[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/lit/ - Literature

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 71TWfi7asJL._SL1500_.jpg (184 KB, 1000x1500)
184 KB
184 KB JPG
How is it?
>>
>>24694536
containment board please, the adults are trying to discuss literature
>>
>>24694540
why would I post there? They wouldn't read this because they hate jews
>>
>>24694542
We do too
>>
>antisemitism on the rise
>antizionism is a convenient vehicle for it
>instead of actual normal non-zionist jews coming out and writing books/articles about it, exclusively zionist jews come out and say:
>"YES, EXACTLY, YOU ARE RIGHT - IF YOU THINK ISRAEL IS COMMITTING GENOCIDE OR EVEN WAR CRIMES IN PALESTINE, OR EVEN THAT ISRAEL IS DOING ANYTHING WRONG IN PALESTINE, YOU ARE A NAZI, AND YOU MIGHT AS WELL GO FULL HITLER!"
kek god bless jews
>>
>>24694536
Any books on the psychological impact of needing to portray yourself with all the features of your enemy and your enemy with all of your own features in order to front with a trace of dignity?
>>
>>24694536
>The pictured Jew has completely aryan phenotype
>>
>>24694563
> GO FULL HITLER!
Ironic coming out the mouths of zionazis.
>>
>>24694685
>> GO FULL HITLER!
What does it even mean?
>>
>>24694536
Kek the review is just another jew hyping his fellow jew up.
>>
>>24694703
It means you’re in the process of ontologically becoming Hitler. A pure state which can only be attained by the most devoted of antisemites, like Greta Thunberg when she expressed her belief that Palestinian children are deserving of food.
>>
>>24694728
ἐντελεχειλχιτλερ
>>
File: 1756918166136277.jpg (85 KB, 640x800)
85 KB
85 KB JPG
>>24694720
Check again my fellow jew.
>>
>>24694563
>weaponize media and lobbying groups to equivocate criticism of Israel with antisemitism
>present Israel as THE safehaven for every Jew
>Jews are hated worldwide
>Israel's existence is on thin ice

I wonder what comes next. Will they have another trick up their sleeve or are they done for as semites cannot change?
>>
>>24694758
You're missing the game.
What's really happening is they're antagonising the millions of angry violent young muslim men to destroy governments and eventually justify more totalitarian rule and kill natives.
>>
>>24694770
How are they coming out of that on top?
>>
>>24694785
One theory I heard was that because islam is more compatible with judaism than christianity. When christianity eventually flips jews get removed.
So their goal is to destroy euro/schristians as a political force.
>>
abrahamic religions were simply a mistake
>>
File: 1580265667602.png (216 KB, 464x570)
216 KB
216 KB PNG
>>24694536
>you are literally a nazi if you don't support israel
How can anyone even tolerate being patronized like this by Jews all the time, seriously.
>>
>more /pol/bait
Go back
>>
>>24694563
>instead of actual normal non-zionist jews coming out and writing books/articles about it, exclusively zionist jews come out and say
There are no normal non-zionist jews. 90% of jews identify as zionist. Zionism means the belief that jews have the right to self-determination in a jewish state. Israel is the only jewish state in existence occupying 0.1% of the total landmass of the Middle East. Wanting to completely eradicate the jewish state (inevitably leading to the genocide of all Israelis) is thinly veiled antisemitism. The justification that Israel is mistreating Gazans by fighting a defensive war started by Gaza to end the rule of a terrorist regime that intentionally targets its civilians for rape, murder, and kidnapping, is thinly veiled antisemitism. Ignoring actual genocides and wars with much larger civilian casualties and actual war crimes like in Sudan and Yemen and instead focusing all outrage on the single jewish state fighting a defensive war against terrorism is thinly veiled antisemitism.
>>
>>24694563
>normal Jews are non-Zionist

I hate to break it to you but even most liberal as hell Jews still strongly support Jewish ethno nationalism. They are just liberal for every other race.
>>
>>24694847
Imagine doing this bit on fucking 4chan of all places. Not even the average normie is dumb enough to fall for this drivel anymore and you think this is the best place to try this act?
>>
File: idf.webm (3.07 MB, 640x360)
3.07 MB
3.07 MB WEBM
>>24694847
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I52jlzT8U-I
>>
File: 1644227189734.jpg (55 KB, 464x404)
55 KB
55 KB JPG
>>24694654
>They cannot create, only corrupt and destroy
Many such cases
>>
>>24694847
>Wanting to completely eradicate the jewish state (inevitably leading to the genocide of all Israelis)
"Yes"
>>
File: 1750265667602.png (2.47 MB, 2902x1258)
2.47 MB
2.47 MB PNG
>>24694847
Jews literally lived in every single part of the middle east for thousands of years. thousands. there used to be Jewish communities even in Yemen and Oman and Saudi Arabia before they were booted after Israel was created. You don't see this kind of stuff anywhere in Europe. In Europe, wherever a Jewish community formed up, it inevitably found its end a short time later in a pogrom or mass exodus. Jews were killed or kicked out of places nonstop outside of the middle east. The only tribe that started this war is, therefor, the Jews. Not anyone else. And I sincerely and wholeheartedly believe that if it weren't for Jews being extremely underhanded and evil, then sectarianism wouldn't exist in the levant and most of the middle east, and most of the middle east would be secular today. It's Jews who not only directly pushed and weaponized sectarianism across the middle east, but they provided the base foundation for its existence by giving Islamic fundamentalism a foil in the form of a Zionist Jewish state occupying Jerusalem.
>>
>>24694914
Have you heard about the jewish origins of the house of saud or the donmeh jews?
>>
>>24694914
>if it weren't for Jews being extremely underhanded and evil, then sectarianism wouldn't exist in the levant and most of the middle east

The logic of the extremely online, people are "brainwashed" into hating their enemy, instead of, hating their enemy.

Try telling an Isis member they are being manipulated by Jews into hating the shia, what do you think they'd say?
>>
File: image-19.png (267 KB, 407x426)
267 KB
267 KB PNG
>>24694563
>normal non-zionist Jews
bro
>>
>>24694930
>Try telling an Isis member they are being manipulated by Jews into hating the shia, what do you think they'd say?
Allahu akbar muhammed jihad
>>
>>24694536
>jew on the cover is presented as a fit, gigachad aryan
>look up the author
>he looks like this
>>
>>24695220
that's not really terrible physiognomy
>>
>jews cross aryans
>aryans punch back
>100 years of Jewish coping about aryans projecting mentally ill hate or whatever

Just stop harming others and you won’t be attacked. I’m convinced you fucks actually WANT to be genocided because nothing else could explain your outright refusal to not harm everything you touch.
>>
>>24695237
It doesn't matter if they do nothing at all schizos will accuse them of completely fabricated crimes like well poisoning and blood libel.
>>
>>24695225
It wouldn’t be if he chose better glasses frame. That turbo Jewish Eli Wallach nose is best paired with large glasses frames. You pair it with small and it looks like your nose is so big that your glasses are tiny by comparison
>>
>>24695810
>well poisoning and blood libel.
Weren't those found to actually be fully documented facts?
>>
>>24694785
They're not. What they do in Gaza and the gloating are them shutting their coffin loudly.
>>
>>24694847
>90% of jews identify as zionist
I forgot that (((you))) refuse to recognize Jews who don't support Israel as Jews.

>Zionism means the belief that jews have the right to self-determination in a jewish state.
There is no way to build an ethnostate without radical nationalism, since an ethnostate is a radical nationalist concept to begin with. It's fundamentally built on the concept of building a nation that excludes people not belonging to the ethnicity from participating in it. Motherfuckers got so spooked by Hitler they now dedicate their lives to imitating him, disregarding how it all ended up for him.

Meanwhile Scots, Basques, Tartars, Galicians, Catalans all have self-determination without building ethnostates.
>>
>>24695810
> The most cited case is around Acre (Akko) in 1948, where Israeli historian Benny Morris (using Israeli archival material) and others have written that Haganah operatives contaminated wells with typhoid bacteria. According to declassified Israeli documents, this was part of an operation called “Cast Thy Bread”. The goal was reportedly to deter villagers from returning and to slow enemy advances.

Totally sane people
>>
>>24696566
20% of Israel is muslim arab with full rights of citizenship
>>
>>24696728
That does not excuse apartheid in the Occupied Palestinian Territories.
>>
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sS9xidsyxXY
>>
>>24696809
I agree. It doesn't excuse how the ruling government in Gaza (Hamas) discriminates against jews.
>>
>>24696830
3 out of 10 bait. Try reddit.
>>
>>24696830
Isn’t this a bit like complaining about how Indian reservation discriminated against the white man?
>>
>>24696871
No because Indians are indigenous to the land like the jews.
>>
>>24696871
indian reservations never fired rockets in Phoenix
>>
>>24696728
>20% of Israel is muslim arab with full rights of citizenship
So, it is not a jewish state?
>>
>>24696830
Hamas are literally israeli owned and controlled.
>>
Feels like the competent Kissinger Jews are being replaced by violent shtetlbillies that can’t run the game like the previous generation.

Normies are interacting worth outright nazi materials on the internet. All my normie friends hate Israel and it’s not even just because of recent tragedies in Gaza. In the long term Israel is in big trouble.
>>
>>24696879
Germany is a German state yet it gives minorities rights as well.
>>
>>24696878
Maybe they should have.
>>
>>24696880
Then surely you agree that they should be destroyed and deposed from ruling Gaza
>>
>>24696884
you are taking the wrong lesson here. pallies should have built casinos
>>
>>24696883
Federal Republic of Germany is not classified as a state of or for any single given ethnicity. It's Basic Law is explicitly irredentist, and it's extremely history includes a peaceful and highly effective reunification with another neighboring state which housed an ethnically close population with a radically opposed ideology.

You could not pick a better example if you tried.

Before you try, I will remind you that USA is not an "American state" (practically the opposite desu), UK is not an English state, French Republic is not a French state, Russian Federation is not a Russian state, and People's Republic of China is not a Chinese state.

The whole thing is that you fundamentally can't have an ethnostate without ethnic discrimination. If it "doesn't discriminate against Muslim Arabs" then it inherently stops functioning as a "Jewish state", since then it can develop an Arabic majority and, say, elect an Arab president.
>>
>>24696895
Lebanon did. Look where it git them.
>>
>>24696911
What about Japan?
>>
File: CasinoduLiban.jpg (57 KB, 800x594)
57 KB
57 KB JPG
>>24696916
they are not a shithole because of casinos, quite the contrary. imagine what a gambling, boozed, and hookers-friendly Levant could have been vgh
>>
>>24696920
Japanese foundational legislature is fucking weird, courtesy of being a product of Douglas McArtur wiping his ass with a piece of rice paper that contained a collection of haiku praising the Emperor. It goes on to define Nippon-koku as a state of Japanese people, and also as a symbol of the Emperor, and also goes on to de-ethnificate the concept.
>>
>>24696932
Japan has less minorities in it than Israel
>>
>>24696878
Indian reservations got in wars all the time with American settlers in 19th Century. They didn’t fire rockets but they sure as hell did things like October 7th
>>
>>24696937
And they gave up and are alive now with comfy reservates. Thanks for proving my point.
>>
>>24697254
Well most got exterminated actually and their reservations kept shrinking because the treaties kept being broken by the settlers. Having been on an Indian reservation visiting friends before, I would not call them “comfy” since many of the houses lack utilities. Most Indians would probably be way happier with their old way of life but the land they have was just the land so shitty that white settlers didn’t want it to enough to take further. The situation of Palestinians is even worse since they weren’t and aren’t nomads, they have a developed society with universities and agriculture, most of the former bombed, most of the latter seized. So their population is way to dense to just be supported on the wasteland scraps, and also due to natural gas, there aren’t even enough scraps considered too shitty for Israel. Also Jews lack the same genetic disposition for sense of remorse that whites have, so they will never be able to regret what they r or ever try to make amends and will probably even be offended by the idea that any ethnicity is entitled to the same rights as Jews are because they preach humanism but don’t have the faculties to feel it, they mostly understand loyalty to Jews at the expense of anyone else except for the unusual bird like Hannah Arendt (who was deeply criticized for lacking “Jew love”)
>>
Chad on the Cover is David Beckham: JEW. You will never be as strong, admired, proud, wealthy as this man, all we can do is mire.

>David Beckham: “I am proud to be part of the Jewish community”
The football legend talks about his grandma's chicken soup, wearing a kippah and his childhood in East London
>>
>>24697295
Your chad Jew pro-Palestine. BASED!
>>
File: chad.png (77 KB, 384x563)
77 KB
77 KB PNG
>>24697295
this image refutes the author
>>
>>24694825
Christianity seems a lot more compatible imo. There's no muslim equivalent of dispensationalist baptists worshiping kikes afaik
>>
>>24695220
>>
>>24696911
So? Ethnic discrimination is good.
>>
>>24698676
It’s considered antisemitic unless Jews do it, and antisemitism Jews hold to be NOT GOOD
>>
>>24694536
Whenever zionists bomb some disordered arab country with the help of the united states they go into a big tough guy act and talk about how they are aided by god and so on. But then when anything goes wrong for them they instantly adopt a pitiful act to elicit sympathy, about how they are weak and in peril and there will be another holocaust any minute This rabbi depicts jews as some sort of aryan superman, but in reality he looks like pic related.
>>
>>24699510
Everyone does that, especially Palirats.
>commits terrorism
Hell yeah!!! Heroic act of liberation. We are big and strong.
>Israel retaliates
OMG!!! they bombed our stack of ammunitions, it's a genocide
>>
>>24696936
I know. The point was that deliberate ethnostate is dead concept.
>>
>>24699524
Deflection. Also, Palestinians are fighting for independence (not terrorism).
>>
>>24699709
You guys are so dishonest. All this performance and righteous indignation, but all you seek is power. Because you think you have the power of the collective on your side and don't fear punishment, you show a complete disregard for any ethical principles or logical consistency.
>>24699654
How is Israel an ethnostate? Because of right of return? Even Germany and other European countries have that for Americans with Gerrman or respective European ancestry.
>>
>>24699723
>a people being genocided
>''but dude why aren't they consistent with the moral framework I invented?"
>>
>>24699752
If you're not going to be consistent then Israeli's don't have any obligation either, dummy. You will cry genocide and in the same breathe champion mass murder. If that is the kind of world you want to live then may the strong win.
>>
>>24694 anti Zionism is the only socially acceptable way to criticize Jews so yeah people are going to latch onto it.

I’m not allowed to say “I really hate how Jews are ethnically replacing Europeans” without losing my job.
I’m allowed to say “I really hate how Jews are ethnically replacing Palestinians”.

It still makes Jews seethe and I get to stay employed.
>>
>>24699758
Can't we sit on bolshevic jews too, or liberal porn jews or has the overton window not shifted far enough?
>>
>>24699785
*we shit on
>>
>>24699757
Don’t put words in my mouth hysteric faggot.
>>
>>24699757
Retardanon, Israel always flouted both accords and international humanitarian law. To pin the blame of Israelis kneecapping unarmed children on KKKKHamas shows you have 0 (zero) knowledge about how the world works. Also, I'm going to shoot your child because it threw a rock at my tank.
>>
>>24699723
>How is Israel an ethnostate?
I'm not the one who brought up "belief that jews have the right to self-determination in a jewish state".
>>
>>24699817
Honestly, does it matter? There's dozens of places where Jews come from that want to see them die. It's not like they're able to return.
>>
>>24699822
pilpul
>>
>>24699822
>Honestly, does it matter?
If it doesn't matter then there should be no need to create a Jewish state.
>>
>>24699858
You “forgot” to read the other part of my post where it explained why there is a need for a Jewish state.
>>
>>24699863
>Israel is not an ethnostate!
>Here is why Jews do need an ethnostate btw
Why are you like this?
>>
>>24694536
I am sympathetic to the Zionists. They rejected the idea of being a middleman or tied to the role of urban financier/etc. which are stereotypically Jewish. Instead they struck out into the farms, built things, etc. They built a nation from the ground up. I wish my people had such fiber.
>>
>>24699886
Define an ethnostate. Because if it means a state created to be a haven for a persecuted group of people then it is. If it means apartheid against religious and ethnic minorities then Israel does not fit the definition.
>>
>>24699817
Ok, but you leftists aren't even opposed to race based policies. You self hating faggots are ok with reparations or other explicitly race based policies for natives or other minorities all over the west. The law of return can be seen as restorative also because jews were scattered and everything. That is in-keeping with your faggy ideology.
>>
>>24699801
Shut the fuck up retard. Either terrorism is wrong or you're a deceitful power hungry nihilist.
>>
>>24699952
>please please please let us have an ethnostate goy
>>
>>24700028
No argument means you are ok with the hypocrisy thus you have a prejudice and Israelis are vindicated and don't have to listen to you.
>>
>>24700046
The argument is international law and your kosher countrymen are seething hard over it.
>>
>>24694758
>Israel's existence is on thin ice
Lol! Imagine being this delusional.
>>
>>24700050
International law is ok with the existence of Israel and the law of return stupid. And I'm not even a jew if you can believe it.
>>
>>24699935
>Define an ethnostate.
Leftists have no neutral definition of an ethnostate. They have to fit it into larger power dynamics. If oppressed, it's good, and if having power, it's bad. No American leftists would argue for open borders on a Native reservation, But Sweden? Poland? racist for not letting in millions.
>>
>>24700060
International law is not okay with Israel being an apartheid ethnostate. Try again and stay on topic.
>>
>>24700070
So the law of return doesn't make Israel an apartheid ethnostate? Thanks for conceding my point.
>>
File: 1755490084833241.jpg (99 KB, 828x612)
99 KB
99 KB JPG
>>24694542
/pol/ is a jewish board. /lit/ is an anti-semetic board.
>>
>>24700077
The selectiveness of the law of return does, and that’s exactly my point:
>UN General Assembly Resolution 194 (1948): affirms that refugees wishing to return to their homes and live at peace “should be permitted to do so at the earliest practicable date.”
>Israel has not allowed their return, arguing it would threaten the state’s Jewish character and demographic balance.

In other words: illegal apartheid state. Thanks for conceding my point.
>>
>>24700113
You rekt him
>>
>>24700113
That has nothing to do with the law of return. Try again.
>>
>>24700125
There is nothing to discuss, you’ve been btfo as I cited international law against you and showed Israel’s illegal denial of law of return to the land.

Either contest the validy of IHL (which not even Israel did considering they were present at the Hague) or close the thread.
>>
>>24700113
Why should the Israelis have to give right of return when Pakistan does not give it to the people that were kicked out during Pakistan’s formation? In both cases a state for a certain people was established and those who didn’t belong to that group were violently made to leave.

>the people kicked out of Pakistan went to India
And the people kicked out of Israel went to Lebanon, Jordan, etc. what’s the difference?
>>
>>24700133
You don't understand what you are talking about. The UN is talking about the right to return for Palestinians on the basis of residency whereas the Law in Israel is based on DNA which the UN has no issue with. Either way the Israeli argument is completely valid. International law is not sacrosanct. Why would you willingly destroy your country for idealism?
>>
File: Hitler Surprise.jpg (11 KB, 209x203)
11 KB
11 KB JPG
>>24694536
I like the way he is literally the German gigachad phenotype from propaganda, they just stuck a kippah and a star of David on him.

Couldn't they have made the gigachad jew? Indeed, what does the gigachad jew look like?
>>
>>24700113
Resolution 194 is a resolution and not legally binding
>>
>>24700189
On what is it based?
>>
>>24700159
Looks like David Beckham, Who is Jewish and proud of it.
>>
>>24699908
They just stole farms from the locals. Anything they lacked people to farm, they bulldozed. To work the farms they have they have to hire Palestinians. And Indians, now.
>>
>>24700133
>>24700189
HAHAHA
So Israel technically wasn't even breaking any international law on the basis of the law of return. For all your gloating, you were completely wrong the whole time.
>>
>>24700159
It looks very much intentional.
>>
>>24700214
• Most legal scholars and UN bodies say Israel’s blanket denial of Palestinian return violates international law (Res. 194, UDHR, ICCPR).
• However:
• UNGA resolutions like 194 are not binding, though they express international consensus.
• Enforcement mechanisms (like ICC or ICJ rulings) haven’t been applied directly to Israel on this issue.
• So: Yes, under international law it is considered illegal — but politically, it remains unenforced.
>>
>>24699935
Israel gives citizenship to anyone of Jewish ethnicity while denying it to many people born in the land they claim including denying those people the right to return after being expelled, specifically because the natives aren’t Jews. The fact that their pretense for Jewish ethno nationalism is that the Germans persecuted them, doesn’t make it different from ethno nationalism for any one else. Ethno nationalism for freed slaves was also championed, Liberia, and the exact same thing happened
>>
File: great great.jpg (61 KB, 959x277)
61 KB
61 KB JPG
>>24700212
>grandfather's maternal grandmother
What percentage is that anon? Assuming that grandparent was 100% Jewish?
>>
>>24700136
Palestinians forced to live in refugee camps in those countries are generally not given citizenship and forcing them into Lebanon lead to the Lebanese civil war including the massacring of Palestinian civilians which was backed by Israel—ever see Waltz with Bashir?
>>
>>24700217
I don't care about opinions. You cited international law. According to the UN Israel has no legal obligation to take in Palestinians. Admit you got BTFO'd, there is more dignity in it.
>>
>>24700217
The UN is under the impression that mixing oil and water is a good thing, so why should anybody listen to them?
>>
>>24700230
Interesting cope angle, but these are legal opinions based on international law.
>>
>>24700227
>Palestinians forced to live in refugee camps in those countries are generally not given citizenship
So go protest in Lebanon/Syria then, they should give citizenship to the refugees. If some dude is born in Lebanon, lived there his whole life, and the last time his family was in Israel was 80 years ago, he’s Lebanese.

The killing of civilians is bad but again it should be something to argue with the Lebanese about. They were the ones who did it.
>>
>>24700230
You’re confusing enforcement with legality. The right of return is clearly recognized in the UDHR, ICCPR, and UNGA Res. 194. That Israel isn’t forced to comply doesn’t make the denial legal — it just means the law isn’t enforced. Plenty of violations go unenforced; that doesn’t erase the right itself.

Just admit you got btfo by a chatbot
>>
>>24700242
> If some dude is born in Brooklyn, lived there his whole life, and the last time his family was in Israel was 2000 years ago, he’s American.
Wow, that’s antisemitic.
>>
>>24700240
Who cares? All sort of people can have opinions, but as your chatgpt answer states 194 is merely a consensus, not binding. No laws being broken all along.
>>
>>24700220
Doesn't that make him a goy anyway as its passed down maternally?
>>
>>24700242
They did it with Israel military backing of Lebanese Christian paramilitary (or as they’re called when Muslim, terrorist) groups

Waltz with Bashir is an Israeli movie about the war, made by a former IDF soldier, and it’s worth watching
>>
>>24700028
You say this as if it's a bad thing.
>>
>>24700251
You’re mixing up enforcement with legality. International law recognizes the right of return in binding instruments like the ICCPR, not just in Resolution 194. Israel’s refusal conflicts with those obligations. The fact that there’s no enforcement mechanism doesn’t make it legal — it just makes it unpunished.

Also, Israel was shitting its pants during the ICJ trials so they do care. They see the way the wind is blowing but you still don’t.
>>
>>24700254
I would assume so, going by rabbinic orthodoxy, though some in Jewry at large would likely claim him because of his fame and popularity. Regardless, the argument of his physical appearance representing what Jewish people look like is clearly bunk because of his tiny amount of dna, and the obvious reality that he looks nothing like Jewish people but instead looks like those from his majority dna group, English.
>>
>>24700265
Jews have to steal genes to look somewhat respectable
>>
>>24700213
For me it’s more the Zionist dream than the Zionist reality. The idea of getting empty land, and building a country of farms and olive groves and universities and hi tech industry on top of it is a dream for me. No more oppression, no more being kicked around by other faiths and peoples, no more mockery. No more pogroms or genocides. Instead you get to become the people who you were meant to be.

I admit the reality is not what I described. And the awkward problem is that the Zionist dream, insofar as it was achieved, came at the cost of the Palestinian people’s dreams. But it is a beautiful dream.

I feel that the world’s problems stem from the fact that not every people have an Israel. If the world was divided into hundreds of Israels, one for each ethnic/religious/linguistic group, there would be global harmony.
>>
>>24700247
You're coping. It is just a political stance and has no legal authority. Also lol at out sourcing your thinking to a chatbot, but even then it agrees with me. You have no further arguments so my work here is done.
>>
>>24700276
No coping here. The right of return exists in binding international law (ICCPR Art. 12(4), UDHR Art. 13(2)) — not just UNGA 194. Israel ratified the ICCPR in 1991. Denying Palestinians return isn’t ‘just politics’; it contradicts a treaty obligation. Enforcement is another matter, but pretending it’s not law is just wrong.

Are you going to outsource your thinking too? Maybe I could learn something from you, for a chance.
>>
>>24700264
This is a contested view. Unless some authority adjudicates you can't say it's illegal. No court has ordered Israel to do anything in regards to right of return.
>>
>>24700295
If the worlds most expert scholars on international law agree it’s illegal, why are you in such a hurry when asked to dispute it?

Also
>non enforcable so legal

So the worldwide unpunished war crimes are legal?
>>
>>24700276
I know you're still lurking, please address >>24700278 >>24700322
>>
>>24700322
It's contested retard so I don't agree that they are violating laws. For example ICCPR Art. 12(4) only applies to citizens and states have a right to control immigration, but my point is that you made it sound so authoritative earlier when you were all "I'm actually citing international law", but turns out there isn't any legal obligation. You got caught.
>>
is mowing down your own civilians with apache helicopters a jewish practice?
>>
>>24700349
You’re blatantly lying now, so let’s be clear:

> It’s contested
Lie #1
“Contested” ≠ legal. Almost every war crime is “contested” by the perpetrator. By your logic, the sky isn't blue as long as it's ''contested''.
Challenge: name one recognized international legal body that says these transfers are lawful.
Quote my challenge verbatim, and then answer. No answer = you concede and get no more replies from me.

> ICCPR Art. 12(4)
Lie #2
Article 12(4): “No one shall be arbitrarily deprived of the right to enter his own country.”
You twist this into “only citizens count, so Palestinians can be excluded.”
Wrong. Many Gazans are stateless because of Israeli policy. UNGA Res. 194 and ICJ rulings explicitly affirm that denial of return = violation of international law.

> States have a right to control immigration
Lie #3
This isn’t “immigration control.” Gaza is occupied territory. Fourth Geneva Convention, Art. 49: “Individual or mass forcible transfers… are prohibited, regardless of their motive.”

That makes it population transfer under occupation (a war crime). Either you deny Geneva IV or admit transfer is illegal. Which way, shill?
>>
>>24700385
I said it was contested to point out how impotent your position is. No court has made a decision yet. Not that on its own it proves legality.
I'm not going to take you up on the challenge because it doesn't prove shit.
>No one shall be arbitrarily deprived of the right to enter his own country.
Yes, country. Israel was not and is not the country of Palestinians
>Fourth Geneva Convention, Art. 49
Came into force in 1950 and can't apply retroactively

This is a stupid conversation. You have been exposed for being a shameless dishonest faggot
>>
>>24700420
The climax of your argument: total silence on my challenge, followed by cope about how it “doesn’t matter.”

>“No court has ruled”
Lie #4.
ICJ 2004 Advisory Opinion + UNGA Res. 194 both affirm the illegality of forced displacement/denial of return.

>“Israel was not the country of Palestinians”
Lie #5
Palestinians are stateless because of Israeli policy. International law covers occupied populations so your “country” cope is irrelevant.

>“Geneva IV doesn’t apply retroactively”
Nobody said retroactive. Geneva IV governs Israel’s current occupation of Gaza and the West Bank. You got caught trying to argue against a strawman.
The right of return is established separately in UNGA Res. 194 and reaffirmed by the ICJ (2004). Your “only Jews have a right of return” argument is Israeli domestic law, not international law. Under IHL, denying Palestinians return because they’re not Jewish is itself a violation.
>>
File: KosherSalt.jpg (19 KB, 360x360)
19 KB
19 KB JPG
>>24700420
>>
>>24694548
>We
>>
>retards trying to do legalese against kikes instead of just calling them kikes
anon I...
>>
>>24700504
Jewish suffering must be kept at a maximum. Cornering them in a discussion is one way to do so. However, reminding a jew he broke the law is like giving a child candy.
>>
>>24700517
Forcing accountability upon a Judean is like saying a demon's name out loud.
>>
File: markup_1000005674.png (1.45 MB, 1400x1585)
1.45 MB
1.45 MB PNG
>>24700502
Jews should get the rope
>>
>>24700420
Hey Ben Shapiro, why did you fuck off the immediate moment you were asked to answer a question head-on?



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.