Simple and Clean EditionTQ: Would you ever run a vanilla legendary creature like one of the Muraganda legends as a commander?
Next person who posts in this thread is an elfsissy
Never, I only run elves
>>98112932I ain't afraid of no namecalling dinosaur; but it seems I was a bit slow falling on the sword.
Best food commander?
>>98112883If it was sufficiently funny, absolutely.>>98112969Based elfchad.
>>98112883Based. This is the thread.
>>98112972
>>98112980This seems really bad actually
>>98112982
>>98112988Wayne Barlowe is one of the most influential artists no one has heard ofDefined the look of xenofauna since the millennium
>>98112883>TQYes. Kalascion's three shot stat line is unironically a solid starting point for a cheap voltron commander.
>>98113000Checked, and he's great. I kind of wish I had a few dinosaurs to add. I might toss his iconic rex as Rotting Regisaur even though it's not at all a zombie.
Any tips on building this deck? I'm particularly attached to the character
>>98113059Play big idiots and turn them sideways
>>98113059Hydras?
>>98113059Basic +1/+1 stompy with nu vorinclex and the plant wurm from eoeSelesnya enchantress Yuna is a reanimator enchantress stompy deck if you want a different flavor of big beater
>>98112883LOOK AT THE WEBSITE, SEE THE POST (THE PART OF COMITTEE REMOVED) THE WIZARD COAST BRACKETSTEIN EDH CONTROLS! THE GAVIN VERHEY BROADCAST CHANNEL, THE MOTHERSHIP UPDATES! THE BRACKETSTEIN RULE 0 CONTROLS. THE GAMECHANGER SOCIAL CONTRACT CONTROLS! THE LATEST COMMANDER UPDATES TO CONTAIN ALL BRACKETSTEIN CONTROLS. EVEN IN LGS TABLES OF MENERY PEDIGREE PLAYGROUPS! VISIBLE UNIVERSES BEYOND, THE MASS LAND DESTRUCTION SOFTBAN LOOP!NET DECKLISTS FOR YOURSELF.THERE IS NO ESCAPE FROM THIS WORSE GANGSTER WOTC STATE, USING ALL OF THE DEADLY BRACKETSTEIN CONTROLS. IN 2025 PINKERTON GANGSTER UNIONBUSTERS BEAT ME BLOODY, DRAGGED ME IN CHAINS FROM MAGIC CON LAS VEGAS. SINCE THEN I HIDE IN FORCED DOCKSIDELESS POVERTY, ISOLATED ALONE IN THIS LOW DEADLY MIDRANGE OLD HOUSE.THE BRAZEN, DEADLY GANGSTER PINKERTONS AND MIDRANGE PUPPET UNDERLINGS SPRAY ME WITH SNOWBALL LANDS DECKS FROM ULTIMATE GUARDS AND EVEN SATIN TOWERS, CROSSOVER ASSAULTS. EVEN IN TABLETOP SIMULATOR, WITH TREASURES, EVEN CLUES AND FOODS, EVEN DEADLY VALUE ENGINES, OR ARISTOCRAT SHOCK “DEATH TRIGGERS” EVEN SECRET LAIR PUSHED ACROSS FORMAT TRAJECTION OF UNIVERSES BEYOND CROSSOVER ITEMS, OR EVEN BLOODY FINISHER “DOING THE THING” TO SHUT ME UP FOREVER WITH A “MLD UNDEFENDABLE EXTERMINATION”, EVEN WITH TRAINED PARROTING BRACKET DEFENDERS, IN MAXIMUM SNOWBALL DEATHSTAR PRISON FOR WRITING THESE UNFORGIVABLE, TRUTHS. UNTIL MY “UNDEFENDABLE EXTERMINATION”, I, ANON E. MOUS, ESQUIRE, 314 E. MAIN STREET, WAUKESHA, WISCONSIN. I STAND ALONE AGAINST YOUR MAD DEADLY WORLD-WIDE CONSPIRATORIAL GANGSTER MARO TCG COMMUNISM WITH WALL TO WALL DEADLY GANGSTER PROTECTION, LIFE LONG SWORN CONSPIRATORS TOLARIAN INCORPORATED ORGANIZED CRIME, THE WIZARDS AND JUDGES, THE DEADLY SNEAK PARROTING PUPPET GANGSTERS USING ALL THE GANGSTER DEADLY BRACKETSTEIN CONTROLS!
Thoughts?
>>98113174>63>36Perfection
>>98113174Why no thrumming stone?
>>98113168Now this is the type of schizoposting I can get behind.
>>98113174Bracket 1 does not get much better than this.
>>98113196This was the top google rezultI can't read that shit
>>98113208It says 由你施放的咒语具有涟动4。(每当你施放咒语时,你可以展示你牌库顶的四张牌。你可以从所展示的牌中施放与之同名的咒语,且不需支付其法术力费用。将其余的牌置于你的牌库底。)
>>98113196Listen here you little shit. Once you start adding that shit it dilutes the purity. What next? Coat of arms, banner of kinship? Fuck that.
Maha is cute!
>>98113174Excuse me?
Now let's play a game called "posting art that doesn't suck"
Todays mail day was a good day
>>98113292This is one of my favorites, too bad the card sucks.
>>98113292Ok
Are you the other anon building The Destined Warrior?
>>98113353>>98113315FUCK
>>98113315I fucking LOVE mail day
>>98113330I think WOTC does that on purpose. Puts good art on shitty cards just to try to get more people to want them.
>>98113448That artwork is on a garbage common. Meanwhile here is what they put on a mythic rare. Jesus Christ how horrifying.
>>98113489Forgot my image
PURPLE MANA BROSI know it's just butthole mana but imagine
>>98112932Redpill me on Etali. Is he too slow for B3?
>>98113492At least Archangel of Titties has other printings.
>>98113514It's okay in b3 the problem is that Gruul Etali is 10,000 times better
>>98113353>>98113360Probably!Behold, a 4!
>>98113537Yeah he's just too pricy for my taste and I'm pretty fatigued on green in general, feels like easy mode.
>>98113514Depends on the kind of B3 IMO. B3 runs the gamut of "CEDH with only 3 gamechangers" to "Constructed but with Ancient Tomb instead of a basic land."
>>98113555The B3 I'd be looking to build towards probably is a bit closer to the former, we basically expect people to attempt game-winning plays right on turn 7 and games don't usually go beyond turn 8.
>>98113562I'd think he's pretty damn slow then.
>>98112972There's no question
>>98112972NONE OF THESE >>98112991>>98113580>>98112980makes food for their friends, all awful chefs
>>98113602>french
>>98113497>6 different mana symbolsMOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOORRRRREEEEEEEEEE
>>98113608It's just this and gonna be gay Thanos shit. I need another drink.
>>98113607Voulez vous couchez avec moi, anon?
>>98113619Oh wait fuck this IS about the Marvel set, isn't it? Fuckin A, man.
>>98113602Ygra makes food OF his friends
>>98113497>20+ year old creature typeholy shit this small stuff makes me so hyped for some reason. anyone have an idea??
>>98113497You missed the best one:>Exile all the cards from your handTHE GLOW UP IS REAL
>>98113645it says 'subtype' without mentioning creature, im guessing World Enchantment or they finally figured out how to make Fortifications work
>>98113656ahhh fuck. well okay still hyped though
>Ward – Get five poison countersOh my god I know this is gonna be monoblack or black/green at most but godDAMMIT my Skrelv deck is salivating at the thought of them doing something whacky and making it white
>>98113656it's probably Arcane, Future Sight is a bit under two decades ago, not over
>>98113534LILIANA NO!
>>98113682>5 mana single target removalGod I will never get over how bad trash commons used to be. Kinda shocked they even let it have instant speed
Planeswalkers are the ultimate timmy fun card type so I'm building a deck around them using the thing. >Sarkhan the Endless>All my Planeswalkers are now creatures>Protection MagicI assume this would work, right? Along with any effects that let me move counters from one creature to another?
>>98113739yes it works, it just puts a shield counter on them, it won't keep them as creatures. it also won't stop them from being put in the gy when they hit zero loyalty.
>>98113752who the hell runs Spark Rupture
>>98113656It's going to be a Tower.
>>98113779Shit I'm thinking about it, never saw it before. I've had quite a few instances where my Guff deck had many walkers out and I played a boardwipe. Would've been easy full-swings>my walkers are now creatures>someone plays a boardwipe>instant speed enchantment removal on my own Spark Rupture in response to make them not-creatures againWould be pretty funny, senpai
>>98113534Loot took her breasts too huh
I'm playing with some beginners. The problem is that the games take way too long, as they have to read and understand all the cards. And they are slow in general. Can you recommend some decklists or precons? Are the Bloomburrow precons good for that purpose?
Thirty (30) starting life is objectively superior to fourty (40)
>>98113824The ones with the nonbinary characters failed. Curious.
>>98113824Build beginner decks yourself. Monocolor, $50 budget.One of the legendary pride mates for white.Krenko for red.Jadar for black.Elves in green.Literally anything that says "whenever you cast an instant or sorcery" for blue.
>>98113492This one actually looks better from a technical art perspective.
>>98112883I'm content with this op as long as pds aka furfag doesn't have it>TQOnly yargle and multani which I do have a deck for
>>98113860>50 dollar budgetloljust buy them the fucking commander starter decks from a couple of years ago. 50 dollar budget commander decks are a meme from a decade ago.
>>98113824Animated Army is a good deck and pretty straightforward to play. Family Matters is kind of janky because of the weird inclusions in the 99. I'm not really familiar with the other two decks.
>>98113860Yeah, that's a good idea too. The problem is always to build simple decks that somehow stay engaging. You play Krenko one or two times and you have seen everything.
My question last thread got ruined by the melty, so here it is again:What would (You) do to improve this deck? I have a few obvious cuts in Elixir of Immortality and City on Fire but I don't know what I should add in.https://moxfield.com/decks/L8BjkFwhl06kQ-L2G3r-mw
>>98113059Walking Ballista/Freed From the Real combo
>>98114061>open deck list>spot UB slop>close the tab
>>98114072Guy who obsessively catalogues every UB card so he knows whether to be offended or not
>>98114078It's like half the thread's regulars. it's exhausting, sometimes
>>98114072wow you're so cool. Can I have your autograph
>>98113497What's this for? The upcoming Marvel set?
>>98114267Yep, the Maro teaser is out. Spoilers are next week iirc
>>98114210Why weren't cosmos monsters of kaldheim typed enchantment creature like the nyxborn of theros?
>>98112972Frodo and Sam. It helps that Abzan colors let you use pretty much every relevant Food support card and tons of lifegain synergy pieces.
>>98113645>>98113656>>98113672It's probably Lair, since lairs are a common trope in superhero stories. You know like Avengers Tower and villain secret lairs (pun unintended).
>>98113691But Anon, you gain a whopping 2 life if you have Spell Mastery, such an upside is worth the Mana!
>>98114485
>build a superfriends deck a couple years ago>only got those cheap <$2 walkers cuz holy shit some of these are expensive, a lot where only 25-50cents>forget about the deck cuz it was ass to play>look up some of the planeswalkers, they're all going for $5-10 nowuhhhh...??? Why the hell is stuff like this guy $9? I feel like I should cash out cuz I'm sitting on almost $100 of these things, and a lot are foils
>>98114534In that Teyo's case, it's because he was only printed once in an expensive precon from Commander Masters. Planeswalkers in genersal tend to receive far less reprints than other types of spells.
>>98114061I answered it last thread, but here it is againPlay more lands. 36 is a minimum, not a maximum. I usually run 38. Mdfcs I count as half a land.Cut>cleric class>pristine talisman1 extra life isn't gunna do much. Your deck wants explosive lifegain, no incredmental with lots of little value triggers off of it, at least with how it's built now.>Narset of the ancient waySame as above, but more likely to be destroyed.>lightning bolt>enlightened ascetic>crib swapBad removal>anger>wonderNo consistant way to get it in the bin. If you add more reckless impulse cards, you can keep it.Basically just replace all of this with card draw. There's lots in jeskai.
>>98114534Sure you aren't thinking of this one?
>>98114676I have both. Both are sitting right in front of me
>>98114534>>98114676Where is he now?
>Howdy, pardner!
>>98114768yummy cum gutters
>>98114683SHE transitioned, nazi
>>98114776Where is she now?
>>98113691I put this in my cube of shame and my friends said it was too good for the cube of shame. Perhaps they’re right, it was next to cards like poison arrows.
>>98113006he cute
>>98113006>turn 1 Dark Ritual into Kalakscion>MFW i have no faceINTERIOR CROCODILE ALLIGATOR; I DRIVE A CHEVROLET MOVIE THEATER
>>98114072>complaining about UB outside of your containment thread Must be nice to go through life retarded
>>98113006kalakscion equip commander's plate
>>98114683There's lots of Planeswalkers whose status after MOM is still unkwown, not helped by the fact that for a while we only got one Planeswalker per set. They've since changed it to 2 Planeswalkers per set because there's less in-universe sets now though.
It's fucked up that both elf planeswalkers were desparked. Not only is there no elf PW left, there's no monogreen one left unless Garruk's next card drops the black. But Tyvar will never walk in again to lay down some elf support. You hate to see it.
>>98115047They'll probably get printings in a Modern Horizons set or something, chill
>>98115047Tyvar literally got a card in DSK. He'll be back when we return to Kaldheim eventually. Call me when YOUR favorite planeswalker is stuck in an aborted storyline and in the competing for attention with a billion other Dominaria villains.
>>98115059Why didn't she just fuck Jared into submission?
>>98115065She doesn't give a fuck about Jared. For her, Jared is a bring-Dakkon-back-to-me machine. She'd no less fuck Dakkon then you'd fuck the bait you're putting at the end of a fishhook.
>>98115059I have a soft spot for her and Dominaria's other black planeswalker ladies.
>>98115065If you look closely you'll see everything below her upper torso is just tentacles so the only hole she has is probably a nightmarish beak
>>98115047Garruk's most recent card is mono-Green, and I think Vivien is still sparked
>>98115059The funny thing is that she was pretending to be the Archmage of the Tolarian Academy when we last saw her, and with the Phyrexian Invasion happening, it's unlikely anyone had time to worry about other possible infiltrators.So she's likely STILL in that position. She's in CHARGE of the Tolarian Academy. She is in the position to mold the minds of wizards all over Dominaria, and also to beef with Strixhaven since the Tolarian Academy was explicitly a rival to it.
>>98115047Planeswalkers as a story concept were a mistake. Planeswalkers as a card type were a mistake. I wish they were both gone forever.
>>98115075>the only hole she has is probably a nightmarish beakIf anything that should make the submission fuck easier.
>>98115089>next Dominaria set we just get Dihada, Tolarian Headmaster>Dihada: "I might be an evil wizard, but I am a DOMINARIAN evil wizard. No upjumped lizards are going to poach MY students. Screw Dakkon, these wimps need some crushing. THE GAME IS ON"
>>98115075Dihada is a shapeshifter. She has any number of type of holes she wants to have.
>>98115089The academies were purged of infiltrators after MOM and even before then Dihada had blown her cover. If she survived through everything she likely moved on.
>>98112972I've been meaning to build Mikey and Donny partners>>98112980Pizza face is a vehicles commander you fool>>98113492The only problems with this art is the dumb magic claw railgun and that the beautiful ebony goddess angel doesn't have her tits and thighs out. Otherwise it's an objectively well-rendered piece
>>98115306>Pizza face is a vehicles commander you foolI don't know why I didn't think of this, thank you anon
>>98115310You're welcome fren, I hope it's fun. I couldn't get over them printing a card effect I was begging for on that absolute ugly bastard of a card
so uh, anyone looking forward to the marvel set?
>FLGS>Pod of three about to start a game>I ask to hop in; sure>Oloro retard goes first, followed by cEDH Sisay (I played a few games with the guy before), Lathril doesn't get green until his semifinal turn so we'll forget he exists, and me with Alela.>Land-go on the Oloro>Sisay fetches into a dual and drops a Chrome Mox>Rest of us land-go>Sisay Enlightened Tutor fetches a Rhystic Study before his next turn>Drooler Oloro: "I'm probably not going to pay the 1 ever." Means it.>Sisay doesn't play it immediately; Noble Hierarch and Esper Sentinel instead>Fast forward a few turns>I have an Empyrean Eagle, Alela, Sword of the Meek, and one fairy out>Retard Oloro has an Orcish Bowmaster. Attacked me and only me that game for no good reason earlier.>Problem Sisay has his commander, Noble, Esper Sentinel, Rhystic, and some rocks out. And a couple duals for good measure. Oh, and a FUCKING WORLD TREE>Lathril is here for the company at this point>Windowlicker Oloro plays some creature, and like several times over the time skip did not pay the 1.>Sisay draws a card>"I'm going to ping that fairy for 1.">Huh? There's an Esper Sentinel and Noble Hierarch right there.>"I don't care. Your token's dead.">It gets +1/+1 from the eagle.>"Oh">Sisay takes his turn, drops a Badgermole Cub from World Tree, putting Pact of Negation on bottom>Very obviously threatening to win on his next turn, but he doesn't have a Pact, and he's not too blue-heavy>My turn comes around>Swing the Fairy token at Oloro, Alela at Sisay>No blocks>Hatred on Alela>Sisay is screwed>Fat Dumbass Oloro: "Dispel">I'm too blindsided by this idiocy to be immediately angry>Pick up my cards because I've had enough of this dickslobbering retard and Sisay is going to Cradle and Emiel>Move to a new table>Sisay pops off two turns later (Didn't need to)>mfw overhear permavirgin Oloro complaining about it
>>98115562I think this anon didn't like the Oloro player
>>98115554Ward - Gain 5 poison counters is deranged, so no
>>98115656>"yeah Ward - 4 was a bit too extreme so we're gonna be more careful with the ability in the future"
>>98115562I'm really tired of these cedh lite faggots in my lgs, when I see one of them, I just don't play in that pod desu. Oldfags with thousands of dollars in cardboard in a casual setting is peak retardation.
>>98115656so will Atraxa take her spot back?
>>98115731I hope not. She doesn't deserve it after she was mean to Ixhel.
Leaks be leaking
>>98113292>>98113330Many such cases
>>98115871>Invisible Woman is just +1/+1 counters>not Shroud or Phaselame as fuck lmao
>>98115833>healedThat's a new word for Magic, which obviously means removing all marked damage on a creature. I'm intrigued about what else they'll do with it.
>>98115896Invisible woman is the wall, dumbass
>>98116000>Thing is +1/+1 countersthat's even dumber!
>>98115843Wow, we are reaching old fogey levels of fucking skill text here.
>>98115730I don't care too much about cEDH pods. With that shop there's a few people that play it dedicated and I can keep up with them if there's no bullshit.What I can't stand is some asswipe kingmaking a cEDH player that shouldn't need the help without even a plan to win the game himself. All the more worse since that pod wasn't competitive outside of the one guy.Magic's an inclusive game; if you want to suck someone's cock that badly you can just ask.
>>98115833I really hate the way this is templated. Really oven of in vibes.
>>98115843This is perfect for Indominus Rex
>>98115833>Healed>Awkward replacement textWorded like someone's custom card
>>98115843In portuguese, he is called "Assa-simian"
>>98116065>literally buttmonkey
>>98115833So if two 3/3s block him, he dies, right?
Is Badgermole Cub not good in commander? ChatGPT seems to dislike it when I have it review my deck for some reason
>>98115916They'll probably use it for more future inevitable Wolverine cards and other Marvel characters with a healing factor like Sabretooth, X-23, or Daken.
>>98116026>Strong guy does the thing that makes creatures strongerIt makes sense to me.
>>98116113Never ever listen to ChatGPT when it comes to Magic. The game is too complex for AI to "understand" how it works.
>>98116113>Using chatgpt to review your deck????
>>98115833>healedregenerate back on the menu soon?
>>98115896>rubber man... draws cards because he's a scientistthe commander cards kind of suck ass flavorwise
>>98116205Doubt it. They moved away from it in favor of indestructible+tapping. Regenerate was always a needlessly convoluted mechanic that didn't work very well flavorwise anyway.
>>98116205I doubt it, they just wanted a flavorful way to depict Wolverine's healing factor. For everything else, Indestructible or "creature dies, then comes back" is simpler.
>>98116113how many mana dorks do you run?regardless, don't use AI for shit like that
>>98115656Strictly worse than hexproof
>>98112883>TQ: Would you ever run a vanilla legendary creature like one of the Muraganda legends as a commander?I already do, giant tribal
>>98116094Yes, since the damage will be dealt simultaneously. But a 3/3 with double strike will not kill him.
>>98116297It's functionally the same outside of can't-be-countered edge cases
>>98112883If I were to build a vanilla commander I'd build this guy because he is simply cool as fuck to me.
>>98113904hell fucking no
>>98116479Everything about this card doesn't even feel like it's from the same game anymore.
1. Redcaps are your favorite flavor of goblin.2. Grumgully, the Generous is your ideal commander.3. Seriously, you need more?
>>98116854>redcap>not wearing a red cap
>>98116841It's a quaint card to be sure.
The magic is goneanyway Im building Crosis
>>98116819They really should have gotten Smith to draw some Kamigawa or Tarkir back when those were fresh.https://adrian-smith.artstation.com/albums/1298277
>>98116113this must be the most midwit post I've seen this year. great job!
>>98116113Everyone's saying that ChatGPT is stupid, but it could unironically be correct if the rest of your ramp package is land ramp with no artifacts or dorks.
>>98116940I only build predh decks these days so I can be reminded of better times while I lose every game.
>>98116981based, whatcha working with currently? Also who are you losing to? I roll up to LGSs with utter dogshit and still manage to win about 1/4 games.
Is there any tribe you wish got more support? Pic related, I'm not asking for much, just one legendary Lhurgoyf shouldn't be an unreasonably tall request.
>>98116997It's incredibly sad how stupid the new crop of players are
>>98116997angles
>>98117006no bully
Get ready for Hatsune Miku secret lair commander deck https://www.ebay.com/itm/366436177336
>>98116995I recently put a jor kadeen deck together because I love mirrodin. It's just a bunch of creatures with keywords that can carry equipment competently. I've mostly been playing it with my regular group and it gets some kills in here and there but it's hard to close out games.
>>98116997Angels
>>98116997Viashino, in that I wish it still existed ;-;
>>98117077shut up, bitch. Here's a villain/doctor/hero/symbiote so be happy
>>98116997Skeletons
>>98116819Consider reducing your filesizes these are unreadably large on desktop
>>98117169Oh shoot, I could actually reduce them. I need them high resolution for printing I think, but definitely not so big for just posting here.
>>98117189>centered textagh my autism
>>98115833>>98115843>>98115871>MarvelUnironically who gives a shit anymore.
>>98116854I dislike anything with an effect that specifically excludes humans so while I enjoy RG and goblins I would not run him.
>>98116997oppai tribal
I miss Chippy.
>>98117233Marvel in 2026 really does feel archaic.
>>98117307>>98117233You have to remember that the people who run magic are real life basedjacks and always have beenShit should've been called Dweebs of the Coast like actually
>>98113626Cool art, I like both desu. I can understand why they didn't want to bring back this one.
>>98117361They've really toned the gore down over time.
>>98116997We demand more archons.
Would you guys be in favour of no ban lists now with all the tier system shit?I would like to have Paradox Engine in my Derevi deck, but I'm not even close to being a cedh dweeb. I just really want that card in my deck
>>98117364Fun fact: there are no mtg cards named Disgust
>>98117531I want the banlist to be expanded, actually
>>98117501Well that's stupid.
>>98117548That's called bracket 2
>>98117553Ah fuck >>98117537
>>98117548>>98117554That's pretty much why the banlist as a whole is up for debate. Banned cards could maybe have their own ranking?
>>98116997I started playing during Kamigawa and the first deck I tried to build from booster packs was an Ogre tribal because, i. my opinion, they had some of the coolest illustrations of the entire block. Predictably, it was unplayable garbage. At the time, I had no idea that an Ogre precon came out with Traitors of Kamigawa, but judging from the decklist, that too was unplayable garbage. Anyway, 20ish years later and Ogre still has no tribal support whatsoever
>>98117554CEDH needs more aggressive bannings than any other "bracket," but to your point, if brackets were actually to work as intended, each bracket would need explicit banlists. Stop trying to tell me your Winota deck is bracket 2, we all know you're lying.
>>98117587I don't like cedh as I think it is fundamentally not what commander is about or functions as, but why do you think it needs aggressive bannings? Isn't the whole idea about cedh to let all the autists go balls to the walls with everything they've got?
>>98117587Rhystic will never be banned because it's the only reason why decks can still be "midrange" and are not all turbo
>>98117606because eternal formats need regular banlist updates so things don't stagnate. While it's less necessary for "casual" EDH due to the somewhat self-policing nature of the playerbase, the CEDH meta has practically calcified.
>>98117639If stagnation is your only concern unbannings will do the trick + help wotc's bottom line
>>98117651unbannings won't do shit to the CEDH meta, Thoracle isn't going to suddenly be dethroned because Iona or Prime Time can be irrelevant in the 99
>>98116997Im hesitant on asking for tribal support because once they finally get it, it's not going to get any support for a while. I still have Sidar Jabari as a Knight commander, but I would of rather had Mardu so I had to settle for some alternatives in addition to Sidar. I would like to see a Temur or Naya Beast deck one day. It would be harder for Naya because Dinosaurs pretty much occupy that space of "bid midrange creatures that do everything".
>>98117661Huh?
>>98117674Dockside's banning barely changed the CEDH meta
>>98117587They should replace brackets with ones based on monetary value. If you spent a similar amount of money on your deck we can play, if not fuck off. I'm tired of retards pubstomping precons at the LGS with their eldrazi deck that they've been investing in since 2019.>inb4 "what about (insert meme budget deck that can sometimes win)"Obviously it's not a perfect system and there are fluctuations, but don't tell me that a $100 deck is even remotely comparable to a $600 one, there's a reason why some cards cost how much they do and it's not only availability
>>98117685So why is it banned again?
>>98117691that doesn't work in the collector/speculator hell WOTC has createdbrackets should actually be based on landbases
>>98117691Yeah i dont think you should be playing memes like chaos or mill vs randoms
>>98117695its effects on regular EDH, which is all the RC ever concerned themselves with
>>98117691You realize those "fluctuations" are exactly what makes Penny Dreadful such a volatile format and why Pauper is now expensive as shit, right? Nobody will want to play a format where new decks become invalidated literally every time prices are rechecked.
CEDH should be ignored or treated as its own thing.All other cards should be given a score, and brackets have a score cap. Some combinations of cards should have a score multiplier/addition when in the same deck. So you might give Exquisite Blood and Sanguine Bond both a score of 0, but a score of 3 when they're both in the deck.>But that's so complicated to make!Yes. It's a complicated game.
>>98117717a more effective way to score stuff like that is infinite combos are worth a flat score, which decreases based on how many cards it needs to pull off. Then you don't need to score each individual permutation of however many infinites there are.
>>98117715Right and brackets are the solution where mean cards like rhystic are banned in bw, the bracket where 90+% of the community belong in
>>98117733B2* lol
>>98117733make b2 played again
>>98117140LCI was surprisingly generous in that respect
>>98117769>best skellington in LCI can't be used as a commander
>>98113174Pack rat?
>Zhulodok precon is 270€
Every card over $100 on its cheapest english printing should be automatically banned until the price falls.
>>98117792this but $50
>>98117059fakeit looks too cute
>>98117769the great mistake was a great mistake
>>98117792Wotc should just sell any box as print to order
>>98113626Timesplitters enjoyer?
>>98117548Each bracket should have its own ban list.
>>98117792based but 5 dollars
>>98116997I would have liked an actual fucking Kithkin commander in Lorwyn
>>98117889gaddock teeg already exists
>>98117889Brigid is fine
>>98117913Are you a retard?>>98117937And are you? Neither of these are tribal commanders. They are a commander that HAPPENS TO HAVE that creatue type. Might as well say we have skeleton support commanders.
>>98117531I don't use the bracket system. So, no. If they try to make moves to force the system then I'll simply sell my shit and go buy action figures.
>>98117962you sound gay
>>98117962People here *are* generally that retarded, yes. People are always posting this when I say I want a proper skeleton support commander
>>98117733Gavin already admitted he can't force people to use brackets and he doesn't want to try and destroy the game for those who choose not to.
>>98117962Brigid makes Kithkins, ergo she is a Kithkin commander. It's like saying Rhys isn't an elf commander.
>>98117233Majority of people.
>>98117548only if we can enforce a system that says no repeated effects, i want a true singleton format
All tutors should be banned.
>>98117989this but all cards that require you to pay to attack
>>98117989Basic land tutors are fine. But otherwise yes
>>98118006wrong.
>>98117989>t. redcel
>>98117989So, fetches, evolving wildes, terramorphic expanse, etc?
>>98118006ESPECIALLY land tutors
this guy fucks
>>98118019I'd argue he's a better Shorikai. The guy just does everything.
>>98118019His voice hurts my ears.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oPoB-lDNqCk
>>98118029didn't realize he was a tranny
>>98117810>fakeI had to look at the artists twitter. The artstyle does check out.
>>98118029It's a card, just read it as whatever voice you want
>>98118029I liked it when he sounded like what a humanoid elephant would actually sound like: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=si8G0pR7zSI&t=65s
>>98118016yes, fuck your deck thinningembrace slop brewing
Anon's opponent cracked an evolving wilds on his end step one too many times and he lost it
>>98117985Their recent (Last couple years) box office numbers beg to differ.
>>98118048SHE'S TALKING ABOUT DINA
>>98118061>2 mana for a basic land that enters tapped?! REEEEE>anyways I play Sol Ring and tap it for 2 to play Arcane Signet
Is he right, uncs?
>>98118090he is based
>>98117977He cannot force brackets any more than he can enforce the london mulligan, if people want unlimited mulligans in their basements that's fine but they shouldnt be surprised they're given the side eye
>>98118090He is Canadian, so no
>>98118051>I just erased multiple deck archetypes...WITH MY STUPIDITY
>>98118019I found this deck really boring and stuck spinning its wheels for 10 turns.
>>98118090Ah so it's a "Please buy the IP set for a dying IP we paid a boatload to acquire at the peak of it's costliness" set.
>>98118105>LGS enforced bracketsmine don't. Sounds like yours sucks.
>>98118163Literally all you have to do is pack the deck with lots of ways to make cards leave your grave and Quint does the rest, it's that shrimple bro
>>98118169>Marvel>dyinglmfaoThis site is so out of touch at times.>b-b-but...moviesAll movies are down. The age of big box office was last decade.
>>98118175>all you have to do is swap 40 non-lands from the deckI saw a video where a guy made the precon "super strong" and he swapped out almost half the deck.It's another Yshtola situation.
>>98118178The comics are even more fucked than the movies
>>98117962>is a Kithkin, makes Kithkin tokens, has strong synergy with a low-to-the-ground tribe like Kithkin>Uuuhhh it doesnt explicitly say kithkin get +2/+2 or something so its not a Kithkin commander!Tribalfags really are braindead retards.
Wizards screwed up and sent some guy on reddit an unnanounced Hatsune Miku commander deck in place of the goblin one he ordered. Unlike the Miku secret lairs, this one actually has art by Kei. That being said its going to be another secret lair commander deck drop that sells out in 10 minutes and then is sold on the aftermarket for 10x the price, so even as someone with 15 Miku figures in his room this is very difficult for me to care about.
>>98118220Yeah I don't care since it won't actuall be purchasable. I think a lot of people just ignore SLDs now because they aren't really obtainable outside of scalpers. It's not even FOMO anymore. You literally cannot buy it.
>>98118220Kind of a boring choice for a Miku reskin
I just want my Mahō Gakuin Seishun Hakusho secret lair is that too much to ask?
>>98118233then buy it from a scalper.
>>98118236I already bought it but it was delayed
>One of the most popular IPs in Japan>Ten of thousands of songs>Ten of thousands on fanart>Manga>Anime>games >Even been used as a Voice Actress>WOTC refuses to give her a mechanically unique cards and instead gives her 30 reskins on 75 cent cardsFUCK YOU FUCK YOU FUCK YOU DEATH TO WOTC! DEATH TO HASBRO! DEATH TO MARK NOSEWATER!
I wanna build a silly lil unblockable guys deck, should I build Gonti or Breena? Or should I just build Raffine and put both of them in the 99?
>>98118338Build this instead.
>>98118338Well one is an Aetherdrift card and the other is ugly so you should probably just build Raffine
>>98118351What on Earth? They printed cephalids again and they look nothing like the original ones? Are there more of these from that plane?
>>98118351Was thinking of Kamiz, but I feel like she just leans more towards building an infect deck more than anything. I also want to benefit from having lots of lil unblockable guys not just a few.
>>98118048Nigga what the fuck are you talking about
>>98117674This is Jew erasure. WotC is being extremely antisemetic with this.
>>98118220You need to grow up
>>98118400Trying too hard
>>98118405What a mysterious post
>>98118410You just admitted to having 15 little girl baby dolls in your room brother. That is NOT cool
>>98118405posted in the fantasy trading card game joke subformat thread on a chinese cartoom forum
>>98118405>>98118416
>>98118319>Caring about some anime bitch on mtg cardsAre WoTC actually based for shitting on weebs like this faggot?
>>98118172>his pod enforced the commander banlistI play contract from below and i tell people ante is just another exile zone, looks like your pod lacks imagination
>>98118338breena is a cutie
So are the links coming back in the next OP or are we done letting that sperg putting furry porn in them?
>>98118319Miku's lore (lol) doesnt warrant a mechanically unique card
>>98118469Why are (You) even asking this when (You) are the one that will spam the thread if (You) don't get to make it?
>>98118469>>98118478for the love of Jehovah Jireh shut the hell up about it
Breena's problems: >First of all you must assume your opponents will never give you favorable attacks, so you're only generating value off her from your own attacks.>You must assume that you have opponents at unequal life totals>You must assume that you have more than one opponent (Breena is a 1/3 flyer with no other text against one opponent)>You must assume you can attack two opponents favorably every turnHonestly she's a lot of setup
>>98112972I've been making something low power with Elanor Gardner, but the right answer is probably something like The Cabbage Merchant.
>>98118503Yeah, it's why I'm leaning more towards Gonti, Night Minister or Raffine.
>>98118423I think it's funny that this is such an iconic reaction image cause I wouldn't expect an average 4chan user to be into Scrubs
>>98118469Maybe if you stopped being such an obsessed faggot about irrelevant shit anons wouldn't make threads just to trigger you.
>>98118520Early season Scrubs was based.
>plays this on turn 4Your response ?
>>98117705>>98117716While fluctuations do happen, commander being a singleton format means that the variance will be marginal, or at least severely dampened: if 1 card out of 100 shoots up in value, it shouldn't push you out of a "bracket" with a $100ish range, except in extreme cases. Also, I would argue that the way the secondary market works, card values are tied almost entirely to banlists, which already do change and force people to upgrade decks anyway.As I said, it's not a perfect system, but I think it runs circle around the current bullshit we have. Here's why it will never ever be implemented officially:1. Using real monetary quantifier would remind people of how much they actually spent and , according to every behavioural economic theory out there, that will drive sales down2. People could be uncomfortable sharing how much they actually whaled out on a deck, and it could create situations in which being beaten by a cheaper deck makes a player reconsider how much of an impact those extra $ spent on a staple really had. Again, this would result in less purchasesSpecifically because of these reasons, the health of the game would improve in the long run, as players become more considerate about deckbuilding and what to cut/include. Cedh retards would experience no change (make a bracket called "unlimited where there is no upper limit"). Furthermore, with enough brackets, the inflation that we witnessed with pauper would simply not happen.I think it's a good system for the players and by the players, but maybe I'm wrong. I am thinking of testing it in my playgroup of 20ish people to start with. If it works I might actually write down some proper rules
>>98114477absolutely, I picked it up recently because I've been so disappointed with production on my friend's decks.
I wish 3dog was good because it's funny
Brackets exist because MTG players are pussy faggots who can't say>Yo, fuck Nadu, play something else or get outta here nigger.
>>98118220>reskinFucking trash. Hate these reskin shit. Just name a new card or don't bother.
>>98118684you're (almost) everything wrong with modern mtg
>>98118684Reskins are actually better and the way crossovers should be done. Mechanically unique ub are why they are so hated.
>>98118680NTA but the problem is specifically the monetary value. It feels really bad to tell someone who shows up with a new deck you know they spent money on they can't play it. If all cards were essentially free (decks <$20) then people would feel a lot more empowered to say that.But if someone dumps $100 bucks on a deck, it feels shitty to tell them they can't use that $100 toy.
>Hatsune Miku>Not a single reskin is an Artifact creatureThis is the worst part, she is an android.
>>98118726Hatsune Miku is real and strong and she's my friend
>>98116997Id like a new commander for sea creatures. Kiora is boring cascade slop and Kenessos is interesting but requires too much topdeck manipulation/deck space. A newer commander would have some in-text way to scry.
>>98116997I wanna build a Zoraline bat tribal deck the problem is that there aren't actually that many decent Bat cards
>>98118469>first thread in literal months with zero shitpostingno, the links stay gone
>>98118944>>98118944>>98118944NEW
>>98118949little early there fella
Looking for some feedback on this budget Sedris build. I think I've got card draw in order, good attacking creatures to help me bring life totals to zero, and ways to keep my Unearthed stuff, but I would appreciate any outside perspective.https://moxfield.com/decks/WEwUJpiwp0CtXcDU-FJsAQ
>>98117962Get ready, here comes that annoying faggot who claims to be some amazing deckbuilder who builds around the tribal traits and that caring about your tribes keyword means ur bad
>>9811852090% of this site was not alive when this show ended>>98118416There's an entire fucking /toy/ board you tard
>>98118455I don't get what you're trying to do. But you've been doing this for like a year and a half now where you keep living in this fantasy land where everyone is forced to use brackets or "no one will play with you."It's fine if you like the system but you literally lie to people to try and get them to buy in. It's old and you need a new troll.
>>98118956We must stop the furry porn at any cost.
>>98113340Based . Thats my playmat and favorite MTG art. In foil its absolutely glorious
>>98118090Hes a bit dramatic on his takes but hes basically the only MTG YouTuber i watch
