/mu/ - Which is better? - Music

Anonymous

10/27/25(Mon)19:05:12 No.128249956

File: mbvslowdive.png (218 KB, 520x260)

218 KB PNG

Anonymous 10/27/25(Mon)19:05:12 No.128249956 Archived

Which is better?

Anonymous
10/27/25(Mon)19:21:49 No.128250130

Anonymous 10/27/25(Mon)19:21:49 No.128250130

Just For a Day is the best Slowdive record but I'm not sure if it tops Isn't Anything

As far as the LPs go Loveless > Isn't Anything > Just for a Day > Pygmalion > Souvlaki > mbv > the shitty two Slowdive reunion records

Anonymous
10/27/25(Mon)19:29:00 No.128250212

Anonymous 10/27/25(Mon)19:29:00 No.128250212

>>128250130
mbv is better than everything except souvlaki imo

Anonymous
10/27/25(Mon)19:43:48 No.128250362

Anonymous 10/27/25(Mon)19:43:48 No.128250362

>>128250130
>the shitty two Slowdive reunion records
they're clearly inferior compared to the '90s albums, but they're ok, especially S/T.
I can think of much worse reunion albums.

Anonymous
10/27/25(Mon)19:45:40 No.128250383

Anonymous 10/27/25(Mon)19:45:40 No.128250383

>>128249956
Just For a Day

Anonymous
10/27/25(Mon)19:46:56 No.128250392

Anonymous 10/27/25(Mon)19:46:56 No.128250392

>>128250362
this

Anonymous
10/27/25(Mon)19:47:20 No.128250396

Anonymous 10/27/25(Mon)19:47:20 No.128250396

My bloody valentine is to shoegaze what johnny cash is to country. Once you hear them, everything else in the genre kind of pales in comparison.

Anonymous
10/27/25(Mon)19:48:45 No.128250414

Anonymous 10/27/25(Mon)19:48:45 No.128250414

>>128250396
ill take townes van zandt over cash but i get what you mean

Anonymous
10/27/25(Mon)19:58:12 No.128250513

Anonymous 10/27/25(Mon)19:58:12 No.128250513

File: slowdive tier list.png (95 KB, 1140x402)

95 KB PNG

>>128250130
I'm surprised people feel strongly one way or another about Slowdive's albums when weighed against each other. Pic related is how I genuinely feel, they're consistently "pretty good".

Anonymous
10/27/25(Mon)20:42:55 No.128251011

Anonymous 10/27/25(Mon)20:42:55 No.128251011

>>128250396
>>128250396
tbf it's because the sound of Loveless is still hard for bands to replicate.
It's easier to sound like Slowdive or Lush so MBV remains rather unique in that regard