In Search of the Lost Editionhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VC4njDm5DzoWhat is Progressive Rock?>https://rateyourmusic.com/genre/progressive-rock/>>https://www.progarchives.com/Progressive-rock.asp#definitionGood albums to start with?>https://www.musicgenretree.org/essential_prog.png (embed)Obscure prog gems>https://rateyourmusic.com/list/antonbildern/a-secret-society-obscure-progressive-rock-albums/Previous: >>129698336
>>129780123FUCK peter gabriel, FUCK steve hackett, FUCK pre a trick of the tail genesis
Japan is prog(yes both the country and the band)https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g_z2AmEqyAI
pink foid
>>129780567Hackett is on Trick of the Tail. Tony Banks says the song Steve wrote on it was the best on one on the album.
>>129780567my nigga ant did nothing wrong
Thoughts on Tool?Inb4>they're shit>they're not progPlease only post serious replies. Thanks.
>>129780123Pink floyd and king crimson are the only good prog rock bands.Yes? How about no.
Anything like picrel ? Like saharan vibe
>>129783196>hey, /food/, thoughts on dog shit?I dislike dog shit, it's not food>woah woah woah, I only want serious replies that reaffirm and validate me.
I strongly suspect Tony Banks cribbed this for Apocalypse in 9/8https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5064k8usrDUhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IlkiFtCPXts
Erogenous zones, I love you.
>>129784501>Tool>Genres>Progressive Metalhttps://rateyourmusic.com/artist/tool
>>129784501>>129785123Also from the same page:>A unique blend of Metal, Alternative Rock, Progressive Rock and even Psychedelic Rock at timesLet me pick out the relevant part for you:>Progressive Rock
>>129783196Im a fan of tool
>>129783196
>>129783196I dont get it
Not that it counts for much, but I think it's funny that three most based RRHOF speeches were by prog musicians.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IHYL9swzD-ghttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cfa-WR_PEwshttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Px57H2bX9HI
>>129783196Pseudo-butt-prog for 90s grunge/nu-metal teenagers who don't listen to prog but want the prestige of being a prog fan.
>>129785418>the prestige of being a prog fanno such thing
>>129785418>the prestige of being a prog fanlmfao there's no such thing why are proggers always so delusional
>>129783196I liked Ænima back in the day, haven't listened in yearshttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=82XqhHYwB-Q
>>129785432>>129785455There is no such thing as "prestige of being a prog fan", that's the point. Tool fans think there is though.
>>129783196Vastly overrated. I just don't get it.
>>129783196The only song I like here is the last one with the Area 51 caller
Favorite non-prog side projects of prog artists? For me it's the Phil Collins Big Band.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R9eQkTJZlNk
>>129786776For me, it's Offering.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7w9Hgg2dAQo
>>129780123That’s certainly one way to mime drums
>>129785376how many non-prog induction speeches have you listened to?
>>129786776Picrel is straight up one of my favorite ambient albums https://youtu.be/fH5x2qKvyvg
How do I actually into Genesis if I like Phils singles like Invisible Touch, In the Air Tonight and Land of confusion?
>>129790162Idk, there are probably some convoluted ways you could go about it but I would say just start with Trespass and go in order from there. Genesis were so prolific that you can chart their history and evolution fluidly from album to album.
>>129790162Contrary to popular opinion, Genesis's transition from prog to pop was a gradual process. By which I mean, start with We Can't Dance and work your way backwards through their discography
>>129790162Duke, their early work was too artsy, too intellectual
proggybumps
>when you remember the time you played the knife and supper's ready for the whole class
the bloody mues
soooo... any good concerts coming up?
>>129799118Might see Beat if they come to the US again
>>129780123Are there any drumless prog albums?
>>129783196Vastly overrated. They have some interesting tempos and melodies but there’s not much you can do with just three instruments, so a lot of their songs just feel too samey to stand out. They also have a tendency to just make long songs that don’t feel like they do anything with that runtime. Favorite song from them is Vicarious, because of the 4/5ths beat it sometimes has. The music videos are neat, I guess.
>>129801593Fall of the House of Usher - Peter Hammill. One version has drums, the other does not.
>>129783196Ugh. Everyone replying to this is a fucking faggot. TOOL is for real niggas but 10000 days is their best album because of Lost Keys / Rosetta Stoned
>>129797184have no shame pal you've done the right thing
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O4-vCHAbxVQ
Acknowledge curved air
>>129802431i want to acknowledge all over her
>>129801920Thanks, anon.
>>129802431Only when she acknowledges my curved penis.
>>129803550>>129804198She's calling The Police
https://youtu.be/H0ZbJWEtF18?si=amuqAx6A6ORICil8This concert has a lot of early performances by prog bands: Yes, Moody Blues, Renaissance Etc. Audio isn’t great, but still cool to see.
Graeme Edge's terrible slam poetry is what prevents me from really loving The Moody Blues.
>>129805060It’s goofy but charminghttps://youtu.be/K9iwtRMo6HA?si=ncHGry3BaD41YvG8
>>129805060Should've done it in a funny nasal voice like the band that ripped them offhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=23FMLqX1Z9o
>>129805060There ya go manKeep as cool as you canFace piles of trials with smilesIt riles them to believeThat you perceive the web they weaveAnd keep on thinking free
>>129780821Took me years to find out that their keyboard player is also in Porcupine Tree
So Phil is crippled because of all the shit he had to take for his voice while touring for basically all of the 80s?
>>129806580Also because he sat like this for years
>>129806612Why did he sit like that?
>>129805060should be flayed alive for thinking this
>>129807079Why
>>129807079/fa/ as fuck
*12 string guitar arpeggio intensifies*
Acknowledge Traffichttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X84JnZ0vTi0
>>129806619phil admits to completely going into music blindly and learning everything himself, apparently doesn't know how to even read theory and came up with his own stupid system that led him to even saying he should've just learned theory.point is, i don't think he ever learned how to drum or sit properly and has been winging it until he just completely fucked his shit up
>>129783196>drop D>0-3-5 chuggingthat's the whole tool discography
>>129806580the steroid is bad but dude especially aged like shit since post-2007 reunion because the drinking which came from his divorce and he only got properly sober just 2 years ago.
>>129783196Dire, just a miserable auditory experience, truly terrible in every way.
Watching fairly attractive 30-something woman reacting to prog
>>129783196shitty, non-prog, pseudo-gnostic buttmetal garbage
>>129812460>Dishonest iconography>Post-gender chord progressions>Proto-Slysoy Disenfranchisement peddled as Incel entertainment/Beta Powerplay>Barking indefinite hipster choruses>Neo /v/eddit hangups: meme lyrics̶>̶M̶e̶t̶a̶-̶Q̶u̶i̶p̶ ̶s̶y̶n̶d̶r̶o̶m̶e̶ ̶>Post-Capeshit bridge transitions>Stoicism as social currency inverted through solipsistic RYM fetish>Effeminate pacing
>>129812539
>>129807130I miss this period of fashion for 60s bands.
>>129808939Traffic is a lamer version of Family. https://youtu.be/8cJAB7Wk8y8?si=D6x6Etez-PquoC1x
>>129814872old good new bad
>>129814872Family didn't have Steve Winwood aka realest wigga singer in british music
how did we all feel about the new ye?
>>129815733>yethe ban?
>>129815750took me a while but i got it
>>129815750>>ye>the ban?i'm sorry, the wh?
All 70s King Crimson albums (except In The Wake of Poseidon) are better than any non-70s King Crimson album.
>>129816132their 3 best albums were not in the 70s though...
>>129816132I'm not falling for the bait U_U
Prog for having to go work in the morning while hungover, and only looking forward to more alcohol when the shift is over because you're so alone and have no one?
>>129817126yeah... that just sounds like prog.
>>129817126THEY CALL ME A WORKING MANI GUESS THAT'S WHAT I AM
Random thought of the day: Insane how all important Genesis members are still alive today
HOLY SHIT PETER GABRIEL WAS IN GENESIS? I haven't heard them but I assumed it was Phil Collins and random session musicians
>>129817994They were really young when they started. Most of the iconic prog musicians of the 70s were all in their mid to late 20s when they broke out and had been honing their chops in and out of bands since the early 60s. Genesis came right out of boarding school and were literally teenagers when they cut their first record, and even when Collins and Hackett came in they were in the same age range.
>>129818084Yeah but the odds all of them still got to reach mid 70s of age is still pretty small even though old Collins is at the death's door nowadays.
what's the best avant-prog band
>>129818380my band
I like Renaissance but I can only listen to Annie Haslam's droning non-rhotic singing for so long before it becomes tiresome.
>>129819673don't shit talk anniebut also her approach to singing on the failed 80s pop albums is interesting cause it doesn't fit at all
>>129818380magma
>>129819693Not that she doesn't have a pretty voice, but I just think it gets old after a while
>>129819673Fuck you. Now I'm going to notice this every time I listen to Renaissance. >>129819693Bonjour Swansong is their best song btw.
>>129818380Embryo
Tool mogged prog and metal
>>129819964>Bonjour Swansongthat's a decent choice. a lot of their 80s stuff constantly is on the brink of being great, but they actually somehow struggle with playing stuff simple. jekyll and hyde is my favorite stab at pop from them
I just don't seem to be able to get into King Crimson or Yes without having at least some reservations. Their songs just have too many random batshit dissonant sections, so even if I like some stuff I can't say the full package actually sounds that good. It feels really different calling those prog vs. calling Rush or Pink Floyd "prog".
>>129820959>It feels really different calling those prog vs. calling Rush or Pink Floyd "prog".well that's because rush and pink floyd are not prog
Rush is literally just Diet Yes
>>129820166tranny opinion
>>129820959Yes is too poppy and conventional to be put alongside King Crimson in terms of dissonant and weird stuff
King Crimson is the only prog band.
What's some good fantasy prog for playing medieval RPGs?
>>129821741King Crimson
>>129821741Gryphon - Red Queen to Gryphon ThreeAnthony Phillips - The Geese and the Ghost
>>129821628Rush would probably agree with youhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i-7FdSUQONU
wo he mad
>>129780567The only peter gabriel song I like is My Body Is A Cage but to be fair I haven't listened to many of his songs
>>129824216I like Red Rain
>>129821689Beware of fusion in prog drag
>>129821689>In Robert Fripp's opinion, once "progressive rock" ceased to cover new ground – becoming a set of conventions to be repeated and imitated – the genre's premise had ceased to be "progressive".He's right, you know.
>>129826178Once a "genre" has a name it's already over
For the longest time I thought those were testicles
>>129826219there should be more prog rock without guitars
>>129826219saying they aren't testicles is like saying georgia o'keeffe didn't paint vaginas
>>129826453well said, i was looking for a way
>>129826437ELP
>>129783196"prog" for people that dont actually like proglike Rush, Marillion, Porcupine shit and Opeth
>>129826644what "prog" is for people who actually like prog
>>129826658All the super obscure, esoteric and cool bands I like that your pleb ass has never heard of, of course
>>129826928So, King Crimson
>>129826658king crimson (1969-1974 only)Banco (1972-1976)Soft machine (1969-1971)Pink Floyd (1969-1971)Genesis (1970-1974)just to name a few examplesamericans cant make progand prog died in europe circa 1978
>>129826658shit like symphonic prog
It will always be really funny when some prog metal fan or any other flavour of cringe just sees the OP and posts shit like Tool because they refuse to read the room.
It will always be really funny when some Yes fan or any other flavour of cringe just sees the OP and posts anything but King Crimson because they refuse to read the room.
It will always be really funny when some King Crimson fan or any other flavour of cringe just sees the OP and posts anything but Magma because they refuse to read the room.
It will always be funny when someone posts anything in these threads
>when you realize peter hammill is probably the most influential and imitated vocalist in all of rock and metal
>>129826936Imagine thinking thinking Wind & Wuthering is not prog.
For me it's midwestern pomp rock.
>>129827253It's synthpop actually
prog was always pop
>>129780821Japan is shit and everything it touches turns to shit. They ruined my boy Gary Numan
>>129797184I did this with Italian prog in undergrad. It was a freshman seminar for a history of horror films class, and our group was assigned Suspiria, so I played a bunch of PFM for Italian prog context for everybody in our presentation. Shit was cash
>>129827142holy shit. are you right? i can't think of anybody with that shrill shrieking voice before him.
GOODBYE MARYGOODBYE JANE
>>129827341Rob Halford’s vocals on the early Priest albums definitely owe a lot to VDGG. The resemblance is almost uncanny at times.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hkty_aj_ep0
I still don't "get" VDGG, but Man Erg is a pretty good song
>>129827341>>129827491He was a big influence on John Lydon, who cited this album in particular
>>129826219House With No Door is literally about me
>>129826936>and prog died in europe circa 1978only standard Prog Rock, but avant-prog bands like Univers Zero and Art Zoyd continued throughout the 80s and 90s
NuRush just made their live debuthttps://youtu.be/kVw-4L59Tw0?si=9nshS4Kwa-gRUqYM
>>129826581Doesn't Emerson play guitar on most of the albums though.
Crazy to think that Keith Relf and Jim McCarty went straight from this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RfCT56z0UVA to this https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zrkk6nCDIgQ
>>129828426Think it was Greg Lake and only on a few tracks.
wtf are these guys yapping about
I'm cleaning up my prog playlist and I can't decide if I should keep the 2021 remasters of VDGG's discography or the 2005 remasters. '21 sounds cleaner but the organ is quieter, it's particularly notable in The Sleepwalkers and it's driving me nuts
>>129828972You literally can't tell the difference
>>129828980I have some cheap gaming headphones and I do notice, it's not some audiophile LARP
>>129829019Sure you do, don't forget your gold plated cables to remove electrical infetterence
Wait, the Frippster was in VDGG?
>>129830195He played on a track or two. That's it.
>>129828242only good avant-prog is Henry Cow and its related projects
>>129831552Henry Cow is literally just shitty jazz
>>129830568so was he technically in VDGG or not?
>>129832637Van Der Fripp
>>129828273I like this solo more.https://youtu.be/O5_rwkCGKN4?t=94
vander fripp
>surname is literally synonymous with nonsense, triviality and bullshitPoetic
>>129832998>disrespecting frippbanned
>peter seinfeld wrote the lyrics>greg lake did the beautiful vocals and keyboard>some other fags did the drumming and keyboardsFrippy contributed literally nothing
Fripp played the guitar on the title track https://youtu.be/c9OVs1muwZI?is=rGbSu3rC55Sm2c-r
>>129833925So guitar is not important now?
>>129833993They're not Floyd, no one gives a shit about guitar with KC
>>129826936>americans cant make progummm no sweetiehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hoo72BGB4KE
>>129832966
>>129833963a stain in his discography
>>129834178sussy amogus
>>129833925It's more like>Greg considered he wrote the main melody of "in the court" and Ian did the rest>I talk to the wind was mostly Ian's >Epitaph was a group effort that was developed after a Greg Lake idea>Moonchild music was Fripp>Schizoid was mostly Fripp with the exception of the opening riff >And of course Sinfield wrote all the lyricsbut in Fripps own words everyone was deeply involved in the creative process, and everyone contributed to the other's ideas. So much so that Giles gets credits in every song because he designed tempo, moods and silences an example of this is that he was the one that came up with playing the break in the middle of Schizoid in unison
FFS (Fripp fuckin' sucks)>muh dissonance>muh atonal shit
>>129826581
>>129826658Asia
>>129835062>Hey guys I brought my tarkus, hope that's ok
>>129835366that one photo with bros
>>129832637Not. He was a guest musician.
catholic prog?
Eastern Orthodox Prog?
Coptic prog?
Baháʼí prog?
>>129835007>moonchild was frippAs if you needed any more reason to hate that faggot
>>129836902>anons are still getting filtered by moonchild in this two thousand and twenty sixth year of our lord*taps the sign*
>>129806619Maybe his butt hurts
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bu7QB-F-HMc
>>129828273This is even worse than I was expecting
Fucking hell I've been going through this Magma live album and they sound way heavier and intense here than in most of the rest of their discography, they just fucking rip and shred through Kohntarkosz, Theusz Hamtaahk and Mekanik Destruktiw Kommandoh here. There's a 30 minute drum solo that's surprisingly not boring, and the guitar solo in MDK doesn't sound like it belong 1974.There's a lot of focus on guitar here that's very uncharacteristic of Magma.
Peanuts King Crimsonhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KM-o6C_ZOpQ
>>129835062Sporkier than I remember
going to see justin hayward tomorrow i hope he plays "Land of Make Believe" or "Voices in the Sky" or "The Actor"
Peter Seinfeld be like>Whats the deal with cat food??
>>129838970It's about what I was expecting. Geddy's voice is worse, but they have more energy than I thought. I'm disappointed there isn't a foot cam for the drummer.
>>129840755I'll go out on a limb and say he plays Nights in White Satin.
>>129841855The drummer is a lot less technical and showy than I expected. Granted it's far from their most showy song drum-wise.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p00e7r7VBN4
>>129836902Trvke
>>129839613you're a schizoid man, charlie brown
>>129783196I don't listen to diaperfags.
>It Bites Marillion on the Twelfth Night of Rush>They all tried, but bitterly failed in replacing GenesisI might've found more embarrassing lyrics than Barclay James Harvest's worst excesseshttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dx2yl9wFjFw&t=2815s
>>129833963Best Prog EP
>>129846040but who was bass
>>129845660That's not Spot The Pigeon.
>>129846046Some Guy
>>129846085Many such caseshttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W3gowJEDSFo
If I had to choose, I'd rather listen to Le Orme's non-70s discography than their 70s discography.
>>129846040Tony
>>129835685Le Orme - Il Fiumehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QcgTGnhh27EIt has the Venice Gospel Ensemble sing on a couple tracks. The only thing that would make it more Catholic is if Tony Pagliuca was on it (he later collaborated with the Pope on the 2015 album "Wake Up")
I love this footagehttps://youtu.be/8qMsr7jjQF0?si=jg-B_3qUugAl9EqQ
>See me a big woman big woman>So full of life>See me a big woman big woman>Gonna be my wifeI didn't realize Peter was an architect
Listening to UK
>>129849744Naturally such listening will morph into ASIA appreciation.
>>129849744danger cunny
>>129849825where have those hands been john...
>>129840755>no actorWhy even fucking live anymore
>>129849921Sorry m8
That kinda vibe
>>129849921Did you get Nights in White Satin?
is king grizzard prog
Drinking buckets of tea and blasting Bankstatement on a grey afternoon is a vibe man.
>>129851092they suck so yeah probaby
>>129851092King Crimson, King Gizzard, King Diamond, King's X and B. B. King are prog
>>129851092oh my science
>>129851092yes
New Robert and Toyah message for April Foolshttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=le8zXRUiFiA
>>129852207
>>129852207Fripp was physically incapable of selling out his own music so the closest he could get was marrying a pop star.
Normalfags: if i had a time machine i would go to woodstockMe: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o3e3w48rZrw
>>129854565>daryl stuermer>chester thompsonliterally who
>>129854565>Six of the Best>Tony Bankscome on...
>>129855725Yeah, he's five of them
>>1298546492 of the best.What Phil did to Chester is sad. Actuslly worse than what Fripp did to Belew.
>>129856205>What Phil did to Chester is sad.Stop hiring him?
>>129854565>finally found out what the title means
>>129854565>Milton Keynes Concert Bowllmao
>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q8zbkqtbG8U&t=1038s
>>129858301gimme the qrd
>>129851092They're part of that psych jam band class that is prog-lite at least.
>>129851092sure, why not?>>129858861
Tool simply mogged them all, sad but true
I need new prog recs. I feel like I have listened to everything.
>>129801683why do you need more than 3 instruments when you are only there for the drums in the first place?
>>129859011>The name "Milton Keynes" was a reuse of the name of one of the original historic villages in the designated area,[42] now more generally known as "Milton Keynes Village" to distinguish it from the modern settlement. A century after the Norman invasion, the manor transferred by marriage to Hugh de Kaynes,[43] whose family held it to the late 13th century (as well as others in the country – Ashton Keynes in Wiltshire, Somerford Keynes in Gloucestershire, and Horsted Keynes in West Sussex).[43] The village was originally known as Middeltone (11th century); then later as Middelton Kaynes or Caynes (13th century); Milton Keynes (15th century); and Milton alias Middelton Gaynes (17th century).[43]
john barleycorn must die
>>129860951british gibberish
>>129864559but enough about genesis
Reminder that the best prog song of the last 5 years was made by Foo Fightershttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6MF6trC529M
>>129780123Relistening after a weekend booze bender. Feeling lost. >>129839613>>129844018>The Bloody Crimson Baron was rollin' up the score
>>129839613i mean listen to that. no wonder Jimi Hendrix would be jumping from joy, baffled at the brand new best band in the world... shame he couldn't be around for prog. (and metal...)
>>129860951Milton Keynes? More like Middleton GAYNES
>>129860653https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HM-LY8q9t4ALocanda Delle Fate. Probably the last Italian album released in the 70s worth a damn.The first two tracks are 10/10 kino. The album admittedly falls off after that, but still worthwhile.
>>129864559Yeah, that's prog in general.
>>129864798i'm sorry
Marillion is really, really cringe
>>129797184>when you remember the time you played tubular bells at a dinner party as a kid and scared your relatives
>>129867363That's how you know it's prog
>>129867363yes. they're a song band and not an album band. they're too pop for prog and too prog for only the biggest of retards. i still like them.
>>129870037Clutching at Straws and Brave have no skips
>>129827325Sadistic Mika is good
>>129870037I think the entirety of Holiday in Eden is great. But don't exactly take my word for it. I'm having an allergy attack and cannot stop sneezing irl .
>mfw hergest ridge
/prog/bros how do we cope with being continually BTFO'd by Senkochad day after day?
>>129871491Why do you care about that spamming tranny
>>129806580Ithought he had a botched spinal surgery and that's what fucked him up.
>>129871491I have no idea what that means
>>129871491I listen to Tony Banks as the closest sage to Mahler.
I THINK TUBULAR BELLS PART 2 THE SONG SUCKS
>>129874299opening guitar noodling and caveman make up for it. it's a lot lower energy than part 1 thoughhergest ridge >>>
