[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/pol/ - Politically Incorrect


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 386938692.png (928 KB, 1080x1452)
928 KB PNG
It's a Religion. One with a lot of Khazars and Browns. Do not fall for the "ethnoreligious group" psyop. This is newspaper. Ethnicity is a synonym for Race, and Jewish is not a Race, it is a religion with mostly Khazars and Browns.
>>
>>534163978
Newspeak* not newspaper
>>
File: mpv-shot0129.jpg (118 KB, 1920x1080)
118 KB JPG
>>534163978
I converted to nigger worship and became racially American though
>>
>>534163978
lets see his earlobes
>>
File: 1772649584533071.png (180 KB, 450x470)
180 KB PNG
>>534163987
>Newspeak
nigger they've been claiming to be both a religion and a race gaining the privileges and protections of both for at least 100 years, wtf you mean "newspeak"
are you just getting around to the charleston or something
have you heard about this "jazz" thing yet
>>
Jews are a fake race not rooted in biological reality but in occult metaphysics. Kabbalists believe that Jews have a fragment of a divine soul, which expresses itself in the DNA according to the Lubavitcher Rebbe, and the soul of a convert is transformed to include one such divine fragment. Obviously conversion does not change your genes, Jews are insane.
>>
>>534164035
>mutt race hammerhead with big tits
>>
>>534163978
>>
Everyone practising Judaism is a volunteer. Legally all members of a genocidal organisation are equally personally guilty of every single act and consequence of that genocide. No member if a genocidal organisation has any human rights, they may not for example own anything. Non of them are entitled to a trial either under existing international law. The group is deemed genocidal and all the members may expect at most is a tribunal to assess membership & identity, though they have no legal entitlement to even that.
>>
>>534163978
if your mother isn't jewish you are not a jew, no you cannot convert to judaism.
>>
>>534163978
why don't they ever roll up the flags instead of making them look like tablecloth?
>>
File: 1773823107031079.png (435 KB, 1024x1017)
435 KB PNG
>>534163978
Judaism is a religion, and the core ritual to their faith is cutting up baby dick. See how quickly the "ethnoreligious" shit holds up when the RITUAL nature of the tribe is made crystal clear and threatened directly.
>>
>>534164179
Addendum: As a personal theory, this assumed divine spark which is supposedly unique to Jews and elevates them to godhood compared to gentile insects must be the reason why Jewish publications keep advancing the narrative that Jews across the world have more in common with each other than with other races.
>>
>>534164189
That would be so cool, but how many of these corpses died to starvation due to weeks of neglect by the Soviets after "liberation"? Probably the majority. It is surprising how little solid evidence exists for a massive industrialised genocide of millions of people. So much of it can be rationalised away with other factors.
>>
>>534164179
Blood .. ... ........ is thicker than water. .. .......
>>
>>534164214
>you cannot convert to judaism.
Tell that Trump and Elon
>>
File: melting-pot (1).png (442 KB, 888x773)
442 KB PNG
>>534163978
>>534163978
>im jewish, im british
they never assimilate & form a staste within a state, enjoying the rights of the host nation & the priviliges that being a jew gives them.
>so things go south in goyim nation, i just fuck off to israel bye lol or move to my uncles place in another country.
>>
>>534164381
they are not jews, that is akin to being trans, you can cut off your balls and glue on tits but you are not a woman, likewise if your mother is not a jew, you are not jewish, wearing jewish skin does not make you a jew im sorry but its just reality.
>>
>>534163978
Jew-ish
Time you anglo rune types got it right
Jew = betrayer
Jewish (goy) = mutt or brown
Fondle my balls please
>>
>>534163978
There are people with Jewish phenotype so yes jew is an ethnicity. You can even DNA test for it.
>>
File: 1710951808884256.jpg (95 KB, 1024x570)
95 KB JPG
>>534163978
>normalize diverse multicultural societies
>browns have 2 passports
>no one finds this double nationality odd
>jews able to blend in just fine.
>>
>>534163978
shut up you stupid nigger. if I can spot jews via their facial features then obviously they are their own race. the goblin jew race.
>>
>>534163978
>Nothing will stop me
Except a knife peeling the skin off of your head and cutting out your dirty jewish heart
>>
>>534164187
hot
>>
>>534163978
There Is only Judaism

Which is Religion!

You can become Israelis
same
as
You can become American (USA citizen)

Judaism is just RELIGION!

Nothing more Nothing Less!
otherwise
they would name state as
JUDEA not Israel!

They making fun of you and you buying into
Antisemitism
because non of you Understand basics!!!

Semite means ARAB as Canaanites (Israeli)
was Arab tribe(SEMITE)

Whole nation stop exist 350 AD

Today Israelis are mostly Germans Poles and western Ukrainians!

Therefore Israelis are not Nation state but They are Immigrant state Same as USA!!!

Language was not used 1800 years as such you have to understand that No nation can exist without Language !
Language was revived artificially back in 1890 but no one use it until 1945!

No historical Nation just Modern state!!!

That is it!!!
>>
>>534163978
Nice flag kikelstein. Who do you think you are fooling you little rat?
>>
>>534163978
Ethnicity isn't a synonym for race, race is biological and ethnicity is cultural. It isn't rocket science nigger.
>>
File: image-asset.gif (992 KB, 490x319)
992 KB GIF
>>534164035
Disgusting
>>
>>534163978
The last 1000 days are upon them
>>
File: 1567346356671.gif (2 MB, 500x281)
2 MB GIF
>>534163978
>Nothing will stop me
>Bullet: Is that so?
>>
>>534164214
>>534164449
you're a liar
none of that retarded shit in the OT
>>
>>534163978
"Judaism" is an organized crime racket, not a religion.
>>
>>534166492
Jews don't follow the Old Testament.
>>
>>534163987
You are retarded or dishonest.
Jew is both genetic disease(genes/race) AND religion, as pilpul users prefer it this arguably convoluted way.
Jews hate transparency.
>>
File: israeli memeflags.png (340 KB, 779x598)
340 KB PNG
>>534163978
>>534163987
k Mr. "Nazi".
Ethnoreligion it is.
>>
>>534163978
It's a group that doesn't stand up for any that tolerate them enough to live amongst them.
Jews are their own worst enemy.
They need to give up and focus on defense instead of attacking all goyim at once inside their home nations... Lest the tables turn on them during global depression.
>>
>>534166585
They do when it is convenient or suits them. For all other things they have the talmud and their commentaries on commentaries of exegesis commentaries.
>534166492
Sure thing memeflaggot
>>
>>534166032
>Ethnicity isn't a synonym for race
In the meaning of ethnoreligious yes it is
You already exclude the cultural part from ethno when you combine it with -religious
>>
File: 109ed.jpg (98 KB, 680x676)
98 KB JPG
534166819
cool cool
>>
>>534163978
No they will never see you as one of them.
The will pretend to, but Judaism is an ethnicity in addition to a religion.
For a jew the non jew is not human, only an animal closely enough resembling them to better serve the jew.
>>
>>534165971
Who do YOU think you're fooling with your ad hominem flag insult? Do you realize there are more jews than anywhere else in the USA or that VPNs exist?
>>
>>534164557
99% of jews are low IQ brown jews (mizrahi,sephradi,ethiopian) that you wouldnt be able to recognize
actual jewish IQ average is very low
that's part of the reason the ashkenazi jews you're able to recognize want to claim it's a racial thing
they're just EMBARRASSED jews as a religion are mostly STUPID NIGGERS
>>
>>534163978
i genuinely don't understand why everyone focuses on the race thing so much which lets you get shot down immediately instead of going for the obvious religion angle that their book condemns us and shit, like obviously a jew baby isn't born evil it's the religion they get pushed into that does it
>>
>>534167435
>obviously a jew baby isn't born evil
It's born a jew and thus an enemy. Most of them are secular and don't give a single fuck about any religion.
>>
>>534166704
>pilpul users prefer it this arguably convoluted way.
>so i will affirm their newspeak term that allows them to deflect all criticism on unjustified racism
>>
>>534166492
i am absolutely not a liar if your mother is not a jew you are NOT jewish this is A FACT, you can cope and seethe however you want but it will not change that i am correct and you are not.
>>
Damn pol kikes really hate op's idea. SO MUCH kvetching and dishonests pilpuls in the comments. Thread will soon be slide'd
>>
File: 1000003958.png (67 KB, 585x340)
67 KB PNG
>>534167035
Arrr matey let's go loot the booty from the fedarrrral resaaaaarve
>>
>>534163978
It's both a race and religion with some overlap, and they both use the term interchangeably for their benefit. Calling the race Israeli and religion Jewish would solve everything but they'd have to be able to prove Israeli blood and they can't anymore since the tribes all intermingled or got with the Ishmaelites against God's command.
>>
>>534163978
Doesn't know about homonyms. This one just comes from a common history
>>
>>534166819
Ethnoreligious is when ethnicity and religion overlap, "ethno" doesn't lose the cultural meaning when combined with "religious". I fail to see how ethnicity means race when used in an "ethnoreligious" context. There's no biology in "ethnoreligious".
>>
>>534167951
that just means ethinicty is its own newspeak so the 'ethnoreligious' pilpul that kikes use is a SOUBLE newspeak term - it's a newspeak within newspeak
>>
>>534168071
You're just overwhelming yourself with your own retardation anon. Ethnoreligious is a descriptive compound, "ethnicity" isn't some recent word game and you're not refuting anything by calling it "newspeak".
>>
>>534168414
i'm deflecting your own retardation at you by refering to your own definitions of those words which indeed make no sense and only serve to obfuscate
do you even understand what newspeak means?
you're comiting newspeak by redefining old words that meant something so that they're more generalized and capable of hiding truth in that lack of nuance
>>
>>534163978
It's maternal lineage. So technically untrue unless you're talking about kids.
>>
>>534169222
I'm not redefining shit, you're just slow. These are all terms used in anthropology and they're fully coherent. Ethnicity refers to shared history, ancestry, traditions, language, religion..etc. Ethnoreligious is a descriptive compound used to emphasize religion as the central/pivotal element of an ethnicity. You'll never hear people calling gyppos "ethnoreligious" for example. And race is a biological descriptor categorization.

It's pretty easy to understand once you calm down and stop malding.
>>
>>534169624
>emphasize religion as the central/pivotal element of an ethnicity.
Ok cool. Now lets see your answer to these question
1. Are secular semites jews?
2. Are semites who believe in other religions than judaism jews?
>>
>>534163978
>i am jewish first and foremost living on your taxes goy
>please stop hating me fucking goy i hope you die tho
>>
>>534169624
Also
3. Are sephardi/mizrahi/ethopian people who believe in judaism jews?
>>
>>534169222
>Saars, do not redeem
Lol, LMAO even
>>
>>534170670
but jeets are the only people who dont dislike you kike
are you sure you want to throw away friendship of the only group that doesnt hate you?
>>
File: 1460499449304.jpg (76 KB, 850x400)
76 KB JPG
>>534163978
man creates god in his image & the wicked jew came up with an equally crooked god as himself.

Hitler being quoted in 'Bolshevism from Moses to Lenin', 1924:

“Character first, then religion, not the other way around! [...] Anyone, however, who has become acquainted with it has found out that what the Jews call their religion coincides exactly with their character. [...] A few hours spent browsing in the Talmud [...] is quite sufficient to remove any doubt about the Jews. It is understandable that they have only the most inordinate praise for the book. When they peep into it their own peculiar nature peers back out at them. And that, of course, is the greatest source of joy for them. Thus, in essence, every Jew is a Talmudist, even if he has never looked at the Talmud. It makes no difference when it was written; in fact, it needn't have been written at all. The first Jew comprised all its essential ingredients.”
_

Hitler wird zitiert in 'Bolschewismus von Moses bis Lenin', von Dietrich Eckart und Adolf Hitler, 1924:

„Zuerst das Wesen, dann die Religion; nicht umgekehrt! [...] Auf Schritt und Tritt gehen wir ihr nach und haben schon bei der ersten Bekanntschaft herausgefunden, daß das, was die Juden ihre Religion nennen, haargenau mit ihrem Charakter übereinstimmt. [...] Ein paar Stunden im Talmud gelesen [...] und über den Juden gibt's keinen Zweifel mehr. Daß die Hebräer das Buch in den Himmel heben, ist begreiflich. Wenn sie hineingucken, guckt ihnen ihr eigenes Wesen entgegen. Und daran müssen sie selbstverständlich die allergrösste Freude haben. So kommt es, daß jeder Jude Talmudist ist, auch wenn er den Talmud gar nicht kennt. Wann er niedergeschrieben wurde, spielt nicht die geringste Rolle. Er brauchte überhaupt nicht geschrieben worden zu sein; schon mit dem ersten Juden wäre er dagewesen.“
>>
>>534163978
It doesn't matter whether if it's a race or not, the important thing is that the only reason someone like that little british twat in your pic identifies as "jewish" is personal gain and exploitation of others. The faggot converted to reap the benefits, nothing else. The solution is to kill everything that identifies as a "jewish".
>>
>>534163978
jews can be granted israeli citizenship based on their jewish dna, ever heard of an test for your christian-genetics to be able to enter white nations?

“The Jewish State has never been delimited in space. It has been spread all over the world, without any frontiers whatsoever, and has always been constituted from the membership of one race exclusively. That is why the Jews have always formed a State within the State. One of the most ingenious tricks ever devised has been that of sailing the Jewish ship of state under the flag of religion and thus securing that tolerance which Aryans are always ready to grant to different religious faiths. The Mosaic Law is really nothing else than the doctrine of the preservation of the Jewish race and, therefore, includes all spheres of sociological, political and economic science which have a bearing on the main end in view.”

Adolf Hitler, Mein Kampf, 1925/26, Stalag Edition

german original:

„Der jüdische Staat war nie in sich räumlich begrenzt, sondern universell unbegrenzt auf den Raum, aber beschränkt auf die Zusammenfassung einer Rasse. Daher bildete dieses Volk auch immer einen Staat innerhalb der Staaten. Es gehört zu den genialsten Tricks, die jemals erfunden worden sind, diesen Staat als „Religion“ segeln zu lassen und ihn dadurch der Toleranz zu versichern, die der Arier dem religiösen Bekenntnis immer zuzubilligen bereit ist. Denn tatsächlich ist die mosaische Religion nichts anderes als eine Lehre der Erhaltung der jüdischen Rasse. Sie umfaßt daher auch nahezu alle soziologischen, politischen sowie wirtschaftlichen Wissensgebiete, die hierfür überhaupt nur in Frage zu kommen vermögen.“

Adolf Hitler, Mein Kampf, 1925/26
>>
>>534163978
>It is a religion with mostly browns
But enough about Christianity, Islam and Hinduism.
>>
File: race-jews-prop#ess.jpg (364 KB, 1524x870)
364 KB JPG
>>534163978
>>
File: Anti dog sentiment.mp4 (3.82 MB, 720x1280)
3.82 MB MP4
>>534163978
If jews are white then how come jews are not allowed to be hateful but have to behave christlike (be pro gay sex, female hypergwmy, race mixing)
>>
>>534170354
>>534169624
no answer
that's what i thought
you'd either be forced to admit op right or show everyone how you're still allowed freely to claim jews can mean anything even with your scientific correct definition of the word 'ethno-religious' (which btw is just one of many definitions according to kikepedia that contradict each other)
nice pilpul tho
thanks for playing
>>
>>534163978
Look at that nosejob.
>>
File: cryptojew.png (245 KB, 487x767)
245 KB PNG
>>534163978
pic rel memeflag retard
jews are not religion they are criminal group pretending to be religious one to avoid prosecution
>>
File: 1691707630410435.jpg (74 KB, 499x418)
74 KB JPG
>>534163978
fuck off, he'll always be a shabbos goy slave.
>>
File: IMG_6099.jpg (379 KB, 1284x1567)
379 KB JPG
>>534163978
Jews were kicked out twice and then invited back in by William of Orange to eat their central bank to place England under perpetual kike usury. Whenever I hears “muh antisemitism” ramp up in the Jew news I know they’re worried they’re losing the narrative like in picrel.
>>
>>534170354
>1
Semite isn't a religion, what is a secular semite?
>2
You can be a jew and not practice judaism, do you read? I told you what ethnicity is.
>>534171406
Calm down sperg, some people have lives.
>>
>>534171826
1. no answer
2. so religion isn't the central/pivotal element
yep that's what i thought
>Calm down sperg, some people have lives.
nah i think you just got embarrassed from being called out cause you replied immidately after my call out
anyway thank you for getting baited only to confirm my point
>>
>>534172129
1.You're the one not giving an answer. Are you asking if secular ethnic jews are jews? Yes they are, not engaging in the religion doesn't exclude you from the ethnicity. If you read what i said when i explained what ethnicity is you wouldn't be asking me this retarded shit.

2.Yes it is, it's the most influential element in defining some ethnicities.
>>
Lying rabbi, you need to have a Jewish mother to get Israeli citizenship which means it's biological which makes it racial. Jewishness is both a religion and a race. You like to make people think it's just a religion though.
>>
>>534172975
This is why i called you slow. You don't need a jewish mother to get citizenship, a jewish grandparent or spouse is enough. The matrilineal shit is religious law, and you can convert to judaism, so your narrative is pointless.

Also, i never said "it's just religion", are you handicapped? I just said in my previous message how belonging to an ethnicity isn't reliant on practicing a religion.
>>
>>534172458
Ok I think you might actually now be a jew but a very low IQ golem that has trouble following implications of my posts and how you're contradicting yourself.
Your point was that jews are an overlap of religious ethnicity, not just an ethnicity. Then you posted a definition that at word means the same in which you said "Ethnoreligious is a descriptive compound used to emphasize religion as the central/pivotal element of an ethnicity." Are you aware of scientific terms such as intersection? By your own words only semites who follow judaism can be jews bc of the need of overlap (requirament of judaism) and ephasis on judaism.
And now by answering my questions like this you're CONTRADICTING yourself directly. Now you're trying to claim ethnoreligious is not an intersection but an UNION. In other words that ethnireligious means race, culture, etc.., religion, + religion which is even more retarded and aids jews in their goal to deprive the word 'jew' of concise meaning.

You not only proved yourself to be a complete retard with 0 command on language but also that ultimately you argue in the favor of jews. I'm done schooling your dumbass because it becomes boring when your opponent is retarded or pretends to be retarded
>>
>>534163978
What matters:

Is this guy MIGA?
>>
>>534173669
Holy fuck anon, religion is part of ethnicity, ethnoreligious is just a term to emphasize the religion in that ethnicity, it is applicable to some ethnicities. I can't unretard you.
>>
>>534164714
This is what the Jews are doing to oursworld. Time to repay them in kind. Gassing Jews is a crimesagainst humanity not because of its cruelty towards the Jews, but because of its softness on them.
>>
>>534173893
and we established by your posts that emphasis has 0 meaning , relevance so jews as an ethnicity can mean anything - culture or religion or race etc
which allows 'religious jews' to use that to their advantage and switch meanings according to their needs - it's what makes it a newspeak term and it's clear your own interpretaion/definition of 'ethno-religious' is exact same shit
>>
>>534163978
If you’re not jewish today and commit a crime and try to escape to Israel but ask them to convert you first, they’ll tell you it’ll take years to convert. Whereas if you’re an atheist jew, you can murder somebody and escape to Israel like it’s nothing. jewish is NOT a religion.
>>
>>534164214
Also this. It’s a years-long process of sucking the rabbi off (likely literally too) and then they don’t fully accept you anyway.
>>
I am adoptin the jew mindset that the world is mine and here for my entertainment.
I am polytheistic.
Hail Hastur Odin Poseidon Set Pazuzu The Lady and The Terrenon Stone!
kill all jew
deport minorities inc mik wop feminist
import 14 yo slave girls
have king
king gives slave girls n castles to white male engineers
end immigration and trade
science n engineering research turbo financed n charged
women cook better than ever in history
flibe.com and greenarrays.com replace oil university media tek wall st mental health games movies net etc etc
small road circles replace red light
middle u turn lane replace overpass
trains
canals n brages
monorails
all free from king :)
no one else prints money or says bad things about white men or shoot in sight death
>>
>>534173444
that's different anon you stupid retard
>>
>>534163978
Why are the doing Jew recruitment now? Did the rabbis run our of foreskins?
>>
>>534163978
>Jewish is not a Race
Sure thing, Chaim
>>
>>534174472
I've already covered this exact thing, but you don't retain anything because you're clearly mentally stunted. These aren't my definitions, they're established definitions in anthropology and sociology. Read this fucking post where i've already explained what each thing means >>534169624

You can see how these terms mean specific things and not "anything" like you're suggesting. A message ago you still didn't know what "ethnoreligious" means even though i've explained it at the start of the conversation. It's impossible to have an argument with someone who doesn't understand the terms he's using.

It's always the ones talking about IQ, it never fails kek >>534167288
>>
>>534175371
Just to make it more concise for you stunted nigger, there aren't biological boundaries in the jewish ethnicity. Refute this and then i might keep responding to you, but you're fucking tiresome right now.
>>
>>534167640
chief rabbi of czech was a convert. avi eskin (if you don't know who that is its a self report). you're wrong and coping
>>
>>534163978
If the whole world converted to judaism they'd lose their shit
>>
>>534171027
Ironically you cannot use a dna test to make aliyah, only showing papers proving jewish grandparents from a rabbi or conversion
>>
>>534163978
Jews are Demons, anon
They outbreed some for aggressive mimicry
But, then they inbreed to maintain the Demon
>>
jew is an invader race

life is race war

jews weapon is jewing aka printing money without doing any work, then restricting action aka regulation theft adn spying aka insider trading
>>
>>534175541
nah i think you're just a mentally disabled 90 IQ moor who is way behind on the conversation and projects your own lack of understanding

>These aren't my definitions, they're established definitions in anthropology and sociology
But it's your interpretation and your so called established definition is contradicted by another already in the 1st paragraph on wikipedia. If you werent a retard you'd realize im not certainly againt the definition but against your newspeak pilpul interpretation of it
>You can see how these terms mean specific things and not "anything" like you're suggesting
all this time i'm just replying according to your own suggestions, definitions, etc. you just dont like your own retardation being mirrored to you

you need to calm down maybe get some tea and take time to process everything
you're seething so much you're literally confusing me with other anons
>>
>>534163978
first anon to start an NGO helping members of the african american community obtain easy reform conversions that entitle you to move to israel will actually be the greatest threat to greatest ally. many are not ready for this truth
>>
>>534166575
>>534166585
>>534166816

Truuuuuuue
>>
>>534172975
i dont know what to tell you other than you're wrong. reform/conservative/orthodox conversions all entitle you to move to israel, although if you want the rabbinot to consider you jewish once you're there you have to convert orthodox in the u.s. or "upgrade" your conversion via the Conversion Authority in Israel. if you can move to israel, have a jewish wedding, funeral, belong to a synagogue, I'm not sure what it would take outside of that for you to accept that conversion is a thing. Prejudices may exist towards converts, not unique to judaism tho
>>
>>534166575
understandable sentiment given flag. if it makes you feel any better it is known that many people during the fall of the ussr bought papers from corrupt rabbis saying they were jewish, despite not being so
>>
>>534176009
You're not using any terms against anyone because you don't understand these terms, otherwise we wouldn't be having this conversation. I've explained what ethnicity is, what ethnoreligious is, what race is. I've explained why matrilineal shit (your argument) doesn't make jews a race, and i've explained the reasons why (conversion, grandparents, spouses).

Tell me where are the biological boundaries in the jewish ethnicity, the biological boundaries necessary for a race to form. It's easy, just answer to that to prove your point. And remove your memeflag, i wanna see which country is responsible for producing you.
>>
>>534163978
>jewish is not a Race
That's a nice try for a rabbi.
>>
>>534176009
fyi the ashkenazi matrilineal line (tracked through mitochondrial dna) tracks to italian converts, separate from the matrilineal line of sephardim. you are only right if you can prove that all practicing jews have the same matrilineal line, which they don't
>>
>>534163978
The Khazars were cynically 'Jewish'. They wanted the legitimacy of a Abrahamic religion but wanted to stay contrarian against the Byzantine Empire and the Caliphate.
Only the ruling class converted and it was essentially a mixture of surface-level Judaism and steppe religion.
>>
>>534176757
this is an interesting continuity going from the Khazars throughout history, where jews have tried to act as the gatekeeper between east and west, playing the sides off each other. I do not fully buy khazar ancestry hypothesis (although there is no question some jews have eastern european ancestry) but it is interesting symbolically
>>
>>534176976
>I do not fully buy khazar ancestry hypothesis
Have you read Thirteenth Tribe? I guess detractors just think it's some Kike monologing for 200 pages. It's full of quotes and ancient sources.
>>
>>534177300
>Thirteenth Tribe
haven't read the book, familiar with koestler. his argument that there is 0% levantine ancestry is definitely wrong and ironically runs cover for mizrahim and sephardim in israel. that being said southern european and steppe admixture (steppe dna being from khazar tribes) does make sense
this is common sense given that ashkenazi jews have slight visual similarities with levantine people but are still clearly distinct visually
>>
>>534177743
>havent read the book
>his argument that Khazars have 0% levantine ancestry is wrong
Don't even know what to say
>>
>>534177887
does the book discuss y chromosome at all? this is the line that most commonly shows up levantine among ashkenazim
>>
>>534178077
I dont know if youre a shill or you ate up their goyslop, but the DNA and chromosome evidence is on the side of Koestler. To do damage control about the Johns Hopkins paper by Eran Elhaik, they engineered some bullshit study with curated samples.

But regardless, here is the dichtomy:
A) They 0% Levantine (or statistically insignificant, because the Christian worldview is that literally everyone on earth come from Noah/the Levant)
B) Germans in the Roman army kidnapped Kikes, brought them to Germany, had rapebabies, and the rapebabies migrated eastward

There is no third option. B triggers kikes real bad, which is why you'll hear the cope that "Jews were having a ton of sex with Roman women".
>>
File: 1681922366668670m.jpg (155 KB, 1024x1024)
155 KB JPG
>>534166732
>B-but the shills say that it's pajeets, niggers and mudslimes behind every memeflag...
>>
>>534178378
>Eran Elhaik
elhaik's study says there is some ME ancestry but mostly southern european and slavic (i.e. Khazarian) which is the same as what I said
I agree that many of the "all jews are genetically related/the same" studies read as goyslop and have some issues. that said i have never heard of option B and would be interested in the literature
>>
>>534178625
Elhaik famously said Koestler was right. And B is in the book. The evidence against it is linguistic analysis.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.