Were Oasis really a punk band?
>>127582307Depends, do they kick nazis, sexists, ableists, racists, and bigots out of their shows? If so then yes they are punk
>>127582352FUCK YES I WILL DO WHAT YOU TELL ME!!!!!!
>>127582352>nazis, sexists, ableists, racists, and bigots I think that's their core audience, actually
>>127582352weak bait
>>127582307No, they were regressive retrograde copyists. But if you wanna have a laugh, tell an American that the Sex Pistols were the only true punk band and watch their head explode in apoplectic rage.
>>127582450Sex Pistols were a band carefully manufactured and designed by the label execs, industry corporations and PR managers. Theres nothing genuine or punk about them. They were a industry plant boy band same as Backstreet boys or BTS
>>127582450>tell an American that the Sex Pistols were the only true punk band and watch their head explode in apoplectic rage.No one cares. The Sex Pistols sucked. All punk sucked. If you want to gatekeep that garbage, it's your prerogative.
>>127582474Reddit take
>>127582307Oasis are about as anti-punk as you can get, both in their benign 70s Slade and T-Rex rip-off sound and their complete embrace of the establishment
>>127582474They were both manufactured and hardly controllable. Do you think McLaren wanted the band to just split after 2 years and a half? They barely did anything for his business, the band was mostly starting scandals in clubs and it was getting hard to manage if not impossible
>>127582307>writes only slow tempo songs, ripping off glam and Beatles>did you know we were punk
>>127582352Liam hates those people but from what I've seen of Noel, he's probably a racist Tory. >>127582352
>>127582352Don't forget the unvaxxed
>>127582474That's true about all punk bands. That entire movement was created by the industry and the music press.There is nothing punk about punk.
>>127582808I hate everything about punk. Their cringe edginess, the shitty music and their try hard attitude. Atleast metal has it's merits. But punk is the worst thing to come out of rock. Except maybe the Clash but they sound good so they're probably not punk.
>>127582307No. Nothing more need be said about Oasis but old faggots need their nostalgia blanky.
>>127582450>they were regressive retrograde copyistsSo, a punk band?
>>127582558>implying Cpt. Sensible, Steve Jones, Mick Jones et al. weren’t fucking obsessed with glam in ‘72shiggy
