Is prog punk even a thing?
>>129968509Pink Floyd in their "Classic" era
>>129968509You could say some the earliest punk bands were progressive because no one had any expectations for them to all sound like the Ramones or Sex Pistols yet. You could trace that part back to the Velvets, then Bowie and Roxy Music. I guess it's artrock than progrock per se.
I don't know how you can pretend to try and pretend to not try at the same time like that but I'm sure someone pretended to do that
>>129968509Yes.
One of the few good punk albums
Anything "punk" in the genre is an automatic garbage, stupid worthless music.
Yes. Source: The Stranglers - Down in the Sewers, Magazine - Motorcafd, Melt era Peter Gabriel
>>129968509
>>129968509Ruins are probably the most well known/earliest thing thing that could be considered "progressive punk"; Their philosophy was combining the intensity of hardcore punk with the complex structures of bands like Gentle Giant and Magma.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MMrSOdvWdr8Technically a lot of the "brutal prog" genre could be considered prog punk in a way.
A MURMUR
>>129968509this counts i thinkhttps://youtu.be/KQ8mRPIC8Y4?si=DnbQ1i9VuFk3v28J
>>129969834And speaking of Ruins, they recently uploaded thishttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VJ9MMaGeShE
>>129968509Deep turtle
>>129968509Television - Marquee Moon is basically prog punk but they call it "post punk"
>>129968618gay, retarded band>>129969601good bandboth aren't prog punk though. you're thinking of The Cardiacs.>>129969865this probably qualifies in the hardcore punk sense>>129969834this too
>>129970712would Volta's debut album qualify?https://youtu.be/f4ntjKcRh8w?si=-0cc-d8QpqGofqxb
>>129970712Cardiacs are probably the best answer>>129971512I think so, at the drive-in was definitely punk, and they're progressive, so
>>129971563In turn pic related inspired atdi and they qualify i'm my opinion
>>129971653What about Slint? I've never really understood them being commonly classified as post-rock when they really don't sound like any other bands of the genre.
I played in a band that couldve fallen under that label, sorta.Someone kept calling us party-prog, but idk.https://hapl0id.bandcamp.com/album/free-time
>>129970500this
>>129968595What about stuff like The Cure? It was goth shit but really punk
for me it's Paintbox.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2tUBfCjI_OA
>>129971667I'd say barely but yeah
>>129970712suck my dick stupid faggot, propaghandi are good, you have shit taste btw
>>129968509Yes. Unironic Prog Punk Rock song btw im not even fucking kidding:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u32GKcxFIOU
>>129968509>post-hardcoe
NomeansnoPigment VehicleMexican Power AuthorityAll has some proggy momentsIf you're also including hardcore, then Converge, Deadguy and probably Man Is The Bastard
>>129968509ehh?https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XMwwJkXWz9galso?https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b6cwzYbr_XI
>>129968509No. Those are two genres on opposite sides of the spectrum.Simple as.
>>129969879this is super sick, no idea how I've made it this far without hearing this. thx anon
>>129968509This album blends prog with punk with flamenco and no other record has been able to replicate it.
>>129968509Cardiacs obviously
>does non-musical music exist?what a retarded question
