>the list is literally just black people
>Dipshit critic responding to critic "work"Holy fuck who cares. Forge your own opinions.
>>130148947>literallyYou sure anon? If I go through the list I won't see a single non-black person? I'm gonna be really mad if you lie to me, anon.
>>130148947Whites can't create art, only midwits think they're better than PoC.
>>130148947Ah yes >Bob Dylan>Carole King >Willie Nelson >Bruce Springsteen >Paul Simon >Taylor Swift >Fucking LANA DEL RAY My favorite black artists, personally.
>>130148947wtf earlier before i went to work you guys were complaining that he only said black people make good art, now I'm at lunch and you guys are complaining that he doesn't think only black people make good art. What will it be when i come home at night?
>>130148947Anthony cheated on his black wife why does he act like this
He makes these thumbnails because its ragebait for /mu/. The list has no shortage of lame ass white bands
>>130149036>only midwits think they're better than PoC>"based" 4chan slang immediately followed by NWO newspeakexquisite bait
>>130148947he is just virtue signaling
>>130149118Only Jews can make good art
>>130149036>Leancel seething all over the board that the washed up fuck is being shat on
I don't care about the opinion of a bunch of idiots that stopped composing or playing instruments beautifully. They gave up on melody willingly for retarded beats. Let them dwell in their manchild beats all the way to jail then death. They stopped creating content of value to mass produce mediocrity.
>>130148947Fagtano has probably given blowjobs to each and everyone of those "songwriters".
>>130149430only fantano hates it for being white art
>>130149799Hating that nepo baby yung lean isn't that strange of an opinion
>>130148947Americaca
>>130149491I'm asking genuinely, do you just listen to classical?not saying you have to listen to beats just"that stopped composing or playing instruments beautifully" can apply to non-classical from the last 70 yearsI swear every classicalfag on here is a snob so I'm hoping you're not one
>>130149036Say what you will about Fantano, but when push comes to shove, he's down for the cause.
Jay Z one of our great songwriters
>>130151168It mogs reggaeton
>>130148947fantano is going the way of p4k, copying the topical slop formula of penguinz0, ragebaiting because the novelty has faded from his shitty reviews, he has outlived his own role in music discussion
holy shit, where tf is Lou Reed? Not just that how come this is so 21st century front loaded? We all know for a fact the best songwriters are not the modern ones. Could literally take out all but 3 of those blacks, they didn't even include some of the actually worthwhile ones like idk Jimi Hendrix or Prince. If they had any sense Tim Buckley and John Fahey would be on there
>>130149062are you seriously defending the list when you practically listed the only non black ones, let alone the only ones that are possibly worthwhile songwriters (sans taylor and lana)
>>130149201complete dishonesty, it absolutely has a surplus of cringe rappers
>>130155388oh i missed living, but still
Can this bald faggot get a rape accusation already? I'm tired of googling an album only for the top video recommended be one of his shitty reviews with him making an obnoxious face in the thumbnail.
>>130148947Fuck off and kys fantano faggot
Inspiring stuff, Kendrick is such a good artisté, how does he do this stuff. In 10 years hip hop albums are going to have 5 minute long film style credits and the instrumental is going be the same crunchy shitty 4/4 beat that you've heard 12 billion times before.
If you stop paying attention to nigger shit such as this bald faggot and Jew York Times shit, they lose their power, just stop caring.
>>130151240Nta but "just classical" always sounds so funny to me when that could mean 200 or more years of dozens of very different genres, forms, styles, instruments, etc.
There were quite a few eye rolls in that list, but Mariah Carey is beyond comical.
>>130155402He's still alive?
>>130153098by cause i think you mean ballwashing every black person in sight right? what makes even funnier is that lack twitter fucking loathes him.
>>130155392No. I didn't defend the list. I was just calling out the OP for being disingenuous. It is literally not "all black artists" The list has fucking Young Thug on it. Obviously it's not a great one.
>>130149417louder for everyone in back
>new york times
>>130157404who do you think posts the talentless hacks threads
>>1301490623 of those are jews
>Taylor Swift>Jay Z>Mariah Carrey>Kendrick Lamar>Bob Dylan>Lana Del Rey>Bad Bunny None of these people are prestigious writers. There are like three worthwhile mentions in the list, but most of this shit is just your average consumer slop. There are hundreds of living songwriters who deserve to be on such a list. Not fucking surprised though.
I don't listen to any hip-hop at all but one of my most controversial takes is I do think black people and women are actually somehow inherently better than men at making music, on average. I have never found a single person who agrees with me on this.Black people are somehow better at rhythm and women are somehow better at more novel structures. On average. Of course many white men are also excellent at both, though, and some of the best of all time were/are white men. I am only referring to distributions/probabilities/averages.
>>130148947white men try not to rank things challenge (impossible)
>>130164476True if you're referring exclusively to transfems
>>130164476Oh you know non of your wpop whores actually write and produce their own songs right?
>>130162290You're a pretentious asshole if you don't think Dylan is one of the best songwriters of all time
>>130149008But you're not going to get through the list, are you?
