[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/tg/ - Traditional Games


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


Does masculinity exist as a concept in your games. I mean in an actual unadulterated form?
>>
>>97985966
I swear to m00t, you better be sliding a puckee thread.
>>
>>97985966
Well yeah, pretty much.
Might makes right, and women are only attracted to strong Chads. In settings where guys can accumulate massive amounts of personal power without having to rely on technology or equipment, that kind of 'strongest man rules' just makes sense.
>>
>>97985993
>Might makes right
Say I tell you the sky is green. What color's the sky?
>>
>>97985993
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oo9buo9Mtos
>>
>>97986007
How hard will you beat me if I say it's blue?
>>
>>97986018
In this hypothetical, severely. For I am a crazed but powerful zealot.
>>
>>97986029
THE SKY IS GREEN AND HAS ALWAYS BEEN GREEN
HAIL THE LORD OF GREEN SKIES
>>
>>97985966
This nigga is gay and wants to see MANLY MEN
>>
>>97986031
I kind of get where he's coming from. It's like, a lot of stories feature the soft, unthreatening kind of guy as a protagonist and it feels very lame.
Hell, if you've read romantasy novels, that's not even what women want. The best-selling slop (like the Poet-Empress, or The Knight and the Moth) have the male love interests basically be dudes who have personally killed dozens of people.
>>
File: FAEruggXsAMtg2l.jpg (111 KB, 960x956)
111 KB JPG
>>97986040
Yeah I agree with that whole sentiment. I'm fed up with basedboys too. I was only having a kek
>>
>>97985993
No one wants to hear about how much you love "chad" cock.
>>
>>97986064
It's funny how your mind immediately leapt to sucking a man's cock, when a normal guy would think "I can BE Chad."
>>
>>97986060
>I'm fed up with basedboys too

No way mods banned "S O Y" here too? LMFAO FAGS
>>
>>97986072
More like you think about being in chad.
>>
>>97986072
He's a terminal bottom lol
>>
File: Green.png (421 KB, 780x438)
421 KB PNG
>>97986029
>>
Fantasy worlds are not written to be masculine. They always assume women are superior magic users. Look at Dungeons & Dragons (particularly the Forgotten Realms). Look at Dark Souls and Elden Ring. The magic is always female or some feminine force.

This is a consequence of writers being male and wanting to see women as more magical and special than they are within fantasy. Even though men were the ones poking at the mysteries of the world. It’s a form of projection. “Oh my god nature is so beautiful it’s like a woman!”. Fuck off.
>>
>>97986125
This is mostly because they're trying to make women useful in some way, without putting them at risk of physical injury.
I think one book that bucks the trend is the Second Apocalypse, there are no female warriors and women are treated the way you'd expect in a Bronze Age society.
>>
>>97986125
Females projection at nature is more so accurate. Nature is brutal and unforgiving and it will fucking rape you in the ass. It’s a Man. Not that a woman can’t be a total cunt.
>>
>>97986125
>taking FROMslop as exemplary
Jesus Christ, holy zoomer post. An extremely derivative and woke series as recent as that does not enter into the conversation.
>>
File: Lotr1.png (273 KB, 480x374)
273 KB PNG
>>97985966
Yes, in every species with sexual dimorfism related to reproduction. In my setting elves have a quasi-sexual dimorfism, not for reproduction (they just spawn from the forest), but because their god thought the differences between sexes beautiful. The female ones can become human though, if impregnated by humans.
>>
>>97986125
>>97986204
What’s fucking woke about fromslop? It’s slop not woke.
>>
>>97985966
What is and isn't masculine depends on the culture.
>>
>>97986089
You wish.
>>
>>97986073
It's a global filter.
>>
>>97985966
Traditional games?
>>
>>97986073
Fuck off newfag.
>>
>>97985966
yes, our fantasy world wemon only exist for breeding and are restricted to breeding farms. every town and city is filled with nothing but men. buff men, twink men, oily men, hairy men, all man all the time. butt sex is haneded out like candy and in our camping we are all humans actively killing off all other species to help create a homogeneous gay ethno state.
>>
>>97985966
Yes, its point costs are listed under Performance Art -> Interpretative Dance
>>
>>97986253
Women are smarter and more magical than men in ER
>>
>>97986125
>Fantasy worlds are not written to be masculine
So sword and sorcerery, grimdark, Mythic, sword and sandals, etc. generas of fantasy just don't exist to you or something?
>>
>>97987191
In what way?
From what I remember basically everything was going to shit and everyone was a failure that needed the MC to fix the world.
It's a dying world that is begging to be laid to rest but can't because of reasons. Man woman and other all are doomed fuckups who will rot and go mad unless the protag does something. If they aren't already rotten and mad, which the vast majority are.

So no. Women aren't more wise or whatever the fuck compared to men. They are retarded failures too. Some of them float around because it makes looking at their bare feet easier, lol.
>>
>>97987246
The masculine stars: 43/52/60 intelligence
The feminine moons: 68/70/72 intelligence

Rennala barged into a men’s magic club and declared looking into space to be gay and navel gazing at the moon to be good.

Imagine if some Wiccan kicked out all of the brightest scientists at NASA and then shifted their education. Oh and her IQ is also the highest.
>>
>>97987246
The masculine sun was displaced by a feminine tree lol.
>>
>>97987308
>no male was smart enough to see the moon
k e k
Bravo Femiyazaki
>>
>>97987070
So you are a nogames and a huge faggot.
>>
>>97986563
Lurk more. /tg/ isn't just for games.
>>
>>97987308
Stars are foundational. An origin point. The moon is conjunctive. An end point.
>>
>>97985966
Does it in real life?
>>
>>97985966
Yes, in the ancient greek sense of "smaller penis = more masculine".
>>
>>97985966
Unadulterated masculinity is relaxed, confident and secure. It has nothing to prove, it is usually quiet outside of a crisis.

The skilled carpenter who can fell his own wood, who lives a quiet life on the edge of the village with his beloved wife for decades, raising his kids, helping them get set up, looking after the grandkids all as he develops a reliable reputation as the guy who can build and fix anything wooden, who's repaired every house at one time or another, known by all as a dependable rugged man who loves a fine ale after a hard day's work is experiencing unadulterated masculinity.

An influencer with no hobbies, no family, no fucking life outside of trying to prove he's the alpha dog and you should buy his hollow life is a pathetic shell chasing masculinity with no ability to ever understand it. The man who craves power simply to have it, not because nobody else is fixing the community, is also an insecure chaser.

Two thirds of our worlds problems come from the fact that these insecure chasers see one another, and because they have no concept of masculinity go "Ah another gigachad like me" and start networking and shaking hands and forming a class of power-holding wimps with the emotional maturity of a toddler.
>>
>>97985966
Masculinity can only exist as the byproduct of becoming confident in your abilities to do something. You cannot pursue masculinity itself directly.
>>
File: 1768586523638021.jpg (631 KB, 1125x1330)
631 KB JPG
I run the most hypermasculine possible.

That's why the men in it understand that women are inferior in every respect and lack the basic intellectual and emotional capability of men to such a degree that they are incapable of true love. For TRVE LOVE you must find a twink with curly haired and alabaster skin like the noblest statuary, teach him rhetoric statecraft, philosophy and military strategy before you write him hypermasculine love poetry and oil up his thighs.
>>
>>97986253
>just climb in the coffin an you gender will be changed!!
>>
>>97992988
Nigga you gay
>>
>>97993017

A weak and effeminate Parthian is behind this post. A barbarian will get henpecked by their wife then pretend a bithynian hoplite with blond curls and freckles isn't masculine.
>>
>>97993151
Yeah this nigga gay
>>
I play Deathwatch so the players are all space marines. Very masculine but in a way completely divorced from sexuality.
>>
>>97987308
>Oh and her IQ is also the highest.
Doubtful, considering the two founders are made of the stuff of sorcery and indeed magic itself.
>>
>>97985966
It's more implicit than explicit, because reading books on the subject of masculinity isn't a very adventurer-y passtime.
Adventurers are more "Praxis" oriented.
They're they guy you see cited in said book.
>>
>>97985966
You want to know if a social construct is present in collaborative game-fiction in an in-universe concrete form? Like, as a stat? Or as a character?
>>
Femboys are considered a rare "ascended gender". They are the kings, high priests, and court magicians. Traditional masculinity ate the loyal guards and women the artisans.

The gods are thought to cross dress
>>
>>97986201
>Nature is brutal and unforgiving
Yeah so a woman then.
>>
>>97985966
We play Runequest, from aloof purity of Dayzatar to primal savagery of Zorak Zoran it has it all.
>>
>>97992988
So you are far too retarded play tabletop games and a huge faggot.
>>
>>97995008
Says the guy who likes the taste of dick
>>
>>97999905
Nah that just you, Sir Fagalot.
>>
>>98000235
>projecting
You can’t turn me gay, you gay retard.
>>
>>97985974
Who is moot
>>
>>97986125
>They always assume women are superior magic users. Look at Dungeons & Dragons
Fucking what? What kind of retardation is this
>>
>>98001836
one of the old 4chan mascots, like longcat, or pedobear
>>
>>97986125
you come off as a closet fag
>>
>>97986125
Gardnerian Wicca Woo-Woo.
>>
>>97986125
They hated him cause he was right.
>>
>>98004960
Ehh it's more accurate for stuff like wheel of time and sword of truth
>>
>>98005579
But he's telling the truth. I always found it weird how both in the roleplay and technology space, a lot of the guys like to write "her" as the default gender for specific things. And I realized it was because of their projection of being the typical "women are great' mentality. Which explains why nerd spaces got hit so hard by liberal and feminist policies.
>>
>>97986007
do you think "right" means "correct" in that sentence?
>>
>>97986040
well yeah, obviously. those stories aren't written for women, so why would the protag be designed to appeal to women?
>>
>>97989568
Yes it is.
>>
>>98001844
Magic is literally a woman in Dee en Dee and you can even FUCK her if she lets you :^)
>>
>>98004740
This is the funniest part of the origins of Wicca to me. It was never some ancient religion. At best it repurposed ancient or antiquated ideas. But it was started by a horny and perverted old man.
>>
>>97986125
>>98005635
It could also be for balancing reasons.

Males = strength
Women = magic
>>
>>97986125
>“Oh my god nature is so beautiful it’s like a woman!”
Aren’t male animals frequently the more beautiful in nature? We’ve become blind to it because we (men) are all attracted to women for the most part, and because of this we refrain from seeing ourselves as the more beautiful sex, especially due to fears of being called a homosexual.
>>
>>98008128
The greatest wizards in D&D lore have been men.
>>
>>98008233
In the Forgotten Realms the strongest spellcasters are women not men.
>>
>>98008243
>forgotten realms

There's your problem.
>>
>>98008251
I’m sorry it’s Ed Greenwood’s fetish to be dominated by a big breasted sorceress
>>
>>98008279
Among many, many others.
>>
>>98007011
Ethics and Morality are downstream of Logic and Reason, as well as Objectivity. Might is no more capable of making things wrong or right than it is changing the color of the sky.
>>
>>98001836
THERE IS NO M00T BUT M00T AND SNAX KS HIS PROPHET! PURGE THE INFIDEL!
>>
>>98008279
considering how he looked, not surprised.
>>
>>98005579
>Wheel of time
>Two sex based magics (shhh book readers)
>Different but equal
>Entire plot of the books is women are retarded and fucking up thet last battle which is why A MAN is needed, and not just ANY MAN, THE FUCKING DRAGON REBORN, and in fact the best women mages in that entire series are ones who learn to be soft and submissive and get married (nyn, morraine, siuan, even alanna). The worst female mage, is the opposite of that and Eggy gets her ass killed for not doing it.
>>
>>98008626
Unfortunately right and wrong are academic concepts in the face of violence, or might. The fly's morality means nothing to the spider, for it is simply mightier.
>>
>>98001831
That is because you are one, retard fag
>>
>>98008251
Yeah, you have brain damage.
>>
>>98001836
Some skinny dork who unironically got groomed by Jeffrey Epstein in 2011.
>>
Sodomy and buggery.
>>
>>98007022
I mean
Who's the target audience for the unthreatening numale protagonist?
Not being facetious, who actually wants that?
>>
>>98005635
I always thought it was just players who speak languages like spanish, french and german where words come with gender pronouns attached to them
>>
>>9798596
First World Problem: Zeta Male Fear
Lack of masculinity being named out loud in an rpg session. The need for oiled Greek digital abs on half-nekkid pederastic "men" ...

>>97985993
Dickless incel talking about strength and what women are attracted to. Pure 4chan.
>>
>>98010805
None of those were a huge part of the tabletop scene in america. It was entirely from americans.
>>
File: 1759462917788674.jpg (53 KB, 612x446)
53 KB JPG
>>97985966
>I mean in an actual unadulterated form?
as in, woodworking, fishing and playing with model trains? fuck yeah I love genuine masculinity
or do you mean some homoerotic fantasy for dudes who romanticize war and spend way too much time "mirin" the """"aesthetics"""" of oiled up muscular torsos?
>>
>>98011302
>it's gay to perfect the body god gifted you

Just say you're a pussy who would be afraid to do any kind of violence. We get it.
>>
>>98008626
So were you going to answer what I asked?
>>
>>98010582
Why do you think the protagonist in fiction for women is always an utterly forgettable blank slate with barely any personality or distinguishing characteristics? Think hard.
>>
File: IMG_9444.png (844 KB, 734x960)
844 KB PNG
>>97985966
Yes
>>
File: file.png (1.66 MB, 2600x3400)
1.66 MB PNG
>>98012157
>>
>>98010857
I really don't get why you're so upset about this. Is something about this making you feel attacked?
>>
>>98008626
>Ethics and Morality are downstream of Logic and Reason
It's the exact other way around. If you weren't capable of making value judgements, you wouldn't have anything to be logical about.
>>
>>98008626
so were you going to answer what I asked?
>>
>>98008626
well?
>>
>>98008626
No, morality comes from preference and emotion, and ultimately from biology, and there is nothing rational about it in the slightest, except in the sense that it happened to improve survival fitness. It is not rational in the sense of conscious reasoning.
>>
>>97985966
No. I play Symbaroum.
>>
>>98021545
Ruined/tainted by 5e
>>
>>97986007
do you think "right" means "correct" in that sentence?



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.