Green Bolas EditionPrevious: >>98767021>Newshttps://magic.wizards.com/en/news/announcements/commander-banned-and-restricted-february-9-2026https://magic.wizards.com/en/news/announcements/commander-brackets-beta-update-february-9-2026>Current Banlisthttps://magic.wizards.com/en/banned-restricted-list#commander-banned>Bracket Informationhttps://files.catbox.moe/4tbvzw.pnghttps://files.catbox.moe/r62yfy.png>Former Commander Website: Learn the basics, and read the format philosophy laid down by the rules committeehttps://mtgcommander.net>Card Searchhttps://scryfall.com>Card Statistics: See what everyone else puts in their Commander decks based on what is posted to the Internethttps://www.edhrec.com>Deck List Sites: You can search for decks that other people have made. Authors often have comments that explain their deck strategy and card choiceshttps://www.archidekt.comhttps://www.moxfield.com>Green Bolas>Manabase Information: Find out what lands you can add to your deck, sorted by category, based on a chosen color identityhttps://managathering.com>Proxy Guidehttps://pastebin.com/9Xj1xLdM>Preconshttps://magicprecons.com>TQWhy is he green?
What was that card where a giant sea serpent attacks the Rhystic university?
>>98771868green is the color of gay
>>98771874?
Why was the other thread deleted?
>>98771897That's the spice, thanksI'm planning to make a deck of sea serpents, wurms, just big guys 4u because they're epic
>>98771904He couldnt accept that he was wrong about biorhythm so he cried to the janny lol
>>98771904OP was being edrama whore
Since when did people use the terms bracket and game-changer? I've never heard them until recently
Flavour>>>>>>>mechanicsShrimple asUB is total dogshit, anyone who says "I only care about le mechanics of le card" should be shot and killed
Pulled a Japanese showcase The Theorist, Jace Beleren. Hold or sell? Can't figure out where the price is headed and I want to pick up the Miles Johnston one eventually.
>looking through piles brewing for pic related>wtf when did I pull a FF Azusa>wth how long did I have doubling season>why the fuck do own a token doubler elspethCheck your bulk anons. Even if you dont play those colours still check that box.
>>98771950>selling game piecesAre you retarded?
Thought this was going to be a bigger hot ticket item than it ended up being.
>>98771948>the community that says 'babies are just a bunch of cells' is now telling me that mtg is more than a bunch of mechanics
>>98771965cringe post
>>98771972>oh if it isnt the ramifications of my reductionism
>>98771948I'd take Hobbit over Bloomburrow.
>>98771965The entire reason cards have names, artwork and even the colour system is because flavour, lore, ambiance, atmosphere etc is genuinely importantIt happens in videogames too, faggots think "le only mechanics matter" and it's retarded thenThere's a reason no one likes UB raping Magic, there's a reason we're attached to certain colours
>>98771977What a passionate postIf only the same idea was applied to real living things instead of a children's card game though!
>>98771965based post
>>98771974bringing up random /pol/ shit shows me you are insane.
>>98771983>if you care about one thing then that means you don't care about anything else4chan reductionism is not helpful anontachi
>>98771991>the community that says 'anything can be art, even a urinal' is now telling me that mtg is more than a bunch of random IPsYour reductionism has simply come home to roost, no /pol/ needed
>>98771996>i'm X on one thing and Y on another same thing>who cares if it's inconsistent, i said soHonesty goes a long way
>>98772000Keep going, nutcase.
>>98772002I accept your concession
>>98772007
>>98772001Genuinely autistic or shitposting? This is the EDH thread, therefore I'm only talking about things relevant to EDH
>>98772008You will never be a woman either, tadc tranny
>>98772010I certainly didn't post that image because I figured you'd have that sort of angry reaction. No sir.
>>98772009I'm just saying i cannot take you seriously given the track record of the majority of this playerbase, they werent exactly hiding it eitherIf you happen to agree with me that's fine but that still doesnt change what the majority really thinks
>>98772013>what do trannies and vegans have in common>dont worry they'll tell you
What's the most reddit colour combination and why is it Rakdos
>>98772008You figure out how to align text properly yet?
>>98772022It's actually simic
>>98772024How so?
>>98772023Personally I don't like how WOTC does text so I do it how I like. Much like how the Miku guy centers his text despite no card doing that and it looking awful.
>>98772029>tree huggers>muh diversity>gender reassignment sur- i mean graft and adapt
>>98772040>tfw vegan environmentalist but against tranny nonsenseColours for this feel?
>>98772044Gruul
>>98772030>doing that and it looking awful.Kindred spirits, I guess.
>>98772053I feel like you try a lot to get my attention and I like it.
>>98772057How do I get women to give me this response IRLIs the answer playing more mono-green?
>>98772044Mono G
>>98772022*gruul
>>98772057I just want you to be better.
>>98772060Obsessively stalk them due to being mad.
>>98772062>want to play mono-G big guys because that's awesome>no counter spells>no way to get back after a board wipeWhat do?
>>98772161bro your kamahl's will?
There should be fetchlands that come into play untapped that aren't 50 dollars other than fabled passage
>>98772248i was confused until i went and looked it up and realized the specific ones I run happen to be the cheapest lol.
>>98772022I'm not sure about color combo, but Izzet is objectively the most Reddit guild. 90% of Izzet guildmembers are characterized in such a manner that is virtually indistinguishable from your average Redditor.
>>98772262Oh, and I should specify, they were like this BEFORE WotC's writing staff became solely staffed by Redditors.
>>98772272There he goesThere he goes again
>>98772262Holy fucking reddit, I think you're right
>>98772278oh my BASEDANCE
I want a commander that's belladonna but easy to keep track of.
>>98772262Reddit would never support a guild run by a transphobic dragon.
4chan thinks they're Dimir but they're actually Gruul
>>98772262Orzhov Ghost Council hands typed this because they can't handle how best guild leader controls two guilds.
'member when Orzhov was run by a bad bitch? 'member when Wizards were fine with straight white males playing their game?
>>98772298
>>98772298the fact that they commissioned ghost teysa artwork but relegated her to alchemy garbage speaks volumes.
>>98772302Not gonna lie bros, I would the first and third
>>98772308I'd fuck em all. I'm hardcore!
How do I find the real versions of UB cards?
>untap symbol on cardI have never seen this
>>98772326Play RGW instead.
>>98772335I mean you have a card like Tifa right, but that's a UB card, so what's her real version with the same abilities, mana etc?
HYDRA TRIBAL
>>98772338It's still Tifa, only the Spider-Man cards got functionally identical alternate versions (and only on Arena).
>>98772331
fleem :)
>>98771868>https://archidekt.com/decks/26976205/tammy_and_her_impossibilitiesFinished putting together UW sloppa of the highest quality. My idea was "modular planeswalkers", spamming the cards that add abilities to planeswalkers and supporting it with the commander and empower Jace. Should be a fun B3.
wait a minute it's not called Oracle anymore?
>>98772395tran, the transibility
>>98772395Doesn't she fuck over the entire Jaceverse by releasing Emrakul on it?
>>98771964It will once a shitty magic youtuber gushes about it. Timmy's haven't realized it's on curve with krenko, and a really good mono color & colorless utility land.
If I were in charge at wizards I would completely reboot the MTG setting.
>>98772437If I was in charge at wizards I would enjoy my free time while having my slaves work their asses off. once a month I take the fancy powerpoint presentation they made for me, check through if AI if everything is correct and tell Chris Cocks how amazing I am.
>>98772421nah, it was offensive
>>98772424Wtf the deck is almost entirely UW cards and it’s still trans and gay? I thought this was what you were supposed to do to be based make it make sense
>>98772432Jace was a bit of a chud so it was deserved, never go chud mode.
>>98772464Are the trans cards in the room with us right now?
Can't decide on my next commander. Stuck between colorless Omnath, Jeskai Vraska, Ur Sphinx, Codie, or Dack Fayden
SEXHow is Selesnya?
>>98772464UW is entirely trans and gay
How many game actions in one turn is too many? I've been eyeballing a manual storm deck that just tries to churn through as much of the deck as possible every single turn, but in goldfishing I'm never sure of a win until well into the winning turn. I just want an idea of how many things I could be doing in one turn before people start getting annoyed.
>>98772487this card has been DEBUNKED by the strixhaven bear
I really do hate UW lore. It's extremely derivative.
>>98772504be derivative of cool things
>>98772512Actual films with this feel?
>>98772521Angels Egg
>>98772522Sorry, actual films for this feel that are also good? Watching some bitch stare at a campfire for 10 straight minutes isn't good
I was making a custom card but these abilities I cooked up seemed very familiar... are there any other cards that do something similar to my custom?
>>98772521excalibur
>>98772531This is begging for a Sir Didymus alt
There's already too many cards, we don't need new ones. Just use an alternate of an existing one.
>>98772526I recommend watching dancing fruit sensory videos cause obviously you need jingling keys in front of your face 24/7
>>98772531>color pie break>3 mana 5/3 with upside that bolts on ETB and shits out treasures>poor formattingI think you need to go back to the drawing board. Anyways, the closest thing I can think of to that is Roxanne.
>>98772541Oshii is a hack, although I remember being 15 and forcing myself to watch through absolute dreck because it made me seem adultWhen you grow up you'll understand
>>98772540>There's already too many cards, we don't need new ones. Just use an alternate of an existing one.This, but 20 years ago.
Why is she sad?
>>98772552you'd be sad too if you saw what magic's become...
>>98772575I still like it but I've definitely blocked out everything since the first Universe Beyond
>>98772531>blas act the board>net like 40 treasures, recast this guy and delete one of your opponentsLmao
>>98772581Arabian Nights was the 4th ever set, anon. Or are you talking about AFR from 2021?
>>98772604You know what I meanThere's a distinct line where MtG became one of THOSE properties
>>98772331Enjoy your combos
>>98772604unique adaptations don't count because they just don't ect.
>>98772615I look like and do this while tapping for four mana
Listen chud, everything the corporation does is good
Merfolk tribal and by extension blue is the most reddit color because it's what that fag Tolarian Community College plays
Scars of Mirrodin is actually when the game went irrevocably to shit. Though, Lorwyn was when the shit began.
It was when they listened to twitter
People have been saying (newest set) ruined the game since I started playing in 4ED.
wtf is Llanowar
I really do not fathom why they didn't just make UB silver borderedThat way the Fortnite: The Gathering redditors can soiface over Tifa beating Optimus, while the actual players can play the real game
>>98772658They weren't even willing to make silver border cards silver border.
>>98772666Honestly this pissed me the most off about Unfinity.
>>98772634'cept invoke 110% saw play despite being on the reserved list
>>98772681Uh no it didn't chud, those cards were never played, now stop noticing things
Should i run chromatic lantern in 5c or nah?
>>98772298hawt
>>98772307The ghost artwork is frankly horrible, it's obvious it would have never made it into a main paper set>alchemy garbageThe card is fun as fuck and it lets me farm endless seething on ladder, really unique tooYou could easily play it on paper as well, using experience counters instead (or some other player-attached type of counter if you also run Minthara I guess)
Alright lads I'm torn between>mono-white>mono-black>orzhov>mono-green or gruul nonsense stompyThis cardboard is expensive
>mull to 6>still a sketchy hand>top deck krosan verge>spend the first 4 turns waiting my taplands to ramp>play pod, go search a sower of tempt>next turn I start saccing their creatures and getting more theft effects on board to control>they have no removal for my mind flayers and what not>dude, you are playing bracket 3nigga you are the one playing indestructible creatures, I literally can't pop 'em
what's the most based wedge and why is it Mardu?
>>98772715gruul stompy is fun, I keep losing against it
>>98772720because black is the best color, black-red has the best 2 color spells and white is there to give the impression that you are playing a bad color so people underestimate you
>>98772681Invoke was also probably the one that was most obviously actually a racist design.
>>98772729access to Swords, Path, Smothering Tithe and Armageddon is pretty cool I guess
There's no legendary creatures from a single one of these sets? What am I doing wrong?
>>98772681Don't forget crusade. Crusade actually has a modern border reprint from an old duel deck
>>98772634Reminder that this entire debacle came about because they were accused of having racist hiring practices (With actual merit behind the claims) and WotC did this to deflect since they didn't want to be on the receiving end of BLM rioters.
>>98772735https://moxfield.com/search/cards?q=set%3Ascars%20t%3Alegend&advanced=
>>98772746>racist hiring practisesLike hiring white people with actual skill instead of some purple hair "non-binary" twitter schizo
>>98772717Reminds of the time when,>I draw no ramp I just curve into my 4 cmc commander (Celes)>for the next couple of turns I reanimate one of the 7 cmc creatures i dumped >"dude wtf your deck is too strong for bracket 3"
I just tell everyone my deck is bracket 4 even when it's not
>haha bro it's just bracket 1, i'm new to the game, i don't even really understand the brackets>i play winter orb, your turn
didn't this guy get banned?
>>98772793no
>>98772730sure but damn if it's the only one of that kind of effect and knowing wotc they will never print anything comparable
>>98772637I fucking love Scars of Mirrodin but I feel like you are still right. There was something off about a card like Wurmcoil Engine being made.
>>98772801Yeah no shit they're not going to print one of the most ridiculous off-color stax pieces of all-time.
>>98772298Eriette and Teysa are still solid commanders that can run Orzhov, surprisingly good colour combination for baddies. Only Mardu is better in that department, and maybe Golgari, if you like your women with a bit of matured stench.
>>98772818fucking PUSSIES
>>98772395Just a reminder, Propaganda doesn't protect your planeswalkers. You may want to cut it for something that does, like:Onakke Oathkeeper, Baird, Steward of ArgiveArchon of AbsolutionNorn's AnnexSphere of SafetyArchangel of Tithes
Is there an Oblivion Ring type effect in Grixis?
Does Premodern Commander work? Are decks with just old-bordered cards playable? Does anyone have decklists?
>>98772720Sultai > Mardu > Abzan > Temur > Jeskai
>>98772424>plays game with polymorph spells and shapeshifters>oh no, the transibilityDo you get triggered when somebody casts Pongify?
>>98772780
Why is panoptic mirror a game changer when all the broken things it can do are banned in lower brackets anyway
>>98772543Can I get a color pie/formatting and wording check on this, anon?
>>98772938Because you can stick Sunfall on there and make the no interaction scrubs seethe.
>>98772910you realize EDH started when old borders were still the *only* borders right?the game mode is called 'elder dragon highlander' because originally the only legal commanders were dragons from Legends>b-b-but is it balanced against nu-magic shitno. obviously not.
>>98772950this niggas name is milk party
>competitive edh>look inside>11 hour games of angle shooting cheatersLOLMtG is not, and never will be, competitive
>>987729501. you have to shuffle after searching2. Room has to be capitalized
>>98772978You know exactly what I'm asking. Is it worth it? I'm not spending time on building decks with old cards and convincing other people to do the same, when this mode of playing isn't fun.
Thirty (30) starting life is objectively superior to fourty (40)
>>98772746This is an Indian postThis is how they weasel their way into your company
>>98772950Honestly you probably don't even need to add the {2} payment because rooms start at 5 mana to fully unlock and those ones suck cheeks.Also shoutouts for making it not cheat into play or have inbuilt protection. You did the bare minimum but that's unironically more than most custom card designers I see. Rare Deadlock fan W.
>>9877303130? I am going count to ten.
>>98773017>Is it worth it?I would argue Premodern (the full format) isn't worth playing when it's barely a novelty until you play against Stasis and Stiflenought for the 8th game in a row. Premodern EDH is an utterly colossal slog because actually winning the game takes 10x longer due to how shit creatures are, and the best wincon is another fucking "mill your whole library" combo with Hermit Druid, except this time instead of Lab Man/Thoracle you use Sutured Ghoul and Dragon Breath.
>>98773056I've never been more disappointed than when I showed up to my first premodern event with RDW. I swear that deck is fucking trash and only exists because the format had few eyes on it.
Judge, slow thread
>>98773186Worry not, we will have our scheduled 100 post ub vs uw reply chain soon enough.
>>98773186Post something worth replying to
>>98773199If the commander isn't appealing, cool and or attractive, I don't play them, shrimple as
How is my deck looking edhg? https://moxfield.com/decks/moGLjF8CIU2cy6NbvfWF_A
>>98773221Could use a few more instant speed kill spells but aside from that, looks pretty good
Bros I've finally narrowed it down to either mono-white humans, soldiers or angels, or selesnya something
>>98771905How's Timmy Blue play? I'm interested in trying it out alongside mana rocks
>>98773238I mean if I wanted to I'd add something like pic related. But I enjoy the purity.
>>98773221Needs a Thrumming Stone.
Okay, I'll start the proxy debate again.>Be yesterday>Playing B2>Syr Ginger vs modified precon World Shaper vs precon Tramplesaurus Rex>4th pulls out Kinnan and tells us some cards are proxies>T1, Grim monolith, Ancient TombWhy are proxyfags like this?
>>98773298Why did you not eject him from the group after he played GCs in a Bracket 2 game
>>98773302Because he's our friend. After he won that game, we all basically piled on to him the next one.
>>98773307If my friend brought out two game changers in a bracket 2 game turn 1 I'd tell him he was a fucking faggot and to play a different deck.
>>98773221Living death
>>98773298>I'll start shit stirring againNo
>>98773298>Accepting kinnan as a commanderThere's your problem.
>>98773238>>98773297>>98773318Yeah after testing on forge it loses to the retard bots, much less an actual person. What's a good number of rats vs other cards like living death, thrumming stone etc?
>recently someone asked if he could proxy a Toxrill, the Corrosive deck>mfw we were all fairly new to magic and didn't realize how bullshit that card was>mfw in the game it was funny at first that he slowly grinded everyone to death>mfw he threw down the enchantments that proc off -1/-1s>mfw Propaganda>mfw kormus bell>mfw urborg, tomb of yawgmothI'm still traumatized but at least I think I know how to deal with that fucking snail now.
>>98773243What if you build selesnya something soldiers?
>>98772730Only legit racists thought this though.
>>98772775Honestly the best option. They'll assume you suck for not being good enough for cedh, so they underestimate. Then you win and you'll feel vindicated when they bitch n moan that you're too powerful.
>>98772695Depends on a lot of factors like how good your manabase is. I like chromatic lantern so I would. But some people find 3 cmc mana rocks not worth it.
>>98773347My most creature heavy deck played 36 creaturesId probably go between 32-36 Needs draw if you want to actually play the game tooI played pic related as my general in my all rats deck, had to play some ramp too cause turn 5 is way too slow to drop him
Swapped out Smirking Spelljacker for Thorin Mountain-king and Perplexing Test for Soul Immolation. Really liking the deck post-switch to Ninjutsu, although the players I got at FNM were a mixed bag. First game was such a dull case of the table running all gas and being generally clueless.>Mr. House player passes with Mondrak, Grim Hireling, Delney, Marionette Apprentice, and THIRTEEN 3/3 robots after a single absurd turn>Jace polymorph player doesn't see the threat and casts a 1 mana creature which he does not polymorph, clones his Jace to draw more then passes???>Calamity player lost all his combo pieces, plays a Dragon Egg then passes???>to salvage the board I have to metamorph Grim Hireling, Moonlit Meditation it, make a Living Weapon Copy, Thousand-Faced Shadow in another tapped and attacking copy, politic the other two players into letting me hit them>then I have to sequentially dismantle his board>still leaves him with House and 13 tokens after>doesn't matter because he has an anthem effect in hand>needs handholding during combat math because he's a Mr. House player>me and Jace player die>Jace goes "Well if I knew his board was good I would've done something to stop him!">third guy dies afterGame three House dropped the new red Craterhoof and with his dudes at +12/+0 and trample he "wasn't sure" if he could kill us. Bleak stuff. Had a lot of fun with the deck anyway.
>>98773587Looks like shit
>>98773601Nuh uh
Thoughts on Experiment Kraj?
>>98773607Not that fun in my experience. The only thing he can really do is make infinite mana and draw infinite cards on the backs of a bunch of shit cards that do nothing without him. He either combos off or he doesn't.
>>98773607Very clunky even back when it was printedYou can make it do some nutty stuff (planeswalker abilities) but it will be a labor of love
What a cutie
Can you play control in Commander like you can in 60 card formats?
>>98773730Yes but your wincon will still probably be either overrun or combo of some kind
>>98771868Just getting around to finishing up my B3 Bolas Control deck. Recently decided to cut Cyclonic Rift for Reigns of Power, and while the deck is clearly weaker as a result, I'm hoping it'll make for more interesting matches. Now that I'm down a GC, I'll probably toss in a Field of the Dead as another potential Archaeomancer + Ghostly Flicker combo piece, using the Lazotep Zombie tokens for flavor.
>>98772885Goated catch thank you
>>98773363>Allowing a 7 mana creature in Dimir to liveYou only had yourself to blame.
>>98773634I love her in my Yurlok deck, I like to imagine pumping opponent so full of mana they explode.
>>98773607as a mairsil player, just play mairsileasier to assemble your jank machine when the pieces can't get pathed at any moment
>>98774071Can I see your mairsil list pretty please?
>>98773373>5 mana for a +1/+1 and a body
>>98773363>>mfw he threw down the enchantments that proc off -1/-1sToxrills counters are not -1/-1 counters, they do not interact with things like nest of scarabs.
>>98774112https://moxfield.com/decks/Z-zC6bmrNUWw5nD1k5pO8gThis is a transitional WIP list from forever ago as opposed to a proper decklist, but honestly might be more helpful since it shows some of the silly stuff you can do with him (like winning with commander damage using Phyrexian Devourer, my supar secret tech) as well as the combo-oriented strats people tend to run (deathbringer throcar + endling + blood pet)
>>98772637explain why
>>98772521the model was obviously pulling a lot from excalibur for the lighting and armor.
>See a card I would considering running >It's from Doctor Who
>>98774446Worry not anon, market research shows you actually like quirky reddit brit #621
>>98774474>621What an oddly specific number, anon
>>98774520How is it weird? That's just the E-number of MSG/monosodium glutamate
>>98774520He's just referring to Armored CoreWhat are YOU thinking of, anon??
How do I make this jank-ass B4 deck I'm brewin less retarded?https://moxfield.com/decks/Tk-gAbd0gnSNyVgeiPA7tQ
>>98771948I'll take princess bride over ever going back to edge of eternity again, gay boy
>>98771948Sorry little bro, Final Fantasy and Lord of the Rings absolutely mog your gay little furry plane and your gay little wakanda plane and your gay little hogwarts plane
>>98774603samefag
>>98774474Doctor Who is Teletubbies for 'adults,' fuck WoTC for intermittently reminding me of it's existence while I'm browsing through card databases
>>98774446>mfw don't give a fuck about where the card or the reprint is from so I can easily pick up things like jitte or shadowspear for cheap because they happen to have Ninja Turtles on em>>98774623First post of mine in the thread, at least check shit before you sperg out, gay boy
>>98774705While I much prefer crossover sets that thematically fit in MTG's setting (Like LotR) I can at least tolerate hasbro and capeshit, even if I would never run cards from those sets myselfDifference is that I loathe Dr Who
post ub sets you'd actually buy, for me it's dark souls or from software in general
>>98774832Another Fallout Set.NMS set 7 days to die setValheim setDarkest Dungeon set.
>>98774446just make an uw proxy of it and you're golden
>>98774832Dark Souls, Drakengard, Warhammer Fantasy, Divinity, Planescape
>>98774832>>98774858Big Bang Theory would be more likely to get a set over these gayass incel larp video games.
>>98774878It's funny because it's true.
>>98774832Star WarsBMWCivilizationMurder She WroteWalmart
>>98774832Proper Warhammer Fantasy set (not smegmar), Star Wars, Warcraft, new Romance of the Three Kingdoms set with upgraded mechanics (and a return of Horsemanship), Mass Effect, DUNC, more D&D sets of non-Forgotten Realms settings
>>98774832yugioh and only for the irony of it. not even my fave vidya IP would twitch my dick because it would clash so bad with all the other garbage already in this card game
>>98774878I don't understand half of what you just said
>>98774832Berserk, Witcher, TF2, Deadlock, I'd also fuck with a public domain series with those book style covers they've been doing recently like pic related. Sherlock Holmes, Alice in Wonderland, Wizard of Oz, ect. like maybe frame it as just a cool library planet set where the books are alive could be the handwave explanation on why so many of them are around or something. It would be kinda fun imo
>>98774888You say it in jest but a Murder She Wrote/Columbo themed set would fuck, I enjoy the case and clue mechanic and would enjoy more cards with em
BazingaUInstantCounter target spell. That spell's controller draws 2 cards.
>>98774912>library planet set where the books are alive could be the handwave explanation on why so many of them are around or something. It would be kinda fun imoSo... like that terrible old Macaulay Culkin movie Pagemaster?Actually, would be a good setting for a set.
>>98774766Ah fair, Who is one of those things where there are a few good episodes that I do really enjoy with peter capaldi, but on the whole i think it's just kind of one of those franchises that have been going on for so long that it just keeps going out of principle like The Simpsons
>>98774952Even the BBC thinks so. They're asking for pitches for a full reboot from zero of Dr Who.
>>98774832A Song of Ice and FireDark CrystalDuneConan
>>98774940>PagemasterHaven't thought about that thing in decades, damn. Even if I'm sure it doesn't hold up now, I really liked that movie as a kid and yeah, pretty much. Slide a younger Planeswalker into the main perspective role of it as he explores the place and have him solve a mystery of the library or something and bang, I'd buy some packs
>>98774832BLACKEDAll of the canon females get good dick for once would be amazing
>>98772637Lorwyn/Shadowmoor block is when I stopped buying new cards. For me it was the bs rules changes and adding in Mythic rares. I just proxy all the newer cards now.
>>98775015>bs rules changesWhich ones, damage not going on the stack?
>>98775015Mythics were added in Alara
>>98775042Correct right after Shadowmoor block. I guess I worded it badly. I didn't buy any cards from Shards of Alara or later.>>98775031That and Mana Burn. I would rather play with pre-6th edition rules then the shit rules we have today.
>>98774987mr.cobson, please contain yourself
>>98774832Legend of ZeldaWarhammer FantasyClassic pulp like Conan or John CarterStar WarsLegend of Korra if only because I like the Bending mechanics
>>98775070What was mana burn even good for? Occasionally killing a storm player who went for it and whiffed?
>>98775135>Occasionally killing a storm player who went for it and whiffed?That seems like all the reason we need. I don't know where this notion of a rule not mattering most of the time means it should be removed.
>>98775135>What as mana burn good for?Making people actually plan their turns, and how much mana they are going to use, not just float a trillion just because they can/
>>98775160>just float a trillion just because they cando you see this often?
>>98775169I imagine it happens now and then when someone shoots a big mana rock with a disenchant or something. There would be no reason to tap it one last time to float a bunch of mana, but mana burn existing would actually make that a decision worth considering which gives you information about what may or may not be in your opponent's hand.
>>98775169I see people making much more mana than they actually use quite often, yes.Just yesterday I saw someone make 40 mana with Jeskai's will and only spend 17 of it.If mana burn was still a thing this would be a dangerous play for yourself.
Explain why you love Magic: The Gathering
>>98774832FromSoftThe Black CompanyRobert E. HowardThe WitcherDuneDomineria
>>98775261I like killing the blue player.
>>98775261Interesting gameplay, collecting and admiring cool fantasy artI like the social aspect, but I'm finding I play modern more now, too many women on commander days. My wife nagged me enough for spending $300 on blood moons, I don't want some fat whore to bitch at me for playing them
>>98775261The narrative aspect of the personality of the land shaping the type of power that can be drawn from it, this power then reflecting in the personalities of those who wield it. It feels deeply integrated with the mana system. Beautiful art back in the day and being a very old game with a huge catalogue of cards makes it feel old and expansive like nature. The rules are very comprehensive and legal-like. A real care for draft formats, I don't see any reason to switch to other card games. Even if the forward direction of MtG has been bad for a long time now.
>>98775169Yes.
>>98775135>What was mana burn even good for?Like most things in Magic, it's best as material for LARPers to say it made the game better.
>>98775411Oh, just like how commander color rules make the "game better".
>>98775261Its fun. Do you really need more reason than that?
>>98775261I started playing because of the art but continued because it is an infinite puzzle that somehow also rewards putting reps in
>>98775344Nailed it
>>98775261I like seeing a playerbase of whiny children get endlessly punished by IsraelCorp, all while said children continue buying boxes because they're addicted to gambling. It fills me with reassurance knowing that these cattle will endlessly support the game in my place (I've been proxying since MMQ).
>>98774832JAV UB
>opponent does something>I declare "in response I tap 2 mana">do nothingOnly do this gag maybe once a year, but it makes me laugh
>>98775551>Hitomi's tits>4 generic>Tap: put a growth counter onto this artifact. Then add two mana of any one color for each growth counter on Hitomi's tits
>>98775551>taimanin UB>orcs finally get non-goblin tied support and it's centered around taking control of female creatures and breeding orc tokens with them
>>98774557needs sram for draw
>>98775488That hard works exactly as printed within WotC's own rules for non-tournament events in EDH btw.
>>98774858Drakengard would perfectly fit, but there's ZERO chance of nu-wizards ever doing that
If a creature you control would be exiled, destroy it instead.
>watch TCC video>he's crying about yugiohs small text and high word count (the word count is, outside a few scant edge scenarios, less than a single tweet)>he's carrying on about how complex it is and how it's not understandable>yugioh cards generally have so much text just to be clear on their timings, effects, triggers, etc>meanwhile he has a magic card>he smugly says reading the card explains the card>when you have cards that say nothing but "ward, dock, mount, flash">have to look all the keywords up in the first placeYeah fuck TCC
>>98775689You're more likely to see Nier Automata for yet another game to shove 2B in.
I loved Automata, I cried at the ending, but whoring out 2B like this just makes me sad
>>98775708Nobody knows who your boyfriend who you chose to nickname "TCC" is.
>edh was created as a wacky format to chill out after playing real magic>retards try to morph it into "competitive" edhLmfaoThis is like when they tried to force Melee to be competitive
>>98775728>This is like when they tried to force Melee to be competitiveSo like the only form of melee people play today?
>>98775732>melee >competitiveOh anon, so much to learn
>walk into lgs>slam down my falcon tribal banding deck
>>98775793You don't play with this
>>98775798I was making a gag earlier but I'm tossing it up, bird tribal can't be that expensive and the sheer hilarity will be worth it
>>98775634shit feel like a retard for forgetting him, thanks anon
>>98775640It does ever since the RC was dissolved and WotC quietly abolished the no wish rule, but don't tell autists that.
>>98775728NOOO YOU CAN'T JUST GRAB THE LEDGE AGAIN AS PUFF ONLY M2K IS ALLOWED TO DO THAT!!!
>>98775798It's legit in bird tribal because a big problem for birds is getting trampled over by a 12/12, which banding solves. As well as making sure your actually important birds don't die to the 5/5 dragon. Banding is legit in combat heavy games.
>>98775708If you have functioning memory, keywords are very helpful in making it so you can read cards across the table, rather than having to have them read to you by a judge when "Blue Eyes Librarian Dragon" causes your opponent to win the game because it isn't Tuesday, but it counts as Tuesday thanks to the effect of another card with nine lines of text.Of course if you have to read the card every time on account of some brain disorder or mental deficiency that's not going to help.
Why do people pump their decklist price by adding the most retarded, rare printing of cards when they could just add the normal 40c print?
>>98775873I don't
>>98775873swag bitch
>>98775873Why does it matter? Are you sorting decks by price or something?
>>98775873I just add whichever one has the nicest art. I won't pay $30+ more for good art, but if one variant is $12 and a better looking variant is $16, I'll spend the 4 extra bucks to have a better look.
>>98775886It's just dishonest and yes I DO play white
>>98775855kek, it do be like that
>>98775873Why would you care about something no trivial
>>98775890>dishonestThe fuck did retard-kun mean by this?
Look at all these Dimirfags pretending it doesn't matterI'm onto your scheme
>>98775897name a single person here from the plane of ravnica
>>98775900The guilds represent certain personality traitsDimirfags are sneaky, hook-nosed, underhanded, lying, cheatsAzoriousCHADS are noble, heroic, law-upholding and law-abiding, gigachads
>>98775900Speak for yourself.
Apparently this is considered some of the worst MtG art ever, but I don't know, I quite like itIt's very weird to be sure, but it has a certain charm
>>98775919mirage had SOVL, it may have been proto-woke but it wasn't actually woke
>>98775919tag yourselves im the windmill
>>98775919Rampage is based.
Can you guys please put a trigger warning before discussing m*ll? It's extremely triggering
>>98775867Which types are outlaws?What does Bushido do?What does Rampage do?How do Cloud Key and Trinisphere interact?Does Sapphire Medallion discount Three Steps Ahead? What about overloaded Cyclonic Rift?What happens when I cast Reprieve on someone flashing back Deep Analysis?What happens when I have Laboratory Maniac and a solved Case of the Locked Hothouse on the field, then tap Selvala attempting to cast the top card of my library (the last card in my deck) but my opponents don't reveal enough lands?What happens when I cast Opalescence and Humility?How does my Urza's Saga work under Blood Moon?Can I use Ninjitsu on a card I took from an opponent with a Threaten effect?What happens when I cast Wrath of God into my opponent's Blood Artist?This is all shit that's not printed on the card and you have to either just remember it or consult the CR.
Do the brains of Americans genuinely just shut down when it involves art of women?
>>98775943hurr durr what's a special summon the card doesn't tell me?
>>98775961You have to have mental illness anyways to care about the art of a children's trading card.
>>98775961I think it’s because the redditor OP is, to no one’s surprise, a closeted pedophile. More than likely frequents /v/.
>>98775428Yes but it's a conversation most people aren't ready for.
>>98775919>I cant WAIT to call the tranny at my LGS a slur!
>>98776020Reddit post
>look into cedh>to be even vaguely competitive you have to buy the staples every deck hasThis shit is so homogeneous
>>98776026But im posting on /edhg/ on 4chan?
>>98775793>>98775862Is it erated to have falcons be birds?
>>98776054Yes, according to Oracle>um chud xhe's called Gatherer now Always was, always will be, Oracle
>>98776020Kek. Literally me.
>sit next to hairy armed creature with adams apple>suppose to pretend this is a woman
>>98775943I get your point but it is funny that you picked bushido out of all the keywords in this game because there isn't a single blackbordered card with bushido that doesn't have reminder text on it.
>>98776034And don't forget, to play it, you have to mulligan until you have at least two moxes in your starting hand.
What is the most turns you've ever seen in a commander game?>at a bracket 2 pod>everyone is barely a bracket 2>turn 16 before anyone is out>ends turn 25 when two opponents were left topdeckig for 7 turns before it ended
>"competitive" game>nooooooo you can't just play efficiently and lock me out of my colours
>>98776092Be nice anon, you should compliment on her having the biggest adam's apple you've ever seen
>>98776132Yeah, they ban this to protect precons and dumb timmies
>>98776132This card would be ok if it was in Blue.
>>98776148I'm a self admitted Timmy that soys over giant creatures, but I hate bans like thisIt's why the format won't be competitive, because they ban stuff because it's "too good", so you're playing a game without all the pieces
>>98776132>9cmc in mono whiteIf you let you opponent cast this then you deserve whatever happens
>>98776154>It won't be competitive It isn't meant to be.That was the entire point of the format.A chill format for judges and players to play while people playing at tournaments while the real games were going on.
What's the point of this ability?
>>98776217To stop yourself from getting killed by swamp walk?
>>98776227I'm actually retarded and didn't think about the opponent using swampwalk
>>98776217the N did a lot of work on this guy
>>98776217>opponent has a creature with swampwalk>don't care cause you have no swamps>they play Urborg Bet you'll wish you had Ur-Drago then, huh?
>go into lgs in 2026>whip out my three kingdoms horsemanship deck>act surprised when the opponent has no horsemanship creatures
>>98776368>horsemanshipIsn't that just too many creature types all in one?
>>98776380Speaking of, what's the most creature types in a single card? I've seen Ogre Warrior Shaman
HOLY KINO
>>98776127i stop counting turns after turn 9
>>98776288I cast "that card is bullshit I'm ignoring it."
>>98776127yeah?
>>98776186>it isn't meant to be>that's why there are bans in a casual format!lmao
>>98776440This isn't a contradiction. You are just dumb.
>>98776449>candy crush, angry birds, monopoly, solitaire>casual games>no bans!>edh>it's a casual game guys!!>nooooo we must ban iona!!no anon you are just dumb and seething
>>98776392Orc Warrior Wizard Cleric Rogue if Burakkos countsIf not, one of the Mutant Ninja Turtle (Human or Dinosaur) cards
EDH, like speedrunning, is competitive, and men can be womenYou're all chuds
>>98776463edh is competitive otherwise you'd be conceding to me every time
In this thread we trust the scienceEDH is competitiveHer penisThe new art is fantasticWe were always at war with Eurasia
>i hate UB i hate UB!>UB comes out of something i actually like>m-maybe UB isn't so bad...I still think it should be silver border though
It see were are past bump limit, so the eternal shitposters show up
>>98776495it's just a schizo assblasted that people can play sweaty on things like smash and edh
>>98776503I'm talking about you. You are the eternal shitposter.
Do cEDHfags really not understand that the format was made as a joke to chill out between real magic?
>>98776511sure whatever you say tranny
>>98776514>the format was made as a joke>that's why they are bans>so we can stop *your brand* of joking around!
Umbris mill with nightmare and horror tribal? Would that be good? The art alone is selling me on the subtype
>>98776524Yes. Deal and cope.
>>98776537i'm not the one coping that they're not an authoritarian hypocrite btw roru rumaothank god gavin knows that commander is all about players playing the cards they love!
>edh is a format about making wacky, fun, thematic decks>cedhfags ruin it like always by making turn 2 victories with infinite combos
What's the best colour combination if I really want to annoy and piss off my opponents? Is it BU?
>>98776554wdym winning t2 via adnaus and losing a bunch of life and your whole library is pretty wacky, fun, and thematic to me!
Taking competitive card games to their utmost logical conclusion results in the best decks being ones that don't allow the opponent to play, but companies like Wizards and Konami ban cards and decks like thisThe format is casual, deal with it
>>98776583why ban cards when we can make brackets instead and not cut our bottom line?the format is whatever people make of it, cry more
>>98776422this one makes other players mad when I play it for some reason
you ever look at your hand/decklist and think "I need another 4 garys"?
>>98776613How many garys we got in edh nowadays?
>>98776597It's fun in turbofog
>>98776644somehow none
Why doesn't something like Galvanic Iteration+Approach instantly win?
>>98776675You don't CAST copies.
>>98776683Oh, it's OVER
>>98776675>opponent gains 12 lifeI would concede on the spot
>>98776683This, on top of approach needing to be cast from the hand specifically.
>>98776613>>98776644>>98776662kokusho was the original gary that required some hoops
Make new, I want to post
the fuck is 7 point highlander
>>98776718>>98776738>>98776738>>98776738Move then faggot
>>98776597Moat for poor people.
>>98776739Kek, the little faggot made one before we even got to page 8. What a thirsty boy!
>>987759354 fucking mana for a combat trick? Jesus
>>98776132I want to use her in my dogshit angels deck, shame about the whole ban thing
>>98775910Nigga, I'm a Grixisfag. Take your guild shit the fuck outta here.
>>98776918It's not a combat trick. You have to play it before combat.
>>98775900I'm from Izzet and I want to have gay sex with male dragons.
>>98775261the stack and rule bending cards
>>98775919nowhere near phil fuglyo
>>98777531Pre-6th batch system was better kid.
>>98775910Orzhov reporting in
>>98775936>Mardu Madness is triggering I just can't stop winning
>>98774832The big bang theory
It worries me how the 3 UB sets were announced but still not revealed.
