cWLtPRec>Massive collection of textbooks on various languages, sorted by familytheswissbay.ch/pdf/Books/Linguistics/>/lang/ inpoot torrentsrentry.org/inpoot>Refold Anki decksrentry.org/refoldPrevious: >> >>218685623
Yyffg
I only speak English, Korea, Japanese
>>218796449*Korean
For two decades, I’ve wrestled with English, pouring countless hours into its labyrinthine rules and nuances, yet it remains an unfathomable puzzle, a verbal labyrinth that drives me to the brink of mental exhaustion. Each attempt to speak feels like wading through thick fog, making me question my brain function. In contrast, after just three years of immersing myself in Japanese, I find a surprising ease. Its rhythms and sounds flow through me like a stream.
>>218797090Your English in this post is excellent, probably more elaborate than most Americans could write lol
>>218796231>What language(s) are you learning?French is my strongest. Trying to grow a little bit or at least maintain it. Trying to maintain my Italian too, though it's less of a priority. I also know Esperanto. Trying to start with Portuguese because I'm dating a Brazilian
>>218797538I can't speak it in real life, though.
>>218797090Didn't you say you spoke it better than me? Keep looking at chatgpt generated charts.
>>218798066I'm sorry, I know I generalize. I've spoken with people from all over trying to improve my English, but the only non native speakers I've come across who are better than me are mainly from Northern Europe and the Netherlands. I grew up a bit distorted mentally because I was hit at an English academy when I was young. Please understand. What I am obsessed with is the native's bloody verbal speed and the emotional thing when they speak the languageI can only speak English if I think of myself as a robot and exclude all emotions.
When I was in middle school. I forced to learn English. I would get hit with a cane every time I got an English word wrong. I had dozens of English vocabulary words to memorize as homework every day.
>>218797837go be that anime girl that only talks to people through writing because she's too shy but instead you're a korean man
>>218798947I would rather hit my head against the wall to get the language syndrome
>>218798555Hab gehört, dass das koreanische Bildungssystem krass ist, aber für Fehler gepeitscht zu werden ist eine ganz andere Hausnummer.
>>218796449That's very cool
>>218791406Watch based Bluey
>>218781684Sorry, I did check, i should have said I cant find it with subtitles. Probably I'm gonna use youtube-dl and then use OpenAI to generate subtitles for myself.>>218784559>I am too easily swayed because now I'm doing beginner Portuguese input. Thanks for the nudge in a direction anon, otherwise I probably would've just procrastinated for another two weeks.Good luck. if you want suggestions for PT-PT, the Portuguese with Leo podcast (he has one for beginners and also for intermediates) is great as it has transcripts. If you don't mind paying money, PracticePortuguese is great too.
Estas glaciigite ĉe mi. Estas eble danĝere aŭton konduki hodiaŭ
>>218796231/lang/ deader than tocharian B
>>218802275Are you living in Portugal now? I recently started learning pt-pt as well and moving to Portugal is an option for me in the future. From just learning Portuguese how much Spanish can you understand? Reading I imagine is pretty easy? I already am B2 in French and I wanted to understand both Spanish and Portuguese, but I have more irl opportunities in Portugal and my local university was offering a Portuguese night classIt's been a breeze so far thanks to knowing French.
Watched a Dreaming Spanish vid with Language Reactor. I have autopause on and listen to every line chunk 2 or 3 times.
>>218806728enjoy fossilization
>>218807040I don't believe in it
I can't do it bros. I can't listen to another beginner level language learning podcast about the weather or morning routines or cultural events in *insert TL country*. I want to skip to the part where I can just listen to audiobooks and watch tv.
it feels like output is so slow. im improving but it just moves so slowly.
bump
Kion vi faris ĉitage? Mi ĵus promenis min kun amiko en la arbaro
>>218801151Being fluent in these three languages is the most common case among trilingual speakers, and so it's not special at all, imc.
What do you think about middle welsh
it's pretty middle of the road.
>>218796231I know you're not supposed to compare yourself to others but holy shit am I a btfo brainlet compared to old language learners.
i have a huge problemI can undersanding 80% of what I read. I can understand 50% of what I hearbut when it comes to outputting my mind blanks and I have to spend a lot of time thinking of words to use
>>218811157You know how in the Sims you can grind charisma by practicing talking in the mirror? Just get reps in of speaking.
>>218805857>Are you living in Portugal now?Yes, almost 8 months.>I recently started learning pt-pt as well and moving to Portugal is an option for me in the future.Nice. i assume the potential move is what motivated your learning? It's relatively easy to get your paperwork and things done here to live if you have EU citizenship. Even though many adminstrative processes have English speakers or have the English language available, you are much better off being able to use the language comfortably. My portuguese is not great, but oftentimes i find that even if many portuguese people insist on using english with me, we can cut through communication barriers much more easily if we compromise with my portuguese instead of their english. so, it helps a lot.>From just learning Portuguese how much Spanish can you understand? No idea, very little? I have almost 0 exposure to any spanish but sometimes have talked with spanish tourists and we could more or less understand one another.>Reading I imagine is pretty easy?spanish, right? I can "read" spanish much more easily because I can see the correspondence with portuguese words and recognize some spanish words that i've memorized because they are common (hacer, poder, the articles, etc.)>I already am B2 in French and I wanted to understand both Spanish and Portuguese, but I have more irl opportunities in Portugal and my local university was offering a Portuguese night class>It's been a breeze so far thanks to knowing French.if you like the country and language i would say go for it.the main downsides of living here i can say are what any native would tell you: lower wages and high taxes. culturally it's a much different, and for me, generally better place than the US.
>>218811157I had the same issue. I thought it was a problem but I saw some people talking about it. Apparently it is so common they even have a name for it. Tip of the tongue. You know the word but it just won't come out. Basically I just spoke more and it started improving.
>>218811157How much do you expect to be able to say? 20%, 30% of what you think?Your normal, baseline thoughts are probably just too complex to be expressed with your current level, so if you try to simplify your thoughts to the most basic like "this is an [object]" or "i am hungry", you'll have a better shot of something coming out of you. Start as small as you can, then keep inpooting and checking up on your output and seeing if the needle moves.
>>218797090>language that is similar to native language is easier than one that is very differentcraziest shit ever, you should write a book
>>218797685>I also know Esperanto.Kiel vi, samideano? Malofte mi vidas E-istojn tie ĉi. Domaĝe, ke Verda-chan ne estas pli aktiva, ĉu ne?
>>218809007Kek
I've started thinking of words at work and then trying to think about what the TL word isToday I thought of ear and somehow oreille popped into my mind but then I got confused because I remember reading Fleurs du mal and there's a bit about 'sur l'oreille du mal' but I knew it was actually pillowcase in that example and then I realised that it's oreiller kind of like an earer, hopefully I don't get the two confused againI hope I can bring my active vocabulary up with this because my work doesn't require any brain function to do
Also I did 2 chapters of Russian Through Reading todayThis does seem pretty promising so thanks to the anon who mentioned it here months ago I've done crude OCR on it and am running it through an AI to correct the mistakes caused by stress marks because I'm too lazy to correct them myself
There is a youtube reel which has a story about a English learner in KoreaSomeone who studied English hard for several years in Korea and then moved to the State said,> I hear the phrase like "What brings you here?" first time. I thought>Wow so that's how they speak it! That sounds kind of poetic! (무엇이 당신을 이곳으로 불렀습니까?)> How do they speak like this?Many Koreans in Korea shocked, Native speakers rocked.
Just learnt Arabs are racist too.Didn't expect this
Recently heard about a linguistic maneuverIt assumes that each new language will go easier, so if you hit a plato in your TL around B1 or higher you switch to a new language and grind it for a month or two, then go back to your TL to continue much fasterHow true is this?
>>218816810this assumes that you're picking similar languages both grammatically and syntactically, not accounting for any decay that'll occur in your original language and overall all it does is shift time that could've been used on the original language towards another language, that'll then also experience decay once you quit studying itthis really doesn't seem useful unless you need to study multiple languages at once and even then it's probably a better idea to just do them simultaneously and not in weird 2 month shifts
>>218807040isn't that for output?
Anki Pro: Someone comes over and canes you when you get a card wrong.
>>218812472Mi estis ĉi tie tre ofte antaŭ kelkaj jaroj. Mi faras iom bone, malgraŭ la malvarmecego, la neĝo, kaj la glacio kiuj malfaciligas vojaĝi en mia kvartalo. Mi kredeble faros panon
Random story from a recent work trip where I language mogged someone:>event in america>attendees mostly american but not all>ended up speaking a little italian, german, and french (and I mean only a little since I haven't studied those in years and only remember a few phrases)>and a couple other languages with a friendly german guy>american lady then says something to me to try to trip me up>wtf was that, some kind of arabic?>shoot off the one fancy sentence I know in iraqi arabic>she says "god dammit" and laughs>i guessed correctlygg
>>218796231>the comprehensible input wiki has Cook Islands Māori, Niuean, Toki Pona, Sardinian, New Zealand Sign Language, 5 typles of Arabic but not Persianthere's truly no hope
>>218818400Ĉu vi partoprenas ĉeestajn E-aranĝojn? En kiu regiono vi estas? Mi estas nordoriente en la lando.
bruh
>>218819542Mi estas en la meza-Atlantika regiono. Ĉe la golfeto Ĉesapika
>>218820341Ĉu vi iam ĉeestis NASK?
>>218815220lel
>>218820441Me ne ankoraŭ ĉeestis Esperantistan aranĝon. Kiel estas?
>>218820599Tre bone, vi nepre venu ĉi-jare se eble.
I saw this while reading and thought there was a mistake
>>218807040what is fossilization?
>>218822162Mistakes ingrained by making them often.
>>218820631Kiel oni ĉeestus?
>>218810071comfy. the Mabinogion would be fun to read
>>218822407ah. So like how Dreaming Spanish says not to even attempt output until you have like 600 hours of input, otherwise you'll build bad habits?
I'm watching capeshit in my TL
Latin is going well but crikey, you retain the information learnt but actually retrieving it can be a pain and you get things mixed up.
>>218823497what's your TL and how far along are you? I'm just starting to understand the Intermediate videos in Dreaming Spanish and am wondering if it's worth marathoning Spanish dubs of the MCU, knowing that a lot of it won't be comprehensible.
Spanish and I'm pretty advanced in terms of listening and reading comprehension. Dreaming Spanish is already often too slow for me but I still watch it sometimes if the topic interests me. I think dubbed movies might still be too advanced for you but you could try powering through it if you're feeling motivated.
>>218824102>>218824470
Any tips on how to PROPERLY consume media to learn a language (in this case French)?Do I just let the movie/show play out like normal and hope I eventually pick it up, or do I go back and repeat after every sentence until I understand? Do I watch with subtitles (same language as audio), or will that distract from listening?
>>218824824What I do is watch something that has subtitles available that match the audio as closely as possible, but I keep the subtitles off. When I can't understand something, I relisten a few times, and if I still can't understand it, I check the subs. If it seems like a useful line of dialogue (unknown word, connected speech, etc.), then I make an anki card from it. Audio front, TL text back.I also listen to podcasts, but these are just to get some minimal extra input in while doing other shit. Podcasts are actually harder since there is no visual context, but I just listen continuously regardless if I understand.
>>218818925this is the only real Persian CI I found on YouTube but she only made 3 videoshttps://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLcOmYEmy0w5ugietm3fw8MOMi25A9TAsZ
Alternatives to Peppa Pig for A1/2 CI? Fuck that bitch, I wanna watch spongebob but my level is too low
>>218825438Bluey but it might be harder than A2
>>218824824I mostly do this >>218825083FWIW, DreamingSpanish (which is pretty respectable when it comes to language learning theory) says not to do this. They don't put subtitles on most of their videos and say you aren't supposed to be rewinding or making flash cards or even consciously trying to learn at all, you're just supposed to watch. The idea is that this is basically how children naturally learn a language.But, a lot of people ignore that advice and have good results anyway, and I hate when I don't understand something. I'm the type of person who will rewind and add subtitles to an English-language movie so I don't miss any lines.The big trick is to make sure it's comprehensible (IE, very low level for beginners, like Sesame Street stuff). My biggest mistake has been trying to advance too quickly, since the lowest level content is boring and I wanted to watch more interesting stuff. But even most kids cartoons are way beyond what a beginner should watch.Idk if there's a French equivalent to Dreaming Spanish, but DS is very good for Super Beginner and Beginner content.Also look up the show called Extra, it's a sitcom with versions in English, French, Spanish, and German made specifically for beginners. It's kind of a high beginner level, the first time I watched it was a version with English and Spanish subtitles and I needed the English subtitles a lot. But I watched it again after I was better at Spanish and didn't even need Spanish subtitles most of the time even though I was still kind of a beginner.
>>218818925you WILL learn to communicate with deaf kiwis and you WILL like it
>>218825696Dreaming Spanish also does Dreaming French although I think it's pretty new so there may not be a ton of content
>>218819968>nous nous>we we
>>218826904In French, nous means both we and us, or in this case, ourselves."We ourselves are called ____"
suprenigo
>>218822793Pretty much
Which is more impossible : Magyarul/hungarian or Finnish/Suomen kieli? Or are they all actually just impossible to comprehend?
>>218826904s'appeler
>>218822459Necesas antaŭe aliĝi per interreto kaj pagi kotizon. Ĉi-jare ĝi okazos en Klevlando kune kun la usona-kanada dulanda kongreso. Se vi ne emas veni al tiom granda kunveno almenaŭ serĉu proksiman klubon. Samkiel en ĉiu lingvo oni plibonigas sian kapablon parolante kun aliuloj.
>>218827764No, it's literally "we call ourselves". "We ourselves are called" would be "nous memes nous appellons".
remembering words NEVER becomes easier
>>218815220I laughed, but what the fuck are you talking about?
>>218826904>>218827764I think you can do it like this in Portuguese too>Nós nos chamamos Paulo e Maria Dumas.
>>218819404you are giving yourself ai psychosis, but if you do it in english it counts as input
>>218827764How about "vous vous", I see this all the time and idk what they mean by it. Seems almost interchangeable with "si vous" but that can't be right
>>218832726The first vous is subject and the second vous is object. Vous vous X = you X yourself/yourselves/each other.
>>218832726Just imagine the first vous is tu and the second one is te.
>>218824824>go back and repeatIf you're an autist who likes to rewatch the same shit over and over, then sure. That's not the "official" method though and the concept they offer is that the more variety you get the better. There are a lot of good youtube channels for french that are beginner-friendly but not literally peppa pig. Never use english subtitles, french subs are okay. Try to pay attention to it, even if it's at your level, if it's just playing in the background while you shitpost (I do this all the time btw) it's not nearly as effective as if you're focused and trying to understand the whole time. I've also seen the suggestion to take an old favorite in english and watch it through in TL if available, since you will already basically "understand" everything and know the plot and characters and you can just load up on vocabulary within that framework. Maybe I should binge through all of TNG in french
>>218825179thanks king
آپ سب کیسے ہیں؟
quemacocos is sunroof in Spanish
I HATE COLLOQUIALISMSI HATE IDIOMATIC EXPRESSIONSI HATE SLANGI HATE DIALECTS FUCK MY RETARDED LANGCEL LIFE
>>218834517this is the only stuff i actually like
>>218834517You know what they say and all that.
>>218834770> You know what they say and all thatI don't know what they sayI searched for this meaning because I didn't know it yesterday. And I was shocked. I probably wouldn’t have been able to use that expression if I were explaining the same context. I would have probably expressed it in a longer way, mentioning that I recorded my time.
>>218835304>clock insorry I mean this,
anyone else been having problems with ankiconnect? seems i can no longer use it with asbplayer
how do I train output as beginner one week in?
>>218836754Don't.
>>218824824you watch with TL subtitles and with word lookup. If you can follow most of it and it makes sense there's no need to repeat watch. If you can't understand it you should repeat watch until you can understand it
>>218819968Don't pretend that that isn't something that happens in english
>>218819968I don't think that that's that strange. Do you do?
>>218819968My friend asked me if I wanted to eat. I said I already had had two apples and he said that that was ok because he had had two too.
>>218819968Before I saw the replies I wasn't sure what the funny thing was supposed to be, I thought it was the name "Dumas" because it looks like "Dumbass"
Starting Japanese was one of the worst ideas I've ever hadNow I can't touch anything Japanese after having quitEveryday I go to work and I see something like 指にご注意してください but I can't start Japanese again
>>218837620Goddamn it I'm listening to the violent cop soundtrack and I see this comment> 晴れた日に独りで歩く時のテーマ
https://www.instagram.com/reel/DSKplCtDAEt/What is this Russian song
>>218830782Hungarian is less inviting in the beginning becausze of the orthography. I think beyond that they're about equally hard.But please choose a language already.
>>218836754Pimsleur
>>218832773>Maybe I should binge through all of TNG in frenchbut nobody speaks French in the future.
I thought I finally unlocked how to roll RsIt turns out I just lost my voice
kill kantousex kagoshimamarry kansai
Where do you start with Chinese?
>>218842995New practical Chinese reader 1
>>218843019How much is it? Is it online?
Honestly it is so bloody weird to me how German and Spanish and French are like "there is no hot water" like it is some philosophical statement, like the concept of hot water has ceased to exist in the universe, proper existential crisis in the shower, innit. Meanwhile in Korean we are basically like "hot water is not coming out" because shit, the hot water is supposed to come out of the tap. It is not some rare thing you either have or do not have, it is literally in the pipes, it is meant to show up. Where has it gone mate, why is it not coming out, why am I standing here getting flashbacks to winter, dripping and furious, because it is not about existence, it is about failure, it is about betrayal. The tap is lying to me, the boiler is ghosting me, the water is out there somewhere and it is refusing to come out. And then I see "No hay agua caliente" or "Es gibt kein heißes Wasser" or "Il n'y a pas d'eau chaude" and I am like okay cool but why are you lot acting like hot water is an item in a cupboard that is missing, as if someone checked inventory and went "yep, we are out of hot water today, sorry lads". Nah nah nah, in my head the hot water is a person who was meant to arrive and just did not turn up, absolute flake. And the whole vibe of Korean is like stuff "comes out" or "does not come out" because we care about what actually happens in real life, not this calm "there is there is not" shit, because I am not calmly observing reality, I am freezing and I want to report the crime shit. the hot water is not COMING OUT, full stop. Like do not tell me it "is not there", it should be there, it is late, it is cancelled, it is not showing up, and you are telling me French is over there doing the whole "il n'y a pas" like it is a polite dinner conversation while I am basically shouting at the shower like "oi, where is the warm one, come on, do not do me dirty". Bloody languages man, same situation, totally different mental model is needed
>>218843209You can probably find it on Anna's archiveI think it's about $25 if you want a physical copy
>>218843209looks to be this onelibgen .is/book/index.php?md5=D32155CD4D252C01CF8F02BC0B63F4CDannas-archive .li/md5/d32155cd4d252c01cf8f02bc0b63f4cdpractically every worthwhile textbook has been reuploaded to either anna's archive or libgen
>>218844175Don't provide links to people here, they should learn how to use libgen zlib and AA themselvesTeach a man to fish and all that
>>218838477seemingly sped up version of thishttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tn-z95ev64s
>>218843337The hot water is not there thoughbeit (meaning it’s not in the location I am expecting/wanting it to be).
>>218841708kill kantouno sex without marriagemarry touhoku
>>218840030I thought I didn't know how to rolls rs but it turned out I have been able to do it since I was kid, I just didn't know how to put them into a sentence. I still need to practice but I'm getting there. Nearly all the youtube videos on how to do it are shit, it's not easy to do, slightly raise your tongue, yet keep it relaxed, and then blow and it should vibrate. Don't pull the tip up, just lift the tongue up slightly but keep it loose and then blow.
>>218819404why are all of you koreans mentally ill maniacs?
I make so many mistakes speaking in french.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Trdd3eG9zFwfun resource for korean. marko's voice is uncanny with the original, and the other voices are all really good. overall i think the korean version is the best.
I watch 김수박, she always speaks at a beginner level
Do you ever look at how many hours you logged into something and think of what else you could've done in that timeframe? Between the paradox games I play, I've logged nearly 4,000 hours. Just think of the amount of languages I could've learned in the same time frame bros...
>>218852248yea as im getting older i want to kill myself more since i know i shouldn't be wasting my time but I still do
What level do you have to get to in a language to not immediately lose it all if you don't touch it for like a year? A2? B1?
>>218853483I think B1. I got to at least B1/B2 in Italian and then stopped for over a year. The fundamentals are still there. I’ve forgotten a lot of the vocabulary, but it starts coming back quickly after some review.
>>218853483I was b2 in Spanish, stopped for almost 4 years now... but it's still there, just waiting to come back. I can read ok but speaking and listening is not good. writing non-existentmy gf got to like b1 in Arabic but has completely forgotten it all after 2 years
>>218843337there is no hot water (in my shower, right now) and i literally have a tank full of hot water in my basement that should be full and hot, so if i don't have hot water coming out of the tap, surely i am out of stock of hot water
>>218852248Yeah that's why I'm here, I have wasted time OCD where I have to be super optimized all the time otherwise I hate myself but I can't actually deliver on the no-wasted-time schedule genuinely so I do copes like watching netflix in TL so my wasted time is slightly less wasted
I fucking hate japaneseIts so nice but exremely time consuming and hard and has this cursed reputation, literally no one must know I am learning itSometimes the utility goblins in my had tell that I need to learn something more useful or respectful, french maybe? Will women start backflipping when I talk to them or algo?
what's the best way to learn mandarin from scratch?
>>218854612put in the timedo the worklearn the radicalstalk to natives (in Chinese ONLY)
>>218854632where is a good place to talk to natives in mandarin?
>>218852248I could have learned Chinese like 3 times over and still took less time than I did playing PDX's shitty GroBPreuBBen generators.
>>218854919China
Easiest and hardest languages for native english speakers excluding difficulty of writing system (only speaking and understanding speech)And only including major languages (10m+ speakers)hardest:Korean>Japanese>Arabic>Mandarin>Thai>Vietnamese>Russian>Turkish>HindiEasiest:Spanish>Afrikaans>Swedish/Norwegian>Danish>Indonesian>Italian>French>Portuguese
>>218854007Does it really have a bad reputation among zoomers? back when I was a kid/teenager everyone loved japan. In 8th grade girls used to do the group dancing shit to J-Pop songs during recess
>>218846041Its their culture
>>218843337따뜻한 물 없어
>>218855182Other germanic languages are far easier than romance languages when it comes to comprehending speech. The cadence being the same is a massive boost, whereas romance language cadence feels like a blur, especially Spanish. On day 1 of learning German I could transcribe everything accurately because the mode of talking is so similar.
>>218855182how did you arrive to this conclusionalso, Japanese speaking/understanding speech should probably be much easierAlso I'm sure some of those African Bantu languages with nasal/aspirated/unaspirated/voiced/breathy voiced/click distinctions and like 8 tones are probably the hardestthere are 12 million Zulu speakers, so it countsgood luck with that one whiteboy
>>218855182Also another brutal Hiroshima-level trvthnvke or whatever: characters make Chinese easier, getting rid of them makes it harder
>>218854007The only languages "worth" learning in the modern age are English, Spanish, Chinese, and Japanese. Just learn whatever interests you and ignore the rest. That's why I chose Japanese for weeb stuff. >Will women start backflippingIt's not worth spending hundreds of hours on a language just so you can impress women for a few minutes. They lose interest just as easily as they gain it. And even then, the language with the best cost performance for getting a girl is probably Spanish for the Americas and Chinese for Russia. それとも、女性はそんな優しさに値しないw
>>218855286We don't say it like that when it comes to the context of the shower or the tap water
>>218855969>Japanesehahahahaha ok weeb
You don’t mind me spitting some Chinese right?最近我没有足够的时间学习中文,所以我感觉进度很缓慢… 顺便问你们这个问题,玩电子游戏是不是一个好方法?我在玩崩坏星穹铁道,感觉挺好的,但这里的语言我认为不太实用。我试过看电视剧这个方法,然而我对它们没有什么兴趣。
>>218843337the murky sprawling labyrinth of the white man's psyche is beyond your ability to comprehendwe are mysterious as the dark side of the moon
>>218855969You forgot Russian
>>218855969if youre a tall/good looking white guy learning any east asian language to fluency basically gives you free selection of asian cuties
Is it truly over? I have comprehensibly inputted for thousands of hours and made no progress. I know almost every word. My net vocabulary is ~20,000 and my active learning time is approaching 6000 hours. I am barely progressing through A1. Did /lang/ bullshit us all?
>>218856813might be over, but if you have 20k words then how is it that you think you're still A1
>>218856830CEFR levels are not based on total vocabulary.
>>218856843yeah, but vocabulary is part of it. what are you missing? i imagine after 6000 hours of input you can string together a couple sentences off the dome which, coupled with a healthy vocabulary, pretty much takes you to like B1 at least. if it's just because you haven't been grammarfagging and your ability to answer questions like>conjugate X in the abdicative intransmutable 5th person prophetic casethen don't worry about it, fuck 'em
>>218856929I have grammarfagged. I've done everything. I know all of the grammar, the vocabulary, and if I read off of a script, people tell me I sound like a native speaker. But I'm A1. I can't function in the language. I struggle with basic conversation. I can recognize every word in a book and still not understand the content.
>>218856813I thought you were making "gains NEVER before thought possible" and that you would shock everyone "especially the Serb"?
>>218856985If you know all the grammar and the vocabulary then this>recognize every word in a book and still not understand the contentIs not possible. The content is the words. If you know the words, and the grammar features associating them to each other, you understand the content.
>>218856988You lied to me. I followed every advice that you posted and it was all a lie.>>218857001No.
>>218857015Deep down you don't want to be fluent and you believe you deserve to be a monolingual. As soon as you encounter some gains you self-sabotage because you're afraid of success. But here's the thing, you're already fluent! You just have to accept it. Stand in front of the mirror and say "I am worthy of fluency. I am worthy of the admiration of natives. I am no longer afraid of letting fluency into my life." and so on.
>>218857148What is this self-help bullshit?
>>218857166Tell me about your mother.
holy fucking shit spanish is so fast with native speakers
>>218857195She's nice. She gave me a bunch of chocolates for my birthday two days ago.
>>218857217Speed stops being an issue after some time. It's the mumbling/poor enunciation that gets me.
>>218857277Wait until you discover mumble rap in your TL.
>>218857286Yeah I have no chance.
>>218856813how many hours of speaking practice?
>>218857625Dozens. But speaking practice is not important.
Goddamn it idk if I should start Japanese again
>>218857634It is.
>>218857716It's not. Only input is important. Right, Serbposter?
>>218857713You should, and you will.
>>218857768I read one page of Japanese last night sadly but this morning I had an existential crisis Idk what happened to my old anki deck, fuck
korean or japanese?
>>218857790Existential crises means the language learning process is working. Wagmi
>>218857802japanese
>>218857760I don't know anymore. Your extremely comedic failure has caused me to re-think some things. We must invent radically new methods to cover such special edge cases like you and Jordie.
>>218857833Do not compare me to Jordie. We're nothing alike. I chose and committed to a language for years.
>>218857836You're on opposite ends of the spectrum, but the results are still the same: permastuck at A0.
>>218857824does it because that shit hits hard sometimes
>>218857852And you're on the spectrum.Owned.Do not reply further.
>>218857836Calm down Leafjordie
>>218857870I was here before Jordie. Use my proper name or gtfo.
>>218857859It hits hard because you care deeply. And that passion will drive you to great places once you get out of the dark.
My existential crisis from my TL is that I'll never be a Pole. I'll never have grown up in Poland speaking Polish natively. I won't even reincarnate into a Pole. This has inspired feelings of giving up and no longer living.
>>218857909based translingual
>>218857909get a serious brain injury and take a bunch of psychedelics and go to poland. this will re-open a developmental neuroplasticity period in your brain and you will learn polish
>>218857982I was wondering actually if drinking would facilitate speaking/conversation practice. If it would help me open up, could the benefits last into sobriety?
>>218858018I definitely speak Spanish better when I'm drinking, so it might work for you
hilariously low IQ thread, what a joyride it’s been to read this garbage
>>218857878never really thought of it that way
>>218858475sorry
>>218858689you are special. you are scared. your thoughts are valid. you matter. you are brave. you are eating hair. i love you.
>>218857982>take a bunch of psychedelicsAnybody tried acidmaxxing for language acquisition? If the computer faggots can microdose to get better at coding then why can't we do it
>>218858833I'm the computer faggot
what do you call this shape in your TL
>>218858875Two semicircles of different sizes attached.
>>218858875Koreans would say >an egg in an egg>알 안에 알
has anyone tried solo journaling rpg games for language learning?
>>218857380>>218857380Imagine being one of these native language learner youtubersDreaming Spanish has people that have some amount of talent, and creativity and are able to come up with skits.show they'll do some dance and put on a show, with obviously a lot of effort put into itthen>laaaa caaasaaaa eees roooJoooand that's your whole life
>>218858875Une demi-sphère avec un noyau convexe
>>218843337Idk how hot water works in Korea, but in the US, we typically have a big tank called a water heater. This heats up the water, and then when we turn the hot water on, it uses the hot water from this tank. A hot shower uses hot water faster than it gets heated up, so if multiple people take showers in the morning then we do in fact run out of hot water. There is no hot water left in the tank. It will eventually be heated up, but at that moment, there is no more hot water left.
>>218860250Idk about the internalHot water not coming out is a case that happens once every five years, in South Korea
is there a free version of language reactor yet? it's not really doing anything special that a local run open source program couldn't do
>>218858833im planning to start microdosing on psilocybin soon for language/music improvements unironically
>>218861551start macrodosing on psyllium husk to improve your shitgains
Is there a reason why macacos do have imageboard culture and latinx dont?
>>218854007>utilityWhen will this meme die?
>>218858875蘑菇头盔
>>218854007>I need to learn something more useful or respectful, french maybe?Japanese is fairly useful because the japanese refuse to learn any other language. French is definitely not more useful than japanese because francophones are either niggers or they don't want you to speak french.
>>218854007English is the only language foreign women care about. They will want to speak with you in English. Even the jap women will want to practice their English.
Madainn mhath, a charaidean! Ciamar a tha sibh? Dè tha thu ag ionnsachad? Tha mi gu math, ach chan eil mo ròs Gàidhealach.
>>218861477check out lute
>>218863895Hispachan? Come on now.
>Sehnenscheidenentzündung>tendinitis lel what a mouth full
Thank God for /lang/.
>>218867684just talk faster
>>218867743/lang/ is Satan's doing, thougheverbeit.
>>218868597You're your own worst demon, canadian, don't blame a webpage for it
>>218868968If /lang/ weren't demonic, why does it always lie about the effectiveness of language learning methods, and tempt you to learn meme languages like Spanish or French?
I'll just hit you with an ad hominem and call you a fat retard just for these>meme languages like Spanish or French>effectiveness of language learning methodsIf you can't sort the wheat from the chaff within your own mind then you'll stay A in whatever language you're doing. You don't even get a number to go with it, not even a zero.
Words I learned today:insouciantveneryexchequercoterminousfissiparouseremiticalwhat about you
i had dream where a white guy was speaking my language but i couldnt understand him at all
>>218798555>>218801075Zoomers no longer experience this.
>>218870506please don't start a cargo cult; not that you would've, but you shouldn't anyways.
>>218866773Bad its dead for years and nobody cares...
>>218871177what?
>>218871658but* shit am I becoming dyslexic
>>218863895>>218871708I think there are hispanic boards on 8chIt took me 3 tries to post this because mentioning it is considered spam
getting there with french now i just need to figure out what to do once i make it
i regret learning languages I hate every country
>>218856396I think playing games is pretty inefficient outside of VNs and other similar stuff that is both text-heavy and requires you to actually read and understand everything. You could try VNs translated to Chinese or natively in Chinese. Other than that I suggest videos and livestreams on Bilibili, if you're not already watching them. China is a very big country with many Chinese, so surely you can find something that appeals to you after searching and going through complete dogshit for a few hundred hours. I once saw a guy who did nothing but livestream himself playing WoW3 MP with a Touhou mod, and another who would only post videos of Red Alert 2 and his fucking Cookie mod for it. You can't get content this bizarrely specific without an extremely large population.There's generated subs for every vid with an accuracy of like 95% or so which helps with learning. You could also try reading books.
>>218874345goose goose duck in TL is the highest possible ROI path to fluency
>>218874406The what now
May I take a moment to scream?
>reading modern Chineseez>reading Qing dynasty novels ez>reading Tang dynasty proseez>reading Mengzia little effort>reading the analectsabsolutely fucking impossible