Was Scaruffi right?
Old Ramon is the best rhp album
The Smiths were only good as a singles band.
>>129843732Nah. Meat Is Murder is an 8, The Queen Is Dead is a 9, and nothing Panera bro ever did is above a 4.
>>129843732I would give TQID a 7.5 but otherwise pretty accurate
>>129843822how so?
If i had a pastrami sandwich would i let morrissey hold onto it fuck no.
>>129843732the smiths is literally backwards
>>129843732I'm 100% convinced Scaruffi just wrote a script that gives the early albums of any band the highest scores, even when it makes no fucking sense (like when he gives that shitty metal band Peter Steele was in 8 or 9, I think Carnivore was the name)
>>129843732I never got RHP wank. But the Smith's ratings are relatively correct.
>>129844811you're really gonna diss my boi Morrissey like that
>>129843732The nigga gave Korn and Limp Bizkit 7's. Why do you care about his opinions.
>>129845105>(like when he gives that shitty metal band Peter Steele was in 8 or 9, I think Carnivore was the name)Type O Negative. Scaruffi literally just recently bumped it down from a 9 to an 8 lol.
>>129843732somewhat.but i dont listen to the opinions of non - instrumentalists
>>129843732Absolutely correct. Mark Kozelek is who Morrissey could have been if he didn't steal his mother's undergarments to try on as a boy.
>>129845105Scaruffi's scores strongly favor experimentation so for a lot of bands that's gonna be their debut
>>129845147I genuinely don't know if you mean their scores should be higher or lower
>>129845236Anything that isn't a fucking 0/10 for either of those bands shouldn't be taken seriously
>>129843732Nah those Smiths ratings are way too high
>>129845263why? I don't really care for nu-metal but they were the sound of a generation and fairly fresh at the timealso, Wes Borland is an extremely underrated guitarist
>>129845288You sound like a bitch redditor. To cowardly to form actual opinions, lol.
>>129845294I gave you my opinion though lolclassic tourist that doesn't know what to say beyond buzzwords and memes
>>129845153It seems like it's gone now, but I remember he also scored the first band Steele was in (Carnivore) in the page for Type O Negative, and it gave them an absurdly high score. I remember checking it out and it was just mediocre run of the mill trash metal
>>129845537not to play devil's advocate but maybe it was just a formatting issue and that score was meant for Slow Deep and HardI mean, Scaruffi isn't exactly known for giving scores that are too high lol
>>129845147he gave 8 for Guns N Roses and Alanis Morissette lmao
>>129845537Wtf, I tried to look it up on Wayback Machine but that page has been "excluded" from the archive. But if you google around you'll see other people talk about the review and apparently how he called the Carnivote s/t "the greatest metal album of all time."What the hell cover up is going on?
Absolutely. Lord Kill the Pain is better (and funnier) than anything Morrissey ever wrote and it's widely considered the weakest song on the album.
>>129843732No, as someone who appreciates singers who can actually sing, Kozelek's voice badly needed autotune before autotune existed. Fucking awful vocalist, and Morrissey's voice is beautiful, an instrument itself
hes gonna die soon isnt he?
>>129845212Always tell people on here that if an artist gets like a 6.5-7, it's a good score for Scaruffi standards and it's most likely going to be their best work
>>129845147>>129845682Scaruffi is absolutely correct on all of these.
>>129848823lollmao even
>>129845682>>129845147>>1298491587s and 8s?Thats way too generous and you fags are complaining?I would have given them 5s 6s at most.
>>129849158It’s Chadcore, you wouldn’t get it
>>129843732nah he's a meme
