[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/mlp/ - Pony


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


How would you have reacted if MLP made the trans Trixie fan theory canon in like Season 7 or something? (She's still exactly the same, they just offhandedly mention it in one episode.) Accept? Don't accept? Indifference?
>>
File: 1605025640186.jpg (151 KB, 764x764)
151 KB
151 KB JPG
>>43141560
im gonna pay you 20 bucks to shut up and fuck off
>>
>>43141560
>canon
>season 7
Huh?
>>
>>43141560
I would be okay with it because I like trans people + the way you made it sound it doesn't seem inflamatory, also I love you anon.
>>
>>43141560
based
>>
Idk if potions that change sex are a thing, but you can definitely do it by using magic (even tho Twilight faked it in Magic Duel). However rare the ability to change someone's sex is, some can do it. Which means anyone who wants to change their sex can just pay for the services of the nearest mage who can perform that spell and change their sex anytime they want

Honestly sex change spells in any fantasy media are naturally going to result in a lot of the population changing their sex, just to see what life on the other side is like for a while, and some would decide to leave their sex changed permanently. It would be rather common realistically. Some people would be going to visit the local sex change wizard fairly often, it would be normalized
>>
Insufferable, unlikeable, wants to be the center of attention, awful to everypony else. Anouncing her as trans would make sense.
>>
>>43141560
Children should not be exposed to gender ideology.
>>
>>43141560
So which thread are you trying to slide, OP?
>>
File: dbowie_v_6mar13_rex_b[1].jpg (217 KB, 1280x1280)
217 KB
217 KB JPG
>>43141560
Negatively. In a vacuum, having a character be a gender-bender is not inherently a bad thing, but in the current climate it would just be blatant PC posturing, basically DEI. I respect authors and artists who made that kind of material when it was actually dangerous, but today it's simply an act of conformity in the eyes of polite society. JK Rowling is not a writer on the same level as Oscar Wilde, and Lady Gaga is not as cool as David Bowie.

By contrast, the anti-equality two-parter that kicked off S5 was actually controversial and counter-culture. It's hip to be fash.
>>
File: IMG_1243.jpg (182 KB, 994x1312)
182 KB
182 KB JPG
>>43141749
true
>>
>>43141560
Trixie is a unicorn, she's magic. She could have changed with magical transformation, y'know something that actually works unlike festering open wounds, turning normal women into harry potter or using a legitimate hormonal issue as cover for your shitty behaviour
>>
>>43141912
Magic Duel establishes that sex change spells are impossible for a unicorn to do
>>
>>43141964
oh yeah
magic potion maybe?
>>
>>43141964
No it doesn't, watch the show
>>
File: GrErm5NW4AAMvs9.png (535 KB, 599x763)
535 KB
535 KB PNG
>>43142158
You watch it, retard.
>>
>>43142189
"Watch the show"
>Okay, I will!!! *reads the shitty fan wiki*

No motherfucker, you and the wiki are BOTH wrong. Watch the actual fucking episode starting at 16:36
https://youtu.be/nnkZ8q2o5xQ?feature=shared

Not one of those fucking things is stated to be canonically impossible. Trixie literally just says "Th- that's impossible!" to Twilight performing the very age spell that Trixie herself JUST FUCKING DID a second ago. She's obviously not LITERALLY saying it's impossible, she is just saying "it's impossible that anyone could be stronger than me!"

And when she says "nobody can do those spells..." she's just being incredulous again, out of pride. She's not LITERALLY saying those spells are impossible. She MEANS "it's really hard to do those spells, practically no one can!" and Twilight's reply of "You're right, not even me" is very fucking obviously just her saying these spells are so hard that very few people can do them.

Do you have autism? Do you have difficulty figuring out when people are being literal or not?
>>
File: You retard.png (2.68 MB, 1920x2080)
2.68 MB
2.68 MB PNG
>>43142278
>Twilight performing the very age spell that Trixie herself JUST FUCKING DID a second ago
LMAOOOOO
>>
>>43142306
Oh wow you actually are retarded. Trixie performed the age spell genuinely, then said "that's impossible" when Twilight SEEMED to do it. Nothing about what I said changes whether or not Twilight faked the spell. The point is Trixie said the age spell was "impossible" when she literally CANNOT mean it literally, because she JUST did that spell, and had no idea Twi was faking it

I'm actually pretty shocked you sincerely thought you made a valid point here. I'm just gonna like...leave? From this conversation? You've proven beyond any doubt that you're waaaaay too stupid to have an intelligent discussion with. So I won't waste my time, bye
>>
>>43142278
Yeah, how did Trixie do those spells? With the Alicorn Amulet, you spacker.
She clearly couldn't do the spells without it.
>>
>>43142278
She's not talking about the age spell dipshit, she's talking about the other spells that are specifically listed in pic rel here >>43142189
>>
>>43142354
>Trixie performed the age spell genuinely, then said "that's impossible" when Twilight SEEMED to do it.
No she didn't, she actually says "big deal"
And you're telling others to 'watch the show', kek
>>
>>43142354
>I'm just gonna like...leave? From this conversation? You've proven beyond any doubt that you're waaaaay too stupid to have an intelligent discussion with. So I won't waste my time, bye
Holy fuck I think that is the cringiest response I've ever seen on this entire site
You sound very smart
>>
File: b4f.jpg (25 KB, 569x428)
25 KB
25 KB JPG
If you can rip ponies apart molecule by molecule and piece them together without fail using magic I see no reason you couldn't rip a pony's dna apart and put it back together in a different way such as turing a pegasus into a unicorn. This could also explain the excess of mares in the universe perhaps Princess Cadence has turned many a creature into cute mares so they can all fuck. This would also explain why the other animal races hate pony-kind because they keep taking their people and turning them into pony.
>>
File: 190244.gif (3.68 MB, 576x324)
3.68 MB
3.68 MB GIF
I'd be mostly indifferent. I would find it odd, though, as in my personal belief gender dysphoria doesn't exist in ponies, or likely Equestria as a whole.
>>
>>43142354
>trixiefag speaks like an insufferable condescending narcissist
Of course. Just like their character.
>>
>>43141560
I would have bombed hasbro

and not just for this but for making any other retarded fan ideas canon, it's always a bad, terrible, awful idea to do that
>>
>>43141560
I would drop the show
>>
>>43141560
I don't really know what transsexuality discourse is about. My mental map of it has a lot more speculations than facts and a lot more gaps, logic leaps and uncertainties than speculations, and I don't expect to ever see these gaps filled in a satisfactory manner unless glowniggers miraculously get disbanded and all their archives go public. So yeah, I think I would end up ignoring it.
>>
>>43141560
Then that would've been yet another reason to hate Trixie.
>>
>>43142598
Why do you hate her? She's a little pony too
>>
>>43141781
This if im being quite honest, everypony
>>
>>43142598
There's nothing wrong with Trixie you just dislike women who are confident and bold because your penis is teeny tiny
>>
>>43142598
cope
>>
>>43142717
...what about that post is cope? what the fuck are you talking about?
>>
>>43141560
>they just offhandedly mention it in one episode
Ah, so it can be censored in foreign countries! Smart thinking Anon
>>
ok
>>
>>43142354
>t. great and powerful
>>
File: full.png (2 KB, 305x305)
2 KB
2 KB PNG
>>43142354
>>43142428
>>43142465
>I'm actually pretty shocked you sincerely thought you made a valid point here. I'm just gonna like...leave? From this conversation? You've proven beyond any doubt that you're waaaaay too stupid to have an intelligent discussion with. So I won't waste my time, bye
Why did this fucking tickle me so much? I'm laughing like a retarded goose. Fucking trixiefags, man.
>>
File: 1720303242987830.png (124 KB, 894x914)
124 KB
124 KB PNG
>>43144220
you're really gonna diss my boi the trixiefag like that
>>
File: 1738501158209558.gif (416 KB, 560x407)
416 KB
416 KB GIF
>>43142354
Imagine seething this hard because R63 spells can't be performed by any unicorn. Sorry nonny Twilight nor Trixie can change gender for you, nor can they have a "marecock".
>>
>>43141560
womp womp



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.