[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/m/ - Mecha

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: HUuIzRsbcAASPTz.jpg (248 KB, 1516x2000)
248 KB JPG
mystery nigga
>>
>>24049577
The first thing that came to my mind was Tallgeese with Hi-Nu wings.
>>
>>24049596
same but with the hi nu wings only
>>
>another chad strike freedom design
Feels good to have seed kino back after the travesty that was gcucks
>>
>>24049851
>those rifles
I think it's a Destiny or Impulse variation.
>>
>people seriously believed Shinn wouldn't be piloting a new Gundam
Man you're all suckers.
>>
>>24049879
>>24049851
What if the guns are meant to be VSBRs?
>>
>>24049577
It would be pretty funny if it was some sort of mass produced version of Destiny Gundam (similar to Rising Gundam or Immortal Justice). I guess call it Eternal Destiny? Some sort of battery powered Destiny Gundam that gets wrecked during the movie while fighting a hijacked Strike Freedom.
>>
File: file.png (548 KB, 800x1031)
548 KB PNG
>>24050094
Unlikely. Destiny was the symbol of Durandal's scheme to enslave the world. It's literally named after his plan. Why would anyone want to mass-produce that?
And besides, you already have Destiny Impulse. Same performance, none of the hassle.
>>
>>24049851
>chad
>k*no
Fuck off my board with your worthless buzzwords, tourist.
>>
>>24050094
That's MSV, so it won't be in the movie.
>>
>>24049987
I don't think that was in question. Neither is the fact that SF will mop the floor with whatever shit Shinn's piloting, even without Kira in the cockpit
>>
>>24050327
105 Dagger was originally an MSV design as well, and it was featured in the movie.
>>
>>24050323
>Same performance, none of the hassle.
Its not the same performance. In the books they say that Impulse Gundam's frame couldn't handle the Wings of Light. Because of the core splendor dilhouettes system, the impulse frame was too fragile and developed cracks and stress fractures from using the WoL
>>
>>24050325
Or else what?
What are you gonna do about it? Gonna cry? Little Duel jr
>>
File: msv.jpg (789 KB, 1883x1279)
789 KB JPG
>>24049577
>>
>>24054206
All MS look the same to you
>>
>>24054206
Ugly ass blue.
>>
File: HVRu_O_aoAAv5T4.jpg (312 KB, 909x1200)
312 KB JPG
>>
>>24054206
>>24054550
they were actually niggas
>>
>>24054206
Man fuck Zakus
We can't have a good guy Green Gundam because Green became exclusive for evil guys
>>
>>24054206
>>24054550
Man, I really hate Immortal's Justice wings. Definitely one of the worst looking Seed backpacks.
>>
>>24049987
This is MSV. Shinn is gonna be piloting Infinite Justice in the film to set up him replacing Athrun at the beginning of Freedom.
>>
File: HVRu_PFasAA5LyG.jpg (267 KB, 1200x792)
267 KB JPG
>>
>>24054770
Are there other units in this MSV?
>>
>The Rising Freedom CDE Spec Model is a simplified production variant based on this unit, with its specifications adjusted to allow for operation by other organizations. The head, chest ducts, and shoulder verniers have been replaced with parts prioritizing maintainability, and some of the armaments have been swapped out for easier-to-handle alternatives.
>>
File: 5czw6a8tg9xh1.jpg (367 KB, 1502x2048)
367 KB JPG
>>24057251
>The Immortal Justice CDE Spec is a simplified production model with its specifications adjusted so it can be operated by other organizations as well. The head, chest ducts, and shoulder verniers have been replaced with parts designed for ease of maintenance, and it is equipped with hand-held weapons shared with the Rising Freedom CDE Spec. The Calcitra Heavy Beam Cutting Legs have been omitted. It is believed that both the Rising Freedom CDE Spec and the Immortal Justice CDE Spec were developed around CE 75, though the exact timing remains unknown.
>>
File: a4nxsmbvg9xh1.png (453 KB, 991x296)
453 KB PNG
>>24057256
>The STTS-909 Rising Freedom and STTS-808 Immortal Justice (CDE-spec models) are demonstration Mobile Suits that were exhibited at the CDE (Comprehensive Defense Exhibition), a weapons trade show jointly hosted by Earth and PLANT. CDE...
[CUT OFF]
>...supplying weapons to third countries poses a threat to national security. To ensure that the weapons sold would not be turned against the country itself, DEDO [apparently stands for "Defense Equipment Development Organization"] implemented specifications controls that went beyond the scope of the design bureau. Specific measures included the black-boxing of critical components, intentionally degrading performance, and...
[CUT OFF]
>...improving long-range capabilities. In conjunction with this, assembly methods were redesigned, significantly reducing the time required for replacement in the event of damage. The heat exchange ducts that make up the thermal fluid circuit—including those in the chest area—were also redesigned to improve heat dissipation characteristics and mitigate the reduction in component strength caused by thermal stress.
>>
File: 2333001122184152867_n.png (382 KB, 1080x894)
382 KB PNG
>>24057282
In other words, these are monkey models, not unlike the proposed F-16/79 or the Tigershark.

It's also interesting that the text says "Earth", rather than "Earth Alliance". Does that mean Orb? Because the text is explicit that these units are derived from the Murasame's technology. While the Atlantic Federation is in good terms with PLANT after the second war and joined COMPASS, that's not the case with Eurasia.
My guess is that whatever potential buyer would probably have been a user of EA-manufactured units (Strike Daggers or Dagger Ls), which would explain the visor head.
>>
>>24056358
They also featured Sword Calamity, for some reason.
>>
>>24057251
nice rifle
>>
File: HVTkA9ybUAAlXKn.jpg (288 KB, 3802x1035)
288 KB JPG
Left to right:
>1/144 BuCUE Tactical Reconnaissance Type
>1/100 Sword Calamity
>1/144 Immortal Justice CDE
>1/144 Rising Freedom CDE
>1/144 Destiny Impulse Theta
>1/144 Strike DRAGOON (from SEED Recollection)
>1/144 GuAIZ Assault (from SEED Recollection)
>>
More information from 2026/12 Hobby Japan magazine:
>At the CDE (Comprehensive Defense Exhibition)—a weapons trade show organized by DIE (Defense Industry Association), an industry association of weapons development companies to which Earth and PLANT belong— PLANT's DEDO (Defense Equipment Development Organization) exhibited these demonstrator MS. The MS were manufactured under DEDO’s direction through a collaborative effort involving established design bureaus such as Heinlein, Asimov, and Clarke, as well as newly established bureaus led by Gernsback, Komatsu, and Smith. It is also reported that technical cooperation was provided by Orb-based companies, including Morgenrote, though both DEDO and Orb have declined to comment officially.

>Their PS armor is equipped with a function that adjusts its reflectivity of visible light, allowing it to adopt camouflage patterns that match the terrain and vegetation of the operational area. Although its ballistic performance is lower than that of the PS armor on previous models in order to reduce power consumption, this adjustment was made at the request of DEDO.

Morita follows on the old tradition of naming ZAFT's design bureaus after SF authors:

>Gernsback
After Hugo Gernsback, legendary editor of Amazing Stories magazine. The Hugo Awards are named after him

>Komatsu
After Sakyo Komatsu, author of "Japan Sinks" and "Virus". Coincidentally, he shares his surname with Komatsu Ltd., a manufacturer of heavy machinery and combat vehicles.

>Smith
Most likely after L.L. Smith, author of the Lensman series.
>>
Disappointed we don't have an MSF variant developed for testing reverse-engineered Cal-Re.A tech and weaponry
>>
>>24059081
My guess is that the movie's finale is a hard closure for the CE.
Nobody touches the aftermath until/unless Fukuda moves first.
>>
>>24059081
>Cal-Re.A tech
It doesn't have any original technology except the beam absorbing armor Femto armor which recharges the battery. And the databooks say you can't have phase shift armor and Femto armor on the same suit. It's why Akatsuki doesn't have phase shift armor either. The Foundation were only a threat because went hard on drone technology and invested so much resources into drones. Plus building up their forces in secret when everyone was busy. Frankly I'm surprising that 4 ships (Millennium and 3 Orb ships) somehow annihilated all of Foundations fleet of dozens of ships by themselves. It's frankly absurd the more you think about it.
>>
>>24059085
Fukuda said he would leave CE in the hands of later talent after Freedom but that was before Zero got oked.
>>
>>24059105
Millenium was that powerful, plus alot of them stood down when Zaft retook control
>>
>>24059248
Fukuda said that there were no Foundation survivors. Compass killed them all. Only the remnants of the rebel Zaft faction survived.
>>
>>24059257
then it's his problem for making the good guys too strong
>>
>>24059257
>>24059246
>Fukuda said, Fukuda said, Fukuda said, Fukuda said, Fukuda said, Fukuda said, Fukuda said, Fukuda said, Fukuda said, Fukuda said, Fukuda said, Fukuda said, Fukuda said, Fukuda said, Fukuda said, Fukuda said....
We are all getting real tired of your shit, Fukudafaggot. PUT UP LINKS TO THE FUCKING TWEETS OR SHUT THE FUCK UP.
>>
File: Naturals in Foundation.png (323 KB, 1316x908)
323 KB PNG
>>24059257
ENOUGH OF YOUR FUCKING LIES. This was already settled a year ago and it was only about witnesses to the SF and IJ (in all likelihood, this answer was made in jest), not Foundation as a whole.
https://desuarchive.org/m/thread/23382903/#23385761

Nobody has said anything about the aftermath for Foundation (either the country or its armed forces) after the nuking of its capital and the elimination of Aura and her Accords. Nobody. Not even the novelization points out anything about it. Was it occupied by Eurasia after it retaliated for the nuclear attack on Eldore? Did the Naturals who were oppressed under the Destiny Plan rebel against whatever pro-Aura forces were still around?
>>
>>24059297
novel
not
canon
>>
>>24059299
The excerpt is about the treatment of Naturals in Foundation, which has nothing to do with the first discussion.
Was everyone killed in the false-flag nuclear attack? Unlikely, since overall casualties from the botched operation are about 50k, according to the movie (Hiroshima killed some 100k, and that was a small city in the 1940s).
>>
>>24059297
1. I was talking about the Foundation fleet in space. They were obliterated completely.

2. The Novel is not canon. Fukuda even joked about supplementary material and said fans shouldn't take it seriously. That the books are only for fun.
>>
>>24059348
>Fukuda even joked about supplementary material and said fans shouldn't take it seriously. That the books are only for fun.
YES, YOU ALREADY SAID THAT SHIT BEFORE, you stupid fucking braindead Fukudafaggot.
https://desuarchive.org/m/thread/24022899/#24023866

Get some new fucking material. What, are you going to rant about the Millennium's origins without even having the FUCKING DECENCY OF PUTTING A SOURCE TO WHATEVER BULLSHIT YOU KEEP TRANSCRIBING FROM TWITTER?!
>>
>>24059348
>I was talking about the Foundation fleet in space. They were obliterated completely.
Wasnt it obvious? Kira fires that electricity attack and all those foundation ships are zapped with like trillions of volts of electricity. those crews must have turned into beef jerky.
>>
File: file.png (218 KB, 720x700)
218 KB PNG
>>24059367
Random question: does the Director's Cut add a Baldr-class firing its three positron guns? Because they never use them in the original cut.
>>
There's no fucking way in hell they're showing the Jesus Machine getting beat by a GM.
>>
>>24059465
do dijehs count?
>>
>>24059387
I skipped through the final battle again and couldn't see them being used even once
>>
>>24059465
The Freedom was beaten by a Dijeh in Build Fighters.
>>
>>24059500
The Dijeh is Amuro's Zeta mech. The fanboys would sooner kill their firstborn child than let anything threaten Zeta Gundam.
>>
>>24059500
Hi Nu jobbed to wires and architecture in Gunpla Builders
>>
>>24059725
That's just a good strategy.
>>
STTS-909 Rising Freedom (CDE Spec) / STTS-808 Immortal Justice (CDE Spec)

>Commentary by Shigeru Morita (Studio Nue)

The STTS-909 Rising Freedom and STTS-808 Immortal Justice (CDE Spec) are demonstration Mobile Suits that were exhibited at the CDE (Comprehensive Defense Exhibition), an international arms exhibition organized by the DIE (Defense Industry Association), an industry group comprising weapons and military equipment development companies from both Earth and PLANT. The exhibitor was PLANT's DEDO (Defense Equipment Development Organization). DEDO is an organization that was reorganized after the war under a new leadership structure and serves as the overarching military procurement agency at the top of PLANT's unique development bureau system. The two CDE-specification units were manufactured under DEDO’s command through a collaborative effort that combined traditional design bureaus—such as Heinlein, Asimov, and Clarke—with the newly established Gernsback, Komatsu, and Smith design bureaus. This development approach was adopted due to the unique status of the demonstration units. While the possibility of technical cooperation with Orb corporations, including Morgenrote, has been suggested, there have been no official comments from either DEDO or Orb.

In a volatile international environment, allies can become enemies overnight. Therefore, supplying excessively high-spec weapons to third countries poses a threat to a nation’s own national security. To ensure that sold weapons do not turn against the country of origin, DEDO implemented spec controls that transcended the limits of individual development bureaus. Specific measures include the black-boxing of key components, intentionally degrading performance, and implementing mechanisms to disable functions via remote control; however, the details remain unknown.
>>
>>24064340 (part 2)
Its most distinctive feature—the demonstration-use color scheme—appears to be mere paint at first glance, but is actually an application of Phase-Shift technology. This function was implemented as a camouflage system that adapts to the terrain and vegetation of the operational area, achieving color changes by manipulating the armor’s reflectivity of visible light. The ballistic protection of the PS armor is set lower than that of its preceding models. Officially, this is presented as a measure to reduce power consumption and extend operational time, but in reality, it is the result of adjustments made by DEDO. Note that while there were earlier models that utilized Mirage Colloid for their camouflage function, this system required complex support equipment for operation and was therefore not adopted. The head sensor array is equipped with a new-generation module featuring improved multimodal capabilities and noise resistance. The shoulder armor features a newly designed layered internal structure, aimed at reducing weight and improving stress dispersion. Consequently, the assembly method has been redesigned, significantly reducing the time required for replacement in the event of damage. The heat exchange ducts that make up the thermal fluid circuit—including those in the chest and other areas—have also been redesigned, improving heat dissipation and mitigating the reduction in structural strength caused by thermal stress.
>>
>>24064341
The CDE emphasized flexible localization tailored to operational environments. However, localizing a Mobile Suit—originally developed as a high-performance multi-role machine—through specification control deviates from its original design philosophy. Consequently, it is reported that the development team derided the approach, saying, “This isn’t a wolf in sheep’s clothing; it’s a sheep in a wolf’s clothing.” Furthermore, some have suggested that this may be attributed to a specific pilot from the previous war who possessed an unknown ability known as the “Superior Evolutionary Element Destined (SEED)-factor". DEDO has not commented on this matter at all.

Please note that the units' names and model numbers at the time of exhibition may be modified in accordance with the regulations of the technology recipient.
>>
>>24064341
>>24064344
>>24064340
>implementing mechanisms to disable functions via remote control
So why would anyone buy these machines?

Why buy these downgraded Rising Freedom or Immortal Justice units when you could buy 50 Zakus without remote disable? Or 50 Windams?

Seems like this MSV is trying too hard to make a niche slot between original Freedom Gundam and Rising Freedom.
>>
File: F-35_SouthKorea.jpg (2.02 MB, 1925x1125)
2.02 MB JPG
>>24064404
>So why would anyone buy these machines?
>Why buy these downgraded Rising Freedom or Immortal Justice units when you could buy 50 Zakus without remote disable? Or 50 Windams?

Why would anyone buy F-35s (instead of much cheaper Gripens or Hornets) when the Pentagon can disable them at any point?
https://www.defensenews.com/global/europe/2025/04/15/f-35-nations-prize-spare-parts-as-us-dismisses-kill-switch-angst/
>>
>>24064427
Because there's huge difference in performance between a Gripen and an F-35.

I don't see the same difference of performance between these downgraded Rising Freedom and Immortal Justice machines. They don't have the dragoon shields, they are battery powered, and Immortal Justice doesn't even have leg beam sabers. Why would anyone buy the Immortal Justice then? Its just supposed to be a close combat specialist but only has 2 beam sabers.
>Pentagon can remote disable them.
Your news article refutes your own point. A kill switch doesn't exist. If it did, then the USA wouldn't be worried about the fighter getting stolen by foreign countries.

But spare parts and supplies can be cut off. If you need engine maintenance or spare parts to fix something broken, then Lockheed can also stop offering software updates though. So the plane won't work properly with the latest missiles.
>>
>>24064450
>Because there's huge difference in performance between a Gripen and an F-35.
And there's a huge difference in performance between a downgraded Freedom and a fucking Windam. It still has all four of its cannons, plus rifle and sabers and Phase Shift. Piloted by an experienced pilot facing enemy grunts, it would still dominate the battlefield.

>A kill switch doesn't exist. If it did, then the USA wouldn't be worried about the fighter getting stolen by foreign countries.
No, the US *says* the kill-switch doesn't exist. Which isn't the same that there isn't one, and if you take the Pentagon by their word, you're a fucking moron. Who knows if there isn't something hidden deep in some firmware that would cripple the fighter for good.
>>
>>24064453
>downgraded Freedom and a fucking Windam.
It's not a downgraded Freedom. It's a double downgraded Freedom. Phase Shift Armor that's even weaker than the movie version, downgraded weapons, decreased output, etc.
>>
>>24064453
>No, the US *says* the kill-switch doesn't exist. Which isn't the same that there isn't one, and if you take the Pentagon by their word, you're a fucking moron. Who knows if there isn't something hidden deep in some firmware that would cripple the fighter for good.

Then that same logic could be applied to any modern fighter that other countries export. What's stopping China, Russia, or the EU from having kill switches in their export fighters they sell to other countries? Your entire point makes no sense.
>>
>>24064464
That just sounds like it's more likely for there to be kill switches than not.
>>
>>24064462
>downgraded weapons, decreased output
Compared to a state-of-the-art unit.

>Phase Shift Armor that's even weaker than the movie version
The one that needed a bunch of needles specifically to shut it down?

You need to think in terms of the opposition you'd be facing. The first battle in the movie gives us a rough idea of that scenario: GINNs, DINNs and ZuOOTs against Windams, obsolete Daggers and even more obsolete linear tanks. Any side that deploys even a downgraded Freedom would dominate the battlefield.

>>24064464
F-35 requires constant system updates from Lockheed to operate. And I don't mean a patch that gets installed over the internet: they have to send a human technician to your base.

China and modern-day Russia couldn't care less who uses their trash, but the US is obsessed with maintaining a technological edge against a potential foe. They've made a tradition of selling downgraded models of their stuff.
>>
>>24064466
So why is the Kill Switch argument against the USA somehow unique or special? If a country doesn't want to buy the F-35 because of potential kill switches, then it doesn't guarantee other countries don't have the same thing in their fighters.
>>
File: T64B.png (597 KB, 800x534)
597 KB PNG
>>24064478
>So why is the Kill Switch argument against the USA somehow unique or special?
Because, again, the US is obsessed about maintaining a technological edge (so did the Soviets, by the way: T-64 was never exported and Bloc allies got monkey models), and Lockheed requires dedicated on-site software maintenance for the F-35. The helmets are made custom for each individual pilot.
>>
>>24064469
>China and modern-day Russia couldn't care less who uses their trash

Oh China absolutely does care. When the Chinese government saw how poorly their Chinese weapons systems and anti-stealrh radar did in Venezuela and Iran against the USA, the Chinese government arrested the Engineers who created the anti-stealth radar, missiles, and the Chinese J-20 stealth fighter. They have been accused of corruption, embezzlement, and selling information.
>>
>>24064484
Yeah but the F-35 is not gimped for partner countries. Everyone in the program gets the same F-35.

Zaft is trying to sell a severely weakened Freedom Gundam.
>>
>>24064493
>Zaft is trying to sell a severely weakened Freedom Gundam.
Which, again, is more than enough against whatever threat your potential buyer will be fighting against. Even a gimped Freedom can rape an entire platoon of Windams like it's nothing.
>>
>>24064501
But you are forgetting that they are selling this as a "premium super Gundam" at premium prices. This isn't some cheapo mass production machine at bargain basement prices. This is a Gundam.

This single Rising Freedom is worth what? 50 Windams in price? I'm not convinced this Rising Freedom is worth that much. I'm convinced the Rising Freedom was only that good in the movie because Kira was piloting it. No way someone like Lunamaria or Agnes could pull off those moves.
>>
>>24064504
>But you are forgetting that they are selling this as a "premium super Gundam" at premium prices. This isn't some cheapo mass production machine at bargain basement prices. This is a Gundam.
What the fuck are you even arguing here? That one Gundam can blow up half a dozen Windams before they have any time to react. The sensor suite is new, meaning it can do its auto-aim beamspam with no issue whatsoever. And yes, those beam cannons in the shoulders (even downgraded from the "real" Rising) will turn Windams into slag with no issue.

>This single Rising Freedom is worth what? 50 Windams in price?
That's a bit much, I think. Akatsuki's armor is worth 20 times the price of an M1, and that thing's basically a Strike with DRAGOONs.
How much more expensive would a downgraded Freedom be in comparison? Five times the price of a ZAKU, which weren't exported by ZAFT as far as we know?

>No way someone like Lunamaria or Agnes could pull off those moves.
What? Taking down a bunch of worthless grunts like the Windam? Shinn did it constantly with the Impulse, which has inferior capabilities compared even to this Freedom. Kira just bothers to get in close to disable his foes with melee, but a more conventional engagement would be shoot to kill.
Agnes was a shitty pilot, but Lunamaria could take out a Destroy and fended off against aces quite competently.
>>
>>24064512
>What the fuck are you even arguing here?
That this downgraded Rising Freedom doesn't seem that cost effective or have enough value to justify the price. Let's assume it costs 15 to 20 Windams. Those 20 Windams can cover a wider area and deal with anything short of a Gundam.

If you do encounter a Gundam, why not just buy a cheaper surplus machine from the EA like a Raider Gundam or Sword Calamity?
>>
>>24064512
>Shinn did it constantly with the Impulse, which has inferior capabilities compared even to this Freedom.

1. I'm not even sure how powerful this Freedom is supposed to be. Stronger than original Freedom? Weaker than Impulse?


2. Isn't that because Shinn knew he had the Deuterion beam system to rely on, so he just spammed his beam weapons without worrying about saving power because Minerva could recharge him easily in just a few seconds?
>>
>>24064525
they barely used the beam, the one time that stood out was when he needed it against a mobile armor
>>
>>24064525
I'm pretty sure it's about on paper with Impulse, maybe a little more powerful but still weaker than a nuclear powered machine. We see during the Eurasia fight that Rising and Immortal can't keep up with a single Black Knight machine while the SF and Destiny can keep up with several at once.

Rising isn't without it's tricks though. The original Freedom could barely make a dent in the Destroy's until it literally jammed it's saber right down it's cannon barrels because it's weapons couldn't get through it's shields while Rising has the remote shield which hacks right through it.
>>
>>24064600
So is this version of Rising Freedom better or worse than the 2nd stage series Gundams like Saviour Gundam and Chaos?


>Rising isn't without it's tricks though. The original Freedom could barely make a dent in the Destroy's until it literally jammed it's saber right down it's cannon barrels because it's weapons couldn't get through it's shields while Rising has the remote shield which hacks right through it.

Fair point, but this export version of Rising Freedom >>24054770 Wing sold to other countries doesn't even have the remote control drone shield. It's just a normal shield. So how strong is this Rising Freedom?
>>
I get why someone would want to buy a cut down Freedom but why would anyone buy a cut down Justice? It has no special features and if they cost the same why not more Freedoms?
>>
>>24064632
athrun fanboys

alternatively it probably costs less because it doesn't have as many guns
>>
File: Raptor cutaway.jpg (184 KB, 1453x863)
184 KB JPG
Imagine, if you will, Lockheed Martin being cleared by the Pentagon to sell a cut-down "F-22E" for export markets in lieu of the JSF:
>downgraded stealth coating
>F135 engines instead of the F119s, thus no supercruise
>no internal weapons bay
>AN/APG-82 radar instead of the Raptor's AN/APG-77

Even with all of those handicaps, you think the big export clients wouldn't jump at the chance? It would immediately be adopted by Japan, South Korea, Singapore, the Saudis, "them"...
>>
>>24064916
But the Rising Freedom is no F-22. It's a 4 year old design from the first war (which in Seed years means it's so old). Plus everyone already has the blueprints for Freedom Gundam and NJC technology. Remember that it got leaked by Rau. So why would they buy a cut down freedom when they could just build their own?
>>
>>24064916
Im genuinely shocked America hasn't restarted production of the F-22. That fighter is still the pinnacle of fighter jet technology. No one can match it in a dogfight. The stealth is also very good too even after 20 years.
>>
>>24065014
>But the Rising Freedom is no F-22. It's a 4 year old design from the first war (which in Seed years means it's so old).
And it's still a powerhouse compared to shitty Windams. Freedom rapes grunts in seconds.

>Plus everyone already has the blueprints for Freedom Gundam and NJC technology. Remember that it got leaked by Rau.
He leaked it to Azrael, who mass-produced it for nukes. Rau didn't put the whole thing on the internet for anyone to download. Keep in mind that the Earth Alliance has zero nuclear-powered MS or MAs. Even the Destroy's is listed as "unknown" in databooks.

>So why would they buy a cut down freedom when they could just build their own?
So why haven't they? Even Foundation skipped nuclear reactors entirely and went with that Femto technology of theirs.
By your logic, there should be a dozen breakaway states like Foundation around making counterfeit Freedoms, plus whatever freelancers and other independents can muster.
Instead, this is a joint project by all of ZAFT's design bureaus, meaning that building even a downgraded battery-powered Freedom is extremely complex and requires all hands on deck.
>>
>>24065024
And aren't all mobile armors powered by nuclear reactors?
>He leaked it to Azrael, who mass-produced it for nukes.
He didn't do it by himself. We see entire rooms of scientists and engineers analyzing Freedom and Justice Gundam blueprints. Azrael shared the data with the EA engineers.
>>
>>24065034
>And aren't all mobile armors powered by nuclear reactors?
Not that we know of. The Möbius series of MAs couldn't have been, at least.
>>
>>24065024
To be honest, I don't pay attention to databooks anymore. Not since the director of gundam seed and the staff started announcing stuff on social media and in interviews. Like the director said that proud defender and meteor were equipped with internal nuclear reactors but no databooks actually say that. But there's no fan explanation otherwise for how meteor is able to be used by Impulse Gundam or why strike freedoms nuclear reactor restarted after docking with proud defender.
>>
>>24065042
>since the director of gundam seed
Fun's over, everyone. Fukudafaggot appeared to ruin shit up.

>proud defender and meteor were equipped with internal nuclear reactors but no databooks actually say that. But there's no fan explanation otherwise for how meteor is able to be used by Impulse Gundam or why strike freedoms nuclear reactor restarted after docking with proud defender.
To be fair, METEORs don't even appear on any of the Freedom databooks (outside of them being docked as turrets for the Eternal) and Proud Defender has a very sparse description.
https://e-hentai.org/g/3252328/a3c050ae1b/

And besides, if ZAFT could retrofit nuclear reactors to the old Duel and Buster, them adding them to something as massive as the damn METEORs is trivial in comparison.
>>
>>24065024
>By your logic, there should be a dozen breakaway states like Foundation around making counterfeit Freedoms, plus whatever freelancers and other independents can muster.
The issue isn't building nuclear reactors. The issue appears to be that building the "cancellor" part is very expensive. So states have put their limited money into putting cancellors on their nuclear missiles. The mobile suits still run on battery. Losing a mobile suit isn't a big deal. Losing a mobile suit with an NJC would be a huge loss. Not every pilot can be a super pilot like Kira and dodge everything and win.

Plus breakaway states and countries probably don't want to have their mobile suits pilots to have too much power and freedom. A battery forces the pilot to return to base for recharge and repair. A nuclear reactor powered suit means any pilot can go rogue and fly away. No one could stop them. It's like those stories we hear of Soviet and North Korean pilots defecting and flying to Western countries
>>
>>24065079
>Plus breakaway states and countries probably don't want to have their mobile suits pilots to have too much power and freedom. A battery forces the pilot to return to base for recharge and repair. A nuclear reactor powered suit means any pilot can go rogue and fly away. No one could stop them.
If your main concern about developing powerful MS is the possibility of rogue pilots defecting, then you have bigger issues at play.

Related, it would've been fun if the Agnes story had been played backwards. Have Ingrid defecting to COMPASS early on after Orphee's complete rejection of her in favor of Lacus (plus not entirely agreeing with Aura's brainwashing), joining the good guys for the final fight, and then dying heroically.
>>
>>24065085
>If your main concern about developing powerful MS is the possibility of rogue pilots defecting, then you have bigger issues at play.
Not really. A strong military in especially unstable regions will always be used to suppress citizens. You can have Daggers and Ginns stomping down the street to intimidate citizens. These militaries would rather buy 100 older MS than 10 immortal justices. More suits = more intimidating
>>
>>24064916
Very few second and third world countries could afford to buy a stripped down F-22 let alone pay for the monthly maintenance.
>>
File: SG.png (1.02 MB, 960x960)
1.02 MB PNG
>>24065091
>>24065093
>A strong military in especially unstable regions will always be used to suppress citizens.
No. If you're a breakaway state like Foundation, your main concern will always be to stop anyone from trampling on your newly found independence. History has plenty of examples, but a good one is Singapore, which is crazy armed for such a tiny country (smaller than Atlanta or Hong Kong).
>170+ Leopard 2s.
>800+ IFVs
>20 Apaches
>24 HIMARS batteries
>40 F-15s
>20 F-35s
>>
File: Map of F-15 operators.png (56 KB, 1425x625)
56 KB PNG
>>24065093
That's why you offer it to the big customers: existing F-15 operators.
>>
>>24065101
You seem to have forgotten that the entire opening of Gundam Seed Freedom was breakaway states in Africa fighting wars and suppressing citizens.
>>
>>24065014
>>24065024
>>24065079
>>24065085

The answer is mentioned in a handful of conversations in Destiny. Piloting Nuclear equipped MS is difficult. It's mentioned in Destiny that more powerful an MS is the harder it is to control and the more skilled a pilot needs to be. Luna thinks Savior is beyond her capability and doubts she can pilot Impulse when it's handed to her (though she underestimates herself) and Shinn and Rey while training against Freedom point out how it's power should make those tight handles very difficult and Kira must be an incredible pilot to do those aerial acrobatics with it like he does.

The average Natural scrub pilot wouldn't be able to handle a nuclear powered MS without crashing. Even Mwu the cream of the Natural crop can't handle anything more advanced than a GAT-X series (the Akatsuki is basically just a fancier Strike with beam coating)
>>
>>24065484
>Even Mwu the cream of the Natural crop can't handle anything more advanced than a GAT-X series (the Akatsuki is basically just a fancier Strike with beam coating)
I disagree strongly. Mwu was able to fight Shinn and Rey and have a slight edge. Mwu was also able to keep up with Extended druggie pilots without issue.
>>
>>24065491
Mwu still has a clear tech gap he can't cross, being limited to the Strike Akatsuki (which is just a souped up Strike) Natural OS use MP units (Windam Murasame) or his mobile armors. He never gets anything more powerful than that. Despite him being leagues of a more skill pilot than the Extended trio nobody suggests he take Chaos instead of Sting for example.
>>
>>24065204
>breakaway states in Africa fighting wars and suppressing citizens.
That was not a breakaway state, dumbass. It's a SEZ affiliated to the PLANTs, where they always had a bunch of influence. And they were fighting to keep the Blue Cosmos supremacists away.
The only ones suppressing their citizens were the Foundation pukes, who were implementing the Destiny Plan.
>>
>>24065854
Every country on earth siding with Plant is a breakaway state. You are siding with Spacenoids
>>
File: Untitled-1.png (50 KB, 990x600)
50 KB PNG
>>24065860
For the umpteenth time, the Earth Alliance doesn't have complete control of the planet, as it is not a one-world government.

And the concept of "Spacenoid" doesn't exist here either.
>>
>>24065868
Those "territories" were conquered by the EA during Seed. Especially Orb. So yes EA was basically a one world government.

>Spacenoid
Coordinator or spacenoid. Same difference.
>>
>>24065906
They didn't "conquer" them. The EA just established control over the lost spaceport in Victoria, but PLANT still maintained its bases after the war ended and had to cede control of Orb and South America.

Stop being an annoying moron.
>>
>>24065911
>and had to cede control of Orb and South America.

Makes no sense. Zaft had no claim to Orb or South America.

>PLANT still maintained its bases after the war ended

No. Their Zaft earth fleets were depleted after the EA blew up Joshua .

The EA had functioning nukes again at the end of Seed. There's no reason they needed to give up anything on Earth.
>>
File: 35.jpg (410 KB, 1395x1003)
410 KB JPG
>>24065916
>Makes no sense. Zaft had no claim to Orb or South America.
First of all, it's "PLANT". ZAFT is the name of the armed forces.
Second, they didn't have any "direct claims" to it, but South America was aligned with them and Orb was a neutral state. You do understand the difference between conquest and being a treaty ally, correct?

>Their Zaft earth fleets were depleted after the EA blew up Joshua .
The forces they sent to conquer Alaska, not the security forces around their allied territories and bases.

>There's no reason they needed to give up anything on Earth.
Regardless of nukes, the Junius Treaty stipulated that both sides had to cede any territory they had conquered during the war:
>All national boundaries on Earth had to be restored to status quo ante bellum. Therefore, both the Orb Union and the United States of South America, which were seized by the Earth Alliance, became independent nations again.
>ZAFT had to leave the areas they conquered during the war. However, they were allowed to operate the Gibraltar and the Carpentaria Base on Earth.
What was the EA going to do? Glass anyone who disagreed with them and reignite a war they ended up very weak from?

You still think this is the One Year War. Stop it.
>>
>>24065923
>Regardless of nukes, the Junius Treaty stipulated that both sides had to cede any territory they had conquered during the war:
Why would Zaft have any claim over Orb. Nonsense.

>What was the EA going to do? Glass anyone who disagreed with them and reignite a war they ended up very weak from?
Zaft was much weaker. Their population is smaller. Every coordinator lost in battle is much worse for them. They can't replace their loses fast enough. They struggle to get pregnant or even have 1 child. A natural can have a dozen kids.

And yes nuke anyone who disagrees. There's zero reason EA has obey any treaty. Nukes are back on the table. They hold the upper hand at the end of the war. Their Earth forces ok the planet are fine . Zaft had no defense since Genesis blew up. And it's doubtful they could defend their bases.
>>
File: 05.41.789.jpg (182 KB, 640x480)
182 KB JPG
>>24065949
>Why would Zaft have any claim over Orb. Nonsense.
Did you read what I just said? It was the Earth Alliance who kept Orb as a "protectorate", an deal that was over with the peace treaty. PLANT (again, it's not fucking "ZAFT") had nothing to do with this.

>There's zero reason EA has obey any treaty.
>They hold the upper hand at the end of the war
But they did. The EA lost thousands of men in space to Genesis. It doesn't matter what you think or say: they signed the treaty regardless of your inane blabbering.
This is like arguing why doesn't Russia nuke Ukraine and be done with it in minutes.

>And it's doubtful they could defend their bases.
ZAFT still had their bases on Earth, which was enough for them to keep a foothold.

Your barely comprehensible writing makes me think you can't even speak English at all, so stop arguing about things you are unable to understand properly.
>>
>>24065965
>Did you read what I just said? It was the Earth Alliance who kept Orb as a "protectorate"
There is no protectorate. The EA conquered Orb. Then the Orb military ran away and set off a nuke blowing up their main factory as they left

>But they did. The EA lost thousands of men in space to Genesis
And Zaft lost thousands of men at Boaz and thousands more when Genesis blew up and thousands MORE when Jachin Due blew up. Zaft suffered MUCH worse. The Zaft chairman said they were going to lose the war if they didn't fire Genesis a few more times. Their defenses were literally crumbling and breaking and he begged his Zaft defense crews to hold on just a little longer until they could Genesis again. The EA was pushing forward bloodied but still pushing hard.

>ZAFT still had their bases on Earth, which was enough for them to keep a foothold.
No they didn't. Watch the anime properly grandpa. They lost their 2 main bases. Zaft lost Carpenteria. Zaft lost their Gibraltar base off screen in between episodes when EA got serious and wanted to push them off the planet. Thousands died when Zaft lose the bases.

Zaft was LOSING the war Badly. Losing. Their only hope was Genesis.

Watch the anime.
>>
File: file.png (52 KB, 800x183)
52 KB PNG
>>24065975
>There is no protectorate. The EA conquered Orb.
The official timeline, which is still printed on the Japanese-language databooks to this day, says clearly that Orb was made into a PROTECTORATE of the Atlantic Federation (note that, in this case, it's not the Earth Alliance).
https://web.archive.org/web/20050429015158/http://www.gundamofficial.com/worlds/ce/background/timeline.html

>set off a nuke blowing up their main factory as they left
It was a regular big-ass explosion to take out the mass driver.

>Zaft lost Carpenteria.
No, they never lost Carpentaria, either on the series proper or "off-screen". Stop making shit up.
The one thing they lost badly was Victoria, which was an EA facility.
Official timeline says that ZAFT lost their grip on Europe and, while the EA attempted to capture Carpentaria, there are no details as whether that operation was successful or not. No details either about losses, so you saying "thousands died" is another of your fucking badly-written lies.
And Gibraltar went back into ZAFT control with the treaty, making any battlefield gain a waste of resources.

>The EA was pushing forward bloodied but still pushing hard.
Does that matter at all when they still accepted a conditional ceasefire, meaning that all of your bullshit claims on your other posts are moot? Would that have happened if the Earth Alliance was as powerful as you keep blabbering it was?

It's pathetic you tell people to watch the anime when none of your claims holds to even the easiest scrutiny. STOP MAKING SHIT UP, FAGGOT.
>>
>>24065989
>No, they never lost Carpentaria, either on the series proper or "off-screen". Stop making shit up
No you just are ignorant. Zaft lost Carpentaria to a siege by the Earth Alliance. Stop quoting old archived websites. They are outdated and contain old info. It's disqualified. Look at Bandais official modern websites.
>>
>>24066006
If you can't be bothered to look it up then I can't be bothered to look it up. Simple as that. The resource existing does not automatically win the argument for you.
>>
>>24065965
>>24065989
Anon you need to read the supplementary material. The first War ended with the EA fleet crippled in space, but in 100% complete control of Earth's surface. In space, the Earth Alliance lost their main space base on the moon, and the surviving Earth Alliance naval fleet had no fallback base. On the Earth, the EA armies were able to completely overpower ZAFT occupation forces through sheer numbers, and managed to successfully drive ZAFT completely off the planet.

However, the the ZAFT space navy, while heavily damaged, still existed and had bases at the Plants to repair and resupply. ZAFT was pushed to the breaking point in space, but barely managed to survive. The EA realized that not having any space base was unacceptable for their remaining forces in space. So they agreed to a ceasefire and things just kinda ended right there. The Treaty was eventually signed. Carpentaria and Gibralter were returned via treaty negotiations. ZAFT was allowed back on the planet. Orb was returned for whatever reason. Everyone was reset to the starting positions.
>>
File: CE 71.png (2.21 MB, 5088x2958)
2.21 MB PNG
>>24066006
>>24066014
>Zaft lost Carpentaria to a siege by the Earth Alliance. Stop quoting old archived websites. They are outdated and contain old info. It's disqualified. Look at Bandais official modern websites.
The modern timeline published in modern databooks (this is the one from Freedom Mechanics and World) has the same information as the one in the old GundamOfficial site: https://e-hentai.org/g/3252328/a3c050ae1b/

So no, you are the one that's making up shit by claiming some non-existing "official modern website".

>>24066019
>The first War ended with the EA fleet crippled in space, but in 100% complete control of Earth's surface.
>On the Earth, the EA armies were able to completely overpower ZAFT occupation forces through sheer numbers, and managed to successfully drive ZAFT completely off the planet.
Again, no proof whatsoever for this. You keep imagining a One Year War scenario that simply does not exist here, despite the superficial similarities.

>Orb was returned for whatever reason.
Because the treaty pushed all the maps back to square one. If Earth was in such a strong position on Earth, why would they return anything to PLANT? Or allow Orb to become independent again?
>>
>>24066019
Just because one old databook says that doesn't make it true. Fukuda says no and the new databooks ignore the old ones.
>>
>>24066056
>Fukuda says no
You again, Fukudafaggot? Fuck off forever off our board. You're worse than Aquarionoid, Yapool Sejin and Pitzfag put together.

>and the new databooks ignore the old ones.
No, they do not. In fact, Freedom M&W reprints a lot of material from the older CE M&W, sometimes verbatim.
>>
>>24066014
That faggot has been doing that shit for a while:
>anon: (makes claim about the CE, with proof)
>faggot: "NOOO THATS OLD MATERIAL NEW STUFF SAYS OTHERWISE"
>anon: "okay, where's the source for your claims?"
>faggot: (posts nothing, keeps BSing)
>anon: "you didn't prove anything, fag. Where's your source?"
>faggot (lying): "IM NOT TELLING YOU!!! YOU DONT HAVE ALL THE SOURCES".
>>
>>24065965
Some of the much older databooks said that the EA launched a ground offensive when they also launched their space offensive against ZAFT. The books (and even some of the tie-in video games based on those databooks) say the EA conquered all ZAFT bases on Earth. But this has been half retconned by newer databooks. It's questionable if it's canon anymore. What's funny is that Mitsuo Fukuda, Director of the Seed anime, has said to ignore ALL databooks even the modern ones and to pay attention to the anime only. He even said to ignore the manga too. So this whole supplementary lore discussion is meaningless if we believe the director.
>>
>>24066414
The backstory has become quite messy over the years. It's not worth arguing about anymore.
>>
>>24065916
The only have as many nukes as they have NJCs. NJCs aren't cheap or easy to make. The nuclear supply they did make were all used or shot down by Freedom and Justice. They'd have to spend a large amount of time rearming first. And this ignores the big point which is that Earth was souring on the war which to begin with was pushed by Blue Cosmos extremists. Azrael and his goons somehow always got their way despite that but they all died during the battle of Jachin Due. Djbril was still around but he didn't initially have the clout Azrael did as he says at the beginning of Destiny he couldn't restart the war without a good excuse to
>>
>>24066442
Diff anon here. Was there some scene in Seed Destiny where the EA generals said they needed another year to prepare and that it was too soon to launch another war, but Djibril said it was fine? I vaguely recall some conversation like that happening but I really can't remember. If it's true it makes me wonder if the EA would have performed better if they had another year of preparation. Imagine an army of Destroy Gundams attacking the PLANTS.
>>
>>24066445
Destroy Gundam are jobbers. Even Kira just reacted with mild indifference when he saw it again in seed freedom.

In gcucks the big zam army got scrubbed by a gyan.
>>
>>24066481
Destroy's are jobbers to protagonist Gundam's. When they aren't around they can do a crap ton of damage
>>
>>24066481
Isnt that because the Destroy Gundams in Seed Freedom were only built out of spare parts and not fully functional? Someone in this thread also said they were downgraded and piloted by Naturals now. So the natural OS makes them much weaker
>>
>>24066496
Watch the movie.
>>
File: 1772765748970.webm (2.97 MB, 1920x1080)
2.97 MB
2.97 MB WEBM
>>24066512
I did. The movie Destroy Gundam was weaker than the anime.
>>
>>24066496
The first Destroy in the film is seemingly complete. It's hard to say anything else about pilots or OSs because other than Stella's Destroy the other Destroy's deployed in the series were just as weak as in the movie.

Stella's Destroy has BS defenses even Sting's doesn't have. And even Stella's are inconsistent in the episode itself.
>>
File: 127_127.jpg (768 KB, 1502x1920)
768 KB JPG
>>24066414
>The books (and even some of the tie-in video games based on those databooks) say the EA conquered all ZAFT bases on Earth.
This is not true. WE HAVE BEEN THROUGH THIS ALREADY.
This Japanese-language timeline is from "Mobile Suit Gundam SEED Anatomy", published last year: https://e-hentai.org/g/2969692/ddc1ba0e62/

Some minor details aside, it's more or less the same content as the one published in GundamOfficial two decades ago: https://web.archive.org/web/20050429015158/http://www.gundamofficial.com/worlds/ce/background/timeline.html

They both mention an EA operation in the Australian continent to neutralize Carpentaria, but none of them points out at its outcome, much less that the EA was capable of securing the whole planet. The fact that they had to make a peace deal that gave ZAFT its two main bases would indicate that the latter operation couldn't have been successful.

>"Mitsuo Fukuda, Director of the Seed anime"
Who the fuck talks like this!? It almost sounds like you're worshipping the guy. Your simping for such an individual is a blight on the board, Fukudafaggot. Even Duel has more dignity than you do, since at least the vermin makes it all about himself.
>>
File: 1763247324166.jpg (55 KB, 640x480)
55 KB JPG
>>24066816
You are incorrect. The Gundam Seed Never Ending Tomorrow PS2 video game covers those events where ZAFT was pushed off the Earth. It's where Sword Calamity, Astray variants, and all those famous Seed MSVs are featured. This game is special because the staff and Bandai themselves said the game is authentic and canon to the Seed anime while promoting of the game to gamers and Gundam fans. It was supposed to be a big selling point about the video game.

Seed production Staff and different members were consulted and brought in to game's development to make sure the video game lined up with anime without any conflicts, and that it gave players a glimpse of what was happening across the Seed universe through different missions. Bandai invested heavily in this video game, and commissioned over 30 minutes of brand new Seed animation. Lots of Seed MSVs were featured as well. As far as I know, it's the only Gundam video game where Bandai has directly come out and said it's canon and authentic to Seed. It was a big deal. They made a bunch of gunpla model kits that were released alongside the video game as well.

Although I think Fukuda isn't happy about it. He's made several comments that he doesn't think Astray is authentic Gundam Seed. But I think Bandai has final say here. If Bandai says it's canon then it's canon. Fukuda can't override them here.
>>
>>24066816
Your databooks are meaningless. Also stop directly linking to e-hentai. You are eating their bandwidth. Download the picture yourself and reupload here as an attachment.

>>24066840
Yeah. Even Gundam wiki acknowledges that its canon.

>Although I think Fukuda isn't happy about it. He's made several comments that he doesn't think Astray is authentic Gundam Seed. But I think Bandai has final say here. If Bandai says it's canon then it's canon. Fukuda can't override them here.
Fukuda is against Seed Stargazer. So I don't consider his opinion valid here.
>>
>>24066844
>You are eating their bandwidth. Download the picture yourself and reupload here as an attachment.
WHAT THE FUCK DO YOU THINK IS ATTACHED TO THE POST, YOU IMBECILE?!

>Also stop directly linking to e-hentai. You are eating their bandwidth.
What "bandwidth"? E-Hentai is a P2P network.
>>
>>24066844
>Even Gundam wiki acknowledges that its canon.
Is this an admission that you are the shithead that's been stealing shit from /m/ to put on the fucking Wiki?

>Fukuda is against Seed Stargazer.
[citation needed]
>>
>>24066848
>Is this an admission that you are the shithead that's been stealing shit from /m/ to put on the fucking Wiki?
No you retard. I'm saying that even a site as anal as Gundam wiki admits the video game is canon.

>[citation needed]
Dude said that he doesn't consider any seed project he wasn't directly involved with as true gundam seed. That's just his opinion but I think it's a shitty thing to say and insults everyone else who helped keep gundam seed alive
>>
>>24066840
>The Gundam Seed Never Ending Tomorrow PS2 video game covers those events where ZAFT was pushed off the Earth. It's where Sword Calamity, Astray variants, and all those famous Seed MSVs are featured. This game is special because the staff and Bandai themselves said the game is authentic and canon to the Seed anime while promoting of the game to gamers and Gundam fans. It was supposed to be a big selling point about the video game.
I looked it up. This is false, or at least not corroborated by any source whatsoever. If you are going to make sweeping claims like this, at least have the FUCKING DECENCY to back them up, you stupid fucking liar dipshit.

>>24066851
>but I think it's a shitty thing to say and insults everyone else who helped keep gundam seed alive
What happened to your "he's the director and his word is law" nonsense?
>>
>>24065036
>>24065034
The Archangel is nuclear powered. So I'm not sure what the big deal is with admitting a mobile armor has nuclear power. Fukuda said that nuclear power doesn't determine a mobile suits performance. Destroy is obviously nuclear powered. There's no other explanation for all that beam spam. Batteries can't do that.
>>
>>24066855
>I looked it up.
No you didn't. You spent 2 minutes on Google doing a low effort search and couldn't find it because you are retarded. Then came back here to whine and bitch. If you were going to do research then at least spend more than 2 minutes doing to basic search. Don't be a lazy retard. Fuck dude. I remember spending DAYS looking up sources back in the 2000s. And your lazy ass can't even be bothered to spend more than 2 minutes doing research. Fucking disgrace is what you are.
>>
>>24066844
>Fukuda is against Seed Stargazer.
Stargazer is kind of boring if I'm being honest with you. The AI storyline made sense either and had no impact on mobile suit development.
>>
>>24066863
If you really had the information you claim to have, then you would post it. Instead, your only retort (as usual) is to lie and try to manipulate people. But I'm not falling for it.
>>
File: 1692246830319.jpg (369 KB, 1280x720)
369 KB JPG
>>24066857
>The Archangel is nuclear powered.
That's different from the nuclear fission used by MS and blocked by NJ technology. From settei and screenwriter Shigeru Morita: https://web.archive.org/web/20031204042935fw_/http://www.gundam-seed.net/special/column/column_01.html
>だけど、SEED世界の未来史では、「核融合発電は実用化に失敗」していてね。Nジャマーの影響下では、宇宙船の推進用レーザー核融合パルス推進だけが唯一、可能なわけ。
>However, in the future history of the SEED world, "Nuclear fusion power generation has failed to be put into practical use." Under the influence of the N-jammer, only laser fusion pulse propulsion for spacecraft propulsion is possible.

>Fukuda said
FUCKING ENOUGH WITH THE "FUKUDA SAID" BULLSHIT. YOU ARE PATHETIC.
>>
>>24066869
Im not the guy who wrote that long post you bumbling retard. But I WILL back up what I wrote when I said Gundam wiki thinks the video game is canon. They do.

https://gundam.fandom.com/wiki/Operation_8.8

They list as part of the official timeline of events. Now go make a wiki account and bother the wiki admins if you care so much about debating whether it's canon of not. They are more anal than you are.
>>
>>24066874
Assuming I believe the ramblings of Wiki editors...
>The war situation remained in favor of the Earth Alliance. However, the operation was protracted and was not settled before the end of the First Alliance-PLANT War, leading to a ceasefire.
Does that sound like the EA won that battle?
>>
>>24066878
Sounds like ZAFT was getting its ass kicked.
>>
>>24066840
>As far as I know, it's the only Gundam video game where Bandai has directly come out and said it's canon and authentic to Seed. It was a big deal.
I've asked before, but why the fuck do you write with the separate sentences? And where are you even getting this information? The fact that your lying ass doesn't have the courtesy of p
And no, your knowledge is incomplete. There was SEED staff involvement in Gundam SEED Recollection as well.

>>This game is special because the staff and Bandai themselves said the game is authentic and canon to the Seed anime while promoting of the game to gamers and Gundam fans. It was supposed to be a big selling point about the video game.
If it is "canon", then why none of the timelines mention that the EA captured Carpentaria?
And if they did, then why did they give it back with the Treaty of Junius and maintain control of the planet? That's not how it's supposed to work.

>But I think Bandai has final say here. If Bandai says it's canon then it's canon. Fukuda can't override them here.
Do you genuflect to any authority figure on command, or you just happen to follow the chain of command?
>>
>>24066889
Sounds like a stalemate, even with EA acquiring mobile suits. And, again, Carpentaria went back into ZAFT hands by the second war, making any effort in that front utterly meaningless in the end.
>>
>>24066878
I never agreed with anons summary of alevents. I only said that Gundam wiki thinks it's canon. Learn to read.
>>
>>24066871
>Under the influence of the N-jammer, only laser fusion pulse propulsion for spacecraft propulsion is possible.
Why can't it be used for mobile suits or mobile armors?
>>
>>24066946
Size. Also, in case you didn't read, it's a propulsion-only system: it can't power weapons.
>>
>>24066946
Presumably a laser pulse generation is too big to put on an MA or MS compared to a battleship Given the Freedom and Justice boast "Ultracompact" Nuclear reactors according to their specs that suggests the reactors are unusually small and are typically much bigger
>>
>>24066974
>Given the Freedom and Justice boast "Ultracompact" Nuclear reactors according to their specs that suggests the reactors are unusually small and are typically much bigger
Those are fission reactors.

Having said that, the Type IIs got upgraded fusion reactors.
>>
>>24066972
Then how does Archangel power its beam weapons?
>>
>>24066840
Iirc the earth alliance never fully captured the zaft carpenter base. You might be thinking of the missions where you can unlock alternate endings. Its been like 15 years since I played Never ending tomorrow though. Its too hazy. I might be wrong about the details. I dont have my PS2 anymore to check


>>24066855
Check the behind the scenes video interviews with Bandai and other production staff. Some of them mention that Never Ending tomorrow ks canon while promoting the game. I remember it being a selling point for the game back in the day. Bandia tried to make gundam fans feel like they would get big FOMO if they didnt play the game
>>
>>24066986
>Check the behind the scenes video interviews with Bandai and other production staff.
I certainly would if could find them anywhere online.
https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=終わらない明日へ

Most are gameplay or people complaining about it a reskin of Encounters in Space.
>>
>>24067000
well too bad it's still canon
>>
File: 050_50.png (950 KB, 1502x884)
950 KB PNG
>>24067008
You do understand that all the borders went back to square one after the peace treaty, right?
Even if they had conquered all of Earth, the map still looks like this in the end.
>>
>>24067000
Oh anon...youtube didn't exist back in 2003.
>>
I have a plot question. Since this is a seed thread I'll post here. I just watched Seed Freedom. Why is it okay for the Earth Alliance to break apart and fracture into civil war, but Kira and Lacus do nothing? But when ZAFT starts to break apart they are labeled as "rebels" and Lacus and Kira intervene with their organization to put the rebels down by force? I think it would be an interesting thing to see the space colonies break apart and have their own factions.
>>
>>24067287
Because Zaft's splinter group also was backing the crazies that demand the world surrender to them or get space lasered.
>>
>>24067347
The why didn't Team Lacus do anything to stop Logos? They sat around and only watched ZAFT fight Logos.
>>
>>24068282
Because the writing always contrived that they were never in a position to do so except in Berlin because it wanted Logos to be Zaft's enemy before the finale switched to Zaft fighting team Lacus
>>
>>24054681
Leopard Gundam is green and Dragon
>>
>>24067287
What the fuck are you even talking about, they didn’t intervene at all with ZAFT’s coup
>>
>>24068852
Technically they did by attacking them and Foundation
>>
>>24068852
>What the fuck are you even talking about, they didn’t intervene at all with ZAFT’s coup
Watch your language.

Did you skip the entire part where Team Lacus saved the Chairman, Yzak, Dearkka, and other important members and snuck them on the Eternal?

Did you skip the part where Andrew Waltfeld led a counter attack on the coup forces ?

Did you miss the part where Team Lacus gave Yzak and Dearkka the new Buster Gundam and Duel Gundam with nuclear reactors?

Did you miss the part where Team Lacus allowed them to use the new Meteors with nuclear reactors which helped defeat ZAFTs coup fleet?

Team Lacus clearly intervened
>>
>>24065020
They pulled a Gundam and used it to produce the weaker f-35 lol

Actually f-22 is the Gundam of current jets, also it’s a quite expensive jet, so money was/is most likely the deciding factor
>>
>>24069210
>They pulled a Gundam and used it to produce the weaker f-35 lol

It's funny because many people have said that without the stealth to protect it, the F-35 is a total dog when it comes to dogfights. An overweight and sluggish single engine fighter jet. It's a fat F-16.

The better solution would have been to have a fleet of F-22s for stealth missions. And mass produce more F-15s for non-stealth missions. The F-15 can carry the greatest payload of weapons and has dual engines. It's super rugged. There are stories where the an entire wing was blown off a ln F-15, but the jet returned home because the engines were so powerful that it was basically a rocket, the wings were optional.
>>
File: file.png (1.56 MB, 640x1920)
1.56 MB PNG
>>24067287
>Why is it okay for the Earth Alliance to break apart and fracture into civil war
How many times have we gone through this? The Earth Alliance is NOT a one-world government. It's a military coalition formed by three superpowers: the Atlantic Federation, Eurasia and East Asia.
To answer your question, Destiny had a bunch ofstates breaking off from Eurasia because they were tired of having the Atlantic Federation ruling over them. These movements were directly supported by the PLANTs.
There aren't any geographical details apart from what's seen on the series, but one of these new states is the Kingdom of Foundation, which was directly supported by ZAFT with weapons and a space fleet.

>But when ZAFT starts to break apart they are labeled as "rebels" and Lacus and Kira intervene with their organization to put the rebels down by force?
What the fuck are you talking about? PLANT (ZAFT is the name of the armed forces, not the nation) has never broken apart in any way. It's the Coordinators' ethnostate. It's also located
What happened in Freedom was a very traditional coup by hardliners.

>I think it would be an interesting thing to see the space colonies break apart and have their own factions.
While the timeline and random dialogue in SEED mentions the existence of other space colonies in L4, PLANT is a single state in L5.

>>24069103
>Did you miss the part where Team Lacus gave Yzak and Dearkka the new Buster Gundam and Duel Gundam with nuclear reactors?
>Did you miss the part where Team Lacus allowed them to use the new Meteors with nuclear reactors which helped defeat ZAFTs coup fleet?
Those two were NOT team Lacus. ZAFT overhauled the old Gundams and METEORs all by themselves. The fact that our guys were on Lacus's side and fought together during the Foundation conflict doesn't mean there was a direct technology transfer.
Even the Eternal has a huge ZAFT emblem on its hull now, as it was formally returned to its forces after the second war.
>>
File: file.png (490 KB, 800x577)
490 KB PNG
>>24069228
>the F-35 is a total dog when it comes to dogfights
Dogfighting abilities are not relevant nowadays, and they haven't been for over 50 years. As much as I hate to say it, the operations in Iran have proven the F-35 doubters wrong. And yes, that includes me.

>There are stories where the an entire wing was blown off a ln F-15, but the jet returned home
That only happened once in Israel after a mid-air collision (not combat; AAMs act like a shotgun blast on the airframe) and the pilot said he would've ejected if he had been aware of the damage.
If what you're saying is true, then there would be buyers for the Silent Eagle, but all potential customers went for the F-35 instead.
>>
>>24069231
>Those two were NOT team Lacus. ZAFT overhauled the old Gundams and METEORs all by themselves.

WRONG. Get up to date grandpa. You have it backwards.

Team Lacus did it with their Secret Clyne faction members who are planted within ZAFT and the PLANTs. Clyne Faction members (politicians, technicians, spies, soldiers, etc) work within the colonies, but are secretly loyal to Team Lacus and Terminal. They are a secret organization. They leak info to Team Lacus and keeps tabs on ZAFT.
>>
File: file.png (775 KB, 1280x720)
775 KB PNG
>>24069231 (went over the character limit. Fuck 4chan)

>It's also located
...on a single spot in Lagrange 5. Why would anyone there look for independence? Its political/administrative structure gives them self-government already.
>>
.>>24069231
>Even the Eternal has a huge ZAFT emblem on its hull now, as it was formally returned to its forces after the second war.
No. The subtitles literally say "Terminal Mobile Suit Carrier - Eternal". Please better attention when you watch the movie. It was secretly controlled by Clyne Faction agents loyal to Lacus.
>>
>>24069250
>>24069103
Just because the "Clyne Faction" and Team Lacus sometimes work together doesn't mean they are allies. They only worked together during the Foundation war to stop hardliners from taking over the military.
>>
File: h252m_0001.jpg (706 KB, 1056x1508)
706 KB JPG
>>24069250
>Team Lacus did it with their Secret Clyne faction members who are planted within ZAFT and the PLANTs. Clyne Faction members (politicians, technicians, spies, soldiers, etc) work within the colonies, but are secretly loyal to Team Lacus and Terminal. They are a secret organization.
No, no, no, NO!

This all bullshit, you stupid fucking Fukudafaggot (I can tell it's you because of the retarded short sentences, almost like if you're larping as a native Japanese speaker). All the time you come up with the most imbecilic nonsense that other Anons have to debunk.

Duel and Buster were overhauled by ZAFT, with no involvement whatsoever from Terminal or anyone else. The model kit says nothing whatsoever about a Terminal involvement, and they were retrieved from Boaz, a ZAFT base. The fact that the major players were connected to the "Clyne Faction" is immaterial to the basic facts. In fact, the Lightning Buster manual mentions Canaver and other members of the "FORMER Clyne Faction" (旧クライン派).
https://jisho.org/search/%E6%97%A7

Please tell me, why do you keep doing this?
>if the good guys are doing something, then its the lacus faction at work because it secret and powerful and works for good
Even when the story debunks it directly, you are still at it. Stop it. You are only embarrassing yourself.

>They leak info to Team Lacus and keeps tabs on ZAFT.
Okay, and how the fuck did they miss ZAFT's military leader being in cahoots with Foundation before it was too late?

>>24069266
>They only worked together during the Foundation war to stop hardliners from taking over the military.
More like "the hardliners took over the military and our guys fought with COMPASS to regain control from them".
>>
>>24069266
>Just because the "Clyne Faction" and Team Lacus sometimes work together doesn't mean they are allies.

Wow you are really stupid. Absolutely stupid. Unbelievably stupid. My IQ is dropping when I talk to you. Tell us anon. What is Lacus' last name? Go ahead. Take your time. Think about it. Oh right! It's Lacus CLYNE.
>>
File: file.png (1.49 MB, 1711x894)
1.49 MB PNG
>>24069264 (emphasis mine)
第1次連合・プラント大戦末期にザフトが核動力 MS専用母艦として建造した高速艦。一時期は行方不明とされていたが、後にザフトに復帰。武装を大幅に換装し、イザークたちの母艦として活躍した。
>A high-speed vessel constructed by ZAFT toward the end of the first Alliance-PLANT War to serve as a dedicated mothership for nuclear-powered mobile suits. Although it was considered missing for a time, IT LATER RETURNED TO ZAFT SERVICE; following an extensive refit of its armament, it served as the mothership for a unit that included Yzak and his comrades.

>It was secretly controlled by Clyne Faction agents loyal to Lacus.
You are making shit up again. All the personnel was PLANT, loyal to the legitimate Chairman. Again, the fact that they were fighting on the same side during the Foundation conflict doesn't make them subordinates to Terminal or anyone else.
>>
>>24069269
>Eileen Canaver
>Ezalia Jule.
>Yuri Amarfi
These characters are part of the Clyne faction. *face palm*
>>
>>24069273
Anon, the "Clyne Faction" was only a thing during the first war, after Patrick's purge of elements he considered disloyal in the wake of the JOSH-A disaster and the theft of the Freedom.
>>
File: Arrest.jpg (1.95 MB, 1920x2160)
1.95 MB JPG
>>24069276
>Ezalia Jule.
>part of the Clyne faction
Would it hurt you to stop being stupid for five fucking minutes?

>*face palm*
This isn't Plebbit or Fecalbook. We don't do this shit here.
>>
>>24069278
Wrong. Patrick didn't get them all. They went underground, changed their tactics, and recruited more members. How do you think they stole the blueprints for Hyper Deuterion Reactors and beam shields from ZAFT. Clyne faction spies working with Terminal. Get your facts right.
>>
>>24069292
>Patrick didn't get them all.
Yes, we are aware of that, you dumb fucking imbecile: >>24069281

>Clyne faction spies working with Terminal.
That's "Terminal operatives working with Terminal". The "Clyne Faction", as a political clique, stopped being a thing after the first war and whomever else specifically loyal to Lacus went to Terminal.
You just want to make up shit, don't you?
>>
>>24069294
>That's "Terminal operatives working with Terminal". The "Clyne Faction", as a political clique
Semantics. Nice try.
>>
File: 13.09.483.jpg (607 KB, 1920x1080)
607 KB JPG
>>24069319
It's not semantics, you fucking retard. And you very conveniently cut off the rest of the post, so you could keep lying. Let me repeat it:
>stopped being a thing after the first war and whomever else specifically loyal to Lacus went to Terminal.

The Clyne Faction was the only made of followers of Siegel (and Lacus, after she took over his father's followers) in PLANT. It existed exclusively during the first war. It was, at first, the faction in the Supreme Council made up of moderates like Canaver, but it was later expanded to a bunch of covert operatives like Waltfeld and DaCosta. Let's make it Official:
>After the theft of the Freedom Gundam, former PLANT Supreme Council chairman Siegel Clyne is branded a traitor. Clyne and his followers become fugitives, waging an underground campaign of resistance to the radical leadership of Patrick Zala. This Clyne faction carries on the fight even after Siegel himself is gunned down, working within the PLANTs to thwart Patrick Zala's plans.
This clique is never mentioned, at any stage, after SEED, because they won that battle. Whatever "underground campaign" they might've been waging in the sacred name of Lacus Clyne moved over to Terminal.

Terminal is much broader in its scope, and has operators across the Earth sphere, mostly along the lines of the Attha family and its flunkies like Malchio in Orb (whether they have made inroads with the EA is unknown). Whatever functions and influence the Clyne Faction might've had moved over to Terminal.
>>
>>24069319
No despite what Destiny makes it look like Terminal is not the Clyne Faction and they only ally with Lacus as convenience rather than her run it.
>>
>>24069269
>Okay, and how the fuck did they miss ZAFT's military leader being in cahoots with Foundation before it was too late?

The same reason they missed Requiem being rebuilt
>>
>>24069418
>despite what Destiny makes it look like
You are contradicting the fucking show? Really? Destiny never mentions the Clyne Faction by name or otherwise.

>and they only ally with Lacus as convenience rather than her run it
Okay, and how does that square with the development of Strike Freedom, which was (rather than a stolen unit from ZAFT they just tinkered with) supposedly a development that was directed personally by Kira Yamato for his personal use?
>>
File: file.png (184 KB, 541x885)
184 KB PNG
>>24069420
>The same reason they missed Requiem being rebuilt
According to the novel, it's literally that, as the same hardliners in ZAFT were the ones who put it back in operation for Terminal.
I wouldn't be surprised if a sequel for FREEDOM puts the fucking thing back in to action for the third time
>>
>>24069424
Destiny only mentions Terminal by name once in one random sentence and didn't fully establish it until well after the show had finished airing. In the show as it aired it just seemed like Lacus had all these people working for her who made all this high tech stuff.
>>
>>24069432
Which is a lot more than the supposed Clyne Faction that still was somehow working in the shadows all the way into CE 75.
Are you going to argue that the AEUG was still active during the events of CCA?
>>
There's no Clyne Faction in Freedom for the simple fact that a guy who shares their views and policies (but wasn't apparently a member of the Faction prior) is the Chairman. They've got no need for a splinter faction when the guy they want is running things to begin with. If anyone is a faction it's the other guys in Plant. Yzak and Dearka (despite their uniforms) are working for Compass and his mother and the rest are just regular Plant members. All they really do is make use of former Clyne Faction hidden stuff as their only connection to it
>>
>>24069439
I'm not Fukuda anon, calm the fuck down. I'm just saying neither Clyne Faction nor Terminal were really well established in Destiny, because thanks to the seat of Morosawa's pants writing nothing past episode 13 really was. People assumed all the ones working with Lacus and building her stuff were the Clyne Faction guys from SEED because the only thing that indicated otherwise was one throwaway line from one of the minor AA crew that most people didn't catch the significance of at the time and didn't know better.
>>
>>24069440
>All they really do is make use of former Clyne Faction hidden stuff as their only connection to it
Not even that. As you said, the Clyne Faction stopped being a thing all the way back after the first war finished and acting Chairwoman Canaver passed it over to Durandal.
>>
>>24069439
>Are you going to argue that the AEUG was still active during the events of CCA?
If you go by the novels, they technically were active. The AEUG split into two factions. One faction joined the Federation and became Londo Bell. The other faction became EGUM and continued fighting for spacenoid rights. It's why Londo Bell is so tiny during CCA. Half of the AEUG refused to join the Federation.
>>
>>24069432
>Destiny only mentions Terminal by name once in one random sentence and didn't fully establish it until well after the show had finished airing.
Pretty sure they were mentioned several times.
>>
File: IMG_6297.gif (161 KB, 400x225)
161 KB GIF
>>24069432
Who tf is Terminal? Are they how Lacus is somehow making the highest tech Strike Freedom in bumfuck nowhere space?

Those last episodes of Destiny were ass, I have never seen a setup still feel out of left field. Durandal deadass speed ran his villian arc.
Rey suddenly gets the sympathetic villian card plus secret disease, and that death scene was odd

Kira and Lacus sounded like creepy kids or cult leaders the whole time with their low soft spoken tone of voice. “We’ll protect you, it’ll be okay teehee” I hated them.

Destiny shit the bed with the final episodes. Just stop watching when Rey kills Seed Bin Laden lmao
>>
File: 091:091.jpg (1.09 MB, 3303x4703)
1.09 MB JPG
>>24069448
>because thanks to the seat of Morosawa's pants writing nothing past episode 13 really was.
Anon, you don't need to tell me that.

You know how all the events in SEED have hard established dates (eg. the war ended on September 27, CE 70)? Well, they do none of that for any of the events in Destiny.
The final established dates are that the Earth Alliance's attack happened on November CE 73 and there was a peace treaty between PLANT and Orb at some date in CE 74, but everything in between is a blur.
>>
>>24069463
>Who tf is Terminal?
If you believe the official website, it's
>A covert organization responsible for tasks such as the transmission of information between nations.
That's all there is to it. There's nothing else.
>>
>>24069461
Terminal is literally only mentioned once where the glasses guy from AA, Chandler I think his name is says that "Terminal" informed them that Orb was planning to attack Minerva again. That's the only time it gets mentioned by name in the entire show. And people didn't realize it meant anything early on thinking he was talking about his computer terminal on the AA
>>
>>24069463
Yes we know. Destiny's problems are well known.
>>
>>24069469
>That's the only time it gets mentioned by name in the entire show.
Nope.
>>
>>24069472
What episodes is it also mentioned in?
>>
File: Capture.jpg (150 KB, 1511x767)
150 KB JPG
>>24069474
about 1/3rd to 1/2th of these results are for the organization terminal as opposed to computer terminal
>>
File: 1778685195407.jpg (349 KB, 1888x1080)
349 KB JPG
>>24069474
>>
>>24069474
PHASE-24. Murrue points out that Terminal (that is, Miriallia, who is undercover as a photojournalist) sent them information about Athrun.
Subbers back then didn't know what to make of it, so they called it "the terminal" instead of a proper organization, but it's here.

By the way, if you want to make your research a bit easier, this website has both shows transcribed to Japanese.
https://web.archive.org/web/20170718095702/http://zakkuzaku.tripod.com/index.html
>>
>>24069493
>>24069496
>>24069514

YOU MOTHERFUCKER YOU WILL PAY FOR THIS
>>
>>24069530
It's easy, Anon: you were thinking of The Factory, which is, correct, only mentioned by name in a single episode, PHASE-39.
If you believed the bullshit that gets excreted in Gundam Wiki, however, you only have yourself to blame.
So if we see any edits, then we'll know for sure those fuckers are stealing shit from /m/. Not that we didn't know already.
.
>>
>>24069448
>I'm not Fukuda anon, calm the fuck down.
Please stop entertaining his delusion. No one believes this meme.
>>
>>24069530
>YOU MOTHERFUCKER YOU WILL PAY FOR THIS
Translation: I was wrong. I'm sorry. I will do better next time. Gundam Seed is my favorite Gundam. I love Kira and Lacus.
>>
>>24069612
I only love Lacus. I would cuck Kira if I had the chance.
>>
>>24069612
Fuck you this is a stupid debate. The show is stupid and I didn't want to watch it anyway. Nyeh!
>>
>>24069612
Based!
>>
>>24069264
>The subtitles literally say "Terminal Mobile Suit Carrier - Eternal". Please better attention when you watch the movie.
Yes, and the subtitles say "Earth Alliance Forces Daedalus Base" when it shows Requiem's muzzle, when the facility had been captured by ZAFT and used by Foundation during the movie.
>>
>>24070676
I believe the base was returned to the Earth Alliance after Seed Destiny. It was agreed the EA would dismantle the Requiem laser.
>>
File: Strip 1.jpg (1.96 MB, 1920x2160)
1.96 MB JPG
>>24070692
>I believe the base was returned to the Earth Alliance after Seed Destiny
No, it wasn't, you stupid fucking ignorant Fukudafaggot (again, your larping sentence structure is the tell). The conference call calls the Requiem firing a violation of the ceasefire "by the PLANTs". So no, it was kept on ZAFT's control, not the EA's.

And why would ZAFT return the base, anyway? So they can repair the giant death laser and have the Blue Cosmos people try and destroy their homeland again? They didn't return Nova/Boaz after the first war either.
>>
>>24070676
>Yes, and the subtitles say "Earth Alliance Forces Daedalus Base" when it shows Requiem's muzzle, when the facility had been captured by ZAFT and used by Foundation during the movie.
And? Please explain your point.
>>
>>24070733
Let's rewind a bit on the argument, since you seem to be too lazy and/or stupid to follow the thread back. During the movie, Eternal is a ZAFT ship operating on its direct service, no longer operating for Terminal or the defunct Three Ships Alliance.

It doesn't matter if the subtitles say it's a "Terminal MS Carrier", since they also call it wrong by saying that Daedalus is an "EA base", when it had been captured and used by ZAFT two years ago.

Also, all of your retarded babbling about Duel and Buster being overhauled by Terminal (instead of ZAFT) is completely incorrect.
>>
File: 1775565151789.jpg (533 KB, 1929x3085)
533 KB JPG
>>24070702
False. You did not pay attention to Seed Destiny. The entire point of the final battle of the anime was Orb, Lacus, and the EA teaming up to take control of Requiem AWAY from ZAFT. So of course the EA has a say in how their base is used after the war is over. They teamed up with Orb and Lacus, and sacrificed the lives of their soldiers to win.

The fact that you are arguing the base belongs to ZAFT, despite ZAFT LOSING in Seed Destiny, and you're also arguing against the subtitles of the actual anime, is utterly absurd. You really need to rewatch the anime properly to get a proper foundation of facts before participating in this discussion.
>>
File: Strip 2.jpg (3.01 MB, 1920x3240)
3.01 MB JPG
>>24070750
First of all, those ships and mobile suits are not "the Earth Alliance", as the formal organization with a chain of command and loyalty. In the same way we see former EA personnel and units fighting with ZAFT during both Operation Ragnarok and Fury, those units that join Lacus' forces are remnants from whatever survived the attack on Arzachel, which obliterated any leadership they might've still had.

>and the EA teaming up to take control of Requiem AWAY from ZAFT
> the base belongs to ZAFT, despite ZAFT LOSING in Seed Destiny
Not from "ZAFT", but from Durandal personally and his faction. ZAFT's faction that was loyal to Lacus, which included Yzak's men on the Gondwana, won that war with the support of Orb and some disposable EA shitters, who were destroyed by the dozen even then.

The movie is explicit that Requiem was in PLANT's control during the movie's events: >>24070702. Are you going to ignore that line just to come up with some idiotic fanfic about the EA having any say whatsoever, when it's clear enough that it was not the case? They weren't even present on the final peace negotiations. Do you think they still had any power, political or otherwise, to dictate terms to anyone and Eurasia was coming apart at the seams?
>>
>>24070740
Unless you can show me an interview of the movie creators admitting it was a mistake then your post is meaningless.
>>
>>24070750
>The entire point of the final battle of the anime was Orb, Lacus, and the EA teaming up to take control of Requiem AWAY from ZAFT

Well their goal was to destroy it, which they did. After that they might have just agreed to leave it destroyed
>>
>>24070762
>ZAFT's faction that was loyal to Lacus, which included Yzak's men on the Gondwana

Yzak did not control the Godwana, his ship was the Voltaire, a Nazca class. Yzak was only stationed on the Godwana during several battles. In the finale Yzak is back on the Voltaire and the Godwana is part of Durandal's forces launching Zaku's against SF and IJ.
>>
>>24070767
>After that they might have just agreed to leave it destroyed
The answer is here: >>24069427

If you believe the novel (made by the movie's co-screenwriter), the facility was too big to simply blow apart, so PLANT, which had been in control of the base since it was captured by Durandal, put it to use for civilian power generation, but ZAFT eventually gained control of it for military use. From there, they passed it over to the Foundation people.

Since the second destruction seems to have been about as substantial as the first (we only see the muzzle being obliterated by the Zeus), nothing stops it from being rebuilt yet again.
>>
>>24070762
>First of all, those ships and mobile suits are not "the Earth Alliance", as the formal organization with a chain of command and loyalty.
Yes they are. Those are EA ships with EA soldiers. They aren't some rogue or rebel fleet of the EA.

>attack on Arzachel, which obliterated any leadership they might've still had.
It's called Chain of Command. If one commander dies, then the next person in command takes control. Either the Earth Alliance president gave the order to assist Orb, or the Admiral in charge of the surviving EA fleet used their authority to order the fleet to support Orb. The EA were never leaderless. Please stop making baseless assumptions.

>Not from "ZAFT", but from Durandal personally and his faction.
ZAFT is not Zeon. There are not factions and different leaders trying to kill each other and backstab each other openly during Seed Destiny. Durandal was the rightful Chairman of ZAFT and being supported by the military.

>ZAFT's faction that was loyal to Lacus, which included Yzak's men on the Gondwana,
Yzak was not loyal to Lacus. Neither were the people on Gondwana. Yzak only sent a radio warning because he didn't want to see Athrun and his friends get killed by Neo Genesis. The flagship in charge of the ZAFT fleet was the Minerva. Once Minerva was shotdown and Messiah fell, the Gondwana assumed command of the ZAFT fleet and a ceasefire was called since ZAFT had lost the battle.

>some disposable EA shitters, who were destroyed by the dozen even then.
Those "EA shitters" made up the bulk of forces attacking Messiah and Requiem. You may dismiss them, but you have already been proven wrong in your baseless claims.
>>
File: Strip 1.jpg (2.07 MB, 1920x2160)
2.07 MB JPG
>>24070772
>and the Godwana is part of Durandal's forces launching Zaku's against SF and IJ.
My bad. In any case, we see a number of ZAFT ships forming next to the Lacus-led force against Durandal.

In Final Plus/Special Edition 4, the Gondwana's personnel accepts Lacus's offer to stop fighting (in other words, surrendering to her).
And later on, we see Lacus returning to PLANT surrounded by ZAFT military personnel and even Supreme Council members.

So tell me, who won that war?
>>
>>24070777
>Yzak was not loyal to Lacus. Neither were the people on Gondwana. Yzak only sent a radio warning because he didn't want to see Athrun and his friends get killed by Neo Genesis.

Yzak was, the Gondwana was not. Yzak and Dearka switched sides and were straight up shooting at Zaft forces during the battle. Dearka even gets blasted.
>>
>>24070778
>My bad. In any case, we see a number of ZAFT ships forming next to the Lacus-led force against Durandal.
That's because Lacus has a bunch of sleeper Terminal agents and sleeper ZAFT ships staffed with crew secretly loyal to her during Seed Destiny. Andrew Waltdfelt broadcasts a secret code phrase used by Terminal on an open channel. Once the phrase is spoken, this causes numerous ZAFT ships to openly defect and join Lacus.
>>
>>24070781
What the fuck are you talking about? Can you stop making up bullshit again Fukudafag?
>>
You can have this...
>>24070777
>Durandal was the rightful Chairman of ZAFT and being supported by the military.

...or you can have this
>>24070781
>Lacus has a bunch of sleeper Terminal agents and sleeper ZAFT ships staffed with crew secretly loyal to her during Seed Destiny. >Once the phrase is spoken, this causes numerous ZAFT ships to openly defect and join Lacus.

But you cannot fucking have both at the same time. Either ZAFT was fully behind Durandal or wasn't.
>>
File: Screenshot (48).png (1.32 MB, 1920x1080)
1.32 MB PNG
>>24070782
Fukudafag is right in this case
>>
File: Screenshot (49).png (1.27 MB, 1920x1080)
1.27 MB PNG
>>24070782
>>24070786
As you can see here
>>
>>24070789
>>24070786
Hey, dipshit. Answer this one: >>24070785

Because I can clearly see "factions" and "two different leaders trying to kill each other" during SEED Destiny.
>>
>>24070785
Technically anon can in the same way Zaft was in support of Patrick Zala but Lacus supporters that were part of Zaft previously stole and crewed the Eternal
>>
>>24070786
>>24070789
No one on /m/ has actually watched Destiny, anon. They just larp.
>>
>>24070794
>previously
Key word there. The difference here is that Lacus not only commanded a good number of ZAFT forces during the final stage of the second war (rather than a single renegade ship), but she also returned to the PLANTs in some kind of leadership position.
>>
>>24070793
The Zaft ships with Lacus are traitors that ditched Zaft for Lacus. Seems easy enough. The AA in SEED wasn't an EA "Faction" after they ditched them after Alaska they were just renegades using EA stuff and wearing EA uniforms because it's what they had handy when they left
>>
>>24070785
>>24070786
>>24070789
>>24070795
FUCK YOU ALL. I HATE SEED AND ALL THIS BULLSHIT.
>>
>>24070797
>The AA in SEED wasn't an EA "Faction" after they ditched them after Alaska they were just renegades using EA stuff and wearing EA uniforms because it's what they had handy when they left
Uniforms apart, the Archangel had formally defected to Orb. They were fighting for them during the EA invasion and following their military's orders.
Nobody would argue that they were an "EA faction" of any sort. Don't be stupid.
>>
>>24070799
Hey don't steal my bit. I'm the only one who childishly crashes out when proven wrong.
>>
>>24070793
>Because I can clearly see "factions" and "two different leaders trying to kill each other" during SEED Destiny.
They aren't factions. The word faction implies they are recognized and operate out in the open. These forces are underground Terminal infiltrators who pretended to serve Zaft, but are only pretending. This is proven by the fact that they already have pre-determined code words and passwords prepared. All Lacus or Andrew need to do is say a couple a words and they immediately return to serve Lacus.
>>
None of this makes any sense. This is like if Taylor Swift suddenly became a military leader and could suddenly make millions of United States of America soldiers serve her with just a few words.
>>
>>24070811
>None of this makes any sense.
Welcome to anime, newfriend
>>
>>24070785
>But you cannot fucking have both at the same time. Either ZAFT was fully behind Durandal or wasn't.
Wasn't it explained that Lacus' Accord powers in Seed Freedom is that she is instantly able to make people love her with psychic ability? You can have normally loyal soldiers but the moment Lacus uses her voice to speak to your troops, she can make them turn against you with her mind powers.
>>
>>24070817
In Destiny that explicitly didn't work. She opened a channel at the start of the final battle and while one or two guys hesitated 99 percent of Zaft started shooting. It didn't work in Seed either come to think of it
>>
>>24070777
>Those are EA ships with EA soldiers. They aren't some rogue or rebel fleet of the EA.
How do you know that? If we already saw former EA forces fighting with ZAFT, who is to say that these aren't also renegades?
Those handful of ships could've even taken a decision by themselves to just join the Eternal, since their one remaining base in space was destroyed. Or they could be commanded by sleeper Terminal agents, like your claim on the "ZAFT infiltrators". Side material is explicit about Terminal being in contact with people on Earth's forces.

>Either the Earth Alliance president gave the order to assist Orb
THERE IS NO EARTH ALLIANCE PRESIDENT. That is not a thing. It's a military pact of three different superpowers, each with its own political leadership, and two of those had been supporting ZAFT openly for a while before the final battle.

We never see or hear anyone from the EA giving any order for them to support Orb, and any claim you do in such regard is fucking made-up bullshit. So it's incredibly rich of you to be moaning about "baseless claims".

>Durandal was the rightful Chairman of ZAFT and being supported by the military.
Then who are these guys forming next to the Eternal? How did Waltfeld get ahold of the Gaia if the military was in Durandal's "complete control"?
If anything, it's worse than Zeon, since there's a pretender with ZAFT equipment and intelligence running shit around.

>Those "EA shitters" made up the bulk of forces attacking Messiah and Requiem.
No, they did not. The footage shows that it was mostly Orb's forces doing the bulk of the fighting: the Izumo-classes and Murasames. The EA shitters only stood there and died either by ZAKUs or Neo-Genesis blasting their ships open.
>>
>>24070819
>>24070817
People are mixing up the Accord Powers (it's short-range telepathy/mind manipulation) and the fact that Lacus was created by Aura to be loved by the people, which works even with a non-Accord impostor such as Meer. See >>24058084
>>
>>24070830
>the fact that Lacus was created by Aura to be loved by the people, which works even with a non-Accord impostor such as Meer.
meer not having mind control powers is just taking lacus' celebrity status. it's not as if should lacus somehow turn off her powers, everyone instantly stops giving a shit, plenty of people are vapid enough to care about a celebrity that was making headlines ~2 years ago
>>
>>24070811
>>24070813
>This is like if Taylor Swift suddenly became a military leader and could suddenly make millions of United States of America soldiers serve her with just a few words.

https://newrepublic.com/post/177385/republicans-weird-taylor-swift
>conservatives have been quick to claim that there is a vast liberal conspiracy to blame
>Conservatives’ claims that the billionaire superstar is secretly a political operative
>>
>>24070841
Not that anon but don't bring up politics, music industry, or Hollywood. They are places filled with weird shit. Many of them are part of secret clubs and cults especially music industry and hollywood. You gotta pledge yourself to them and agree to their weird rituals in order to be successful. Many worship pagan gods and cults behind the scenes. It's an open secret.
>>
>>24071002
You've never even seen Eyes Wide Shut.
>>
>>24070840
>plenty of people are vapid enough to care about a celebrity that was making headlines ~2 years ago
People listened to "Lacus" because of her actions during the first war, not any kind of pop celebrity status.
>>
>>24070778
My queen!
>>
>>24075527
NO!
MY QUEEN!
>>
>>24075527
>>24080337
Get a room, Kira and Orphee.
>>
>>24080583
Because you asked for it:
https://e-hentai.org/g/4308101/76960f5918/



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.