>during the pen and paper incident, the Caliph Umar prevented Muhammad from writing his last wishesShouldn't it be like a giga heresy?
>>220307835If the Qoran itself says that the Prophet should be obeyed?Mayhaps they were afraid that Ali would be picked as Muhammad's successor?
wasn't he illiterate?
>>220308074Probably. He probably wanted a scribe to write it for him
>>220308176It's actually interesting because while Muhammad was probably illiterate, his favourite daughter wasn't.
>>220308074>>220308297Wasn't he a merchant or something? Wouldn't that mean he'd handle documents in some form, or at least read and sign them on occasion?
>>220308497you had your jews for that kind of thing
>>220307835Mentally ill freaks shouldn't be allowed to write
>>220308497No, his wife Khadija was the merchant. He guided the camel caravans or some shit
>>220308645t. Umar bitchboy
why havent anyone tried to unearth Mohammad tomb to see how he looked like
>>220308991good luck excavating muhammad's tomb in a country that has the quran as its penal code
>>220308991Because they probably believe hes completely undecomposed or reverted back into a little child or some retarded bullshit like that and doing so would shatter that myth
>>220309176 Not really. Muhammad was seem as human and not as divine as Jesus was
>>220308991> how he looked likewdym he’s probably dust at this point
>>220308497>>220308074Everything we know about his life was written down 150-200 years after his death. It's probably a heavily edited story. In Islam anything and everything can be denied.
>>220308991https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Destruction_of_early_Islamic_heritage_sites_in_Saudi_Arabia
>>220308497He was a literate Syrian who was a Student of a Jacobite Unitarian Christian Monk before he Met Salman and Ali
>>220309306this is the main reason why islam is so retardedfor every hadith and event in muhammad's life, there are multiple contradictory sources and the "canon" ones were chosen and written down by 1 (one) guy 200 years after muhammad's death the quran is literally right there, it says it's a complete book and that it contains everything you need to know about islam, but muslims ignore that and value the hadiths more even though they'd never admit that
>>220309241Uh huhthats why he was the most perfect being to ever walk the earth and everyone needs to be named after him ang get their head cut off for doodling him
>>220309368>The destruction of heritage sites associated with early Islam is an ongoing phenomenon that has occurred mainly in the Hejaz region of western Saudi Arabia, particularly around the two holiest cities of Islam, Mecca and Medina.[1] The demolition has focused on mosques, burial sites, homes and historical locations associated with the Islamic prophet Muhammad, his companions, and many of the founding personalities of early Islamic history by the Saudi government.[1][2] In Saudi Arabia, many of the demolitions have officially been part of the continued expansion of the Masjid al-Haram at Mecca and the Prophet's Mosque in Medina and their auxiliary service facilities in order to accommodate the ever-increasing number of Muslims performing the pilgrimage (hajj).[3]
>>220309844That was done by Wahhabis who pretty much believe most Muslims commit Shirk when they pray to Muhammad because you are only supposed to invoke God according to the Quran
>>220308991>>220309090>>220309176Because it'd contradict the Sunnah and maybe nuke Sunni Islam along with it. According to the hadiths the prophets' (including Momo) bodies are eternally perfectly preserved and cannot ever decompose, so if we opened up Mohammed's tomb in the Green Dome in Medina and found a bunch of bones either it'd mean the hadiths are completely fake
>>220309912I didn't know Muslims prayed to Mohammed
>>220309368>>220309844Completely irrelevant since the prophet's tomb is already known and nobody would dare destroy it. Not even the Qarmatians who sacked the Kaaba, shattered the black stone, and defiled the well of zamzam with hundreds of slaughtered pilgrims tossed in desecrated Momo's tomb.>>220310135They don't they just constantly invoke his name in everything they do and every ritual and every prayer all day every day. Semantics i know
>>220309306It was probably more like 30 years thoIt's the hadith that are written much later, with dubious validity
>>220309759Most perfect man
>>220310226صلو على محمد صلو على النبي I don't see how Muslims justify this while maintaining a "no shirk" belief where Shrines are to be destroyed
>>220310081>found a bunch of bones either it'd mean the hadiths are completely fakeIt was a metaphor o algo
>>220310361صلو على محمد ≠ صلو إلى محمد. شوية مثل قول "صلينا على المرحوم بعد وفاته" ولكن للحج حمادةSemantics again i know but good fucking luck getting them to admit the Mohammed stuff isn't shirk. But Allahu forbid you visit a Sufi scholar's tomb that right there is 1000% Shrik, Kufr, Zandaqa, crypto-judaism, etc and you deserve to get beheaded for ithttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_Sinai_mosque_attack
>>220310502Are you Sufi?
>>220310502>Most Muslims for the Majority of the Religion's history were MushrikinSome Salafists literally tried to justify not caring about Palestinians based on this btw, as Palestinian Muslims had a Maqam tradition
>>220310669>>220310669Saudis are the lowest muslims in history. Basically Umayyads reborn
>>220310833>Basically Umayyads rebornThe thing is, say what you must about those Degenerate ArabistsAt least Yazid and Muawiya and Marwan were appreciaters of Fine Arts and had a soft side for Christians Modern Salafists are weird Reactionaries chasing an imaginary "golden age of orthodox islam" that was only in Ibn Tamiyyah's mind
>>220309533How do I know what the Quran is with the hagiography? >>220310306I forgot it what's his name. The grand kid of Abu Bakr? who sent those letters are the earliest source. But that's just the basic skeleton of the story.
>>220311613YeahThese niggas would probably stone Muhammad himself if they met him
