Disma editionLast real thread: >>128452947FAQ: https://pastebin.com/DCGqE5iL
BLASTING
i saw blood incantation live. it was cool.
disma? more like ligma
>>128511242elaborate if you wood
YOU KNOW I LIKE MY GIRLS A LITTLE BIT OLDERI JUST WANNA USE YOUR LOVE TONIIIIIIGHTDON'T WANNA LOSR YOUR LOVE TONIIIIIIGHT
>I wanna suck>COCK>*da dararara da daradara d...*>I want to suck (cock)>COCKSo, who's it gonna be
Thanks for the cliquespam
>>128511114
>>128511105New album when, bros? They said they were gonna try to get it released by the end of this year, but nothing yet.
>>128511114>>128512372DM boomer bands are by far the least reliable when it comes to album release dates
>>128512372chud bands always take 9 billions years to release anything, lazy fucking cunts
still AOTY
>>128512494>>128512518The album has been recorded for months. It's the label's fault for not releasing it yet.
>>128512494For me, it's Pentastar
>>128511114Happy I discovered this masterpiece from these threads
>>128512966
>>128512998it's a good record, great composition
>>128512900cope
>>128512966Vitrified Entity and Equipoise both do the flamenco/tech death thing too but First Fragment's songwriting ability is like 2 dimensions above them. would still recommend them all though. Alice Simard from Vitrified is probably going to be the next big Quebec tech death guitar hero cause shes still only in her early 20s and outputting crazy crazy shit. be sure to check out Dark Tranquility if you havent already
>>128513118DT isnt nearly as good for me, thanks for the other recs
>>128512339you should be banned permanently for listening to this shit
>>128513163the most tolerable anon right here
>>128513163Is that a threat? Sure sounds like one, friend.
https://i.4cdn.org/wsg/1763486094525983.webm
Someone just roke up
Master of Puppers \\m//
This was very good. Wayne never disappointed
>>128513199probably the thread destroyer because it looks all calm rn
I've never heard of Kublai Khan TX, Fit for an Autopsy, or Sanguisugabogg. Are any of them good?
Xiu Xiu's vocals are dogshit and ruin whatever musical potential was there>>128513351Kublai khan is just beatdown/metalcore I'm pretty sure, would be hype live at least
>>128513369>beatdown/metalcoreI suffer in midstate new york. Every single "metal" show you go to is just hardcore in disguise. Wanting to listen to real metal means in getting on a fucking train. What do zoomers see in hardcore?
>>128513402"fuck blumpf"
>>128513434Hails
Only wiggers and bare spot Ken dolls prefer Obituary over the almighty Tish!!https://youtu.be/x-P38hfCdyE
>>128513402Catchy, mid-tempo riffs and shouted vocals (fun but heavy) as opposed to fast brootal screamo metal (edgy)
>>128513465Was this not said by a wigger?
>>128513496Nah, too much death metal I'd say
Prozak's ideology is fundamentally flawed because it is self-serving, normative (built on value judgments about what metal should be rather than what it actually is), prescriptive instead of descriptive, and performative rather than analytical. He didn't map the genre as it exists; he forced a curated narrow taste and then built an ideological system around it. Once you stop accepting his framing and compare it to real history and real music, his whole worldview falls apart.First, his attempt to draw a hard divide between metal and rock is pure revisionism. He framed metal as stoic, mythic, transcendent, and rock as fun, swaggering, "normie", as if they were entirely separate universes. But historically, metal grew out of rock, and the two were treated as overlapping categories. In the 70s and early 80s, "rock", "hard rock", and "heavy metal" were used interchangeably by bands, fans, and press. Black Sabbath called themselves heavy rock; countless metal bands referenced rocking hard and rock 'n roll in their lyrics and imagery (Judas Priest - Rocka Rolla, Rainbow - Long Live Rock 'n Roll, Holocaust - Smokin' Valves, etc.). Fans today still place Scorpions, Rainbow, early Def Leppard, and even Thin Lizzy near or inside the metal canon. Metal arose from rock both culturally and musically. Pretending they are distinct worlds isn't analysis, it's a value maneuver designed to exclude classic heavy metal and elevate extreme metal as the "true" form.cont.
>>128513723Second, his attempt to brand extreme metal as "neoclassical" is pure sleight of hand. Classical music carries enormous cultural prestige, and he wanted that prestige attached to his preferred genres. The logic was: classical is the highest art; I like death/black metal; therefore death/black metal must be neoclassical. It's like calling a rusty car a Ferrari because you personally like it. But real neoclassical metal actually exists: Yngwie Malmsteen, Jason Becker, Tony MacAlpine, Vinnie Moore, Rhapsody, Borislav Mitic, etc. all openly use classical themes, motifs, leads, and orchestration. Death and black metal, by contrast, are intentionally harsh, abrasive, and ugly; they have nothing to do with classical music in sound or intent. Calling extreme metal "neoclassical" while ignoring the musicians who actually draw from classical tradition isn't criticism, it's farcical ideological rebranding.Third, and this exposes the core flaw: the ideology always came first, and the musical claims were bent to fit it. He wasn't describing metal; he was reshaping the definition into a hierarchy that placed his preferred subgenres at the top under prestige labels, while pushing everything melodic, accessible, or historically foundational to the bottom. There is only one word that accurately describes this kind of posturing: poser. Once you examine the genre's history and actual musical content instead of the value-laden rhetoric, his entire system collapses.
Artist: DarkthroneAlbum: PanzerfaustSong: Beholding The Throne of Might>And destruction upon the holy man>Who hails a jew
>>128513351>Sanguisugaboggwhy is this band so pushed
>>128513723>>128513735Get a job
>>128512372Next year. They did play a few new songs at Metal Threat and Chris said the artwork needs to be finalized and it's the same guy who did the Earthendium cover art.Disma's a band I knocked off as being kinda trendy because OSDM was at its peak shilling in 2015, now I kinda feel like I was too harsh in my judgement.
>>128513723>>128513735Don't get a job so you can post more of this
>>128513856I have a job. I posted this after work.
What did prozak even do to you?
>>128513936Banned him for "being annoying"
>>128513735Prozak doesn't even care for classical music.
>>128513735>Third, and this exposes the core flaw: the ideology always came first, and the musical claims were bent to fit it.This is definitely true.
>>128513735>>128513723Pozzak obviously has no idea about anything related to classical, if you know even a tiny about about the genre you would know he just spouts terms without a clue as to what they mean. Le "leitmotif" king was exposed to me as a sad joke the second I read a single paragraph from him. >>128513960Correct. His last.fm is literally 100% baldcuckery. He has no classical composer or performer in his top 100 listens.
>>128514003It's not though, he actually talked about this on some podcast someone posted not too long ago
>>128514027>>128502778
>>128514035Well I'm not going to listen to him talk to that other rambling bald idiot. My senses tell me it's true even if his narrative differs.
>>128513402the medium tempos make it more like rap and the big bands are all produced to sound like edm. it's not a accident that metallica slowed their tempos down on black album. that's what normies like.
>>128514027Dude OSDM has leitmotifs because sometimes they tremolo 1-2-3-4 and then they tremolo 2-3-4-5.
Anyone who likes Sleep Token should be forced to wear a band around their arm designating them as lesser human beings
>>128513723>>128513735I neglected to mention one more thing: his reviews are just senseless word salads. Take these gems from his Storm of the Light's Bane review:>Brainwave tendencies of sloping melodies move like rock n roll and this music repeats too often the idiosyncrasies of that genreWhat does it mean for brainwave tendencies of "sloping melodies" to move like rock 'n roll? How does Storm of the Light's Bane have anything to do with rock 'n roll (see my first point in my post for the answer).>it inverts and enunciates a recursing serpentine despair in virulent and corrupted voices as if through the distorted transmission of a sick comic radio script reporting the apocalypse.What?>this release is sleeker with a more warlike dedication to functionality within artWhat is "warlike dedication to functionality within art" supposed to mean, in this context?
Any place where I can find examples of typical metal drum patterns? Want to program some in a DAW to fuck around.
>>128514231>senseless word saladsAre we still talking about Prozzak here?
>>128514027>you would know he just spouts terms without a clue as to what they meanliterally (you)
>>128514231My favorite Pozzak line was >providing a seething cover of powerchords to spell out dominate melody through rhythm and counterpoint modal resolution iterating structure>providing a seething cover of powerchords of counterpoint modal resolution iterating structure>powerchords counterpoint modal resolution iterating structureHow baIdcuck Pozzak drones never realized they were reading a complete moron is beyond me.
Guy acts tough and all but I bet Prozak haunts his nightmares, that's why he keeps bringing him up, he's trying to cope
>>128514299>avatarpostHidden, left unread
dude check out this leitmotif*BRAAAAAAAP*
Please explain to me how this isn't neoclassical but Morbid Angel and Burzum is.https://youtu.be/ZKbPPuaHnxw?t=1317>>128514258Yes.
>>128513723Thank you for the hecxrement
>>128514336that dude looks like a gigantic faggot
>>128514231>brainlet can't understand high IQ criticism
Prozak had a separate site for "neoclassical" which included some metalhttps://www.anus.com/zine/music/
>>128514366He's playing with skill and from memory an entire concert he wrote himself, with the Japanese Philharmonic, to what looks like a full house. What have you done?
>>128514372Please do explain it then.
Rec me power metal that's actually grimy as fuck with an attitude and not just overproduced trash. Picrel
>>128512040it's I WANT A COCKCOCKI WANT TWO COCKSCOCKS
>>128514378https://www.anus.com/zine/music/stratovarius/destiny/lelOn Stratovarius:>Of the flood of "power metal" out there, there are a few bands who despite their addiction to cheese make phenomenal music within the constraints of their genre. This is one of them.
>>128514378Wasn't there a review of MBV Loveless on here? And Loreena McKennitt? That must have been written back when he actually had a gf.
>>128514400Here you go, King:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-RjHAIk5ZzMhttps://youtu.be/dozzxSbYGdk?t=57https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=23zbZ7mrbLM
>>128514378The only good thing about that page is that it introduced me to Dead Can Dance.
>>128514425>asks for power metal without overproduction>posts the most overproduced BG album
>>128514445The newer ones are even more overproduced. In fact Twist in the Myth was a step back from A Night of the Opera, a bit rawer.
>>128514400Here you go, dude. This is so raw and not produced it should be exactly the kind of Power Metal you're looking for.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uaMMg1J564g
>>128514406>I WANT A COCK>COCK>I WANT TWO COCKS>COCKSOhh yessss, that also rhymes well. I WANNA COCK. Maybe I'll get one someday...
>>128514470This is better but doesn't really feel power metal, just regular 80s HM
>>128514408Correct.
>>128514394>>128514299>plebeians can't grasp the recursing serpentine despair in virulent and corrupted voicesloving every laugh
>>128514299>providing a seething cover of powerchords to spell out dominate melody through rhythm and counterpoint modal resolution iterating structurewhat the fuck is that supposed to mean lmao
>>128514400Persuader's early albums are pretty raw soundinghttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_8cBDe-tjqg&list=RD_8cBDe-tjqg
>>128514511My bad, here you go:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jRmjhHOeh4chttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tSQcY_q4rPg
>>128514609It means Prozak knew that decades later some autist would stumble upon his writings and endless seething would result
>>128514609Pozzak is so retarded he doesn't even know powerCHORDS cannot be a melody. Nevermind whatever the flying fuck "counterpoint modal resolution iterating structure" means. The guy is literally a complete and total moron stringing together words he hasn't even bothered to google the meaning for.
>>128512040>COCKReminder that this tranny slayed more pussy that you've seen in your whole life. How does this make you feel?
>>128514668I've no idea who that literal nobody even is, and I doubt he had all that planned out.
to be fair, you have to be a genius to understand prozakian analysis
>>128514673>chords cannot be melody
>>128514676>Worshipping women so much that turning yourself into a tranny means you "win" so long as you got a crumb of pussy.The world as it exists because weak simps decided that pussy was worth more than self respect.
>>128514673Powerchords can form melody with the root notes, e.g. the Iron Man riff, is a melody, but what he wrote is total nonsense so it doesn't really matter
>>128514684Godzak is our lord and savior
>>128514699>self respectLook where you are right now lmao
>>128514419>Loreena McKennittbeloved here
Masterful emptiness commands space for the jarringly exact yet inverted and ambiguous structures of alienated riffing, as tension builds in the growing melody and abrupt breaks to statements of evolving theme. Ritual cadences in vocals and song structure gain presence as atmosphere builds and mood shifts again to an abstract and darker tone. Concepts of ancient mystery and mysticism thrust these songs forward in destruction of the mindset of the current time, establishing this classic for both musical and ideological reasons.
>>128514697>/shredd1t/ is as stupid as Pozzak isLoving Every Laugh. No wonder they worshipped this idiot for so long. >>128514716Incorrect, not only are chords NOT melody by their inherent nature, but technically "melody" in its traditional meaning requires proper progression, which paralLEL fifth spam cannot have, ignoring that fact that a paralLEL fifth is a chord.
>>128514400omen - battle cryvisigoth - the revenant king
>>128514400What you're really looking for is more USPMhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7dcSzgIj-0ohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_lBNmcqNCmchttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_n_vMIskFNwhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M8pHndTZ-MEhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WxSSj0EjwWYhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YxFDpTzLmqQ
>>128514511>>128514400This production is pretty raw:https://youtu.be/AEPKb736boU?t=28https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jirq0rz_0xo
>>1285147412/10 made me reply
Nice to see Prozak still mentally dominates the h man
Who revved him this time?>ProzakNice eceleb worship
>>128514741>technically "melody" in its traditional meaning requires proper progression,Which is?Also, tradition has been changed, and definition of melody is broader. Iron Man has melody played with power chords. It would be a melody without the fifth interval, and it still is a melody witha fifth
>>128514748That all sounded really gay, no thanks.
>>128514783Only Hecthreads are worth posting in.
>>128514741A simple melody is still a melody dude. There's no difference between a melody of single notes and a melody of double stops/parallel fifths/power chords.
>>128514748Ok some of these hit the spot just right. Really underdog picks as well. Good post anon>>128514827Everything sounds gay when you're sucking cock daily
>>128514813>tradition has been changed, and definition of melody is broader.Incorrect, technical terms are not slang, they do not change meaning just because lay-people are stupid and lack understanding. >>128514837/shredd1t/ IQ strikes again.
>>128514676It doesn't make me feel anything. I don't like pussy, I love cocks. And men.
I'm not reading any of this
I don't get it, why is that guy obsessed over Prozak, why not another random dude from the internet? Why is he obsessed?
>>128514726Talking to a bunch of men, thank the gods.
>>128514870How is posting about someone being wrong an obsession?
>>128514859>technical terms are not slang,Technical terms can become broader too. In the most primitive sense, melody is anything you can sing, and Iron Man riff is singable and thus a melody.
>>128514881Because it's not the first time, I've seen him mentionned in many threads prior this one. It seems that Prozak dude rents free in some spammer's head
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NBmRIq0EGX4
>>128514881Because he is a Pozzak drone upset that his idol turned out to be an idiot. Never once have I bought up Pozzak first, his drones mention him and then once you prove their eceleb idol to be among the most stupid on the internet, they declare that you are "obsessed" for laughing at the monkey they themselves cannot stop bringing up unprompted.
>>128514867Correct
>>128514898I am not those people. This is the first time I posted about him. As for why, read the post. Because he's wrong.
Is the new Primitive Man any good?
>>128514883>Technical terms can become broader tooIncorrect. >Iron Man riff is singableExtremely low IQ, reaching Pozzak tier.
>>128514913Meds
>>128514859I accept your concession of defeat. I reiterate: There's no difference between playing Twinkle twinkle little star and playing twinkle twinkle little star using power chords.
>>128514913Fine but isn't that guy 50 now and not even active online? What did he do to you?
So the next trend in melodeath is just making heavy AOR?https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8lnviIWjliEhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BK8eDu-tuSA
>>128514928>>128513950
>>128514925>There's no difference between playing Twinkle twinkle little star and playing twinkle twinkle little star using power chords./Shredd1t/'s finest mind, just another comedic moment in this stand up show of a general.
>>128513241Not metalAlso their worst album
>>128514928I was listening to some '70s heavy metal and it sounded really rock-ish. Then I remembered his spergy writings about how metal is totally different from rock and not the same thing at all, even though up to 1983 it pretty much was.
>>128514927Based albumhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FhMsOB88dfo
>>128514945We get it, you have no counterargument. All you can do is shriek "/Shredd1t/" over and over again.
>>128514921>IncorrectHow so?>Extremely low IQ,You are being dishonest. Not surprising.
>>128514963>See some slobbering retard on the side of the street yelling out "CHORDS ARE MEEEEELLLOOODY">His pants are at his ankles>Despite being more than 200 ft away, his foul stench still fills the air>Can't get a look at his face as the sun keeps reflecting off his deeply melanated and smooth scalp>Thank the gods I was born white>Laugh and continue walking away
Hector on his death bed"I wish I could have argued on 4chan's metal general more" "I wanted to own more shredditors" "I wanted to listen to more slop"
Fellow Hectorians, can we declare another victory?
>>128515011 I never said chords are melody. I said you can make a melody of chords. And there's another poster who said the same.
>>128515024All of these unironically. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rrLa0dPOYYQ
>>128515024>I wish I could spark one last argument about musical terminology I still don't understand>I wish I could call someone low IQ baldcuck, just once more, god please
>>128515050>chords are melody. I said you can make a melody of chords.>I never said you can make shit turn into diamonds. I said you can make diamonds out of shitSometimes I really do think the posters here are literally too stupid to be human, you are not a real human being, you do not think, you are simply a homunculus larping as human.
>>128515051Why are you being so pretentious? This isn't /classical/, are you trying to virtue signal with Brahms? lmfao
>>128515104>lmfao
>>128515104>Midwit sees any sort of classical>P-pretenious KWAB
rocking metal motherfucker
>>128515104He couldn't even tell you about Brahms or why he likes him without having to google shit, he's also too insecure to post on /classical/ because everyone would laugh at him. Notice the samefag replies. this general is a lost cause
>>128515143>this general is a lost causeYes, because you're lacking in pattern recognition
>>128515143>He couldn't even tell you about Brahms or why he likes himThat would be correct, since I only just started to listen to him. Mostly because he is supposed to be similar to Medtner, of whom I love more than all else. I don't have a full view of classical yet, its an immensely broad genre and takes a load of time/dedication to get, so I refrain from speaking about it too much, unlike metal where I know every in and out and thus free to speak of it easily.I don't post in classical (often, I still make posts) because metal is or at least was my main genre, I don't post in /bleep/ even though I listen to Machine Girl or Aphex Twin, well... assuming there was a /bleep/ to post in anymore anyways. >>128515168Correct.
>>128514963>We get it, you have no counterargument. All you can do is shriek "/Shredd1t/" over and over again.Correct.
>>128515205>Classical>GenreAlright, this is just pathetic kek. I'm out of here
I just roke up
>>128515250Terrible gotcha, why do you think forums for the genre are called "talkclassical" yet discuss all eras from classical to modern to reconnaissance? There is classical (genre) and classical (era).
>>128515274Incorrect.
>>128515296Thank you shreddit.
1 post filtered.
>>128515205>unlike metal where I know every in and out and thus free to speak of it easily.djentlemen, we have the joke of the year
>>128515318Boring post.
Another Hec L.
>>128515334>This is monophonic (one note at a time)>chord progression isn't a melodyEven Jeetpt agrees withe me, just hilarious watching this place blow itself the fuck out every time I step foot in here.
>>128515318LOL
>>128515205>I don't have a full view of classical yet,Yet you speak about it confidently every single time. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunning%E2%80%93Kruger_effect
oh no
>>128514673>>128515360>chords cannot be melodyjust accept the L
>>128515414Nope, I speak of the parts and periods I know and the composers I have listened to. I could tell you very little about people such as Brahms or Schubert, since I don't listen to them. Nor do I discuss them with others. >>128515423Thank you shreddit.
>>128515360New low of reading comprehension. Did you even bother to read the full statement? Are you physically unable to admit defeat?
>>128515444You're just an irritating faggot. Nobody likes you here
>>128515445He's just mentally ill, he'll never accept he's wrong. Reddit and Prozak rent free in his head, he will never live free. >>128515444Commit suicide
>>128515465Prozak is the dumbest literal nobody gorilla and should've never even been brought up on this website. But yes, he can't accept that he's wrong, or maybe he does but won't admit.
Hector masturbates while listening to Symbolicance and Jute Gyte.
>>128515514>Symbolicanceliterally who
>>128515514Correct. I also like to do it while listening to The Synarchy of Molten Bones.
>>128515445>New low of reading comprehensionThis, but in regards to yourself. Directly states me to be correct in both definitions as per the quotes I gave you. >>128515514>>128515546Correct, but also Scriabin
>>128515488Why don't you just start your own website and write reviews and use "leitmotif" in the correct manner.
>>128515528My favorite Vegan black metal project.
>>128515561>Directly states me to be correct It literally didn't.>"Iron Man" riff qualifies as melody is more correct>it can include elements like arpeggiated chords or harmonically thick lines>a pure chord progression isn't a melody (there is no "chord progression" in Iron Man)According to your logic, even anything that is doubled with octaves is no longer a melody. LOLIn fact, there is very little separating melody from chord voices even in traditional chord/melody setting. Iron Man is just melody, there are no chords (intervals aren't even chords).
>>128515079Quote where I said "chords are melody" you nincompoop. Even so I explained my point and I am right.
>>128515619>It literally didn't.It literally did when it wasn't giving value judgments that AI is garbage at. As per its own actual definitions:>This is monophonic (one note at a time)>chord progression isn't a melodyCHORDS cannot be MELODY, they are separate technical terms for a reason. A dyad cannot be a melody, a melody is MONOPHONIC, a chord is HOMOPHONIC. You are low IQ. >>128515647You said "I never said chords are melody.", iit was merely cut short in a poor copy paste, but the rebuttal included the full statement, for I said "I never said you can make shit turn into diamonds. I said you can make diamonds out of shit" not "you can make shit turn into diamonds. I said you can make diamonds out of shit".
Jutish Gyatta
Dogs will eat dog food
>>128515670I don't follow your strawman. And I don't care. The Iron Man riff is a short melody. It doesn't matter if it's voiced by single notes, or doubled with the fifth interval.Like >>128515619 said, according to your logic even doubled octaves aren't melodies. You are even more stupid than prozak.
>>128515670Iron Maiden harmonized melodies must blow this moron's mind.
>>128515670>value judgmentsIt wasn't value judgement but a logical argument. How can it even have value judgement, it's an AI >This is monophonic (one note at a time)Then polyphonic music is excluded. That's it, if it has more than one note at a time it's no longer melody. Do you even think or is your brain pea-sized?>CHORDS cannot be MELODYA top voice of chords is usually what "melody" is called. Chord itself is not melody, it can contain melodies
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lZ01-4B6si8
Don't you guys also love jerking off while listening to Symbolicance? I can't be the only one.https://symbolicance.bandcamp.com/album/symbolicance
>>128515747Not metal
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hulIVdZgQRMThis has an In Flames feel
>>128515735Correcthttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hk7_RxzkcYw
>>128515785F
>>128515699>doesn't matter if it's voiced by single notesYou wish.>>128515728It was a value judgement, and its own definitions went against that value judgement because Jeetpt is as "intelligent" as shreddit is.>Then polyphonic music is excluded.Incorrect, polyphony by definition must have its voices rhythmically differentiated, else it would be homophonic. >A top voice of chords is usually what "melody" is called. Chord itself is not melody, it can contain melodiesUtter gibberish. Melody is a monophonic series of single notes. What you are describing is chordal progression. Shreddit IQ strikes again.
>>128515824Faggot, loser, and a dork. You
>>128515847Thank you shreddit.
Anyway, what's the best Jute Gyte album to masturbate to?
>>128515876Go back and stay there, faggot.
>>128515906Defeated shredditor can only whimper "p-please leave" after his ritual btfo. KWAB.
>>128515935>in my mind it was real
>>128515965Boring post.
>>128515465>>128515458Thank you obitors.
>>128515824retard
why are metalheads like this
>>128515986Whoops meant to reply to >>128515793
>>128515965Correct.
>>128516005Don't you get tired of this
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yTSs1v3ETEcI want something that sounds like this but downtuned and even more aggressive.
>>128515824>its own definitions went against that value judgementIt didn't. You misunderstood its definition.>polyphony by definition must have its voices rhythmically differentiated,Polyphony isn't just that "by definition".>Melody is a monophonic series of single notes.And chords can be dissected into monophonic series of single notes.
Hard to refute
>>128516047>It didn't. You misunderstood its definition.Incorrect, the definitions were straight forward as per my quotes. >Polyphony isn't just that "by definition".Incorrect, you have no idea what you are talking about.>And chords can be dissected into monophonic series of single notes.Incorrect, melody and chords are separate terms for a reason.
>>128516062>root noges corming a singable monophonic lineCorrect.HECTOR CAN'T FATHOM THIS because he is a BRAINLET
>>128516062Lmao
>>128516071>Incorrect, the definitions were straight forwardYes, they were. >IncorrectYou can look up in any dictionary if you wish, your definition of polyphony is incorrect.>Incorrect, melody and chords are separate terms for a reason.Reason which you do not understand
YOU ARE A BIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIITCH
>>128516072>noges corming anotes* forming*
>>128516077Which circus does she perform at?
>>128516097>Yes, they were.Correct. >your definition of polyphony is incorrect.Incorrect, feel free to prove otherwise, polyphony by definition MUST be rhythmically differentiated, else it would be homophony.>Reason which you do not understandNot an argument, concession accepted.
I FUCK NUNS
>>128516062>actual definition sidevs >lay person "anything goes, words have no meaning in the modern subjectivist world" sideCorrect.
>>128516125Funny joke!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g_ureU7TTSEhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7alxUJki19c
>>128516102Correct.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bpBWS3djrKoMan this band is excellent.
>>128516127>CorrectBut you didn't understand correctly.>feel free to prove otherwise,By providing definition? Sure>a style of musical composition employing two or more simultaneous but relatively independent melodic linesNowhere does it mention "rhythm".>Not an argument,As is your entire post.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2D3_-ivnPAc
>>128511114https://youtu.be/MDenFROBp14
All these links look like garbage
https://youtu.be/8Br2MZKjstY?t=151
>>128516175>But you didn't understand correctly.This, but in regards to yourself. >Nowhere does it mention "rhythm".Shredditor literally too low IQ to know what "independent melodic lines" means, he has no idea that this literally means rhythmically differentiated LMAO. >As is your entire post.You wish.
>>128516188Play them, idiot
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ODp_Dq2VrC
>>128516188https://music.apple.com/ca/album/natur/634225252
Buncha fucking guys ITT.
>>128516205>This, but in regards to yourself.>no u>he has no idea that this literally means rhythmically differentiatedNope, it doesn't mean that. It can be rhythmically similar too.>You wish.It speaks for itself, I have no wishes.
Symbolicance
>>128516235>>no uConsidering that is your entire post, and has been for the majority of this chain, that is peak irony.>Nope, it doesn't mean that. It can be rhythmically similar too.Incorrect, that is quite literally not the case, to be "independent", it must be rhythmically independent. >It speaks for itself, I have no wishes.Again, you wish.
>>128516228*gays
>>128516264>Considering that is your entire post,Nope, but nice try. "No u" only came from your lack of creativity and arguments>that is quite literally not the case, Except it is. It can be, and is almost always rhythmically similar. >Again, you wish.I have no wishes, only facts.
unironically good disso?
>>128516281>Nope, but nice try. "No u" only came from your lack of creativity and argumentsThis, but in regards to yourself. >Except it is. It can be, and is almost always rhythmically similar. Completely and utterly incorrect, they would not longer be independent.>I have no wishes, only facts.You wish.
>>128516291Jute Gyte. Unironically.
>>128516303More like Jude Gyatt LMFAO.
>>128516303i might try it, but it seems people here talk about it in a tongue-in-cheek manner
Spam metal?
>>128516296>This, but in regards to yourself.>yet another no u>they would not longer be independent.They would be, because rhythm does not determine the independenceYou're boring and you lost. Get off.
>>128516329Don't. It's fucking garbage and rightfully mocked here. Even the guy himself denounced his obsessed fanboy and donated his purchase to transgender organization
Poor shredditors can't even figure out the difference between homophony (not rhythmically independent), and polyphony (rhythmically independent).Reminds me of pic related, this place really is one giant comedy show, based polyphony exposes the retards each and every time. Why? Because metalcuckls only think in homophony, polyphony is literally beyond their comprehension. >>128516331>>128516331>because rhythm does not determine the independenceTotal delusion, independence is rhythmic independence, else it would be homophony, poor shredditors are too literally low IQ to understand what polyphony is.
>>128516330Correct, served fresh right out of the tin.
>>128516329Do it, but you will be filtered into oblivion anyways. Then you'll spend your time like >>128516346 being mindbroken over Adam Kalmbach for the rest of your life.
>>128514946Nu metalAnd I found Cannibal to be weaker
Adam Kalmbach is a joke. A funny one
Adam KalmBACH is a polyphonic genius.
>>128516401Correct.
Adam Kalmbach is a Jew.
>>128516408Correct. >>128516401Incorrect.
>>128516408Implying you even understand polyphony lmfao.
>>128516427Whoops meant to reply to >>128516331
>>128516401Correct
>>128515788Don't insult nevermore with in flames slop
>>128516427Lol.
Just another hecGOD vicot0ry.
JG - Your blood and soil are piss and shit
Varg is gay and has AIDS.
>>128516493Lol
>>128516493Correct.
>>128516435No I didn't lol.
>Just another hecGOD vicot0ry.
>>128516580Why are you pretending to be someone else, retarded troll?
Polyphony - multiple independent voices telling you you’re a fag
>>128516610You're putting way too much effort into this.>>128516614LOL
>>128516623>You're putting way too much effort into this.ok schizo
>>128516652Incorrect.
>>128516652Correct.
Great metal discussion
listen to brutal death
>>128516894I don't like the album covers sorry
Polyphony
>>128516982Post five examples
>>128516944i like that one over there and the one below it
California thrash doesn't really do it for me
>>128513193Russian girls’ voices/accent are so sophisticated, I love listening to them
>>128517582Agreed
>>128517747what metal band is she in
Polyphony is Hector gobbledygook, he never ever gave an example of what it is
>>128517747>>128517755thank you simps
>>128517755Flyleaf I think>>128517916Not a simp but etc
>>128516493>>128516576Samelass
/shr3ct0r/ has been defeated
>>128518119I didn't know but thanks for the heads up, king.
>>128517790Just because he doesn't know what it means doesn't mean he can't still appreciate it
Might give this whole AI metal trend a try. Any tips on where to start making my own music?
Maybe some Trhä-style AI metal
>>128511105Why is a rad name like heaven shall burn wasted on such a mid band
>>128518216sounds like a name a 12 year old would come up with
Someone better start cooking
Let's fucking go!
https://youtu.be/FJ8-19CnU2k?si=-gC5jPEjoLGDqvIRGreat band kino movie
>>128518459Fake nebula
>>128518269I'm not hungry right now sorry
>>128512913Bees Made Honey in the Lion's Skull for me, personally
>>128514875Faggot lol
>>128514910Disingenuous post
>>128512494>>128512913>>128518662Great albums. My fave would is Pentastar too tho.
We stand for the DAWG and kneel for Prozak in this thread
What the fuck is Prozak
35 minutes is the perfect length for an album
>>128518791
>>128518784The God of metal curation
