> supposedly one of the greatest minds in sawker
They were guinea pig testing this rule in the Canadian Premier league. It was a mess
>>158672222I just think they need a margin of error. An offside should just be a quick obvious call. If linesman can make assessments in seconds, why does var need to take minutes?
>>158672244Because people complain, and if post-review shows a wrong call was made, the ref gets death threats and the federation gets constant calls for the match to be replayed.
Everyone misunderstands offsides. The rule was created not to help the defense, but to help offense flow better. The more movement the more opportunities the offense will have to fool the defense. Whenever someone suggests changing the rule "so it's easier to score" they are just making it harder. The 2nd problem is the line drawing part, most suggestions only change where the line is drawn, but that doesn't help solve the problem of having to draw the line in the first place.Two things could be done:> Change the rule so it decreases the number of offside callsFor example, allow the play to continue as long as the offside player does not take a shot, but makes a pass to an onside player instead. This way you not only reduce pauses, but also decreases the frenquency of VAR checks.> Change the rule so offsides begin before midfieldThis by itself could in theory increase the frequency, but it would also do the opposite of the Wenger rule: incentivize defenses to go even higher, which would obviously cause more counters. I'm particularly intrigued about this one as I think it would be more familiar for the usual fan, but it would also incentivize Ngubu playstyle which I despise, so I would rather the 1st one. VAR also needs a fix: challenges. There is no need to autocheck everything, let the refs on the pitch call everything as normal, give each team 2 challenges per half, limit VAR checks by 1 minute, and that's it. If they get the challenge right they can keep it to make another call.
I really hope this is fake as fuck
>>158672311The problem with challenges in a game like football is that there are only a couple of turning points every game so you'd just end up challenging every red card, penalty, and close offside decision anyway.The way to do it would be to give teams a certain number of challenges per season.
The solution is simple: Keep the rules as they are and abolish the VAR.It's part of the game to shit on the ref. With VAR, the only thing that changes is that the ref's authority gets questioned.This is like... life. You sit together with friends drinking beer complaining how women are all evil, that the boss is an asshole and that the ref rigged the match last weekend.Why do they try to change those simple things that make the world go round?
>>158672356>The problem with challenges in a game like football is that there are only a couple of turning points every game so you'd just end up challenging every red card, penalty, and close offside decision anyway.True, but 2 challenges per half, with the possibility of keeping them if you get it right is plenty for most matches I'd say. There aren't that many questionable moments and managers would have to be careful with momentum swings and challenging dubious stuff all the time.>The way to do it would be to give teams a certain number of challenges per season.Huh, I like that>>158672478True true, there is always that option
>>158672311>Everyone misunderstands offsides.Because the rule itself is deeply flawed.
>>158672244>I just think they need a margin of error.THIS, but specifically for the VAR.My main problem with VAR and offside right now is there is no margin of error taken into account. There absolutely is a margin of error involved with the limited framerate system, such that you cannot be sure the automated system is correct when we're talking about differences of like 1 cm.Something like one of the following needs to be implemented:>calculate the maximum margin of error possible given the framerate - this would involve the maximum amount of distance two Usain Bolts could generate between each other when running in opposite directions for the duration of one frame - and goals cannot be disallowed if the difference is smaller than this margin of error>build a more advanced system which can calculate the speed at which every player is moving on the pitch, as well as do the math based on these speeds to calculate the margin of error based on those speeds and the framerate - goals cannot be disallowed if the difference is smaller than this margin of errorAs it is right now, I think it's fucking bullshit to disallow goals based on 1cm offside because that's clearly within the margin of error of the current framerate used.
>>158672222It was a dumb idea from the startThe only doable change is making the offside position depend on where the feet are, that would eliminate this shoulder discussion. Apart from that, you can't do anythingIf you want quick certainty, you need the (semi-)automatic offside detection technology. No other chance
>>158672694The problem with all this tech is that you have thousands of leagues and tiers out there and it takes a while to adapt everywhere>>158672657>Because the rule itself is deeply flawed.True
This is a problem because soccer is a low scoring game
>>158672478>abolish the VAR
>>158672716I'll never get the supposed issue with it being low-scoring. It's part of the thrill that any goal might be the deciding one. Maybe the game ends 1:0, maybe it ends 4:4. You don't know. There can be scoring opportunities without them leading to goals, even a 0:0 can be exciting. The amount of goals is not necessarily congruent with the amount of excitement. An average of 3 goals per game is fine, but there needs to be some devianceI couldn't care less about the NBA making every game end 130:126 by allowing everyone to travelHow many goals would be needed?
>>158672754To be fair, the NBA allows some players (LeBron) to travel more than others.
>>158672754in basketball the main problem is not with the scoring but the fact that only the 4th quarter matters and it's chopped up by like 9 timeouts
>>158672222Pretty disappointed with wenger since arsenal fans forced him out. I wanted him to stay in management. But he's basically just done private wenger things and come up with kooky ideas to UEFA
>>158672768It seems that some people want that for football. Allow timeouts, keep "hydration breaks" ... and increase scoring by as much as possible. If I know a game will have a minimum of six goals, I usually won't have to watch anything but the final 10 minutes either
>>158672222Wow so the thing you could infer from the beginning was proven right? what a shocker, crazy to think this guy was a manager.actually explains why he says AI is the future of managing since this is his full ability.
>>158672716>This is a problem because soccer is a low scoring gameIf that were true Futsal, Sevens and Indoors Football would all be more popular.
>>158672803This guy is 77. He can't cut it anymore. You cannot expect him to be capable at that age. At least he's capable enough to make some money with his retardationA shame to see a German stoop so low, though
>>158672311Are you dumb? That just means player will be offisde on purpose as long as they are not the ones taking the shots
>>158672222well no shit, I didn't need a trial to understand that>>158672244>margin of erroryou're still making the same mistake, at what point is that margin of error not an error anymore? people will then argue if it's an obvious offside or not. the debate will never end.
>>158672860Correct. That's the sacrifice. It spreads the game out without the usual problems of no offsides. It unlocks new playstyles too with playmakers purposely behind the defense, which in turn would make them have to worry about backpasses from the offside playmaker and break the defensive line, which would also open more space up front
>>158672244>>158672870This, you are just changing the problem. People will still complain about the margin of error being rigged
>>158672222just let clubs mark their own offside lines in their pitches then make a basic cheap laser thing that you can install on the sides of these 2 lines and that's it, that's all you need.
there just isn't a good solution to this
>>158672311>VAR also needs a fix: challengesThat shit will just slow the game down even more compared to how VAR is currently implemented. Just look at an NFL or college football game and see how long and drawn out the challenges get.>>158672478>Keep the rules as they are and abolish the VAR.I couldn't agree more, instant replay/VAR in sports is terrible, it just slows everything down and people still bitch about the calls.
>>158672907>That shit will just slow the game down even more compared to how VAR is currently implementedNot really. With use and time limits like I suggested, you would probably pause the match far less than they already do with autoVAR shit at every offside or mid foul. The point is to reduce VAR and give control to the managers, not allow them to challenge anything and everything with no limit.> Just look at an NFL or college football Completely different situation. Those are basically turn based games, they need these tactical pauses. American sports also exagerate a fuckton on timeouts and challenges for business reasons, but other sports like Volleyball for example have very reasonable challenge systems which is more of what I suggested here
>>158672222He's a gay gooner what did you expect?
defending is...bad?
center of massmake the offside line the center of massthat way the game doesnt change drastically but we get rid of retarded shoulder/toe offsides
>>158673082Correct answer but that would mean AI analysing the plays which would make people even more skeptical so the issue would remain.
>>158673082>make the offside line the center of massCan you please draw a circle around this player's center of mass?
>>158673090we already have those 3d renders and its never going away so we're forced to just trust them to pick the correct frame and trust the technology to correctly model the players bodies and position.but the main problem is that the way the lines are being drawn right now, a lot of goals where the attacker was NOT in an advantageous position get disallowed. no matter where you put the line, there will always be controversy whenever theres a close call. but when the line is in the centre of body mass, i believe it will be easier for people to accept the goal was disallowed since it will be clear that he had at least some real advantage
>>158673159but you will still have the problem of a discrete boundary on a continuous dataset. The AI will say the player is 0.1mm offside which we all know doesn't give him any advantage but you'll still have to rule him out. Even if you give an allowance of say 5cm if the player is 5.01cm offside people will still complain.That's the fundamental flaw with the rule post VAR, the spirit of the law is to prevent tap in merchants to camp the box while also giving a safety net for the defense to restrict the opponent's space. When you remove the human element (because of corrupted referees) the only alternative is not the spirit of the law but the letter of the law as the computer is unbiased.
>>158672694Just draw thicker lines from the defender and have it so an attackers scoring body part must be ahead of the thick line
hockey style offsides with a permanent "last defender"you are welcome I fixed soccer
Stop debating offside, and just scrap var for offside. Its as simple as that. Its complete bullshit. Looking through half a minute of fucking video looking for reasons to rule goals out. Goal line technology works, keep it. Pretty much everything else is bullshit. Retrospective tackles? Dont care, scrap it. The ball brushed a single hair? Toes are offside? Someones hand? Their noseand forehead? Oh no 1cm of the ball crossed a touchline during a cross! Its just bullshit. Ruined the game. Referees with microphones and cameras. I dont even want to see or hear the referee.
>>158673404>Looking through half a minute of fucking videoSemi-automatic offside worked well and was very quick. It should stay/be expanded. But any sort of long check should be avoided
>>158673106best player, always onside
>>158673600
>>158673196thats my point though. we should be allowing more goals and disallowing less. if a players toe is 1mm offside, it doesnt give him any advantage. if a players center of body mass is 1mm offside, it does give him an advantage. now is there a difference in advantage between being 1mm off and 1mm on? obviously not, but either way the line has to exist, and this way, less goals would be, in my opinon undeservedly, disallowed
>>158673644Thoughts on this situation?
>>158672904There’s no way to make everyone happy, but plenty of the ideas in this thread are better than the ideas the professionals have been coming up with. I still think they should put detectors in those telemetry bras that players wear now, and base everything off those. We have the technology, and the top leagues have the money. In lower leagues, no VAR, and that’s fine too. It would also remove the stupidity of being offside by a fraction of a buttock.
>>158673208This is a quality idea. People might still gripe if a player is 1mm past the thick line, but 1mm past the thick line might be 10cm offside, so there would be a lot less moaning, at least initially.