[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/lit/ - Literature

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: c0y97cpwh0i51[1].jpg (142 KB, 1280x938)
142 KB JPG
ned and cersei converse in the godswood edition

ASOIAF wiki: https://awoiaf.westeros.org/index.php/Main_Page
Blog: https://georgerrmartin.com/notablog/
Old blog: https://grrm.livejournal.com/
So Spake Martin (interviews): https://westeros.org/citadel/ssm/
Book search: https://asearchoficeandfire.com/
SSM search: https://cse.google.com/cse?cx=006888510641072775866:vm4n1jrzsdy
General search: http://searcherr.work/
TWOW samples: https://archive.org/details/411440566-the-winds-of-winter-released-chapters

old: >>25637069
>>
File: 1770955238176.jpg (163 KB, 900x900)
163 KB JPG
>does nothing
>>
Does anyone else think Orangudan Dave will kiss Minsper Wislonk on the lips? Perhaps grab her tits a little bit? What would Drohblerary Slaptap think of that if he saw it? Would it lead to war between Chamblar and Smankton?

ANYONE?????
>>
how does a thread this niche STILL attract schizos?
>>
>>25656397
>I have my own ghosts, Bran. A brother that I loved, a brother that I hated, a woman I desired. Through the trees, I see them still, but no word of mine has ever reached them. The past remains the past. We can learn from it, but we cannot change it."

Why does he think Shiera is dead? Who is Quaithe then?
>>
>>25656471
What makes Bran so special? Being a Stark? Being crippled? I doubt Bloodraven's legs work.
>>
>>25656471
There is no indication in the books that Quaithe is Shiera, never understood where that theory came from.
>>
>daenerys fucks this guy
>>
When are we going to see more basediality further than Varamyr warging into his bitch while she's being taken by One-Eye, and Bran peeing on One-Eye Varamyr?
>>
>>25656479
Retards think Shiera was hooking up with the most magical guy in westeros, whose her brother, so she must be a magic user to, Quaithe is a mysterious magic using woman and isn't dead so it must be Shiera.
>>25656490
Ramsay made Arya (Jeyne Pool) fuck his dogs too
>>
>>25656502
Consensual, please.
>>
>>25656502
>>25656490
Prendahl also threatened
>What you are is a horselord's whore. When we break you, I will breed you to my stallion.
>>
>>25656478
Descendent of aemond one eye
>>
>>25656515
What is with people threatening to have horses rape Dany?
>>
>>25656550
Dothraki culture is just horses and rape. It's a wonder George didn't confirm that they rape (or "rape") the horses, too.
>>
>>25656479
What's with the star motif then?

>"Quaithe?" Dany called. "Where are you, Quaithe?"

>Then she saw. Her mask is made of starlight.

>"Remember who you are, Daenerys," the stars whispered in a woman's voice. "The dragons know. Do you?"

>>25656502
>she must be a magic user to
I mean she was literally reputed to perform the dark arts so it's not that ridiculous to assume she did magic.
>>
>>25656559
Stars are present throughout Dany's chapters, before Shiera was ever invented.
>>
RIP to this cute shota's relevance. At least he survives this way.
Do we really only get rare news about the Brotherhood Without Banners and their Leavers though?
Like what actually happened with Edric Dayne, Gendry, and Hot Pie?
Gendry stayed with the Remainers, right?
>>
>>25656571
Muh sun and stars drogo is like 90% of those mentions.
>>
>>25656612
That's my point nigga. She also has the dream about her silver under starlight. It's such a vague mention that appears throughout Daenerys' chapters that associating it with Shiera (whose last name is SEAstar anyways) is a stretch.
>>
would you rather
>stay 10 years in in prison
or
>stay in prison until george finishes winds
>>
>>25656619
>whose last name is SEAstar anyways
Quaithe guides Dany like how stars guide mariners at sea. It's like poetry, it rhymes.
>>
>>25656471
>Why does he think Shiera is dead
Because she was born like 100 years ago. If she's alive somewhere shes using magic fuckery to hide her presence.
>>
File: IMG_8998.jpg (143 KB, 1179x1533)
143 KB JPG
>>25638075
Jon will give himself the last kiss while he is in Ghosts body. This sacrifice will kill ghost and will also be the explanation for activating Jons wolf blood that makes him more aggressive like the other starks that have it, while also symbolizing the death of his stark identity and the birth of his life as a Targaryen. He will keep the cool red eyes too.
>>
>>25656699
>Jon will give himself the last kiss while he is in Ghosts body
Necrophilia aside oh my god Jon x Ghost kissy
>>
>>25656215
It's kind of a running thing that all the high-born people are said to be the hottest ever and the best fighters ever and then half of them die in silly ways and Arya, who is supposed to look exactly like the hottest turbowaifu who has wars started over her, actuaIly looks like a peasant boy.
>>
>>25638075
Stoneheart exists to make Brienne choose between her vows because keeping contradicting vows be hard and shit. And she has to kill Stoneheart because Jaime still has to be alive to kill Cersei.
>>
>>25656821
Arya?? No lmao. Arya is supposed to be a lanky boyish featured girl with a bit of a horse face. Basically the exact opposite of the pudgy short actress they cast her as.

Sansa is supposed to be a great beauty. And sophie turner gets outclassed hard by the other redhead A listers who are 10 or 20 years older than her.
>>
>>25656830
Arya is consistently described as resembling Lyanna who according to multiple people, including Kevan Lannister, was hot. She's only called horseface by her retarded sister and her pack of hanger-ons.
>>
File: j5ayn95ale3c1[1].jpg (287 KB, 2400x1200)
287 KB JPG
>>25656830
it's actually fucking awful what actresses do to their cheek fat

Starlight from The Boys' actor did it, Sophie Turner did it, they look fine and turn themselves into ghouls
>>
>>25656821
Arya is a prepubescent girl and she has an androgynous look to her in her youth. She is becoming cuter as she ages.
>>
>>25656699
>birth of his life as a Targaryen. He will keep the cool red eyes too.
maybe that's how George will reveal Jon were Targaryen, folk that close to the last dragon prince like Barristan Selmy and Jon connington will comment how he resemble Rhaegar
>>
>>25656699
>the birth of his life as a Targaryen. He will keep the cool red eyes too.
Wouldn't it make sense for his eyes to go purple if hes supposed to be come back looking like a Targ.
>>
>>25657388
No because theres literally zero reason for his eyes to be purple. Also albino targs like bloodraven have red eyes. Jons wolf is albino. Jon presumably comes back to life looking like an albino targs.
>>
File: HXHDo4oWAAAU7Ge.jpg (230 KB, 1071x1469)
230 KB JPG
ABOVE THE REST!
>>
>>25657388
Red represents fire (Targaryens AND the Lord of Light), matches him to Bloodraven and Ghost, and even makes him resemble the weirwoods as he noted with Ghost. There's way too much setup (including Stoneheart getting explicitly red eyes) for it to not be red if he comes back with his appearance changed.
>>
File: 1769173721231.jpg (87 KB, 736x872)
87 KB JPG
>>25657427
>>25657462
I see the vision
>>
which has the better design
>>
>>25657737
Show Blackfyre, I actually really do like it and Dark Sister. I only wish it had a ruby in the pommel.
>>
>>25656699
This whole discussion makes me wonder why the show failed to include this sacrifice aspect of resurrection. Grrm was right when he said that reviving gandalf was a mistake, especially given that there was no cost. The show quotes that “only death can pay for life”, but seemingly forgets this with all of the resurrections that occur. Why?
>>
File: 1794842423518722[1].png (1.1 MB, 1280x806)
1.1 MB PNG
>>
File: IMG_9024.jpg (107 KB, 736x946)
107 KB JPG
How come people never talk about why it makes zero sense for daenerys to get 3 dragon eggs? This is a major plot hole and is sort of proof that george didnt come up with the blackfyres or faegon until well after the first book. Im just reading akotsk now for the first time, and george one of the biggest themes in this universe is about how power resides where people believe it resides. Rebellions fail solely based on aura and whether or not the claimants have the symbols that are associated with the throne.
Given this, why the fuck would illyrio give daenerys 3 dragon eggs when they are the very symbol of house targaryen and he has his own secret heir that he planned to put on the throne? These eggs are nearly as important as the house sword.
>>
>>25657888
Zamn
>>
>>25657891
Maybe he did not think fAegon would hatch them. Dany doing it is basically an accident.
>>
>>25657945
Its not about the dragons. Its about the eggs. Dragon eggs are completely gone from the world. They are a massive symbol of house targaryen. This is a guy who supports the blackfyres, and their big claim to the throne was that their guy had the sword of the targaryens and symbolically deserved the throne. 2 of the 3 dunk and egg novellas are based on this idea that there is no real legitimacy to a claimant to the throne, and its more about symbolism and power residing in where people believe it does. These eggs are hugely important and illyrio would obviously not just give all of them away when he is supporting fAegon. The onvious explanation is just that george didnt have it planned when he wrote this part of the story.
>>
>>25657969
Maybe Illyrio has more eggs we haven't seen
>>
>>25657974
Retard logic. Maybe illyrio has 20 dragons.
Illyrio knows Daenerys and her brother are trying to take back the throne, they are trueborn targs, (his historic enemy as a blackfyre supported) and he willingly gives them items that legitimize their claim and symbology to the throne. He has no reason to bolster their claim when it directly goes against his own goals. He could have given daenerys any gift. There was no purpose to it.
>>
>>25657986
maybe fAegon is TRVEaegon
>>
>>25656550
She's GRRM's fetish loli character. The old paedo loves putting her in disgusting postitions. Aside from that Mongols are done so dirty in ASOIAF.
>>
Viserys should have lived. not Dany
>No disgusting rape/paedo fetish scenarios
>No mucking in Meereen
>No SJW subplot with freeing the slaves
>No Daario
>Actual chance of a dragon attack on King's landing
>No Daario
>>
>>25658143
Dany works better because viewers excuse her dark tyrannical behavior due to her beauty and sex, and can be rug pulled by her total mask off heel turn at the end of her arc. If it was viserys from the start everyone would know he’s just a dark lord end boss, but with dany you can bait them into falling for a cult of personality dictator. It’s meta as hell, and frankly genius
>>
>>25658158
>Dany works better because viewers excuse her dark tyrannical behavior due to her beauty and sex, and can be rug pulled by her total mask off heel turn at the end of her arc. If it was viserys from the start everyone would know he’s just a dark lord end boss, but with dany you can bait them into falling for a cult of personality dictator. It’s meta as hell, and frankly genius
Except thousands of people have already figured it out. Most ethnic girls famously hate Daenerys. With Viserys it could be interesting because less people would simp in story
>>
>>25658158
>dark lord end boss
>twink
>a whiny possibly intellectually disabled guy
>>
>>25656441
silly anon, it is BECAUSE it is niche.
>>
GRRM seems like the type of guy who will book end Dream so everything is a reverse of what happens in the first book. How do you think scenarios will be the same but retaining that bittersweetness

>Bran executes someone after becoming king mirroring Ned's lesson of executing the Night's Watch deserter (more than likely Littlefinger)
>Prologue with someone from House Royce watching The Others head back north but on more peaceful terms
>A Mormont is leading the Wall again
>Tyrion at the wall again maybe voluntarily helping to rebuild it maybe voluntarily joined the Watch and is Mormont's steward
>All three of the dragons will be dead symbolising the true end of the Targaryen dynasty
>Another gathering at Winterfell maybe making a new peace treaty between The Others and the Children of the Forest once the new Long Night is over. Stark kids reunion happens here.
> Jon maybe has to make a difficult decision after committing a crime rather than go back to the Watch he simply leaves with The Others going further north into exile
>>
Does anyone think Lord Ploppants will shit himself?
>>
STAAAANIS
>>
>>25658209
>"One day, Bran, you will be Robb's bannerman, holding a keep of your own for your brother and your king, and justice will fall to you. When that day comes, you must take no pleasure in the task, but neither must you look away. A ruler who hides behind paid executioners soon forgets what death is."

>That was when Jon reappeared on the crest of the hill before them.

I have always found this passage very very very suspect.
>>
File: 1775827082938.jpg (639 KB, 1982x2048)
639 KB JPG
>>
>>25658143
Monkey's paw, Viserys is even more histrionic after birthing dragons and develops a gay crush on Ser Paedo bear
>>
How do we feel about the theory that Stannis allowed Rhaella to escape out of pity? Is it OOC
>>
Why is this at the top of the catalogue? News on winds yet?
>>
>>25658314
Anons can detect that Shrike theory 2.0 is nearing completion and are champing at the bit for it
>>
>>25658209

Another one I potentially missed MAYBe Daenerys dies but she has two kids who wind up bumming around Esso's or Westeros in a similar manner to what she and Viserys did eventually receding into irrelevancy as their name means nothing anymore not without the dragons to back them.
>>
File: Waymar Royce.jpg (313 KB, 2048x1297)
313 KB JPG
>brooo he was so heckin brave and when he said dance with me i nutted so hard XD

I feel like people are way too charitable towards this guy for doing the bare minimum.
>>
Jon should have slept with Satin while he still had the chance
>>
>>25658701
It wouldn't have worked out, they're both bottoms.
>>
>>25656383
nice tits cersei
>>
>>25658580
Really anon? Being the first person to stand up to an Other in 8,000 years is the bare minimum?
>>
The show beautified way too much

Brienne, Jorah, Tyrion are way too good looking.

There was a lot of fat people erasure. Strong Belwas was adapted out, and Kraznys and Lollys are both not fat. Wyman Manderly is a bit of a big dude in the show but nowhere near book Wyman in size.
>>
>>25658867
Eh, it was a mixed bag. Catelyn should have been a big titty milf in her 30s and Daenerys and Cersei should have been more stunningly beautiful than they actually were in the show. Renly was also made a onions manlet rather than a chad, which makes the reveal that he's a fag more of a well duh moment than an actual surprise. Beric was also made older and uglier than he actually is, which again kind of ruins the fact that his revivals slowly ruin his youthful beauty by turning him into a walking corpse. I like Alfie Allen but he's also nowhere near handsome enough for book Theon.
>>
File: image[1].jpg (136 KB, 1120x1120)
136 KB JPG
>>25658911
Alfie Allen was good but yeah he looked kind of monkey-ish.

He certainly looked a lot better than post-torture Theon though

I think Erling Haaland honestly looks a ton of what Book Brienne would look like
>>
>>25657882
>Why?
Because the show was a sloppy adaptation made so a couple of sleazy jews, whose only writing credits before GOT were a few schlocky movies, could party around Europe for a few years on Warner Bros' dime
>>
since HBO has this IP in its grasp for probably quite a long long time I can only hope the AI stuff gets good enough for someone to pump out a halfway to great animated adaptation. That would be neat.
>>
>>25657882
What sacrifice did thoros make to revive beric 7 times? George is a hack who doesnt follow his own advice
>>
>>25658209
Bran is going to live well beyond a normal human lifespan and become a wizened old husk that spends his days napping and telling stories of the past to the future generations of Westeros, ala Old Nan
>>
>>25657891
It's a completely legitimate explanation that he just wants someone close to him on the throne to get more power and now he has several options.
>>
Does anyone think King Pootrousers will poo himself?
>>
>>25658867
I feel like Tyrion and Brienne are still quite sensible since the main point is that they're tall or short but Jorah being a handsome and charismatic and Dany not fucking her is out of character.
>>
>>25659121
Methinks that Daenerys is no longer an option considering she would want Illyrio killed for selling her off and hiding that she ostensibly has a living nephew from her, so I don't think that is a legitimate explanation.
>>
>>25658911
Renly was by far the worst casting of the first season and the whole depiction was a sign that the showrunners are retards who don't understand what the point is.
>>
>>25659125
If he did poo himself then Elengton Spodburts would kill his family because they stabbed each other in thhe past so no he eouldn't do that.
>>
>>25659127
Yeah he has several options exactly because one might go horribly wrong.
>>
>>25659130
Surface level reading. Elengton would want Pootrousers to poo himself. It gives him leverage in the Council of the Wonky Ones
>>
>>25659132
Daenerys did go horribly wrong, and it's because of his actions in the first place. He gave her the means to declare herself as queen by having Viserys die (which Illyrio absolutely should have foreseen) and insane power in the form of dragons. If Viserys and Daenerys were intended as alternate options he shouldn't have remotely given them the freedom he gave them. Even assuming Viserys somehow magically succeeded and now has a Dothraki army behind him, wtf do you do with Aegon and Connington at that point? They're also out of reach and aren't going to just let themselves be put aside, in fact they're going to either try to get mercenaries for themselves or book it to Viserys who regardless is now going to want blood because Illyrio kept a rival from him.
>>
>>25659136
Yeah but think about it from the perspective Elengton. You're just walking along trying to farm some oats but then Pootrousers comes along and demands tribute and then shits himself? And it's like hello this is the guy I am paying tribute to. Owe fealty to. A guy that just shat his trousers in my fields, in front of my peasants. Homestly it could lead to.revolution in upper Bonklie, Elengton can't lie this doen, now he has to commit either wipe up the poo and become his lackey or standup for upper Bonklie and say look I ain't paying no tribute to no guy that shits himself. And Fraeworn Shittington is shitting on the wings just begging to be reinvited to take the whole damn kingdom. This is why Game of Thrones is just so great, you can:t get this level of intrigue anywhere else, GRMM is a master at his craft
>>
>>25659125
>>25659130
>>25659136
>>25659143
Sorry but licensed academics agree that this anti-Semitic conspiracy theory has been deboonked. >>25655339 >>25655361
Please submit yourself to the nearest mandatory thought correction facility.
>>
>>25659139
"Young girl kills the supposed king" isn't really the first thing I'd prepare for. And he still prepared for it.
>>
File: Grey King.jpg (159 KB, 1199x1294)
159 KB JPG
Anons am I losing my mind, both Shrike and the drowned priest and Shrykes (lizard man hybrids) are specicially mentioned in the index for the world book.
I thought 'well yeah its the index dude' but like Carcosa where the Yellow Emperor, one of the three powers waging a civil war to rule the Golden Empire of Yi Ti doesn't get a mention in the index. Shrykes are only mentioned once in the whole world book.

Btw did you guys ever notice the horn the Grey King has on his belt here. Wonder if that is the Kraken summoning horn used by Hrothgar of Pyke, and the House Celtigar horn is the exact same horn, since that also summons krakens.
>>
>>25659121
Retarded explanation. If faegon didnt work out he could hive her the eggs agter that. Giving them in advance just creates a power struggle. He would have no reason to hedge.
>>
Faegon is a weed that only grew in Gurm's garden when he was writing feast/dance. He had not conceived of him in the first book.
>>
>>25659322
Its obvious to anybody that this is the case. the blackfyres didnt exist in the first book, which is why the contradiction of illyrio giving the eggs to dany happens.
>>
>>25659322
>>25659523
>Faegon is a weed that only grew in Gurm's garden when he was writing feast/dance. He had not conceived of him in the first book.
You're most likely correct that Faegon as we know him wasn't planned in AGOT, but it's clear he had the idea of an opposing Targ faction in the main story very early on with the mention of the Dance in the first book, then The Hedge Knight's introduction of Aerion Brightflame as an antagonist not long after. Think he changes his mind about the Brightflame thing and comes up with the loose idea of the Blackfyres while writing ACOK, but doesn't have a concrete idea of who the modern day Blackfyre will be, so he throws in a vision of the Mummer's Dragon during Dany's House of the Undying trip as a hint/seed. Then the Blackfyres get solidified in ASOS and Sworn Sword, which is where I think he finally decides on the baby swap and Faegon as a character
>>
>>25659969
A pretender Aegon has always been in the cards, I'm pretty sure, there's interviews going back to the late 90s and early 2000s where George was being coy about Aegon's "survival."
>>
I hope Young Griff really is Aegon. It would be a "King asleep in the mountain" thing, awake at last to save his people from the pending political & supernatural crises.
>>
>>25659976
He's not. The theory that he's real is based entirely on the idea that it would throw a wrench in Jon being a hidden prince, but remember that we're not supposed to know that Jon is a secret Targ, George is just a lazy hack and is taking ages. Aegon is a red herring so the Jon reveal is an actual twist, or at least that was the idea before Jon being a Targ became common knowledge.
>>
>>25659987
Jon can still be a hidden Targ, and the PTWP. Aegon being alive just means he'd be the on to become King, not Jon.
>>
>>25659995
The problem with that is that since George is taking his sweet ass time, we also know that Bran is going to be king, so Aegon isn't going to serve as a challenge to Jon in that regard either. I will be very surprised if Jon even meets Aegon with only two books left. Jon might not even know he's a Targ before Aegon's already bit it.
>>
Why has George of Martin stopped blogposting?
>>
>>25659285
Woiaf has an index?
House Goodbrothers sigil is a horn, they decend from grey kings brother. there were probably a few kraken horns
>>
>>25660179
It’s over
>>
>>25660179
Maybe he’s realized that no one cares about his boomer ramblings.
>>
File: 941o3t17312i1.jpg (71 KB, 961x722)
71 KB JPG
>>25656699
Do we think Jon gets the full Ghost color scheme to color-match Rhaegar or do we think Jon keeps the Stark colors to look like Arya's twin when they bang
Both GRRM-approved options
>>
>>25660475
Arya is 11.
>>
>>25660475
Actually Jon turns green because he’s dead and not coming back
>>
>>25659995
People who think fAegon is genuinely the real heir are retarded. You have to just not understand storytelling or GRRM at all to come to this conclusion.
>>
How to create Valyrian Steel and how to complete whatever is needed to make dragons are two sides of the same coin. Both are some high end obscure, soul bonding ritual magic. Fuck how'd I not see this before.

Also Stannis won't burn his daughter but someone within his camp will. My speculation is either Val, or Seylse. Maybe both. The real tragedy, and irony, is that at some point after the Battle of Ice Stannis will have a huge wake up call and post nut clarity about the whole R'hllor worshipping thing and realise it was a huge mistake.

Bran's going to stop Theon's execution though by giving the northerners some kind of sign not. to go through with it that much is certain.
>>
>>25660668
>Bran's going to stop Theon's execution though by giving the northerners some kind of sign not
why tho bran wanna use theon's body as vessel or something?
>>
>>25660668
>Stannis is actually gonna…
Nigga nobody cares anymore because this series isn’t getting finished. The contrived retardation of season 5 is all you’re gonna get in terms of Stannis’ final arc.
>>
File: prank.jpg (732 KB, 1080x1642)
732 KB JPG
>>25660475
>pale white and covered with flour

There's your color scheme.
>>
>>25660789
even in flashback foreshadowing Sansa is worthless, I'll never understand the popularity of this character
>>
>>25660798
Sansa fans literally havent even read the books. If you ask them what they like about the character half of the time they talk about things that never even happened and probably originated in fanfiction. Her arc is shit and george clearly has no clue what to do with her as he planned to kill her off early in the initial draft.
>>
>>25659969
AGOT also has the dungeon discussion between Varys and Illyrio where it's implied that Dany isn't the only thing they're planning. Though Gurm probably wasn't sure what the other thing would be.

>>25660838
By now he's pretty clearly set on the idea that she goes from a naive young girl to a talented schemer.
>>
File: 1772652220625.jpg (131 KB, 736x526)
131 KB JPG
>>25660475
Hes getting the Ghost look. An albino Targ like Bloodraven.
>>
I wish House Justman was still around.
>>
File: images[1].jpg (35 KB, 679x452)
35 KB JPG
>Jon and Arya fall in love in the original draft of ASOIAF
So is GRRM just obsessed with incest or something? I thought it was just ASOIAF but he added stuff like selfcest in Elden Ring
>>
>>25661196
The selfcest in Elden Ring is is limited to the gods and godly incest is a trope for polytheism since irl they're the only beings in excistence.
The incest in ASOAIF is just the setting, his other works don't have any
>>
>>25661017
Tainted by bl*ackwood blood
House Teague mogs
>>
File: 1763809609863.png (3.48 MB, 2048x1540)
3.48 MB PNG
>>25661196
>incest
Uh based
>>
>“No,” Catelyn agreed. “You must name another heir, until such time as Jeyne gives you a son.” She considered a moment. “Your father’s father had no siblings, but his father had a sister who married a younger son of Lord Raymar Royce, of the junior branch. They had three daughters, all of whom wed Vale lordlings. A Waynwood and a Corbray, for certain. The youngest . . . it might have been a Templeton, but . . .”
>“Mother.” There was a sharpness in Robb’s tone. “You forget. My father had four sons.”
>She had not forgotten; she had not wanted to look at it, yet there it was. “A Snow is not a Stark.”
Wow Catelyn really scraped the bottom of the barrel for literally anyone to be Robb's heir besides Jon, huh

She also completely forgot all of her manners and courtesy the instant she heard Mya Stone was a bastard
>>
>>25661217
at least say house mudd
the teagues were the worst of the river kings, nobody took them seriously
>>
File: book cat vs show cat.jpg (483 KB, 1818x2048)
483 KB JPG
>>25661239
why did the show try to whitewash catelyn so hard?
>>
>>25661239
I think it's during the day of the Red Wedding where all the Frey girls are lined up to greet them and it's revealed Catelyn is a complete eugenicist.
>>25661248
Female.
>>
>blackwoods are stronger than tullys
>brackens are stronger than tullys
>vances are stronger than tullys
>freys are stronger than tullys
>mootons are wealthier than tullys
>mallisters have a more prestigious lineage

I too would be massively insecure if I was Catelyn.
>>
>>25661239
The sexual tension between Jon and Catelyn was so thick it could only have been intentional.
>>
>>25661017
yeah you would wouldn't you ya homo
>>
>>25661243
For me it’s the fishers of misty isle
(Descended from the fisher queens, misty isle = the isle of faces)
>>
>>25661003
Albino Jon is as kino as it is completely unsupported by the source material.
>>
>>25661217
The Teague system
T. Turn up out of nowhere with an uknown origin
E. Encroach upon the westerlands and pillage gold
A. Amass wealth and sellswords
G. Gain kingship and then die in battle with your sons
E. Evaporate from history
>>
>>25661248
Have to whitewash all women so the plebs can handle it (as evidenced by them being completely incapable of handling Dany suddenly not being whitewashed).
>>
>>25661511
It wasn’t just the woman characters that got whitewashed stupid. Show Tyrion got whitewashed so badly that his book counterpart was a very different character.
>>
>>25661609
Tyrion is also way uglier in the books and is missing his nose after the Blackwater. Dinklage is a 9/10 or 10/10 for a little person and he barely even has a scar after Blackwater.

Also Show Tyrion didn't threaten to torture Tommen to stop Cersei torturing one of Tyrion's whores so he is missing probably one of his biggest asshole moments
>>
>>25661836
GRRM's Tyrion is a grotesque nightmare dwarf along the vein of Pär Lagerkvist's Dvärgen; the tv version is a plucky hero who says snarky things. The book version Shae is a teenager forced into prostitution and is horribly killed but the show version made her annoying and obviously adult
>>
>>25656849
Hollywood thinks this is beautiful
>>25656245
Drogo = Drogon
Viserys = Viscerion
Rhaego =Rhaegal
>>
>>25661848
He also rapes a sex slave in Volantis after he flees Westeros. The show changed it to him refusing a sex slave, cause raping someone is very unlikable.

I also think honestly Toby Jones is closer face wise to Tyrion than Dinklage, he kind of has the squashed appearance
>>
>>25661967
>He also rapes a sex slave in Volantis
He paid for a whore and fucked her. Describing it as "rape" is a bit too much there.
>>
>Daenerys frees missandei and says she is free to leave or to serve her
>Missandei in the books is 10 years old
How exactly does this help Missandei? Her only skills are in speaking languages and translating, she has no parents, the Masters of Astapor don't give a shit about her, she has nowhere to fucking go. She basically has to serve Daenerys but cause Daenerys said "you're free" it just assuages Dany's conscience about slavery
>>
>>25662097
Arya is 11 and doing just fine, Missandei has a very in-demand skill and would also be fine. Dany has her own issues but that was genuinely noble.
>>
>>25662097
>How exactly does this help
Yeah this is said to Dany at least once where essentially her "children" are still forced de facto to serve under her because she completely overturned their lives and sacked their homes and killed their masters.
>>
>>25662104
>oh my brothers bannerman is here
>i should run to the forest where i just got kidnapped and they tortured and raped and killed everyone around me
Arya has the silliest plot armor in the series.
>>
>>25661967
Yeah, pretty much.
>>25662070
It's a sedated sex slave who had no choice in the matter so he technically gave money to a pimp/human trafficker and possible kidnapper, not to her.
I know this book's fans are mostly rape fetishists, but that would be considered rape even by medieval standards
>>25662109
Dany is basically living out her hero complex
>>
>house called tarGAYryen that practices incest
>not a single pair of same sex siblings fucking

George?
>>
>>25662726
There's only one (or two if Rhaena was gay and not bisexual) named Targaryen that's gay in the first place.
>>
Rhaegar should have won the Trident
>>
>>25657891
Faegon was definitely invented by the publishing of ACOK at the very latest considering the 'cloth dragon' reference in the House of the Undying.
Varys and Illyrio's scheming is a major backdrop in the first book that doesn't make much sense on a surface level.
The order of information is basically:
>Illyrio supports Daenerys, gifts her dragon eggs and Jorah as a guide
>Robert tells Eddard that Jorah is a spy in Varys's service. This is the first implication that Illyrio is manipulating Daenerys
>Varys tells Robert about Daenerys's pregnancy. He then argues in favour for Daenerys's assassination in the small council
>The assassination attempt goes through but Jorah intervenes to prevent it, possibly due to Varys tipping him off
>Arya overhears Varys and Illyrio conspiring with one another to overthrow the realm. Who they want on the throne is left ambiguous
The implication from this mess (that I can get) is Varys and Illyrio consider Daenerys a useful pawn in their plans but not an indispensable one, or they wouldn't have risked encouraging an assassination attempt against her.
So what George was thinking when choosing Illyrio to gift Daenerys the eggs is completely unknown still, but it doesn't seem like his intent was for Illyrio to be a loyal supporter of Daenerys.
My guess is that the reveal will be Illyrio gifted the eggs to Daenerys hoping they would hatch, since returning dragons to the world is necessary for prophecy and magic shit to occur, and only a true blood Targaryen could do so. But Illyrio's plan from the start was probably always to remove of Daenerys from the picture after she had served this initial purpose
>>
>>25657891
>>25663052
Are you guys forgetting those eggs were thought to be fossilised/petrified? To Illyrio and everyone else they were just an expensive gift, nothing more.
>>
I realized something the other day.

Gurm is a good author. The ASOIAF series is a great fantasy series, easily top 5 of all time by any objective metric.

The TV show(s) poisoned all of the goodwill that people had towards this IP.
>>
>>25662726
Grrm hates homosexuals. Renly and Loras, that one Targ bitch, you don't even want to know how badly JonCon is gonna get it.
>>
>>25663124
The first half of HotD season 1 won them back. HotD is garbage now, obviously, but a lot of people haven't realised it yet (kind of like seasons 3-6 of GoT). People also loved Dunk and Egg, but one season per book is way too slow given how long the breaks are between seasons. Egg will be a grown ass man by the time they reach Gaeymon.
>>
I still don't get how the eggs hatched.
>>
File: 1782169882050.mp4 (113 KB, 1280x640)
113 KB
113 KB MP4
>>25663124
>The TV show(s) poisoned all of the goodwill that people had towards this IP.
GoT would not have ended in disaster if he told HBO or Warner Bros to adapt the books more faithfully. The last two books were barely adapted.

But the core issue is always from George and his inability to finish anything. The main series? Incomplete. Dunk & Egg? Incomplete. The fucking psudeo history books? INCOMPLETE!
>>
File: magic.png (670 KB, 722x478)
670 KB PNG
>>25663136
>>
>>25663120
Read the comment dumb fuck. The eggs are am important symbol of the house. Blackfyre is more than just a sword. Maybe read the source material. Power resides where people believe it resides.
>>
>>25663140
>The last two books were barely adapted.
The parts about the main characters were adpated (albeit shittily). There was never a chance that they would adapt the filler (Arianne, Quentin, Brienne's wanderings) or all the setup that goes nowhere (Lady Stoneheart, Faegon, Euron as le scary sorcerer). If GRRM himself knew what to do with all that shit, he would've finished the series years ago.
>>
>>25663169
Dragons are a symbol of House Targaryen, nobody gives a fuck about eggs, living or stone. Do you think Bobby B freaked out when he heard that Dany got dragon eggs?
>Damn she has dragon eggs, the symbol of House Targaryen! The small folk and noble houses will surely rally to her because she has dragon eggs!
Lol no. They're a nothing burger. People cared about the Dothraki horde and her Targaryen blood.
>>
>>25663188
Read akotsk you fucking moron. Symbols of the house and the throne are what makes or breaks a rebellion. The third dunk and egg novella is literally about a claimant for the throne trying to get a dragon egg because he needs a symbol that legitimizes his claim for the throne and he doesnt have blackfyre.
>>
>>25663252
That book was about a doomed rebellion started by a guy who misinterpreted a dragon dream. Them scrambling for any shred of legitimacy is part of the joke, that they're so desperate they'll bring up fucking dragon eggs as proof of his claim to the throne. Fuck the sword, fuck the egg, the reason no one cared was because he didn't have Bittersteel.
>>
>>25663120
>expensive gift
Extremely expensive. Euron had one and it was enough to pay for a faceless man which we are also told is expensive enough to cost as much as an army.
>>
What happens if Count Ploppington finds out Dame Shartleton has been having sex with Earl Sloparse?

ANYONE?
>>
>>25663291
A live dragon head is worth a lot more than a stone dragon egg.
>>
File: 1739967714861455.jpg (66 KB, 1170x1132)
66 KB JPG
>>25663299
A live dragon egg*.
>>
>>25663299
How do you know he had a live one?
>>
not literature btw
>>
>>25663299
Erm what
>>
>>25663293
This has been deboonked, Nazi. Robert Maxwell has made it so. Take your mandatory psychotropics immediately.
>>
Is this seething /his/torian jealous that we're actually allowed to think without a loicense new or has this been a regular thing?
>>
>>25663304
Because he tried to hatch it. How do you know he used it to pay a Faceless Man.
>>
>>25663445
Well...Daenerys also tried and succeeded in hatching petrified eggs.
>How do you know he used it to pay a Faceless Man.
Cause of his shit story about how he threw it in the sea makes no sense and we know he hired a faceless man to kill his brother.
>>
>>25663455
He says he threw it into the sea, because his brother was thrown into the sea, and he paid for that act with the dragon egg. Its not complicated.
>>
>>25663896
wat....
>>
>>25663443
He's been here at least a month.
>>
>ao3 is down again
>>
so gta6 is out

where the fuck is it, George?
>>
>>25663973
Gone, reduced to atoms,
>>
>>25663124

I'm a pre-HBO Game of Thrones fan having gotten into the series around the time A Feast for Crows came out and I agree to an extent. The shows have been fun for the most part some good; some bad but I miss the smaller fanbase it had back in the day. The fanbase has only gotten worse as the series has gotten more exposure and popularity over the years, Makes me wonder had GRRM not gotten the TV deal and Ice and Fire hadn't exploded in popularity in the way it did if we'd be finished the main sequence of books now.

This series is truly a monkey's paw.

>>25663052

I really don't think we're ever going to get a resolve on Aegon's true parentage in the end and it probably won't matter. Unless he dies death by dragon symbolising he's a pretender I think it'll add a lot more complexity to his character.
>>25663136

Soul magic my man. Look at how the funeral pyre and ritual worked for Daenerys when Drogo was on his death bed but I think that was just a lucky accident more than anything it's just because Daenerys had the eggs on hand close by that everything resulted in the way that they did so the three souls are: Drogo, Miri, and Rhaego.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.