Wong Kim Arks parents were "Permanent Residents" who were "Domiciled" in San Francisco and held "Allegiance" to the United States of America when they gave birth to Wong Kim Ark. They were not Temporary Visa Holders/Sojourners/Workers, nor were they Illegal Migrants.To be protected under the 14th Amendment you need more than to be "subject to the laws of the united states" as was determined in Elk v. Wilkins (1884) where it was ruled that one must be "completely subject to the united states political jurisdiction" and "owing them (the united states) direct and immediate allegiance."This was later reaffirmed in 1898 with United Sates v. Wong Kim Ark in which the word "Domicile" was used 28 times, and the word "Allegiance" was used 114 times.
Senator Williams further expanded upon this as the 14th was being written where he specifically mentions that being subject to the laws of the United States by merely being within its borders was NOT ENOUGH to qualify for Birthright Citizenship.Illegal Aliens by their very existence are NOT eligible for "Permanent Domicile" within the United States as their very person is subject to removal and deportation at any time and they are not legally allowed residency within any state in the republic.Temporary Visa holders as its very name suggests are Temporary Sojourners/Workers who still owe "allegiance" to whatever nation state they were originally born in.
>>532229038Okay, but what does "permanent resident" mean in the time frame of of Wong Kim Ark? Was there like an actual process Chinese people had to go through to get into California or did they just show up? Because plenty of illegal Mexicans have long-term "domiciles" all over America.
>>532229532>Parents migrated before the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882>Chinese nationals could generally enter the U.S. without numerical quotas or strict visa requirements>Thus legally in the country>15+ years in the country, business owners, fixed address for the most partThat was basically enough to be "domiciled", but not citizens themselves (that was then reserved for "free" Whites only).
>>532229038False. If you steal someones wallet in Japan they will arrest you. So obviously birthright citizenship is constitutional.
>>532229532Domicile = Lawful presence with the intention to stay permanently. An illegal migrant who by very definition of his immigration status is subject to deportation the moment he is caught by immigration enforcement CANNOT ever reach the legal definition of "domicile"
