Poppy Genesis editionWhat is Progressive Rock?>https://rateyourmusic.com/genre/progressive-rock/>https://www.progarchives.com/Progressive-rock.asp#definitionGood albums to start with?>https://www.musicgenretree.org/essential_prog.pngObscure prog gems>https://rateyourmusic.com/list/antonbildern/a-secret-society-obscure-progressive-rock-albums/prev: >>129378583
>genesis>virgin yup
https://youtu.be/Jbs3-f3yEj0
>forces everyone to acknowledge Calling All Stations>ignores From Genesis to Revelations completelyWhat the fuck is his problem?
>>129503893Johnathan King still owns the rights to From Genesis To Revelation
>The unbearable
>>129503903Can they just get them back? They're fucking rich
What's your favorite /prog/ song that features flutes? For me, it's Rhayader by Camelhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_BXx-BvW3AM&list=RD_BXx-BvW3AM&start_radio=1
>>129505289Some songs that instantly come to mind.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0-jlVaJbj5Qhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HkgYq7dtyN8https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X-jnzDSaTl4https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vGsmRXZY3_M
>>129505289get em out by friday
Here's your new Rushhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g_SWRSUHfLI
>>129503774The original disturbed version is better, when did this boomer band cover disturbed?
>>129505289https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cSLB_htKSYs
Proggers who peaked with their debut?
>>129510317Genesis RushPink Floyd King Crimson
>>129510475weak bait
>>129510317noneprog takes time
>>129511084https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=naTLugO5Krs
>>129510831Half of those are common opinions though
>>129511437The only acceptable answer is King Crimson. Pink Floyd if you like the Syd Barrett stuff
>>129510317King Crimson by far, followed by Camel
>>129510317Anglagard though they only have 3 albums
Wikipedia says this band is progressive metalYour thoughts on them?https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wJNbtYdr-Hg
>>129505289Think as a Brick
>>129511863Rick Beato has devoted at least three videos to them and what supposedly makes them unique. I'm just not hearing it myself, but their popularity is somewhat encouraging.
>>129510317Anglagard (debatable)Birds and BuildingsFrostKarmakanicmany might say Marillion, but they'd be wrongMars VoltaNemo possiblyPremiata Forneria Marconi (possibly)Spock's BeardSteve HackettThe TangentI have excluded bands that had fewer than three albums in their prime. If they came back 20+ years later to milk their fans with slop, those albums don't count.
>>129512595Hackett? Please Don't Touch, Defector and Spectral Mornings are all better than VOTA.Also, Marillion never peaked.
buttprog?
>>129512655>Please Don't TouchStopped reading there. Thank you for reminding me that piece of shit exists. A while ago someone asked what album has the biggest discrepancy between your personal rating and PA's. This is it by far. I'd give that a 1 star. I think there may have been a track on it that was tolerable. I bought this CD on a whim at a record store and it is the only CD I have ever gotten rid of.
>>129512666Are you an asian asking for a butt plug?
>>129512683No one cares that you have shit taste.
>>129512666I'm still not sure what butt rock is, but I imagine Flying Colors is in the ballparkhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AMDV0erLyXw
>>129512666Yes?
>>129511084>prog takes timeHence why none of these bands have works as good as their early material. Classical composers often made some of their greatest works at an older age, even some movie makers do that. Prog is great for taking rock music further, but a lot of times it feels like it never went far enough. Just like a lot of typical rock and pop bands prog artists are running on fumes ~15 years into their career
>>129514084Magma, IQ, and Mike Oldfield released their greatest album over 30 years after their debut. Those are the only acts I can think of that do it. The rest peak around 3-8 albums in, all within 10 years of their debut.
>>129512595Never understood when people say this regarding anglagard, their first album was the only thing I listened to in the beginning but their second two are so much better after it clicks it's not really close
>>129514084All rock is fueled by the vitality of youth, that's why it has a vigour that classical lacks
>>129515709
>>129515736a german, a serb and a polish jew walk into a bar
>>129505289would locomotive breath count?
>>129515736Moving Pictures
Good morning, /prog/. Currently listening to this.
>>129515422Well damn then I should just listen to classical then. There's as much vigour and it can actually persist with age. >>129514176Christian Vander is on a level of his own even in prog. I'd argue Tim Smith is there too but I'm not sure if that recent Cardiacs album is as good or at least comparable to On Land and in the Sea, etc.
this song gives me a nostalgia bonerhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n5Haxf7kV5w
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9SfRo_YoSbw
>>129512595>Frost*I was gonna mention them but I'm not sure if they really count when they are a super group
>>129517495The success of Marillion must've been a gigantic ego bruise to all the UK rock critics who wanted everyone to believe prog was never popular or acceptable there.
>>129512655>Marillion never peakedMisplaced Childhood and Clutching at Straws are masterpieces
>>129520073Kayleigh was a pretty big hit even here
>>129520073In 1973 a New Musical Express or Melody Maker readers poll voted Genesis the best live act in the UK.
>>129520083If your standards are very low maybe. The whole band probably cried themselves to sleep each night because they weren't Genesis.
>>129512666Any of the Tool inspired bands like Karnivool, Cog, Rishloo or Soen
>>129520157They do not care about shallow comparisons like thatAnd after Fish left they have changed their sound
any marillion bros ever heard of BYAMPOD?
Is this the greatest prog rock album of all time? Please show me the way.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QQ1Zo6faTQY
>>129520478Only the title track is good.
What is the prog version of Rust in Peace by Megadeth?
>>129520997Moving Pictures, awful vocals
>>129514176>>129517187Magma is turgid garbage
>>129521641Magma is liquid rock
thoughts?
>>129521792Kino Bob Dylan impression by Adrian Belew.
>>129521792overrated. one of zappa's weaker 70s releases, if it didn't have bobby brown i think people would realize this.
>>129520069This discussion literally started with a supergroup
>>129521641>>129521681magma is dümbhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DANPsMx-N84
>>129503774those fucking puppets traumatized me as a kid. absolutely disgusting
>>129520478I hardly ever listen to the B Side, the only song there I actually like is Jeremy Bender. Shame because the title track is one of the greatest prog epics of all time
>>129511863I think they and you would be more useful as plant feed.
Pale Gates of Sunrise: Vol. 1>https://rapidshare.io/183x/pgos.rar
Name a better prog love song than Kayleigh
>double album gets a single CD version>it doesn't contain the best track
>>129525526There's the obvious choice you're talking about, the contrarian choice, and two objectively wrong choices. The only question is which are you.All of which is moot because Invisible Man is clearly the best.
>>129525829Ocean Cloud of courseWith Neverland close second
>>129525880Whoops. I didn't see Neverland is omitted from the 1 CD version. Change that to two obvious choices. And you chose correctly.
>>129525894It isn't, I just meant that it's the 2nd best song on the whole album
>>129503774What is the best pop song made by a prog artist?
>>129527842https://youtu.be/VIBCPAWUEKM?si=A9ATW7lpZIk2lrnX
>>129527842https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=smVIHvV2a9o
>>129527842Would you consider Tempus Fugit by Yes a pop song? It's pretty catchy desu
>>129527842Sledgehammer
>>129527842Solsbury Hill
What does /mu/ think about Tangerine Dream’s 1978 record, Cyclone? I personally enjoy the blending of live drumming, & wind instruments, with their trademark Berlin School sound. Steve Jolliffe’s vocals are an interesting, though sometimes intrusive, touch; & are easily the weakest of the new additions to my ears
>>129529233ha, shit sounds like that larpy band, whats the name again... Black Magic SS (well yes technically it's the other way around)
>>129529018kino>>129528113that shit sucks
>>129529233it's alright, i heard it once and i remember appreciating it for switching things up and being more straightforward. i think it's hard to connect to tangerine dream a lot of the time cause they switch lineups and sounds up so much fucking times
>>129521792yo mama is peak zappa
>>129527842https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sJEXqbmOZP0
>>129529233Side B is the best Tangerine Dream track of atl time
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S90Cz8czK8U
>>129530387This one got a good laugh out of me. I have never heard of this band before, so I gave them a listen after work yesterday. The vocal work sounds close enough to Steve Jolliffe’s raving, so I can see what you mean by the comparison>>129531211To my understanding, the Virgin Years are the most consistent period in their discography. Most of their seventies records comprise of Froese, Franke, & Baumann; with Cyclone, & Force Majeure being the only two of the seventies Virgin output to lack Baumann’s contributions. The remainder of the Virgin Years saw Johannes Schmoelling join as the third member through the first half of the eighties. I am not too familiar with their output following Schmoelling’s departure, but I have not been too terribly impressed with what I have heard. They really seem to loose the creative momentum that built them into the colossal force in electronic music by the turn of the nineties>>129535127This is a first! Madrigal Meridian is easily the highlight track on the album; but I have never heard anyone praising it as highly as you. You should check out some of the bootlegs of their live performances from 1978, as they are closer to the B Side of Cyclone than the A Side
>>129527842https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P3pzX5iKFsk
Just got Foxtrot and Third for cheap at my local record store, I'm living large right now
I'm vitamin-enrichedWhat's more, I'm absolutely wholesomeNo artificial flavorings or anything so loathsomeYou'll fancy me at lunch, not to mention teaI'm easily digested naturally
new sepultura song:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o7anH4l8Ipc
>>129521792Zappa insists upon himself.
>>129527842TWIIILIIIIGHT
no this is the Sepultura prog trackhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E_cPO1P83I8
>>129540700You lost, son? Also>post-Chaos AD Sepultura
Turns out pic related isn't AI, just a really shit drawing.
>>129541059More soul
>>129541059did you retards forget what a filter is?
>>129505289https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G8ASP47aOl8
>>129541076yeah. right here.
I'll make one point on the prog situation...Gong > Yes
>>129527842https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WVrJoYtO9hc
>>129510317Gentle Giant, their debut is my absolute favorite
>>129543730Terrible /prog/ hivemind opinion.
>>129542861>this is a filter nowWouldn’t Larks’ tongues be better suited as a filter?
Proggybumps
>>129547795robert fripp's preggy bump :)
>>129545549Really? It's probably my least favorite of their good run of albums. Not that it's bad, their other albums are just really fucking good. What do you like so much about it?
>>129548082Their first few albums were mid because they had shit drummers dragging them down. Even John Weathers isn't that great, but he can at least keep up and has a cool style. I don't know why they never got a virtuoso type drummer
King Crimson peaked with Islands, artistically speaking.
>>129549086Islands is dosh
>>129549650I don't know what language you're speaking, but I'm going to assume you agree with me.
>>129527842https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kU8OJAOMbPg
Phil bros, we're winning.
>>129550627Sade moggs everyone else on that list.
Fripp is a presumptuous no-talent
>>129550752Ya
>>129550627the fuck is that list
>>129550772Pink must've told her fans to stuff the ballot. Also you can vote once a day until the poll closes which is bullshit anyway.
>>129549086>>129549650>removes Ladies of the Roadhol up.. it's PEAK?!??
>>129550627>>129550772a fan vote of this years rock and roll hall of fame nominees.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dMIbBnXz1H4
>>129552883wonder when theyre gonna make new stuff. something in the vein of slag tanz would be awesome.i didnt care much for kartehl t b h. edgy magma best magma.
>>129553023I remember hearing that they had new stuff in the works for 2025 last year but I'm not sure if anything came of that. Not all of their live stuff gets uploaded to Youtube and like half of their stuff isn't on a studio album.
>Porcupine Treevery good, great even>No-Manmeh>Blackfielddouble meh>Bass Communion>Incredible Expanding Mindfucknot really my thing, but ok I guess>Storm Corrosion"we want the goth girl audience but got twinks instead">Steven Wilson solocomplete and utter dogshit
>>129553991>complete and utter dogshitRaven and Hand cannot erase are fantastic
>>129554936Insurgentes is his best
I listened to Civilian by Gentle Giant and I loved it. I wish they continued to make more music in that new wave style.
>>129555317No matter the style, Gentle Giant would have continued to make amazing tracks.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=scRV5ChgALMhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P5Ws26hUxtU
Saw him last night and I'd say Steve Hackett is pretty spry for 76
>>129527842https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZkvHH8fn-OI&list=RDZkvHH8fn-OI&start_radio=1
>>129555753I would also nominate this for >>129525399
>>129553991Trust me, they wanted the twinks and got what they asked for.
>>129553991>Steven Wilson >complete and utter dogshit That's all you needed to say
>>129557485kys
>129558260timid little bloke
>>129558464Based Rog fuck Steve Wilson
samefag
>>129529233I like it but you do get the sense that Tangerine Dream probably couldn't do an album in that style again, their instrumentation doesn't leave a lot of room for vocals>>129535127Do agree with this
>>129551181Album might work better if Ladies of the Road is replaced with Lady of the Dancing Water, from Lizard. The song's good but it feels like a bonus track shuffled into the main sequence
>>129551181>>129562332i like ladies of the road but there's no excuse for how bad fripp's solo at the end is. probably one of the worst guitar solos committed to tape
any other *clack clack* *BAM BAM* YOOOOOOOOOOcore /prog/?https://youtu.be/M9Vq0PCe_Lo
>>129562341I like it because it's shit. The whole thing's a joke song anyway.
what's the COOLEST sounding prog band??
Listen to instrumental progressive metal right nowhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ymwk7x901Nw
>>129548082Haven’t listened to all their discography so I can’t say my opinion on the band as a whole, but I guess it’s because its more mainstream with the way the songs are structured. I dislike meandering and randomly places lyrics and beats, along with random noodling. I like more purposeful free rhytms, so the power and the glory was a hard listen for me. It’s also a very fun album>what was that?>only me, hear the echo of my feet :D
>>129557485His CTTE remix was ass not gonna lie
>>129557485>>129558464>>129558824t.
>>129557485trvke
>>129565614Why'd you post a photo of yourself?Pic rel is me btw
Finally listening to Duke. It's pretty good so far
>>129565594Same with his Red
>>129567677for some reason he separated the vocal tapes so that you can hear everyone separately, which is the exact opposite of how harmonizing is supposed to workhttps://youtu.be/o2KtDh_3JCc?si=6rVtBIMvwdm7NGu2&t=141
>>129563108Great Deceiver era KC
>>129567489Based. It deserves more love in the prog scene.
>>129567489>>129569129It constantly competes with Selling England for the #1 spot in my Genesis ranking.
Roger lost.
>>129563108Jethro Tull
>>129567476Ayn Rand & Rush = shit taste.
>>129569604Dave it's time to get off the computer.
>>129510317
>>129563108Pink Floyd
