Flavorful Seasoning EditionPrevious: >>98574745>Newshttps://magic.wizards.com/en/news/announcements/commander-banned-and-restricted-february-9-2026https://magic.wizards.com/en/news/announcements/commander-brackets-beta-update-february-9-2026>Current Banlisthttps://magic.wizards.com/en/banned-restricted-list#commander-banned>Bracket Informationhttps://files.catbox.moe/4tbvzw.pnghttps://files.catbox.moe/r62yfy.png>Former Commander Website: Learn the basics, and read the format philosophy laid down by the rules committeehttps://mtgcommander.net>Card Searchhttps://scryfall.com>Card Statistics: See what everyone else puts in their Commander decks based on what is posted to the Internethttps://www.edhrec.com>Deck List Sites: You can search for decks that other people have made. Authors often have comments that explain their deck strategy and card choiceshttps://www.archidekt.comhttps://www.moxfield.com>Manabase Information: Find out what lands you can add to your deck, sorted by category, based on a chosen color identityhttps://managathering.com>Proxy Guidehttps://pastebin.com/9Xj1xLdM>Preconshttps://magicprecons.comTQ: Times when you've mined the salt intentionally or not?
Anyone got a good white devotion list? I want to make a white power deck with all these cards. I don't mind including Crusade, but I'd prefer something I can switch it out with. So fucking gay that WotC banned that card. I'm gonna start an argument with it at the FLGS given that MULTIPLE other cards with Crusade/Crusader in the name are still allowed.
>>98579972
>>98579945>I play rhystic>Haha, I also pay rhystic>Haha, I also play rhystic, 3 rhystics, lets go!>I play smothering.>Bro x3>They all forget the draw is a may and rage at the fact I'm out pacing them with all the ramp they're giving me.Literally didnt do anything, got plenty of salt
>>98579972dawn elemental, phyrexian vindicator, benalish marshal
>>98579945>TQ>Playing with new group for the first time>Playing my old Sephara deck>Board is pretty big, full swing on another guy on the Selesnya midnight hunt precon>Holding pic related to defend myself>Gruulfag I've never met before tells everyone I'm open and to kill me>"White doesn't have any sort of combat tricks that would save me" I tell the rest table pretty sarcastically>Gets to Gruulfag's turn and he full sends me>Cast Rally of Wings and untap my shit>He freaks out and calls me a liar for saying that white can't do anything like that>His board gets btfo and he dies to me on the backswing>Next couple months I play more games with him and he never once trusts me and warns other players I play dirty in pregame because he misread some basic sarcasm
>TQThe only time I can think of is when I used my Ashcoat deck against a friends Raphael deck, I got about 12 rats out from my graveyard using Patriarchs Bidding, he started saying how much I fucked up doing that but after buffing them from combat attacking someone else with just Ashcoat I milled his library with Altar of Dementia
>>98579972no one will do shit if you play that card. did you find your copy on eBay for 10 bucks yet
TQ: Never, my pods aren't salty. The most was annoyance from a player because I kept attacking him with Ayara Oathsworn instead of the ramping player, I needed to do that to trigger the tutor
I love this janky card like you wouldn't believe.
>>98579987This didn't happen btw.
>>985800551shotting people with Jarad since 2012
Rock and Bauble torture
>>98579996>misreads sarcasm>spergs outUnironically might be autistic if he didn't pick up that tonal cue. Not defending him at all, just I've met people who were deaf to that sort of thing, it's wild.
>>98579988Thank you. I already have a Benalish Marshal.>>98579984See this shit isn't even offensive. But whatever. I have the new version anyway which is the same card and the art is generic but at least it has no link to IRL shit so they have NO RIGHT TO COMPLAIN.If they wanted to ban that art version to be "woke" I would still think it's gay but at least I'd understand.God I seriously hope everyone at WotC dies of prostate cancer. Half the "female" employees probably will.>>98580004>no one will do shit if you play that card. Yes they will, some faggy fucking soi boi will whine about it if it's a pub event. And ALL my IRL MTG player friends, except for one (who quit playing MTG after original Innistrad for the most part) are annoying leftoids who will seethe about this card as well.>did you find your copy on eBay for 10 bucks yetI got a new printing for 25 cents in the FLGS bulk rare bin. I don't see that art on Ebay for less than 20 bucks.
>>98580099there's also anti-venom if you're ok with universes beyond
>>98580099oh nice. there was a dude last thread saying he wanted the card for a mono white deck but couldn't find it on eBay at all but apparently didnt know how to use boolean operators to filter out what he wanted. or maybe was just a retard. I mean if you think people would freak out then maybe they would I just dont see people doing it. could be the state (or province whatever)
>>98580067Found the rhysticbabby
>TQOverload salt with a pinch of kingmaking
>>98579972You just have to run Jihad in the same deck to prove you're not racist
>>98580178ahh what a great cycle
I'm debating if I even want to make a Whtz deck. It just seems too physically difficult to play with a 200+ card deck. Even if I single sleeve it.
land was a mistake
*island
>>98580263Land is the biggest flaw of this game
Land is the only reason to play this game. Everything else is just curve.
this card fucks
Anyone ever build her? Is she """fun"""
>>98580307UB slop so no, also I’m trans and going to my lgs tonight to girlgasm with the girlies.
"Let me solo her">>98580301correct
>>98580307I want to but I already have two artifact based decks
Post the most recent commander you've been working on
>>98580347It turns out trying to cram banding, lures, and rampage into the same deck is actually really fucking hard.
>>98580347I'm using an alt skin for him though.
>>98580353post it
>>98579945why the hell does this cost 5 when vindicate (destroy target permanent) and anguished unmaking (exile target non land permanent) cost 3? black doesn't even offer anything that white can't remove in those costs so whats the deal?
>>98580055woah might have to replace Lhurgoyf with that lil bitty
>>98580115yeah it might be my area, I dunno. people are so gay here. it's not even that liberal of an area. I just fucking hate all these stores that cucked to WotC because they knew all it took is one soi boi snitching on them and they lose WPN status.
>>98580370>Why does bad card exist when there's good card?A real riddle for anon
>>98580370saltblast is older than you
>>98580367
>>98580382I mean if they're literal homos and trannies I guess find another store but I just dont see that when I go out. there was one 50+ year old troon at a big hobbit pre-release I did and I even called them a "he" unintentionally and just kept talking and there was no freak out. maybe they were just a cross dressing dude wearing a blouse I dont know. or an extremely ugly woman the stores also have to obey Pokemon which magic eats pokemons shit and if parents dont want to send their kids to LGS' because theres groomers there, the store is picking pokemon (the money, which aligns what is good)other than that I would have to say you must live in a real liberal shit hole just not Seattle or minneapolis levels of hellscape
>>98580412not the worst flavor honestly
>>98580401I'm older than MTG. I honestly dont remember this card but I like the flavor a lot>>98580386see above
they should group up more tribes like they did with outlaws, that was fun>1WR Enchantment >As long as its your turn, fighters you control have first strike and haste. >(Barbarians, berserkers, mercenaries, samurai, soldiers and warriors are fighters.)
>>98580414man after watching gta 6 trailer it really shows just how fucking gay wotc and a lot of the community are in comparison
>>98580420the real reason is that it's an uncommon for 2007 planar chaos limited
>>98580428GTA6 is a game trying to capture the largest audience possible while MtG is a game trying to extract as much value as possible from a drastically smaller one.
>>98580414>minneapolis levels of hellscapeVisited Minneapolis to see a friend who was in town, we stopped by a random hole in the wall pub for a cube event and guess what, nothing happened and it's like any other city, touch grass retard.
>>98580412Would
>>98580442Everyone would Pomni
>>98580457I wouldn't. I'm not a pedo
Thirty (30) starting life is objectively superior to fourty (40)
>>98580461That bitch is 25. Damn near hag status.>>98580441These cards were cool looking.
>>98580435even for card games, mtg is very very gay
>>98580471It's really fucking annoying that magic is ran by feminists.
>>98580508Sometimes you have to decide between political ideological consistencies and fun.
>>98580471>Pokemon balances their gameNo they just employ the 2008-2018 WotC policy of telling you it will rotate and to stuff it if Git Probe is showing up at 4 copies in every deck including ones with no blue access.Also important qualifier is that Pokemon has a large IP to rely on to boost sales, while MtG's brand is comparatively immensely niche.Aside from that it's accurate.
>>98580441this has been debunked>t. florida man
>>98580517yeah it's really easy to balance a game if the game is as simple as pokemoni just shake my head when you have to search hard for an mtg woman that isn't covered up from neck to toe while pokemon regularly shows skin, i'm certain many people in wotc take offense to liliana showing her bare shoulders and there's an internal battle to keep *that* part of lili
>>98580307The only people that give two fucks about this character are foot mutants.
>>98580538Pokemon doesn't even balance their game as simple as it is. Game-warping cards are printed constantly and they just get to shit up the game for 2 years because the policy is "no bans unless it makes it physically impossible to run a tournament" (which they did with Lysandre's Trump Card causing matches to take multiple hours). People just don't know this because nobody actually plays the game.
>>98580587well people do play the game its just they are children who's parents keep them off the internet like they should
>>98580538they are sick people dude. it comes through in the art that is commissioned. they are completely warped from reality. of course a real woman is offensive
>>98580412Israel’s strongest pedophile in the thread.
>>98580686I don't know what any of this means. Which implies it is probably schizobabble.
>>98580055He's great. Love him in shovel man.
>>98580611That's the same caliber of "play" that the average Commander "player" engages in. Which is to say they're so stupid they can't even correctly identify the cards raping them every game.
I hate how every time a share a cool story with /edhg/ someone always says>This didn't happen btw.It fucking did happen! Why would I waste time making up some shit on the internet for nothing? Literally nothing. It happened goddamn it!
>>98580729>I hate how every time a share a cool story with /edhg/ someone always says>>This didn't happen btw.
>>98580729This post didn't happened
>>98580729
>>98580689Sorry, “minor attracted person” or MAP to be more inclusive for WOTC code of conduct purposes. Surely you understand that you faggot tranny freak, get your Impotent Tranny Freakshow posts out of here you disgusting dysgenic loser freak.
You all will be going to discard town
>>98580745Holy fucking meltdown
>playing casually>Commander League or something is going on>Players get points for in game missions>I'm a pod with a player I know plays high power shit like chrome mox and diamonds in random decks>He's playing Kefka>He's got psychosis crawler out, asked an opponent to let him get through with a transformed Kefka>Opponent doesn't know what's going on and let's him do it. >I kill psychosis crawler in response to the Kefka trigger>He throws a fit because I'm going to win next turn instead of him winning right now.>I'm not participating in the league and explicitly said I wanted to prevent anyone from scoring points. >I won next turn.This happened, fuck combo.
>>98580729for updoots or (((you)))'s>>98580733this has been debunkedwho's ready for some Friday night commander tomorrow. its bed time for bonzo here on the BAYOUUUUU
>>98580754>Kefka playerDeserved
>>98580751Your parents curse their own reproductive organs for producing offspring so aggressively retarded that not even a Down syndrome Orthodox Jew could compare to the level of retardation Satan cooked up with your fathers sperm and your mothers ovaries.
>>98580750not so fast bucko
>>98580767
>>98580750oh wait and if that wasn't enough, how's THIS for size? (mode 3)
Bring back the grotesque into Magic
>>98580769>>98580750whoops forgot pic rel>NOT SO FAST FUCKO!
>>98580347Traded my buddy awhile ago for Mishra and the Dragon Engine, and he has an Urza, Lord Protector deck with the M&W Stones.Working on a thematic deck for Mishra, just ordered a bunch of Brother's War cards and it has a Phyrexia spin with Oil Counters.The hope is we can 2-Headed Giant sometime for the fun of it. Otherwise we see if the shitty brother gets to die next time.Link is a little out of date, mostly swapping 3 Mountains for Swamps>link: https://manabox.app/decks/AaAtXO_Tc6egfxVKsJmLHQ
>>98580778what was the last honest set? IMO
>>98580778This is someone's fetish
>>98580827I have most of these cards in my bulk according to manabox, can I make this deck? What’s the overall strategy of the deck?
>>98580839I'm not giving you permission to make this deck.It's like Bracket 2 anon. Not every Commander decks need to do something in particular.
>>98580848Sorry I’m going to rape your deck and turn it into a high bracket 3.
>mortis dogs>rapacious guest>disciple of bolas>foot chopper>shartlooking for power matters in WB color identity
>>98580876WOOOYEAHPOOPIE RAPIE!! POOPIE RAPIE!!
>>98580877Nested Shambler
>>98579984
>>98580838It's called emetophilia.
>>98580992I'm aware.
>>98580729>It fucking did happen!>It happened goddamn it!
>>98580780>remove soul>actually removes their skeletonfalse advertisement
>>98580983>shithole country playing one of the pricier formatsbased brazil flooding their card shops with counterfeits so everyone can play the game for cheap
>>98580884Do the goyim really?
>>98581027>>shithole countryNo one mentioned the United states lol
I like playing precons. I took my Squirrel precon to the LGS and got a win with it. I got the Squirrel-Garruk ultimate ability off, and a few turns later I was the player that bounced-back from a board-wipe the fastest, and I beat everyone up with my Squirrel + Wolf army.
>>98581353he cute :)
>>98581021The soul is stored in the marrow don't you know>>98581353Fable of Wolf and Squirrel
>>98581232Well, obviously, since they're discussing shitholes, not the solitary world superpower. Do try to keep up, oh obsessed thirdie.
>>98581374Wait, what does China have to do with anything?
>>98580877does this count?
>>98580745You play a game with MLP and Spongebob.
Friends are thinking of doing a Custom Commander night. Does this seem balanced? Should I make her a flip instead or something?
>>98581621I'm sorry I have autism but, if you "return her to the battlefield" then you didn't replace the effect of dying. so that ability should say "When Malenia dies", not "If Malenia would die", like eg Unstoppable Slasher. It dies, triggering death triggers, and re enters, triggering etbs
>>98581704wotc would do an intervening clause here>When Malenia dies, if she wasn't sacrificed, you may pay 1RWB (yes your pip ordering is wrong too). If you do, return her to the battlefield with a Scarlet Bloom counter on her.>waterfowl dance feels like it should do more damage than a fury imo
>>98581717>>98581674alright, take 3. thanks for helping out anon. 6 damage seems alright? or should it be scaling to her power or something
>>98581762For waterfowl dance, it should be "this turn" unless you have something that is tracking earlier turns. Pic related is all cards that mention "That turn" and notice how most of them are extra turn spells/stopping extra turn spells by tracking something about a "turn".
>>98581606MLP and SpongeBob at least have cultural significance. Impotent Tranny Freakshow is a product of cultural rot and serves solely to accelerate transgenderism in the neurodivergent. You are a literal goyish slave.
>>98581762Have the damage scale with the scarlet rot counters and reduce the cost of the ability to 3 in mardu.
>>98581717>you may pay 1RWB (yes your pip ordering is wrong too).I didn't want to say anything because I wanted to limit my autism lol.Btw unless I messed up in my search, this appears to be the only "if it wasn't sacrificed" card in existence. not a line of text that wotc likes! I assume you >>98581762 put it in the card to clamp down its power level or whatever though, it's not as if Mardu is lacking for sacrifice outlets after all
>>98581811And to add, have it so the scarlet rot counters it receives are equal to the amount of combat damage that was dealt to it before it died, if it receives no combat damage it returns with only one counter. Also adjust the stat line to it being a 5/1 to further incentivise people blocking it.
>>98581834Oh gotta remove first strike too
>>98581843>>98581834>>98581811alright here's your version>>98581832and yeah i just put that no-sac there since it would feel weird to put her on the field and immediately kill her with like ashnods altar or something since the rot is kinda like her desperation move. didn't know that it was such a rare conditional
>>98581887What's the point of her getting more than one counter if they don't fall or get removed through some other action
>>98580471Pokemon would be better if douchebros weren't scalping everything.
>>98581887>wordswordswordsI'd say this is too many abilities and too retarded, but with the way things are going in two years that's probably going to be te average mythic expectancy.
>>98580877Altar of the Wretched!Auron, Venerated GuardianCosmic CubeDragon Throne of TarkirDread DefilerGhoulcaller GisaMask of GriselbrandMurder Investigation Wall of Limbs
>>98581887>I love my waifu so much, so when I make a card for her in magic she needs to be convoluted and also broken!The worst.
>>98580441>city slicker telling people to touch grassWhere?
>>98582175That's why Tifa rocks
>>98581887Hate the trend of legendary creatures needing so many fucking keywords because build-around abilities aren't enough key-jingling already.
>>98582224It's trying to capture all of the aspects of a character in a tiny text box which is probably a mistake but I always laugh at mtg players being averse to reading
>>98582175Azula is wonderful
Why not make Melania as flip saga creature that will die after her last chapter so you need to keep the lore counter(scarlet rot) count always low?
>>98582175How's it broken? It doesn't even do anything threatening until it dies once
>>98582233This is a card game not some shitty nuDND campaign. I'm don't care if your little special interest character is a lesbian and therefor does zero damage to any cards with a woman in the art.
>>98582247any UB of a soulslike will have the bosses as legendary creature transform cards so that nerds can say "phaaaase twoooo"
>>98582251>Complaining about what WotC does with real cards
>>98582258Smough and Ornstein will have meld cards if you know what I mean
>>98582260Yes. If you're gonna make custom cards don't imitate their shitty mistakes.
>>98582258Based
>>98582285I'm waiting for your billion-dollar card game.
For me, my Commander Waifu is Freya Crescent.
>>98580729>why would someone just go on the internet and tell lies?
>>98581887>Put a +1/+1 counter on her>She deals 6 infect damage on combat (wth evasion)>Then taps to deal another 6 infect>HoW iS tHis bRoKeN!?!?
>>98582285Alright second try. How's the balance on this?
>>98582427Cost is a bit clunky on the ability but did you intend for it to be repeatable to any creature?
>>98582427i dont like the lord effect.
>Summon: Fenrir didn't arrive in the mail before FNMAhhh my autism.
>>98582432Fuck meant to post the list, whatever. Hoping I get a real pod this week. The zero-interaction games made this deck play way more oppressive than it truly is. I want to get an honest experience.
>>98582429maybe it could be "other creatures you control with Reach" instead since he was one in charge of the Silver Knight Archers>>98582428Oops, it's meant to be a once per turn thing
>>98582442>Oops, it's meant to be a once per turn thingNo, no, I misread the ability. It's probably worded as intended.
Just saw this, guess im making a journey to the west deck.
>hakbal has unblockable lethal on everyone>cast stasis>the two other players (with mana up..) sperg the fuck out>hakbal player is unbothered, despite having 14 commander damage on everyone>one guy even scoops, but I convince him to not scoop twice>I have no mechanism to abuse this, and I told them about it before because I had the cool art>I sac it after one turn and I miss my untap, don't even bother removing any of hakbals shit>the two players use their removal on my sol ring, and my commander >hakbal kills all three of us at oncejfc, memes just mind rape people
>>98582458really tells you a lot about broader social issues
>>98582427
>>98582223Boringly simple and broken is arguably worse than convoluted and broken because it reeks of>fucking fine you want a good tifa card here play some landfall and then swing for game now fuck offLike wotc is just making the card good because they know people want it not because theyre actually trying to do anything interesting
>>98582521>Like wotc is just making the card good because they know people want it not because theyre actually trying to do anything interestingi want a wheel good sir, and you don't reinvent the wheel
>>98582511Why does he even have deathtouch, we're the one who finished the job with Kalameet, he just made the dragon unable to continuously fly
>>98582458>cast stasis>immediately gets hard targetedI mean, what else did you expect? The player trying to scoop right after is faggy I'll totally give you that, but I'm surprised you didn't expect to get focused down the moment that Stasis hit the stack. Regardless of if you had a way to benefit off it or not.
>>98582561Yeah, see, mind raped. If I had just used a board wipe, or won it’d be fine
Most of you think its bot real
>>98582574stasis is still mld btw
>>98582582which is why I told them at the beginning of the game that I am going to use as a dimir ramp piece or ebreak and have no way to abuse it, just have the cool art I want to run once
>>98582582if I radiate an opponents generous gift - is that MLD?
Any idea what I can take out of this deck for Kellog? I'm thinking Hoard Robberhttps://archidekt.com/decks/16689238/tax_evasion
>>98582599mld combos that rely on your opponent aren't counted as mld, this is covered by gavin as he specifically mentions someone making all lands into creatures while another wipes the board
>>98582574What kind of weird cope is this?>Yeah I played a fag card and people didn't like it>But if I didn't play a fag card people would have been fine
>>98582581Since we are back to bracket autismThis is my deck, I have 3 extra turn spells. I have fractured realm, paradox haze and panharmonicon with yshtola out. I put the top 12 nonlands on suspend 2. Which includes time warp and temporal mastery. On my next turn, I cast those 12 spells with double upkeep. Is that chaining extra turns? To me, it’s not an engine designed to loop, but if it gets big enough, I can exile half my deck and cast it, but I typically win before I take more than 1 turn at that critical mass
>>98582655>Is that chaining extra turns?gavin never defined what 'chaining extra turns' means so go ahead, 95%+ of all extra turn bs go infinite anyway
>>98582629Yes, that is the meme itself. ‘The fag’ card. Despite mutually helping my opponents not die, they used their removal on my commander (this is after a merfolk bounce sweeper) that doesn’t really impact the board, and I was more awestruck that they wouldn’t at least kill the islandwalk merfolk. Instead their free will was raped, and they could only see ‘fag card’
>>98582672I just like casting season of weaving on my chronozoa and then the next turn time spiral
>>98582677your argument essentially boils down to 'if people were better at the game they wouldn't be overreacting' but alas you need to remember who instilled edh to be a casual not to be taken seriously format to begin with
>>98581887We're posting waifu cards now?
>>98582695 The only reason I’m talking about this, is because I work in AI. I recently was debugging a prolific meme in my ai workflows, where they would start to invent and speak with specific words designed to trigger other agents to be lazy and run tests that prove nothing.So while I’m playing stasis, had a pregame discussion because I was given the good art. Essentially, the meme was so pervasive, that despite playing a game for packs, despite never being in a winning position or having any value pieces, or tutoring or a crazy kill on sight commander, they mill my muddle (only creature) and my sol ring on turn 9, despite hakbals lethal board. And then were blindsided by it. It completely consumed all of their attention.
>>98582677>Makes game-losing play (casting Stasis)>Copes and says if his opponents just helped him he wouldn't have lostThe raped male leaves.
>>98582677>Casting Stasis when somebody has lethal on boardYou don't know how much anybody's interaction costs so yeah no wonder people are scooping.
>>98582740I was never going to win, I’m not upset about losing. It’s telling them about it before the game, the response, and their surprise at losing, it put mental tunnel vision on because of a meme
>>98582737>i can't believe there are people out there completely taken in by a card's notoriety without even critically thinking if it's correct at all times or nothere's food for thought: ancestral recall is actually worse than rhystic study in edh, but far too many people will not believe you
>>98582603G-Guys?
>>98582749>casts removal on my piecesWell, they had enough to live if they killed the island walk metfolk, I still would have died to anything since I didn’t have enough blockers anyway.
>>98582757they should both be banned
>>98582788Alas sheldon said rhystic is a fair card so he could use it in his infamous ruhan deck, that's why primetime was banned instead
>>98582629>>98582561>I'm going to lose to Hakbal>but I have removal so I won't>but someone played a card I dislike>so I'll blow that up out of spite then die???
>>98582603I don't know shit about Fallout but I always thought Kellogg would be a cool commander option. Even with the "activate only as a sorcery" shit. Anyway, the Dire Fleet Hoarder kind of does double duty for you doesn't he? Provides a creature to sacrifice and a treasure to do more stuff with as well. I'd likely cut the Blood Fountain first myself. I also have to wonder how often you really get enough mana to cast that Brass's Bounty. It would make for a big swing if it comes down but it being so pricey mana wise would have me putting it on the "considering cutting" side of things.
>>98582818I don't think I ever casted Brass Bounty but yeah I think I can cut the Blood Fountain since it really doesn't serve a purpose besides giving me something to sac
>>98582751>"I'm not upset about losing">Comes to /edhg/ to complain about losingDon't need an AI to spot the lie
>>98582763What did they cast on your Stasis? I'm not interested in a hypothetical, I mean the actual literal spell.
>>98582757Here's a thought: you mald about Rhystic every day.
>>98582889they didn't remove stasis. They cast chaos warp on my commander(whif into an instant), and song of dryads on my sol ring. If you look at their POV, the player cast stasis, with muddle, sol ring and stasis out, and they perceive me as a threat and completely ignore the 10 merfolk unblockable board - then it's reasonable.
>>98582923I actually like rhystic believe it not, i use it in every b3+ i have with blue in it
>>98582934I would believe you if you didn't whine about every. fucking. day.
>>98582935It's always worth making fun of the dumb decisions of sheldon and the rc
>>98582926So they didn't have enough removal to stop lethal and you're getting mad at them because they reacted to you further limiting their options. You're just blatantly in the wrong here m8
>>98582940You play dumb shit like Toski voltron then get mad when blue decks beat you.
>>98582946Imagine being so mindbroken you complain about toski BEFORE it gets ritualposted
>>98582846>I don't think I ever casted Brass BountyThen that's definitely another card I'd consider cutting later on when you've found other cards you're interested in. Considering you've got a lot of cheap make treasures guys in your list, this guy could also help out a bit in generating them in the early game. Also surprised you don't have a Bloodghast in this kind of deck. Figured he'd be an almost auto include.
>>98582969>BloodghastI actually didn't know he existed, thanks for the recs anon will make some due changes
>>98582958Imagine confirming you know what I'm talking about and thus preemptively out yourself.Every day with you. Same stupid shit.
>>98582988Here's a thought: you mald about Toski every day.
>>98582958when every thread has some form of>Waaa waaa Rhystic study is broken! Unban prime time!>MLD proved brackets are stupid because of Liliana Dreadhorde General!>UB NUMBAH WUN! MAGIC STORY LE BAD! (posts Transit Mage)>Proxyfags = poorfag counterfeiting pubstompersat the same time that low test squirrel it's not hard to figure out a pattern
>>98583010Where's the lie?
>>98583001Defensive fingerpointing, schizo
>>98583020I would believe you if you didn't whine about Toski every. fucking. day.
>>98583015you're a retard who doesn't know how to play and wants more meh-vel and black aragorn
>>98583010You say this like this hasn't been all EDH "discussion" for 8 years. For the 7 years before that it was "How do I build Krenko, Mob Boss?"
>>98583030You type like a beta male.
>>98583034>u dont know how to play!Is thar why you're mad that i blew up your lands with liliana?
>>98583030Nobody mentioned Toski until you did the exact same "rhystic le bad prime time unban" routine again.It's old, dude.
>>98583042Defensive fingerpointing, schizo
>>98583010>All of these things are true and make me feel personally attacked. Please stop guys
>>98583045conception accepted
>>98583055And yet rhystic is good as a gc and primetime should be a gc too
What are some Human synergy in Slesnya? I'm building Silk since she's sexo and I'm assuming her wincon is go wide with tokens and finish with Finale or the Hoof or Ibex etc.
>>98583057>>98583059>>98583063Threadshitter FUMING.
>>98583060>utterly mindbroken by gavin approved mldImagine that i got someone schizoing out over a planeswalker, blood moon dickriders could never
>>98583059who are you quoting? All of them are you just coping for being bad at the game
>>98583071schizo pretending to be having edh games in the thread lmao
>>98583079Being afraid of primetime is the definition of being bad at the game tho
>>98583010You forgot "FFX Inspiring Call during fake laugh post."
>>98583091faggot id run primetime if it was unbanned because its a broken card. You just don't know how to win without it because you think that gayass screenshot of a 1/1 squirrel with inquisitors flail is hot shit
>>98583088I'm no good at pretending, trannies got me beat on that
What are some gigachad creatures? By gigachad I mean creatures that already beat the vanilla test (p/t equal to cmc), and then also have upside on top of that. Stuff like Brimaz
>>98583091>Being afraid of Rhystic Study is the definition of being bad at the game tho
>>98583099>faggot id run primetime if it was unbanned because its a broken card. And i run rhystic because it's a broken card too, why are you mad again?
>>98583104Obsessed and hypocritical
>>98583099Nta but there's probably 50 cards better than Prime Time that are legal RIGHT NOW and if you want I'll even try naming them. Hell, I can probably name 20ish cards better than Prime Time in MonoG.
>>98583108I never said rhystic be banned tho?
>>98583093Tidus_laugh.jpg is part of general 4chan culture, no different from pepes
>>98583116because you never shut the fuck up about it
>>98583130>>98583120
Mail came in today. We will fly.
>>98583128It really isn't. Zoomzooms don't know what it is, and people from back in the day know that it's an ironic cope laugh. Only secondaries from "bad voice acting in gaming" clips thought it was funny.
do you guys have fun doing this every single day
Ritual posting should be bannable and all ritual posters should be banned.
>>98583136>>98582796
>>98583149That's the power of advanced autism. Get into a routine and never want to break it.
>>98583143nta but I think he just meant this drawing which was a meme on /v/
>>98583122>Hell, I can probably name 20ish cards better than Prime Time in MonoG.Post them, and see how many of them are shit that I think should also be removed from the game.
>>98583154Point at the doll where i said rhystic should be banned
>>98583165point at the doll where I said that you said it should be banned.I can be pedantic too
A banlist discussion? Between perma bracket 3 players? Aw yeah this is the shit I come here for
>>98583079>(You) CopingWhatever you say kid.
>>98583165Do you want us to use a doll, or your authentic fem-Cloud figurine? >>98583120
>>98583176Oh so you talkin about primetime? Yeah he should be unbanned, problem?
>>98583192indians read english better than you lol
>>98583187Sorry but i like ff7 for tifa not cloud
>>98583064look at Katilda Dawnhart Prime lists, she will want Silk in the 99 and vice versa probably
>>98583197Glad we agree that primetime should be unbanned then (gc ofc i'm not a barbarian), i will mention it again when the time is right
>>98583192At this point I'm firmly for Primetime remaining banned just because it makes you unhappy.
>>98583211But i'll always have my rhystic ;)
>>98583210>schizo actually tulpas someone who agrees with him
>>98583200>Primetime is balanced, guys! That's why I want it for my landfall decks!
>>98583222Well if you're really that afraid of primetime you'd speak about it no? Cuz silence means yes.
>>98583164>Birds of Paradise>Burgeoning>Delighted Halfling>Worldly Tutor>Sylvan Library>Bloom Tender>Seedborn Muse>Exploration>Finale of Devastation>Invasion of Ikoria>Chord of Calling>Fanatic of Rhonas>Green Sun's Zenith>Icetill Explorer>Survival of the Fittest>Earthcraft>Badgermole Cub>Legolas's Quick Reflexes>Sylvan Tutor>Crop Rotation>Scapeshift>Defense of the Heart>Birthing PodDishonorable mentions:>The One Ring>Lotus Petal>Chrome Mox>Mox Diamond
>>98583232I use rhystic in yshtola btw, i like my waifus
personally, I like playing mtg
>>98583245believe it or not, you can think a card is broken without being afraid of it.you're obsessed with trannies because you argue like a woman
>>98583261So why not have 1 more broken card in a cardpool full of broken cards again?
>>98582582this has been debunked>>98582757this has been debunked. a bird in the hand is better than 2 in the bush (and yes I will pay the 1)>>98582946toski cant be countered. I'm primarily a blue player but I play my mono green toski Voltron deck a lot and beat all colors. >>98583063no primeval titan isn't going to be unbanned and shouldn't be. rhystic is a powerful yet balanced card (pay the 1, disenchant, counter it or punish extra draw).>>98583220speaking truth to power here>>98583210it won't be unbanned and the bracket system will be retired since people don't use it
>>98583281Cedh is the only barometer for a card's actual powerlevel and primetime will be lucky to have a single home in lumra there
>>98583269because there should be less busted shit in the game instead of more you stupid shithead
>>98583305There should be more busted shit actually, if it's too busted make it a gc and voila everyone should be playing b2 anyway
>>98583247A lot of these are good, but have decent counterplay. BoP takes a turn to get online and only generates one (additional) mana per turn while dying to a bunch of incidental burn. I personally get more mileage out of Bloom Tender than it.>>BurgeoningThe problem with this one is that you need the cards in hand to make it work, and it's a dead draw late in the game if you missed out on that early burst, and with a lot of decklists, my own included, starting to place a greater emphasis on artfact mana rocks, it's not as good as it usually seems unless you have some existing landfall synergy. Same deal as bird where it's good, but not busted.There's a lot of cards on that list that are just efficient mana pieces or tutors, but they ignore the fact that Primetime is both stapled on a repeatable body.>>Badgermole Cub>>Legolas's Quick Reflexes>>Birthing PodAgreed here.>>ScapeshiftI can see this one, but at the same time that usually eats your manabase for a turn.>>Defense of the HeartI've heard some people say it's telegraphed, but honestly I can see your point here.
I'd rather discuss Nicol Bolas's committed romantic relationship with Ugin.
>>98583312keep it banned and ban field of the dead
>>98583335BoP also costs 1 mana, strongly contrasting primeval titan which costs 6. I would hope that the 6-drop does more than the 1-drop.The rest is you just agreeing that these cards are stronger than Primeval Titan.
>create a self reported paper game tracking system and give rewards like arena for using itThere you go I saved paper magic and solved the EDH problem in one go
>>98583346I won 10000 games yesterday Mr. WotC.
>>98583344Field of the dead was made a gc for one reason and that's to remove it from b2, same reason as farewell
>>98583350That's very good of you timmy. Here's your $3 off product coupon for the week and since those are 10000 self with no store reported wins everyone knows your a smurf.
if my deck can ramp into Insurrection and kill someone on t4 does that mean it's a bracket 4 deck?
>>98583391No
>>98583384>Pay store owner $10 to report 10000 wins
>>98583391If you consistently do it most games, sure.
>>98583415If i get to do it only 8% of the time is it b4? What about 10% 15%? 20%?
>>98583105that's a stupid fucking metric, here's an actual gigachad
>>98583345>The rest is you just agreeing that these cards are stronger than Primeval Titan.I conceded three and gave you a "maybe" on two more.>>There's a lot of cards on that list that are just efficient mana pieces or tutors, but they ignore the fact that Primetime is both stapled on a repeatable body.Please reread this part and realize I didn't want to list every single one just to give the same reason (i.e. Crop Rotation).And it's not just that you get more out of a 6-drop than a 1-drop. With BoP, you get a very early mana lead, but that lead peaks at 1 additional mana, doesn't thin your deck, and at best for combat is a one-time blocker, making it useless late game. Primetime is a repeatable deck thinner, so it has value even if you draw it late into the game, and you get value out of it as soon as it enters, limiting the counterplay around it.
>>98583430Use your feelings
>>98583391No, but if it can consistently win on turn 4, then yes it's a very strong bracket 4. In my experience, bracket 4 games usually end turns 5-8, but if everyone is playing a lot of interaction it can almost double that.Insurrection is one of the best ways to close out a powerful game, but chances are people will have fogs, sac outlets, etc. to counter it in high powered games, so it rarely just roflstomps the table on turn 4 or 8.
>>98583433>Primetime is a repeatable deck thinnerNo timmy fetchlands do not thin your deck so your draws get better
>>98583404At that point your just a whale user, because 10,000 at once would be easily identifiable fraud that hurt the WPN store. That sort of rate of people trying to smurf that many games to troll or otherwise cheat people would be acceptable I think, presuming there would be report options and stuff.
>>98583432Based gato.
>>98583437I'm actually being logical here but what a coincidence that nobody can define what 'consistent' even means
>be office wagie>no friends at work>friendly in general but kind of awkward/loner>find out everyone started learning EDH and has been meeting up regularly to play after hours>even old coworkers from 2-3 years ago have been goingI would fucking destroy them if I were there
>>98583433>Prime Time having a body is what makes it better than cards that win the game on the spot because they tutor to playYeah okay bro this isn't 2011 where Snapcaster Mage being a 2/1 is what pushed it over the edge.
>>98583247>Green tutors are broken>Anyway I want a card that tutors two lands on etblandniggers deserve nothing lmao
>>98583485Damn so broken
>>98583492Can't be blinked, can't be tutor'd with aforementioned green creature tutors, can't be cloned, can't be given haste to get 2 more lands, can't go get 2 more lands next turn, can't block, can't attack, does not trigger greens numerous big creature = draw etbs, can't be reanimated, shit false equivalency see me after class.
>>98583483I remember when Titan was still legal and consistently getting him out on turn 3, sometimes with haste. Absolutely terrorized tables.
>>98583517>aforementioned green creature tutorsYep and that's why tutors are more broken than creatures
>>98583451You don't play Magic.>>98583483>>Prime Time having a body is what makes it betterConsidering how many of your cards are just efficient creature tutors, how is this not relevant?>where Snapcaster Mage being a 2/1 is what pushed it over the edgeSnapcaster was never good for "being a 2/1" in this format, he was good for being a body with a relevant effect in the colors he was in. You got value on his entry and a blocker if you needed it. You could make the argument that the 2/1 body had a lot of relevance in constructed, but the same could be said for Primetime since people cheating that out became a problem.
>>98583523Primetime is a repeatable tutor
>>98583519That's a nice deck you have there timmyAnd yes my deck is b3 legal too
>>98583527Because the card you're searching won't be Primeval Titan. If your deck wins off lands it's running Crop Rotation and Scapeshift, not Hour of Devastation.
>>98583523Damn almost as if the card you're advocating for is a tutor that happens to be a creature or something
>>98583535If you need multiple attacks with primetime you're doing your land combo wrong
>>98583545*Hour of Promise
>>98583415>>98583400hm.I mean I definitely can't do it consistently but the deck consistently ramps to 8 on turn 4. It's Ashling, Rekindled doing a basic 2-4-7 plan (although in this deck it's actually a 2-4-8 since Ashling adds multiple mana after the first turn). the gimmick is that I wanted all of the threats to be noncreature spells, so there are a bunch of 7-9 mana sorceries along with the whole mana-spent matters suite from Final Fantasy. I just threw Insurrection in because it's an 8 mana sorcery that I like. but it feels like every time I happen to draw insurrection by turns 4 or 5 I'd be kind of sandbagging not to boom out the biggest threat with it...>>98583449that's the thing though, I'm not under any delusions that the deck would be a problem in a bracket 4 playgroup. I'm worried about it being too strong in bracket 2 or 3 which is what I was targeting...I think I might cut it even though I like it
>>98583551>attacknta but lmao
>>98583549Some tutors are better than others and there are better tutors than primetime, because primetime can only find lands
>>98583562Primetime can only be a repeatable tutor if it attacks>but blink!You're also doing your land combo wrong
>>98583572Primetime is busted even though he tutors only land because he PUTS IT INTO PLAY and he does it TWICE, and he does that every damn turn you get to untap with him. He's one of the best tutors period.
>>98583605Primetime wont see play in rogthras 100% guaranteed
Troll of Khazad-dûm in the dollar box at the LGS!
I kind of want to put this together but it's really hard to ignore how much worse it is than monoG Loot
>prime time has broken many formats>He's totes fine though, you're just bad
>>98583620but anon, Loot can't pull a Zacama
>>98583560Insurrection is theft and theft is only as strong as its opponentsIf your retard pod complains tell them to start running weaker cards
>Summer Bloom was the problem not Amulet>Splinter Twin was too strong
>>98583621>he thinks primetime's the star of the show
Prime Time is gonna look like a joke when they finally jump this bad motherfucker over to paper
>>98583651I think amulet titan is significantly less problematic in hundred-card singleton than in 60 card formats
>>98583682Yes and that's why primetime should be a gc
>>98583659enjoy your acorn symbol buddy
>>98583480I used to play Commander with some co-workers, but I ditched just because the dude who hosted it was consistently a slow-player who constantly asks for takes-backs and over time I realized I wasn't having fun and I was spending more time 'on my phone, waiting', then actually playing the game. They were cool-dudes aside from that. There's this other dude at my office I used to play Magic with but then quit roughly around when UniversesBeyond became a thing. I see him at work and he goes out of his way to avoid eye-contact with me. He was kind of a smarmy dick back then, but when I saw him recently he looked like he got mind-crushed and he is a shell of his former self (last time I saw him was pre-covid)./schizo rant about Magic playing co-workers
>>98583695That too will be peeled away with time. They're already in the process of printing alchemy cards into paper and once there are enough of them they'll change the legality rules. The water is heating up little froggy, soon you will be boiling.
>>98583651Considering hes part of the deck name, yeah he is.
>>98583712they really do like the slow roll method of normalising controversial prints
>>98583771Any fun thematic ways to build him?
>>98583551>>98583593>land comboThis accidentally admits that Primetime entering only once is a huge threat.
The only way I can think of to build Selesnya mill is to make a bunch of tokens with altar of dementia and altar of brood. could also just make a fuck ton of mana and then use sands. Even with green's bullshit draw i dont think making everyone draw a ton of cards would probably work. maybe in addition to the other ideas. idk
>>98583778none.
>>98582458literally me but after casting a hushbringer
>>98583853The best way to play mill off color is to just become an artifact deck. Painter and Grindstone can go in any deck. If that is too competitive for your tastes so you can do some dumb shit with artifact untappers, keening stone and all the mana in the world.
I had fun at the LGS today!I hope you guys do too, or are playing with friends
>>98583894playing with friends tomorrow I also need to get sleeves for some new decks
what are some interesting blink targets I could throw in my vannifar deck?
>>98583391yes because that is the ceiling of the deck
>>98583687that's 2 cards vs 1 card tho
>>98583391Are you a fellow Ovikabro? That's how I won with that deck last time I played it
>>98583920prime time
>>98583920Primeval Titan
>>98583894I only build decks, I don't play them. I also shitpost on /edh/.
>>98583920thoracle
>>98583920sorry, there are none
>>98584046i knew this UW shit wasn't for me, fuck this i'm going back to my The Whizzer deck
Oh boy I cant wait for reality fractur where only about 1/3 of the cards will be fractured while 1/3 will be the same cards but normal and also its a strixhaven set too! dont you guys just love strixhaven?
>>98584058post list when done. I really wanna see the synergies
>>98583920Has anyone mentioned prime time?
>>98583920uhhhhhh... uhhidk
>>98583920Primeval Titan is basically THE flicker target in simic. Nothing else even comes close.
>>98583010I'm just here to post bullshit.
>>98584299You have strayed far from the concept of a goblin.
>>98584313I don't agree, but it is what it is.
>>98584317Holy Moly
>>98584317This is porn. Kill yourself immediately.
>>98584317I want to put my dick in those boob orifices
>>98584313and I say he has not strayed far enough.
>>98584401I would never use these, but they are very funny
>you can blink something and something happens, therefore it should be bannedTimmy hours i see
>>98583840Who knew hour of promise resolving was such a huge threat
>>98583952It is, in practice, one card
>>98584446You say this like sorceries and creatures are somehow equivalent in green.
>>98584474You can run another color to fetch sorceries to emulate titan
>>98584299>>98584317Imagine getting absolutely mogged by a bunch of shitty cars.>>98584401>>98584404>>98584410>>98584417>>98584421
>>98584441ok no this nigga should stay banned
>>98584299she cute
>>98584466that effect should have said "towns" instead of lands
>>98584524Every card that would get out of jail will automatically be a gc so it wont ruin your pod timmy
>>98584421>>98584417>>98584410>>98584404>>98584401I wish this had been Aether Drift.
>>98583762>Considering hes part of the deck name, yeah he is.Amulet gets top billing for a very good reason
>>98584575>Top billing A comes before T in a alphabet anon, that's how naming convention works.That's the only reason why it's amulet titan and not titan amulet.
>>98584575What were you trying to imply with this anon the deck has always used both of them together and the deck namesake includes both
>>98584585It's because it flows better, alphabetical order has nothing to do with it.
>>98584585RDJ was first billed before benedict cumberbatch aka sheoldred when he shouldn't be? fuck avengers LIED to me
>>98584585But then why does my friend call his deck Temur Stompy and not Stompy Temur
>>98584524You don't understand. This anon can't think of single another way to beat Rhystic Study players in mono green than playing busted creatures.
>>98584597Chex mix autists!Don't be intentionally retarded.
>>98584591have you ever wondered why it was called amulet bloom back when summer bloom was legal
>>98584609It is b>>98584617ecause he's an American with an American education.
>>98584575The straightman in a comedy duo usually gets listed first. Also Titan is the punchline wincon and Amulet is the means.
>>98584557Imagine if aetherdrift had a crossover with f1/nascar/car brands and your chase mythic just had a random chance of being a version of that card in a race suit sitting on top of a fucking honda civic or some shit
>>98584613i dunno man necro's pretty busted too
>>98584636i don't see the punchline in a love song of night and day
>>98584650Is that... LAND RAMP!?AIEEEEE SAVE ME TRINKET MAGE!!!
>>98584617And it still ran primetime.
I don't understand this level of cope to just try and hand wave that primetime is a strong card
>>98584668and it didn't get billed because 'normal' nonexplosive primetime beats is hilariously bad and a desperation play and that's why pilot go through all the effort to memorize the lines because the explosiveness is the #1 reason to play the deck
>>98584626Swing and a miss he's from Singapore
>>98584650Night is more important than day and "song" describes "love."Do you play the game or just eat the cards?
>>98584682Night is more important than Day because he's black and wotc loves people the darker they are
who's playing commander tonight in person rather than MODO?? any new decks youre trying out???? whats GOOOD?!
>>98584680Well shoot you got me guess they better change the name of the modern deck to amulet grazer primetime just isn't important and actually hilariously bad. All these years they've run him as a big joke
>>98584690they should unban summer bloom in modern actually
>>98584682>"song" describes "love."Uhhh....
>>98584690By that logic Thoraccle is balanced because almost none of the decks that use it as a wincon include it in the name.And also Delver wasn't important in Izzet Delver because it's listed second.Can you seriously think about your posts for two seconds you actual retard?
>>98584702I forgot the >
>>98584713You were the one trying to downplay primetime because it wasn't in the namesake of summer bloom. Don't turn around and blame me for pointing out both version of the deck still used the card.
>>98584641That would have been infinitely better than the piss rares we got so I'd take it.
>>98584732so why is thoracle legal while primetime isn't? they both don't get billed in deck names but are wincons
Primetime is fine
>>98584732I meant >>98584713 for >>98584680
>>98580471Pokemon doesn't bother to do any bans in Standard because the Pokemon TCG is literally perfectly fine with exactly one viable deck existing in the meta. Their laziness to make an interesting card game is not a plus by any metric. This shouldn't be that much of a problem when playing online since Standard is not their only format, but you still to this day cannot play all your Expanded cards on their current client.
>>98584740NTA but honestly the only thing that's probably saving Thoraccle is that it actually is the "only shows up at cEDH" line they said about Dockside
>>98584755so dockside will be a gc too eventually because hey it'll only show up in cedh frequently? kinda makes primetime ban kinda silly huh
>>98584762>Disingenuous whataboutism to a statement nobody made
>>98584751cedh blue decks aren't collectively called thoracle decks, they are called by their partner name or their commander or their archetype because the wincon is trivial the way to get to the win is what's important
>>98584762Dockside got banned people WERE using it to be oppressive in non-competitive games.Seriously, do you actually play the game, or do you just stick cards in your mouth and start chewing?
>>98584740>muh thoracleWay to self report that you don't even play cedh
>>98584776Correct, that's why "amulet is listed first" is such a stupid argument.
>>98584781Just don't spam artifacts around that guy, how is that hard?
>>98584781and by making it a gc it won't oppress b2 games
>>98584317Vaush ass proxies, nigger over here beating his little micro chode to “short stack goblins”
>>98584783why is wotc reporting that people want thoracle banned then
>>98582140some funnies there
>>98584798>Just don't play mana rocks
>>98583920>not building her as pure spellslinger control for salt
>>98584810Rhystic being a permanent that you can just play around makes it balanced, people crying and begging for it to be banned just want to goldfish in front of their opponent with zero thought.
>>98584810because it scares little timmies like you and is not the actual top dog in cedh
>>98584823Yeah just ensure the table collectively doesn't play 3 artifacts or enchantments. Easy!
>>98584829>because it scares little timmies like youthoracle doesn't scare timmies as much as primetime does clearly
>opponent plays rhystic>Draws 30 extra cards>Wins
>>98584834If you're not being sarcastic this is the dumbest thing you've said all thread.
>>98584838correct.
>>98584810I want them banned. For no reason but to see people on pulling out their hair and jumping into incinerators with their rhystic collections
>>98584834landfall player here, i don't feed dockside, i do my part now do yours fucktard
>>98584840>Losing argument >Vaguepost in butthurt
>>98584840>allows the player to draw 30 cards straight without ever paying 1 mana or casting removal>”BULLSHIT CARD BAN IT ARRRRGGGHHH FUCKYOUFUCKYOUFUCKYOU”
>primetime this primetime thatYeah sure but what about my zesty elf?
>>98584823Now you're getting it!
>>98584854>RLNope.
>>98584854wizards can't milk him so he stays in gay baby jail
>>98584854>reserved listwotc would find a loophole to get true duals reprinted first before rofellos ever gets out of the slammer
>>98584852>every player at the table must play 10 turns behind to appease the rhystic player :)
>>98584838Green has so many cracked options for getting lands for nothing that prime time might as well be considered powercrept. If your pod is consistently getting raped by annoying cards you can just play around them with more removal.
>>98584862The loop hole is just doing it, like they did with sol ring.
>>98584864But also only play Radha because Dockside wasn't a problem.
>>98584864Yes, if you want to do your gayass decks strategy with zero consideration for your opponents you should just goldfish at home.
>>98584867maybe when wotc grows a spine and not be seattle ultra faggots
>>98584865Hot take: I'm always thought that card should be banned. Not GC. BANNED.
>>98584854>RL elfHe's dead, Jim.
>>98584873every single player at the table must agree to not play their deck or you feed the rhystic player, in which case you will lose to the rhystic player or the guy feeding the rhystic player
>>98584876>banning a tempt cardYou’re gonna make me puke bro that’s so fucking funny
>>98584878
>>98584865this card is weak because your opponents could not take the offer, no this never happens but it could
>>98579972They banned it and then put actual real life crusaders into the game in the Assassin's Creed set. So dumb.
>>98584884Take every complaint people here have about Rhystic and a few about Prime Time and you'll have what this card is.
>>98584902>woke 1.0 was craaaaazzzzyyyyou can already hear it
>>98584881
>>98584921*draws 4 cards*
>>98584921>thanks for paying the 1 and setting yourself back a card anon, much appreciated, we'll take it from here :)
>>98584924>your game can’t recover from 4 mana of removalWhat the fuck are you doing bro? Just ramp more dummy it came for free with your Sauron precon.
>>98584922>He can't read cardsPlease play something other than Toski tribal. You need to expand your card pool knowledge.
>>98584934>oh you can recover? good job anon you'll be the designated police the whole night, you see our poor decks can't recover so please do the needful...
There is no legitimate argument for prime titan remaining on the banlist. The ceiling for the card is dependent on your bracket and the only time it is a real problem is if you are running some overpower lands or degenerate land combo. It has been like a decade and the power of the format has exploded. The worst thing it will do is make landfall decks stronger and who gives a fuck. People act like the format is. It full of broken bullshit already and more is being printed. >Omg omg anon is going to tutor for his best lands tapped repeatedly omg omg what will we doo?It's honestly strange seeing anons here and on reddit scream to high heavens about how overpowered it is meanwhile retard shit like the one ring, bow masters, consecrateed sphinx, the great henge and a million other stupidly powerful cards infest the format.
>>98584942This didn't happen by the way
It's not coming off the list give it a rest anon
>>98584952
>>98584952those cards should all be banned too
>>98584959i was there 3000 years ago when people thought releasing gifts ungiven would break the format...
There is no legitimate argument for black lotus remaining on the banlist. The ceiling for the card is dependent on your bracket and the only time it is a real problem is if you are running some overpower spells or degenerate combo. It has been like a decade and the power of the format has exploded. The worst thing it will do is make burn decks stronger and who gives a fuck. People act like the format is. It full of broken bullshit already and more is being printed.>Omg omg anon is going to ramp for his three drop omg omg what will we doo?It's honestly strange seeing anons here and on reddit scream to high heavens about how overpowered it is meanwhile retard shit like the one ring, bow masters, consecrateed sphinx, the great henge and a million other stupidly powerful cards infest the format.
>>98584967I want sundering titan off but I'm not about to spend 6 hours letting people know that
>>98584968unforunately the reserved list strikes againthis one, however, is totally fair
>>98584968nice
>>98584974*totally banned
>>98584972but think of all the grudgeposting and the gloating when time proves you right
UNBAN THE ENGINE YOU COWARD
>>98584978for now
>>98584984>>98584988Literal cope
>>98584984I saw anons here scream for years about braids and biorhythm and now that they're both legal I haven't seen a single decklist pic with ether in these threads
>>98584987Reminder that this hit the list because they were afraid of Emry.
>>98584999You need to have gigantic balls to play Cabal.
>>98584988On what grounds? Dockside and Jewed only get better as the rest of the game powercreeps.
>>98585002It was Urza and they didn't want to ban an at-the-time chase mythic.
>turn 1 braids>go
>>98584968The power 9 should be unbanned.
>>98584974>printed for commander>literally unplayable outside of commander (literally)>banned in commanderwhy did they think this card was okay?
Post your motherfucking decks
Why do we even ban things? Just go wild west with the format.
>>98585023*rest of the Power 9
>>98585015>On what grounds?1. cedh is very sloppy and needs more turbo2. wotc specifically told the retarded rc NOT to ban them3. wotc needs reprint equity4. this is the real purpose of the gamechanger concept
Did the RC faggots ever post proof they received muh death threats?
>>98585026Unsightly. Delete this.
>>98585024Because Opposition Agent couldn't sell packs on its own.
>>98585031Post your motherfucking deck
>>985850291, 3, and 4 are just shallow opinions, 2 you have no source for
>>98585038I will not. My camera is out of batteries and I am not going to replace them at this hour.
>>98585029>turbofag when they couldn't win on turn 0 and had to call other ways of playing as slop
>>98585051hey the cedh community called the rhystic smothering copy enchantment meta slop, not me, personally i'd just call them goodstuff
>>985850471 is actually correct and proves you don't play cedh2https://www.reddit.com/r/mtg/comments/1fwtdp1/fact_check/3 and 4 is just business and proves you are unemployed
Felix Argyle is my Commander.
>>98585059We need to purge cedhtroons from this world.
>>98585070Shunran Nishi is mine.
>>98585026
>>98585069>He then specified that Wizards didn't want all four of these cards banned at once. "I don't know if they said 'Hey, let's just Nadu and Dockside' or what, but they were like 'This full decision, do not do this.'"Please read your source, redditor.
>>98585070he cute
>>98585078>He then specified that Wizards didn't want all four of these cards banned at once>i can't recall the exact details but i know for sure they said "This full decision, do not do this.'"you may not believe josh lee kwai, but there's my source and the rc is now dead, who knew wotc could be right twice a day
>>98585070he cu-->>98585089dammit
Stephen King Universe UB soon
>>98585078>>98585091god, rc was so fucking based for this
>>98585117cozy new bake
>>98585091Why did you cut some words out of the quote?
>>98585119Actual new one here.>>98574745>>98574745>>98574745
>>98584441Out of the big three banned green creatures, this one is the most agretious, and deserves to be unbanned the least.Rofellos needs to be unbanned. It was only banned as commander for years with no problem, and rule 0 and Braids now being legal gives no reason to keep this banned. Don't like it as a commander? Rule 0 it out. In the 99? Only strong early turns in mono green, and so what? Tons of other green cards are just as strong in that situation.Primetime is straight up bonkers, but doesn't lead to unfun play like Sylvan.I think all three should be unbanned fyi.
>>98584317why do the skele-gobs still have ears
>>98585415Same reason they have shoulders and defined arms, they are zombies or something not full skeletons.
>>98585026I'll take pictures of my decks again once my new mat arrives. Every other picture I have is very out of date at this point. This deck doesn't get many changes.
>>98584999I love my braids deck but people are literally so fucking whiny about stax it's not even fun to play because they just spend all game bitching about it. Something has gone horribly wrong in the 30 years this game has been around because I genuinely think people enjoy bitching about cards more than playing them
