>>42123316
she not
/end thread

>>42123348
she is
xy = male

>>42123316
Well she is but gender dysphoria is still real ans trannies are hot and easy to get to have sex with so we should let boys with dysphoria transition anyway, even if it's just for having sex with them

File: dysphoria.png (35 KB, 544x563)

35 KB PNG

>>42123381
gender dysphoria is fake too

>>42123390
>P-Tube
Topkek

>she
His name is Robert

>>42123390
>comparing observable physics to psychiatry
Dumbfuck

what if the world was made of pudding

>>42123316
she's so fucking MILF

>>42123316
I think she is wrong, I don't think trannies are pretending. But I also don't think trannies are identical to women. Kind of a third thing.

That being said, people should be able to do what they want so it doesn't matter either way.

>>42123638
you are the one who is wrong

>>42123390
"gender dysphoria" is autoheterosexual frustration at not being able to be your own girlfriend (for mtf) or your own boyfriend (for ftm)

>>42123316
England is a fallen nation and the royal family will be replaced by a sultanate by the end of this century.

>>42123316
She's clearly looking for a reason to exist. I hope that the beautiful hon j.k. Rowling can find a deeper meaning in her life that can bring her real happiness, but I'm truly proud that shes pushing so hard to escape the pain she feels :) she's a strong warrior! Truly :) you go girl!

>>42123852
i wish scotland was indepedent so i could become a politician and deport her to england

>>42123316
Absolute projection holy shit

File: KNEEL.jpg (287 KB, 1080x1440)

287 KB JPG

>absolute projection holy shit guys

>>42123316
Even if she were correct, so what?
In a few years I will have lived as a woman longer than my pre-transition existence. Exactly zero people have called me "sir" for over a decade now.
So either I'm "pretending" really well or I must have gotten something right about myself. Either way, it's immaterial to social reality.
Also, why exactly do opinions from a marginal third world island at the edge of Europe are so important?
I mean... it is the country that also comes up with news like this: https://www.dailystar.co.uk/news/latest-news/glam-6ft5in-model-kicked-out-36399985

It seems that over there in Jkrowlingstan they're even more confused about what is a woman than us trannies

>>42123793
How so?

Even if that were true why should she care? Let people live how they want to live, men embracing feminity rather than ridiculing it is a good thing, it's one thing we seem to have gone backwards on in history , sure women have a lot more freedoms now but their appearance interests and style choices are somehow still considered embarrassing when adopted by men, meanwhile in history men wore makeup, dresses and pink like it was nothing, there was also a lot more openness around sexuality without it always being such a source of discourse.

>>42123316
if?

>>42123316
guess i would simply be a man pretending to be a woman then
but how does that change anything?

>>42124515
It changes a lot of things

>>42124890
idk, to me it seems like it's only about how you call me

File: 1717149385819782.jpg (17 KB, 211x298)

17 KB JPG

>>42124903
If it's all pretend, then it's all an act. If it's all an act, then they can turn it off. If they don't turn it off despite objection from women and children, they are predators.

>>42124926
Children don't object. Children don't give af.
The opinions of women do not trample the individual rights of other people. Besides, women are actually overwhelmingly supportive of trans rights.
It's not "objections from women and children" - it's objections from a minuscule portion of old women upset that nobody takes them seriously anymore and that young passoids are mogging them.
It's all inter and intra-sexual competition at the end of the day.

>>42123804
Gender dysphoria is entirely unrelated to sexuality.

File: 1721319952684290.png (164 KB, 421x641)

164 KB PNG

>>42125777
is it tho

>>42125874
It is.

>>42123316
She is and they should not have equal status to women in everything because they are fundamentally different, but that doesn't mean they don't deserve to be respect as people too.

>>42123390
She has a point

>>42123316
The mold speaks.

>>42125777
And yet
Here we are
on a board
where "T" is part of the common initialism for weird sex people

>>42126334
My point stands.

>>42123316
Yes.

>>42123638
>I think she is wrong
>I don't think trannies are pretending.
>But I also don't think trannies are identical to women.
>Kind of a third thing.
So they're pretending to be women?

>>42123316
she's free to think that, but it's p much as retarded as denying climate change at this point. also working to marginalize ppl that arent harmful is obviously a bad thing

it's literally a semantic argument, you are arguing solely over the definition of "woman" (which is entirely arbitrary as all words are made up). if you waste your time engaging in such arguments you are simply retarded,

>>42123316
but trans women don't claim to have vaginas. if being a woman is having a vagina, how are trans women pretending to be women by taking estrogen and wearing different clothes?

>>42125874
>what about this pervert

>femininity is exclusive to women
She's dumb

File: 1747927034333425.png (1.15 MB, 768x1024)

1.15 MB PNG

>>42123316
Rowling is only relevant because trannies reacted to her in the first place. As to whether she is right or not is entirely up to trannies, trannies CHOOSE to take the stance that they are no different than cis women and if you say otherwise you're committing a hate crime and that is why trannies are losing.
Never forget that it is trannies who took hating trannies from a fringe position to a societal norm.

>>42126924
actually rowling is relevant because she's a billionaire who wrote the most popular children's book series in the world

>>42126944
That doesn't make someone relevant. Tell me one thing George RR Martin has tweeted out without looking. If when Rowling started tweeting nobody did anything the only people who would know or care about it would be the sort of retarded adultchild who already vehemently disagrees with her stance. Her entire platform is built on retarded fucking trannies who can't stop acting like circus clowns.

>>42126975
>That doesn't make someone relevant
yes it does lmao
any world famous billionaire can be relevant at any moment by opening their mouth

>>42126990
What did George RR Martin tweet about today? No looking, he's sooo relevant you should know.

>>42127003
how is anyone supposed to know what anyone tweeted without looking at twitter?
retard

>>42127009
Oh so you admit that you're wrong and that I'm right and that had trannies done absolutely nothing literally nobody would care about Rowling.

>>42127032
grrm is a relevant popular celebrity though
of course with nowhere near the wealth or reach as joanne

>>42127044
>JK Rowling tweets about trannies
>literally only her retarded faggot fans see it
>they're all a bunch of leftwing losers so they disagree with her
>she continues to be a completely irrelevant person
It's literally that easy. Don't know how I can lay it out for you any clearer. Anyone outside of your sphere only found out about Rowling because of the death threats.
I'm not going to sit here and explain to you what "relevant" means, you're proving my point that trannies willfully make themselves disliked right now.

>>42127094
>Anyone outside of your sphere only found out about Rowling because of the death threats
show me one single death threat she recieved

File: 1745607802788415.jpg (896 KB, 2148x1199)

896 KB JPG

>>42127118
The one I sent her.

>>42126897
Because they call themselves women?

>>42127094
>>she continues to be a completely irrelevant person
she's a world famous billionaire
trannies disagreeing with her doesn't make her any more popular

>>42126924
>trannies CHOOSE to take the stance that they are no different than cis women and if you say otherwise you're committing a hate crime and that is why trannies are losing.
The moment trannies started to state this is the moment when it was over.

>>42127134
other people using a word differently than you isn't them pretending
a person with one white parent and one black parent might describe themselves as both white and black, but white supremacists would disagree with them saying they're white. but they're not pretending to be white, they understand whiteness differently

>>42127144
Being a world famous billionaire does not make you relevant. You're confusing relevance for popularity. As I've already explained it and laid it out at this point you're either doing so because you're genuinely subnormal IQ or because you're bad faith, which is a good microcosm for the issue with trannies in general.

>>42126944
Children are dumb, they like Italian brainrot, used to love Skibidi Toilet, previously tiny toons, shit like that, kids liking something does not guarantee quality

>>42127160
>a person with one white parent and one black parent might describe themselves as both white and black
But it's actually true though? Like, it's biologically true.
Meanwhile trannies aren't biological females. They're biological males.

>>42127167
>Being a world famous billionaire does not make you relevant
delulu

>>42127178
>But it's actually true though? Like, it's biologically true
race doesn't exist is biology, there are traits that are more common across populations, but that's not race.
now address the actual point, trans women are not claiming to have vaginas, so it doesn't make sense to describe trans women as pretending to be women while also defining womanhood around having a vagina

>>42127147
so true
we should go back to the good old days when trannies were women in men's bodies and got sex change surgeries to become female
no more "identities", that just leads to this >>42127178

File: 1735642785633486.png (442 KB, 1433x661)

442 KB PNG

>>42127196
How do they feel about trannies?

>>42127211
>world famous

Your birth certificate should not be able to be changed, but you should be able to get a gender recognition certificate for their sex change.

if someone asks what your sex is you should be permitted to execute them on the spot

>>42127216
Explain how is she relevant, for instance what would change if Harry Potter, the only thing she's ever done disappeared.

>>42127200
Race doesn't exist but differences do. Obviously African and European people look different. Same how males and females are different.
>, trans women are not claiming to have vaginas,
Alot of them do.

>>42127242
there would be tens of millions of pounds less contributed towards transphobic campaigns and politicians in the last decade

>>42127242
I kinda feel like you know you're wrong and are just coping because you posted something dumb like 20 minutes ago or whatever

>>42127243
>Race doesn't exist
yeah, which is why you can't be "biologically white"
i accept your concession
>>42127243
>Alot of them do.
you mean a lot.
and no, they claim to have surgically altered genitals that they would describe as a vagina and that jk rowling would not. still not pretending, still just using a word differently

>>42127249
>the world would have one less evil person
An upgrade
>>42127265
>dodges the question
Answer, you made the claim

>>42127275
You can't be biologically white but you can have European phenotype. That is really different from African phenotype.

>>42127275
How are they not pretending to be females when they alter their genitalias to look closer to females

>>42127296
yeah, and a biracial person describing themselves as white isn't pretending to have a perfectly european phenotype, they're using the word white differently than white supremacists do.
>>42127309
how are they? pretending is something you do in your mind. physically doing something real and describing it differently than other people might isn't pretending.

>>42127294
>Answer, you made the claim
the claim that she's relevant?
because she's a world famous pop culture figure with billions of dollars, with wide reach on the internet and traditional media
perhaps you have a different understanding of relevance

>>42127216
Okay so what's George RR Martins stance on pepperoni pizza. No googling. He's so relevant you must know everything he does.

>>42127339
It's crazy to see the delusion in real time. No wonder trannies are used as scapegoats so much. You believe shit like this.

>>42127339
>dodges the question again
lol what a waste of oxygen

>>42127346
>He's so relevant you must know everything he does.
why?
I don't know either one of their opinions on pepperoni pizza

>>42127335
They're still not females? Females are born as females.

>>42127376
nope, some females are born as males

>>42127373
There you go. And that's because a bunch of fucking sausages haven't come out to send them death threats and platform their opinion. Trannies are retarded, they need to learn to do nothing because their actions are so fucking dumb that doing absolutely nothing would be better.

>>42127335
You can be mixed European and African
That makes you mixed.
So both european and african, alot of people agree on this.

>>42127387
Schizophrenia.

>>42127390
it's probably because jk rowling doesn't talk about her opinions on pizza
if she had a personal obsession with food and decided to share her opinions on pizza, there would be headlines about that too

>>42127394
>alot of people agree on this
but not everyone, because racial labels are subjective. however, when people disagree on those labels, neither one is pretending. they're just using different language to describe the same thing, because they feel different things are important

>>42123316
What if fire is hot?

>>42127405
that's not pretending either

>>42127410
There were no headlines about Rowling's opinion on trannies because there is no story there and she has no fucking relevance. It only blew up because of the backlash. You platformed her, I'm done explaining it, I've made it obvious if you're too retarded to get it there's no point discussing it further.

>>42127427
if you say controversial things there might be controversy
jk rowling being famous is why there are headlines. If she said she liked pineapple on pizza it's not the fault of people who disagree with her if someone writes a headline. and joanne's twitter account can reach millions of people without any disagreement at all
go kill yourself already

>>42123554
Troons fly into narc rages and threaten to kill yourselves over being called something you are, so you think people who won't indulge your fetishes will fly into narc rages and threaten to kill themselves over being called somethimg they aren't. Why are you like this? It's weird.

>>42124400
>Even if that were true why should she care?
Because it's had effects on public policy that are harmful to actual women.

>>42127468
If those people send her death threats and never shut up about her liking pineapple pizza for years and all the headlines are about that then yes, yes it is those people's fault. You literally give JK Relevance every day.
>>42127469
Trannies need to be banned from sharing their opinions. They should be put into dehonification camps and made to shut the fuck up. Transphobia solved in a decade.

>>42126895
Words mean things no matter how mucb pomo word salad you spew.