i'll start
idk but if you took XTC's 10 best songs and arranged them for Red Velvet, you'd have one beautiful album.
>>129478938Its a shame how insanely common it is in emo music for the great instrument work to be completely overshadowed by their horrible vocalists who cant sing for shit.
>>129478938>>129479939I don't know why you were expecting "good" singing on a punk album.
>>129478938My exact impression the first time I listened to this album>>129479973Brand New guy can sing sufficiently well for his vocals not to ruin the song
>>129479973>Sunny Day>punkI hate 2020s tourist so fucking much.
>>129478938Everything black metal really.
>rhcp ruined by keidis and his lyrics>limp bizkit ruined by fred and his rapping>modest mouse singer has a grating voice
slint = spiderland is fucked because of that awful frontman. Shouldve just been an instrumental album
>>129479973I don’t think sdre has bad vocals, but if you compare it to jimmy eats world, elliot and mineral then maybe. Not all emo has bad vocals. Its just a common trend.
>>129480672i think it adds to the charm
>>129478938Anything by Vaselines.
>>129480322Look pretty punk rock to me anon.
>>129480672>Shouldve just been an instrumental album
>>129480524there's plenty of black metal with non-shrieky vocals if that's what you're referring to
>>129478938Robert Smith can not sing for shit sometimes and this is a prime example. The depressing, bleak, horror, suicidal, nihilism of this album is overshadowed by the wails of a man with jumper cables clamping his nipples
>>129478938Every Yes album
Everything by Placebo
>>129481929Come on Die Young is their Slint album
>>129480672i just don't think you totally understand spiderland honestly. the vocals are one of the most interesting aspect of the album and is the highlight and makes the climatic end of goodmorning captain. that song wouldn't be as impactful or memorable without the vocals
>>129478938>>129480672>>129481953>>129482466>>129481929>expecting good singing from punkI think maybe pop music like Magdalena Bay or Charlie XCX or Lana Del Ray might be your speed stop listening to punk, post-punk, proto-punk or post-rock or metal please.
>>129482702you understand that there are many different vocal styles within metal, some of which might appeal to a person, while others don't? same goes for most of the genres you listed. this has nothing to do with whether someone is a good or well-trained singer
>>129478938What other singer could sing the chorus of In Circles the way Jeremy did? Fuck you.
>>129478938All of Bjork imoshe has amazing instrumentals in Vespertine but her voice is so squeaky and annoying.meanwhile the instrumentals sound like Final Fantasy which has really good orchestration:https://youtu.be/F2cz8Z7-frM?si=3mOzMV89WsxwDPmBhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pGeclAFSMC4
>>129482810Punk is kinda well known for not having traditionally good vocals though.
>>129478938What exactly do we mean by shit vocals?
>>129484248the vocalist is a bad singer or the vocalist is a terrible lyricist like shit tier becuase one can get away with mid tier lyrics or even nonsense like Noel Gallager lets be real. I'm in paaaaainbecause there is no raaaainnudes on maaaainwe gnna be rockan roll stars!! yeeeeee!
>>129481056Except girl vocals >>129479939Try pee
>>129478938Fuck off
