POLL: https://strawpoll.com/3RnYXx65zyeThis will be an interesting poll, because I am unsure on what the consensus is on /mlp/ on how to rank these seasons relative to each other. There does seem to be solid consensus that these seasons are worse than Seasons 1/2 but better than Seasons 6-9. Anyways, I'll be voting and rooting hard for Season 4 since I think its the best season of the show and that it's not close. I think Seasons 3 and 5 are good but flawed (I'd say they are worse than Seasons 1 and 2). I could see Season 3 winning this poll since it feels more similar to tone to Season 2 and only had Alicorn Twilight in the last episode, making it seem like the natural preference for Season 1/2 fans (who seem to be the majority of this board).
STOP THE COUNT
Been over 10 years since I watched these episodes, but for the most part I *think* my ranking would go:5 > 4 > 3Honestly hard to say between 4 & 3. 5 I think is the best season of the whole series though, so that's an easy placement.Actually, regarding all seasons, I think my ranking is something like this:5 > 2/6/7 > 4/3/1 > 8 > 9Slashes being "these are pretty close and the ranking might easily vary once I do a proper rewatch of the series".(Granted a rewatch could *completely* rearrange the list, but it's unlikely.)So yeah, 5 is the best, 9 is the worst.
>>43243615Hmm...So looking over the actual episodes that were in each season...maybe I gaslit myself on S5 a little bit. Like, there's good episodes in it, but maybe not as many as I was thinking, especially when comparing against other seasons.Really shows how much I need to just SIT DOWN AND REWATCH THE DAMN SHOW.
Season 1 vs. Season 2 poll: >>43243455
>>43243472S5 easy.S4 was the only season that made me feel like dropping the show. Haber made pony great again starting with S5.
how many season ranking threads do we need
>>43243472>I could see Season 3 winning this poll Dang I was completely wrong, at least so far
>>43244030OP is an insecure piece of shit desperate for validation over his favorite season. He's an offboarder that spams this trash in Reddit and X too.
>>43244009>Haber made pony great againThat's what a satanist would say.
>>43244400I wonder if after season 9 a Trump like pony ran against Twilight by promising to Make Equestria Great Again by kicking the non pony immigrants out, putting tarrifs on Equestria's neighbors, and finding involvement for foreign conflicts
>>43244203It's not that season 3 is bad, it's just that it is the least appealing to re-watch. When there are only 13 episodes and your audience have opinions so different from one another, any episode is a big risk if it doesn't land.
>>43244419Season 3 dropped the ball with having 2 Spike episodes but no Rarity episode
>>43244478Spike at your service should've been a Sparity episode, not an Applespike one.
>>43244965from what I remember Spike At Your Service had good humor despite the shit writing, but I'll see if that holds up on rewatch.
