why are Black folks so much better at making music?
Are they?
https://youtu.be/Yt3PB2GiLeU?si=DUMummfuQux_AWDm
>>128705392They got mogged in all their genres except Rap because Rap is not even music.
>>128705543I'd ask which Jazz artists you think are at the summit, but I don't even wanna know. Keep that shit to yourself forever.
>>128705602>jazz>artists
>>128705643>you >not a philistine
>>128705664>BEE DOO BA DEE BOP BEE BOO BOP BA DOO BEE BOOPA BOO BEE BOODLE BEE BEE BAP BAP BEEP BOOPA BOP>omg genius
>>128705392Stop being racist yourself. That's not the way to fight chuds.
>>128705674>dood, it ain't even got no singin'
>>128705705or melody
>>128705726The first Jazz that everyone listens to, Miles Davis’ “Kind of Blue” is extremely melodic. I assume you haven’t actually listened to any jazz, and are just larping to bait people
>>128705726It definitely does sometimes. Regardless, music ≠ melody. Furthermore, a lack of melody doesn't preclude something from being art. I'm racist as fuck, and even I think you're retarded. Stop posting,
>>128705392Is this 1961?
>>128705602a valid point 50 years ago but who are the big black jazz artists in the modern day?
>>128705861No, it's the Clown Year of Our Lord Skibidi Geese 6 7 frfr
>>128705933Jazz has been dead for quite some time.Ahmed is pretty good, but they're definitely not for everyone.https://ahmedquartet.bandcamp.com/album/giant-beauty
>>128705392They aren't.It's the bar of reasonable expectations that keeps dropping.
>>128705392>five of the pastiest white boys to ever live became the best r and b band (the blackest music form besides rap) in history.>and even Eminem is best rapper.that's gotta sting.
>>128706251cope more timmy all y'all goofy ahh dicklets do is steal hour music
>>128706251you'll consider that only if you're a fag
>>128708642i literally don't do these pointless bait back and forth's .....but, reminder, all of the rules of harmony and melody all people in western countries (and most of the rest of world) use (no matter their color) was deduced by people we refer to as white.
>>128709678white people treat melody and harmony like a math problemblack people just feel it intuitiviely
>>128705392She performed at the world cup draw literally just a few hours ago. her, Wyclef and her sons. it kinda sucked lol
>>128705392I would agree but most of the music I listen to is made by white people and asians, got nothing against black people, I just don't like much of their music
>>128709689Both cringey and somewhat accurate at the same time. A rare occurrence.
>>128709689there might be some truth to that.but returning to my best r and b band ever statement:the fact that keith richards obsessively studied old blues records to learn every nuance (and what worked best and what didn't) was the special sauce that allowed him to eventually make r and b derived music far superior to the more rudimentary stuff that inspired him. most of the guys he studied just didn't have that analytical framework that allows taking stuff to the next level in whatever field.i mean i like james brown, but all in all, the rolling stones were just more varied and more harmonically interesting. (jb is very monotonous and repetitive)i'm happy to be disabused of that rating if you can (we're all to a large degree limited to what we've been most exposed to and i've definitely listened to way more rolling stones), but i doubt it can be done.
>>128705392Hardship makes great art and the White man his never experienced true hardship in his life.
>>128709689>>128709879ok. tried this one https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JOD-M7WZkZQ out. it's literally the same groove throughout (besides a slight variation in his infamous 'bridge). why?probably because jb and the band didn't know how to harmonically resolve it to create a more interesting effect.rolling stones use a lot of repetition too, but they also knew cool ways to resolve chord progression. the secret sauce.
>>128705392i dont believe in this racial competition bullshitbut i would say the black music tradition is more rhythmic generally, white people seem more rigid
>>128710105i literally lasted a minute on this one --- from the most sampled artist in hip hop.just too repetitive for my tastes.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1cBZcpSeiFc&list=RD1cBZcpSeiFc&start_radio=1
>>128710105this song is supposed to be background music to social experience"resolutions" and the shit you're talking about is treating a song as an artpiece
>>128705543based
>>128705392
>>128710755I mean a thread on rating who makes the best 3 or 4 minute sound collages is by definition asking people to look at the stuff as 'art pieces'.
>>128709678Barbershop music in the modern sense is not singable using standard Western harmony. The exact origins are obscure but the evidence suggests it was probably invented by black people.
>>128709879I've always felt they were a bit too studious, but no one understood the tension between black and white cultures that lies underneath rock music like they did. Or at least no other rock nerds were able to use that knowledge and make consistently good music.
>>128705782>Regardless, music ≠ melodycompletely wrong, retard.
>>128705392>capital B
>>128710755yes and that's the fundamental difference between white and black music. the latter is like aw that's just noise to bump at a house party and don't think too hard into it.
>>128709879>i'm happy to be disabused of that rating if you can (we're all to a large degree limited to what we've been most exposed tomight be shocked to learn that Taylor Swift's musical knowledge is mostly limited to the shitty 90s-00s radio pop of her childhood
She's holding all of those prizes, but what's the point if I don't even know who she is? Really activates the almonds.
>>128705392they're good at appeasing Jews
>>128706251>and even Eminem is best rapperis this nigga for real?
>>128705392Why did she leave the Industry? Because she was Christian?
>>128720016is this true? I get the feeling blacks sit around listening to music more than any group (i.e., not just as party noise).
>>128705392She didn't write a single thing on that album. It was all done by her band.
>>128705392you already knowit's because black folks have SOUL
>>128721934I know that they pay attention to the music being played way less
>>128721934based on what?
>>128722945just living by them. I mean it's a constant din of loud music.
k
>>128723004yeah because they always have it on in the background, they're not sitting there pondering it
>>128705933Esperanza SpaldingSonny RollinsSamara JoyMarshall AllenHerbie HancockKenny BarronJack DejohnetteTerri Lynn CarringtonAnd a lot of greats died over the past couple years: Ahmad Jamal, Wayne Shorter, Lou Donaldson
>>128723004>>128726689>they're not sitting there pondering itwell hold on that depends, it its rap (not music) then yeah probably correct, but if its blues or soul or jazz or funk, good chance they are
>>128718263>thinks melody is all there is to music >calls people retarded Lole
>>128727211>ut if its blues or soul or jazz or funk, good chance they areHate to tell you this incel but you're listening to black women masturbating on webcam or getting fucked by white guys.
>>128727541underaged porn brained response
>>128727555Feel free to check.
>>128727541>>128727607i'm not the anon with the neighbors
>>128705392jazz, good; but today they do not play jazz
>saying blacks are lazyall the old cats from the early 20th century up until rap worked harder than anybody at their music. if anything blacks probably took music more seriously than white folks since it was one of the few professions they were allowed to do.
>>128728897yeah James Brown had insane discipline. simpleton white boys like us should look up to him not some corny rockstars
>>128705392I know right, huh
>>128732881he was a literal crack head who had his band play the same groove while he yelped some indecipherable gibberish all thru the 70's.and I sorta like the guy, but facts is facts.
>>128732881Herbie Hancock and his 390 albums.
