Essential leftist literature?
Principles of CommunismCritique of the Gotha ProgrammeValue Price and ProfitThe Communist ManifestoThe Jewish QuestionSocialism scientific vs UtopianState and Revolution
>>25204149Ready Player One
the book of disquiet
>>25204149the bible
GPT tier question, get with the times
>>25204154>no capital
>>25204149all available on marxists.org>Bloch, The Principle of Hope>Horkheimer, The Social Function of Philosophy>Adorno and Horkheimer, The Culture Industry>Benjamin, On the Concept of History
>>25204149In current year? None.
AdornoBakuninDebordGorkyGramsciHarveyKeynesKropotkinLeninFoucaultPopperRawlsSartre
>>25204149
>>25204320>Keynes>Foucault>Popper>Rawls
>>25204392Whoop whoop
>>25204149Poop.
>>25204149google "how to tie a noose"
>>25204149Hegel, Marx, Engels, Lenin, Stalin, Mao, Ilyenkov, Deng, Parenti, Hudson. Forget about fucking losers like Adorno and Bordiga or Debord, they've accomplished nothing. Western leftists love to worship losers and hate on the ones who actually did something meaningful.
>>25204149107 Days by Kamala HarrisWhat Happened by Hillary ClintonA Promised Land by Barack ObamaAntisemitism in America: A Warning by Chuck SchumerBecoming by Michelle ObamaHow to be an Antiracist & Antiracist Baby by Ibram X Kendi
>>25204582Mass murder qualifies one as not a loser and counts as meaningful, got it. At least the second term carries a note of "historically important", which is plainly true, but of course not in the unwarranted positive sense that you seem to have in mind.
>>25204149The hidden hand
>>25204686You are the raped. And when the West finally catches up to China and gets liberated, you won't get to enjoy freedom. You'll be raped, once again, you miserable disgusting faggot.
>>25204771Mao was a class collaborationist. Look up what the stars on China's flag mean
>>25204149It's literally all trash religious cultist bullshit.
>>25204582>something meaningful.Like destroying nations, killing tens of millions of workers? lmao>>25204771>brainwashed marxist calling others rapedlmaoalso china isn't communist nor is attempting communism. You are mentally ill.
>>25204149my diary desu
>>25204149How to Be an Antiracist - Ibram X. KendiWhite Fragility - Robin DiAngeloDiagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 5th Edition: DSM-5 - American Psychiatric Association
>>25204149Are there any books out there for a layman not steeped in Marxist theory that discusses the implication of catering entire economies to the wealthy like we're seeing now, especially with artificial intelligence? If my history is correct, then I think the last time this occurred was in the nineteenth century, and it led to colonialism. But now that there aren't any untapped markets left to exploit thanks to globalization, will it just be a race to the bottom on a massive scale to squeeze as much wealth as possible out of the masses?
>>25205055All these classes which collaborated with the proletariat were ultimately acting under pressure to serve proletarian interests, you fucking retard. Which is pretty much what Marx and Engels suggested when they wrote that peasants and pauperised petty bourgeois could join forces with the proletariat. You’re a retard cuckold.>>25205597Lenin, Stalin, Mao, Deng, Xi etc. all modernised backwards nations and doing so, saved billions of people.>china isn't communist nor is attempting communismYou lying faggot, every single five-year-plan is conducted for a final aim: socialist modernisation which is the term the CCP uses to describe higher phase communism. Kill yourself, leftcom tranny.
>>25206237So when is the Chinese state planning to abolish itself?Because it just keeps on getting bigger, more intrusive and more repressive.
>>25206237>famine is modernisation, and saves billions of people
>>25206237China will NEVER stop being authoritarian.
>>25206237found the delusional tankie cultist lol>leninlmaohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bWWqhsh848E>StalinHis entire nation industrialized due to insane levels of capitalist investment. Western capitalists basically built the entire USSR's economy Read Sutton's work on this.Also stalin wasn't necessary for soviet development, in fact he hindered it.https://www.nber.org/papers/w19425>maoliterally killed tens of millions of people in failed central planning experimentsI know you probably think it's heckin based to be forced onto shitty inefficient collective farms at the point of a gun and forcefully starved but this is what happened.>DengMoved away from socialism and towards capitalism. That's the reason China industrialized. They aren't going back to socialism.>XiRetard that is moving away from the policies that made china rise. The country is experiencing a decline thanks to him.>higher phase communism.lmao meaningless marxist gobbledygook. You people are mentally ill religious cultists.
>>25206478>So when is the Chinese state planning to abolish itself?This shit is so fucking funny lmao.Marxists will cope by redefining what a state means and pretending it always meant that.
>>25206529>>25206237Not to mention the fact there were countless market economies that went from third world to first world, much faster than communist ones and with less bloodshed.Marxist countries only industrialize when they get help from capitalists or switch to capitalism themselves.China, USSR and Vietnam are perfect examples.I don't know how tankies can see modern Vietnam and not immediately want to kill themselves, as it's a direct refutation of their beliefs.
>>25206237Killing the SSparrowSS were necessary to achieve communism. Class collaboration is awesome when it's red. Grass is blue.
>>25204149Economics:1. The Elgar Companion to Marxist Economics2. Marx - Das Kapital3. Lenin - Imperialism4. Nkrumah - Neo-Colonialism5. Baran & Sweezy - Monopoly Capital6. Emmanuel, Arghiri - Unequal exchange: A study of the imperialism of trade7. Paul Cockshott - Towards a New Socialism8. Keynes - The General Theory (Keynes wasn't a socialist, but trying to understand any discussion in post-1945 Economics without reading him is a fool's errand). Politics:The absolute first thing you should read, before the following is G.D.H. Cole's "A History of Socialist Thought". It's an absolute masterwork, detailing every new ideological and philosophical development in Socialist theory from the French Revolution, until the collapse of the Comintern, and it provides a shitload of historical context that you won't easily find anywhere else. Beyond that:1. Karl Marx - The Political Writings (Three Volume set, contains everything important by him. 2. Lenin - Essential Works (The Most important ones are 'The State and Revolution', and 'What Is To Be Done?')3. Mao - Five Essays on Philosophy & Five Golden Rays4. Fanon - The Wretched of the Earth5. Federici - Caliban and the Witch6. Huey Newton - Revolutionary Suicide7. Sophie Lewis - Abolish the Family8. J. Joseph Finkle - Screw Consent (The single greatest breakdown of the role of consent in sexual-politics that I've ever read). 9. Antifa: The Antifascist Handbook10. Gramsci - The Prison Notebooks
>>25204149Read anything from Pierre-Joseph ProundhonRead anything from Peter KropotkinRead anything from Mikhail BakuninRead anything from Emma GoldmanRead anything from David GraeberRead anything on LibcomRead anything on the Anarchist LibraryMarx and other Authoritarian-Communists aren't worth reading. They're just State-Capitalists and their ideas lead to worker exploitation just like with capitalism.
>>25206803I read The Conquest of Bread by Kropotkin to see what he was all about and it was so dogshit it permanently altered my perception of anarchists
>>25206767>>25206803Why do people waste their time reading this pseudoscientific garbage?>>25206829>KropotkinKropotkin's work seems like a child wrote it.It's so economically illiterate and wrong about basically everything.
>>25206829>I read The Conquest of Bread by Kropotkin to see what he was all about and it was so dogshit it permanently altered my perception of anarchistsI read IT by Stephen King to see what he was all about and it was so dogshit it permanently altered my perception of all horror fans.
>>25206861anarcho-capitalists are all willing slaves to capitalists or capitalist demons in human form.either way, all anarcho-capitalists are sub-human.
>>25206889I'm not an Ancap, I'm a Libertarian leaning Liberal.>willing slaves to capitalists Not really. They support polycentric law and believe private property rights can be enforced by private law. Elements of this have existed in the past.>all anarcho-capitalists are sub-human.Even the most intelligent socialist is more retarded than them.Socialists are statist bootlickers.
>>25206931>They support polycentric law and believe private property rights can be enforced by private law. Elements of this have existed in the past.In feudal fiefdoms, medieval principalities, and ig Dubai and the US rn... shining examples of worker exploitation, slavery, severe wealth disparities, and strict class structures bordering on or outright being caste systems where only the capitalist top ~1% have real freedom.Amazing system if you want only the most selfish and abusive ppl to be comfortable.
>>25204169NT was. OT on the other hand was pretty hardcore. Yeah god would flood the planet and do some shit but would always have humans backs. Jesus was the pot smoking kid but god would always keep an eye on humans protecting them from the nephilim and vampires. Jesus didn't burn local but god did.
>>25206964>In feudal fiefdoms, medieval principalities, and ig Dubaithat's not even close to what I was talking about, but nice tryExamples of Ancap and semi-ancap stateless societies:French AcadiaMany areas of the American Midwest during 1800s.Cospaia 400 yearsFree Frisia 700 yearsNeutral Moresnet 100 yearsAncient Ireland 2000 yearsMedieval Iceland 400 years>Amazing system if you want only the most selfish and abusive ppl to be comfortable.Take Acadia for example. It was wealthier and more peaceful than the rest of new France despite having basically no state and full private property rights
>>25206861You cannot be grouping Marx into the same group as the guy who wrote a narrative novel about nothing and tried to pass it off as theory
>>25206227Capital in the Twenty First Century is actually a great one in this regard. The focus of the book is on the implications of an economy where the rate of return on capital is higher than the rate of economic growth, that is to say, a situation where the rich get richer and the poor get poorer. It's well written and uses real world examples, like the case of Ivy League Universities becoming money managers of their endowment and slowly being converted into hedge funds rather than institutions of education. Highly recommend.
>>25206227>>25207452I took your post as meaning you wanted recommendations for a layman not steeped in Marx. If you meant a book from an author not steeped in Marxism, I would recommend The Wealth of Nations by Adam Smith. He actually spends a fair bit of that book detailing how wealthy people use their power to manipulate the system and the market to their own benefit. Here are some excerpts:The interest of the dealers, however, in any particular branch of trade or manufactures, is always in some respects different from, and even opposite to, that of the public. To widen the market and to narrow the competition, is always the interest of the dealers. To widen the market may frequently be agreeable enough to the interest of the public; but to narrow the competition must always be against it, and can serve only to enable the dealers, by raising their profits above what they naturally would be, to levy, for their own benefit, an absurd tax upon the rest of their fellow-citizens. The proposal of any new law or regulation of commerce which comes from this order ought always to be listened to with great precaution, and ought never to be adopted till after having been long and carefully examined, not only with the most scrupulous, but with the most suspicious attention. It comes from an order of men whose interest is never exactly the same with that of the public, who have generally an interest to deceive and even to oppress the public, and who accordingly have, upon many occasions, both deceived and oppressed it.Our merchants and masters complain much of the bad effects of high wages in raising the price and lessening the sale of goods. They say nothing concerning the bad effects of high profits. They are silent with regard to the pernicious effects of their own gains. They complain only of those of other people.People of the same trade seldom meet together, even for merriment and diversion, but the conversation ends in a conspiracy against the public, or in some contrivance to raise prices.The rent of land, therefore, considered as the price paid for the use of the land, is naturally a monopoly price. It is not at all proportioned to what the landlord may have laid out upon the improvement of the land, or to what he can afford to take; but to what the farmer can afford to give.
>>25206237you are no leftist, chud tankie
Surprised nobody here has mentioned Rousseau, Godwin or Paine. >>25206237The Meiji-Restoration saved billions also I presume>>25206767The list provided on economics is too unfocused, and the one for politics a joke. Total neglect of the philosophical here, though I suspect that’s due to the vehemently anti-Hegelian influence of Cockshott. No Eighteenth Brumaire - yet the ‘Antifascist’ handbook and Federici? You’d get more about the skullduggery of politics from Weber or Orwells travelogue of Spain. >>25207017>Paris Commune>Ancient IrelandPsychobabble
>>25207452Many things in this book have been debunked. Piketty is a terrible statistician.
>>25207474lmao all leftists are fucking tankiesimagine thinking you're any better than them you commie subhuman>>25207543>PsychobabbleLiterally all leftist thought is psychobabble.You people are in a cult.
>>25206478The State doesn’t abolish itself, you fucking tranny retard. It withers away. Only retarded anarcho-trannies think communism is about ‘abolition’ in a purely negative sense when Marx and Engels both distinguish abolition and sublation in their writings in German. This distinction is inherited from Hegel’s logic as sublation/Aufhebung also implies a preservation of some sort.>>25206480Mao and Stalin literally ended cycles of famine which occurred for centuries. They also doubled the life expectancy of their population. You’re a CIA Epsteinite goyslave whose mind been raped repeatedly.>>25206529>SuttonHAHAHAHA YOU FUCKING RETARDSutton selectively quoted many important documents out of context, like a report from then-U.S. Ambassador to Russia David Francis which was based entirely on unverified rumors. He deliberately confused post-war aid deliveries like those of the American Relief Administration after 1920 with financing of the Bolsheviks during the civil war. The most infamous allegation among Tsarists and right-wingers who claim Wall Street financed the Bolsheviks, is that they were supported by a banker named Jacob Schiff. However, cables and letters between Schiff and U.S. government officials disprove this theory and show that he not only opposed the Bolsheviks but supported the White Army. Sutton had deliberately misquoted files from the U.S. State Department out of context in order to flip Schiff’s position regarding the Bolshevik Revolution on its head. He’s a liar.The rest is pure CIA goy cuckslave propaganda. However, I’ll address this:>Deng moved away from socialism and towards capitalism.Per Marx in his Critique of the Gotha Program, the lower phase of communist society still bears, in every aspect, the birthmark of the capitalist society. Deng used the residual capitalistic elements to serve the interests of the people. That’s how China lifted 800 MILLIONS people out of poverty. Meanwhile, your Western countries are getting poorer while your capitalist overlords get away with raping infants. Thats what you’re defending Epsteinite cuckslave.>Xi Retard that is moving away from the policies that made china rise. The country is experiencing a decline thanks to him.lmao you compulsive liar, China has never been more powerful. Even the orange retard couldn’t impose tariffs on them, he cucked out like a little bitch. Is that all you’ve got? CIA propaganda and blatant lies? Did you just post that long ass reply to defend to rich pedophiles who rule over you? Jill yourself, dawg.>>25206536Vietnam’s economy is controlled by the State, retard. Like China’s. Those reforms opening up the markets were in both cases purely pragmatic and implemented within numerous strategic five-year-plans. Vietnam executes its corrupt millionaires while you work for them and they get to rape your children. You are cattle. Bow down, goy
>>25204582debord is cool, comrade
>>25207465damn adam smith was a marxist?
>>25207624A lot of Marx's most famous criticisms of Capitalism were already stated by Smith.
>>25207653so smith is a marxist, just as marx is a proponent of democracy and a critic of socialism.
>>25207611>words words wordsChina is capitalist doe
>>25207611Found the mentally ill extremely angry tankie bootlicker that will never accomplish anything politically lmaoYou're critiquing like one source of Sutton when he actually had a wide variety of verified sources.Also I was mainly talking about his 3 book academic series on soviet economic development and capitalist investment into the ussr. Not his books he made for the layman.Your argument mixes Sutton’s 1917–21 “Wall Street” book with his 1930s tech-transfer work, then asserts a Schiff “gotcha” that’s backwards. In Sutton’s own text, he says the Schiff/Kamenka cables refute the claim of a Jewish banker conspiracy behind Bolshevism and says Schiff was unhappy about the Bolsheviks and even drew U.S. State Department attention to pleas for Allied intervention against them. Independent scholarship likewise describes Schiff as anti-communist and not a Bolshevik financier.On Francis: yes, FRUS shows Francis reporting “rumors current” and even saying he “attaches little importance” because many rumors prove unfounded. That means a careful historian shouldn’t treat those rumor lines as decisive proof—but it doesn’t prove Sutton “lied” unless you show a specific quote where he removed the caveat and built a major conclusion on it.On ARA: the ARA Russia operation is famine relief formalized by agreement in August 1921, and the U.S. State Department prints the agreement. That’s not “financing the Bolsheviks during the civil war.” If you claim Sutton conflated them, quote the exact passage.>CIA goy cuckslave propagandaYou people think any source of data that isn't from a compulsively lying murderous dictatorship is muh CIA.lmao religious cultist>Deng used the residual capitalistic elements to serve the interests of the people. lmao I love this cope. So they need to temporarily use capitalism because it actually works and doesn't completely fail like central planning does?>That’s how China lifted 800 MILLIONS people out of poverty.Yes by using CAPITALISM. None of this happened under they abandoned maoist central planning. Other countries that implement capitalism end up with mass poverty alleviation too.>your Western countries are getting poorer lmao really?Why do workers in Taiwan make almost 4x what workers in China make? It seems that communism is hindering their development.
>>25207611>capitalist overlords get away with raping infants.Your statist overlords, mao and stalin were literal child rapists LMFAOWhy do you bootlickers even exist? HAHAHAHA You want the state to completely control your life and make all of your decisions. You'd let them hook you up to the matrix if the vanguard party wanted.>you compulsive liar,You're a communist, look in the mirror.>China has never been more powerfulThey were more economically productive before xi. Now they have decline. It's almost as if central planning doesnt work.>CIA propagandaYou are in a religious cult.>defend to rich pedophiles You support extremely rich dictators.>Vietnam’s economy is controlled by the Statelmfao they've constantly liberalized over the past 35 years and that's the reason they've grown so much.They keep shrinking the state side of their economy every year.You have no idea what you're talking about.>pragmatic absolutely love this fucking cope HAHAHAHAHA
>>25207611>The State doesn’t abolish itself, you fucking tranny retard. It withers away.lmao what the fuck is the difference?Also how the fuck is an all powerful totalitarian state going to magically wither away?Imagine unironically believing something like this and at the same time claiming to have a functioning brain?Communists should just kill themselves immidiately.>also implies a preservation of some sort.So the state WON'T wither away?Make up your mind.
>>25207611>Mao and Stalin literally ended cycles of famine which occurred for centuries.Industrialization in general did that.Why did countries that implemented economic liberalism grow without mass famine and authoritarianism while communist ones had the largest famines in history?It's almost as if you force people onto inefficient collective farms, steal their food and shoot them if they try to leave, THEY STARVE!I mean DUH!>They also doubled the life expectancy of their population.Learn what selection bias is.https://praxben.substack.com/p/brief-comments-on-chinese-life-expectancyAll communists are pussies and manchildren btw
>>25207624>>25207653>>25207662both smith and marx were retards that believed in the labor theory of value, which was later replaced by marginalism because it made much more sense and had much more explanatory power.The austrians were correct, as always.
>>25206237>You lying faggot, every single five-year-plan is conducted for a final aim: socialist modernisation which is the term the CCP uses to describe higher phase communism.>we will achieve TRUE COMMUNISM™ IN TWO MORE WEEKS!
>>25207611>Deng used the residual capitalistic elements to serve the interests of the people.Wait what? I thought mao worked hard to get rid of those elements? I thought they were bad.Now you say they are good and can be used to help the people?Why not use socialist elements to help the people?Do you have any idea what you're even talking about or is this just cope?
>this entire thread
>>25207689surefeel free to explicate the marginal value of your post
>>25207698nice self portait
>>25207745>NO U!that drawing must have hit close to home for you tankioid
>>25207752ok, pigface.
>>25207754lol
>>25207762nice meme folder, pigface.im sure youre very tall and fit and get all the girls, right?
>>25207762this you?
The Bible
>>25207784only the good parts
My diary desu(I am antonio gramsci)
>>25207769Nope.Trump's a communist retard like yourself lol>>25207767Actually I'm a trans woman :)I posted the commie hon because all communist trans women simply do not pass.Here's a picture of essentially every cuckold communist pigdog.
>>25207767communists and nazis are both incel loserswhen you have an ideology based around exploiting and enslaving others, you're gonna be an incel
>>25207866>>25207860ok lit friendsyou gonna let this level of unread idiocy on your board?
>>25204320good list but>No Giorgio Agamben
>>25205597People who post things like, the Chinese are going to come rape you, etc. etc. reminds me of the poem "Waiting for the Barbarians" by Cavafy.Also it gets funnier when you see a lot of Chinese posting online in English being Sinotriumph maxxers but Chinese posting online in Chinese are going into full civilizational self-annihilationism and are like "Xi has ruined everything, our economy is totally messed up, the fucking Great Leap Forward had better net return on labor than this." Their debt to GDP ratio has skyrocketed past the U.S. and E.U. btw.
>>25207987nice
>>25207666Your skull will be opened and its rotten content will feed dogs.>>25207678>You're critiquing like one source of Sutton when he actually had a wide variety of verified sources.The wide variety of 'verified sources' does not confirm what you say, that's Sutton's problem, retard : selective quotation, interpretive overreach, and the systematic removal of hedging language from primary sources. The documents exist. The leap from "this document records a financial transaction" to "Wall Street conspiratorially engineered the Bolshevik Revolution" is not in the documents, it is Sutton's inference and it is a sign that this retard wasn't serious about his methodology. The Hoover Institution which published the trilogy notably distanced itself from his conclusions even while treating the data compilation as useful. Now let's address: >Academic Trilogy SpecificallyFirst, normal commercial trade is not a conspiracy nor a sign of deficiency from a communist standpoint. Sutton catalogs technology transfers but cannot establish that they were coordinated, ideologically motivated or that the parties intended to sustain Soviet power rather than simply profit from contracts. Merely listing transactions proves nothing, retard. Second, the causal claim is undemonstrated. Sutton's underlying thesis is that Western technology was decisive to Soviet industrial survival and development. But the Soviet Union also received substantial technology transfer from Weimar Germany under the Rapallo Treaty (1922) and subsequent arrangements, far better documented, including the secret military-industrial cooperation at Lipetsk, Kazan, and Tomka. Sutton systematically underweights this alternative channel. His counterfactual claim that without Western capitalism the Soviet state would have collapsed is simply asserted.Third, he cannot distinguish categories. The trilogy collapses together government-approved commercial trade, private business deals, humanitarian relief, contracts signed etc. BEFORE the Revolution and Lend-Lease-era transfers. These have entirely different political and contextual meanings and cannot be bundled into a single explanatory framework.>You people think any source of data that isn't from a compulsively lying murderous dictatorship is muh CIA.But you are actually repeating lies spread by the CIA and debunked by actually documented sources, you goy cattle slave. >lmao I love this cope. So they need to temporarily use capitalism because it actually works and doesn't completely fail like central planning does?Hey, retard, the economy is still entirely centrally planned. Hell Capitalism itself is centrally planned today, you fucking retard. You think an entire nation like the US doesn't work with plans and budgeted previsions which are decided by the Federal State?>Why do workers in Taiwan make almost 4x what workers in China make? It seems that communism is hindering their development.Taiwan is China, retard.
>>25207679>Your statist overlords, mao and stalin were literal child rapists LMFAOThese are baseless claims which rely on no historical evidence. The only sources are tabloids and the biography of one of Mao's bodyguards which was published by a Western editor and refuted by many people who knew Mao himself. Another example of Khruschvite-CIA propaganda. >You're a communist, look in the mirror.You literally claimed that Xi's policy lead to China's decline when its rise has been unstoppable, especially since 2020. Sit tight in your cuck chair, cuckboy>They were more economically productive before xi. Now they have decline. It's almost as if central planning doesnt work.Meaningless statement lmao China has accomplished 90% of its 5-year-plans while you bitches pay taxes so Trump can send money to Israel and subsidize the bankers who will put you in debt and rape your children. >You are in a religious cult.No, the only idolatrous fuck is you. You worship transsexual pornography and hot pockets your whore mother makes for you. >You support extremely rich dictators.MUH DICTATORSYou sound like the most castrated liberal ever. Did you take your hormones today, tranny? >They keep shrinking the state side of their economy every year.You keep lying as if Vietnam's 5 year plans weren't openly available on the internet for everyone to see that I'm telling the truth and that you're a lying cuckold who's being raped by the Epstein class. >>25207682>what the fuck is the difference?Yeah, I knew a cuckold retard tranny like you couldn't grasp the difference, even though I've explained what it means.>So the state WON'T wither away?No, retard, that means that the sublation of the State implies its persistence during the transitional period. Once it withers away, its form will be purely social and not institutional. The people will be the State. >Industrialization in general did that.Yeah, that's the point, retard. Mao and Stalin turned backwards feudal states into industrial superpowers. You're conceding my point, you gigantic cretinous subhuman. >It's almost as if you force people onto inefficient collective farms,The collective farms were so useful they helped double life expectancy. Try harder, goyslave.>PRAXBENAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHAHThat cuckold got raped in his debate against Haz.>>25207692>I thought mao worked hard to get rid of those elements? I thought they were bad.That's a nice straw man. I think you should kill yourself. Stop your hormones, tranny. End it all. Become another statistics. >>25207698You've been samefagging for like five posts now. You're absolutely destroyed. >>25207860>Actually I'm a trans woman :)HE'S ACTUALLY TRANS HAHAHAHA YOU'RE DONE
>>25208060>>25208079boring
The Unique and its Property
