[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/tg/ - Traditional Games

Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.
  • Roll dice with "dice+numberdfaces" in the options field (without quotes).

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


No longer down for maintenance!

[Advertise on 4chan]


File: shm-55-aphotic-wisps.jpg (222 KB, 672x936)
222 KB
222 KB JPG
Global Rule 3.c Edition

Previous: >>97881576

>Most recent banlist update
https://magic.wizards.com/en/news/announcements/commander-banned-and-restricted-february-9-2026

>Most recent bracket system update
https://magic.wizards.com/en/news/announcements/commander-brackets-beta-update-february-9-2026

>Outline article introducing the bracket system
https://magic.wizards.com/en/news/announcements/introducing-commander-brackets-beta

>Current banlist
https://magic.wizards.com/en/banned-restricted-list#commander-banned

>Former Commander website, where you can learn the basics, and read the format philosophy laid down by the rules committee
https://mtgcommander.net

>Statistically see what everyone else puts in their commander decks based on what is posted to the internet
https://www.edhrec.com

>Learn about PDH, Commander's budget pauper format
https://pdhhomebase.com
https://www.pdhrec.com

>Deck list site: You can search for decks that other people have made. Authors often have comments that explain their deck strategy and card choices
https://www.archidekt.com
https://www.moxfield.com
https://www.tappedout.net

>Find out what lands you can add to your deck, sorted by category, based on a chosen color identity
https://managathering.com

>Card search
https://scryfall.com

>Proxy a deck or a cube for cheap
https://pastebin.com/9Xj1xLdM

>Precons
https://magicprecons.com

>TQ
Reflect on what could have been. Name something from a recent set that you wish had happened but didn't.
I'll go first, I wish Lorwyn had reprinted wisps. I'm especially mad that they didn't, given they did invent vivid and made colors on board a whole theme.
>>
>>97883934
I wish they would have unbanned more things this last review.
>>
>>97883934
I wish that TMNT had a reprint of Damn that had art of Raphael yelling at the sky.
>>
Don't spam unnecessary threads because you don't like shit in the OP.
>>
>>97883967
then leave? if you don't like something you are supposed to leave I hear and not revenge shitpost to make the invaders miserable, no sir
>>
>>97883955
Like what? And I swear to god if you say "unban everything and bring back the tuck rule" we are NOT going to Disney World, I will turn this car around right here, mister.
>>
>>97883975
You leave you absolute shit eating cum guzzling loser. You sat here all day seething constantly over a single link in a general and spamming the last thread with dozens of posts proclaiming your butthurt faggotry then you spammed the catalogue with an unnecessarily early thread to and admit you're going to keep doing so because you can't handle other anon's tastes and you're a wannabe reddit mod faggot cock sucker who constantly shits up every goddamn thread with constant off topic whining.
>>
File: 1775874127264620.jpg (84 KB, 1261x1551)
84 KB
84 KB JPG
>>97884016
Stop putting furporn in the OP.
Now.
>>
>>97883934
>Reflect on what could have been. Name something from a recent set that you wish had happened but didn't.
Detectives on Ravnica could have been good. But they didn't plan it as such, the plan was "top down detective set" and then they picked a plane for it after the fact. I will be forever puzzled as to why they thought having 1000 detectives in the set was a good idea when the most resonant detective story has ONE (1) detective solving the mystery, but hey, wotc is retarded sometimes.
>I'll go first, I wish Lorwyn had reprinted wisps. I'm especially mad that they didn't, given they did invent vivid and made colors on board a whole theme.
True, the color matters theme felt half baked in Eclipsed. Color matter is a really deep well that is underexplored. I'd like to see devotion, hybrid, and color matters explored more fully in a set, sort of like Theros plus Shadowmoor. Lorwyn Eclipsed just had too much going on to deliver fully, wish it were two sets.
>>
>>97884016
>You sat here all day seething constantly over a single link in a general
You have 0 justification for constantly putting it back in. I have no idea why you're seething so hard when people take it out. It's against the rules, fuck off if that upsets you.
>>
>>97884041
>Color matter is a really deep well that is underexplored.
Amen to that. There's so much potential for high interactivity in games where color matters and someone can change colors of shit at instant speed. I neeeeeeeeed it
>>
>>97884041
> I'd like to see devotion, hybrid, and color matters explored more fully in a set
if we still had blocks they could do it, but now that every set is an island, never gonna happen
>>
>looking at sultai arisen
>its sold out from all my nearby game stores
>online it sells for 60+ bucks
wtf
>>
File: help.png (577 KB, 800x482)
577 KB
577 KB PNG
>>97884016
>"guys look!!! I put furry porn in the OP!!! isn't that funny? WHAT!? it's not?! well how about YOU make the next thread if you don't like it!!!!!"
>does
>faggot loses his goddamn mind
>>
>>97884049
Fuck off bitch. No one is seething about a link being taken out of a general, we're tired of you being massive faggot. You spammed the last thread with 20+ posts fucking crying about the general then you literally sat here all day waiting to spam a new thread even though the last one is nowhere near image limit and still active because you had to be a power tripping faggot gaslighting like "everyone who doesn't like me is a furry" when it's the fact you're spamming off topic bullshit all day every fucking day and now we have to put up with rushed thread spam because you need to go on a gay little thread war crusade for the next however long because you're a no life loser. get a job.
>>
>>97883934
>Is ____ worth $[two or three digit number]?
lmao buyfags
>>
File: bellobrain.png (89 KB, 598x601)
89 KB
89 KB PNG
>>97884068
>No one is seething about a link being taken out of a general
You are.
>we
Who?
>>
File: 1647895972258.png (267 KB, 547x596)
267 KB
267 KB PNG
>>97883988
>unban everything
>bring back the ruck rule
>bring back the old legendary rule
>ban UB by default
>>
>>97883934
>Reflect on what could have been. Name something from a recent set that you wish had happened but didn't.
I feel like a chump having complained about Map tokens and role tokens when Ixalan and Eldraine were two of the best sets of the last few years. Sure it was a little complex but those sets were excellent, LCI especially. I wish I had appreciated them more.
>>
>>97884080
That's it, young man! Christmas is cancelled!
>>
>>97884080
>the ruck rule
>if your commander is removed, you need to walk 12 miles with 35 pounds in a backpack in less than 3 hours or it gets torn in half
>>
>>97884070
>Validate me! I matter! My fake cards matter!
No. I will never validate you.
>>
>>97884068
>We
We?
lol
"We"
lmao
>>
File: 1650171812941.jpg (113 KB, 640x1176)
113 KB
113 KB JPG
>>97884090
das rite!
>>
>97884078
>97884097
>not even 25 posts in
>pds is already samefagging

what a cursed and shitty thread lmao
>>
>>97884057
Tam is such a sick card. I got her in ECL draft vivid deck and it was a blast. Makes me like her storywise desu when normally I'm a doomer about modern Magic story

>>97884059
I don't think Lorwyn set followed by Shadowmoor set is a big ask at this point. They feel very different, basically being different planes, and Eclipsed seems to have done well enough maybe we can get two separate sets in like 5 years lmao. The time to wait for set production is so grim, any feedback they get now will take 3+ years to be seen given how long it takes to produce sets
>>
>>97884057
I want to FUCK Jace's child
>>
>forty doll hairs
>>
>>97884113
I sincerely doubt the old "we make sets 3 years out" thing is still true, they clearly had to truncate the timeline as they started cramming more sets into the year. I doubt they were planning on six full Standard sets even a year before.
>>
File: sudden.png (1.44 MB, 672x936)
1.44 MB
1.44 MB PNG
Is this too harsh of a card for bracket 2
>>
>>97884057
>gorgon
>normal hair

Goddamn UW sucks.
>>
>>97884136
She just cut the heads off, you can even see the dried blood.
>>
File: jace & vraska.png (193 KB, 748x555)
193 KB
193 KB PNG
>>97884113
>Tam is such a sick card. I got her in ECL draft vivid deck and it was a blast
I do kind of wish she had a 3rd color, because if they ever expand on color matters or color hack as a theme, a 2c commander is just inherently not as good at the job.
Also so disappointed her Strixhaven card fucking sucks. Uncommon landfall draw bullshit. Like simic needed more of that. God I fucking hope she gets a good card in Reality Fracture
>>97884118
WotC, hire this man.
>>97884136
Half human
>>
>>97884141
That's braided hair, not snake bodies. Gorgon snakes go all the way into the skull.
>>
>>97884135
No.
>>
File: Spoiler Image (73 KB, 760x1024)
73 KB
73 KB JPG
There's only one half human Magic related character I'm interested in seeing.
>>
>>97884141
Retard
>>
>>97884080
hell yeah brothor

in march I played my first commander game since maybe 2018ish? imagine my shock when Clone didn't kill their commander "well thats a useless card now"

ban UB except for high-fantasy sets IE, Lord of the Rings, Final Fantasy (only cards from FF 1-12), Baldur's Gate and Dungeons & Dragons sets

unban and reprint the power 9 + library of Alexandria or just a MOX SPECIAL BOX $300 and you get Mox Ruby, Emerald, Sapphire, Jet, Pearl & Diamond

reprint Timetwister + Wheel of Fortune and put dual lands with REAL BACKS into actual "tournament legal" (ie not official proxies) boosters with other commander staples like Mana Drain, Demonic Tutor, Crop Rotation, Land Tax, DOCKSIDE EXTORTIONIST + JLO and Guru Land reprints in the land lots with also new full art lands by Terese Nielsen & Seb McKinnon

add 10 green cards to the game changer list

I started playing commander in 2011 and I don't really remember the tuck rule for some reason.
>>
Chud commander
>>
>>97884166
>ban UB except for high-fantasy sets IE, Lord of the Rings, Final Fantasy (only cards from FF 1-12), Baldur's Gate and Dungeons & Dragons sets
you get the rope with the rest of the UBfags, zero tolerance
>>
File: 1757628066364721.png (803 KB, 850x500)
803 KB
803 KB PNG
>>97884144
>Half human
>Just green no snakes
lmao
>>
>>
>>97884166
>in march I played my first commander game since maybe 2018ish? imagine my shock when Clone didn't kill their commander "well thats a useless card now"
rule changed in M14 bozo lmao nice larp
>but but but
>>
File: darksteel.jpg (119 KB, 716x1000)
119 KB
119 KB JPG
>>97884135
absofucking lutely not its basic magic. but in bracket 2 which shares the crybaby title with bracket 3 the player you play it against WILL say its unfair, like this card or anything else that interacts with them or at all strays from their of-mice-and-men style vision of how the game should go
>>
>>97884164
Why do you keep commissioning this stuff, Elk?
>>
>>97884136
are you a neural net bot anon? that doesn't actually have eyes? those are definitely snakes
>>
File: 1759651475887510.png (954 KB, 697x975)
954 KB
954 KB PNG
>>
>friend and local community group all talking about potential commanders and characters that will appear in Marvel/Star Trek/The Hobbit or how much they didn't like Turtles and Spider Man
>zero talk about Strixhaven or Lorwyn and absolutely no discussion about Reality Fracture

UW is deader than disco
>>
>>97884172
great flavor, I might have to build around him

although all non-green commanders are inherently transphobic, homophobic, xenophobic cis huwite males patriarchal cards
>>
>>97884174
Legitimacy based
>>97884166
There is no approved UB. There can never be any consensus on what UB "fits" Magic and what doesn't, and I'm not about to appoint some faggot whose tastes I might not agree with to make the decision.
If it involves licensing IP from anywhere, or utilising works that would be subject to licensing were they not public domain, it's out. The only acceptable design space for Magic is concepts that are so universal that no issue of copyright can arise.
>>
File: 1758529900179605.png (2.72 MB, 1080x1440)
2.72 MB
2.72 MB PNG
it's coming
>>
>>97884207
Epic bait anon!!!!!
Meanwhile Lorwyn sold out immediately while Spider-Flop is still on shelves.
>>
File: the-new-black-lotus.jpg (115 KB, 716x1000)
115 KB
115 KB JPG
>>97884174
doors that way loooooser!
>>
>>97884125
They can move releases around, like how they pushed back Lorwyn based on the feedback about there being too many releases close together, but they were only capable of doing that because the set was effectively done. It does seem they have a year plus of sets in the pipe that cannot change much, based on listening to 500+ hours of Maro prattling while I drive to work.
>>
>>97884217
>Lorwyn sold out immediately

Cool! Proof?
>>
>>97884174
I don't know why UB fags don't get this, if you allow one UB you allow all of it. This was obvious from the moment they rolled out Walking Dead Secret Lair and Godzilla cards in Ikoria.
>>
>>97884187
yeah I dont remember it at all it might have happened once or twice to me in the 2010s- you were still in diapers then anyway so what the fuck do you know. its past your bed time
>>
>>97884222
Proof you're not a raging AIDS riddled homosexual? Your word will not suffice.
>>
What's a fun bracket 2/3 i could build with Thalia as the commander?
The obvious first thought is some staxslop but idk what the actual wincons there could possibly be.
>>
>>97884207
Nah my UW commander is pretty sweet
>>
>>97884228
So no proof and you're retarded, got it!
>>
>>97884226
>but but but
Yeah ok.
Also I'm a millennial, though I do have to work tomorrow so maybe getting some Zs is apt.
>>
>>97884207
what is even known about reality fracture? is it going to be another plane shift color shit? knowing MARO the jewish king of magic and how he hates balancing the colors, I dont expect any planeshift color pie breaks anytime soon (current example A being the extreme pedestrian set of groom-haven)
>>
>>97884229
This Thalia i mean, sorry.
>>
>>97884229
>staxslop
>but idk what the actual wincons there could possibly be.
Pic related, or one of the life-gain based wins.
>Felidar Sovereign
>Test of Endurance
>Aetherflux Reservoir
>>
>>97884207
UBrowns still coping with their Homelands tier flops, sad to see...
>>97884217
Known fact, UWhites stay patrician and winning as always.
>>
File: taking-our-game-back.jpg (123 KB, 672x936)
123 KB
123 KB JPG
>>97884215
hell yeah. groomer-haven btfo. troons out of MTGO and gōtc in 2027
>>
>>97884234
So you're a raging AIDS riddled homosexual? Oh dear :(
>>
File: LifeGain-Wins.jpg (848 KB, 1344x936)
848 KB
848 KB JPG
>>97884242
those are my boys, my mono white tribal cats life gain deck from 2010
>>
>>97884238
>is it going to be another plane shift color shit?
Alt timeline color swaps. We've already seen one.
>>
>>97884238
>what is even known about reality fracture

Nothing much really. All I know is that there is as close to zero interest in it among Magic players I know locally and online as is possible for a set to have. Even here in this general full of UWspergs how much discussion have we seen about it? Nothing, no hype, no anticipation.

Since it is a UW property though we can assume the following:

1) The art will consist of 70% black women.
2) Gay couples are guaranteed.
3) The story will be boring and indecisive.
>>
>>97884258
>MOMMY MOMMY LOOK AT THE BAIT I POSTED!!!
>>
>Reality Fracture
>Nissa and Chandra are STRAIGHT
>>
>>97884258
Final Faggotry enjoyer detected, complaints about homosexuality deeply ironic
CONCLUSION: move to UBrown containment
>>
>>97884245
Okay but will you accept black Snape?
>>
File: lw5wz6br6no41.jpg (156 KB, 640x1046)
156 KB
156 KB JPG
>>97884266
Considering how this is one of the few genuinely good things wotc has done with their ip I wouldn't be surprised if this was the one gay couple they broke up lol
>>
>>97884266
Impossible! sexuality is the ONE thing that can't change across the multiverse mkay?
>>97884267
Honestly one day we should just fork the general. Or create a Magic Without UB thread for all formats.
>>
>>97884245
MTG dead from controversy by 2028
>>
>>97884274
Why is this a good thing
>>
>>97884258
Bait used to be good
>>
>>97884239
you did what now?

im pretty sure theres better stax pieces to not have to waste your commander slot on that.

but if you like it, mono white needs LAND TAX, Gift of Estates, Sunstar Expansionist, and Kor Cartographer and Knights of the White Orchid + Swords + generous gift + dark steel mutation + wrath of god + austere command +farewell + ****smothering tithe***** is literally a game winner

(more powerful than rhystic arguably especially with huge white game ender creatures and spells like catastrophe/armageddon.

I would go tribal on something, if doing life gain, cats. knights works well as well, angels are a bit overcosted but used to be awesome
>>
>>97884277
>"someone should..."
No. YOU go make that thread and watch it die completely in less than a week.
Go ahead, nobody is stopping you.
Do it you lazy faggot.
>>
>>97884280
He's a gooner who jerks it to lesbians.
>>
>>97884290
>furfag OP melty
Uh oh stinky
>>
File: aaaa save me Garfield.png (158 KB, 1080x619)
158 KB
158 KB PNG
>>97884277
>Honestly one day we should just fork the general.

Feel free to try. It'll be dead and you'll all come running back to cry about UB all day anyways.

>Or create a Magic Without UB thread for all formats.

Nothing is stopping you fags from doing so. I've heard this larp for 3+ years now. Where's that format at? It's almost as if the overwhelming majority of the player base doesn't have a problem with UB or something.

Crymore pissbabies
>>
>>97884287
Are cats much better than humans? I was thinking maybe those if i go tribal.
>>
>>97884298
No i just hate people who say "someone oughta!", especially when it's something they actually could easily do.
Just do it if you want that thread to exist.
>>
>>97884277
>Or create a Magic Without UB thread for all formats.
Two e-celebs tried this and have failed.
>>
One day the UB bubble with burst. Its not sustainable and the community is getting more and more annoyed with it.
LotR, FF, and Avatar may have sold well, but they won't be able to hold up the crushing weight of shit UB forever.
>>
File: jud-112-epic-struggle.jpg (252 KB, 672x936)
252 KB
252 KB JPG
>>97884251
Based. Now that my nigga Biorhythm is free I'll be playing that, but I have Epic Struggled my way to victory more than once
>>
>>97884319
MTG in general is going to collapse under its own weight, UB or no. 6 or 7 sets a year is legitimately too much, and regular players are starting to check out.
>>
>>97884319
the online community is a minority.
>>
>>97884327
Most people I talk to at the 3 lgs I regularly go to are getting fed up with it as well. Its not just online.
They like the ones from the franchises they like, but hate the rest, which is to be expected. Most people aren't buying Spiderman just because its magic, and etc.
>>
>>97884331
Did they buy all the UW though
>>
File: blue-harrow.jpg (136 KB, 672x936)
136 KB
136 KB JPG
>>97884252
if its really color shifted this would be the biggest shits in a long time, ive been waiting for more color pie breaks to balance out the game since groomers is doing their best job to fuck up everything especially in commander.

first time around blue got a shitty harrow, this time....probably something worse but black got wrath of god. it was mostly a great set but didnt go far enough

I have very little confidence in gōtc to produce a good set especially when the chief- homo-enabler at large Rosewater has said how he hates any kind of color pie breaks. so I imagine- like with all current magic products it will be dull mechanic wise, highly nerfed to favor beginners, troons and green players (basically all the same thing)

I hadn't heard any leaks of reality fracture yet since it's not. coming until October so I imagine thats why no ones talking about it. that card you posted has the strixhaven set logo even if its got blue abilities

that said if they are somehow not massive faggots and make some great color shifted cards I will draft the fuck out of it and I haven't done a good Swiss draft since Ixalan (not counting mystery booster 2 or modern horizon 2 sloppa)
>>
>>97884331
Most decks at my LGS are UB
>>
Why aren't they reprinting FF?? My store hasn't gotten FF packs in so long now.
>>
>>97884340
no time for new print runs, gotta print the 15 other sets
>>
>>97884335
More or less yes.
>>
File: very-nice.gif (3.46 MB, 640x480)
3.46 MB
3.46 MB GIF
>>97884320
hell yeah brothor
>>
File: 1749788338279527.png (710 KB, 1185x1200)
710 KB
710 KB PNG
TODD I WANT MY FUCKING TES UB SLOP HURRY THE FUCK UP
>>
>>97884319
>One day the UB bubble with burst.

Yes. And that'll spell the end of Magic as a whole. If UB isn't moving sets anymore nothing will be and the company will fold.

>Its not sustainable

Correct. Too many sets per year is already exhausting consumers and the hype of seeing actually beloved IPs in Magic form is slowly wearing off as it becomes normalized.

>and the community is getting more and more annoyed with it.

No but they're not being wowed by it anymore.

>LotR, FF, and Avatar may have sold well, but they won't be able to hold up the crushing weight of shit UB forever

Correct, although there are still myriad IPs that would bring in billion dollar paydays. The well is not bottomless but we're not even close to the bottom yet.

And of course as mentioned above, UWfags gleefully rubbing their hands in anticipation of the day UB fails are retards because when UB dies Magic dies. There's no going back and Hasbro will not and cannot accept a return to pre-2020 sales numbers, they were already a failing company that managed to extend Magic's life by switching focus to Commander, which was a lucky accident that it existed at all. UB is the company's life preserver, when it sinks the company sinks too.
INB4
>Well that's good Magic should fail because blah blah blah-
If anyone actually hinks that they're a massive retard for being here in the first place instead of cashing out and moving on.
>>
File: unh-52-duh.jpg (307 KB, 672x936)
307 KB
307 KB JPG
>>97884343
congrats because they're not enough of them that's why wotc went with UB in the first place
>>
>>97884336
that card is a preview of Reality Fracture's gimmick from Strixhaven. Ral Zarek is ordinarily blue/red, not black.
>>
>>97884347
>the well is not bottomless
it can be recycled over and over, just like how Weiss Schwarz does it
>>
>>97884347
>when UB dies Magic dies
Magic is already dead
>>
>>97884336
It probably wouldn't fit what Reality Fracture is doing, but one color shift I've wanted for a while is black Silence. Toshiro Umezawa did it with the power of a monoblack kami, so there's a 20 year old precedent.
>>
>>97884347
>Magic will be completely dead without UB!
Wizards can buy themselves out of hasbro if they feel the need, or another company would probably buy it if hasbro decides to wash their hands of it.
Those things could never come to pass, sure, but they aren't out of the realm of possibility.
>>
>>97884359
The record breaking sales and player base strongly disagree. What YOU wish the game was is dead. You continuing to engage with it is your problem not ours.
>>
>>97884319
It warms my heart to see newer player brought in by UB actively disliking other UB products. I pray this results in a positive for games (more players) plus a positive for sets (less UB)

>>97884324
A legitimate worry. But that is part of the plan. Consumers only have so much money. So they'll hit me up 3 times a year for the real Magic sets, and other parts of the nerd economy for money on 3-4 UB releases a year. As long as they don't go under the line on in-universe sets, I'll still be here. And as long as there's still dumb nerd money they'll find it with UB. The one thing that bring me solace is that players brought in by UB will soon become anti-UB when it's not "their thing" meanwhile they'll be jamming with Lorwyn or Edge of Eternities three times a year. There is enough churn that I don't see the candle going out soon unless they make another couple horrible mistakes.

>>97884327
The normie momentum irl has shifted against UB for the moment. We'll see where it goes this year. Hobbit is probably a big success but Marvel is questionable in this climate. WotC taking 3 years to develop sets makes pop culture bets surprisingly risky. Wort case scenario is a Wizards failure puts Hasbro short and tanks the whole company, which is possible.
>>
>>97884365
what you see is a shambling corpse, animated by greed and desperation. The game isn't in a healthy state, despite what numbers Maro likes to trot out.
>>
File: Ajani-pridemate.jpg (122 KB, 672x936)
122 KB
122 KB JPG
>>97884305
in commander I haven't really tried it but my old legacy 60 card deck was mostly cats but I also had 4x Serra Ascendant in it. But 4x of these bad boys got REAL big

slap some lifelink and evasion/protection equipment/ totem armor aura's on and you got a real party.

Also the original Ajani Goldmane planeswalker would make a token that was your life total but I think it was a spirit avatar rather than a cat. but give that token the Loxodon Warhammer and that was yet another win-con
>>
>>97884367
>The normie momentum irl has shifted against UB for the moment
bro Avatar was like 5 months ago
>>
File: 1759029304773187.png (17 KB, 1092x213)
17 KB
17 KB PNG
>>97884336
>I hadn't heard any leaks of reality fracture yet
We literally had the leak 6 months ago
>>
Why did Warhammer and Fallout succeed where other low-magic franchises failed?
>>
>>97884340
I'm not entirely sure they have carte blanche to print more. I don't know what their license agreements are, no one does. Not like they print more of their best selling UW sets either.
>>
>>97884363
Wizards folds alongside Hasbro if their mtg cash cow fails and no one is buying a poison brand that even Harry Potter and Sailor Moon and Dark Souls and whatever other UB we're going to be getting couldn't save. Delusional cope, like modern/standardtards convincing themselves one day commander will fail and everyone will go rushing back to 60c formats.
>>
>>97884367
I would rather have an UB set than the in universe literal faggot groomer shit where every character is a homo or a dyke like in groom-haven. its especially cancerous when you know Hasbro owns the Harry Potter IP and groomers of the coast will be directed by hasbro to make an HP set. making redundant watered down "school of witchcraft and wizardry" cards + a whole other 2 different sets of "Hogwarts at home, groomer pride edition"
>>
>>97884374
People who play Warhammer and Fallout crossed over with MTG more than people who played Assassin's creed and watch dr who.
>>
>>97884370
The future is now old man
>>
>>97884370
I didn't hear anyone excited about Avatar. I guess on WotC's end "3rd best selling set of all time" or whatever, but that's based solely on sales from distributor to retailers. It's retailers speculating on how many units they think they can move, and then putting in an order. Whether it actually gets into the hands of players is a different matter. That's why WotC can claim Spider-Flop was top 10 best sales of all time, meanwhile it's gathering dust on shelves.
>>
>>97884379
>I would rather have an UB set than the in universe literal faggot groomer shit where every character is a homo or a dyke like in groom-haven.
Yeah because that's a very real dichotomy and not bait.
>>
>>97884374
Extremely strong cards, gimmick of being some of the first major UB sets, and being actually currently popular franchises with large fanbases.
>>
>>97884386
do you see avatar rotting on shelves though
>>
>>97884377
People buy dying franchises all the time and try and turn them around, what the fuck are you even talking about?
>Delusional cope
Why do doombrained retards always say this crap without a shred of self-awareness?
>>
>>97884397
>doombrained
but you're the one saying mtg is dead, a shambling corpse even
>>
>>97884371
I was not back to playing 6 months ago.

color shifted characters rather than color pie breaks are NOT good and again knowing MARO hates that, makes this a VERY grim outlook...if theres not a blue and/or red cultivate I won't purchase a single PACK (and already dont plan to)

seriously leaning on changing the color of the characters is not a good prospect.

when people think of the reality shift its the colors doing shit they cant normally do. its rare so it makes it fun, and the cards are valuable. its why Damnation still costs $20 while WoG is $2

if they miss that core point, this shits is dead in the water. stillborne. but that groom-haven planeswalker has blue abilities yet is mono black- I dont get why it has the groom-haven set icon though
>>
>>97884395
No but I also don't know how representative my LGS is. I can tell you they have 14 of those stupid pizza party boxes on the shelf. And 1 each of the spiderman and avatar whatchamacallits, them art panel things where the cards make a big picture? Those things.
Oh they have literal boxes of Secret Lairs too. It's funny when they first come out, they put them near the register to prevent theft, but now theyre just on regular shelves
>>
Purple is coming bozos
>>
>>97884407
As in the 6th color?
Doubt it. I'd be cool with it, but I doubt it.
>>
>>97884397
>People buy dying franchises all the time and try and turn them around

Like what? And I'm not the doombrained one I'm the one laughing at UWfags for being so butthurt about UB in the first place. Y'all are the ones praying and crying that you hope the game starts to fail because you think it'll somehow wind the clock back to 2001 or whatever the last year you thought mtg was good while the majority of the playerbase has accepted the new normal or cashed out and moved on.
>>
File: 1759024543985147.png (209 KB, 1491x821)
209 KB
209 KB PNG
>>97884407
Pink mana for a Barbie UB or SL. Already called it.
>>97884409
It's a very ancient meme, newfriend
>>
>>97884375
My store just got a new shipment of LOTR packs like a few weeks ago actually
>>
>>97884392
not this shit again the game is from 1997 and it was a funny thing written back then as a way to sneak into a whore house to steal back your girl who got kidnapped by a literal human trafficker

only in the non-canon, western-DEI influenced (now removed from square as of 2025) is this 20 minute segment of the game played up as any kind of thing, the song "stand up for groomer pride" did not exist in 1997. and this faggot did not exist in the real game of FF7

continuing to fail to acknowledge that leads me to believe 1. you are braindead 2. in the closet yourself
>>
>>97884407
Black is already purple coded. If there was a new color it'd be pink and basically be a mix of selesnya and izzet mechanics but with overpowered troon characters.
>>
>>97884417
>NOOOO THIS TIME IT'S DIFFERENT
Lol whatever you say, FFXIV troon
>>
>>97884414
that cant be real are you shitting me?
>>
>>97884424
>>
>>97884386
If UB becomes a toxic product (as it seems to be trending based on Spiderman and Turtles) then stores will order less UB in the future. Especially for questionable properties like Marvel, with which Wotc seems to have signed a big multi-year contract. Meanwhile Lorwyn, EoE, Tarkir are so in-demand they don't have enough. The mid-term implications are obvious.
>>
File: 1757364382609948.png (396 KB, 800x600)
396 KB
396 KB PNG
>>97884414
>>97884421
>The first pink/blue/white legendary
>>
File: ghost of UB future.png (42 KB, 1415x469)
42 KB
42 KB PNG
>>97884426
Ring it up, we got one.
>>
>>97884414
>It's a very ancient meme
Except it was an idea they were seriously thinking of doing at one point. Using Caves at the basic land type, but sure. Call it a meme i guess.
>>97884426
Yes he's shitting you.
>>
>>97884431
Nothing short of Dodge v Ford being overruled can save Magic the Gathering.
>>
>>97884426
>>97884434
Ah ya had to go and tell him.
This is a "real" leak for 2027 for what it's worth. More or less believable than the joke timeline? You tell me.
>>
>>97884432
>first YouTuber UB and first pink/blue/white precon commander

BASED BASED BASED
>>
File: 1768711972522745.png (1.91 MB, 1575x3462)
1.91 MB
1.91 MB PNG
>>97884444
I wish to cum in Elk's fursona, diaper OFF
>>
>>97884441
I'll never not laugh about how this dumbass didn't even bother checking his chatgpt generated shit post and let MH3 get through.
>>
>>97884431
>Meanwhile Lorwyn, EoE, Tarkir are so in-demand they don't have enough.
if they were truly in demand understocking would hurt the lgs
which means they actually knew what the numbers were that's why they didn't order more, assuming the lgs is in the black overstocking is a better bullet to bite than understocking
>yes you are an idiot and don't know anything about economics
>>
File: Defender.png (4.83 MB, 1994x1496)
4.83 MB
4.83 MB PNG
Post decks
>>
>>97884424
no idea what FF14 is but im sure its one of your favorite games to play and that you never once played any of them from 1-10. or were even alive when half those games were new.

go draft some groom-haven pre-release man yeah thats the good stuff that "universe within" stuff great writing from the literal scum of the earth written for "people" like you
>>
>foil only
roundhouse kick wotc into the concrete
>>
>>97884441
I don't think a single Atog was in the MH3 set
>>
File: Abdel Red.jpg (4.39 MB, 4032x3024)
4.39 MB
4.39 MB JPG
>>97884448
>>
>>97884455
>no idea what FF14 is but im sure its one of your favorite games to play
Sure sounds a lot like you do know what it is and know why me bringing it up would be insulting to you.

I haven't played any Final Fantashit game because I am not:
a) 30+
b) autistic
c) a troon

How many of those can you deny for yourself?
>>
>>97884460
>fag Command Tower
>>
>>97884431
Cool anecdote bro! Meanwhile my buddy has two vending machines he fills with TCGs including magic and Tarkir EoE and Lorwyn barely sold their boxes and there's 80%+ left of the second one while he's onto his 3rd/4th box of LotR and FF and in a facebook poll the most requested additions were Fallout and Ixalan.
>>
File: PXL_20260222_154805975.jpg (2.12 MB, 3965x2361)
2.12 MB
2.12 MB JPG
>>97884448
>>
>>97884464
>I haven't played any Final Fantashit game because I am not:
>a) 30+
ok zoomzoom
>>
>>97884468
>Proxies
Gay
>>
>>97883955
I wish they had done the opposite.
>>
>>97884470
>he concedes that he's a middle aged balding tranny with autism
lol
>>
>>97884475
whatever you say zoomie
>>
>>97884460
Based Talisman. That one is my favorite of that art cycle. It's just too bad I hate White and Red.
>>
>>97884447
Are you retarded? I actually talk to my LGS owners and they literally could not order more ECL or EOE for a while.
>>
>>97884478
Jump higher if you want the last word
>>
>>97884345
What colors would each Elder Scrolls race be?
Dual or tri?
>>
>>97884473
Not buying the same expensive cards over and over again.
>>
>>97884480
cool anecdote, wotc will totally stop requests for more orders of "best-selling UW sets" fr fr
>>
>>97884407
Purple is just Esper.
>>
File: Myrel update.jpg (4.78 MB, 4032x3024)
4.78 MB
4.78 MB JPG
>>97884448
Fair magic
>>
>>97884467
What 3rd world country do you live in with trading card vending machines? And the vending machine crowd (casuals and passersby) is not the same as the regular Magic audience.
>>
>>97884486
>i had gay sex exactly once so it doesn't count
you don't need to twist yourself into these arbitrary rules to justify being f2p you know, just proxy even if you don't own a single genuine copy
>>
>>97884493
>Gold border
Not legal, please replace
>>
>>97884466
>sodomites actually believe they own the rainbow
They should remember what it symbolizes.
>>
>>97884489
WotC have a limited number of printers and this has caused supply problems before. If they have contractual obligations to other companies to print a set amount of product with their IP on it do you think they’re going to break that agreement to print more of their own product because it’s successful? How do you think that would go down in court?
>>
File: images (9).jpg (62 KB, 516x387)
62 KB
62 KB JPG
>>97884497
>vending machines are...le 3rd world

holy mutteroni
>>
>>97884484
Dunmer surely have to be grixis, I don’t know how you’d portray them as just 2 colors
But simpler races like Nords can just be boros
>>
>>97884414
I've said it before and I'll say it again.
If we ever get an AU with Mirrodin Pure, it'll be a timeline where Memnarch successfully steals Glissa's spark, but accidentally cleanses himself of phyresis in the process and successfully rallies the Mirrodins against New Phyrexia
>>
File: pwned.jpg (4 KB, 275x183)
4 KB
4 KB JPG
>>97884464
I am definitely over 30, if youre not over 30 you dont belong here low-t

everyone knows the games after 12 have become not RPGs and are modern action sloppa- the fact you jumped to identify it shows me you have played it and are familiar with how shitty of a game it is

and not an autistic or a troon but I take it you have been groomed by troons and are a mental retard. let me guess you also haven't gotten laid once in the last 2 years and not even 30 yet have a massive receding hairline

low-T numale. if you dont remember seeing 9/11 on TV you've got shit in your diapers. cri moar faggot
>>
>>97884489
Ah so you are retarded, got it
>>
>>97884511
I'm ok with this
>>
>>97884506
>wotc agreed to print less of their UW because they've calculated that UB will sell more to distributors which is all they care about
that is even more damning to the UW brand, thanks for admitting it's total shit
>>
>>97884516
Peak soi post. How many funkopops do you own?
>>
File: The Master Plan.jpg (559 KB, 3072x1893)
559 KB
559 KB JPG
>>97884448
Get a load of THIS
>>
>>97884517
uh oh melty
>>
>>97884520
If the game is rigged so shareholders have excuses to keep pulling the UB slot machine crank, that must mean in-universe is bad actually
>>
>>97884497
>What 3rd world country do you live in with trading card vending machines?
Probably the US
>>
>>97884509
Are you that anon and you're saying your friend has vending machines in Japan? and that your friend's vending machine experience is indicative of the north american trading card market? seems a lil silly desu
>>
File: 1772296285438264.png (639 KB, 1200x369)
639 KB
639 KB PNG
>>97884510
Altmer
>Esper
Argonians
>Sultai
Bosmer
>Abzan
Bretons
>Bant
Dunmer
>Grixis
Imperials
>Jeskai
Khajiit
>Mardu
Nords
>Temur
Orsimer
>Jund
Redguards
>Naya
>>
>>97884172
...and that's a good thing!
>>
>>97884527
correct, maybe UW should've sold more, useless thing
>>
>>97884531
I can't argue against this, it is sound.
>>
>>97884497
yo kid go to bed its a school night

>other countries have had (for several decades now) vending machines with beer, vapes and even COLLECTIBLE TRADING CARDS because American nig nogs and meth-heads dont break into them 3 hours after they're installed
>>
>>97884467
Do you know what vending machines he has and how many different pack options they hold? I might want to look into this for my store.
>>
>>97884499
I'm fine with all the "gay sex," thanks.
>>
File: mor-71-offalsnout.jpg (238 KB, 672x936)
238 KB
238 KB JPG
>>97883934
>Reflect on what could have been. Name something from a recent set that you wish had happened but didn't.
I understand why, but I would liked to have seen a lot more evoke elementals from Lorwyn. Another reason it should have been two sets
>>
>>97884518
Honestly, it's what I hope for.
>>
>>97884542
Nah instead they get into shoot outs at 10 am for pokemon cards
>>
>>97884578
I go school learn I say fuck you cop I no drunk then bang bang he shoot my tire
>>
File: got-em.gif (307 KB, 220x220)
307 KB
307 KB GIF
>>97884521
the same amount as houses you own= precisely 0
>>
>>97884578
no clue what this is referencing since Japs can't own guns generally aside from some very strict shotgun and hunting rifle permits and one of the the last major shootings there (assassination of Shinzo Abe in 2022) was with a fallout 4 style Pipe pistol
>>
>>97884538
Sotha-Sil
>Esper
Almalexia
>Initially Mardu, but Rakdos by death
Vivec
>Five color and/or colorless
>>
>>97884641
Still good
>>97884531
After chewing on it a bit, the only thing I'd change is swapping khajiit and redguard, mainly because the cats have such a rigid but diverse biologically-centric hierarchy. Feels very G to me. I get the nomadic reasoning, but still.
>>
www.youtube.com/watch?v=t5OPALGswJA

This is what it used to feel like to play Magic. Bring it back.
>>
>>97884677
>swapping khajiit and redguard
It's tough because Cats are Naya coded in Magic, but Khajit tend to be scum coded in TES, hence black and Mardu.
>>
Why the change?
>>
>>97884724
>>
>>97884724
>>97884731
Probably gonna play better in limited, easier to reliably hit lifegain triggers every turn and can do it multiple times per token if it goes unblocked or survives combat. Encourages interaction, I can see it being a lot more fun overall desu
>>
>>97884531
Yeah about right. Good effortpost
>>
>>97884724
Isn’t that just the pest made by one of the Legendaries? I think other pest creators in the set are the normal ones
>>
>>97884686
Arent Redguard slavers too? Whereas the non humanoid khajit have a whole in tune with nature thing. I think they’re similar enough to Mardu khans and naya nature shit that WotC would keep them to those lines
>>
>>97884531
>argonian
>Sultai
You're right, but i still don't like it.
>>
>>97883934
>Reflect on what could have been. Name something from a recent set that you wish had happened but didn't.
Proper skeleton commander that I like. This applies to every set in the last 20+ years
>>
>>97884818
>They finally release a skeleton commander, who is a lord, and makes his own army
>The monkey's paw curls
>He's mono-red for some reason.
>>
>make a new deck
>17 cards that let you draw, combination of permanents and instants
>draw zero of them 4 games in a row
>first one to lose during all 4 games at game night
Holy shit I want to fucking die I'm so fucking miserable right now
>>
>>97884794
I think the commander deck pests are the originals while the mains set pests are the new ones that trigger on attack.
>>
>>97884825
You'll get em next week anon.
>>
>>97884821
haha I would be SO FUCKING MAD. I've built one monored deck and it's so awful to play I swore to never do it again. Though if it'd be done in a neat enough way like "when you cast a burn spell create an X/X skeleton where X is the damage dealt" or something to that effect I might be compelled to do it
>>
>>97884836
Maybe. I forgot just how extremely fucking miserable Magic is when you only draw one card per turn. Oh my god I was bored out of my mind going "draw, pass" all damn night
>>
>>97884825
>>97884842
Sis? Your mulligans?
>>
>>97884821
>mono-red
I'd like one with red just for Skelemental alone.
>>
>>97884842
Yeah it sucks ass when you have nothing on board and no card flow, siting through three turns of people with triggers and nonsense. I usually try to pass the time by getting excited for whatever the most unconventional deck at the table is. If the Kurkesh player so much as plays a basic mountain, I'm cheering and applauding, a tear dripping from my eye
>>
>>97883934
>Reflect on what could have been. Name something from a recent set that you wish had happened but didn't.
Ban Rhystic Study in EDH at every bracket level.
>>
>>97884896
play Zur's Weirding or Chains of Mephistopheles or any of the dozens of draw hate/limit cards if you're that upset. Also it's banned in b2 and b1 already.
>>
>>97884896
Try Breathstealer's Crypt.
>>
>>97884274
Nissa's character of racist elf was completely destroyed and now her entire character is simping for Chandra. Chandra used to be hot but now she lost her tits and gained a manjaw. Nothing good came of WotC pairing Nissa with Chandra.
>>
>>97884899
>>97884907
>I always have it
Spoken like true noobs of the game. Did you just start playing a year ago, champs?
>>
>>97884896
Curse of Fool's Wisdom, Orcish Bowmasters, Fate Unraveler, Leela, Kederekt Parasite, Notion Thief, Nekusar, Omen Machine, Phyrexian Tyranny, Razorkin Needlehead, Scrawling Trawler, Smothering Tithe, Sheoldred, Spiteful Visions, Uba Mask
>literally every card that says exile/destroy an enchantment
You're actually a retard if you think Rhystic or even Mystic are a big deal.
>>
>>97884921
>they always have it
What an astonishing argument. Just build Xyris and they won't cast their Rhystics anymore.
>>
>>97884921
>haha he doesn't know rhystic is already banned at b2
>>
>>97884896
>i want to play B3+
>NO NOT LIKE THAT!!!!
lmao gonna D-Tutor my Rhystic just to watch you squirm like the little bitchpussy you are.
>>
>>97884896
Agreed.
>>
>>97884802
teslore came up clean-ish in my half-assed search so I dunno about Redguard slavery
>>
File: 1776057315918627.webm (1.57 MB, 1280x720)
1.57 MB
1.57 MB WEBM
Can you spot the UB player? Its hard because they look just like us
>>
Obsessed.
>>
>>97884896
If they're going to keep Rhystic legal they should unban Dockside as well
Rhystic is subjectively more powerful and objectively more pervasive than Dockside ever was, in every power level
>>
>>97884825
This never happened by the way
>>
>>97885013
That's actually a MTG player who hates UB
>>
>Went through all the trouble of uploading Dr. Who gif to Catbox and finding a YouTube link with timestamp to add it to the OP
>Anon makes OP early to troll
>>
>>97885049
This never happened by the way
>>
File: file.png (96 KB, 300x212)
96 KB
96 KB PNG
>>97885037
I wish it never happened
>>
>>97885050
There's always next thread
>>
I might've caused the meltdown of the gay bolas poster a while ago. I saved his pictures with his filenames and wrote straight bolas. Forcing him to use a different picture, because I already posted it(duplicate file found). He must've been seething and decided to put it in the OP instead. Sorry guys. I just like fucking with mentally ill ritualposters.
>>
File: 1771682824492124.jpg (27 KB, 596x335)
27 KB
27 KB JPG
>>97885050
>>
>>97885057
>mentally ill ritualposters
redundant
>>
>>97885057
Didn't he just post the same image with one pixel changed?
>>
>>97885065
He did. But stopped doing it after a while.
>>
>>97885057
>Pictures
It was one picture nearly a year ago. Don't gas yourself up that much.
>>
>>97885069
Maybe he too got tired of seeing MtG's downward spiral and stopped playing, and consequently stopped coming here. His decks haven't been updated in a while.
>>
>>97885057
>because I already posted it(duplicate file found)
Changing hashes is so easy you can do it by accident and 4chan's entire image backend is based on MD5 hashes. At least one of the mobile browsers can automatically randomize hashes and filenames for every image you upload and I'm pretty sure there's a userscript to do it on desktop as well.
>>
>>97885057
>>97885065
>Stopping a ritualposter from posting for a short time
>Forcing him to change 1 pixel in that image
This tiny inconvenience might make them go crazy. Well done
>>
>the ritualposter is actually extremely based and it didn't bother him at all
Take it easy, schizo. No need to reply a dozen times here
>>
Classic poopdickschizo
>>
>>97885072
So somebody else is shoving his retarded gay bolas stuff into the OP? I doubt it.
>>
>>97885082
I'm not the Dr. Who poster but I was the guy willing to put it in the OP, so I believe it.
>>
>>97885084
multiple people might have posted gay bolas as well then and multiple people act like poopdickschizo.
>>
File: 1760710812029583.png (19 KB, 460x211)
19 KB
19 KB PNG
Shitposting in the OP is site culture
>>
>>97885089
I'd believe that too honestly.
I did kinda find the gay bolas posting funny especially when it actually happened in the story. Honestly it was kinda nice he stopped shortly after. Felt like a closing arc to a real story.
>>
You guys act like it's not normal to indulge in a wee bit of dragon yaoi from time to time.
>>
>>97885096
Who hasn't wanted to see Bolas getting railed by Ugin every now and then?
>>
File: 1651353018311.jpg (145 KB, 600x586)
145 KB
145 KB JPG
>>97885057
Based, but you're lucky that ritualfag is one of the more tame ones. Any psychopath from /vg/ would quadruple down on that shit.
>>
I prefer dragon girls personally.
>>
>>97885098
If this was /vg/ then the mods would have to personally make every /edhg/ OP or autists would flood the board with threadwars.
>>
>>97883955
this is exactly what the GC is for. just treat it as an extention to the ban list. wotc is too pussy to use the word ban so they made this
>>
>>97885057
kek, based
Never give furniggers an inch or they'll take a mile
>>
>>97884122
I warned you about the shortprint product exclusive cards and nobody listened
>>
>>97885102
/vg/ hasn't had much moderation in a while
>>
>>97884319
sadly, every set has a new audience with untouched wallets so the money will flow for as long as they keep hopping IPs
>>
>>97885120
I just remember the time it happened in /csgog/ because someone kept accusing another anon of hiding images of MissHarvey in the OP.
It got so bad the mods ended up making the OP with purple name turned on, and the autist still said MissHarvey was in the OP and tried to force the threadwar until he got banned 3 times.
>>
>>97885065
Yeah, I saved those as well and reposted them.That's why I said pictures.
>>
>>97885027
dockside is the one that makes you way more value on the spot
>>
>>97885132
I fail to see how this accomplished anything when you were allegedly posting multiple Bolas images a thread. It sounds like you were just doing his job for him.
>>
>>97885152
Newfag
>>
>>97885153
Good retort.
>>
What is the next best one-sided boardwipe after Cyclonic Rift?
>>
>>97883934
Why are Lorwyn-Shadowmoor merfolk so goddamn fugly?
>>
>>97884896
or....get this...quit being a whiny pussy and play the rhystic tax
>>
Need some input because I can't find the relevant ruling: someone casts a multi-target spell like Hex, targeting 2 creatures from each opponent, each having only 2. Opponent A uses a redirect effect. Can he redirect one of the targets on his creature to one of the creatures already targeted controlled by opponents B or C? Or does it have to be a creature that hasn't been targeted at all yet?

Gut feeling says the latter, but need some way to make sure
>>
File: myco.jpg (100 KB, 488x680)
100 KB
100 KB JPG
>>97885240
vandalblast + Mycosynth Lattice

although more often than not Toxic Deluge + 3 (to offset a random giant growth) usually kills everyone else's shit but my commander

also 3rd ability of Mount Doom lets you sac a legendary artifact + Mount Doom to kill all but two creatures. good closer to a big board
>>
>>97885266


redirect would mean you would just be able to reorder the same 6 legal targets. redirect doesnt let you target the same creature twice. to protect your own creature you'd need to phase it out or regenerate it before the spell resolved

use the Gatherer

>Rulings
(10/1/2005)
You must target six different creatures. If you can't, you can't cast Hex. If some of the creatures become illegal targets before the spell resolves, Hex will still destroy the rest of them.
>>
>>97885240
Ruinous Ultimatum
>>
Thirty (30) starting life is objectively superior to fourty (40)
>>
>>97885565
no its not
>>
>>97885240
winds of abandon
>>
File: 20260413_082723.jpg (433 KB, 646x902)
433 KB
433 KB JPG
/tg/, I need your help editing my deck, but I don't want you to straight up fix it for me.
Relative n00b here. I'm building an Eriette deck, so a lot of auras to give away, with as much hexproof, indestructible, and "creatures can't attack you unless" as I could find.
But now the list has over 160 cards and I'm having difficulty deciding what to cut out.
So, what should I prioritize? Can you give suggestions, please?
Since this thread is almost at the bump limit, I'll repeat the question and post the list on the next thread.
>>
>>97885565
Add this to the OP
>>
>>97885625
Will do.
Also adding monoG being boring. It's no longer around, but it's in my heart.
>>
>>97885620
You want to focus on two things.
>auras that are tricky to remove, such as Darksteel Mutation that simultaneously do not cause issues for you (aka areas that do stuff like "this creature loses all abilities")
>Auras with flash so that they can be used as instant protection, something Orzhov sorely lacks
>>
>>97885240
wash out
>>
>>97885620
First, pick the much superior art.
>>
yeah, I just printed out a $1000 basic land. wotc's gonna freak
>>
>>97885640
>Darksteel Mutation
Oh, this is evil! I'll make sure to keep that kind of aura in mind. Thank you, anon.

>>97885785
Already drew the hearts, bro. No turning back now.
>>
File: 1728586211883687.png (409 KB, 780x691)
409 KB
409 KB PNG
Unban Mana Crypt
>>
I bought a bunch of planeswalkers and planeswalker support cards to turn my Atraxa deck into a super friends deck.
The prices for all those cards are all pretty low right now, so I figure planeswalker strategies are unpopular / not broken right now.
I realise I'm not original by any means, but I'm excited about it because the deck will be so different from any of my own or my friends I play with.
I don't know where else to say it.
>>
>>97885920
Shit was busted and you know it.
>wow 3 damage in a format with 40hp
>where being able to go full gas lets you murder everyone
>>
File: 1757235088142286.jpg (393 KB, 958x960)
393 KB
393 KB JPG
>>97883934
>TQ
>Lorwyn is the only plane where you can justify putting in large quantities of unusual creature types like kithkin, scarecrows, treefolk, or giants
>Make the set mostly comprised of already massively populated creature types like merfolk and elves
People like to bang their drums about how awesome lorwyn eclipsed was but to me that shit was a travesty. People liked the original lorwyn because of how different it was from the other planes and so much of the world had to be pushed to the side or out of the frame completely for the same shit we see on every other plane.
>>
File: Sidar Jababy Deck.jpg (1.28 MB, 3878x2227)
1.28 MB
1.28 MB JPG
>>97885988
Personally, as much as I was hoping to fall in love with Lorwyn again, I just sorta didn't. Some of the stuff is really rad and captures a bit of the aesthetic but almost as if they turned up the bloom and made it too clean.
I think people are giving it such a glowing review because it's perched precariously between Avatar and TMNT, and actual fans of the game want to give Wizards the notion that places we like, places we love, are more than enough for us. I may have been late to the party, but I went and bought the Auntie Ool precon just to make sure they got yet another sale on this, and obviously because I've wanted a -1/-1 counter deck for a while even though this precon is a hot mess out of the box.

unrelated; I reassembled almost the entirety of Sidar Jabari, but I toned the power down a considerable amount (removed most tutors, no fetches, not even my typed triome, etc). Wanted it to be a more 'silly tribal' deck with some aggression built in, and I really want to get a kill using Primal Odin at some point. New list, compared to pic related
https://archidekt.com/decks/21487765/knights_honor
>>
>>97884041
Detective set on a world where human life is so cheap was never ever going to work. The under city is extremely dangerous to anyone that isn't golgari and it's just cool, gruul has been openly waging war on all of civilization forever, simic and izzet experiments are constantly getting lose and going on rampages, and it's an open secret that orzhov just slaughters the guildless and also uses souls as a currency. This is not a world a that is terribly concerned with human lives it's ridiculous to suddenly go "oh yeah there's actually tons of detectives all over the place that aren't just the azorious and wojek"
>>
Hooooooooooooly fucking shit dog WHY is equipment such an expensive archetype? Every halfway decent card is 10 bucks, minimum. Equipment (and voltron in general) gets fucking dogwalked by so much random crap in the game these days it isn't even funny. Are people really paying these prices to get EDICT.COM'd? Yeah yeah I know proxy yadda yadda I'm gonna if I want to play it but shit dude you can't tell me every equipmentfag is paying this much to lose to a random artifact sweeper every friday night
>>
>>97886014
>think people are giving it such a glowing review because it's perched precariously between Avatar and TMNT, and actual fans of the game want to give Wizards the notion that places we like, places we love, are more than enough for us.
NTA but I didn't even think of that. Lorwyn deserved better.
>>97886067
Equipment is forever trapped in the really unhealthy spot of
>cost to play
>cost to equip
>needing to be good enough to justify
And it leads to cards that are extremely good and expensive but no one wants to use outside of equipment as an archetype. If you slap Feast and Famine into almost any deck, it does an incredible amount of work. Voltronning with Equipment is the weakest way to play it.
>>
>>97883934
>TQ
when I saw the space set commander spoilers, was excited about getting new modular tech. instead, I got charge counter combo slop.
>>
File: 1705949615324770.png (228 KB, 392x352)
228 KB
228 KB PNG
>>97886057
press F to pay respects to magnifying glass panties
>>
>>97885988
I tried to say this in the main mtg general and got blasted for it by a "but I did eat breakfast" thinker. Totally agree, a very unoriginal sequel to a very original plane.
>>
File: om1-187-urban-retreat.jpg (456 KB, 1343x936)
456 KB
456 KB JPG
>>97883934
>TQ
Spiderman had two shard tri-lands that had alternative ways to put themselves into play, but because the set was so damn small they couldn't even find room to complete the cycle for naya, esper, and jund. I don't care about Spiderman but I like both of these designs and it burns my ass the cycle is forever incomplete because the set was too small for the rest. Posting the arena art for these since any mention of Spiderman sends this thread into a killing frenzy.
>>
>>97886014
>Sworn Defender
What the fuck is the point of this card? 4 mana for a 1/3 with an ability that doesn't do anything?
>>
>>97883934
>Reflect on what could have been. Name something from a recent set that you wish had happened but didn't
I wish Lorwyn would've created a card for Adair River Span.
>>
Actually now that I think about it, ravinica is a better mafia world than new capenna
>>
>>97886057
True, but the main story is about Teysa, a guild leader, being killed, which is definitely a murder worth investigating. Where they went wrong was having a detective agency with a ton of detectives in the set. Even if they absolutely wanted to do detective tribal in limited, a better execution would have been a threshold 1 or Homicidal Seclusion type strat for it.
>>
>>97883934
>Reflect on what could have been. Name something from a recent set that you wish had happened but didn't.
I wish Jeskai had been Naya or Bant instead. I wish Prowess and spellslinging didn't become the "thing" for monks. I wish Monk's Fist didn't suck absolute ass. I wish Monk Class wasn't shitty.
>>
>TQ
Kinda something that I wanted to happen, but in a different set.
The idea of God's corrupted through worship.
Cool concept. Outrageously poor execution.
Having the Phyrexians "invade everywhere all at once" is already an outrageously stupid idea for a million reasons. But this one especially pisses me off because you could have easily built an entire set around this single card if you just did it with the Eldrazi instead. MOM already had way too much stuff going on, it didn't need something like this as a cliff note.
>>
>>97886116
I also very obvious they wanted to do a labyrinth set not a lorwyn set
>>
>>97884135
I used it to counter an overwhelming stampeded on someone completely swinging out at me and it was the most satisfying thing watching their wincon crumble
>>
>>97886125
Did people make proxies of those arena cards yet? Haven't seen those in real life
>>
>>97884041
I kinda feel the same way about Caverns of Ixalan.
IIRC, the way it originally ended made it seem like they were going to have the dinosaurs invade the vampires, which would have been kinda cool.
But suddenly we got TIME TO SPELUNK!
>>
>>97886067
>talking shit about voltron
Apologize to my wife right now before she slaps your shit.
>>
>>97886179
What, you mean the art or just the cards as written?
I've got a buddy who owns urban retreat, but naturally, it's peter Parker's bedroom
>>
>>97886195
I'm talking about the arena versions. People online cry so much about the spider-man art. I thought somebody might make proxies of it to not see ub art. Haven't seen it yet
>>
File: runners-bane.png (279 KB, 298x431)
279 KB
279 KB PNG
>>97886146
A pretty easy solution would have been to do a Dragon's Maze thing and create a situation where every guild is inclined to participate and want to solve the murder for a reward. Sure a guild like Rakdos having detectives is stupid, but if the guild were doing it to acquire something I could entertain the facade.
>>
>>97884135
HELP GAVIN BLACK IS BEING HARSH AGAIN
>>
>>97886071
Lorwyn is one of the coolest planes we ever got, so it definitely deserved another turn but you gotta remember it was a block before. Lorwyn, Eventide, Shadowmoor, and we still had a feeling of so much more to see.
>>97886116
A lot of those people are on that level or feel genuinely illiterate
>>97886129
The way I like Sworn Defender is the way I like a lot of bad cards
>on theme/in tribe
>unique and weird ability
>unlikely anyone has ever seen one in the wild
For actual usecase, if you keep 1 mana open it's a perfect blocker against a LOT of pumped up threats.
>opponent swings a 9/9 at you
>block
>pay
>have an 8/10 blocking the 9/9 now
Mind you this doesn't take into account Anthems or +1/+1 counters so she can also become, with a single counter/anthem a 9/11 (never forgetti) in this situation. Works when you swing with her too.
>>
File: file.png (5.31 MB, 2560x1440)
5.31 MB
5.31 MB PNG
Name a better commander than Azula. Protip: You can easily do this I just like her a lot
>>
>>97884371
>Ice Chandra!
>Healer Liliana!
....Why are these bad, Wizards?
>>
File: truke.jpg (21 KB, 451x443)
21 KB
21 KB JPG
Noncombat damage should count as commander damage.
>>
>>97886369
Back to bed, Nekusar.
>>
>>97886369
Just run infect, faggot.
>>
File: G-Oi7J2WMAAQA4N.jpg (46 KB, 320x446)
46 KB
46 KB JPG
>playing my mecha deck
>have mechanized production on pyrewood gearhulk, making copies of myr battlesphere with artificer class, have full anime art mecha suit krang out, army of drone tokens as well
>drop a blightsteel megatron
>I haven't attacked anyone
>just chilling
>other players are confused I dont just win
>>
File: file.png (642 KB, 488x680)
642 KB
642 KB PNG
Besides the 2 card combos this guy can do and generic rakdos wincon could you build him with a storm strategy?
>>
>>97884135
I fucking love that card. Since people know I have it they stopped attacking me when I have three mana open.
Basically you can "play" this card without actually having it in hand. Better than any counterspell in terms of fun.
>>
>tq
I just wish we could go back to blocks, even 2 set blocks. Barely got to know Bloomburrow or the returns to Tarkir and Lorwyn. Inb4 muh 3rd set doesnt sell. Don't care didnt ask, WotS sold great and 2 set blocks is also acceptable.
>>
>>97886572
*Sharts out a year of MKM followed by a year of OTJ followed by a year of DFT*
>>
kinda weird that only Paradigm are lessons but I guess it's still nice for Iroh if you happen to mill them you still get to cast them for effectively free
>>
>>97886607
Are learn cards still unplayable or are they good now?
>>
Migrate to this one later. I won't be around to bake when the actual turnover is.
>>97886605
>>97886605
>>97886605
>>
>>97886613
avatar improved them a lil bit and getting to double dip with the flashback being 1 generic really does help their case of playability
>>
>>97886617
Can you make another one? In case you're not around when the next thread is full? Thanks in advance
>>
>>97884511
Yes please Mirrodin was the best plane and wotc shat the bed by having the phyrexians win.
>>
>>97886596
Why not both? Blocks for things that need more time like Lorwyn and Tarkir and one off sets for UB slop and stuff like MKM and OTJ that dont need a whole block? The 6 sets a year with no real connection except a few throughline legendaries feels like such a rushed, schizophrenic mess.
>>
>>97886655
Didn't know that you're the new CEO of WOTC. They'll give you a block of mkm and otj and only one set of lorwyn and tarkir instead
>>
>>97886653
New Phyrexia was genuinely a cool concept and design.
It's just unfortunate that MoM fumbled it so poorly that it ended up erasing not just one, but two entire planes from the MTG lore in the process.
>>
File: IMG_2179.jpg (153 KB, 716x1000)
153 KB
153 KB JPG
>>97886067
Equipment was a great paradigm shift in the OG Mirrodin. The card you posted was from the revisit, Scars of Mirrodin and was a “chase card”, one of my buddy’s open one in his 2nd pack of Scars way back when. It was always a good card

Sword of body and mind was also pre-released earlier in 2010 in the From the Vault: Relics Mox Diamond box so it’s always been hype-beasted to all hell

Pic related is my favorite current equipment and it’s damn near $50, completely fucking stupid but it is a Voltron or “Timmy” game ender that slots into any deck in any bracket + functions as an extremely usable artifact on its own
>>
>>97886843
>From the Vault
Why the hell do we not get more of those? It should be categorized like top 10 of equipment, lands, mana rocks, etc. and sell them directly for $40.
>>
>>97886843
i remember this being a dollar chud rare...
>>
>>97887143
Consider From the Vault: Monks or maybe even From the Vault: Skeletons.
>>
>>97887252
>he thinks there's 10 skeletons
>>
So we're all agreed we stay here until 404 instead of moving that that retard furfags megalomaniacal cage?
>>
File: Eriette.png (1.07 MB, 672x936)
1.07 MB
1.07 MB PNG
>>97885620
/tg/, I need your help editing my deck, but I don't want you to straight up fix it for me.
Relative n00b here. I'm building an Eriette deck, so a lot of auras to give away, with as much hexproof, indestructible, and "creatures can't attack you unless" as I could find. But now the list has over 160 cards and I'm having difficulty deciding what to cut out.
So, what should I prioritize? Can you give suggestions, please?

- Commander
Eriette of the Charmed Apple

- Creatures
Accursed Witch
Archangel of Tithes
Archon of Absolution
Baird, Steward of Argive
Balemurk Leech
Blazing Archon
Codsworth, Handy Helper
Danitha Capashen, Paragon
Faithbound Judge
Fountain Watch
Peacekeeper
Summon: Yojimbo
True Believer
Windborn Muse

- Artifacts
Arcane Signet
Crown of the Ages
Darksteel Plate
General's Kabuto
Hammer of Nazahn
Lightning Greaves
Mithril Coat
Norn's Annex
Power Conduit
Sol Ring
Thaumatic Compass
Unwinding Clock
Whispersilk Cloak
>>
>>97887484
this thread has been so much better once the shitposters migrated. people are actually talking about cards
>>
>>97887507
Auras
Archery Training
Armor of Faith
Artificer's Hex
Brainwash
Burden of Guilt
Consecrate Land
Curse of Vengeance
Detainment Spell
Radiant Grace
All That Glitters
Ancestral Vengeance
Angelic Gift
Binding Agony
Blight
Bonds of Faith
Compulsory Rest
Contaminated Ground
Darksteel Mutation
Despondency
Favorable Destiny
Overencumbered
Relic Ward
Trespasser's Curse
Abzan Runemark
Animal Boneyard
Armament of Nyx
Arrest
Asha's Favor
Aspect of Gorgon
Blessing of Leeches
Boon of Emrakul
Cage of Hands
Curse of Shallow Graves
Curse of Vitality
Curse of the Forsaken
Pillory of the Sleepless
Redemption Arc
Soul Link
Angelic Destiny
Armored Ascension
Brink of Disaster
Candlelight Vigil
Caribou Range
Consecrated by Blood
Curse of Exhaustion
Curse of Oblivion
Cursed Land
Indestructibility
Koskun Falls
One Thousand Lashes
Takklemaggot
Torment of Scarabs
Angelic Reward
Commander's Authority
Curse of Death's Hold
Curse of Misfortunes
Curse of Thirst
Curse of Fool's Wisdom
Nettlevine Blight
Cruel Reality
Overwhelming Splendor

Non-aura Enchantments
Authority of the Consuls
Detainment Spell
Fasting
Blind Obedience
Greater Auramancy
Black Market Connections
Necropotence
Profane Procession
Ivory Mask
No Mercy
Sphere of Safety
Spiritual Asylum
>>
>>97887517
Sorceries
Akroma's Vengeance
Bone Shards
Bone Splinters
Damnation
Day of Judgment
Deadly Tempest
Depopulate
End Hostilities
Epic Downfall
Farewell
Fell
Final Act
Hour of Revelation
Peace Talks
Planar Cleansing
Promise of Loyalty

Instants
Abstruse Appropriation
Anguished Unmaking
Archenemy's Charm
Bake into a Pie
Despark
Dire Tactics
Parting Gust
Path to Exile
Swords to Plowshares
Vraska's Contempt

Lands
10 Plains
10 Swamp
Bleachbone Verge
Bottomless Vault
Command Tower
Concealed Courtyard
Desolate Mire
Fetid Heath
Fountain of Cho
Icatian Store
Isolated Chapel
Orzhov Basilica
Reliquary Tower
Scrubland
Shattered Sanctum
Shineshadow Snarl
Silent Clearing
Subterranean Hangar
Tainted Field
Vault of Champions
Vault of the Archangel
Volrath's Stronghold
>>
>>97887511
I’m just gonna fork the thread when this one expires.
/mtgnoub/?
/mtg/(-UB)g/?
I figure there’s no sense having a counterpart for each format and we can all get along
>>
>>97887719
when I was brainstorming names for it a while back I used realmtg or original mtg but now that jotc has coined the term "planar" for standard I'd maybe use that as a prefix
>>
>>97886212
any temptress spy archetype could be a rakdos detective. no need to give some demon a silly hat and a magnifying glass.
>>
>>97887507
what the fuck are you doing
create a moxfield account with a throwaway email and post a link
>>
>>97887511
not true, I'm still here, just getting old
cough cough
>>
>>97887719
>>97887789
just make the regular general UB free and create an additional /edhubg/ for the tourists
>>
>>97887511
Rent free and obsessed
>>
You're going to find out real quick what happens when you split the thread; it's not even going to be worth popping popcorn for.
>>
>yet another off topic post
Great thread, you got here
>>
>>97887507
it's shit
>>
This thread is so great now
>>
File: 1776114165868206.jpg (120 KB, 731x1024)
120 KB
120 KB JPG
>>
Hey I thought you guys were having a great thread over here. How come you have to go to the "fake one" and spam post rage bait and seethe if it's so great over here?
>>97888641
>>97888617
>>97888596
>>97888556
>>97888541
>>97888538
>>97888517
>>97888499
>>97888446
>>97888407
>>
Amazing how much you're seething about a thread existing outside of your control
>>
That's why you fags are flooding the other one with your seethe right? Because it's so good here!

Please make your gayfork already.
>>
>>97887143
replaced with Secret Lairs and Special Guests
>>
>>97888663
Really showing your hand by posting people complaining about various shitposts and saying they're all attacking you specifically. Just confirms that you're a mentally ill shitposter and behind every shitpost in /edhg/
>>
>>97888901
No u
>>
>>97888901
Cool. Good luck with your new general and stay there and stop spamming other threads when no one pays attention to your faggotry.
>>
This is a great thread now. The other thread sucks
>>
>>97884825
Hey bud. At least you didn’t get all four of your lands blown up on turn 4 because some idiot in your pod thought the best way to deal with a threat was to play a Chaos Warp that flipped into an Ulamog.
>>
Why isn't Thassa's Oracle banned? Shit is so anticlimactic
>>
>>97890479
it is already "banned" in b1-b3 so 95% of players won't ever see it



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.