When did we stop caring about his opinions?
who?
>>127918916when fader mind broke him
>OP cared at some point about himhuh
>>127918916I never cared about some dumb bald faggot and his useless opinions. Same goes for Cuckgau. They're all useless. Form your own opinions.
>>127918936what about based piero scaruffi?
>>127918916No one should have ever cared about his opinions
>>127918950>is that... skibidi toilet music?! 10/10scaruffi doesnt really like music
>>127918950Scaruffi doesn't even finish most of the albums he listens to, or the ones he doesn't like. Which for how much he reviews I totally understand but still
>>127918992>>127919053you cannot deny he is based
>>127918916Probably after he gave the money store a 10 and his redditor fan base stormed /mu/ and never left
everything after danny brown xxx review
I actively avoid his opinions on music I listen to. I only watch his videos when he's ripping on some shitty music I'm never going to hear.
for me it was when he gave The Raven Who Refused to Sing a low score because 'muh authentic instruments' which turned out to be false
>>127918916I never cared about him.He was always for the zoomers on /mu/ who needed someone's opinion to copy
>>127918916You cared about his opinions? Why?
>>127918916for me it was 2012/2013 when he dissed my favorite band at the time
>>127919927I have no one to send pic too :(
>>127918916Why does anyone here care about any critic? Just be your own critic.You're the man now dog. I'm your biggest fan. You.. Yeah you.
>>127918916I never started caring
Critics are the antithesis to creators. Think about it.
>>127918916 you never stopped caring. there are Fantano hate threads like every 3 days, which continue to drive engagement. deep down, I bet he appreciates it.
>>127920681It's pretty simple. Not much they need to think about.But you don't even need to be a creator. Everyone has the musical world at their fingertips. Critics are a relic from a time when you had to dish out your hard earned cash for a single album.
>>127918916His reviews from like 2010-2014 were pretty good and insightful.
>>127918916interested to hear what he has to say about getting killed after p4k gave it a 9.0
>>127920899>Fantano hate threadsI don't hate Fantano. I'm trying to get you to love yourself. That's it. Stop being a fucking cuck for once. I believe in you.
>>127920947>>127920681agreedmusic is made by those who hear it, not necessarily by the performers. when you yell about how bad an album is, you're announcing your limitations as a listener. when you praise an album, you're congratulating yourself for your listening skills.critics are absolutely, totally useless. I used to think back in the day, when you had to drop $17 for a CD that you couldn't really listen to first. that the critics were helping, but at some point I realized the critics had no value even on that front: no matter whether a critic pooped on or praised a record, you had no idea if they (the critic) actually had any idea what they were talking about, or if the album was any good. It's a literally toss-a-coin 50-50 you might like it, you might not, and the critics did nothing to improve those odds.
Fantano is no better or worse than any other critic. >>127921001>I don't hate Fantano.didn't say you did. stop trying to make everything about you. That's it. Stop being a fucking narcissist for once. I believe in you.
>>127920681The critic is the real artist.
>>127921005>music is made by those who hear it, not necessarily by the performers. when you yell about how bad an album is, you're announcing your limitations as a listener. when you praise an album, you're congratulating yourself for your listening skills.And yet, Taylor Swift still sucks dick.
He skipped reviewing like 4 albums I really liked from 2020 to now and that's all it took. Ty Segall Harmonizer and Gezebelle Gaburgably Gayburger are two of them
Fantano said listen to this and he was right.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KhhUYx6F5_E
What can be deduced about a person whose "greatest albums ever" list is this : https://www.besteveralbums.com/thechart.php?c=83661 ?
>>127918916this guy doesn't exist in my reality outside of the obsession this board has with him.
>>127918916Idk lol he looks like a flaming homo he's probably gay >>127919065>Bowie died of cancer in 2016.>XXXTENTACION was shot dead in 2018 at the age of 20. Not a big loss for music.
>>127921010Nah he's gay so that makes him worse, also I'm not sure if you are but you type like a faggot I'm pretty sure, are you underage perhaps?
>>127922307I agree, if the board didn't vacuum up his little TRT penis I probably would've forgotten his name by now
>>127920268this is a big ol' /thread post
Ratking never losing hype!
>>127918916probably the day he tied his nutsack
>>127918916EWWWWWW HE LOOKS LIKE A SQUIRREL WTF HAHAHAHAHA
>>1279189162017, when the Fader article broke him. Where have you been since then?
>>127920967This
>>127920268>ZOOMERS ZOOMERS ZOOMERSfantano got popular on /mu/ over a decade ago when zoomers were still in kindergarten. good job on outing yourself as not only a self-hating zoom zoom but a newfag that got here last year
>>127918916
>>127920587I'm not an oldfag so this made me finally look up the meme.
>>127918916after the fader article and then again when he claimed he would stop talking about kanye and then uploaded 10 more video talking about kanye
>>127923049zoomers start late 1996, zoomer
You can watch a reviewer to learn about new music without letting their opinions change what you think about the music you know. are you that weak minded?
>>127918916When Julian Casablancas said he had shit taste
he stopped reviewing albums im interested in. its basically a rap channel now
>>127918916When did we ever care about em? Is he even a musician?
i have never talked about him with any person in real lifealso the point has been made several times in this thread about critics and music streaming
His teeth are dull but he's the only music critic that still has them. No publications would dare to publish a negative review since so many of them are in the pockets of record labels
once you hit 30 it's not possible to be able to review modern music because you aren't part of the youth culture that it's written for, so roughly 2016.
>>127918916After the Fader article
>>127921186Hes not wrong desu hes just one-sided. Art actualizes its value through those that interpret and appreciate it, like he explains. But it is the art itself that contains the potential to be actualized, and some works simply do not contain the depth necessary to keep that process of interpretation and appreciation going for very long. No critic without the art, no art without the critic.
>>127923049>zoomers were still in kindergartenNot that anon but some of us are older than you think. >>127923623It's either 1995 or 1997. Hate this bullshit. but It's only cited as 1996 on the faggy subreddit
>>127923623nothing to do with what i said zoom zoom. the point is, it wasn't zoomers giving fantano relevance.
>>127918916never cared about his opinions except that one time when he triggered the /pol/ tourist MAGA trash with his "unreviewable" reviewhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M0jEngxUFz4>>127922359>you type like a faggotyou would know. project harder.>>127921221somebody's mad that Tay isn't sucking their dick. cope and seethe, incel
>>127918916Never cared. I only ever watched him because I had literally nothing else to watch.
>>127926545it's class of 2015so late 1996 onward
>>127926658>it wasn't zoomers giving fantano relevanceit is in the 2020s at latest
>>127918916You first
>>127921005>when you yell about how bad an album is, you're announcing your limitations as a listener.It's a dangerous comment to make because it enables every talentless fuck to counteryell at your in return for being a bad listener or whatever. No, to hell with this. I have my very heavy biases because I know what I want to hear
